sikhs dressing up for gurdwara
gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 09 Sep 2004
vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh!
the other day i was at the local superstore and i saw a well-respected singh who was in my punj pyare, which was a pleasant surprise so i went over to say fateh to him... but what i was surprised at was that normally this singh has a huge dumalla and always a chand tora and other shastar... he's even been given a farla... basically he's always dressed in full bana complete with huge sri sahib and hazooria
when i saw him at the store, he was wearing just a plain kurta pajama, smaller keski, and sri sahib UNDER his clothes... no other shaster on his keski or anything... i barely recognized him...
so my question is, why would someone dress up so nicely for the gurdwara or for a 'big smagam' (i remember seeing him also at a 'smaller' smagam and he wasn't as impressively dressed as the bigger smagams) and then when they go out in public, its like they just get rid of it all
isnt the whole point of wearing shastar for protection? a chand and tora in your dastaar plus chakars and other shastar make it like a helmet... why would you wear this 'helmet' in the gurdvara, where you're LEAST likely to be attacked, and not out in public where there's a much higher chance of someone attacking you? why would you wear your sri sahib underneath your kurta? let's forget about that for a moment... firstly you would need to get a smaller sri sahib to fit under your clothes discreetly... so why would one get RID of protection when they most need it?
is it wrong to dress up nicely in bana for a huge smagam and then 'scrub out' for the rest of the time? isn't guru sahib always with us? shouldn't we always be ready to defend ourselves and others?
sorry for rambling on...
please submit some feedback..
vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh!!
Re: sikhs dressing up for gurdwara
Ranjit Kaur Gill · 09 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
It is not practical to be in ful bana all the time.
on a side note we have a "panj piyara" in malaysia who keeps an indonesian maid (MUSLIM) to wash his kacherras for him..cooks their food .....and lives on his wife's earnings... And this is no ordinary panj piyara but that of a fundamental Taksaali niketan brand which claim to be direct descendants of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI.
He wears bana only at panj piayara services.....other times he is in western dress.
so thats that.
Ranjeet Gill
Re: sikhs dressing up for gurdwara
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 11 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Bhen Ji ranjit kaur Ji,
I am also from MALAYSIA. I agree with you that it is not practical to wear the FULL BANA all the time...and also when we wear the Kirpan it is usually "under" the shirt ( to avoid unnecessary confrontations with the "law" )
But i dont agree with your comments about someone. What people do in their "private" lives should be kept "private". many people in Malaysia have Indonesian Muslim maids....and if she washes the family clothes ( cheap skates shut off their washing machines to "save" electricity and make "full use" of their maids since they pay them a "princely sum" of USD 100 A MONTH !!!) then she can wash his kacherras also. Whats the big deal anyway. Also a lot of Malaysian couples both work in order to have a richer life style. This man's wife "may" be earning more than him but that hardly makes him "live" on her earnings ( the way you say it seems to make him a pimp )....Gursikhs deserve better than that.
To save further grief....Iwould NOT become a Panj Piayara if I were him. Our JEEWAN must reflect our inner strength. If I cant even wash my own kacherra daily, then I dont have the moral strength to be a Panj Piyara and must DECLINE...but if the person doesnt decline ( maybe because his organisation is desperately SHORT of Panj piyaras...I KNOW because some have to be IMPORTED from INDIA for an ocassion....luckily GURU JI just asked for FIVE HEADS....just imagine our level of difficulty finding enough if Guru Ji had asked for 50 heads/or heaven forbid 100 !!!...since we cant even FIND FIVE !!! ) then lets give him the benefit of the doubt and close one eye - PLEASE... Washing such dirty linen in public really doesnt help our image.
these are just my personal comments. Please dont feel offended.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
dass jarnail singh
Re: sikhs dressing up for gurdwara
Gursikha(n) kee har dhoorh deh · 11 Sep 2004
-------
It is not practical to be in ful bana all the time.
-------
althought im not in full bana all the time, i dont think its impractical... i know of a few young gursikhs who do stay in bana at all times... and im sure i would never see this singh wearing pants and a shirt... only chola or kurta.... and a kurta pajama isnt too far from a chola so its not really impractical