Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Singh · 31 Aug 2004

We've all heard about the hostage beheadings in Iraq and read about them. I had heard that the videos were also available but never shown on mainstream tv because they were too graphic. I got curious and found out about a site that has them. I decided to watch. I now understand why they aren't shown publicly. I don't think I could stomach watching another. But I did gain some insights. The way the Iraqi butchers throw the captive down onto the ground and then hold him still while slowly slitting his throat and then beheading him is EXACTLY how they perform halal to a goat. The captive may moan or scream and wiggle but the butcher feels no mercy. He keeps going until the head is off. All the while the others chant Allah Hoo Akbar or some other verses. When I saw this, I also wondered whether Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee embraced his shaheedee of beheading like this or in one blow? I don't know. But this is what I believe: those who can slaughter an animal, especially using the halal method but any method in general, can just as easily slaughter a human. The same sounds an animal makes and the same jerks are made by a human and the butcher doesn't care since it's all routine to him. He can continue to slit the throat while reciting praises of Allah at the same time. My uncle was murdered by being stabbed in the neck and I remember that my cousin who used to eat meat immediately stopped afterwards. I asked why and he said that the they had killed his father the same way butchers kill an animal and he couldn't fathom eating the corpse. Meat kills mercy. And mercy is the source of faith. I don't think a meat eater can be a spiritual person. Is God really going to be pleased or even forgive the crime that they have committed on the innocent animal (or the innocent hostage in this case) just becaue they have used his name during the crime? I shudder to think what will become of them in Dargah.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

jagroop singh · 31 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! Veer Ji, Exactly my thoughts also re: carcass-eating. See, Gurmat is so simple, obvious and pristine that when you meet your Sat Guru Sahib Ji, you find that the answers were there all along...within your very heart, wherein dwells righteousness, compassion and mercy. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Singh · 31 Aug 2004

from MSNBC.com >>>>>>>>>>> The video of the alleged killing of Nepali captives showed a masked man in desert camouflage apparently slitting the throat of a blindfolded man lying on the ground. The blindfolded man moans and a shrill wheeze is heard, then the masked man displays the head to the camera before resting it on the decapitated body. >>>>>>>>>> I really don't think anyone should try to watch this on video though. It's honestly not somethign someone should see or something any normal human can tolerate (God knows how the people that do it manage. Are they even human?).

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

sikh · 31 Aug 2004

singh ji what an excellent post and if this post does not make you stop eating meat nothing will, well done.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

* · 31 Aug 2004

it's true. animals in halal are killed teh same way as they killed those hostages. If people could just see how an animal suffers before death, we'd have a lot less meat-eaters.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

TRIGGER · 31 Aug 2004

Don`t plants suffer when they are chopped and cut?? Do the "compassionate" vegetarians ever think about this?

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Mkhalsa · 31 Aug 2004

I totally agree with you Singh 100% But at the same time.. >>>It's honestly not somethign someone should see or something any normal human can tolerate <<<< i am pretty sqeamish but singhs need to be able to kill when necessary, if we cant, how are we to stand up for something when its needed?

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Singh · 31 Aug 2004

Mkhalsa, being able to kill is one thing, but slowly slitting someone or something's throat is pretty close to intolerable. I don't think anyone should be killed like that. Trigger, If you can recall a carrot running away from you in the garden or screaming for mercy, then by all means, don't eat them. It requires no absence of mercy to kill a plant. It does not require someone who is cold-blooded and merciless. Kililng an animal is very simmilar if not the same as killing a human in terms of experience. It screams and cries and begs just like a human. If you can do that to an animal, I'm quite certain you could repeat it with a human.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

g · 01 Sep 2004

Trigger... That had to be the worst arguement I have ever read that was just weak... Have you ever heard of conciousness? or maybe a soul... a plant does not have these things... it does not have a nervous system do you know what that is? it enables us to feel pain... hmmm I Guess maybe you knew none of this? because Im sure if you did you would have relized plants do not feel pain and do not have conciousness so therefore would not care eitherway if they are dead or alive... plus most plants drop their fruit or vegatables... so I dont really know what point you where tryin to make because there isnt one

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Sally · 20 Sep 2004

I am 52, a woman who would never hurt a human being and love animals more than humans. However, I grew up in the Mid-West and my parents owned one of the largest feedlots. I had pets that disappeared and I was never given a proper answer as to their disappearance. I went hunting with my brother but my mission was to scare the animal off and enjoy the site of their beauty. I have watched every beheading. This is perhaps the most foul human act I have ever seen. Since I have seen these, I want to kill those criminals for doing these acts of extreme violence. If I had the chance I would kill them. Why?, I say to myself can I think these thoughts? Because they are demonic and the world has changed because of them. They are the devils employee's. I also can no longer stand the smell of barbeques and the thought of eating meat. I see photos of Asians killing dogs to eat. How sick is that? Humans, especially the males can be horrible creatures and do unspeakable things. I pray for this world to change. I pray for the families of these poor' innocent individuals who are being butchered by these demons.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

comparison · 20 Sep 2004

after seeing these butchers in action, i think what a devastating sight however to comments like "i dont think i could watch something like this again, or this is the worst thing ive seen" i almost find such remarks offensive, after just some of the images and stories from our history, recent and otherwise, after seing and reading this, i find the acts being discussed on this thread as nothing but mild in comparison to the massive level our own ppl/bros/sis's/families have gone through, and i feel those who make comments such as the above have a weak stomatch and need to take a look at what the butchers did to us in comparison. this in no way is to defend or lessen the actions of the mullah butchers described or reduce ur sympathy for these ppl who go through this, my only goal is 2 point out that anything we r talking about here, sikhs have "been there, gone through that" and more already.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

h Singh · 21 Sep 2004

I agree with Singh. Anyone who watches those beheading videos and still can eat meat should be ashamed of themselves. An animal feels just as much pain as a human does. A person would have to be really heartless and shameless to eat meat after that.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

g · 21 Sep 2004

I think the most disgusting part is that these people do these beheadings in the name of god... more and more I believe if there such a thing as the devil... that islam would be its fallowers I just cant understand how people could do such horrific acts and all in the name of God... its the complete opposite they are destroying what god has created and hurting family of these people... just imagine if you had to watch a video of your husband wife brother dad sister being beheaded... this is unexcuseable and if there is a hell every single one of these people are going to it I wouldnt even call them people they are filth... I see no solution to stop these people... if they arent killing diffrent religions diffrent races... they are killing eachother... there will never be peace aslong as there is a islam... I can see why sadaam was so harsh on these people there was no other way... only way he could control them was to kill them off and put fear inside them... how else do you handle this? what do you do when people believe god has sent them here to kill off everyone who is not muslim?

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

:s · 22 Sep 2004

These iraqis are crazy. I dread to think what will happen to them in the afterlife. The sound of arabic now brings to my mind, automatically, thoughts of death and savagery. I can't hear arabic without feeling revolted anymore. They are below animals.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 22 Sep 2004

It's intresting how "Singh" said that one can not be a spiritual person without the virtue of mercy. The first panj pyara was Bhai Daya Singh. In anycase, the beheading is just disgusting. But we all know it's not the first time and it won't be the last. Singhs have been burned alive, boiled alive, cut to pieces, have had garlands made from their children's body parts.... the list goes on. I am not racist and nor do I hate anyone but I can't help but notice that in terms of violence/torture in the name of religion ... none in history can come close to what muslims have done in name of Allah.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

singh · 22 Sep 2004

One thing I learned from these videos: I was watching the hostage (now they dont' even drug them, they're fully aware and conscious for the entire duration). He first sat there and he must have known death was approaching. He swayed a bit during their final declaration before killing him. Then he screamed as they threw him to the ground. I was thinking: imagine if I were in his position. I would be trying to do abhyaas like I'd never done before. But in fact, we are an awful lot like that hostage. Death is above our head all the time, who knows when he'll butcher us? We don't have any guarantee on life. Maybe every second of our life we should be doing abhyaas like we would if we were that hostage. Easier said than done. But at least it made me understand how death is always above us and how a Gursikh should always remember that.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

Lisa · 23 Sep 2004

Please someone,,send me the link/address to the VIDEO of the beheadings...im not a sicko,,i want to find some meaning to the viscious,hateful, act. i want to see if these murderers had any soul in their eyes when they did this (i doubt) i want to see ,,so i will never forget how we humans can kill another human as if they were stomping on an ant. Please send the link? thanks in advance

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

h Singh · 23 Sep 2004

Lisa, I would advise you not to view those videos. I still regret that I saw one of those videos. It’s very brutal and barbaric.

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

stinky · 27 Sep 2004

I just wanted to add something I noticed to this thread. I used to eat meat as a kid, my mother would force me to eat it, saying I won't develop properly if I don't. But I haven't been near meat for 10 years or so. At the time meat was cooked at our house, I never noticed a smell in our house. Just recently I stayed at my uncles house for about a week and I noticed this unbearable smell at their house, can't quite explain what it smells like. Nothing like meat, raw or cooked. Just a very disgusting, nauseating smell. I was under the impression that they did not eat meat, but drank occassionally. I later concluded the nasty smell was coming from their leather sofa's. But each time I visited their house in that week, the smell grew stronger. Finally it became so strong, I did not wish to breathe in that foul air. I was gone out somewhere with my uncle, and I just out of curiousity asked him if they still consumed meat (my question had nothing to do with the smell) and he answered "yes" and that they are trying to quit. I was disgusted and decided not to go to their house anymore. At the same time I realized what that smell was. It is interesting how the smell grew worse and worse until I found out that there was meat being prepared in their house. Here's another interesting fact, they hadn't prepared meat for a few weeks when I was visiting, because out of respect they decided it was wrong to eat maas/drink while they had an amrithdaree staying with them. So this smell is constantly present in such houses. Just yesterday, we had to drop by someone's office which was located in their house. As soon as we stepped in, I smelt that same smell again. My husband also smelt it and he has never eaten meat. So I have concluded that this dirty, filthy smell is a warning sign for khalsa, to avoid such places. [%sig%]

Re: Iraqi Beheadings, Meat & Gurmat

g · 27 Sep 2004

yeh I know what smell you are speaking of... its present in every meat eaters house... I cant stand it... but they dont seem to notice it I allways try to run out of places like that... hate that smell