Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Militarism

Militarism

ns · 25 Aug 2004

Wahegur Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh I'm not a proponent of Nidaar Singh, but an interesting debate none the less. What strikes me is the eloquence of the Muslim speaker (he seems to paper over some searching questions very well), we just don't have the same capability amongst us. have a listen:: Announcenments: Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya Gurdev Nihang Niddar Singh has made exclusives appearance on: 1. BBC Radio 4 Program 'Beyond Belief' Nihang Niddar Singh discusses the Sikh perspective on military traditions. http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/programmes/beyond_belief/index.shtml (select the programme for `26 July - Militarism' from the `Listen to previous programmes' drop-down menu) Beyond Belief - Militarism Radio 4, Monday 26th July, 4.30-5.00pm The New Testament urges Christians to put on the armour of Christ, Sikhs wear a symbolic sword while for Muslims the spiritual life is a jihad. In Beyond Belief this week Ernie Rea and guests discuss the military traditions of their faiths. Are the metaphors used simply colourful language or is such talk dangerous? And how have they informed religion's often violent contribution to history Wahegur Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: Militarism

jagroop singh · 27 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! Veer / Bhain ji, Have just listened to it - absolutely agree. The Muslim speaker had a much more valuable input to make than Niddar Singh. Also, to be absolutely honest, Niddar Singh needs to really think about the way he interacts with the media. In the recent issue of 'Martial Arts Illustrated', he is asked a question regarding the efficacy of swordsmanship/traditional weaponry and armour as opposed to modern machine-based weaponary such as AK47's. Bear in mind that the interview is about the North Indian martial arts tradition i.e. he is expected to talk about ShastarVidiya. He proactively brings 'terrorism in the Punjab' to the subject. Now given the arena in which he is speaking (martial arts), and given that he is not expected to and largely unable to elaborate upon the complexity of any non-martial issues he raises, why on earth did he mention 'the terrorism in Punjab' as an example of the harm that can be done when AK47's / dangerous weapons end up in the wrong hands? So basically, readers of Martial Arts Illustrated will have been left with the strong impression that all of those Mahan Gursikhs who were forced to defend the Panth during the intensely dark and recent years of heightened militancy in the Punjab (as a direct and unavoidable reaction to state-sanctioned and managed wholescale oppression) were all nothing but misguided terrorists within whose hands weapons such as the AK47 were dangerous and abused. Now that is really sad and utterly irresponsible upon his part. It would be nice if he could now make clear exactly what he was trying to get at. If any of his students/shagirds visit this forum, please find out from him if he can explain his perspective to the Sangat. Thanks in advance for any information you can provide. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!

Re: Militarism

S Singh · 27 Aug 2004

I have just listened to the entire show. I have to admit, the Muslim speaker, Salman Saeed was very impressive. Niddar on the other hand was no where near as capable in answering the questions. I think the Sikhs lack educated speakers. Where as the Christian and Muslim speakers on the show were educated, Niddar was in comparison uneducated.

Re: Militarism

Mkhalsa · 27 Aug 2004

>>>It would be nice if he could now make clear exactly what he was trying to get at. If any of his students/shagirds visit this forum, please find out from him if he can explain his perspective to the Sangat.<<<< The answer is right in front of you. One who has a deeply held beleif that gursikhs are misguided terrorists is nothing but a traitor.

Re: Militarism

Moninder Singh · 27 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Gursikhs can never be traitors, but even you should know MKhalsa that after the first couple of years in the wake of june 84, many people that picked up arms were uneducated in what the struggle actually was and how gursikhs are supposed to behave in a time of war. Long gone were the times of Bhai Khanaiya where water was given to the fallen opponents of Sikhism during the course of war. The past two decades has equally produced some very valuable Gursikhs and Paapis for our panth. It was not just government agents that were sent to Punjab in the disguise of a Sikh Saroop to discredit the Khalistan Movement, but also many commoners that had a bone to pick with someone else that caused even more damage. On too many occasions were innocent people killed, bibian kidnapped and forced to marry a so-called kharkoo's relative and innocent people (both Sikh & Hindu) forced to pay hundreads of thousands of rupees for the sake of "the movement." I am in no way defending Niddar Singh, please don't take my comments in that context. I am simply saying that the Khalistan movement was not as pure as it is made out to be on many forums. Not to the fault of any of our beloved GurSikh Shaheeds, but because of government plotting and commoners committing atrocities in the form of Sikh Warriors. Too many "wrong peope" picked up arms during the movement, organization within groups suffered and the movement is at a standstill (not over). I am 100% for the Khalistan that we have drafted on paper, it may not be a reality yet, but time will tell. I have moved way off topic, I am sorry if I have said anything to offend anyone. That was not my intention. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Militarism

Mkhalsa · 27 Aug 2004

>>Gursikhs can never be traitors<<< That was my point exactly. Nice to hear your input though.

Re: Militarism

real anon please stand up · 27 Aug 2004

Just as in anything else there are some people that misuse and abuse things that they should not be involved in. It can be compared to the Bhagat Singh incident during the freedom movement. But there were a lot of genuine singhs that were forced to take up arms in order to face the government's oppression. Hundreds/thousands of innocent youth from the villages were abducted and are now no where to be found - their only crime was that they were sikhs.

Re: Militarism

ns · 30 Aug 2004

Wahegur Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Please let's not debate 84 over this , my post was just to make aware of the speakers we have these days. Niddar Singh has contacts as far as I know with Parmjit SIngh (author of the Warrior Saints book) and they are trying ot promote Sikhi within the media and their version of it, they have loads of media contacts and not soon in the distant future I even here they are going to make some presentation on TV of Sikh Martial arts. I know mostly of all issues that are wrong with Niddar Singh but who else do we have in the UK with such contacts, we need people to really put an effort in otherwise like I have posted here for awareness, that is all which will happen, the real story of Sikhs, the points raised such as by Mohinder Ji, will the correct representation of sikhe ever come out??? or will it just remain on web forums? Wahegur Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: Militarism

khalsa · 30 Aug 2004

wjkk wjkf Lets not insult someone who is doing nothing else but preserving sikh martial heritage pre-singh sabha movement. Mkhalsa, every statement you make has no research thought or evidence behind it. Do us all a favor and stop posting useless information on the net. 1984 is a controversial issue in which you can not judge someone simply because they are anti-khalistan. Research carefully everything that you state about niddar singh. He is now acknowledged all around europe thanks to martial arts illustrated. dont close your mind to things you dont understand. wjkk wjkf

Re: Militarism

Mkhalsa · 30 Aug 2004

khalsa, you just made me laugh! i know what im talking about. but do you? 1984 is controversial? only to the ignorant or the dushts. anyone who learns all the facts will stand with the panth. any sikh who doesnt is disobeying sarbat khalsa. any sikh who makes fun of shaheeds is not a sikh but a DOG. ive done all the research i need to do.

Re: Militarism

jagroop singh · 31 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Have just rejoined this thread... Just to clarify, the question i initially posed was related to the WAY in which Niddar Singh DIRECTLY ALLUDED to 'terrorism' in Punjab. Whether advertantly or inadvertantly he is, in my humble opinion, guilty of causing misinformation and PROACTIVELY bringing a bad name to the Sikh Freedom Movement GENERALLY through his ill-conceived words and more importantly, the IMPLICATIONS of these words. We can accurately assume that he is, as are perhaps others associated with him, of the view that certain key Jathebandis during the fredoom movement were nothing but 'fundamentalists', 'vegetarian fanatics' and 'terrorists'. This is because the websites associated directly with him and his parchaar basically say so - they may have been selectively 'edited' now but hopefully everyone acknowlegdes that at one point, at least one of these websites DID make such opinions blatantly clear i.e. INDIVIDUALS within jathebandis were not referred to but rather BLANKET STATEMENTS were made about WHOLE jathebandis. So, these opinions become direct criticisms of monolithic organisations as opposed to distinct individuals who may have erred from the Dharam Yudh...In my opinion this was completely innappropriate and wholly inaccurate. His statement in Martial Arts Illustrated is just the latest example of his views. Please bear in mind, as i keep having to remind LOTS and LOTS of people, that in no way do i have a personal vendetta against him. i just feel that he and his associates have made, and continue to make, serious mis-statements and clearly antagonistic comments. Nothing more, nothing less... Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!

Re: Militarism

jagroop singh · 31 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Dear Veer/Bhain 'Khalsa' ji, You wrote: 'Lets not insult someone who is DOING NOTHING ELSE but preserving sikh martial heritage pre-singh sabha movement'. > Dear Veer / Bhain ji, i certainly agree with not insulting someone by name-calling and other such-like un-Gurmat behaviour. However, let's get back to the issue - you have just hit upon the crux of the problem - if only he were to stick to 'preserving sikh martial heritage pre-singh sabha movement'! The problem is that Niddar Singh and a relatively small number of his associates have intentionally caused a hoo-hah by doing a 'who's who cussing session' of various Mahan Gursikhs of the 20th Century. Amongst these outbursts, the Jatha has obviously been singled out for special attention. This approach has certainly got them the publicity they seem to have been craving for. However, as the saying goes, 'the more manure you throw at roses, the better they begin to smell'. For your information here's a few of the roses who are/have been directly criticised in an offensive manner; just because they have extremely differing views to these modern Sanaatanist/'Akali Nihung' protagonists: - Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh - Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh - Jinda Shaheed Akali Nihung Baba Nihaal Singh More relevantly, if Niddar Singh and co. truly did nothing else but attempt to preserve pre-Singh Sabha martial heritage then there wouldn't have existed the very real issues i mentioned earlier in this thread - i.e. inappropriate, inopportune and generalised criticisms of the Sikh freedom movement as a whole. Vahiguru alone knows why Niddar Singh and his associates just couldn't stick to propogating Shastarvidya and their Sanaatanist ideology, which i certainly find interesting. It is certainly healthy to discuss alternative schools of thought/interpretations of Sikhi - even if one does not agree with them. However, what has seemingly happened is that these have just been used as a vehicle to push forward anti-Panthic and generally offensive opinions through otherwise thought-provoking and alternative Parchaar. As i said in another thread, a missed-opportunity. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, vahiguru ji ki Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Militarism

Mkhalsa · 31 Aug 2004

>>>Niddar Singh DIRECTLY ALLUDED to 'terrorism' in Punjab. <<< Perhaps khalsa is right. You know, there is a very real problem of terrorism in punjab. It was really bad in the 80s, but now its a terrorism that uses propoganda and other methods, but still terrorism. Who are the terrorists? that is the question. Government sponsored terrorism is and always has been the problem in punjab. From the mughals to the british to the hindus. Its all the same, and u know what? sikhi and gursikhs have ALWAYS come through and WON. Terrorism will be dealt with one day when the innocent rise up and say NO MORE!

Re: Militarism

khalsa · 31 Aug 2004

For your information here's a few of the roses who are/have been directly criticised in an offensive manner; just because they have extremely differing views to these modern Sanaatanist/'Akali Nihung' protagonists: - Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh - Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh - Jinda Shaheed Akali Nihung Baba Nihaal Singh ____________________________________________________________ All that needs to be said is that all they speak is the truth and nothing but the truth whether it is harsh or not. Say what you all must, I have no further analysis to anything.

Re: Militarism

jagroop singh · 01 Sep 2004

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! Dear Veer/Bhain 'Khalsa' ji, i didn't intend to post any further replies so will make this my last. You wrote: "All that needs to be said is that all they speak is the truth and nothing but the truth whether it is harsh or not". Again, you have hit another central crux: the problem is that even if people such as you accept all their 'information' as Truth, even you cannot fail to question why at least one site has been heavily edited in order to dilute much of the harsh criticism we are discussing. So the burning question that transpires can be posed as follows: Is their TRUTH so WEAK that when it meets opposition it becomes watered down? Bear in mind that Siree Guru Sahib Ji teaches us that Truth is Sarbloh...Pure, unalloyed, uncomprimising, strong, rigid, powerful, unrelenting etc. If the website material was changed because they felt they had made mistakes then fine; but make this CLEAR...offer apologies etc. However, the editing process that has taken place seems clandestine and sly as opposed to apologetic and reformist; because they haven't made clear the intentions and motivation behind these changes. What more can be said of people that in the name of Truth write such harsh things about Mahan Gursikhs, only to change their words however in doing so, fail to make clear why they did so? Yet they want to convince everyone, through an admixture of questionable intellectual acrobatics and patently false not to mention offensive statements, that they are the 'real deal, 'the real Khalsa', Siree Guru Sahib Ji's 'fauj' etc. May Siree Guru Sahib Ji protect his young lions and lionesses from falling into such insidious traps of falsehood...May Siree Guru Sahib Ji judge them, and us, accordingly. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!

Re: Militarism

Kh4lsa · 10 Sep 2004

Akaal Purukh ki Fateh. . . . . You guys neds to understand different people have different mantalities, that Musalmaan who debated, that Christain who debated were NOT Military people! If we think about it, the only person who has practicle experience about the subject on that debate was Niddar Singh. For a Singh to talk about WAR and Military, we need to read and understand thoes scriptures written by Guru Gobind Singh which this guy has done. OK so the other communities put forward Niramals for their religion, had they they put forward either Jihadi's OR Cruisaders, which have a valid opinion in this topic maybe thier opinions in this may have been of more value! Regards True Khalsa Wannabe

Re: Militarism

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 11 Sep 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. "akal purakh ki fateh......thats a new one..he he he he. true khlasa wannabe ji....seriously why the need to change WAHEGURU to "akal purakh" ??? did GURU JI make a "mistake" ?? or is WAHEGURU somehow inadequate or inferior to akal purakh ??? Lets leave things the way GURU JI showed us shall we. Bhul Chuk Maaf jarnail singh...

Re: Militarism

Kh4lsa · 17 Mar 2005

Exactly, another fanatic who cannot see that no matter name you use HE is still the same . . ALLAH, RAAM, SHIV, JEHOVA, GOD. They are all attributes, he does not have one name. . . .MORON! WhaheGrur Ji ka Khalsa, ALLAH ki Fateh! Regards my brother!

Re: Militarism

thinki9ng · 17 Mar 2005

allah ki fateh? what you on geez? common dont insult guru gobind singh jis greeting bro. Your intention may be to say god has diff attributes which we agree on but dont change the greeting by Guru Ji thats given from him please. Outside the greeting given you can call god by his attributes.

Re: Militarism

kidhaaa · 17 Mar 2005

yo niddar singh is a really nice man he voices his opinion which he is free 2 do- why dnt you discuss how 2 attain sachkand rather than "well i think niddar singh blah blah blah" cussin down next man, just relax ur kacheras