Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Mehtab Singh · 02 Sep 2004

http://www.keralanext.com/news/?id=46324 India News: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus' 2-September-2004 New Delhi, A Muslim cleric said Thursday that the community shared a close relationship with the Sikhs, but the bond had been clouded by the historical blunders committed by Mughal emperors. Referring to the massacre of Sikh gurus by the Mughal emperors, Imam Maulana Moazzam Ahmed of the Fatehpuri mosque in old Delhi said: "They (emperors) were Muslims only by name but their acts were not in tune with the Islamic philosophy." The fifth Guru Arjan Dev was killed by the men of Mughal emperor Jehangir for supporting a rebellion by his son, while the ninth Guru Tegh Bahadur was beheaded by emperor Aurangzeb for failing to perform a miracle in his court. "But Sikhs and Muslims have always shared a close relationship," Ahmed told an all-faith meeting here to celebrate the fourth centenary celebrations of the Sikh holy book, Guru Granth Sahib. [%sig%]

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Mkhalsa · 02 Sep 2004

lol, what a newsflash!!! (centuries late)

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Mud · 02 Sep 2004

"Guru Tegh Bahadur was beheaded by emperor Aurangzeb for failing to perform a miracle in his court" I thought it was because Guru Tegh Bahadur was defending the Kashmiri Hindus? Anyone want to clarify this? What miracle did Aurangzeb want Guru Tegh Bahadur to preform and why wasn't he able to do so?

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

lakhvir singh · 03 Sep 2004

GuruFatehJi. GuruJi had declined to perform any miracle to redeem himself from sure execution at the hands of the Mughal emperor. The Guru had not 'failed' to perform the miracle - he declined to because he had challenged the Emperor that if the Emperor was successful in convering him to Islam, so would the rest of the country follow suit. The reason why the Guru declined to perform any miracle to save his own life was because it would have been a selfish move and he was there to redeem and protect the Hindu faith, not his own life which he had come to offer so as to soften the stand of the tyrants. GuruFatehJi. L*

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Mnajeet Kaur Gyani · 03 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Guur Teg bahadur sahib Jee was given two choices by Aurengzeb to save His Life. 1. Adopt ISLAM or 2. Perform a MIRACLE to show He was DIVINE. Guur Ji REFUSED BOTH. IN SIKHISM it is Anti-Gurmatt to "perform miracles".....because essentially miracles are nothing but "magic trickery" or Interfering in NATURE/NATTURAL LAWS of Akal Purakh. We who beleive in Akal Purakh as the PERFECT Doer of ALL things can never GO AGAINST an action of Akal Purakh. Example: a miracle would be to raise a dead person to life. Akal purakh has amde this person DEAD. IF we perform a "miracle" and revive him...isnt that saying in effect: Akal Purakh made a MISTAKE...by killing this person and now i am rectifying that by reviving him. Bhagat Namdev was also ordered by the Sultan to show a miracle by REVIVING a dead cow. Bhagt Ji refused..saying He who killed the Cow can Revivce it if there is a need BUT not me. Bhagat ji was then ordered to Adopt ISLAM. he refused this also. Manjeet Kaur

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

bhopinder singh · 03 Sep 2004

guru ji's reply to the emperor was you may cut my head and yet not cut my head it is the miracle dhan dhan sri guru teg bhadur ji

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Jagjit Singh · 03 Sep 2004

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, just a one off statement by ploitically correct cleric. hardly big news, and even less reflective of generally muslim opinion. Most muslims see see any prophets or Gurus as false, apart from there one and only Mohaamed. In slough last week, young muslims en mass distributed leaflets in slough high street slagging off Jesus. Then they wonder why no-one likes them. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 03 Sep 2004

yes but in the end the cow was revived and the king suffered immensely.

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 03 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. It is NOT that sikhs cannot perform miracles. Miracles is interefering in God's Work and called KAHIR. A miracle was performed by Baab Atal rai son of Guru hargobind Ji when he revived a dead playmate. Guur Ji was very angry with him and told him you will have to take the place of the dead boy yourself. baaba ji did just that and laid down his life that very instant. Baba ram Rai ji, eldest son of Guru Har rai Ji performed over 100 miracles in the Court of Aurengzeb...and then even altered a TUK in Gurbani..for which he was Banished by guru Ji forever. Mian Mir also requested Guru arjun sahib jee's permission to CLASH the Towns of Lahore nad DELHI and smash them to dust..GURU JI replied NO. "tera Bhaan Meetha Lageh...." I am satisfied in Wahegur's Bhaana" The Ultimate MIRACLE as shown By Guru Teg bahadur ji is - Taan hundeh NITAANA, Mann hundeh NIMANA...Have the POWER but keep it under control is a miracle. jarnail singh

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

- · 04 Sep 2004

"IN SIKHISM it is Anti-Gurmatt to "perform miracles".....because essentially miracles are nothing but "magic trickery" or Interfering in NATURE/NATTURAL LAWS of Akal Purakh. We who beleive in Akal Purakh as the PERFECT Doer of ALL things can never GO AGAINST an action of Akal Purakh." There is this Sakhi of Guru harKrishan sahib ji enabling an illerate to do "*katha' of the Geeta to a Pandir who Challaanged Guru harkrishan SAhib ji - is this not a miracle to show tha he really was the Guru?

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 04 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The sakhi of Guur harkrishan Ji enabling an illeterate to do katha is GURU JI's KIRPA... This is NOT a MIRACLE. Guru Ji's KIRPA made a Confirmed Murderer, thuggh, and serial robber called Sajjan Thuggh into a SAINT in one instant. Guur Ji's Kirpa made sinners and CANNIBALS like Koda Raksh into SAINTS instantly. Guru Ji's Kirpa is a Supreme GIFT...and it doesnt INTERFERE with NATUREs LAWS....like making a DEAD COW get up and walk.. Just consider: Sajjan thuggh remained a SAINT till the day he died. That is a GURU Ji's KIRPA. IF Guru Ji had performed a MIRACLE....and REVIVED a DEAD COW....that COW will ONE DAY SURELY DIE ??? WONT IT NOT ?? Then what is the MIRACLE ??? Tell me where is LAZARUS.. the DEAD MAN that JESUS revived from the dead. ( in a MIRACLE by JESUS ) IF LAZARUS died once more then what is the use of such a miracle? NATURES LAWS are SUPREME..and WAHEGURU Makes DECISIONS that are FOREVER. IF som eone wants to perform a REAL MIRACLE of revivign a DEAD Thing that NATUE hasd KILLED.. then that thing should LIVE FOREVER . Leave Guru Ji harkrishan ji aside for just a moment...even Ordinary hospital records are full of "miracle cures" such as this...MUTES for many years suddenly begin to SPEAK... and such. BUT NO HOSPITAL in the World has a RECORD of a DEAD CORPSE coming ALIVE and LIVING TILL TODAY ??? That is the "difference" between NATURAL LAWS and... DO You mean to tell me that since GURU TEG BAHADUR Saahib Jee REFUSED to perform a "miracle" HE was NOT a TRUE GURU like Guru harksrishan JI ?? If you think like this you are sadly MISTAKEN. Guur Ji Angad Sahib jee was also "nindiaded" by a Tappa or HOLY MAN that Guru Ji was the reason there was no rain. He told the farmers if you chase GURU JI OUT there will be rain. Bhai Amardass ji a Sikh of Guru Angad Ji was very hurt by this remarks BUT GURU JI said: IF my going away will cause rain and an end to the DROUGHT, I will go and He went off...BUT then it still DID NOT RAIN.... then Bhai Amardass Ji said to the farmers: You didnt do agood deed by letting Guru Ji leave..GO wherever you take this TAPPA there will be RAIN...and it happened that wherever the people dragged Tappa rain would begin to fall...so much so that the people began to FIGHt to DRAG the Tappa to their Fields and he DIED in this Pulling and shoving. IS this a "miracle" ?? No its still GURU Ji's KIRPA through a SIKH's BELIEF in His GURU. FAITH can MOVE MOUNTAINS is not an idle Proverb.. Kirpa and Faith are the same thing. jarnail singh

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

manjeet Kaur gyani · 05 Sep 2004

waheguru Ji ka Khalsa waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Singh##Kingz...funny symbols writes: <<<>> IS THAT a MIRACLE ?? IS that particular cow still alive somewhere?? THAT would be a miracle - if it still dies afterwards..the so called miracle was a magic show. Anyway that particular cow was "temporarily revived" NOT by Bhagat ji but by WAHWGURU to show the King that Bhagat ji was HIS bahgat. and also that particular king is NOT around today either. Just a temporay miracle staged show !!!! GURBANI that turned Sajjan THhuggh into a SAINT is STILL around TODAY...and still has the "miraculous Powwers" to DO what Gurbani did 500 years ago... NOW THAT is what I call a TRUE MIRACLE. GURBANI even after 500 years can turn a evil no gooder to a SAINT Soldier... This is WAHEGURU's True miracle of all time and for all time and for all ages.... Manjeet Kaur

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

manjeet Kaur gyani · 05 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. What types of Miracles are you looking for ?/ Jesus revived the dead, and turned Water into WINE !! and used five fishes to feed multitude... Big deal. Lazarus DIED again, Wine is made from GRAPES and Churches have nothing to feed anybody since... Guur Nanak-Guru Gobind Singh Ji turned a spineless people under the boot of the Slave Masters for 1000 YEARS ( an ENTIRE MILLENIUM ) into KHALSA WARRIORS that TURNED BACK the TIDE of these Invasions and MOVED the Borders of INDIA from LAHORE to KABUL in Afghanistan. After one thousand years of slavery the Indians had an independent Kingdom... The Sikh Gurus started the Guru ka Langgar that FEEDS MULTITUDES all over the World even TODAY...500 YEARS after GURU Nannak Sahib Jee.. 40 Sikhs fight an IMPERIAL army of One Million....UNTIL it is the Invading ARMY leaders thta SWEAR FALSELY on the KORAN to get the Khalsa to vacate the FORT....... out of THOUSANDS of SIKH Prisoners..NOT ONE SAVES his LIFE from a HOrrendous DEATH by becoming a MUSLIM......children as young as FIVE years and seven Years prefer DEATH to CONVERSION THAT is a GENUINE MIRACLE if ever there was one. Manjeet Kaur

Re: 'Mughals blundered by massacring Sikh Gurus'

M. Singh · 06 Sep 2004

The news post shared by Mehtaab Singh ji indicates, something common & fresh emerges, when we sit together.