Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Balveer Singh · 16 Sep 2004
Gurfatehji,
We all know the situation that occurred whilst Guru Sahibji was at Mecca and that he donned blue attire with a book under the armpit which contained gurujis writings covered with clean cloth according to Bhai Gurdasjis var.
My question is when Guru Sahib was to enter Mecca, guruji would have been asked if he was a mussalman, if his response was affirmative then he would have provided a derogative reply with accordance to gurbani within Sri Guru Granth Sahibji.
"I am not a Hindoo, nor am I a Muslim. My body and breath of life belong to Allah - to Raam - the God of both." ||4|| (Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Ang 1136)
I do not make pilgrimages to Mecca, nor do I worship at Hindu sacred shrines. I serve the One Lord, and not any other. || 2 || I do not perform Hindu worship services, nor do I offer the Muslim prayers. I have taken the One Formless Lord into my heart; I humbly worship Him there.|| 3 || [Ang 1136]
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 16 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
THAT is what is meant by TURNING MECCA.
Guur Ji ceretainly did not TURN MECCA around PHYSICALLY...if that was the case EVERYTHING IN MECCA would have turned around and everything would be at Ground ZERO...
GURU JI debated with the hajis and TURNED their way of thinking around to HIS WAY.... that ALLAH is all around us and NOT in the Kaaba ALONE.
My humble opinion.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Balveer Singh · 16 Sep 2004
Gurfatehji,
Thank you for your reply, however, I dont think I made myself clear :
My question is that non-muslims are banned a visiting pass into mecca to see the kabba, how did Satguru Nanak Sahibji get in, when you need to declare verbally that you are a muslim... did Guru Sahib say he was or was the ban not around in them days?
We are told by Bhai Gurdasji what occurred in mecca however Bhai Gurdasji does not explain how guruji got in.
Look forward to your replies.
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Kulbir Singh · 16 Sep 2004
In those days, there were not rigid system as they have in place currently at Mecca. Guru Sahib was dressed up like other Haajis and I don't think he was asked to fill out a form declaring himself a Muslim as they do it now.
Regarding Kaaba revolving around, along with Guru Sahib's feet, I truly believe that it actually happened. If Guru Sahib had just changed the mind of Jeevan Shah, then it would not have become such a big story because Guru Sahib changed minds of countless people in his time. At the same time we should remember that it was Vaheguru who performed the miracle and Guru Sahib would not have intended to revolve the Mecca with his feet.
Gurbani lists several miracles that occurred with Bhagat Naamdev, Bhagat Kabir and Bhagat Prahlaad jee. So something like this to have happened to Guru Sahib does not surprise me.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 16 Sep 2004
I agree with veerjee Kulbir singh - mecca physically turned, and jeevan shah's mind spiritually turned after that.
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 17 Sep 2004
Bhai Jernail Singh Ji.. what do you have to say about this:
"tta(n)go(n) pakarr ghaseettiaa firiaa maakaa kalaa dhikhaaree||"
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 18 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
First of all I agree with Veer Kulbeer Singh ji about the entrance into mecca...no passports and viasas or forms of declarations to fill up as now.
Secondly it is my personal opinion that "MECCA" as such means that, the town was open to all...but the KAABAA must have been closed as even TODAY not every MUSLIM can get close to Kaaba ( our Prime Minister Dr Mahathir was given a special privilege by the saudi Authorities to enter the kaaba shrine )
TO "SEE" if anything physically moves or changes DIRECTION.... ONLY ONE LANDMARK must MOVE. For example if the Statue of Liberty which faces the SEA is MOVED or changes direction..then ALL the REST has to be in the Same place for us to see that the statue has moved....IF EVERYTHING MOVES then how do we see what has moved..
Looks like Bhai Gurdass Ji is using the words Mecca and Kaaba interchangeably...Muslims PRAY in the DIRECTION of KAABAA ( mecca just happens to be in the same place in a general way )... so if at all any LANDMARK moved then it must have been the Kaaba.....not the entire city of Mecca as then NOBODY can see any change as everyhting is in its usual place...
1. If the kaaba was "moved" then it was RETURNED to its original place ??? Why ?? What was the purpose of this miracle...since NO MUSLIM stopped worshipping that way.
2. Then at hardwar GURU JI also "Changed " peoples MINDS...DIRECTION....not phyiscally change/ or make HIS WATER fall down in PUNJAB ( Guru Ji COULD have DONE THAT and SHOWN that as well ( or waheguru done that )...but there is no record of that.
Based on this I beleive that GURU JI "turned" or changed the MINDSET of the hajis who DEBATED with Him about God's prescence in every place and not only in kabba. Just like GURU JI managed to convince the Hindus at hardwar while throwing water in the direction of Punjab..GURU JI also Turned the Muslim Minds while His Divine LEGS were being PULLED around.
Take into account _ A BILLION MUSLIMS STILL PRAY towards Kaaba/Mecca Five times daily...NOTHING CHANGED
A BILLION HINDUS also pray at hardwar and throw water to their pittars living in the SUN...NOTHING CHANGED either.
Changing MINDSETS is FOREVER....those that beleived in GURU JI changed forever...THOSE that beleive in PHYSICAL CHANGE...will forever keep looking for PHYSICAL CHANGE ( MIRACLE) that their eyes must see to beleive. IF I am to become a Christian soley because I beleive Jesus revived the Dead lazarus....then I MUST SEE JESUS REVIVING A DEAD MAN before I will beleive in Him as Divine. IF we tell a MUSLIM...you must beleive what GURU NANAK says in His GURBANI.....and he turns around and says: OK Tell Guru Granth Ji to TURN MECCA around and I will beleive.??? what are we going to do ??? Can any Brahmgianai/sant/etc turn MECCA around TODAY to show the Billion Muslims ?? In one STROKE the population of Sikhs will rise by a BILLION !!! and then we go to hardwar and create another Billion Sikhs instantly....
GURU JI's REVOLUTIONARY GIAN is in the GURBANI....lets PREACH that GIAN...it has the POWER to CHANGE minds. That GIAN is very much alive and well... all we have to do is to use it.
GURU GOBIND SINGH JI "created" the Panj piyaras....it was NOT a ONE OFF "SHOW" that ONLY occurred in 1699 at Anandpur sahaib...HE gave us the FORMULA to CREATE a MILLION 1699's FOREVER.....we can create the PANJ PIYARA MIRACLE whenever we like...THAT is a TRUE MIRACLE.
Similarly GURU NANAK ji gave us the FORMULA...not a one off show of miraculous powers. Lets use the FORMULA to spread His Teachings...many millions will become SIKHS using this Formula.
Dass Jarnail Singh.
PS. I have no 'axe to grind" with any veer ji that beleives in actual physical miracles as such. Every one sees GURU JI in his own special way.....and I can live with that. I dont claim to know everything or that everything must be my way only...God Forbid.
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Manjeet Kaur Sidhu · 19 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Rememeber...the MIRACLES shown by our GURUS are not for a single lifetime or day only....they are FOREVER and RENEWED DAILY all over the world.
Wittness how GURU NANAK changed into GURU ANGAD... A Miracle ....AApeh GURU ate AApeh Chela...
HOW GURU NANAK JYOT went through from Guru nanak to GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE...a Miracle forever
HOW GURU GOBIND SINGH asked for and RECEIVED FIVE HEADS on a PLATTER.... SIKHS ALL over the World RENEW this MIRACLE many many times daily at AMRIT SANCHAARS...which Produce the Same results that Guru Ji produced in 1699...
These are the LIVING RENEWABLE MIRACLES that we remember our Gurus For....
1. The miracle of Mecca revolving....happened only ONCE ( if it did - no comments on this)..... surely anyone has a RIGHT to ASK/QUESTION this Happening/EVENT as HE has NOT seen it with his own EYES...????
BUT the MIRACLE of JAPJI SAHIB/ASA DI WAAR/Oankar/Swaeyeh Mahalleh pehleh Ke/ etc are TODAY, and FOREVER CHANGING PEOPLES LIVES all over the world and will continue to do so .... THIS IS A TRUE MIRACLE of the Shabad GURU that is available for everyone's eyes to see for himslef any time any day.... IF MY CHILDREN ASK ME: Show us PROOF that MECCA revolved..... I have NO ANSWER. I CANNOT show them and niether can anyone else no matter sant or brahmgiani..... BUT if they ask me: SHOW US HOW JAPJI SAHIB can change a Person.... I have a thousand ANSWERS - verifiable and truthful...and I am NOT a sant or Brahmgiani but an ordinary sikh.
These are the MIRACLES I BELIEVE IN.....not Guru Ji revolving Mecca, or flying about on his magic carpet/Kharawwan etc which many sants quote, giving quotations form Bhai gurdass Ji varran/Janamsakhis... etc
GURU NANAK - GURU GOBIND SINGH JI.....changed a DEAD CORPSE ( dead for 1000 years ) INTO the VIBRANT KHALSA...that is ALIVE TODAY all over the WORLD.....compare this MIRACLE to one about JESUS that made a recently DEAD man Lazarus LIVE for a few days/weeks/months/years ??? Where is LAZARUS TODAY ??? Guru Ji's KHALSA is incrreasing by leaps and bounds by the DAY.. Now you tell me which is a BIGGER MIRACLE ??? Yet I always hear about so called miracles : dead cow revived ?? etc so what ???With HUGE Miracles of GURBANI and kHALSA right in front of our eyyes we still want "tiny miracles" like revolving cities, dead cows coming to life ??? WHY ?? Forgive me but I see no relevance in these small time "miracles"...they are PALE candles in front of the SUN of GURU NANAK...performing miracles in the KHALSA FORM.
A truer MIRACLE happened to GURU AMARDASS JI.....when Bhai dassu the son of Guru angad Ji KICKED GURU JI in open COURT...and GURU JI immediately caught hold of his foot and started massaging it saying oh my son, your foot must hurt so much as my old bones are hard !!! AND BHAI DASSU's HEART CHANGED IMMEDIATELY.....he swa the LIGHT !!! Now that is what I call a MIRACLE. ( you will know what i mean if we look at ourselves...does any one dare to even "LOOK" in our direction in the Gurdwara.....and we "STARE" back...how many of us will let anyone KICK us in the BACK....and massage the foot of the attacker ??? ( BE HONEST )
I CAN PERFORM THIS MIRACLE DAILY ( if I have GURU Ji's KIRPA ON MY HEAD)..anywhere in the world.....BUT I CANNOT TURN MECCA !!! ( and dont tell me I can IF Guru Ji has KIRPA on me because this is NOT going to happen or MECCA will be TURNING almost DAILY if not weekly....becasue GURU Ji has KIRPA on a lot of us but we dont go around doing this stuff !!!) IT is definitely EASIER to MASSAGE the FOOT of someone who KICKS you than turn mecca around on its axis...but this is a MIRACLE because the GURUS TAUGHT US to DO what they DO...IF We can PRODUCE PANJ PIYARAS DAILY and perform the Miracle of 1699...can anyone in the world TURN MECCA for the CNN/BBC world wide Media to show ???? There is a difference !!! The Khalsa creation is a MIRACLE the Gurus taught us to Perform...the other is a one off lessson for some soul long gone....therefore we MUST concentrate on the SECOND miracle which we can all perform as SIKHS and leave the rest to history.
Dassree Manjit Kaur
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
ShaktiShali Sheaa Soora · 20 Sep 2004
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
The only way other religions will convert to a Sikh and understand the way of life is if all that Sikhs now become stricter and do more and more Naam Bhagti then ever. This has to be done at amritvelaa no matter what as you all know, in the day is well if Sikhs have time i.e. no work to do. All other enjoyments have no taste, an illusion to the mind in making it think this is fun.
jaagith joth japai nis baasur eaek binaa man naik n aanai ||
He the Khalsa meditates on the Ever-radiant Light, day and night, and rejects all else but the one Lord from the mind.
The above Gurbani line, which is from Guru Gobind Singh Jee states that the Khalsa does not get caught in the delusional worldly web by placing the mind in other fake pleasures.
The revolution of khalistan can only be achieved by the Khalsa, not every Sikh can be called Khalsa now. There are only a few out there. The Shaheed Singh (from Saachkhand) when with Bhai Rama singh Jee told him that the reason why Khalsa hasn’t achieved its rule yet is because the Sikhs aren’t strict in the rehit as well as not all Sikhs keep all of there panj kakkars on after taking Amrit. Also their amritvelaa is very weak since a small amount of Sikhs awake at amritvela.
judhh jithae einehee kae prasaadh einehee kae prasaadh s dhaan karae ||
It is through the actions of the Khalsa that I have been victorious, and have been able to give charities to others.
In the above Gurbani line Guru Gobind Singh Jee states that he was only successful through the actions of the Khalsa. This means a Sikh must become a Gursikh and stay strict and strong in their religion in order to keep Miri and Piri, a balance in life.
gur sathigur kaa jo sikh akhaaeae s bhalakae out(h) har naam dhhiaavai ||
One who calls himself a Sikh of the Guru, the True Guru, shall rise in the early morning hours and meditate on the Lord's Name.
By mastering Amritvelaa one is called Gurus Sikh as said in the above line.
Afterwards Bhai Rama Singh Je was told that when the Sikhs become Gursikhs then something secret, unknown would be revealed to the Panj Pyarya. Then Khalsa shall firstly be achieved in Punjab and then throughout the whole of India. While this is happening the Khalsa shall be helping others, offering a house to all building more hospitals basically even animals won’t remain ill. Other religions will about the Khalsa fill more interested.
This whole event has been written in Bhai Rama Singh Jees book, ‘In Search Of The True Guru’.
AND then will billions of muslims and Hindus become Sikhs. But firstly the Sikhs have to show more love to Vaheguru Jee and follow Guru Gobind Singh jees way of life just as the Brhamgyanie Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee did and all other Brhamgyanieaa.
eae man aalas kiaa karehi guramukh naam dhhiaae ||1|| rehaao ||
O mind, why are you so lazy? Become Gurmukh, and meditate on the Naam. ||1||Pause||
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
SinghagainstBling · 27 Nov 2004
Bhai Gurdas Ji did not only mention the incidence concerning Guru Nanak Dev Ji but also the same for Bhagat Namdev Ji twice which is listed below.
Can there be any doubt left now if the Bhagat Jis could do it dont you think Guru Sahib Ji could?
Guru Sahib had awsome shakti blessed from Akaal do you think he was limited and bound in maya chains like us who cant see beyond the physical limitations of the scientific realm ? God created earth dont you think his messenger could make it turn? Can you a human being bring a dead being back to life with all your science, qualifications, post grads? Bhagat Namdev bought a creature back to life through bhagti.
There has to be a line between science and sikhi when one is limitless and one limited to physics. the moon earth and sun planets rotates, Guru sahib cant make things rotate now? Its in hukam of the Creator Divine that it moves the direction matter is a slave to the Maker. Guru Sahib blessed by Akaal can do anything he likes He is Beyond Science and rational thinkers, the world rotates the way he wants it to, this land has been made for the saint what greater saint than Guru Nanak Dev JI himself?
http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=57
gaae muee jeevaaleeoun naamadhaeo dhaa shhapar shhaayaa||
On another occasion God brought a dead cow to life and also thatched the hut of Namdev.
faer dhaehuraa raakhioun chaar varan lai pairee(n) paayaa||
On yet another occasion, God rotated the temple (after Naamdev was not allowed entrance) and made all the four castes (varnas) bow at the feet of Namdev.
bhagath janaa(n) dhaa karai karaayaa ||aa||
The Lord accomplishes whatever is done and desired by saints.
This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 12
kalijug naamaa bhagath hi(n)dhoo musalamaan faer dhaehuraa gaae jeevaaee||
In kaliyuga, a devotee named Namdev made the temple rotate and dead cow alive.
" God rotated the temple" not percieved , thought, imagined, or seemed to to have.
"made the temple rotate" - no hidden codes/massala/chillis/salts peppers/ in the thaali. Bhai Gurdas has said it plain and clear straight out not once but twice. the Truth is so crystal clear, how anyone can doubt Bhai Gurdas Ji Vara, the "Chabbi to Guru Granth Sahib Ji" is way beyond moorakhs like me.
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Guldeep Singh · 28 Nov 2004
Jio Jio Nama Har Gun Ucharay, Bhagat Janna Ka Dehura Phiray.
As written is Guru Granth Sahib Ji, the temple did turn and the door faced Bhagat Namdev. This temple still exists in Maharashtra. It is still turned around. It is the only temple in the world where as you enter, the idols are facing the "back" of the temple. ie. the temple swerved around but the inside stayed put.
If the temple turned for Bhagat Namdev Ji, the Kaba can definately turn for Guru Nanak Dev Ji.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Re: Satguru Nanak Devji and Mecca
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
I am CONVINCED. Thank You.
Sabh te Wadda SATGUR Nanak Jin kal Rakhee Meree.
dass jarnail singh.