Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

Kulbir Singh · 14 Sep 2004

Sant Samaj is totally wrong in not accepting the Nanakshahi Calender. Daas, Kulbir Singh Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak Tribune News Service Amritsar, September 14 The Sant Samaj, headed by Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, has announced to hold ‘parallel’ quadricentennial celebrations of the installation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib in the SGPC complex tomorrow in violation of Nanakshahi Jantri, approved by Akal Takht . The Sant Samaj and two Takhts — Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib — had already announced to hold the quadricentennial celebrations as per old Bikrami calendar, which was considered direct challenge to the authority of Akal Takht. However, nobody in the SGPC was ready to take the responsibility of giving permission to the Sant Samaj for organising a function in violation of the Nanakshahi Jantri. Jathedar Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, who initially feigned ignorance about the proposed ‘parallel function’ by the Sant Samaj, said that it was a matter of concern that certain vested interests wanted to create division in the Sikh Panth. During a meeting with Jathedar Vedanti, representatives of Dal Khalsa and Sikh League, including Mr Kanwarpal Singh and Mr Mohinder Singh Grewal, respectively, said that the move of the Sant Samaj to celebrate the 400 years of installation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib had drawn flak from all over the world. Taking exception to the Sant Samaj’s opposition to Nanakshahi calendar, they blamed its leadership for sowing the seeds of discontent amongst the Sikhs. First they had divided the Sikhs on maryada issue by practising different maryadas in their respective deras, now they had opposed Nanakshahi calendar, a true manifestation of distinct religio-political identity of the Sikhs, said Mr Kanwarpal Singh. Emphasising the need for urgent measures to check further divisions amongst Sikhs they said the Jathedar should play a vital role in this regard.

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

GKD · 14 Sep 2004

in modern day who is member of sant samaj, seems like a whole bunch of bologny whats goin on if these sants can't help with unity who can?

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

AnotherSingh · 14 Sep 2004

http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/index.php This is DDT's view of this calender. Just in case anybody's interested.

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

indy · 15 Sep 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh lakh lakh vadaiyin to all the cyber sangat on Maharaajs phela parkash divas, which falls on this day 15th Sept according to the orignal calender what Guru ji used. There are Sri Akhand Parth Sahib Jis in england today in walsall and tividale where Baba tarkhur Singh ji acting Jathadar Damdami Taksaal and jatha will be hold divans. stay Chardi Kala indy

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

................. · 15 Sep 2004

15 sepember is the right date Full stop

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

Harbhajan Singh · 15 Sep 2004

****15 sepember is the right date Full stop******* -Not according to the Akal Takht it isn't!

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

..... · 15 Sep 2004

according to Akal Takht Kesh are part of the "Ks" not Keski. So why do AKJ belive in Keski. Bring Unite in the sikhs dont fight for small things.

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

well actually · 15 Sep 2004

The Akal Takhat is not Guru, khalsa Panth is.

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

:-o · 15 Sep 2004

GurFateh Ji, My local Gurdwara Sahib (UK) celebrated today aswell (15/09/04)... :-) Lakh Lakh Vadaiyin Guru Maharaaj's Parkash Divas :-)

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

lowly · 15 Sep 2004

Is the present jathedar a puppet of the SGPC? Why was Jathedar Ranjit Singh taken out of his position? Lakh Lakh Vadhaia on Parkash Divas Of Guru Maharaj!

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Sep 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear " well actually ji, " who is "khalsa Panth" to you ?? The Guru Khalsa Panth has already Celebrated this mahaan Gurpurab on 1st September, 2004 WORLWIDE. Now another dhaii paa kichree is being cooked separately by a few dass jarnial singh

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

well actually · 15 Sep 2004

bhai jarnail singh jee, today's sikh masses are like sheep. if there was a party at harimandir sahib for badal's birthday all the sikhs in punjab would show up to celebrate it. what are you telling me about celebrating this gurpurab.if we wanted to celebrate this gurpurab we would stop cutting our beards and killing our daughters. we would stop cheating our relatives of money and performing superstitious rituals under the guidance of pakhandi babas. the masses are not the guru khalsa panth. the guru khalsa panth is the whole of the khalsa, which is very small compared to the 22 million "sikhs" claimed in the world. the khalsa are very rare and they are a class above your typical half-sikh. we have made a joke of our own panth. i am not saying that sikhs should not have celebrated any gurpurab.whoever celebrated on the 1st of september, great for them. whoever celebrated on the 15th, great for them.but the issue that concerns me is nanakshahi calendar. how was the calendar made by one man accepted by a phony jathedar under the power of badal --- without holding a worldwide sarbat khalsa like the one in 1986 / 87? as i said before - the only official hukam from the akal takhat that stands since 1986 is that the khalsa panth has declared khalistan. everything since then is null and void, as i accept hukam from nobody but my guru in the form of guru granth sahib, the punj pyare, or the khalsa panth.

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

Rashminder Singh Oz · 16 Sep 2004

akaal takht sahib has declared that khalsa panth should nanakshai calender thats it gurfateh ji

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

M Singh · 16 Sep 2004

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, Sant Samaj is not wrong on Calendar issue. Akal Takhat Jathedar Vedanti Ji had done wrong by releasing it from Akal Takhat Sahib. That was SGPC affair, it should not have been given the " Akal " touch. Arshi Ji, please note, we as sikhs are itself Dhai Paa Khiri on this planet. Majority is not always correct, generally wrong. AKJ people are very few among sikhs, but they are correct on many issues. Of course, Akal Takhat is supreme. but our Jathedars not always. Bhai Puran Singh Ji as Jathedar was correct, on calendar issue. Pehla Parkash Gurpurab Celebrations were being done on "Bhadon Sudhi Ekam" from 1605 to 2003. This includes the period of the GURUS also. So, we should not be harsh on this issue. Anyway, calendar issue can be discussed in detail on this forum, provided the sangat is ready to rethink on the issue, very politely.

Re: Sant Samaj’s move on celebrations draws flak

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 16 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I am not happy with the nanaksahi calendar also - most of it is anything but NANAKSHAHI. One person rehashed a few dates and such and called it nanaksahi...but it also has some puranmashis and such which are ANTI GURMATT. ( BUT the SANT SAMAJ SUPPORTS such PURANMASHIS STUFF !!!!)..so on this I DIFFER from sant samaj. BUT i am supporting it for the present because the Akal Takhat SGPC has passed it. When the time comes we can always call a Sarbatt Khalsa and MODIFY or totally REJECT this calendar and create a TRULY SIKH Calendar...but until then we should stick to one - having two makes a joke out of us.....soem Gurdwaras celebrate on one day...others on another....children phone and ask which is wchich ??? all becomes a joke. DR Harjinder Singh Dilgeer created a totally SIKH Calendar with totally Sikh names for 7days, 12 months etc...sgpc/akal takhat gave it no attention. When a Sarbatt khalsa is called that calendar can also be discussed. This Calendar is issued by the Canda Based Edmonton Sikh Affairs Journal. I could find no fault with it...but since the Panth ahs not accepted it we cant do anything about it. dass jarnail singh