Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
Mnajeet Kaur Gyani · 03 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
YES and then we would have GURBANI CHANNAN all over and the DARKNESS of AGIANTA would disappear.....
The Multimillion dollar gurdwaras, marble langgar halls, SAROVARS all over, etc etc ...... are a sheer waste of the Sangat's GOLAK. The Guru ji's GOLAK MUST be spent on Spreading the MESSAGE of GURBANI...literature, gurbani should be freely available to all who want to study Sikhism...
Thios will put an end to those sants derawallahs etc who want so desperately to "keep gurbani under wraps" and out of reach of the ordinary Sikh ( Tuseen aapna kaam karo ji, ate gurbani paath pooja sanoo karneh do...aseh paath karangeh ate usda FALL asin tuhanuu devangeh ( for money / Other favours...of course).
Guru Ji came into this World to TELL US ALL HE KNEW...that is why they spent over 250 Years and 10 jammas to COLLECT all the GURBANI from all over the World into One GRANTH.....to enable us to connect with waheguru through one easy step. NO prophet worked so hard to set up such a religious Super Highway for his followers as our Gurus did for US.
We need NO MIDDLEMEN, NO intermediaries, NO "superior or elevated souls" to guide us....ALL that is an advertisement gimmick of those who want to CONTROL the Super Highway guru Ji built for US.....they have vested interests and want to impose TOLLS on this Highway to enrich themselves...EVERYTHING we need to "KNOW" is written down in easy language in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. All we need to do is apply our EFFORT and LOVE...and GURU will take a THOUSAND MILES to our one STEP towards him...
Manjeet Kaur
Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 08 Sep 2004
sikhitothemax is an AMAZING invention, amazing seva and awesome tool
but the interpretations / translations of gurbani used in the software are sometimes way WAY off...
there needs to be a complete adjustment of all the interpretations
Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 08 Sep 2004
I personally enjoy reading teeka's (translations) done of gurbani. Especially when it is done thoroughly by such Panthik gianis as Bhai SAhib Singh and Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara.
I like reading their teekas because they provide insight into the root words and gurbani viakaran with clarity that comes from a life dedidicated to gurbani research.
We can learn so much.
Since we are not able to discuss gubani with these and many other sewadars who have passed away, their views and opinions are passed to us through their books.
I belive these books should be freely available to all.
I attended a few keertans where gurbani was projected onto the a screen but after a while i didn't like it anymore. I can't explain why I just don't like it and I think that it does more harm than good in the long run.
Simply because the translations are taken by many...as 100% correct. IN my limited understanding of gurbani i know that many of the translations are totally incorrect.
Secondly, in my opinion and this might not be the case with everyone... it takes the attention away from people listening to the keertan and trying to understand it themselves.
Thirdly, i haven't seen an increase in the amount of people that singh along. I mean the best way to get laha from keertan is to listen and sing along and these two things don't seem to be encouraged by the projectors.
Again, these are my observations i might be wrong.
However i belive that the projectors are a great tool in a camp / classroom environment.
Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
kar kirpaa sabh rayN theevaa · 09 Sep 2004
While I agree with "ns" I also tend to agree with "Friendly Neighbourhood Singh"
The translations offered in SikhiToTheMax are often WAY WAY off the meaning that many Gursikh vidvaans offer in Punjabi. . . and thus it leads to misinterpretation and misrepresentation of the message of GUrbani
However, I disagree with FNS veerjee on the comment that less people sing along. I have noticed a drastic improvement in the ability of youth and adults alike to be more involved in the keertan if the software is used.
Nonetheless, I think the idea has disabled itself in someways as the transliteration (pronounciation) is typed SO SMALL at the bottom in SIkhiToTheMax software that most kids can't read it.
The transliteration (pronounciation), interpretation (translation), and the GUrmukhi akhars should all be equal size, different colours, seperated by thin black lines.
And the interpretation (translation) should be completely redone by a group of Gursikhs knowledgeable in GUrmukhi, English, and the transition between one and the other.
My humble suggestion:
15 people from around the world who are very knowledgeable in this stuff, including the original inventors of the software, should meet and re-make the software. Then, all the Gurdwaras in the world should purchase one copy for $15 and all the money should go to Pingalwara and the Bhai Fauja Singh society in Punjab.
:-D
Waheguru ji ka khalsa,
WAheguru ji ki fatheh!
P.S. a copy of this post is going to the software's sevadars at [address removed] ---- I urge you to also contact them.
[%sig%]
Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 30 Sep 2004
sdd,
you must be related to a lot of writers...because they all use small letters ??
i thought everyone knows that relationships are blood/genetics/hereditry...how does use of capitals/small letters/ or letters with some worthy content/letters without any content...make relations of people ?? i must be mssing something??/
ASHKAY JAIYEE.....here are readers and others busy discussing gurbani, sikhi, gurmat, history, asking questions.....your brain is busy trying to see spiderman, batman and jokers ...sdd ?? what does sdd mean ?/ are you related to dss??? ssd/sds ??? ( all of them live in my neighbour's houses down the street and i thought i would make sure )
my grand daughter uses all small letters becasue she is in pre school - are you somehow related to her ?? I HOPE NOT .
dass jarnail singh
PS. NO manjeet Kaur Bhen Ji is NOT related in any way or known to me. BUT her ideas are GOOD.
Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Oct 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Dear sdd/ and :\ above: You seem to be OBSESSED with small and big letters instead of the substance of the message.
Wonder of wonders you BOTH seem to have MISSEd entirely a mail that appeared on Mann singh and the Facts by a CHELA of Mannsu....IT is ALL in Capitals with not a SINGLE small letter. ????
GURBANI is all written in small letters because there are no capitals in Punjabi...in English we have Capitals and non capitals for a reason. As a trained English language teacher for 30 years i have the habit of writing as i do..no matter as i beleive we must pay attention tot he substance ratehr than XXXXX read the BOOK instead of looking at the cover only.
Bhul chuk Maaf
I hope this is POSITIVELY the LAST time any one comments on this MINOR MATTER.
dass Jarnail singh.
Re: Englsih translation of SGGS
Gurpreet Singh · 21 Feb 2005
Sat Sri Akal.
I visited a gurudawara and observed the SikhiToMax translation of Shabads and it was a great experience. I am looking for the translation of Guru Granth Sahib. Looking for a web site or phone # where i can get somne information.
Thanks
Gurpreet Singh
[%sig%]