levels of khalsa?
GO TEAM CANADA!! · 17 Aug 2004
If Bibek/Sarabloh is mandatory rehit, then what about those who don't keep it? Can they still be considered full-out Khalsa? [%sig%]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
GO TEAM CANADA!! · 17 Aug 2004
If Bibek/Sarabloh is mandatory rehit, then what about those who don't keep it? Can they still be considered full-out Khalsa? [%sig%]GO CANADA GO · 17 Aug 2004
Khalsa Khaas Kahavey Soi Jis Ke Hirdei Bharam Na KoiFriendly Canadian Neighbour · 17 Aug 2004
Well to do degh, langar sewa you need to be a bibeki. To be totally tyar bar tyar you need to have sarbloh and bibek. If one is serious about having a solid spiritual jeeven bibek is a must and the panj pyare tell you that. full-out khalsa are those who try to follow as many of guru sahib's hukams as possible. but don't get me wrong ... if you are an amritdhari you are a daughter/son of guru gobind singh jee. Nothing can change that except if you commit a bajjar kurehit. Have pride in who you are ... you are very lucky and have amazing karams to be amritdhari. but we should always try to improve our spiritual jeeven.aanadh · 17 Aug 2004
yeahhhhhhh i dunno eating only from amritdharis and only in sarbloh cannot be coined the word "bibek" as bibek means "bringing two things into one" or otherwise eliminating duality in your mind and eliminating duality in your mind is more important to do first to be totally tyar bar tyar i don't think you need to eat only from sarbloh and from amritdharis to be tyar bar tyar you should be practicing amrit vela, nitnem, honest earnings, dasvand, lots of simran, and eating habits should be vegetarian and not eating from patits or people kicked out of the panth - that's it bibek is the most misunderstood word out there bibek does not mean eating from sarbloh bibek means not having doubts in your guru.tarunjeet singh · 18 Aug 2004
Vaheguruj i ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe What you must remember is that SArbloh Bibek is not the do all and end all of SIkhi , it's only one small aspect of the rehit of a Gursikh a tool that will help you along the way, there are many many Gurmuikhs that have reached very high states of sprituality without sarbloh bibek, Guru Gobind Singh has given darshan to many without sarbloh bibek. Sarbloh Bibek is a good thign and all Gursikhs shoudl try and keep this rehit, but it is useless if the rest of your sikhi is weak. A Gurmukh once said to me that before you keep sarbloh bibek you need to keep pukka amritvela, and the rest of your rehit should be proper hardcore, if not it is just a show to people. Vaheguruj i ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fatheDogma · 18 Aug 2004
Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee was not sarblohi or bibeki (i think) Was he now full out Khalsa?Mkhalsa · 18 Aug 2004
>>>to be totally tyar bar tyar i don't think you need to eat only from sarbloh and from amritdharis <<< >>>Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee was not sarblohi or bibeki (i think) Was he now full out Khalsa? <<< these kinds of ridiculous arguments only come from those who have no idea what htey are talking about. those who have never wanted to try it and dont wish to learn about it. i made the same arguments at one time. guru sahib changed me. try it, then see if your argument makes any sense.yea · 18 Aug 2004
I dont know if Sant baba harnaam singh was bibeki or sarblohee.. but what i can say is that SANT BABA HARNAAM SINGH JI HAD SUCH a high avasta, he was one with God. He was a brahmgiani.. IF you read se kenehya, u will be amazed with a ton of "WOWWWWWW"'s*anon* · 18 Aug 2004
jal hai soothak thhal hai soothak soothak oupath hoee || There is pollution in the water, and pollution on the land; whatever is born is polluted. janamae soothak mooeae fun soothak soothak paraj bigoee ||1|| There is pollution in birth, and more pollution in death; all beings are ruined by pollution. ||1|| kahu rae pa(n)ddeeaa koun paveethaa || Tell me, O Pandit, O religious scholar: who is clean and pure? aisaa giaan japahu maerae meethaa ||1|| rehaao || Meditate on such spiritual wisdom, O my friend. ||1||Pause|| nainahu soothak bainahu soothak soothak sravanee hoee || There is pollution in the eyes, and pollution in speech; there is pollution in the ears as well. oot(h)ath bait(h)ath soothak laagai soothak parai rasoee ||2|| Standing up and sitting down, one is polluted; one's kitchen is polluted as well. ||2|| faasan kee bidhh sabh kooo jaanai shhoottan kee eik koee || Everyone knows how to be caught, but hardly anyone knows how to escape. kehi kabeer raam ridhai bichaarai soothak thinai n hoee ||3||41|| Says Kabeer, those who meditate on the Lord within their hearts, are not polluted. ||3||41||Harpreet Singh · 18 Aug 2004
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Is a 'sarblohi' sikh better than a 'regular' amritdari sikh? Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh_/\_ · 18 Aug 2004
asking if a sarblohi singh is better than an amritdhari one is like asking is a five-kakaar wearing singh better than an amritdhari one. Ideally an amritdhari singh wears five kakaars and is sarblohi so the question is irrelevant.tarunjeet singh · 19 Aug 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Can anyone provide details of hukumanama that state that sarbloh bibek is a must???? MKKhalsa wrote:- <<>>> Bhaji it's not ridiculous to question wether sarbloh is essential when Gurmukhs have reached very high avastay without it, If we go back to the original post :- If Bibek/Sarabloh is mandatory rehit, then what about those who don't keep it? Can they still be considered full-out Khalsa? can anyone answer the above plese?????? Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathejagroop singh · 19 Aug 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sad Sangat Jio, Perhaps Admin should refer people to threads which have already discussed such topics; that resurface regularly...they could index some previousd threads for this purpose and then refer people on. Admin do this to an extent already. That would allow us to concentrate on furthering our Sikhi as opposed to going over the same ground. Newcomers could digest previous threads and then if need be ask further questions which PROGRESS the discussion...as opposed to repeat what went before. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 19 Aug 2004
good answer " _/\_ " i like the way u think...my sentiments exactly.Kulbir Singh · 19 Aug 2004
We don't have any measuring instrument to measure avastha of any gursikh. How can we say that so and so Sant or Baba was not a Sarblohi but had great avastha? I have heard similar arguments against Kakaars too. One who cannot keep rehit can never have high avastha. He or she may have ridhi sidhi and million other powers but Naam Rass can only come if full rehit is kept. Once I went to a gursikh's house and there I saw pictures of some sant who was a monna (one who cuts hair). I asked the Singh who that person was. The Singh said that this "sant" was a brahmgiyani. I asked him, how he knew that this "sant" was a brahmgiyani when this person was not even a keshadhari and did not keep kakaars. At this the Singh said that ones who get connected to Vaheguru from inside, don't need to keep any outside rehit. I debated with him for some time but when I realised that my attempts to persuade him were going to be futile and I kept quiet. Just because a person can show some ridhi sidhi does not mean that such person is a Brahmgiyani. The biggest nishaani (sign) of a Brahmgiyani is that such person would be egoless. One who does not keep rehit has ego because such person has ego or guts to say no to Guru Sahib's rehit. Only a egoist person would say no to rehit or would not keep rehit. One who submits to Guru Sahib keeps all rehit, without any questions. This does not mean that all those who keep outside rehit have no ego. Ego goes away with Naam Abhyaas and no other way but an egoless person would keep full rehit and not shy away from it. Baba Harnaam Singh was an amazing gursikh but let us not use arguments like "since Baba Harnaam Singh was not a sarblohi, sarbloh is not a rehit". No one is perfect. Sarbloh is an important rehit that every Gursikh must keep. Without sarbloh, Bibek is not possible and without Bibek, Sikhi is not possible. We fully believe in the vitality of Sarbloh Bibek, along with the main karam - Naam Japna. Daas, Kulbir Singhtarunjeet singh · 19 Aug 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Bhaji Kulbir Singh worte :- Without sarbloh, Bibek is not possible and without Bibek, Sikhi is not possible. We fully believe in the vitality of Sarbloh Bibek, along with the main karam - Naam Japna. Bhai Sahib can you please allaborate on teh above sweeping comment. Firstly can you explain:- 1) what your interpretation of Bibek is ? 2) "Without sarbloh, Bibek is not possible and without Bibek" << please explain why ???? 3) If the above is correct would this mean that all mahapursh and gurmukhs that haven' kept sarbloh did not have bibek ? 4) " Without Bibek, Sikhi is not possible" <<Balpreet Singh · 19 Aug 2004
We've discussed this topic of Sarbloh and bibek 101 times already on this board, please take time to do a search and you'll find it debated ad nauseam. As for references to rehitnamas re. sarbloh, please see the article in the Gurmat section. Bibek is a fundamental concept of Sikhi and it extends to eating as well. Not eating food that has been cooked by manmukhs is a practice that has been followed by Sikhs from the start and continue to be practiced. Those who keep this rehit can feel the difference. As someone moves along on the Sikhi path, they themselves will feel the need to keep bibek and will almost automatically begin to do it. Bibek is most easily kept with the help of Sarbloh. I would not go so far as to say someone who doesn't keep sarbloh bibek is not a Sikh, but I will say it is an essential rehit that is a necessary aid to living a Sikhi jeevan.Dogma · 19 Aug 2004
Kulbir Singh Jee, >>>Baba Harnaam Singh was an amazing gursikh but let us not use arguments like "since Baba Harnaam Singh was not a sarblohi, sarbloh is not a rehit". No one is perfect.<<< I personally think that he was a perfect Gursikh. I also think that Bhai Randhir Singh jee was the perfect Gursikh. I also think that Sant Attar Singh Jee was a perfect Gursikh. Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee followed Akal Takhat Rehit Maryada to the fullest. Just because he was not Sarblohi or Bibeki does not mean that he was somehow imperfect. That is what you are implying...although you do not directly come out and say it. There have been sooooooooooo many Gursikhs out there who have achieved muktee and not ALL of them were identical to each other. Everyone was unique. My only point is that there seems to be a lack of tolerance in your view and especially with Mkhalsa's view. I was amazed by Bhai Randheer Singh Jee's jeevan, but I was EQUALLY amazed by Baba Harnaam Singh Jee's jeevan. The main focus of both of these Gursikhs was on Naam Simran....which I believe, is the TRUEST Rehit. Bhai Sahib jeeo, my only wish is that you would be more tolerant of Singhs in the past, present and future who do not follow the EXACT same Rehit as you have. Baba Harnaam Singh Jee did amazing things for this Panth. He encouraged countless people to take khande-kee-pahul, he went to Jail in protest of the Indian Government. Can't you see the similarities between him and Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh Jee? Lastly, to Mkhalsa Jee. You claim that I have never tried being Bibeki/Sarblohi and do not want to learn anything about it. In fact, I have tried it and I have read all the articles relating to it. I am sorry if what I said caused such krodh in you. It was not my intention. maaf karna jee.. To answer the ORIGINAL question posed. My answer is it is not mandatory rehit. Akaal Takhat doesn't recognize it as mandatory, therefore it isn't. For those Singhs who do practice it, give them the fullest respect because it HARD to be a TRUE Bibeki/Sarblohi Singh. ' A "full out Khalsa" is not determined by who cooks his food or by what plate he eats out of. The definition of a "full out Khalsa" is much more deeper than that. Just as Guru Sahib is so great that he cannot be limited by our definitions, in the same way, Guru Jee's Khalsa cannot be limited by our definitions either. bhul chuk maaf. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee FatehFriendly Neighbourhood Singh · 19 Aug 2004
A Gursikh is someone who follows rehit to the fullest they have given up their mat and adopted gurmat. So by that token all gursikhs should keep bibek because it is khalsa rehit. Now, if you have a question as to wether sarbloh bibek is khalsa rehit that is a different issue altogether and i would recommed the article on this site. >>>> Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee followed Akal Takhat Rehit Maryada to the fullest. Just because he was not Sarblohi or Bibeki does not mean that he was somehow imperfect. That is what you are implying...although you do not directly come out and say it. >>>> No one wants to be disrespectful of Singhs. The point of the matter is that without proper bibek one can not be one with waheguru. If you eat from people who are manmukhs then their karmas affect the food. When amrit is made, you must have noted that all the punj pyare physically touch the bata at all times and their eyes never waver from the bata. Is it not logical to think that the opposite of amrit would be created by manmukhs if they were to stir sugary water. >>>>There have been sooooooooooo many Gursikhs out there who have achieved muktee and not ALL of them were identical to each other. Everyone was unique. My only point is that there seems to be a lack of tolerance in your view and especially with Mkhalsa's view. I was amazed by Bhai Randheer Singh Jee's jeevan, but I was EQUALLY amazed by Baba Harnaam Singh Jee's jeevan. The main focus of both of these Gursikhs was on Naam Simran....which I believe, is the TRUEST Rehit. >>>> I agree that naam is the most important rehit but that does not in any way make the other khalsa rehits insignificant. >>>> Bhai Sahib jeeo, my only wish is that you would be more tolerant of Singhs in the past, present and future who do not follow the EXACT same Rehit as you have. >>>> God is one, Khalsa is one and rehit of Khalsa is one. I don't think Kulbir Singh or anyone else for that matter has come across as intolerant. I know I personally don't publicly flog those who don't keep bibek. It all happens with guru's kirpa ... no one is born a sarblohi. However does this mean that we should stop parchar of guru's sahibs rehit? Ofcourse not. Rehit is everything. It what makes us unique and rehit is what hold the panth together. >>>> Baba Harnaam Singh Jee did amazing things for this Panth. He encouraged countless people to take khande-kee-pahul, he went to Jail in protest of the Indian Government. Can't you see the similarities between him and Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh Jee? >>>> No one is saying that he wasn't an amazing person. On the contrary it was mentioned earlier that he was amazing. But, that doesn't mean that because he didn't keep bibek that no one else should... because we are all responsible for our own spiritual jeevens. When we go to dargah...we have to answer for ourselves ... for our own choices. Now it is a different matter if you don't belive in bibek rehit. However that doesn't mean that it isn't a requirement for Sikhs. I know many who take their kirpans off when they shower etc and they also do a lot of paath. Does this mean that i can take my kirpan off too? >>>>To answer the ORIGINAL question posed. My answer is it is not mandatory rehit. Akaal Takhat doesn't recognize it as mandatory, therefore it isn't. For those Singhs who do practice it, give them the fullest respect because it HARD to be a TRUE Bibeki/Sarblohi Singh. ' >>>> According to the above statment you obviously belive that bibek helps on the path of Sikhi. Then how can it be optional? The punj pyare don't compromise on what metal they use to make amrit. To them it's not an option ... then after taking amrit from that bata how can it be an option for us? >>>>A "full out Khalsa" is not determined by who cooks his food or by what plate he eats out of. The definition of a "full out Khalsa" is much more deeper than that. Just as Guru Sahib is so great that he cannot be limited by our definitions, in the same way, Guru Jee's Khalsa cannot be limited by our definitions either. >>>> Guru sahib in bani defines who a gurmukh is. It is one who gives his head to guru. Who follows guru's hukams without question and part of the hukam is to be vigilant in what we eat and who we hang out with. Bhai Kaur Singh ji was a chardi kala Singh. Did you know that he ate meat for along time? Does that mean we can all eat meat too and that being a vegetarian is an option and not a mandatory rehit? Ofcourse not. Bhai Kaur Singh ji simply didn't know and when he did have a dicussion with Bhai Randhir singh ji about it he stopped eating meat because he realized his mistake.sakhi · 19 Aug 2004
There is that sakhi about God eating the bananna peals instead of the bananna when they were being served by a servant, full of love, that had lost all Sudh Budh at the arrival of God. The question to ask is what will God not do for his bhagats. Baba Harnam Singh is a bhagat that had darshan of Guru Gobind Singh Jee and shaheed singhs. This arguement does not have anything to do with kakaars, as anyone that has taken amrit is required to keep their kakaars ang sang. If your guru tells you to drink 4 glasses of water a day, the way to get your Guru's happiness would be to do what they say.jagroop singh · 20 Aug 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Siree Guru Sahib Ji says: 'Ghat ghat ki antar ki janat, Bhale bure ki pir pacchanat'. This Pankti reminds me that it is Vahiguru who is the Inner Knower; for me to comment on other people's Avastha, their level of Guns or Avguns (especially in relation to the level of Rehit they keep), would lead to Ego i.e. away from Vahiguru. May i say though that those supporting Sarbloh Bibek have not so far insulted or belittled anyone. Let's remember that Siree Guru Sahib ji says that Sikhi is finer than a hair and sharper than a sword so of course, when we use thick and blunt words as instrument sof communication and understanding, our intentions will often be misread and even ore often misinterpreted... Perhaps when Gursikhs ask Vahiguru to help them 'bear the unbearable' it relates to issues such as this...to beg that they may undergo experiences and receive the Giyaan thay have been blessed with without using it to lower the esteem of others; whether intentionally or unintentionally. Even when it is such an over-arching and personally-experienced emphatic Truth, that every pore upon the body wants to present it as such... Bhul chuk maaf karna Sangat jio.. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!tarunjeet singh · 20 Aug 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Kulbir Singh can you please answer the questions I asked of yourself as above so that we can gain a clearer understanding of sarbloh Bibek. I have read all previous posts regarding sarbloh bibek and none of them give clear direction as to where Guru ji has stated that Sarbloh Bibek is a rehat and that withotu it you are not a SIkh as Kulbir Singh stated. I did find the following passage in the Gurmat section of this website ( Admin can you please provide reference to which rehitmamma this passage is from and if possiable if the whole rehitnamma can be viewed) "Patr sarb loh kay, bhougtay asan souaad....loh patr mai chhakai," meaning: using utensils of sarbloh, one eats tasty food...one should eat in sarb loh utensils" (Padam, 75) Again I would ask Admin and Kulbir SIngh to clearly answer the above points as if you are correct then I am not a SIKh obviously this is very worrying to me and if need be I would keep Sarbloh rehit. Thank you Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fatheAdmin · 20 Aug 2004
Tarunjeet Singh, As the article itself indicates, the rehitnama being quoted is the Bhai Daya Singh hukumnama. Kulbir Singh had not said anywhere that someone who does not keep sarbloh bibek is NOT a Sikh. He's correct that keeping bibek is a necessary step that one must take to progress in Sikhi. As has been mentioned many times on this forum, sarbloh is a hukum of Guru Sahib and a Sikh should follow every hukam. If he is unable to do so, then he should acknowledge it as his own weakness and not try to criticise the rehit itself. As for where Guru Sahib has said to keep sarbloh: where has Guru Sahib said to give dasvandh? Or to keep 5 kakaars? How about marriage through anand kaaraj or the maryada for amrit sinchaar? None of these things have been written down by Guru Sahib but are passed down generation to generation in the Khalsa. Sarbloh is one of these rehits.tarunjeet singh · 20 Aug 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Admin ji Would it be possiable to view the whole rehitnaamma issued by Bhai Dya SIngh? To all Singhs only by discussing these issues can we learn from them the fac that these issues come up often shopudln't be mocked as some viewers are new and therefore learn form the posts. Admin worte :- <<>>> Your are correct, what he did say was :- <<>>> Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fatheJ Singh · 20 Aug 2004
We all know that jatha endorses sarbloh and full banna with dumalla and I respect that but, to me, these are not mandatory "rehits" to become a singh. Keeping them does't make one singh any "superior" than the other. By all means don't eat from a manmukh but to say that manmukhs karmas will be passed over to you by accepting any food they serve is manmatt and, with all due respect to Friendly Neighbourhood Singh, it sounds exactly like what a brahmin would profess. Look around, we drive cars made by manmukhs, live in houses constructed by manmukhs, eat produce grown by manmukhs, breathe the same air that "they" breathe, use countless amenities provided by these manmukhs, and the list goes on and on and on and on. Why wouldn't those karmas pass over to us? Aren't we enjoying the fruits of their labour? >>No one wants to be disrespectful of Singhs (Baba Harnaam Singh Jee?). The point of the matter is that without proper bibek (you mean sarbloh?) one can not be one with waheguru.>> This is just your opinion singh, not a fact based on sikh rehit. Yes, I have read all the previous posts and articles related to this topic. Admin, giving dasvandh, keeping 5 kakaars and marriage through anand kaaraj are unanimously agreed upon rehits and we can't keep on adding things that aren't. I disagree that sarbloh is a hukam of Guru Sahib and not keeping sarbloh makes one a lessor of a singh. Vaheguruji ka Khalsa, Vaheguruji ki fatehBalpreet Singh · 20 Aug 2004
J Singh, you wrote, "giving dasvandh, keeping 5 kakaars and marriage through anand kaaraj are unanimously agreed upon rehits and we can't keep on adding things that aren't" Did you know that until the 1930s and even later the five kakaars and even marriage through anand kaaraj were not agreed upon rehits? Did you know amrit for women was not an agreed upon rehit? Because these rehits were revived and brought forward again they became "unanimously agreed upon". You are entitled to your beliefs that food made by a manmukh does not have a negative effect on one's jeevan. Gurbani would contradict you, but again, you are free to believe as you wish. I refer you to the bibek article for references about how food can have an effect.J Singh · 23 Aug 2004
Balpreet Singh, I am aware that a number of issues have been debated in the past and some of them have been "unanimously agreed upon" as well, but not sarbloh. It's been encouraged by AKJ along with full banna with dumalla and I respect it, but it's not a mandatory rehit. Do you think keeping sarbloh makes one Singh any "superior" than an other Singh? Just Yes or No Where does Gurbani says that accepting food from manmukhs (not dokhies or paapies) whould pass over their karmas to you. As I said, we enjoy countless amenities provided by manmukhs, this very Internet being one of them. Vaheguruji ka Khalsa, Vaheguruji ki fatehMkhalsa · 23 Aug 2004
wow the stereotypes of singhs and the hatred of rehat on this thread amazes me. if you dont want to follow it, why insult gursikhs by calling them fundamentalists or saying they are egotistical and think they are better than everyone. nobody said bibek and bana are the be all and end all of sikhi. you people are making it sound like that. sarbloh is one tiny rehat out of many many rehats that sikhs should follow, but you all blow it up into some big issue. why dont we argue about the importance of kashera? back when keski requirement was removed a lot of people didnt wear kasheras and didnt want it to be mandatory. guess what, it was made mandatory as I am sure keski will be again one day. all these arguments are hilarious. most of you have no idea what you are talking about. i dont say this to be mean or egotistical but the fact is, study something before you say its brahmanistic or other such things. I know how u feel, ive been there, but look at me now, i am 100% opposite, why? because i bothered to learn, understand and was willing to change. those who are not willing to learn or change cannot be a sikh, sikh means student. >>>I personally think that he was a perfect Gursikh. I also think that Bhai Randhir Singh jee was the perfect Gursikh. I also think that Sant Attar Singh Jee was a perfect Gursikh. Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee followed Akal Takhat Rehit Maryada to the fullest. Just because he was not Sarblohi or Bibeki does not mean that he was somehow imperfect. That is what you are implying...although you do not directly come out and say it. There have been sooooooooooo many Gursikhs out there who have achieved muktee and not ALL of them were identical to each other. Everyone was unique.<<<< doesnt your first statement here contradict the last one? how can they all be perfect yet unique? only guru sahib and akal purakh are perfect. no human, no matter how high their avastha, can be perfect. this is something guru sahib has taught us. if bhai randhir singh and sant attar singh or baba harnaam singh were perfect, how can one beleive in raag mala and the other not? how can one beleive in keski as a kakkar and the other not? using your thinking then one of them is imperfect or fake. this is not true. gursikhs only know what guru sahib wants them to know or how much guru sahib has revealed to them, and thats it. they do not know everything - they know a lot, but not everything. regarding tarunjeet singhs continued comments, read the article in the gurmat section, it answers everything. these same questions keep coming up again and again and again. its very annoying. its such a small part of the daily life of a sikh (the most important being nitnem and simran) that you guys blow it up into something its not. regarding food affecting you. there was a scientific study with water crystals showing that when water is near something unpleasant it changes its structure compared to when it is near pleasant thoughts etc.. this totally falls in line with gurbani. also, havent you ever heard the expression, you are what you eat? theres an article about sarbloh on mkhalsa.com as well which says more.J Singh · 23 Aug 2004
>>if you dont want to follow it, why insult gursikhs by calling them fundamentalists or saying they are egotistical and think they are better than everyone.>> Am I reading the same thread that you are reading Khalsa ji? All we are doing is asking. Sometimes having all "yea sayers" around you creates the atmosphere of " we know it all". As a sikh, I am not interested in teaching but learning. >>most of you have no idea what you are talking about. i dont say this to be mean or egotistical but the fact is, study something before you say its brahmanistic or other such things. I know how u feel>> Not surprised at all, that's exactly what I expected. With all sincereness though singh, I don't think you know at all how I feel. >>there was a scientific study with water crystals showing that when water is near something unpleasant it changes its structure compared to when it is near pleasant thoughts etc..>> What are we talking about here? Can't we just stick to Gurbani and what's being asked. Anyways, my question was to Balpreet Singh. I have read most of your posts and I do really respect your knowledge and inputs to the forum.Balpreet Singh · 23 Aug 2004
All things being equal, does wearing baNa and keeping sarbloh make you a better Sikh? Yes. Simple answer. Keeping more rehit and obeying more hukams does make you a better Sikh. And I don't want to hear the argument "Oh but what if he doesn't do any paath or amrit vela?" because I've qualified my remark with "all things being equal". Of course someone who does nothing except keep these external rehits is not doing the right thing. As for karams being passed on...I never said this was the reason to avoid food cooked by manmukhs. I said it was to be avoided because Guru Sahib has said in baaNee many times to not eat this food. Why? We can hazard guesses, but only Guru Sahib knows for sure.Mkhalsa · 23 Aug 2004
>>>I don't think you know at all how I feel. <<<< Yes I do. I used to post the same thing. I can quote myself from about 3-5 years ago. "Why would you only eat from amritdharis, you guys are brahmans" "you are such egotisitical people think you are better than everyone" "why dont you guys do patt, you dont know anything about sikhi, its all about love" "what does food have to do with anything?" and all sorts of stuff. I even went as far as calling tapobaners (then westoners) taliban. Yes, I was that liberal. Of course this was before I knew anything about them (only heard rumors).. hehe sorry singho. But as soon as I learned a little bit about such great singhs, guess what, I began to learn. I learned about how singhs do incredible amounts of naam and bani and sarbloh helps them to keep their simran stronger. I didnt quite understand so as I grew guru sahib himself stepped in and gave me a compulsion to love sarbloh. something that just came naturally from naam abhyaas. and soon I learned what sarbloh and bibek is REALLY about. and frankly, none of us can explain it, especially not in english. Its really something you just know and feel. if sarbloh wasnt important amrit and degh wouldnt be made in it. guru sahib wouldnt have made langar in sarbloh, he wouldnt have mandated it from amrit sanchars, it would be important in shastars. but the fact of the matter is, there is something important about it. read the article on my site and you will see some of what I think it is. bibek is important for many reasons. how can you even dare call yourself a vegetarian without being a bibeki? I know of many goras that keep stricter bibek than most sikhs. They are strict vegetarians and wont eat a lot of processed foods because they know it has meat, they do research, yet most sikhs say they are vegetarian and cant even bother to read a label. most breads and pasta sauces, soup cans everything has lard or beef fat or something similar by different names like mono and dyglicerides (This stuff is in ice cream, peanut butter, crackers, bread, everything), lecithin, glycerin these are all different names for meat and guess what, its in everything. if you dont keep some bibek you arent a vegetarian and you probably arent even following sgpc maryada of eating only jhatka. thats my two cents.J Singh · 24 Aug 2004
Balpreet Singh, thanks for entertaining my question. I respect your stand of believing that sarblohi singhs with full banna are superior to all other non-sarblohi singhs. I am of a belief that doors of sachkhand are equally open to all singhs who submit themselves to the Guru, sarblohi singhs with full banna and non-sarblohi alike. About "all things being equal", only Vaheguru knows the true the avastha of his sikh. We have our biases. Again, I am not against sarblohi singhs at all. All I was saying was that it's not a mandatory (must have) rehit. Vaheguruji ka Khalsa, Vaheguruji ki fatehMkhalsa · 24 Aug 2004
J Singh jee, if its not mandatory, how is it a rehat? arent all rehats guru sahib gave us somehow mandatory? or does it depend on what level of bhagti we want to do and how easy we want to make it for ourselves. sarbloh bibek (and strict amritvela) make bhagti really really easy. a lotttt easier than it is eating out and doing nitnem sometime before the afternoon. so i mean, guru sahib gave us rehats to make it easy. I mean when you take a university class, the professor says the text books are optional. but what happens if you dont buy the book? what chance of passing do you have compared to someone who bought the book? the same way, you may think rehat is optional, but dont you think it would be easier for your bhagti if you followed more rehat?Singh10 · 25 Aug 2004
I read the topic subject and was wondering are there levels of being pure? Khalsa means pure; you can either be pure or not be pure.????? · 25 Aug 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh In the same Hukumnaama by Bhai Dya Singh it also says that you shoudl allways tie a ucha bunga dummalla and also have five shastar in your dastar. Know does that mean that if we don't follow these rehits we do not have Bibek and thus we are not Gursikhs and will never be one with God ?????????? OR ARE WE BEING SLECTIVE IN WHICH REHITS ALLOW U STO MERGE WITH GOD Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fatehBalpreet Singh · 25 Aug 2004
?????, Would you care to quote the rehitnama where it says the boonga dumalla part?????? · 25 Aug 2004
Woudln't it be clearer if the whole rehitnaama be displayed as tarunjeet singh had requested above........ ......can someone please provide the whole rehtinaama. Balpreet Singh the point is :- OR ARE WE BEING SLECTIVE IN WHICH REHITS ALLOW U STO MERGE WITH GODDogma · 25 Aug 2004
Mkhalsa Jee, I never stated that any of those three Gursikhs were perfect. I said they were perfect GURSIKHS. There is a difference.Duh · 26 Aug 2004
>I never stated that any of those three Gursikhs were perfect. I said they were perfect GURSIKHS. There is a difference.< and what is the difference?Dogma · 26 Aug 2004
" >I never stated that any of those three Gursikhs were perfect. I said they were perfect GURSIKHS. There is a difference.< and what is the difference?" I suppose exactly what Mkhalsa Jeeo said. No human can be perfect. Only Waheguru is perfect. A perfect Gursikh, in my mind, is one who personifies the qualities of Guru Sahib. Compassion, Love, Strength, Courage..just to name a few! ;)Mkhalsa · 26 Aug 2004
>>>you shoudl allways tie a ucha bunga dummalla and also have five shastar in your dastar. Know does that mean that if we don't follow these rehits<<<< I hope that comment isnt directed towards me lol...yea · 26 Aug 2004
yah man Srimaan baba harnaam singh ji was a perfect gursikhhhhhhhhhhhh :) waheguroooooooooooharjinder Singh · 27 Aug 2004
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh I don't keep Sarbloh Bibek but I have the utmost respect for Gursikhs who do, it was a Puratan Revat (habit) of the Khalsa which has mostly diminished. I think you can get Prapti without Sarbloh Bibek, but I don't feel it is correct for Gursikhs to try justify not doing Bibek as they don't do it and just argue against it to feel better themselves. Like I said I don't do it and have my reasons, but a good starting point for Gursikhs would be to read Gurmat Bibek by Bhai Randhir Singh Jee, in this book Bhai Sahib mentions Sarbloh Bibek as one of the final points of Bibek, from this my understanding is it could come later in your avastha, but it is part and parcel of attaining Bibek - unity with God, breaking of duality/dubda. Mentioning other Gursikhs who do not practise Sarbloh Bibek is a fair point but if you delve a little deeper you'll find that roughly 95% of them would have been practising some sort of Food Rehit (i.e. only eating from Amritdharis, or people who don't take intoxicants, or only eating organic food etc, etc.) Trying to justify Sarbloh with Rehatnamas won't wash as there are many Bachans which we don't practise as well even if we are doing Sarbloh Bibek, eg. - Brushing teeth with Datan & many Rehatnama's are questionable in authenticity, the short and simple being either u accept it to be a Rehat which we should all strive for or u don't. I don't think we can judge who is a Khalsa or not that is the Guru's decision and a Khalsa would never admit they were at this avastha. Hopefully I haven't added fuel to the fire as this wasn't my intention, to end ask yourselves these questions: Why is Amrit always prepared in Sarbloh? Why is Degh always preapred in Sarbloh? Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki FatehBibekia · 31 Aug 2004
To Author: tarunjeet singh I find it amazing how you are today asking for facts or proof on sarbloh ie. rehetnameh etc, as to you keeping Sarbloh for two years. On what understanding then did you keep this rehet and what was your experiance from it? What made you turn away from it too?... I feel Sangat can benifit from your view on the whole thing you have praticed and have questioned today. Thanks in advance.tarunjeet singh · 01 Sep 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Dear bhaji/bhenji Bibekia You wrote:- <<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>> Pyaaray veer/bhenji I have not kept sarbloh rehit and I haven't stated anywhere above that I kept it for two years so I think you are confusing me with some else. Thank you Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathehuh? · 02 Sep 2004
Jernail Singh Aryshi ji, are you a bibeki? ....what is your comments? ...please?Bibekia · 02 Sep 2004
Are you not from Birmingham? You have your own site going, now hang out with the Uk Nihungs?tarunjeet singh · 02 Sep 2004
no bibekia veer ji that is a diffferent taranjeet singhJarnail Sin gh Arshi gyani · 02 Sep 2004
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. dear duh veer Ji, I am new to the Bibeki rehat. Just started about two years ago in 2002 at age 55. All along I have been following the SGPC rehat SRM....but over a period of time I found out that this is the bare minimum. If one needs to aspire to higher things....one must rise above the bare minimum and reach higher. My late dad was an ardent fan of Bhai sahib bhai randheer Singh ji ( and thats where I get my "fannish" love affair with bhai sahib jee )..BUT strangely he never became a bibeki...although I know he was much more a GURSIKH than I ever will be due to the massive Gurbani paaths he did and memeorised the entire Guru Granth sahib jee, vaaran bhai gurdass ji, dasam granth banis, kabits bhai gurdass ji, and many more books. maybe that was due to his economic problems being a granthi and all with a large family to support on a small salary...he had no time for sarbloh and all that and had to make do with whatever he got...or maybe not. i dont reallly know but he did spend a lot on books and on our education. As i go along this path of bibek-sarbloh... i find that the deeper i go the more satisfying things seem to become. Slowly i have been convinced that GURU JI indeed had a purpose in stressing on Sarbloh as a major part of our lives. ALL our kitchen utensils were changed to sarb loh and we dont use other types anymore. All the Gurbani i have read seems to point in this direction. My whole family feels more healthier, we are happier and more satisfied and generally the well being of all has improved vastly. Thats all i can comment on for now. i dont wear a dumalla though or carry any extra shastars besides my gatra kirpan. Havent reached that awashtha yet i guess. Dassan dassra jarnail singh.bhinder · 03 Sep 2004
all that is to be said is that true khalsa's of guroo jee followed bibek in puratan times only when necessary. They used to do it in times of battle and war. The TRADITION began during akali guroo hargobind jee's time. Nihangs used to follow this khalsa tradition but no longer is it always necessary. Only when it seems needed. Same with on the account of sarbloh. Thats how is began. The majority of the true khalse today do not follow it. Your choice. Not emphasized anywhere included anywhere in bani.Mkhalsa · 05 Sep 2004
only when its needed? that doesnt make ANY sense whatsoever. arent khalsa supposed to be tyaar bar tyaar? so we should only wear kirpan when needed? like say if we are going into a ghetto, or going to a a war or something where there may be danger, but otherwise, whats the point of wearing kirpan at home? COME ON.. thats hte lamest argument i have heard yet lol.Rashminder Singh Oz · 06 Sep 2004
Nice to know about you Bahi sahib jarnail singh ji actually i am not a sarbh lohi bibeki but with guru kirpa i am Bibeki.... i always had a question in my mind to ask you about ur views on sarbh loh bibek as far i know all people following strict sgpc rehit under estimate sarbh loh bibek but i loved ur point sgpc rehit is common for khalsa panth but is the minimum rehit one should keep. with gur kirpa we should try to focus on life styles of purat rehit vant sikhs vaheguru jiFriendly Neighbourhood Singh · 06 Sep 2004
This is meant for people who belive that sarbloh "is good to keep but optional". how can it be optional for us when it is not even optional for panj pyare. i mean have you ever hear of the panj pyare have a discussion over wether to use a platic or glass bowl? It is not an option for them and we as Sikhs who go to them begging for amrit give our heads and then walk out of the amrit sanchar and suddenly become so wise that we decide that sarbloh rehit is optional. If you admit that Sarbloh bibek helps in the path of Sikhi then how can anyone who is serious about having guru sahib's darshan not consider it mandatory? Is it okay to live your life knowing that you are not living up to your full potential as a Sikh?Kanwaldeep Singh · 06 Sep 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh respected arshi ji you are so right in your point about the sgpc rehat being the bare minimum for a sikh.I am not a srabloh bibek singh as of yet but with Guru ji's kirpa I hope it happens sooner than later.I was wondering if any sarabloh bibeki singhs/singhnees can give me a few tips as how to walk on this path of sarabloh bibek. My kids seem to want to try it a.s.a.p. All input is very much appreciated. daas kanwaldeep singh [%sig%]Kanwaldeep Singh · 09 Sep 2004
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh anyone....?Singh · 09 Sep 2004
here are some threads on sarbloh bibek: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=9715&t=9290#reply_9715 (some really good tips in this one - 4th post) http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=9162&t=9035#reply_9162 (rehitnamas on bibek) http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=7544&t=7368#reply_7544 (more tips - sarbloh bibek practically) http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=4455&t=4220#reply_4455 (purpose of bibek thread) http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=1236&t=1154#reply_1236 http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=825&t=433#reply_82 (is it difficult to keep bibek?... quote from this thread: If you live in Toronto then Tapoban Sahib can help you get sarabloh baattay and other stuff. Visit Tapoban Sahib any Sunday morning and get baattay from there. There is a Chinese store on Spadina Road in Toronto where you can get sarabloh frypans, kaRaahees, kaRchhees and khurchanay at good price. If you are from BC then you can get all sarabloh bartan from khalsa school. ) http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=12833&t=12709#reply_12833 http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=12028&t=11188#reply_12028 http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=11691&t=11572#reply_11691 http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=10779&t=10731#reply_10779 http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=10680&t=9884#reply_10680 that's all i found just by typing in "bibek"... as you can see this has been discussed a gazillion times before :) make sure you read the "really good tips" onesKanwaldeep Singh · 09 Sep 2004
Thank you very much Singh ji. daas Kanwaldeep Singh