Can Sikhs go Swimming?
Ian Thorpe · 23 Aug 2004
Is it okay for Sikhs to go swimming?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Ian Thorpe · 23 Aug 2004
Is it okay for Sikhs to go swimming?Jai Singh · 23 Aug 2004
Yes.Admin's Chamcha · 23 Aug 2004
Yes. Topic Closed.kaur · 24 Aug 2004
why wouldn't they be allowed????????? · 24 Aug 2004
but howJarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 24 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Yes of course one can go swimming, diving, scubaiing, sky diving, bungo jumping, surfing.....and whatever God's Nature has for us to Enjoy Nachhna kuddan man ka chao....have fun....nothing anti gurmatt in SPORTS and Recreation Activities like camping, jungle exploring, cave exploration, moun tain climbing etc etc. Every fourth weekend or so my family goes out with the "granthi" that in malaysia is a siropa holder from the so called "fundamentalist" maryadas ( read very very strict !!) and we go swimming whatever in the wild rivers of Ulu yaam ( backlands in malaysia). I am a SGPC maryada proponent and he is AKJ/DDT/Sant/Satowalii gali/bhai mani singh taksaal/etc etc...everything else in between...but our families really enjoy great weekends....together.we dont let this get in the way as we both know deep down we are both on the path to gurmatt with slight differences... Enjoy.. dass jarnail singhobserver · 24 Aug 2004
I think AmritDhari Singh/Singhnis should not go for swimming in local community pools. I know many people who told me that many people urinate in the pool while they are swimming. I have also noticed that these GORAS don't wash them properly and then just go into swiming pools. How can an AmritDhari Singh/Singhnis of Guru Gobind Singh can same dirty water in his mouth, where Amrit has been placed before by Panj. Please give yourself a time and think about it.... · 24 Aug 2004
observer...what a racist remark...that all GORAS dont wash themselves properly... i know people who go into apnay punjabis homes for their business...and they have told me that many punjabis are disgustingly dirty... you seem to have the stereotype that a Sikh must be from Punjab. get that out of your head and you will see that people of other skin colours can be sikh as well.Singh · 24 Aug 2004
I think there is nothing wrong with swimming itself. Swimming in a public pool would make me think twice though in terms of hygiene issues. Kids regularly do really dirty things in public pools and it just seems gross to swim in them. Having your own pool or swimming in fresh water wouldn't bother me at all though.anon · 24 Aug 2004
WJKK WJKF. i would just like to say that a lot of the topics here are always questioning small things that overlook the bigger picture!!!! sikhism doesn't prevent one from being a part of society in any shape or form, eg going swimming or like someone else has said on another thread, shaking hands. its the essence behind the action thats more important- where's the equality in saying gore are dirty?? the thought here is totaly negative!!! sikhi is about being in Chardi kala and having HUMILITY!!!! bhul chuk marf karni. WJKK JKF.kaur · 24 Aug 2004
>>>I think AmritDhari Singh/Singhnis should not go for swimming in local community pools. I know many people who told me that many people urinate in the pool while they are swimming.<<< This is a person hygenic choice - it has nothing to do with Sikhi. It's a personal hygenic choice. Nothing more nothing less. >>I have also noticed that these GORAS don't wash them properly and then just go into swiming pools. How can an AmritDhari Singh/Singhnis of Guru Gobind Singh can same dirty water in his mouth, where Amrit has been placed before by Panj.<<< People don't really put pool/chlorine water into their mouths... And plus the water is cleaned, it's not like they leave the same water there for the whole week, they have filters and stuffAdmin's Chamcha · 24 Aug 2004
As I said, yes we can swim. Topic Closed !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ns · 24 Aug 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Mine is a practical question, I would like to go swimming, and surfing the last time i went was probably when I was about 10 years old, Arshi Jee could explain what do you do with the sri sahib , how do you tie it and also do you where a swiming cap over the keski or what other means do you use to keep the kakkars intact while enjoying these activities. I appreciate the reply in advance.Thanks Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fatehobserver · 24 Aug 2004
>>>>This is a person hygenic choice - it has nothing to do with Sikhi. It's a personal hygenic choice. Nothing more nothing less. When you are a part of Khalsa Panth then there is no personal choice. It is Rehat thing and drinking (or putting in your mouth and allowing in Pavitar Kesh) such kind of water is not allowed. >>>>People don't really put pool/chlorine water into their mouths... And plus the water is cleaned, it's not like they leave the same water there for the whole week, they have filters and stuff It always goes into your mouth when you are swiming, you can not hide this. Secondly, even if it is cleaned after one day, imagine how many people swim in it everyday? How many different types of skin diseases and other non-bathed people swim into it. Khalsa is NAAYARA in rehat and i don't think putting dirty (infected) water into your mouth is healthy in any way. What if someones urinate close to you?TRIGGER · 24 Aug 2004
Whats the fuss man . . . . . . .urine is very theraputic, it has been used by yogis for thousands of years, but modern science has just recently discovered its medicinal properties when taken internally or externally . So of course go swimming, . . . have a few sips to drink, and then do your bit to add to the pools magical properties! . . . . yum yum ! ! NICE !g · 24 Aug 2004
hmm Most Goras I know wash them selfs better than most indians I know... so I Agree public pools are dirty but they are also add alot of clorine to them that kills bacteria and other things so its not unsanitary to swim in a local pool its just if you can stomach the fact that people do urinate in them and dont worry its clean urine :) haha anyways I go surfing in the ocean and thats full of fish urine fish poo fish other things.. dead fish dead other things.. and there no clorine for it.. so does that make it wrong? since Im a Gursikh should I not go in the ocean .. be real manMkhalsa · 24 Aug 2004
observer.. a pool that is cholorinated and constantly filtered (ie the filter is going 24/7) is probably a lot cleaner and less jhoota than a river. what did singhs in the old days bathe in (AND DRINK)? river water. pools are at least as clean as a river in india, but probably a lot cleaner. even public pools.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 24 Aug 2004
waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear ns: Both, that is my granthi friend who keeps very very strict rehat and me with my SGPC Rehat keep all our kakaars all the time. The Sri Sahib is tied tightly to the body with a kamarkassa...and the keski is kept on really tight so it doesnt come off. The idea is NOt to keep the kesh dry ( if wearing a swimming cap is all about )...what is the use of going surfing and then trying to keep dry !! If the joora is tight and intertwined with teh keski it wont open under normal circumstances....mine never has. I open the kesh at home and have a proper bath. we have been having fun for nearly two decades now. so go ahead and enjoy a good outing. Dass Jarnail singhSingh10 · 25 Aug 2004
haha TRIGGER, thats gross with all those kids taking a leak in the pool. Jarnail Singh posted: "Nachhna kuddan man ka chao" - this is an excuse some punjabi people use for bhangra and things of that sort, but the gurbani tuk is only saying that it is a chao or wish of the mind; it is not the hukam of the Guru.Not Very Good Swimmer! · 25 Aug 2004
Earlier this summer myself, my Singhnee (Dastaar vali), daughter (Keski vali) and son (too young to have either!) went on a hliday that was essentially based around an indoor water activity world. We had no probs with kakaars etc. and had a thoroughly good time whilst doing something that is probably the best excercise you can do. We put our shoti kirpaans in our keski ( without the case) and my Singhnee wore a cap over her keski. I wore long shorts over my kachera. My Singhnee wore ful llength lycra cycling/swimming trousers and a similar top (looked like part of the Aussie olympic sqaud!!). Anyway enough about our extensive wardorbe!! In terms of hygiene etc. I have worked (as an engineer) in public pools (amongst other municipal buildings) run by local governments for the last 11 years. I can confirm that the entire volume of the pool water is filtered aprrox. every 3 hours and the water is also constantly dosed with chemical detergent (we usually say chlorine but its a bit more than that) and sampled every 1 hour to check for presence of bugs etc. So simple answer to original question ...Yes. One final parting shot I find remarks like saying goray are dirty etc. more disgusting that anything I have ever seen in a swimming pool!!ns · 25 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh Dear Jarnail Singh Jee, Many Thanks for your cooments I will defiintely try that when I get to Maui Hawaii surfers paradise in the not too distant future. Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fatehsomeone · 25 Aug 2004
well what do people wear when they swim? I don't think it is appropriate for Singhs/Singhnis to wear the available swimming gear. Either it doesn't cover enough skin or it is way too tight to be be modest. Besides the pool doesn't get any fresh water in it. It's the same nasty water being recycled with detergents etc. the rivers are constantly flowing that's what makes them clean i think. Besides i wouldn't drink straight out of a river anyways b/c of hygiene issues unless the river was in the mountains somewhere. If you are in the pool with others then their is a strong chance that you will swallow their urine and other bodily fluids. that's just nasty. If someone took a bath without using soap would u then go and take a bath with the same water and risk swallowing it. that's the problem with stationary water. It doesn't matter how fast they clean the water because the water that touched the body of the swimmer next to you can end up in your mouth before that particular quantity of water is recycled.Canadian Singh · 25 Aug 2004
I think that it is appropriate for men to go swimming but not women.g · 25 Aug 2004
yes you could drink the water that has touched the body of the swimmer next to you... but it wouldnt be harmful in anyway so I dont know what your tryin to prove? all it does is sound rude, and unless im mistaken gursikhs bathe in the sarovar around harmandir sahib... why is that no unsanitary? do they add any chemicals to clean it? I dont know much about it... if I am mistaken please correct me, but if that is the case then what is the deal with that? its just as you said if somone took a bath with no soap then would you go jump in the same bath? isnt that whats done in harmandir sahib? and if thats so then are you sayin sikhs are cleaner than everyone else? forgive me if I am mistaken or have said anything to offend... but if that is what your sayin then I believe it is rude and very ignorantparty pooper · 25 Aug 2004
>>>my Singhnee wore a cap over her keski.<<< hoe sikh sir ttopee dhharai || saath janam kushattee hue marai || He who as a Sikh places a hat on their head; will be reborn seven times as a leper. Thankhaanama Bhai Nand Laal Jeekaur · 26 Aug 2004
>> It always goes into your mouth when you are swiming, you can not hide this. Secondly, even if it is cleaned after one day, imagine how many people swim in it everyday? How many different types of skin diseases and other non-bathed people swim into it. Khalsa is NAAYARA in rehat and i don't think putting dirty (infected) water into your mouth is healthy in any way. What if someones urinate close to you?<< people could also urinate in harmandar sahib's sarovar... waheguru waheguru waheguru waheguru waheguru if any one ever did tha tthey'd get so much paap, but you know... lots of people with skin diseases go there especially, cause they think they'll get healed.. rivers are dirty too but singhs use emJarnail singh arshi gyani · 26 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Kaur Ji, In case you are not aware the water in the Harimandir Sarovar at Amrtisar has been coming in from a RIVER flowing nearby for the past hundred years or so. It is channalled from the river through an underground Hansali. It is still the same river and same hansali but now there is a multi million dollar PURIFICATION PLANT installed to CLEAN the "Amrit"... Why they have a Purification plant to clean "PAVITTAR AMRIT" is ??? an open question.....There are villages and towns on the river banks......and you can make your own conclusions...as to the quality of the water flowing in and why it needs to be purified. The truth of the matter is that it is just water for bathing and cleaning the BODY.... the real AMRIT is INSIDE the Kirtan of GURBANI that goes on inside the Harimandir Sahib jee....anybody try and "clean" or "purify" that is out of his mind. Secondly there is NO paap or Punn Hindu style in GURMATT. Every action and reaction is WAHEGURU inspired and out of our control. Dass jarnail Singh.observer · 26 Aug 2004
Saroovar of Harminder Sahib Jee has magical powers. It has done in past and is still doing it, you can't compare Saroovar water with a lake or river water. "KAAGA HANS KAARAAE" It is constant rain of Gurbani at that place which makes this water different from others.g · 26 Aug 2004
Author: Canadian Singh Date: 08-25-04 19:14 I think that it is appropriate for men to go swimming but not women. -- um Canadian Singh Men and women are equal in sikhi so what you are sayin is 100% against sikhiIt's me · 26 Aug 2004
Kaur: >>people could also urinate in harmandar sahib's sarovar... waheguru waheguru waheguru waheguru waheguru if any one ever did tha tthey'd get so much paap, but you know...<< Hey what's up with that??? Myfriend peed in harmandar sahib's sarovar when he was five, would you call that paap. By the way I don't think a shardaloo sikh would pee in in sarowarJarnail singh arshi gyani · 27 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh; Dear observer Ji, But you forget that the "kaagaan hans kareh" incident was witnessed by the PINGLA BEFORE any Gurbani was sung ( hey even the Harimandsir was not yet Built??) Anyway are any of these BLACK CROWS changed into WHITE SWANS around ??? whre are they to be seen ?? Surely there must be Thousands ??? Did the Other ANIMALS that bathed in this magical waters also turn COLOURS ??? and if YES why doesnt Bani mention them ??? Like DEERS, COWS, TIGERS, FROGS, etc etc that must been in the hundreds around the POOL in those times ??? Is there any special reason ONLY CROWS can CHANGE COLOUR ?? Can a White CROW (albino) change to BLACK ?? WHY CANT any BLACK CROWS be canged to WHITE SWANS TODAY ??? Can we beleive thet this water can CHANGE SPECIES ?? isnt that against NATURE ??? and Gurbani is NEVER against NATURE an IOTA. WHY here ??? can a Black Elephant change into a "Parsaddi hathi" or Snow White Alaskan Bear ??? or a Panda Bear or a kangaroo ??? Why NOT ?? Why specific only to Black CROWS ?? Veer Ji the Gurbani Tukk: Kaagan hans kareh.... REFERS to the MAGIC OF GURBANI..... Guur Ji says that GURBANI can change a Paapi Mann as Black as CROW into a White SWAN...and GURU JI proved this: Read how a Black hearted MURDERER, THIEF, BRIGAND...and much more called SAJJAN THHUGGH changed into a White Hearted SWAN SAINT after hearing the GURBANI sung by GURU NANAK...."OOjal keha chilkana.... shabad... GURU NANAK Ji also changed many many such evil persons by GURBANI.....read the Janam sakhis. NOT even ONE SAKHI states that GURU NANAK changed some such paappi through WASHING HIS BODY in "amrit" or water !!!! Guru Ji is using an ALANKAAR....Black Crow= Black Heart .. White hans= Swan ( saintly Heart)...not real living black crows ??? Those Paapis murderes thiefs brigands who go to HARMANDIR SAROVAR and hope the water will change them into SAINTS are washing" milk in water"....the ONLY thing that will change them into SAINTS is the GURBANI being SUNG inside the Harimandir sahib jee. read Gurbani about the real meaning of AMRIT SAROVAR and Naavan chaleh Teerathin !!!!! hundreds of TUKs in Gurbani CONDEMN such ritualsitic bathing in sarovars teeeraths...Mere washing of the BODY is not going to clean your mann. NO WAY. Dass jarnail singherm... · 28 Aug 2004
a women ... a man... one word EQUALITY!observer · 30 Aug 2004
In Nutshell, there is a BIG difference between Darbar Sahib Sarvor and local swimming pool. One has been purified by Amrit Rass Gurbani and other is just a simple dirty water, where Gursikhs are not supposed to bathe and sip it out.amrit sarovar · 30 Aug 2004
I believe the vision of black crows turning white was meant as a symbolism that the pingla had seen. Even recently there has been news of people benefitting in having some sort of disease cured by bathing with devotion in the amrit sarovar. The body needs to be cleaned with water but the mind inside the body (a form of Harimandir Sahib) needs to be washed with amrit naam. har jeeo a(n)mrith birakh hai jin peeaa thae thripathaanee ||Jarnail singh arshi gyani · 30 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. dear Amrit sarovar Ji, you wrote: Even recently there has been news of people benefitting in having some sort of disease cured by bathing with devotion in the amrit sarovar. ............ a simple google search will list thousands of such "miraculous" cures" by bathing at the shrines of Lourdes...etc etc.etc.... a million and one palces of pilgrimage...and a million and one such "cures"...you must have heard of miracle cures happening to Hindus at KUMBH MELA while bathing in the Ganga !!! hundreds are listed at their Web Sites...and Muslims also have their own Zam Zam Holy water to cure diseases.... BUT ALWAYS...the "DO or DIE" Stamp of approval will be " YOU MUST HAVE FULL FAITH"...if one is cured...well and good....IF not cured.... the saying will be" Pooran shardha nahin honee, ardass pooran sharadha naal nahin keetee... Any Modern Medical Facility will LIST such miraculous cures also....a patient comes in with terminal cancer one day...and next day doctors are amazed to see FULL CURE PLACEBO....is a scientific term used in drug testing...THIS MIRACLE also WORKS and millions of times..... SO ???? GURBANI doesnt place any such "pooran shardha". SHARAT..if you read Gurbani...your mann gets cleaned. FULL STOP. The more you read the cleaner it gets. GURBANI is SOAP of the SOUL.....just as you rub soap on dirty cloth and it gets cleaned ( NO POORAN SHARDHA NECESSARY)...Reading gurbani cleans the Mann ( NO shardha necessary). GURU NANAK has already explained this very clearly in JAPJI SAHIB JEE. dass jarnail singhobserver · 31 Aug 2004
Mr. Arshi, What "Sarab rogh kaa avkhad naam" means? If Gurbani only cleans mind. Full Stop. If a bad word can make one angry and one can go in full temper and which eventually can cause him high-blood pressure and then other health problems, then certainly beautiful words of Gurbani can do magical things and can cure some one. Don't just make blind statements and say Full Stop. Try listening to Gurbani and feel the magicial bliss.Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 31 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Mr. observer, you have a nice name but you dont seem to "really observe" anything. Take the trouble to read my so called "blind statement" once more ( not just observe !!!) I say: READ GURBANI.....and IT CLEANS the MANN. FULL STOP. The words Full Stop means there are NO SHARATS, NO "small print guarantees" etc etc that you have to do this or do that for the benefit of Gurbani. READING GURBANI BENEFITS anyone REGARDLESS.....only thing is the "effort" one puts in. The MORE effort one puts in the More Benefit...JUST like SOAP...the harder you rub the soap the cleaner it cleans....BUT SOAP WILL CLEAN regardless !!! SAME for GURBANI. FULL STOP. Sarab Rog ka Avkhaad naam...means JUST THAT. NAAM is the ULTIMATE CURE... And the MANN is the ULTIMATE CONTROLLER...anything that CURES the MANN cures everything. havent you heard" Mann jeeteh JAGG JEET...IF one has won over the MANN one has won over the WORLD ....Ones MANN is the WORLD....and you are attempting to teach us that the mann is not bigger than the "body/tan/sreer ??? isnt your point above about quoting Sarab rog ka avkhaad naam a POINTER to SREERAK ROG/ sickness of the BODY ?? ( and you blindly mistook that I MISSED the BODY part in the Magic of GURBANI ?? Psychiatrists the World Over KNOW that if the MANN is "SICK" then NO medicine in the world can CURE the "body" under its control...this person may have a perfect six footer muscle built body....BUT he will be in a MENTAL ASYLUM due to a sick MIND... BUT if ones MANN is FITTER than the FITTEST...then even SITTING ON A SIZZLING HOT PLATE IN HEIGHT OF SUMMER......DOES NOT MAKE ONE ANGRY........One says: TERA BHAANAA MEETHA LAGEH.... Here the "body" is burning and cooking with blisters etc.....BUT the Mann is so much at PEACE that the body" rog"/suffering/ etc means NOTHING IF ones MIND/MANN is at PEACE.... NO WORDS can make one angry/raise blood pressure/whatever. Sarab Rog ka avkhaad NAAM is CORRECT - Gurbani cures the MANN and a cured mann is ALL POWERFUL......and in this stage blood pressure/poor health/etc etc are all IMMATERIAL and DONT BOTHER the "SAINTS" / Gurbani LOVERS.... even a TINY BIT. This si the reason why GURU ARJUN could sit on a hot plate and be CALM......while we manmukhs sit in AIRCONDITIONED OFFICES/CARS/HOMES.......and then let one "single so called bad word"by someone UPSET us SO MUCH that our blood presure goes up, we have health problems and go blind in ANGER. FYI i have "experienced" the bliss of reading and IMBIBING Gurbani.....not just "observing".... and making "blind".... statements. FULL STOP. Bhul Chuk Maaf Dassan dassra jarnail singhobserver · 01 Sep 2004
Good you now agree that Gurbani can do more than any thing else ...... Now in the same way Harminder Sarvorar water is also purified by magicial Gurbani.....and it is far far better than a local swimming pool......because of magicial Gurbani VARKHA every second..... ------------------------ "FYI i have "experienced" the bliss of reading and IMBIBING Gurbani.....not just "observing".... and making "blind".... statements. FULL STOP" ----------------------- This tells your UCCHIE AVASTA........... Please refer Guru Sahib Jee as Guru Arjun Dev Sahib Jee. Secondly, you shouldjasvir kaur Thind · 01 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Veer/Bhen Observer Ji, Any Mann (mind) with GURBANI inside it doesnt "need" any other purification.......GURBANI is self cleansing and revitalising ( NO BODY "CLEANS" SOAP !!! or "washes" washing powder before putting it in the washing machine !!!) The SAME cannot be said of the SAROVAR WATER. It is common knowledge that a MULTI MILLION USD PURIFICATION PLANT has been installed to "purify" this water flowing in from a nearby RIVER. WHY SO ??Whatever happened to the already "purified water due to gurbani varkhaa !!) WHY are they "WASHING" the SOAP ??? Any specail reason the Sikh rehat maryada clearly states: SWATTCHH ( CLEAN - PURE ) WATER must be PUT in a sarbloh Bata for Amrit Sanchaar. WHY must the water be already CLEAN and PURE...BEFORE any GURBANI is READ over it ??? can you suggest that water be taken from any river/pond/source...because GURBANI VARKHAA will PURIFY it anyway?? IS our MARYADA WRONG in insisting that the water be PURE before Gurbani is read ?? There is a CD going around in which the Giani ji states ( authority quoted is GURU GOBIND SINGH JI HIMSELF no less !!): Water stirred with a Sri Sahib will always PRODUCE BOYS = bahadur Shah was one such person. Why didnt GURU JI give us this valuable secret ( instead of banning Kuri maars - becasue if GURU JI told his SIKHS this secret..NO BODY would give birth to a GIRL...and thus no one would be a Kurri maar !!!) Here also there is absolutely no mention that any type of water can be stirred wth sri sahib and made PURE ( it is understood that the water must be clean !!) In my most humble opinion imputing such connotations to GURBANI is SLANDER of GURBANI. Gurbani is NOT a MANTER./JANTAR/MAGICAL FORMULA to make "water pure"...GURBANI is read during langgar/deg/preparations not to make such "pure" but to keep GURBANI in our heart and MIND. The instruction is to SWAAS SWAAS JAPNA of GURBANI/NAAM and that INCLUDES our natural functions such as bathing etc...surely you dont suggest that we are also "purifying" our bath water as well..through gurbani varkhaa !!! GURBANI is FOR the MIND and SOUL and AATMA MANNN.....it has absolutley NO EFFECT on things like water, plants, metals, wood, walls, bricks, wells, taps, fountains, etc etc. Consider this... the water from the sarovar has been flowing OUT into the RIVERS nearby for nearly 400 YEARS now....shouldnt the ENTIRE SOUTH INDIAN OCEAN ( in fact why stop at that...go further.. the ENTIRE OCEANS of the WORLD 70% of our water should be AMRIT by now !!! Does AMRIT convert the water or the other way around ??? I leave that for you to answer. I live in Sultanpur....it is here that GURU JI bathed in the river and brought back GURBANI from Sach khand...can I take it that this RIVER is full of AMRIT since GURU JI himself bathed in its waters ??? There are many Gurdwaras giving out gurbani varkhaa here also. I look forward to your answers. Dasree jasvir kaur- · 01 Sep 2004
Someone meantioned Amritdhari Singh/Singhness getting water of Gorae urniating inth e pool - Well why breather - Gorae urinate on streets as well!observer · 01 Sep 2004
Jasvir Kaur.......... Just tell me one thing if Gurbani does not effect water or plants or enviornment, then why Panj Payaras recite Gurbani while preparing Amrit. Why don't they just read it and then make everyone listen to it. Gurbani when recited during Amrit Sinchar in the water- with Khanda does something different, which can only be felt and can't be explained. Hope you understand what i mean....jasvir kaur thind · 01 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. dear Anon ji, Thats precisely the POINT i ma making. AT a Amrit sanchaar ceremony... the PANJ PIYARAE in the Tabiah of GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE perform a SPECIFIC CEREMONY....an initiation ceremony. Before 1699 the GURU JI used to DIP HIS BIG TOE in Water to make it into CHARAN-AMRIT. Again this was just a CEREMONIAL INITIATION RITE. Here NO GURBANI was involved at all. This was a common ceremony used by ALL the holy men/Rishis/ "gurus" of the time..and some used other ceremonies as well. In the sum total a ceremony is a ceremony and nothing more....AFTER that the Follower or SIKH has to actually FOLLOW his GURU's TEACHINGS to the Letter or He is left just an empty shell of a follower only. However NONE of the two reasons apply to the SAROVAR you claim is full of Amrit that is SAME as PANJ PIYARA AMRIT. Have you had Panj Piyara Amrit ? The PANJ SIT in BIR AASAN, HOLD the KHANDA in One Hand, and HOLD the Batta of Amrit in the other Hand, LOOK DEEP into the AMRIT in DEEP CONCENTRATION while RECITING GURBANI. The whole ceremony is held in a PRIVATE enclosed place free of any disturbance. As to your question as to why the panj dont just read and make everyone listen is a question only GURU GOBIND SINGH JI can answer as He started the Ceremony in 1699. Are any of these conditions applied to the SAROVAR and if so HOW ?? Then HOW can BOTh Amrits be the SAME ?? IF you still INSIST the SAROVAR AMRIT is SAME as panj piyara Amrit...then WHY have the PANJ PIYARAS at all - the SAROVARS ( and many many more being built by the Sants at gurdwaras all over in this same mistaken BELIEF ) are Chok FULL of "amrit" and just take our BUCKET FULLS for Amrit sanchaars Misguided people that beleive all this nonsense PLACE water bottles under Guru Granth sahib Jee hoping that water is also "amrit" due to it being near to Guru Ji...This is Manmatt because GURU JI is SHABAD GURU and meant to be Read, understood and Followed...not meant to be used to turn water into "amrit" like iron into magnet by placing near a magnet. Dassree jasvir Kaurns · 02 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh This is the problem with us, we confuse and complicate everything, can't beleive how long this thread hqas gone, I feel a bit embarrased to contribute to it now but here is my 2 cents. Gurbani has some kind of effect on any matter on this earth, whether it's water, soil or anything, this is tried and tested. If you don't believe it then just read bani over a glass of water for a couple of days and keep a normal glass of water for the same number of days ,then taste the water of the two glasses, I can assure the taste will be different. But please don't get confused here and take it as amrit, amrit was prepared by our Guru Sahiban and are part and parcel of dicipline, maryada, don't belittle actions of Guru Ji Gubani clearly mentions " Gur ki karni kahee dhaavo"... Think about the guy who posed the original question, wonder what he is thinking of us boyz and gals. We can go swimming no problem anywhere in the world, but we cannot and I repeat cannot swim around the pools of our Gurdwaras as that water is blessed by Gurbani and is not for our lesiure or exercie usage. I 'll be going swimming soon in the wild surfers paradise Hawaii with my kakkars intact as practically described by Arshi Ji earlier Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke FatehManjeet Kaur Gyani · 02 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Well said Bhen Ji jasvir kaur Jio. Couldnt have said better myself. Gurbani and the Guru Granth sahib Jee is Shabad Guru and is NOT a Manter/janter of the Brahminism type. IF a person just goes to an Amrit sanchaar and Chhaks Amrit...in the Mistaken beleif that thats ALL he has to do now to be "saved" by the Guru and he has no further obligations then he is sadly mistaken. This Amrit is just the BEGINNING of a long and ardous journey that will bring untold JOY and BLISS.....BUT with the sharat that the person FOLLOWS the Teachings of the Shabad guru. MERELY swallowing the "amrit" bestows no special powers or privileges. I read in a book that had a statement by a SANT that once aperson has chhak Amrit, HE will BE SAFE for 10,000 YEARS....the Power of Amrit will ENSURE that he is BORN into a SIKH FAMILY and over teh births of 10,000 years he will keep rehat and be saved forever..... THIS statement CONTRADICTS every single line in GURBANI that says again and again that MANUKHA JANAM is PRICELESS and you get this Chance ONLY ONCE...and here a sant is telling you have 10,000 chances at Human Birth just because you have taken Amrit. ( Someone is sure to come along and say Guru Gobind Singh ji told this SANT all this....BUT I beleive What GURUBANI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE SAYS. ) There is NOT a SINGLE LINE in the Entire Guru granth sahib jee that says that anyone can have 10,000 human Births just because he ahs chhak amrit/charanamrit/whatever. Every shabad says " AI bandey, YOU HAVE ONLY ONE CHANCE at Human Birth....bEWARE and BECOME GOOD because you will NOT get this chance again...and along comes this sant (JI) and contradicts all this Gurbani. Now I hear a CD on japji sahib de Mahanta has been released ( surprisingly NOT a SINGLE LINE of Japji sahib is in this CD on its "mahanta"...bUt the CD does contain " the Powers of Jantar mantar Japji Sahib...." and all this is attributed to GURU GOBIND SINGH JI noless....apparently GURU NANAK SAHIB JEE must have "forgotten" to inform about the mahanta of using Japji sahib as a MANTAR to get SONS, WEALTH, Big HOUSES.....Dhan Dhan sikhi and its SEWADAARS !!! We WOMEN have always been accused of being "totally SANT/DERA orineted by our husbands and sons....lets show them this is the 21st Century...the Centrury of the INTERNET where ALL have access to STEEKS and Meanings of GURBANI. The time of these misguided (a) Gianis is OVER for GOOD. Manjeet KaurManjeet Kaur Gyani · 02 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. dear veer.bhen ji observer jio, I sense a "sacarstic "smell in the "Uchee Awastha" remark about another reader...WHY ?/ because i sensed that since you cannot contribute anything sensible...you decided to take "offense" at the way GURU Ji GURU ARJUN SAHBJEE is referred to by jarnail singh Arshi....and teach him a lesson ???...in "respect" ??? and "bring him down from his uchi awashtha all in one brilliant stroke of your observer pen ??? Well what would YOU say about the following: In our DAILY ARDASS we say: "Gur nanak laiyee dhiyaeh.... ( NO DEV SAHIB JI etc ) Fir Angad Gur te Amardass..( NO GURU, DEV, SAHIB or JEE) Ramdasseh hoi saheaeh.... ( NO GURU, SAHIB OR JEE) Arjun Hargobind nu simro sri har rai ( NO GURU, DEV, SAHIB or JEE) sri har krishan dhiyeah.... teg bahadur simreyeh... NO GURU, DEV, SAHIB, Or JEE )... DO you think the AUTHOR of the ARDASS had ABSOLUTELY NO RESPECT for the GURU SAHIBAANS...as YOU IMPUTE to Arshi Ji. ( because he wrote: Guru Arjun" The Author of the ardass above referred to ALL the GURUS by their First names only !!!! and we also do that DAILY all over the World ??? Where does your "respect" go when you recite the ardass the way it is written??? LOVE and RSPECT are in a person's heart....you had absolutley NO RIGHT to "intrude" into jarnail singhs heart and try to IMPUTE that eh has NO RESPECT or LOVE for Guru Ji. I notice you "observe" a lot and "see" very little. No offense. Manjeet Kaurobserver · 02 Sep 2004
Respected Jasvir Kaur and Manjeet Kaur read my post carefully and tell me where in the post i said that Panj Payara Amrit is equivalent to Sarovar water. Here is my post for your consideration again..... ------------------------ Just tell me one thing if Gurbani does not effect water or plants or enviornment, then why Panj Payaras recite Gurbani while preparing Amrit. Why don't they just read it and then make everyone listen to it. Gurbani when recited during Amrit Sinchar in the water- with Khanda does something different, which can only be felt and can't be explained. ------------------------- Again according to you - Gurbani does not have effect on water or enviornment - then reading Gurbani during Amrit Sinchar in the water shatters your claim. As mentioned by "ns" experiment it yourself you will find the difference. You both seem to be biased in your opnions and support Jarnail Singh without any supporting evidences. My challenging statement never varied and again i state that Harminder Sahib Sarovar water is Mesmerized by Gurbani and is quite different from a common swimming pool. Why doing ISSNAN in Sarvorar you feel blissed, because of effect of Gurbani? Just for your consideration i will tell you few things....and i don't want you to state it as Bharamical events.....if you don't still believe it then experiment it and find it out..... 1. My roses in the garden were dying quite oftenly and i was told that while doing Sukhmani Sahib Path put a container of water near by and then later put the water into the soil where roses are. To my amazement after few days roses started coming back to life. 2. Punjab in terms of Agriculture is #1 in India and it breaks all the records every year. Once i read a statement in a paper in India long time back that the reason of Punjab to be a great fertilized soil is that in villages in Punjab there are Gurudwaras in most of the areas in the fields and the vegitation is mesmerized by Gurbani and hence crop is gets a positive effect. There are tons and tons of stories related to it and if you still do not believe it then i can't do anything. Hope you understand my point.Mkhalsa · 02 Sep 2004
gurbani and naam effect EVERYTHING.. this is another reason for bibek because food is better.. anything that is touched by gurbani for such a long period of time as is the water in amritsar, there must be something special to it.Jarnail Si gh Arshi gyani · 03 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I agree 100% with Observer's points 1 and 2 in the above mail. It is NOT Brahminic "ritual" IF performed all by oneself WITHOUT "buying" this so called amrit from some one else.... What most people do is go to some so called SANT JI and "ASK/BEG" him to GIVE some of HIS "amrit"... The SAME goes for people who put water bottles in and around Guru Ji during Akahand Paaths..... ALL thierr "effort" amounts to is ... 1. Fill up the bottle with tap water at home.... 2. Carry it to the Gurdwara.....3 Place the bottle near guru Ji.....and 4 Take the bottle home. SUCH WATER is NOT AMRIT as the person put in ZERO EFFORT at reading Gurbani/Listening to Gurbani etc...MUCH LESS FOLLOW GURBANI in His LIFE and then Use some of that "amrti" which HE HIMSELF PREPARED. MY family and myself READ GURBANI the whole time our house langgar is prepared...and firmly beleive the whole FOOD is AMRIT and has properties above ordinary food. 2. YES the PUNJAB where SIKHS are the MAJORITY is Blessed by GURBANI. Because there is NO other explanation for the VAST difference between PAKI PUNJAB and INDIAN PUNJAB in Food Production as Paki Punjab is RICHER SOIL, more water, better environmet in terms of bigger landholdings......BUT Paki PUNJAB is way behind the Indian Punjab in Food Production acre for acre. The only explanation for this is Gurbani and our Gurus....because when SIKHS were farming those very lands now in pakistan.....the lands produced vey high yields..but not now. DO not "observe" a "contradiction" in my views...if you look and read carefully you will see I am AGAINST the RITUALISTIC "buying and selling" of "amrit:, Naam, Gurbani, mantars jantars etc etc by vested interests like the Sants deras etc who are ONLY interested in such activities but NOT in encouraging genuine GURBANI reading, Vichaar becasue IF peopel start doing THAT then NOBODY will BUY their act. SO when I "observe" a Person attempting to stage an "akhand Paath" at his house...for reasons like his neighbour just did and he must have his "leg" up...and I know he has NO INTENTION of even listening to one sing;le sentence of Gurbani etc....THEN I WILL TELL this PERSON - YOUR AKHAND PAATH has absolutley NO VALUE WHATSOEVER. Then IF this person turns around and says: jarnail singh arshi TOLD ME "GURBANI has NO VALUE whatsoever".... THAT is What I mean in my mails about "amrit" and "sarovar" etc. To a Person like the above just mentioned, getting a "bath" at Amrtisar is just an opportunity to get his "paaps" washed away..without saying the word Waheguru even ONCE....I SAY to this person and his BATH...the SAROVAR means NOTHING. This is why I say" EDUCATE our people as to WHAT GURBANI REALLY IS...Read it YOURSELF, UNDERSTAND it, USE it, LOVE it, SAVOUR IT..RELISH it...and then watch the BLISS...Paying others to read it for you in akhand paath, paying sgpc to do it by MAIL/internet bookings etc etc paying a SANT to BUY his so called Kamaii wala amrit etc is ZERO VALUE. I hope Observer Ji gets my point by now...and realise where I am coming from. Dassra dass Jarnail singh.observer · 06 Sep 2004
Respected Jarnail Singh Thanks for clearing your views. Now i totally agree with you.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 07 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki afteh. veer Ji "observer".jio, Respect is mutual. Thank you and really no harm done. As i keep stressing..we are all learners - all SIKHS of the same GURU and lighted by the same JYOT of waheguru. It is a difficult task to explain "ILAHI GURBANI" in mails and articles...ONLY GURU JI could do such an excellent job inspite of the "limitations" of the human language, alphabet, paper ink etc, our GURU jI's managed to put down Waheguru's Message from Sach Khand across to us so perfectly. May Guru Ji Bless You with even more illumination. Dassan dassra jarnail singhSIKH OF GURU NANAK DEV SAHIB J · 07 Feb 2005
waheguru jee ka khalsa;waheguru ji ki fateh please make sure you don't take your kachehra off as that would be a kurehit and you would have to appear before the punj pyare no doubt. waheguru ji ka khalsa;waheguru ji ki fatehakj_singh_4eva_and_eva_amen · 07 Feb 2005
vjkk vjkf could some1 please explain how one can wear a kirpan proplerly, ie. on gatra (NOT in keskhi) while swimming, also its not so great to get ur keski drenched jus to have a swim, it dnt matta if your keski and hair get wet but if all the impurities in the water get on ur hair thts nasty and not so great. y bother goin swimmin at all? it doesnt help in ur sikhi at all so forget it, its jus a worldy pleasure, if u want excercise go for a run vjkk vjkf101 · 07 Feb 2005
jujust build a pool in your back garden and go swimming... easy as thatKulwinder Singh · 07 Feb 2005
As their are lot of people asking very silly questions, I though I asked sill question too. When Getting out of car should a Sikh always get out of right door of car, if I get out of the door near to me will I be doing some Korehit ? LOL Please all of you Very Mega Ultra Supper Galaxy Intellectual Cup Winner Wise people, please do me a favour and tell me what to do. Thanks look forward to more time wasters . Kulwinder SinghRedwhiteandblue Kaur · 07 Feb 2005
Sikhs shouldn't go swimming? Dang, I'm glad you told me that before I planned a trip to the Golden Temple. Ah...silly me. Here I was thinking that there was a sarovar there or something. Glad ya told me in advance :-)Gurdaspuria · 07 Feb 2005
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh Sikhism is a practical religion does not limit anybody from participating in any sports. Just be practical and use common sense. I know a number of high schoolers in our area who are on their schools swim team, even some are captains of the their team and are sabat soorat. Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee FatehThakur kaur Taksali · 07 Feb 2005
i go swimming and i am a sikh too. bebegkd · 08 Feb 2005
hilarious such a huge arguement weather u can enjoy life or not when khalistan is made, a navy is gonna be needed, we will have ports...if no sikh knows how 2 swim 2day what will happen 2morow?