Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 10 Aug 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. Bhai Khaneyiah.... the Founder of the modernRed Cross "concept" 300 hundred years ago in the battlefields of Guru Gobind Singh Ji...is 300 Hundred Years..... No one seems to be interested..... Is it becasue we are too engrossed with other things ?? Neither the Punjab Govt or even the SIKHS themselves have raised this grand centenary in any news or in any gurdwaras... This si too good an opportunity to MISS as SERVICE of HUMANITY Sarbatt da Bhalla is our cornerstone.... The HARYANA GOVT has taken a steal on this issue by celebrating 300 hundred years of Bhai Khaniyah Ji.....by having aspecial Yatra to Bhai Sahib jee 's Villahe Shadahaura in Pakistan to bring a special Gharra of water from this Pind,,,and put up a statue of Bhai Sahib jee in HARYANA as well as establish a Bhai Khaniyah Chair in Haryaya University. Proves my point that we have so many Shaheeds and Grand celebrations to celebrate that we dont need to waste precious time on "barsis" ( which are Anti-Gurmatt anyway) Dass jarnail Singh

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

A Singh · 10 Aug 2004

"Bhai Khaneyiah.... the Founder of the modernRed Cross "concept" 300 hundred years ago in the battlefields of Guru Gobind Singh Ji...is 300 Hundred Years....." Perhaps more accurate to complete this otherwise nicely written post would be "founder of the SEVA PANTHI Sampradaya" with the blessings of Shamsher Pita Guru Gobind Singh.

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

jagroop singh · 10 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Veer A Singh ji, One thing that i found immensely interesting in the 'Sarbloh site', offensive content aside, were the details concerning the different Sampradayas. Being someone who only recently 'got into' Sikhi, this was stuff i'd never encountered before. My main influence has been chardi-kalaa Sadh Sangat which gets together and does amazing keertan...and i've got to converse with some Chardi Kalaa Gursikhs. Therefore, because i have not done much Sangat with those who propound Sanaatanism, i wonder if you could answer the following questions, as you seem to be someone who has some knowledge regarding Sanaatan philosophy/practices: - Apart from oral history, which are the earliest records that refer to or describe as first hand witness accounts the Seva Panthi Sampradaya... indeed, as well as the other 3 Sampradayas, as distinctly compartmentalised? - Is there a 4th Sampradaya i.e. Damdami Taksaal and if so, how long has it been one? - Fundamentally, the Sampradaya concept strikes me as one which seemingly centres around 'specialisation'...Various and distinct groups of 'Sikhs' focusing upon one particular area e.g. martial, seva, scriptural etc. Perhaps you agree. Perhaps i am correct in stating that 'Nirmalas' for instance went so far as to not wear a Kirpan i.e. they did not carry Shasters, One wonders how they would defend themselves if need be with such a focus upon non-violence at ALL costs... Siree Guru Sahib Ji (Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji) has always struck me as wanting Sikhs to become 'complete/puran' i.e. holistic human-beings. For instance the Sant Sipahi concept, in my limited opinion, precludes that a Sikh aims to become all these things...the greatest of Saints...the most powerful of warriors...the most humble of Sevadaars etc. What are your thoughts regarding this? i ask because it seems to me that Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Sat Bachan almost infers that seperate Sampradayas are perhaps not 'the final answer' i.e. the whole is bigger than the sum of its parts. Please do not view this as an attack upon the Sampradaya/Sanaatan school of thought. Thanks in advance Veer ji. ps - i will limit myself to only replying possibly only once more to your potential reply - i do not wish to take attention away from the point of this thread which was specifically to discuss the importance of a great Gurmukh and his jeevan. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

A Singh · 10 Aug 2004

Jagrrop Singh, Thanks for your well-mannered and polite and constructive post, it is truly pleasing to have someone ask direct questions and not go out and out on a anti-this or that attack. Anyhow, I must spell out a few matters, I am not a "Sanatanist" per se, I do however believe in "aad sach, jugad sach, hai bee sach, Nanak ho see bee sach"... As per Sampradayas, I have no problem in accepting their position and legitimacy and first came across them not on the Sarabloh or associated sites but when reading the Encyclopedia of Sikhism by Prof. Harbans Singh. This was followed by a Katha by Baba Hari Singh of the Damdami Taksal (I believe this is now available on the gursikhijeevan site when he discusses mool mantar), so my take on them is not too different from yourself, they are more 'specialist' lifestyles and I can see that traditionally what we today view as "Gyanis", "Keertanias", "Ardasias" etc may have their roots in the Sampradaya, particular the Nirmala and Seva Panthis. I myself have many questions certain claims made by these sampradaya today, perhaps if the Moderators may allow a discussion without it falling into a "Nang" or similar type discussion, we could look at our "ithias" in respect of these sampradayas?

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

jagroop singh · 12 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Veer ji, Thanks for the response. Sounds like a good idea; anyone else wish to share their constructive thoughts... In fact, should a new thread be started? Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. In today's Online Edition of Ajit jalandhar is a headline news item that says: SGPC and Punjab Govt both NOT in the mood to Celebrate Bhai Khaneya Ji's 300th Anniversary... Thus it is left to Private organistions and individuals to celebrate this momentous event...What a Cruel Joke with our History... Does any one need any more proof that the "GOLAK" in punjab has utterly corrupted our leaders and dharam de Thekedars And i have a fleeting suspicion that all this may be due to Bhai Khaneya Ji not being of the so called high class JATT Caste which CONTROLS the SGPC/Akali dal badal/Punjab govt etc If we cant even be bothered to "acknowledge" the Founder of Sewa Panthi ( Modern red Cross)...its no wonder that we have produced ONLY ONE Bhagat Pooran Singh Pingalwara since Bhai khaneya Ji.....and we all know how Bhagat Ji is "honoured" right now and what will happen to him in 300 Years... Guru Gobind Singh Ji HUGGED Bhai Khaneya Ji to His Divine Chest...we hardly care to remember him !!!!.....and we claim to be Guru Ji's Ladlian Faujaan !!! Look at how the christian world celebrates Mother Theresa !!! and compare that to how we treat Bhagat pooran singh pingalwara... Dass jarnail Singh

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

- · 14 Aug 2004

>>And i have a fleeting suspicion that all this may be due to Bhai Khaneya Ji not being of the so called high class JATT Caste which CONTROLS the SGPC/Akali dal badal/Punjab govt etc << ahh singh that's ridiculous no one cares about that guru nanak wasn't a "jatt" - does anyone care? sheesh

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

avidya · 16 Aug 2004

WaheGuruji Ka Khalsa WaheGuruji Ki Fateh The committee assigned to organise and coordinate the celebrations at anandpur sahib include Haryana ministers. Their respect stems from Pandit Nischal Singh ji Sewapanthi's contribution to places like Yamun Nagar. Perhaps those of you who have travelled to Rishikesh by bus will have seen the chowk with statue of Bhai Kanhaiyya ji in Yamun Nagar. A similar one exists in Bhatinda near Sewapanthi HQ at Goniana Mandi.

Re: BHAI KHANEHIYA - 300 YEARS

avidya · 16 Aug 2004

Gyani ji Please read the website, as your statement that there has only been one other sewapanthi since Bhai Kanhaiyya is slightly offensive to the memory of many other Sewapanthi mahapurush. Simply because little of their lives is recorded in post 1920s punjabi and english literture does not mean they didn't exist! That is the aim of the website, to spread awareness. Strictly speaking Bhagat Pooran Singh was not a sewapanthi, although he demonstrated many of their qualities (apart from the scholarly training in Gurbani). However, he was honoured by the Sewapanthis a few years back, along with other non-sewapanthi mahasevaks. Before anyone gets high and mighty, I have the greatest respect for bhagat puran singh's example and am simply pointing out a fact here!

< Missed Opportunity >

jagroop singh · 18 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Dear veer/bhain 'avidya' ji, Thanks for that pointer - a very interesting site. Nonetheless, i sincerely think it is the Gursikh's ultimate purpose to become holistic in the sense that to become Pooran, one must be a Sant Sipahi. That is my limited understanding of Gurmat and i sincerley do not wish to push this onto any one else. Regarding the site specifically. what really struck me was the sakhi about Baba Shaam Singh ji and the young boy - it's amazing and an inspiring lesson regarding thre level of humility that must accompany one with an Uchaa Avastha. What is really sad though is that this site is clearly linked to at least one other particular site which although having personally provided me with some interesting and alternative readings into Sikhi (i.e. Sanaatanism), shot itself in the foot by inappropriately and inaccurately criticising Mahan Singhs and Shaheeds Singhs. The mention of a 'Nihang Teja Singh' as the webmaster is my evidence; this individual has many sins upon his head for even allowing himself to be involved in such propogation..never mind being the originator (which may or may not be the same person). i hope Siree Guru Sahib Ji allows him and the others involved to atone for this in this very life instead of carrying such a heavy debt forward...what a burden that would be. In particular, the way that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh was presented and Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh labelled a 'nang' was absolutely repulsive. i guess the originators wanted to create a 'hoo-hah' and attract lots of attention towards Sanaatan/'Akali Nihung' philosophy...and certainly, these objectives have been achieved. However, irrepairable damage has been done and the positive debates / discussion / learning opportunities that these sites could have promoted and progressed have sadly been lost. Granted, one site has been revamped so that initially offensive material has been removed or edited however, without an apology or at the very least a statement as to the motives behind this editing, it comes across as clandestine and sly as opposed to aplogetic and/or reformist. So, a missed opportunity overall then. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!