Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Hazur Sahib

Hazur Sahib

amrik singh · 22 Sep 2004

VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh. recently a friend of mine went to Hazur Sahib and recorded some video footage from inside the Gurudwara. i was watching it and noticed that there were several (i think five) saroops of Dhan Dhan Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. my question is what is the significance of the five saroops? is there any significance? the second thing i noticed that 2 saroops were in palkhia, and the other 3 were on a manji sahib but not in a palkhi. what is the reason for this? the third thing which i noticed was that when Aarti was being performed some people were 'hovering' their hands over the flame and then 'hovering' that same hand over their faces. is this a hindu influence? or is there a deeper meaning? im just very intrigued.... thanking you in advance. please forgive any mistakes that i have made. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Hazur Sahib

Jagjitsingh · 23 Sep 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, Hazoor Sahib is not run by any sikh organisation, but run by a Maharastra Governing Board, which pledges allegance to RSS/BJP. It has many anti sikh rituals there from the arti, to numerous Guru Sahib saroops, to Joths, to kirpan de Amrit for bibian, to nihangs killing goats for langar, to bhang, etc. It unfortuanately is not an example of the Guru Granth/ Guru Panth Gurdwara setup, rather a RSS vision of what they want all of our Gurdwaras to become. There is no significance in what is done there, apart from promoting Hindu rituals within sikhism context. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Hazur Sahib

Manjeet Kaur Sidhu · 23 Sep 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Hazoor sahib takhat has been under the control of the GOI for centuries and most of its ceremonies are overtones of HINDUISM and NOT allowed in the Sikh rehat maryada followed at Gurdwaras worldwide. The other granths may also be Dasam granth..but i cant say for sure as i have no direct first hand knowledge. maybe some other veer can be of help. manjeet kaur

Re: Hazur Sahib

A Singh · 23 Sep 2004

I would suggest reading up on the maryada that is held at Hazur Sahib, before jumping on the usual "this is a RSS/Hindu" bandwagon. I don't agree with all their ideals, however matters such as Aarti and giving reverence to both the Adi Guru Granth Sahib and Dasam Granth Sahib have their roots in our 17th and 18th century traditions -check out Banasivalanama and other texts for references.

Re: Hazur Sahib

Jarnail Singhh Arshi Gyani · 23 Sep 2004

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer jagjit Singh Ji is absolutley right. There is very little genuine SIKHI at hazoor Sahib and now also Takaht Patna Sahib is also following along the same lines of RSS/GOI influence to weaken the Kaum by encouraging divisive and hindu based rituals etc and challenge the Akal takhat's supremacy. 90% of "maryada" at hazoor sahib and Patna Sahib is RSS/Brahmin based and against the Principles in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. dassra jarnail singh

Re: Hazur Sahib

AnotherSingh · 23 Sep 2004

"90% of "maryada" at hazoor sahib and Patna Sahib is RSS/Brahmin based and against the Principles in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE." Really, like what?

Re: Hazur Sahib

jagjitsingh · 23 Sep 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, the whole tradition of aarti is covered by Sahib siri Guru Nanak dev ji himself. Please read the bani, and understand its context. It is self-explanatory, and shows the emptiness of ritualism. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh A Singh wrote: > I would suggest reading up on the maryada that is held at Hazur > Sahib, before jumping on the usual "this is a RSS/Hindu" > bandwagon. > > I don't agree with all their ideals, however matters such as > Aarti and giving reverence to both the Adi Guru Granth Sahib > and Dasam Granth Sahib have their roots in our 17th and 18th > century traditions -check out Banasivalanama and other texts > for references.

Re: Hazur Sahib

:-o · 23 Sep 2004

Just a thought... If up to '90% of "maryada" at hazoor sahib and Patna Sahib is RSS/Brahmin based', then why isn't anything done about it? Because this is the first I am hearing of this... Also, if 'Hazoor sahib takhat has been under the control of the GOI for centuries' then why hasn't anyhting been done about this? Sikh's around the world are at work to stop Harmandir Sahib getting into the hands of GOI, why isn't anything down about Hazzor Sahib?

Re: Hazur Sahib

thinker · 23 Sep 2004

a lot of the people on this forum are sitting ducks all the gyanis, bhais and bhainjees -- nobody does anything, people just complain who is actually going to get off their lazy butt and make a difference? me? you? us? ... we're pathetic

Re: Hazur Sahib

h Singh · 23 Sep 2004

Thinker, I agree... but making the general sangat aware of the problems is also needed through such message boards. I have learned alot from the posts on this message board.

Re: Hazur Sahib

_ · 23 Sep 2004

Some of those granths that are parkash are Japji Sahib de granth where continuous paat is done of JapJi Sahib at the Takhat. All sikhs are required to go to Hazoor Sahib once before they reach the age of 60.

Re: Hazur Sahib

__:::___ · 24 Sep 2004

except the fact is that Hazur sahib has had the same traditions since before the british raj's influence. all the propaganda about the rss and goi is not true.

Re: Hazur Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 24 Sep 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. _:::_ Ji..PRECISELY. You have hit the nail right on the head. ALL the KHALSA JI were BUSY fighting in the JUNGLES...and DESERTS...while the RSS ( BRAHMINS) had a filed day CONTROLLONG ALL our GURDWARAS and GRANTHS as well. Thats when they changed all our MARYADAS and GRANTHS to suit their HINDU beleifs....in the 17th - 18th centuries... LONG BEFORE BRITISH RAAJ came along... Every SIKH was in HIDING and sikh heads were being SOLD for a price.... so the only persons who were in charge of our gurdwaras were Nirmalas, sadhs, MAHANTS etc who were heavily BRAHMIN. This is precisely why the SINGH SABHA MOVEMENT began in the 1920's to REVIVE genuine Sikhi and CHASE OUT the HINDUS from our GURDWARAS and REMOIVE the MAHANTS.... SGPC came in durign this time after many many sacrifices and morchas... Unfortunately all this happened ONY in PUNJAB...Hazoor sahib and Patna Sahib being away from PUNJAB ESCAPED ATTENTION...and continue thier BRAHMINISED maryadas till this day. Are you aware that the Harimandir sahib Parkirma was CHOCK FULL of HINDU DIETIES STATUES until the Singh sabha Lehr and SGPC came along and threw them all OUT.... The RSS/GOI is not a "new" thing as you beleive.....it is THOUSANDS of YEARS OLD.....and this is what swalloed BUDDHISM....and now has its eyes on SIKHISM. Jarnail singh

Re: Hazur Sahib

yes · 26 Sep 2004

>>All sikhs are required to go to Hazoor Sahib once before they reach the age of 60.<< where does it say that

Re: Hazur Sahib

avidya · 26 Sep 2004

WaheGuruji Ka Khalsa WaheGuruji Ki Fateh Jagjit ji and Gyani ji, Gyani ji, although I appreciate your sentiments, Sri Darbar Sahib was not 'chock full' of murtis. Please check your sources. On the issue of Arti being an 'anti-sikh ritual' as stated by Jagjit Singh ji, he would do well to read basic sources on Sikhi such as Bhai Gurdas' Varan. In pauri 6 Bhai Gurdas states on the issue of a gurmukhs daily routine 'Raati Keerat Sohilaa, kar AARTI prasad vadhanday'. I find it highly offensive to have gurmat referred to as 'anti-sikh ritual'. Please correct this. There is a real danger of people who are illiterate with standard Sikh sources making rash comments based on set assumptions.

Re: Hazur Sahib

sikh · 27 Sep 2004

avidya are u literate - i think the type of literacy ur promoting is best kept gupt bhai jagit singh is stating fact.

Re: Hazur Sahib

A Singh · 27 Sep 2004

Avidiya, I concur with your comments concerning Aarti, which is all too often termed 'hindu' or 'rss' influence, there are numerous (sikh) sources pointing to its practice with puratan Sikhs. We need to be a little more vigilant in defining our exact definitions, such that we keep RSS-type nonsense at bay without losing our own heritage.

Re: Hazur Sahib

Balpreet Singh · 27 Sep 2004

Aartee is a Hindu ritual. It is not practiced by Sikhs. Though, Sikhs do have their own style of Aartee. This is keertan. If anyone has even briefly reflected upon Guru Nanak Dev jee's shabad on Aartee, they will see that wordly aartee with candles and scents is nothing. The true Aartee is Naam and keertan of Vahiguru's praises. Which puraatan sources tell a Sikh to do Aartee?

Re: Hazur Sahib

A Singh · 28 Sep 2004

"bhaee parapat manukh deh huria gobind milan kee eh teri bariya... ...avar kaaj teray kite naa kaam, mil sadh sangat baj keval naam" The last line is often translated and explained as follows:- All other worldly tasks are of no avail, meet with the true company and spend you time solely on the recitation of naam. Now a naive view would be to look at this line as an indication of literal renunciation from life (avar kaaj terey kite naa kaam), those who wish to understand it from the point of view of 'Gurmat' will see beyond this, likewise for other more modern and politicised renditions of Gurbani concerning certain courtly customs. Also, I'm interested to understand, if Hazoor Sahib and Patna Sahib, on account of being outside Punjab didn't have the 'clean-up' presented by the Lahore Singh Sabha and later the SGPC, how come no idols are still found in these locations, or are they? Moreover, if "90%" of the Maryada is Hindu, then how what is the 10% that is Sikh? I mean 90% is a seriously large portion, please could you verify what the exact practices are that fall within this bracket? The Bhen-Ji making this rash comment, also admitted to not having been to the Thakt let alone knowing that the second granth kept in the Hazoori is the Dasam Granth. For details of this practice, please refer to the Banasivalanama and also to the Hazoor-Sahib Maryada Parbodh (this is now online courtesy of Amrit Pal Singh Amrit).

Re: Hazur Sahib

Balpreet Singh · 28 Sep 2004

A Singh, Firstly, Hazooree Maryada Parbodh is hardly a puraatan source. It was written not 50 years ago. Bansavalinama is a very controversial work but please do refer me to the mention of aartee with deevaas. I havn't read the maryada of aartee anywhere in any rehitnama or anywhere else. The rites at Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib are not the original ones. They are the ones imported from Punjab during the mid to late 1800s. Maculiffe states that the maryada at Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib is very different than the one in Punjab because it has not been adulterated by Hindu rites and beliefs. BUT he also says that Sikhs from Punjab are coming and introducing these Hindu practices and dilluting the maryada there. I can give a page reference if you want it. So the brahminised practices used in Punjab found their way into Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib. And yes, these two takhats were not reformed by the Singh Sabha movement and hence these practices have lingered. The practice of blowing conch shells and ringing bells and doing aartee is a very Hindu ritual still followed by Udasis in their deras along with many Sehajdharis like those from Sindh. If you look at Sindhi "gurdwaras" you'll find images of Hindu Gods along with Guru Sahib and also idols. Guru Sahib is treated very much like the idols and the same practices are done to it. Is this "puraatan"? No, it's the way a Hindu who doesn't understand Sikhi would treat Guru Sahib: they are trying to use Hindu traditions to respect Guru Sahib, despite the fact that these practices are not according to Sikhi. Aartee is a Hindu practice, introduced by the non-Khalsa caretakers of Gurdwaras during the persecution of the Singhs. It is NOT some old maryada.

Re: Hazur Sahib

A Singh · 29 Sep 2004

Balpreet Singh, the Banasivalanama is the reference for the practice of keeping both Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Dasam Guru Granth Sahib Ji in parkash together, I do not have work to hand, so cannot quote the precise page number -however, have a look at one of the many 'anti-Dasam Granth' articels floating on the net, since they are bound to have this in their works, as they love to accuse Kesar Singh Chibbar of being a Brahmin conspirator. Funny how the fact that Bhai Mati Das and Sati Das, also chibbar Brahmins, are never referred to by their caste descent, however Kesar "SINGH" Chibber also ends up being accused of some thing or the other on account of him being a Brahmin! Bhaji, I am still not convinced that the Singh-Sabha did not get into Hazoor Sahib or Patna Sahib, as both Gurdwaras and Thakts are controlled by the SGPC (the child of the Singh Sabha movement). In any event, how come there are no idols and other such 'Hindu' matters in vogue at Hazoor Sahib, if indeed the Maryada is 90% HIndu as suggested above? Please could you help me understand this

Re: Hazur Sahib

Balpreet Singh · 29 Sep 2004

A Singh, The SGPC do not have direct control over either of these Takhats. They have their own management boards which have members of the local sangat, state government officials and then a couple of SGPC members as well. But they are NOT controlled by the SGPC. I'd say it'd be more apt to say the state governments exert the most control. As for idols: If I recall correctly, I read an account by an Westerner who saw Patna Sahib and he did describe pictures of Hindu gods inside. At any rate, putting pictures of Hindu gods in the post-Singh Sabha period would have been just too much of a stretch. There would not have been any way the Sikh sangat would have accepted it. These rituals can push tolerance and be explained away, but idol worship of Hindu gods would not have been tolerated. Bansavalinama: this is contentious not just because he is a brahmin, but because of other statements and remarks which seem almost insulting to the image of the Gurus. It is concluded from this that being a brahmin, perhaps he was still pushing that ideology.

Re: Hazur Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 29 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bhai Sati dass Bhai Mati Dass and Bhai Mani Singh.....ALL became Shaheeds and no one disputes their "brahmin" ancestory....just like NO ONE would Dare call GURU NANAK a "Khatri"...and impute janeau wearing etc as normal to Guru nanak as he was a Khatrii.... Once GURU NANAK broke with all those Khatri tradtions and beleifs..He showed He is GURU NANAK and a SIKH. But if the writer of Bansawalinama IN SPITE of BECOMING A SINGH...still imputes certain practises of Brahminism ( his background) then he is guilty of being a brahminised "SINGH"... There are many such DASTAARDHAREE HINDUS who look and act like SINGHS but are brahmins in thought and deed. There are many out there who ACCUSE prof sahib Singh of " GURU GRANTH DARPAN"...a masterpirce on Guru garnth sahib Jee, as being BIASED in favour of "HINDU" BHAGATS, BHATTS, etc because he came from a HINDU BACKGROUND. These sources who belong to the Teja Singh Bhasaur Panch khalsa Diwan Group WANT to EXCLUDE ALL GURBANI thet is NOT written by SIKH GURUS from the Guru Granth sahib. SO when Prof sahib singh advances PROOFS that show that Bhagat bani is indeed put in there by GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE, these people LOOK for his HINDU BACKGROUND to attack him !!! Many people also point out to Master Tara singh ji's HINDU BACKGROUND as the "reason" he supported the Nehru gandhi Combine against an independent Khalistan... Ultimaterly WHICH "SIKH" came from a 100% genetically PURE SIKH background when even GURU NANAK came from a HINDU Khatrii background ??? We should LOOK at the THOUGHTS and DEEDS of a SINGH...not his parents ancestory.

Re: Hazur Sahib

A Singh · 29 Sep 2004

Jarnail Singh Bhaji, I concur with your closing comments ("We should LOOK at the THOUGHTS and DEEDS of a SINGH...not his parents ancestory.") and I am not ruling out matters related to Kesar Singh Chibber, however one only has to read the article on this website concerning Raagmala (and please this is not an invite to anyone to begin another thread on this topic) to see how some modern "Gursikh" writer freely make wild comments like accusing Sikhs of the past in being "Sikhs only in name". In fact, on the point of this paper (by Madan Singh of Apollo Road), he even cites Teja Singh Bhasauria as a credible source!!!

Re: Hazur Sahib

Mandeep Singh · 12 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh. To all my brothers: I'm just back from my first ever trip to Sachkhand Sri Hazur Sahib. I still saw those Hindu style rituals being followed over there. Just wanted to find out why they exist and found this mailing list. I saw that Bhai A Singh is interested in knowing 90% hindu rituals followed over there. Here is the list. Pls see if we really its not what Sikhi Taught, then can't we correct it. 1.There really *mandir* style arti that is performed over there. Amazingly they start with hymn from Guru Nanak Dev Ji, which talk about to Gagan being Thal and Suraj being Deepak. 2.Poojari jee take arti close to sangat and sangat rush to be revered by Arti. 3. Also Mandir Style Bells are used inside the Gurudwara during some rituals which I didn't understood. 4.In morning, Poojari ji make Chadan paste, which is then applied on the foreheads. Also Coconut is offered to Guruji. 5.When poojari move out of two savedar help push sangat aside, so that he can move. And poor people kneel down or even lie down to his feets. 6.In case there is some VIP guest during arti hours. Then some baba comes for some special blessings. Was not able to find more about the Baba Ji. 7.Bang is very much avaiable inside the Gurudwara Campus. But I feel thats very common practice among Nihang singhs. Nothing specific to Sri Hazur Sahib. 8.In Azaib ghar I saw I painting where Guru Gobind Singh Ji is seen as swaroop of Sri Ram. Call it avtaar. 9.Usually the room inside the Gurudwara sahib called Angitha Sahib is closed. Was not able to find a convincing answer Why? There is high degree of secrecy. They usually keep it locked during the Day. In evening when it was open by Poojari Ji (who sole has access to it) and people started shouting "Guru Ji is coming out". I was astonised and asked the person who told you that Guru Ji is locked? 10. Similarly near to MaalTekri, there is Dargarh of fakir who took care of "Treasure" that guru Ji kept safe with him. Some 9th Generation of the Fakir maintains the Dargarh. The contribution of the Fakir, generate respects for him. But people started bowing there head down on Dargarh and even I heard people that its important to visit Dargarh as it will fulfil you wishes. Some said a visit to Dargah is helpful if you have Joint paint. These are few things that I noticed and that bothered me. I extermly sorry If I saw things in wrong light. I'm nothing more than a kid as far as I knowledge the Sikh history is concerned. I only understood basic principles of Sikhi as dictated by Japji Sahib and Rehras Sahib. My knowledge is really limited. So if some knowledgeable person can shed some light on this, it will be helpful.

Re: Hazur Sahib

!! · 12 Oct 2005

as for as hindu idols being in the harmander sahib parkerma yes they were placed at 7 different places around the parkerma. hazoor sahib's rahit maryaada is different it is more brahamnical. yes hazoor sahib started the parkash of so called dasam granth between only 40 - 50 years ago. yes they do perform aarti with deevas. about 34 years ago they were also making fool of the sangat. they had an old empty 40 gallon oil drum with tight lid so that air could not escape. they were telling the sangat that guru ji is present during the mid day langer and if u concentrate while u r eating u will hear a drum sound. this sound was coming from the drum as the air expands because of mid day's heat. i had experienced this manmat myself. [%sig%]

Re: Hazur Sahib

Amazed... · 13 Oct 2005

You guys are classic... Listen Artee Artaa with the conch blowing and the bells is not "HINDU"! Let me explain. This is courtly marayda, just like a Chour Sahib. If you saw someone in a Hindu temple doing Chour Sahib of their pictures , would u suddently accuse all people who do Chaur Sahib are Baahmins? Please people. This marayda is purataan marayda and Nihang Singhs, Nirmalai and Udasis have kept this purataan marayda. Im sure if you ask any really old school Taksali Singh, they would agree. Aad Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Dasam Guru Granth Sahib Ji have always been together , like A Singh has said. This is not brahminism either.

Re: Hazur Sahib

O Singh · 13 Oct 2005

AMazed Jee, Arti arta is was never practiced in the royal courts of India. Neither the Rajput (Hindu) or the Mughal courts practiced this. This is a practice that was predominant in Hindu Mandirs and Hindu homes.

Re: Hazur Sahib

Zorawar Singh · 13 Oct 2005

just read Guru Nanak Dev Jis arti and compare it to the Hindu aarti. Then you will understand what nonsense is being said by those who have constantly put down Sikhi in favour for Hindu mat.

Re: Hazur Sahib

!! · 13 Oct 2005

amazed jee u don't understand the true meaning of aarti in guru granth sahib. who's aarti u r doing? if u r doing aarti of guru granth sahib ji then it is like a hindu deity an idol and guru ji is not an idol. if y r doing the aarti of aakalpurkh then there is no need of these small deevas as sun, moon and millions of stars are doing His aarti. no need for dhoof as sweet smell of sandal wood is comong from malyalm mountain. guru nanak ji condemned aarti of any form. aarti is not part of sikh maryaada or sikhi in any way. [%sig%]

Re: Hazur Sahib

ljkl · 14 Oct 2005

O Singh You are chatting BS bruv. All Hindus do artee, including Rajputs. I am one so I shud know

Re: Hazur Sahib

O Singh · 14 Oct 2005

ljkl, Aarti was never a part of the Rajput royal courts, but rather it was carried out in the Mandirs, or Hindu homes. So to compare Arti with 'Chour Sahib' is like comparing apples and oranges.

Re: Hazur Sahib

undergroundsingh · 15 Oct 2005

there are two saroops of shree guru granth sahib,one of shree dasam granth,one japjee sahib,one sukhmani sahib. there is larewaar akhand paath of shree guru granth sahib jee,every time. the other saroop is for daily hukamnama. dasam granth sahib jee is also parkaash daily. laree war akhand path of sukhmani sahib and japjee sahib.

Re: Hazur Sahib

avidya · 16 Oct 2005

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh What I find incredible is the picking and choosing of certain individuals and their mindsets. The fact that the aarti shabads are macrcosmic (i.e. the description of the whole of matter itself being the devotional worship of parmaatma) being said to be at odds with symbollic worship with fire, incense, water, flowers and sound. Surely taking the same assumption that it is 'manmat' to manifest the metaphysical principle in a physical object, would make amrit sanchaar in your thinking another hollow brahminical ritual? The old Kala Afghana route perhaps? If I mention historical texts then 'they have been brahminified', if I mention tradition ' it is kept by brahminified Sikhs'. Of course the touchstone to your arguments is Gurbani, but clearly as mentioned above, the aarti shabads are as much against practical aarti, as they are against any other act of symbolism in Sikhi. To my own mind, you need to look to the Guru's own lives as well as Gurbani to contextualise it. Taje for example tiraths. It is held by such a mindset that visiting and bathing at tiraths are utterly manmat. Yet Guru Amar Das MADE a tirath at Goindwal! It even has symbollism attached to the steps at the baoli! So it would seem if you go back to Gurbani and consider it in this light, you find the correct teaching which is that the outer aspects of practice can be symbollic, but they must be truthful, meaningful and full of devotional worhsip to Parbrahm. If they are done out of any other motivation then it is pointless. I digress! Traditionally the actual aarti contains all panchtattva on the thal giving it a similar interpretation. Aarti isn't just the stay of Takhat Patna sahib and Takhat Hazoor Sahib, but also of all four main samprdas (Nihangs, Udasin, Nirmalay and Sewapanthis) who in the case of the Udasis were elected to run the Gurdwaray by the Guru himself during the dark years of the early 18th century, the same order he writes of in Bachittar Natak. The claim of idol worship by '!!' by doing aarti of Sri Guru Granth Sahib is surprising since clearly Gurbani states that Guru is nothing less than sarguna Paratma. If that sounds like heresy you need to read Gyani Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwale's katha on Japuji Sahib which states the same. Balpreet Singh's complaint that there were paintings of devtay in Sri Patna Sahib back when is also naive. If a Gurdwara can have pictures of Sants, or paintings of bhagats up, what then is the issue of putting up paintings of fellow devtay who hold a similar position when mentioned in Gurbani?! This is plain paranoia! Rather than define gurmat by the political and identity needs of the day, spend time really thinking about what Gurbani is stating which is a timeless statement of truth. Please do not impose such petty identity issues on Gurmat. A final issue, vaguely related here, which has been on my mind for sometime, and which some of the sangat on this forum will be able to explain... From what I read, when things are 'totally anti-gurmat' like this, then you advise fellows Kaurs and Singhs to stay away. I presume this would have been the original sentiment of Jagjit Singh, and Jugroop Singh has stated such sentiments with regard to even speaking to some of the supposed nangs of the UK. If this is the case; a) Why did Bhai Jeevan Singh serve as granthi for so long at Sri Patna Sahib with its clearly 'anti gurmat' maryada of an elaborate aarti of the image and asthan of Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji using a conical aarti lamp? Surely he shouldn't have stayed an hour longer had he shared your opinions? b) Why do AKJ continue to hold Raensabhais at Sri Takhat Patna Sahib with such 'manmat' maryada and BJP sponsored practice? Surely this would make the attendees equally dubious using your own logic? No accusations are being made on my part, because I imagine those individuals simply accept this is the maryada even if they disagree! I have seen a Bibi ji following AKJ maryada who was part of the raensabhai group with my own eyes stand for the aarti, although not moving forward, at Sri Patna Sahib. I'd be interested in the answer.

Re: Hazur Sahib

jj · 16 Oct 2005

if its so messed up why is it a takhat???

Re: Hazur Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Oct 2005

It is a TAKHAT...because Guru Ji/Panth declared it to be... BUT "merely being a "takhat" doesnt mean it is all correct in every way...because the "Takhat" is not abuilding...but the People who RUN IT....and people can be..all sorts...messed up real bad..or just alittle bit..or not at all..depends....

Re: Hazur Sahib

SIngh · 19 Oct 2005

Its funny that some ignorant people are confused about Arti being a Sikh ceremony. Such people rather than worrying about puratan accounts need firstly to READ GURBANI itself, which makes it clear that the real Arti is not the Hindu form of worship, therefore it is not part of Sikhi. Where Arti is mentioned in Gurbani it is therefore not in the literal sense but is an analogy for worship, unless one thinks that Gurbani or Bhai Gurdas contradicts itself, ie by showing from the very beginning that the Hindu form of Arti is not the real Arti then going on to practice it. The fact is that Gurbani is the real source of Gurmat and people should perhaps care to research this in the first instance rather than confusing themselves. avidya further wrote "Balpreet Singh's complaint that there were paintings of devtay in Sri Patna Sahib back when is also naive. If a Gurdwara can have pictures of Sants, or paintings of bhagats up, what then is the issue of putting up paintings of fellow devtay who hold a similar position when mentioned in Gurbani?!" From Gurbani you would no that no Devtay has a position in Gurmat. In-fact it reveals how Devtay have their essence in maya. All the gods and goddesses are enticed by Maya. Page 227, Line 4 -- Guru Nanak Dev The angelic beings, goddesses and gods are deluded by doubt. Page 258, Line 14 -- Guru Arjan Dev You worship gods and goddesses, but you do not know the Supreme Lord God. Page 332, Line 15 -- Saint Kabir Devtay in Sikhi have no position of authority (and yes I have read Dhasm Granth before you jump on some next bandwagon) but are mere creations. They are stuck on the loose of births and death, and also long for Waheguru and are in his hukam just like everyone else. On a related note a Gurdwara should not be a gallery of photo's of saints anyway, let alone holding photo's of Devtays or whatever else you may think of.

Re: Hazur Sahib

keepin it real · 19 Oct 2005

i got back from hazoor sahib this summer, and i saw everything mandeep singh saw...and more. It was the first time i had ever been there and i was disheartened when they started putting tilks on peoples foreheads and to see a someone wearing a dastaar with a tilk on there forehead looked pathetic. One thing i noticed was that all the gurdwara's had some sort of tourist business running and they were actually asking us to not put money into the golak but near a photo so once you had left they could take it for themselves (which i saw). Also at one gurdwara we were giving money for buliding funds and as they were writing out a reciept they had not filled out their side of the book (like in cheque books you write the cheque and tear it out but you also fill in the little tab fot your own reference) and my brother in law grabbed the book and he found that it was 75% used and none of it had been filled in. So who knows how much of the sangats money is used for building funds and how much was eaten up by these conmen? pul chuk maaf karni

Re: Hazur Sahib

Manveer · 19 May 2006

I even i went last summer, and yes its true they do everything u said, actually they even stole a purse from us, and said they didn't know where it went? It was w/in 5secs ..maybe they have hired ppl to do this? But I think the aarti sounds nice, people like me, who have not read the Granth Sahib, i have no clue if were supposed to do it or not..alll i know is that i like it....can't we all get long? lol? i mean whats the big deal. If we act like this...then wats the difference b/w us and hindu's and expecially Muslims..who fight?