Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhs In the City

Sikhs In the City

Harbhajan Singh · 02 Sep 2004

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Just watched a program on BBC TV in the UK called 'Sikhs in the City', it was narrated by Kulbinder Singh who is a comedian who is best known in Goodness Gracious Me. On the whole I wanted to congratulate the BBC and Kulbinder for making this program, so to give a insight in Sikhism. There good and bad points in the program. I will just put them down and let sangat or whoever saw the program comment. Please remember I am just typing this 5mins after watchg program so might get things wrong, please forgive me. Good things were the following : Bhai Fauja Singh - marathon Runner. He should be a inspiration to all Sikhs worldwide, especially in western countrys. His trainer remarked that when Bhai Sahib gets tired or in trouble he starts Naam Jaaping. It gave an insight on the charity he runs for which is Bliss, cares for unborn childeren. Bhai sahib says he trys to help the most helpless of us all the unborn babies. It was amazing to see him run and projecting a good side to Sikh people. Policeman - I forgot his name. But he also was a good addition to the program. Doing a honest job and trying to keep your values of Sikhi intact are a hard thing. Bhai Sahib is doing a comendable job and protraying Sikh Men as citizens of the UK who are not afraid to go into the police force. Just a brief note that I see more and more young Sikh policemen, even though I wouldn't consider joining as already got a career but it is good to see a different face to our police force. Bhai Butta Singh - Gatka piece. It was good to show the martial side of Sikhi. I wouldv'e like Bhai Sahib Jee have older students from his class and more shots on the actual skills, more on history wouldv'e been good but more pluses. Twin Artists - Was another good selection, they were teaching students in Edingburgh (scotland) on how to paint in the Indian and Sikh style. World Wars - Small section on the contibution of Sikhs in the 2 world wars. Showed the memorial in Brighton(i think) and the efforts of a Sikh teacher to continue with a anniversary memorial day at the monument. Sikh Comedian - I am definatley going to see this singh when he does his show. He batters all those Politicaly correct type sikhs who says it ok to give up your identity as long as your a good person. I urge people to go and see his show and give him support as he has got his heart in the right place and has a unique way of preaching Sikhi in a funny way and can connect with audiences from all backgrounds. His show is actually called 'Sikhs in the City'. Jeevan Singh Deol - Sikh reasearcher, I can see people say this is a bad point aswell as a good point. He is a reasercher at the British Library on Sikh scriptures. I have heard him on the radio and he has a vast amount of knowledge. OK he is a mona Sikh but even he accepts that one day he might change. The good thing is that he will show more respect to the scriptures than most people. Even though the scriptures which were broadcast were on a Table and he wasn't wearing glove, which i assume you would if your handling century old material. But I think it would be good if some large sikh organisation sponsers him to make sure the Manuscripts are taken care of in the proper way. Bad Points - Sonia Deol - She seems to be just the wrong person to put in a Sikh program. She is basically a British Indian and thats about it. More British than say Indian and Sikhi is probably way down the line near the horizan with this woman. I have heard many shows, and it was good to see her setup. On her 400th anniversary show she had Jeevan on and the chairman on the Birmingham Sikh Council, I don't no his name. But the only good things which were said was from Jeevan on his descriptions on Guru Granth Sahib Jee. The other Singh shouldn't really be on as his english wasn't that good and he would go off on one and talk about something totally irrevalent. Now as I was talking about Political Correct Sikhi as people like to promote it. Sonia is a typical example. She didn't show Sikhi in a good light at all. She didn't say anything postive about Sikhi, other than its taught me to be a good person and see everyone as equals. Duh did some one write that for you!!! She went to see her parents for the weekend which is good and commendable. Her family seem nice and mum is religious. But then she was getting ready to go out for the night with her pals and her phone rings and its got the tune from that slapper propgram 'Sex in the City' she says all the girls should have this ringtone. I just died of shame. But thanks god she wasn't on for too long. I think she was on it because she works for the BBC and her ultra hip britsh asian dudes mustv'e said, Dude Sonia a hip Sikh girl get her on that program!!! No THANKS DUDES!!! Sorry for the long Article!! but there were more positives than negatives, THANKS BBC, Do it again sometime, once every 2 to 5 years is not enough considering the amount of Muslim stuff thats on!!! Bul Chuk Marf Karna for the long post. Harbhajan Singh Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: Sikhs In the City

sikh · 02 Sep 2004

harbhajan singh thanks for the write up i am about to watch the program now but before i even begin i know i am going to be upset by it why i here you ask. well the title a play on words with the american program sex and the city is this the repspect we are accorded for such a momentous occassion in our history? why are we sikhs so blind to let this constantly happen to us. the muslims a few years back had a whole week dedicated to them and their religion and we get 30 minutes with a title formed from another progrm in the hope that it will try and draw a slightly wider audience and iits shown at 1130pm? the bbc should be disgusted with itself

Re: Sikhs In the City

sikh · 02 Sep 2004

ok watched program right... how on earth was deol going to her parents a good thing i'f have prefered her staying in london and the program showing her clubbing. rather than show her mum doing 'paat' in a room which i am not sure she had parkash of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji which had pictures in it of sants and the gurus we then see the mum bowing to the photos what the hell was that about? her mum is dolled up to the nines with lipstick etc. what exactly is she following about sikhi? why do we constantly hear this crap from sikhs about outside identity not being important its whats inside that counts? where were the sikhi bibian with their dastars why are programs like this so scared of rehitvale sikhs? the only person who talked sense in the program was the police officer well done veer ji there was a pointless peice on some indian/sikh painters giving some rubbish talk on identity.......waste of time the sikh reasearcher jeevan singh blantantly describing respect of Guru Ji as a ritual when will we sikhs realise who the real enemies of the panth are. on the whole waste of time and we would be better of without no publicity than have some which is this bad - now bring on the blinded sikhs who thought this was great.

Re: Sikhs In the City

sikh · 02 Sep 2004

and the fifth guru as pointed out in the program was not assasinated!

Re: Sikhs In the City

Rashminder Singh Oz · 03 Sep 2004

Thanx Veer Ji Vaheguru [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs In the City

ns · 03 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh... People are asking where are the bibbann with dastars on the program?, why is this and why is that, why the manmukh's displayed , where is ultimate or the near enough picture we all want to see. One Veer points out above the BBC must be disgusted with itself..I say we all are to blame , not the BBC or anyone. There is 500000 plus strong Sikh community in the UK, mostly economic strong but not sikhe strong and all we can get is the influence of one Sikhe programme every 4- 5 years on TV late at 11:30 P.M. I remember the 300th Anniverary programmes in 1999 were also at ridiculous times. In comparison to us the muslims are doing a fab job, there programmes are aired at the crunch 8:00 pm type of time and are quality. For the question of the real Gursikhs and Bibban with dastars where are they, the only answer is that you'll catch them at a smagam but nowhere else, sorry. This our sorry state of affairs , in the last 50 plus years the community has grown to over 500000 and we haven;t even produced at least 5 excellent speakers who would represent Sikhe on media such as T.V. This is true and I apologize if I have offended anyone and it does hurt, I am also in here to be blamed. Desparate situations require desparate measures, but the only measure we do are is to write on web forums and then forget it , including myself. Sure there are people who are doing panthic things and they rightly should be but it's all in small groups etc, no none group gets along with another, well I Haven't seen one yet, still looking so I can join them....................... Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh...

Re: Sikhs In the City - BEADBI!

Mandeep S · 03 Sep 2004

Jeevan Singh Deol - how dare he! i feel this prog was partly targeted to 'bad' the campaign by sikhs to get proper respect shown to the many banis the library has. I mean the guy was reading a pothi without covering his head, did u see him wash his hands or take his shoes off, or sit on floor, clean rumalay???? total beadbi! and then he goes to call the way in which we look after guroo sahb to be a ritual, that was purley his opinion, just because he does not understand it not does he even like it, does not mean that its ritualistic. i feel this in particular is targeted at the campaign! most of what he said was just him defending his own personal belifes and way of life retrospective of what guroo sahib says, ppl just changing religion to justify their own actions just to hold onto some shred of cultural/religious identity in which they go against on a daily basis. Respect For Guru Granth Sahib sevadaars, hope u take his disrespect up as yet another example of the libraries inability to show proper respect to gurbani, u know the saroops and pothis that were stolen from the sikhs.

Re: Sikhs In the City

anon · 06 Sep 2004

Butta Singh was an absolute joke "gatka means to dismember piece by piece"

Re: Sikhs In the City

Lakhvir Singh · 07 Sep 2004

'ns wrote: . . . For the question of the real Gursikhs and Bibban with dastars where are they, the only answer is that you'll catch them at a smagam but nowhere else, sorry . . .' Now that just broke my heart . . . Is that really true? I see all those videos and pictures and I have been so amazed that hearing that all this is just at smagams took the ground from underneath my feet . . . L*

Re: Sikhs In the City

Lakhvir Singh · 07 Sep 2004

GuruFatehJi. First of all, I offer my humblest gratitude to the sevadaars who put that video online. I downloaded and watched the whole programme. Thank you and may the Guru bless you manifold. At first, I was excited when the video began. It seemed like just the right thing to show to the Kenya sangat here, having watched Fauja Singh and the policeman present the real picture of a Sikh. But then later, my enthusiasm broke down into sighs . . . and soon, any need to show this clip in Kenya, simply faded away. In the first place, Sikhi in Kenya is so weak, and then if this was to be shown to them, the people here would just find further reason to stay away from Sikh values - because of the way some Sikhs in UK define being Sikh. I was completely put off by the image portrayed by the researcher and by Sonia Deol. Just because these people have chosen to become part of the majority does not mean that 'being clean on the inside' is good enough for one to be called a Sikh. I told myself, 'Thanks, but no thanks, my Guru never said anything like that.' Weak-willed people will always chose the easy way and defend it with their own self-advocated reasons. They have hardly listened to the Guru - they have hardly given him a chance to help them become the Guru's Sikhs. It makes one say that one who does not listen to the Guru is no Sikh at all. And that is a fact. How can one, who disregards what the Gurus have instructed for all (and not for just selected ones) the concept of Miri-Piri / Bani-Bana, even lay claim to being a Sikh of the same Gurus? If what they claim that it is the 'inside that matters and not the outside', I would like to know how much of their 'inside' has been made better by at least contemplating on the verses of the scriptures of the very faith they claim is theirs - Sikhism. How can a scholar or researcher, who has Sikh roots and calls himself a Sikh too, not even understand the very basics of respect to Sikh values and principles? What sort of a researcher is he? Of what use is all that knowledge to him that has taught him close to nothing about respect to his very own religion? He treated the Pothi Sahib like just another book, like another specimen that would further his own respect to the world of scholars. How much does that scholar know about the Pothi Sahib that he is studying? As a Sikh, I would expect him to at least be able to read its contents, if not understand them. All he was doing was studying the paper and the design and that's all. That's a role model for Sikhs? It just does not seem right. The BBC has done a good job to at least bring out a handful of Sikhs who portrayed some of the finest examples of Sikhs, but I don't blame them for not being sensitive enough to guage whether what others portray is within Sikh ideals or not. I think they need to be informed - because they represent the Religions on the BBC - that just being born into Sikhism does not make someone a Sikh. A Sikh, I believe, has come into this life to earn his/her Sikhi, and not just lay claim to being Sikh by doing close to nothing what the Gurus instructed their Sikhs to do. A Sikh who believes in the Ardas and contemplates on it will never be satisfied by saying that it is just the inside that matters and not the outside. Those that do say otherwise have verily told the Guru, 'I do not agree with you. You're wrong GuruJi.' I have not come across a single GurSikh who has ever challenged his Guru, and those that have more concern about what they think is right, rather than what the Guru says is right, are not Sikhs. It is simple logic. I think I'd rather not show that video to the Kenya sangat because majority are so ignorant here, so sorry to say that. Last week, we had a youthful jatha come over from Canada for Parchar in Kenya and many Sikhs looked at their Bana like it was something strange. They found it amusing when the Singhs and Singhnia said out Waheguru with so much more pyaar and energy. They found it amusing, too, when the full-Bana Kirtanee kids recited Waheguru Simran with so much power and energy. That's how Sikhi is in Kenya right now. But things are changing . . . a lot of youth here have recently become Amritshak owing to Parchaar going on by visiting Jathas from India and UK. But even then, they need more Parchaar in Sikhi - being Amritdhari does not autimatically make one a GurSikh - he/she still has a lot of Naam-kamaai and Gurmat to acquire from Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The Amridharis in Kenya is growing, but if they are given the spiritual knowledge of the Guru's, they will fall easy prey to corruption and vice. Overall, the video is good reference for me, but not good enough to educate the masses that already know close to nothing about what it is being a Sikh. I think that the inspiring parts is all that makes that video even worth keeping in the archives. The rest have just spoken for themselves, not for their Guru. Bhul chuk maaf karni ji. GuruFatehJi. L*

Re: Sikhs In the City

Lakhvir Singh · 08 Sep 2004

GuruFatehJi. Sorry about a typo-error in my post above, wish there was someway to edit it . . . but I'll correct that line here: '. . . The number of Amridharis in Kenya is growing, but if they are NOT taught the spiritual knowledge and wisdom of the Gurus, they will fall easy prey to corruption and vice . . .' My humblest and deepest apologies for that unintentional error. GuruFatehJi. Dass, L*

Re: Sikhs In the City

EastLondonSingh · 08 Sep 2004

Fauja Singh is a excellent example of a Sikh. However, in the whole poplulation of 500,000 Sikhs in the UK the only person we always seem to be able to put forward as our ambassodor is a 90 year old man. Can't we get some young khalsa?? No offence meant to Fauja Singh Ji, he's still cool!!

Re: Sikhs In the City

ns · 08 Sep 2004

Lakhvir Singh wrote:Now that just broke my heart . . . Is that really true? I see all those videos and pictures and I have been so amazed that hearing that all this is just at smagams took the ground from underneath my feet sorry ,it breaks mine too as it's kinda true, may Guru Ji bring about some khalsa's to the forefront one day...

Re: Sikhs In the City

raaah · 08 Sep 2004

i dnt bleev thats the case. where do u expect the singhneeaa to be?

Re: Sikhs In the City

s · 08 Sep 2004

vjkk vjkf mayb i'm a bit dopey bt where exactly is the online video?

Re: Sikhs In the City

? · 08 Sep 2004

here the url for the video http://www.sikhifm.net/VIDEO/sitc_web_hi.wmv

Re: Sikhs In the City

Singh · 10 Sep 2004

VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh. 'being clean on the inside'!!. did Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj not have a clean heart? was he not clean on the inside? if 'being clean on the inside' was enough why did Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj create Amrit and the Khalsa. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Sikhs In the City

jagroop singh · 10 Sep 2004

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, i think that for many people it is hard to accept/practice and LIVE the totality of Siree Guru Sahib Ji's teachings - to set the goal of becoming the Pooran/Complete Human-being...so we have to try and not be too harsh and instead give love to anyone and everyone who is trying to move forward...this is just a general point. However, i also strongly agree though that when media opportunities arise we must ensure that we do not misrepresent Sikhi and most of all DILUTE it. Sonia Deol, herself a media personality, should have been aware of this and should have consequently made a distinction between her 'practise of particular aspects of Sikhi' and the holistic Sikhi preached by our Siree Guru Sahib Ji. The empahasis upon inner and outer rehit which is central to Sikhi was therefore inadvertently challenged by her input...she projected contradictions. This is an interesting learning-point for all Naujawan to bear in mind when you get media opportunities or are able to advise others as to how they should porject their experiences successfully without damaging the pristine concept of Gursikhi. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!