BC Sikh Gang Violence
singh · 10 Aug 2004
Guru Gobind Singh, the last of the living gurus, is said to have justified the drawing of kirpans thus: "When all other means have failed, it is righteous to draw the kirpan." But today, far from the Punjabi heartland, and in the heart of British Columbia, upwardly mobile young Indo-Canadians are recklessly packing their guns even as their lives are being snuffed out in the streets of Vancouver by deadly bullets. These young Canadians of Indian origin are doing neither India nor Canada proud. They have become victims of their own brand of violence. According to the Washington Post July 23rd edition, the police are describing the problem as a closed cycle of killing and revenge. "They are Indo-Canadians killing Indo-Canadians," said Kash Heed, commanding officer of the 3rd Police District in Vancouver. "Seventy-six murders ... mainly within one ethnic group. The cycle of violence, we've not cracked it yet." Wallace Oppal, a justice of the Court of Appeal of British Columbia, observes. "For the most part, kids involved here are people who come from middle-class and upper-class homes. They get involved for the glamour." He points out that parental neglect is sometimes a factor. "Parents are devoted to not only buying the first home, but the second home and third home," he said. "They provide their children with the means, but not the guidance." And Indo-Canadian Khushmita Bagri reminds: “We just lost another Indo-Canadian boy yesterday Wednesday July 14. Just when we are starting to forget about the deaths another one dies. How many more need to die before a change is made. This is definitely getting out of hand.†Another Indo-Canadian has this to say: “all this brown on brown crime needs to stop, we need to come together as a strong community and get rid of this violence that is leaving many of our young ones dead before their time. its time to stop the hate!†In the words of a first generation Sikh activist: “Indo Canadians need to think of what they are doing and trying to prove with every hit they make and every gun they blow, in the end it doesn't matter if you were tougher it matters if you were wiser.†What all this boils down to is that it’s mostly Punjabis killing Punjabis. And, more pointedly, it is Sikh Canadians killing other Sikh Canadians. And each time that happens, it is yet another classic case of a young life stopped on the streets by a hail of bullets in what appears to be an interminable drug trade turf war. It means that those who left the plains of the Punjab in the 1960s and 1970s, and made it in British Columbia, are seeing their hopes dashed in a cycle of unending violence that’s gripping their second and third generations. With more and more young lives lost in gang-related and drug-related violence over the recent past, media reports say that Indo-Canadians are on a killing spree. They compare it to the mafia. Since 1994 police have documented more than 76 murders involving Vancouver area ‘s 150,000 strong Indo-Canadian community. These assassinations in night clubs, drive-by shootings and attacks at family gatherings has created a climate of fear, with witnesses unwilling to come forward and families forced to hire security guards for normally joyous events such as weddings. In many cases, they are young men from middle-class families who get involved with drugs and bump up against more serious organized gangs. The killings -- many gangland style -- involve mostly men in their 20s who were raised and educated in Canada. Reports say that the violence originates in the drug trade. But the problem has spun into vendetta killings among young men who don't know any other way to settle scores. Some within the Indo-Canadian community argue that per capita, the proportion of young Indo-Canadian men involved in shootings seems higher than most other demographic groups, at least these days. And, despite the public forums police have set up in an effort to address the issue, the growing death tally has many in the community looking for answers as to why the violence is happening and how it might be stopped. Consider this. Recently, five Indo-Canadian men in their 20s were injured in a hail of bullets when rivals opened fire on them as they stood in the parking lot of Newton's Hook & Ladder Pub. Also police arrested four men in connection with the April killing of Gurjinder Singh Sidhu, 27, a teacher who was gunned down outside his home. In October Surrey resident Rakinder Bhatti, 26, was killed in a drive-by shooting near the Dasmesh Darbar Temple. At about the same time, businessman Narinder Mander, 28, disappeared from a Vancouver street. Robbie Kandola, was another statistic in the on-going cycle of violence in Vancouve’s Indo-Canadian community. The same goes for Davinder Gharu whp went home just after midnight and died in a hail of bullets as he pulled up in front of his family's home. Each became a classic case of a young life stopped suddenly on its tracks by a hail of bullets. The Vancouver Province has linked Davinder's death to the drug trade and gang violence, but his family remains perplexed. The suggestion of drugs and gangs does not fit with the life of the young man they thought they knew so well. Davinder’s parents, who left Punjab in the early 70s, thought they knew their son. He was close to his family. He was also deeply attached to the Sikh religion, although he compromised a bit, occasionally shaving his beard. Six months ago, for the first time since childhood, he cut his hair. His parents told Davinder to visit with friends during the day, not at night. They suggested it might be better if he didn't go to parties and nightclubs. They told him it was no good to be staying out late. It didn’t help. Raj Jheeta, who knew some of the men who have been killed recently, said peer pressure was a significant factor for those drawn to violence. "They wanted to fit in. They wanted respect and fear," said Dr. Jheeta, who is now a naturopathic physician. “Money is not the issue for these guys. It has a lot to do with self-image," he said. GANGS AND DRUGS The words gangs and drugs time and again tumble out of the stories by the media and the police, both of whom are seeking to explain the motives for the killings. Neither, however, has publicly accounted for the undertow of violence and factionalism stirring deeper through the troubled heart of the Indo-Canadian community. It may be shocking, but when you dissect these murders you will eventually find many of the problems in the Sikh community are tributaries flowing out of the temples and the Khalstani cause. It is here that the so-called rival drug or gang factions first came to life. Police point to the two separate 1994 killings of brothers Ron and Jimmy Dosanjh, reputed drug kingpins, as the start of the current cycle of violence. The brothers, both leading members of the International Sikh Youth Federation, made no bones about their devotion to the Khalistani cause for an independent Sikh state in India. Throughout most of the 90 s, the Sikh temples from Fremont, California, to Vancouver, British Columbia, were in conflict between rival community groups seeking to control its cash flow and power base. The mainstream media considered it as a tug-o-war between moderates and fundamentalists, according to their perceived allegiances to the struggle for Khalistan. Gang members were street thugs recruited by these camps to show muscle, and provide intimidation. Reports from within the gurdwara committees suggest that it wasn’t uncommon for renowned toughs to receive the blessings of temple priests and senior community leaders by day and then their blind eye by night as the same young men peddled drugs as petty dealers. One report acknowledges that many of the men who have died or been involved in the street violence come directly from the various families controlling the gurdwaras. ‘Listless, and glutted by the endless financial support of their parents, these young men continue the gun play and violence, only now over issues as trivial as cheating girlfriends, or even caste differences.’ In fact, reports suggest that many of the young men were kids, easily hypnotized by the power and the glory of violence, and believed in its efficacy as tacitly supported by their parents and religious leaders. Thus, what began as a fight within the gurdwaras over control and money has morphed into a cancer slowly taking one young man at a time to his grave. Ironically the community leaders who show up nowadays to lament the violence may be as much to blame as the boys packing their guns, and biting the bullet for a fight they did not start. VOICES NOT HEARD Rattan Mall, editor of the Indo-Canadian Voice newspaper, has been calling for a task force to deal with Indo-Canadian violence since the beginning of 2002. The violence, he says, is coming from young people brought up in both so-called moderate and fundamentalist households. "If we don't take action now, this is going to continue," he warns. "It's got to be real action." The "false glamour" doesn't help either. In the midst of strife within the Indo-Canadian community, says Mall, a young man comes along who doesn't appear to take anything from anybody, and he's got respect, money and "chicks." He becomes a legend to a lot of kids, who think they can do the same things he did and get away with it. Dave Hayer, a Sikh and Liberal MLA, has this to say of the violence in the community: "No one seems to have any answers. We have to work together." He observes that new immigrants are often so focused on working hard to get ahead that they're not spending enough time with the family "to guide them." He observes: "Kids have fallen through the cracks." Parents need to pay more attention to what their children are up to, he says. "If they (sons and daughters) are driving a $50,000-car and they're not working, where's the money coming from?" Balwant Gill is president of the Guru Nanak Sikh Temple, which has some 37,000 voting members. "You tell me, how the temple people can stop it?" Gill says of the violence. "We are willing. We are condemning it. It's very sad." Gill explains that the problem Indo-Canadians face confronts the community at large. Two working parents means less time watching the children, he notes, and little or no time to sit down and talk, to find out how school is going, and who their friends are. He adds that it will be very difficult to change the course of those young men already living the gangster lifestyle. Often, he added, their own parents are scared of them. Renu Bakshi, a CTV reporter in Vancouver who wrote an essay for Maclean's magazine last month entitled "The Roots of Gang Warfare," suggests parents best re-think how they're bringing up their boys. Bakshi notes her essay has spawned "unbelievable" controversy among local Indo-Canadians. All too often, she maintains, Indo-Canadians celebrate the birth of a boy but mourn the birth of a girl. "They're the kings," she says of boys in Punjabi culture. She charges that too many boys are spoiled, and being brought up free of responsibility and with no sense of authority has deadly potential. Bakshi notes that young men are being slaughtered, yet "our community hasn't been able to step up to the plate and do something about it." "It breaks my heart, it really does." She suspects thousands of Indo-Canadian boys in B.C. are allured by the gangster lifestyle. "No other community has had this many murders. That's a fact," she said. Bakshi says a possible solution to the problem lies in education. Too many Indo-Canadians' attitude toward raising boys "has to change yesterday," she says. Millions of dollars are poured into local temples, and hundreds of thousands of those dollars are used to fund court battles between rival factions, Bakshi notes. Some of that money, she says, should be used for parenting education at the temples. "I'm calling for them to give it up," she said of the money. "We need to save the next generation." Another Sikh, who saw the violence in her own family, explains: “We need to stop the secrecy. If you have a child who is doing drugs or selling it, you should be able to go to a place and talk about it with other Punjabi families. No family is perfect and getting involved with others in the community can only help. I am talking from personal experience. My brother died Nov. 20. 1999 - from a heroin overdose. He was addicted for 2 years that we know of. My family took great pains to make sure no one found out and unfortunately, we lost the war on drugs. He died in a public place and of course it was on the news and everybody found out anyway. So what did it matter. We see White and Black celebrities and sports figures coming out about their problems and people consider them heroic for overcoming their addictions. "Our community needs to start thinking the same way. When people came to our house to pay respects, it was unbelievable how many told us of the same thing happening in their families. It is an epidemic but we hide it because Punjabi's have to appear successful in life. We need to join together and get rid of this devil before it consumes us. Even though my brother was an addict and made dealers richer, I don't hold a grudge against the dealers out there as I know their mothers are going thru the same Hell that my mother was and is. When it happens to your family, then you realize how heart-breaking death is and you can relate to the pain of others. "If you know of an addict or dealer, see if you can confide in them. All of our parents have the same dreams and if we are to have drugs in our lives, let's make sure that it's because our children are doctors or pharmacists. Life is so short and precious and you need to hold on to those you love before you lose them forever. If my family had opened up about my brother, perhaps he might have been saved by the advice of another.†Meanwhile in a recent article entitled ‘Web site glorifies gangsters’ and subtitled ‘Users rank Indo-Canadian criminals’ The Vancouver Sun reported that police are concerned about an Internet chatroom that glorifies Indo-Canadian gangsters as community heroes, even ranking them as to their success in the criminal world. Police say some of the information shared on the site about still-unsolved murders should be provided to the police, instead of spread as gossip on the Internet. Like one set of comments titled "Who was the best gangster of all: Peter Gill, Bindy Johal, Ranjit Cheema or Jimsher Dosanjh?" Gill is in jail serving a sentence for obstruction of justice. Johal, an admitted cocaine dealer who was gunned down in December 1998, was a suspect in rival dealer Dosanjh's 1994 murder. Cheema is currently fighting extradition to the U.S. on a drug trafficking charge. Indo-Canadian leaders told British Columbia’s top law enforcers they are frustrated at the slow pace of addressing the violence within the community that has claimed the lives of so many young men in the last decade. Amar Randhawa, 28, a spokesperson for twenty-four community activists and leaders from Vancouver-area temples, said "Generally, I think there's a lot of frustration because I think our community has been unfairly stereotyped and labeled in the mainstream community, it hurts us as community leaders to see our young community members dying and reading in the papers of another casualty." Another Indo-Canadian confessed: “Every time I call my Mom I always here of shootings and what not about the boys in our community. WAKE UP! It's not cool to be a drug dealer. Frankly I think these boys need to be rounded up and locked up for good. Our parents came to this country for us to get educated and have a good life. Not to deal drugs and shoot each other. Other races are laughing at us because we don't think with our heads. Stop being arrogant and hot headed. Stop killing our brothers and sons. I am surprised to see so many educated Sikhs in other parts of the country and yet in Vancouver every other guy is a drug dealer. Perhaps these guys need to know how it is to work two or three jobs in a foreign country and raise a family. Our parents could have stayed in India and maybe that was their mistake. I respect my parents for what they have given me. It's not too late, realize your purpose in life is not to be a Killer. If you kill someone is always out there waiting to kill you and it's not worth it.†Anita Sahota, who recently signed a petition drafted by young activist Poonam Dhillon, calling for a task force to study the issue of violence among Indo-Canadians, says: “Violence affects us all but it is clear that the East Indian community has plunged into despair. Too many youths choose a life of crime because it provides status and of course money. This is not the way our ancestors made a life for themselves when coming to Canada but it is appealing on many levels. Parents need to question where the money and cars are coming from or their child may be the next to join the long list of dead youths…We need to fight this before it spirals out of control.â€