Re: Malpractices of Sikhs
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 28 Jul 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
imho this tuk from gurbani is referring to others to keep their faith....gurbani si full of other shabads where the muslim is exhorted to beceome a good muslim, a hindu is advised how to be a good hindu...
NO OTHER holy book of Any other religion has this "advice for SIKHS...etc... instead Non-Beleivers are called KAFIRS and branded as sinners who will go to hell.... this i think is worse than "shattering" other peoples beleifs...
We have respectfully incorporated wriitngs of so called hindus, brahmins, shudars, muslims etc in our Guru Granth Sahib jee and bow to them just as respectfully as to our own Guru Ji." We need not apologise for our beleifs in our Gurbani.
Sikhi is not about CONVERTING others BY DISGRACING, back biting, dragging down....CONDEMNING other faiths.... we dont promote ourselves by condemning others... Sikhi proves itself the better religion by DRAWING a LONGER LINE......rather than SHORTENING/ERASING other's lines
but then again since we have our own GURU SAHIBAANS to show us the Right Way.....why shoudl we still continue to beleive in hindu gods. ( respect is dfferent from beleief ) I respect Prophet Mohammed, Jesus..BUT i DONT BELIEVE in them....should i ?? If so WHY ?? Am I contributing to "shatter" other peoples faiths if i refuse to beleive in "raam chander of ayodiyah as my god" ??? i fail to see the connection.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Malpractices of Sikhs
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 28 Jul 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
most of the talk about "aal " religions being same/similar/leading to God etc etc is most often uttered by "apologists"...usually SIKHS who attend multi-religious talks, seminars /meetings symposiums etc.
imho the spokesmen from the other religions like christianity/islam/hinduism will announce forcefully...Islam is the ONLY way...dito for the others...but when the time comes for the "sikh" to speak....he will start saying "all religions are same...they all have good points....all Paths lead to God...the God is Same...etc etc...
I have attended a few such seminars and symposiums, some even organsised by Sikh Organistaions with Guru ghar golak..... the other religions' speakers and reps come fully prepared to disseminate info about their own religions and convert a few...the sikhs go there and start saying all this about same religions, same god, same path etc...once i sat next to an anglican minister at ine such meeting organsied by a sikh organisation..the man was surprised to hear what the sikh chairman was talking about.....how can all religions be the same he told me...my Church, the Seventh day adventists is the Only TRUE Church ....how can a sikh know about my church....i told him the sikh doesnt even know about his own.....
Reality check: Buddhists dont even beleive in a God?Akal purakh...Islam has to beleive in Muhammad even before you can beleive in Allah in Christianity if you Dont beleive in jesus you will go to Hell...and Allah, jesus/god/ etc are NOT Akal Purakh at all. Just a cursory reading of what Allah/God is in the Bible/Koran will tell you that this "God" is vastly different from the Waheguru in Gurmat....no way the two are even remotely similar... So hw can all religions lead to the Same God when this God is NOt the same at all ??
The above article by singh is very well written and explains this all fully.
Dass jarnail Singh.