Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Matrimonials!!!

Matrimonials!!!

Not Sure · 03 Aug 2004

I am Amritdhari. I have posted on a matrimonial site. I have received some correspandence, some from families on behalf of the girl and some girls directly. Are we allowed to get to know these girls via email that have responded to my adds? Is this acceptable? Pleae advise!!

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Gurdeep Singh · 03 Aug 2004

Of course you can email her or even meet her, sometimes our culture lets us down with these types of issues. It is better to get to know the girl and her views before marrage. Take her out and have a nice meal....

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 03 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. If you keep everything above board...and dont indulge in any hnaky panky under the counter thingy....it is perfectly as per gurmatt to get to know your prospective partner. It is NOT advisable to go into a Life long partnership without knowing the other party.....her Amrtidharee status, her likes and dislikes, hobbies, education, diet preferences etc etc....But trying to "pick up" or go on "dates" etc would be wrong...meet up in the company of relatives or respected elders. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: Matrimonials!!!

question · 03 Aug 2004

i wanted to know about this as well...like can a sikh ask another to get married? or would it be totally wrong? how about talking to the other person if its done in a totally clean way with no bad stuff?

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 03 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. This is the 3rd Millineum.....not the Dark Ages. It would be perfectly ok to ask a person directly...instead of doing through vicholahs and all that stuff. Vicholas have their own axes to grind and sometimes hide things for their own benefit. As long as everything is clean and above board and no one tries to cheat or hide facts...it is as per gurmatt to find your life partner yourself. Gurbani or Gurmatt does not restrict us to use vicholas. But it is definitely wise to consult ones parents, elders because they do "know" a few things we dont. For one thing if you consulted the parents.... then if things go wrong one can depend on them sort of fall back on for support.....if you went out on a limb on your own.....then the Fall will be also on your own....and falling on ones own can be pretty HARD !!! The Matrimonials also "hide" tons...if you read them you will see every girl is tall, fair, beautiful educated, appreciates BOTH cultures, innocently divorced ( if divorced - no one admits the guilt)...and then about the parents...wealthy parents, civil servant parents, own houses, have own business etc etc... You will NEVER see a single advert that says: Girl is short, ugly, uneducated, comes from poor family, ...etc etc. Similar matrimonials also for boys.... this whole thing is a virtual MINEFIELD...One wrong STEP and you are history. So be careful.....or you will rue the day... Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Not Sure · 04 Aug 2004

Can some of the older sangat share there experiences in finding there partner. What did you look for in a person? How did you know they were real gursikhs, not just trying to get married and get out of there house? I figure I would find someone in Canada as I was born here to. I kinda am scared about India, as I never know if they just want to get immigration!! The thing is I kinda do come from a messed up family!! Parents are sick, not all family is amritdhari, we do not own our own house, but I do have a fairly good job. I am just a bit insecure about our own family situation. But the thing is time is passing on and I have this urge to get married now as I doubt our family situation will change as it has always been the same. Did any of you have similar circumstances. It seems that even the gursikh family's these days are very material based!!!

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Some singh · 04 Aug 2004

I think to 'Not sure'.. . Your household is probably alright, sometimes we look down at our own life rather than thinking whats worse. I have seen familiies as well that are so desperate to sell their girls to Canadian suitors, its unbelievable.. When I went last year, a 15 year old girl and her mum tried to do my rishta... It was pretty disgusting telling them I am only 19..

Re: Matrimonials!!!

hmm? · 04 Aug 2004

so is everyone in agreement then, that it's not against sikhi to ask someone to marry you? maybe Kulbir Singh could comment?

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Kulbir Singh · 04 Aug 2004

One should follow proper protocol when getting married. To say that it is fine to talk to someone (without conditions) before marriage is not correct. As much as possible one should avoid unnecassary talking with the opposite sex. As much as possible one should involve one's parents in talks for marriage. If for some reason parents cannot get involved then elderly gursikhs should get involved. If both parents or elderly gursikhs are unable to get involved for some reason, then it is okay to approach the potential spouse with proposal. But otherwise, to do love marriage as they do in Western countries is not according to Gurmat. The notion of getting to know your spouse before marriage by talking to her/him or dating etc. is not according to Gurmat. Such manmatt should be avoided at all costs. ----------- I am Amritdhari. I have posted on a matrimonial site. I have received some correspandence, some from families on behalf of the girl and some girls directly. Are we allowed to get to know these girls via email that have responded to my adds? Is this acceptable? Pleae advise!! ---------- In this case, why not let your parents or someone else do all the correspondence? To start talking on email or chatting with girls under the pretension of "getting to know" them is not right. Do not get involved in such correspondence. This will lead to intimacy that is not appropriate before marriage. This is what I know from sangat of Gursikhs and reading books of Gursikhs. Baaki Rabb deeyaan Rabb jaanae. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Matrimonials!!!

tigress · 05 Aug 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh kulbir singh, sorry but i would be so scared of marrying someone I hardly knew and didn't get to talk with. Vaheguru ji's bhana aside, i am human with human emotions. Not everyone goes crazy with lust from talking to another, you can establish a beautiful bond and trust with the one you are going to marry which will make the transition for the girl who till then has probably always lived with her parents to her new home a lot less traumatic. And yes, it is traumatic for a girl, for she leaves behind every comfort and security she has known to go into an unknown, unfamiliar situation. To then go into a marriage where you have not even formed a bond with your marriage life partner is not the way i would do it, and I would rather not do it altogether if that was the only option for me. I would have no problems living by myself and in contemplation with the Divine if the alternative was marriage to someone i did not know properly or get to know well. What happened to live and let live? if you are unable to become friends with ur betrothed before marriage, then that is fine for you and your partner, no doubt you would both deal with it in your own ways, but there is no reason to make such rules for everybody out there, I see no problem with correspondance with your betrothed and if you start to feel piaar for your spouse to be then so much the better. For lets not forget, we contemplate he who created piaar every day. humbly Vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Matrimonials!!!

what?????????? · 05 Aug 2004

kulbir singh writes "As much as possible one should avoid unnecassary talking with the opposite sex" what sort of seige mentality is this? maybe we should ban bibian from the gurdwara 'incase' we think bad things......

Re: Matrimonials!!!

slim · 28 Dec 2005

hmm? wrote: > so is everyone in agreement then, that it's not against sikhi > to ask someone to marry you? maybe Kulbir Singh could comment?

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 28 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh "what sort of seige mentality is this? maybe we should ban bibian from the gurdwara 'incase' we think bad things......" There's only one possible reason for why anyone would have a disscusion with the opposite gender, and this reason is because the demon of lust inside the body will feel attracted to her. Therefore, it would use the mind of the person to conduct any type of topic, which might even be completely useless but the demon would use this chance to get closer to that female. Furthermore, even though you may think you have the situation under complete control, that person is always wrong since the demon's inside of the body have control over the mind, ten organs and the senses. Until that person reaches Saachkhand their completely under the influence of evil. "As much as possible one should avoid unnecassary talking with the opposite sex" Bhai Sahib kulbir Singh Jee's correct in saying that by having discussions with the opposite gender has to be avoided. Bhai Sahib 'tigress' Jee, you may have a discussion with the soon to be spouse but with the awareness of the parents, as e.g. there should defiantly be a convention with the familys and then both genders can have a private disscusion in a seperate room, but within the house. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Matrimonials!!!

singh singhnia nu parnam · 28 Dec 2005

i understand bhai kulbir singh jis point and it would be most valid if amritdharis really stuck to rehat on a level, but not everyone these days take amrit for assal reasons. I come across girls who flirt around, guys who flirt around, some have weaknesses wheree other person has strentgh in other way too. Back in punjab some years ago we had certain values that bound us together, we had no way but to find a way where there was no way. These day you not know where a person come from. if a person is chosen for another both amritdhari, and one has higher level of this or that kaam kamaiya haumai or rehat, or say one has no rehni behni adhata as per elders while other does how will this work out? even where the partners are chosen as per bhai sahib kulbir singh is saying? for this reason i think its most important that amritdharis are suitably matched in adhata so they will not clash. I am not so sure about opposites attract kind of thing may be in some ways but if my future partner wanted to do things i did not and we both clashed over it then thats not good. These day people are too different, and do not like the old school traditions, what if modern type amritdhari marries old school lad raised in bzurg adhata? or other thing? i do not support ideas where people venture off to meet others unless gursikhs are present.

Re: Matrimonials!!!

ik · 28 Dec 2005

"If both parents or elderly gursikhs are unable to get involved for some reason, then it is okay to approach the potential spouse with proposal." kulbir singh, i think it was a mistake for you to say that. even though you gave justification, i think it send a wrong message. young people these days will think of any excuse to say as to why their parents or any elders shouldnt get involved. there is ALWAYS a way to get an elder involved. besides, we should not keep an eye out at ALL for any one of hte opposite sex. we can ask someone to get involved, but never ask directly. that is not what sikhi is about. if you ask an elder, and if guru ji wants to, when he asks the person will agree or disagree.

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Chacha Chattar Ram · 29 Dec 2005

Is homosexualy wrong with sikhism? I am not gay, but I just want to know for "EDUCATIONAL" purpose.

Re: Matrimonials!!!

amarjeet singh · 29 Dec 2005

"There's only one possible reason for why anyone would have a disscusion with the opposite gender, and this reason is because the demon of lust inside the body will feel attracted to her." hahahahahahahahaha dont be silly, i agree that maybe u shudnt speak to the person ur gonna marry, but to say that if u speak to someone of the opposite gender u have lust for them is completely stupid. absoloute rubbish jus read it thru to yourself and see how dumb it sounds what if u were discussing a topic at a sikhi camp or somet, ur not allowed to discuss it with opposite gender cos it mite giv u lust????? dont be silly. we should see all amritdhari singhs as brothers and all amritdhari singhnis as sisters. so that doesnt mean we avoid all our brothers if were girls and ignore all our sisters if were boys. it means treat each other like siblings. if u feel like u get kaam wheneva ny1 of the opposite gender speaks to u, maybe u got sum big problems

Re: Matrimonials!!!

Swinder Singh · 30 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I hope every body must have learned the name of Ajamal. He is known as sinner in the gurbani. Ajamal Paapi Jag Janey-----Guru Teg Bahadur ji How he become paapi, is a sakhi that he was a learned disciple of his guru and used to visit daily the kutia(abode) of his guru. There was a dwelling of some pros. on the way. His guru restricted him not to come and go through that route. He argued with his guru saying that I am learned enough to understand difference between wrong and right so guru ji please donnt worry that I shall get involved and that. In defiance to the advice of his guru he didnt leave using that route. Now happened that his guru cautioned him against. He got involved with the pros. and ultimately he has to marry her. He had six sons out of that sinful marriage. But during the period his soul remained cursing him and he always did ardas to his guru to pull him out of that sin. As such, his ardas bore fruit and his guru met him any way. He caught the feet of his guru begged for forgiveness. Then his guru told him that the next delivery of your wife will bring you the seventh son and name him Narayan. He did that. After sometime he got bed ridden due to some illness. During his bed ridden days he always use to call his yougest son Narayan, Narayan come on Narayan, Narayan,Narayan….......As this was the blessed word of his guru so he got his Liv connected with the almighty Narayan and immersed with Him and got rid of his sin. Ajamal ko ant kaal mein Narayan sud aye-Guru Teg Bahadur ji Result: There are so many slips between the cup and the lips. So as suggested by Veer Kulbir Singh ji, it would be better if you meet the girls only in the presence of some elderly people and that not too frequently. Bhul Chuk Maff Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.

Re: Matrimonials!!!

confused · 30 Dec 2005

i agree with Amarjeet Singh...you can have a conversation with someone without there being any sort of hidden agenda