Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

hindu gods

hindu gods

singhnee · 27 Jul 2004

do we belief in the hindu gods? i always thought that the gods existed because in the gurbani they always say..braham mahesh..sachipat. i recently heard that hindu gods are fake. And the stories of raam and krishna must be conciderd as a moral story to separeta bad from eval. just as adam and eve, abraham and arc of noah. is this true??

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 28 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. bhen jio, This topic has been discussed in aprevious thread titled: bhagat kabeer on raam". as they say daal wichon ek dana tohiya bass hunda hai......to check if the daal is cooked you need to squish just one seed-daana.... bhagat kabeer's clear gurbani on the name of raam clears any doubts as to his "raam" is waheguru or the king ram chander. to kabeer his raam is waheguru. so all the other "names" of hindu gods such as krishan, gopi, narayan, gopal, etc etc are also all for waheguru...and NOT for the hindu gods as in hinduism. go through that thread and give us your input. dass jarnail singh

Re: hindu gods

!! · 28 Jul 2004

Hi friends It gives me pain to write this but then we the sikhs, have strayed from our path. We (many learned sikh scholars included) have time and again been writing to prove the non-existance of the Gods like ram, krishna etc. There have been books written by sikh writers on this issue. Please remember what Guru nanak had to say about the faith and the religion of others. gurur Nanak said Jagat jalanda rakh lae apni kirpa dhaar Jit duwarrey Oobrey titey leho ubaar (At Whichever door the people burning from worldly issues find peace, let them have peace my Lord) and we are going all-out to shatter the faith and beleifs of others, which is no good posted by (a sikh)

Re: hindu gods

singhnee · 28 Jul 2004

i think i get it... its not up to us to say the mythecals are true..we should respect other religions and we could learn about the stories. So nowhere inthe ggs it says every story is fake,because thats disrespect. am i right?

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 28 Jul 2004

Personally, I think Ram Chander is reffered to as is Ravan and many other Hindu Gods and Devtay. They are a part of God's creation so talking about them does not make you a hindu. What were Sikhs before they were Sikhs? We were Hindus, correct? There is nothing wrong in reffering to Hindu Gods, its not like Gurbani tells us to worship them. Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani, I respect you but I am saddened to see your stance on this subject. What are your thoughts on the following lines (If you think Hindu Gods are not reffered to): --------------------------------------------------------------- aaeiaa suniaa bidhar dhae bolae dhurajodhhan hoe rukhaa|| Hearing that Lord Krishan was served and stayed over at humble Bidar's home, Duryodhan remarked sarcastically. Bhai Gurdaas Ji Vaars Bhai Gurdaas 10 --------------------------------------------------------- gaavan thudhhano ei(n)dhr ei(n)dhraasan bait(h)ae dhaevathiaa dhar naalae || Indra, seated on His Throne, sings of You, with the deities at Your Door. Guru Nanak Dev Ji So Dar 8 ----------------------------------------------------------- kott ei(n)dhr anaek dhaevaa japath suaamee jai jai kaar || Millions of Indras and countless gods and super-human beings meditate on the Lord Master and celebrate His Praises. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 455 ------------------------------------------------------------- hanoomaan sar garurr samaanaa(n) || surapath narapath nehee gun jaanaa(n) ||2|| Beings like Hanumaan, Garura, Indra the King of the gods and the rulers of humans - none of them know Your Glories, Lord. ||2|| Bhagat Kabeer Ji Raag Dhanaasree 691 ----------------------------------------------------------------- a(n)dhhulai dhehasir moo(n)dd kattaaeiaa raavan maar kiaa vaddaa bhaeiaa ||1|| The blind, ten-headed Raavan had his heads cut off, but what greatness was obtained by killing him? ||1|| Guru Nanak Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 350 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: hindu gods

another singh · 28 Jul 2004

Not always does guru refer to Waheguru when mentioning the names of hindu gods. Many times, Guru Sahib is giving us an example of their life myth, or stories. 1.) Here Guru Nanak Sahib is saying that Waheguru is the highest and he IS those gods: example: gur eesar gur gorakh baramaa gur paarabathee maaee || (The Guru is Shiva, the Guru is Vishnu and Brahma; the Guru is Paarvati and Lakhshmi. ) 2.) Guru Sahib also makes the point that even these Hindu God's look up to the almighty Waheguru; this has been stated very early on in Sikhism. Since Guru Sahib respects these God's, we must naturally do the same, and in the same fashion as he has: example: gaavehi chith gupath likh jaanehi likh likh dhharam veechaarae || Chitr and Gupt, the angels of the conscious and the subconscious who record actions, and the Righteous Judge of Dharma who judges this record sing. gaavehi eesar baramaa dhaevee sohan sadhaa savaarae || Shiva, Brahma and the Goddess of Beauty, ever adorned, sing. gaavehi ei(n)dh eidhaasan bait(h)ae dhaevathiaa dhar naalae || Indra, seated upon His Throne, sings with the deities at Your Door. gaavehi sidhh samaadhhee a(n)dhar gaavan saadhh vichaarae || The Siddhas in Samaadhi sing; the Saadhus sing in contemplation. gaavan jathee sathee sa(n)thokhee gaavehi veer karaarae || The celibates, the fanatics, the peacefully accepting and the fearless warriors sing. gaavan pa(n)ddith parran rakheesar jug jug vaedhaa naalae || The Pandits, the religious scholars who recite the Vedas, with the supreme sages of all the ages, sing. gaavehi mohaneeaa man mohan suragaa mashh paeiaalae || The Mohinis, the enchanting heavenly beauties who entice hearts in this world, in paradise, and in the underworld of the subconscious sing. gaavan rathan oupaaeae thaerae at(h)asat(h) theerathh naalae || The celestial jewels created by You, and the sixty-eight holy places of pilgrimage sing. gaavehi jodhh mehaabal sooraa gaavehi khaanee chaarae || The brave and mighty warriors sing; the spiritual heroes and the four sources of creation sing. gaavehi kha(n)dd ma(n)ddal varabha(n)ddaa kar kar rakhae dhhaarae || The planets, solar systems and galaxies, created and arranged by Your Hand, sing. saeee thudhhuno gaavehi jo thudhh bhaavan rathae thaerae bhagath rasaalae || They alone sing, who are pleasing to Your Will. Your devotees are imbued with the Nectar of Your Essence. 3.) It is very easy to overlook the importance of Hindu Gods and their relationship to Sikhism. Our Dharam is about Waheguru and Truth. We must read bani, and understand the relationship which was set up by Guru Nanak Sahib very early on in Sikhism, and early on in SGGS. Some last examples will keep us in the right track: siv siv karath sagal kar jorehi sarab maeiaa t(h)aakur thaeree dhohee ||1|| Everyone calls upon You with their palms pressed together, saying, ""Shiva, Shiva"". O Merciful Lord and Master, everyone cries out for Your Help. ||1|| aapae siv sakathee sa(n)jogee || He is the Uniter of Shiva and Shakti - mind and matter. 4.) Below, Kabeer Jee couldn't have said it in better words, that Shiva, Hanumaan, and other Hindu Gods are all spiritually awake. Kabeer Jee (just like all Guru Sahibs) recognizes the spiritual levels of these Hindu Gods, but then Kabeer Jee says -- GURMUKH JAAGAI SOYEE SAAR! (being gurmukh is the most excellent way to reach Waheguru). jaagai sukadhaeo ar akoor || Suk Dayv and Akrur are awake and aware. hanava(n)th jaagai dhhar la(n)koor || Hanuman with his tail is awake and aware. sa(n)kar jaagai charan saev || Shiva is awake, serving at the Lord's Feet. kal jaagae naamaa jaidhaev ||2|| Naam Dayv and Jai Dayv are awake in this Dark Age of Kali Yuga. ||2|| jaagath sovath bahu prakaar || There are many ways of being awake, and sleeping. guramukh jaagai soee saar || To be awake as Gurmukh is the most excellent way. eis dhaehee kae adhhik kaam || The most sublime of all the actions of this body, kehi kabeer bhaj raam naam ||3||2|| says Kabeer, is to meditate and vibrate on the Lord's Name. ||3||2||

Re: hindu gods

!! · 28 Jul 2004

Yes you seem to get me rightly - all I meant was we shouldn't try to prove that Ram/Krishna etc didn't exist and that they are mythological figures etc as we don't know for sure. Also we shouldn't say this in front of a hindu as it may hurt his feelings. Gurbani is our guru and unto it we all should look, and we should try to avoid the unnecessary discussions about Ram/Krishan etc naam japo merey saajan saina - waheguroo waheguroo waheguroo waheguroo

Re: hindu gods

!! · 28 Jul 2004

My apologies for being misunderstood:- All I meant was that we shouldn't try to prove Ram ji/Krishna ji etc didn't exist and that they are only mythological figures or figments of imagination etc. Also we shouldn't say this in front of a hindu as it may hurt his feelings. Also we needn't talk on this amongst ourselves (i mean on sikh egroups)because it creates an unnecessary aura of superiority in our minds if we are able to disapprove the others. No doubt Gurbani is all powerful gyan of the lord. Lets propogate and publicise the fact that gurbani (Dhur ki bani - the word of lord) comes from the mouth of not one person but a number of persons of all faiths and colours Lets take pround in the fact that Orators of gurbani (creator of gurbani - Dhur ki bani - God) were sikh gurus as well as the Hindu bhagats as well as the Muslim fakirs. Lets publicise that the Guru granth sahib ji is a prersent tense proof of respect for Kabir/Naamdev/Nanak in equal measures. But at the same time lets not try to disapprove others. No Doubt Guru Nanak is great . Guru Nanak pardoned all the sinners, whosoever he met with:- Guru Nanak pardoned the likes of kauda rakash (One who had wanted to make a cannible food of guru nanak and Mardana) Guru Nanak pardoned the likes of sajjan thug (One who had tried to rob him at night and then throw him and mardana in the well) or whosoever / no doubt dhan guru nanak is great but we should try to avoid the unnecessary discussions about Ram ji/Krishan ji etc Friends, i feel - Gurbani is our guru and unto it alone we all should look and naam japo merey saajan saina - waheguroo waheguroo waheguroo waheguroo

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 29 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear !! and others, i too agree that we shouldnt say things a hindu wouldnt want to hear..why would anybody want to tell a hindu that "HIS GOD KRISHNA" doesnt or does exist. to a Hindu obviously ALL the 33 KROR DEVTAS EXIST . So let it be. I for one woudnt go around looking for Hindus to tell them this "great fact"...which hindu in his right mind would listen to me !!! GURU NANAK travelled to ALL the Major Hindu teeraths just to tell them that....IF ALL hindus had beleived in GURU JI there wouldnt be any Hindus today....but it is historical fact that not many listened even to GURU NANAK...so who are we to tell others what is right and what is wrong. Any sikh who goes out of his way to tell hindus that their gods dont exist or are myths is WRONG.....what we SIKHS genuinely beleive is our buisness. In a similar manner no hindu should tell me that the ram-krishan in Gurbani are HIS GODS...because HINDUS came FIRST and the SIKH GURUS WERE HINDUS......and so naturally ALL Hindu GODS are also SIKH GODS !! and if a hindu does tell me that i would dismiss it. IF Ram and Krishan are REAL GODS equal for Hindus and SIKHS by virtue of this name being mentioned in Gurbani.... then the 33 KROR DEVTAS, MILLIONS of INDRAS are also VALID GODS for us ??? In Hinduism there is only ONE "INDRA"...BUT Guru Nanak sys MILLIONS of INDRAS..... what is GURU JI talking about ?? WHICH particular INDIRA is GOD and which is NOT ?? it is an exercise in futility...why not just concentrate on our GURUS, martyrs jeewans as chanan munareh and Gurbani and naam simran.. Thank you for your input. I have learned a lot. dass Jarnail singh

Re: hindu gods

Singh · 29 Jul 2004

Anyone who posts quotes from gurbani MUST put the ang ref. Too many times have we found that translations are misleading or blatantly wrong. With out the ang refs for other to check and see its no pint using them, as we don’t know if the bani is actually saying what the person is arguing. The admin should make a point of only allowing posts with the exact ang refs like other phorums.

Re: hindu gods

Singh · 29 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah People really need to read Gurbani and find out the obvious for themselves, rather than asking others blatantly obvious questions. It’s clear that hindu gods etc did or do exist. However Gurbani reveals unlike in Hinduism they are not all powerful gods, but simply a part of creation, subject to birth/deaths and are under the control and lower than Akal Purkh. They are simplt different creatures and tools and are not to be worhipped as they are subject to the laws of nature like everyone apart from Akal Purkh. As for names like Ram, Gopal, Gobind etc these are Karam naams (names with attributable meanings) and are for Akal Purkh. When a name like Ram is used for Ram Chander its blindingly obvious to the reader that here the same name is being used for someone else and not as a Karam Naam for Akal Purkh. I may sound harsh but people who cannot even understand this basic concept of Gurmat ie one unequalled Akal Purkh to be worshiped really need to stop debating about Keski’s, sarblo, bana etc and find out the very basics of sikhi first.

Re: hindu gods

Singh · 29 Jul 2004

!! It's all well and good not hurting Hindu's feelings, but Gurbani is crystal clear that that Dev's, Krishna, Ram Chander etc are not Akal Purkh but just part of creation. Gurbani also reveals how caste, rituals and many aspects of Hinduism is not all true. What should we as Sikhs to.? Simply beleive in what Guru Ji reveals and if that hurts the feelings of anyone than what can we do, as long as we are in Gurmat. We should not bring Bani down by changing meanings etc or making compromises in order to make Hindu's or anone else happy. Guru Ji does reveal Krishna, Ram Chender as existed and indeed God was inside them just like its inside you and me, but the difference is that they were not God as beleived in Hinduism. Knowing this we must not hurt anyones feelings regardless but must also accept and follow Gurmat. krisan balbhadaro gur pag lag Dhi-aavai. Even Krishna and Balbhadar meditated on the Lord, falling at the Guru's Feet. ang 165

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 14 Nov 2004

It is important to understand that hindus believe in 1 God too, check this out: Too Many Gods! Too Much Confusion! http://hinduism.about.com/cs/basics/a/aa072103a.htm What is Brahman? In Hinduism, the impersonal Absolute is called “Brahman”. According to this pantheistic belief, everything in existence, living or non-living comes from it. Therefore, Hindus regard all things as sacred. We cannot equate Brahman with God, because God is male and is describable, and this takes away from the concept of the Absolute. Brahman is formless or “nirakara”, and beyond anything that we can conceive of. However, it can manifest itself in myriad forms, including Gods and Goddesses, the “sakara” form of the Brahman. According to Prof. Jeaneane Fowler of the University of Wales College, Newport: “The relationship between the many manifest deities and the unmanifest Brahman is rather like that between the sun and its rays. We cannot experience the sun itself but we can experience its rays and the qualities, which those rays have. And, although the sun’s rays are many, ultimately, there is only one source, one sun. So the Gods and Goddesses of Hinduism amount to thousands, all representing the many aspects of Brahman” (Hinduism: Beliefs, Practices and Scriptures)

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The word RAAM occurs 2553 times in Gurbani....ONLY EIGHT times is it used for RAM CHANDER son off Dusrath king of Ayudhiya. Ram Chander is described as a ORDINARY MAN ( not DEVTA) who is CRYING for his WIFE, wandering about lost seeking help from Hanuman's forces to get her back from raavan, his big family is mentioned in Sloks at end of Guru Granth. Just like SIKHS today name their children " Nanak Singh, Gobind Singh, Ram Dass Singh etc after the GURUS... it is entirely possible that Raja Dasrath named HIS son "Raam Chander" AFTER the Name of WAHEGURU - RAAM that was popular during his time. SO just like NANAK SINGH th NOvellist is NOT GURU NANAK by any shot...this Raam chander king of Ayudhiaya is NOT Raam Waheguru by any shot. The REST of the word RAAM is for RAMMIYA HOIYAH RAAM - WAHEGURU... a person living in Ayudhgiya COULD NOT BE RAMIYAAH HOIYAH in ANYTHING let alone everything. Jarnail Singh.

Re: hindu gods

Search For Tat · 15 Nov 2004

I understand people do not want to criticse other religions. But if you look at some of the things they believe, then how can you not criticise? This is not done hurtfully, but as part of debate. Gurbani often criticises a wide array of practices, many of which belong to many religions, such as fasting. Is Gurbani wrong? There is nothing wrong in debating other religions. Otherwise accept the world rotates on the horns of a bull??

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh Ji, I think gurbani is VERY CLEAR where it mentions Ram Chander or RAAM (Vahiguru). But I have to totally disagree with your assessment that Ram Chander was an ordinary man. This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 1 qRyqy C`qRI rUp Dr sUrj bMsI bf Avqwrw] thraethae shhaathree roop dhhar sooraj ba(n)see badd avathaaraa|| In Treta in the Sun-dynasty descended in the form of the kshatriya(Ram) a great incarnation.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 15 Nov 2004

also Jarnail Singh Ji: This Shabad is by Bhatt Kal in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1390 sqjuig qY mwixE CilE bil bwvn BwieE ] sathajug thai maaniou shhaliou bal baavan bhaaeiou || In the Golden Age of Sat Yuga, You were pleased to deceive Baal the king, in the form of a dwarf. qRyqY qY mwixE rwmu rGuvMsu khwieE ] thraethai thai maaniou raam raghuva(n)s kehaaeiou || In the Silver Age of Traytaa Yuga, You were called Raam of the Raghu dynasty. duAwpuir ik®sn murwir kMsu ikrqwrQu kIE ] dhuaapur kirasan muraar ka(n)s kirathaarathh keeou || In the Brass Age of Dwaapur Yuga, You were Krishna; You killed Mur the demon and saved Kans. augRsYx kau rwju ABY Bgqh jn dIE ] ougrasain ko raaj abhai bhagatheh jan dheeou || You blessed Ugrasain with a kingdom, and You blessed Your humble devotees with fearlessness. kiljuig pRmwxu nwnk guru AMgdu Amru khwieE ] kalijug pramaan naanak gur a(n)gadh amar kehaaeiou || In the Iron Age, the Dark Age of Kali Yuga, You are known and accepted as Guru Nanak, Guru Angad and Guru Amar Das. sRI gurU rwju Aibclu Atlu Awid puriK PurmwieE ]7] sree guroo raaj abichal attal aadh purakh furamaaeiou ||7|| The sovereign rule of the Great Guru is unchanging and permanent, according the Command of the Primal Lord God. ||7||

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I base my assessment of Ram Chander of Ayudhia as a MAN/KING and nothing MORE than that on the following GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI. 1. Nanak Nirbhau Nirankaar..HOR KETEH RAAM RAVAAL...AAng 464 2.Pandeh tumra RAAM CHAND...so bhee avat dekhiya tha.. Ang 875 3.ROVEH RAAM nikala bhiyah..Ang 953 4. Man meh JHURREH RAAM CHAND... ang 1412 5. Raam JHURREH dil malveh.... aang 1412 6.Raam gayio raavan gaiyo jakohn bahu parwaar..aang 1428... ONLY AN ORDINARY MAN like one of us will CRY and WAIL with SADNESS in HIS HEART...for His wife/children/sons/MAYA of this World. Compare this behaviour of CRYING to GURU GOBIND SINGH JI who sent his two SONS into battle to CERTAIN DEATH, with his own Hands and Said BOLEH SO NIHAAL SAT SRI AKAAL when he saw them FALL. When GURU JI learned of the DEATH of his other two sons ( and MOTHER)..He said.CHAAR MOOYEH TO KIA HOOAH JEEWAT KAYEE HAZAAR... When GURU JI saw Bhai Jeeta bring back His FATHER's Head ( GURU TEGBAHADUR JI) he hugged him to his chest and said Ranghreta Guru Ka BETA... MEN like you and me cry when our wives die, desert us, get kidnapped by villains...READ Pangtee Number TWO given above.... try and SEE if there is any sign of "respect"..as should be given to a DEVTA...NO respect but a casual..Pandeh I saw your "raam" coming.... I just cant understand some peoples' "affinity" to these raams and krishans... WITH Mahaan GURUS like GURU GOBIND SINGH JI before us...we still go running to these mortals who CRIED and WAILED at their wives separation ( ram knew his wife was in prison..just imagine hOW MUCH HE WOULD HAVE CRIED and WAILED if she had DIED ??) The word JHURREH means "dying inside" ( GRIEVE MUCH)...only ordinary men do that..WE DIE INSIDE with "GRIEF" when we cannot bear the PAIN?? Are we talking about a DEVTA here?? Excuse me..in my "pea brain" NO. SO VERY VERY SORRY If I hurt your raam chander devta sentiments but for me this is the TRUTH and GURBANI amply supports this view. GURBANI is NEVER TWO FACED/DOUBLE SPEAK.... IF the 6 pangtees above speak of ram chander a man...then the REST of the Pangtees are NOT about the SAME "person". Another reason I am not too much impressed by ram chander and krishan is that WITH the whole world suffering..these NEVER VENTURED out of their own little kingdoms.... Compare this to GURU NANAK who travelled HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of MILES, through jungles, deserts, mountains, dangerous places..SODHAN chhharria lokayee..THAT is the MARK of a TRUE PRPOHET for the WHOLE WORLD. They are mentioned in Gurbani as they are Part and parcel of INDIAN RELIGIOUS TRADITION. So if Bhatts say YOU, WAHEGURU were Raam Chander in Satyug....YES that is Perfectly all right as WAHEGURU WAS ALSO SITA, WAHEGURU WAS ALSO RAAVAN...and so on....IF WAHEGURU WAS KRISHAN in DWAPAR..WAHEGURU WAS ALSO KANS his Mamma, WAHEGURU WAS ALSO all the KAURAVAS all the PANDAVAS...WAHEGURU IS EVERYTHING IN ALL THE YUGS..... so what do we make of all this....treat all .....sita lakshman, raavna, krishn, pandvas kauravas dasrth etc etc etc as DEVTAS...BECAUSE ALL of them ARE WAHEGURU also. GOOD LUCK to you as there ar 33 KROR of such out there....if you even begin to COUNT all of them your life will be gone counting...and you will have NO time for any SIMRAN of WAHEGURU and any time for our GURUS and GURMATT. Carry on PLEASE..as that is your perorgrative...but dont tell me to do the same. Jarnail Singh.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Janrnail Singh Ji, I don't care how you want to interpret Gurbani, what I dislike is your temperment. Control your temper please. You can interpret however you like, its up to you but don't tell me your interpretations are correct and the only way everyone else should see it. Anyways I think in noway are Ram and Krishan ordinary. However God sent his brightest light in KalYug since that is exactly what we need and that is Guru Nanak.

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Wahegur Ji Ki fateh. Dear P Singh Ji, Sorry if i offended you. MY "interpretations" of Gurbani are for MYSELF ONLY. No one is FORCED to accept them and I am no scholar or PHD so that you or anyone may feel "compelled" to accept them. NO such need ji. I am NOT a SANT ji/bb Ji/Brahmgiani either so not much there either. I write from my own experiences and for my "hobby"...if someone benefits..ok..if not..also ok. I fonldy like to think i have controlled my KRODH....however this is a dangerous beast and very powerful....so sometimes it does break out...although in this case i dont remember feeling any anger at anybody...anyway who knows except Waheguru....so if that is the case sorry ji. "BRIGHTEST LIGHT" is correct...absolutely correct. SO my opinion is when I have the BRIGHTEST LIGHT lighting up my life....i have no use for Ghee lamps or candles..although i understand some people still like to "keep" a few oil lamps and candles just in case the "Electricity" goes OUT....BUT I am not one of those...as MY BRIGHTEST LIGHT will never go out..ever. So I totally "respect" your sentiments of keeping a few candles in your closet just in case.... good luck. Dassan dass jarnail singh

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 16 Nov 2004

this has nothing to do with keeping candles in my closet, I'm quite infuriated that you think I have some backup Prophets to rely on if Guru Nanak doesn't coem through. This is very insulting. I just like to give respect where it is due and viewing Krishna and Ram as Joe and Bob is not giving them there due respect.

Re: hindu gods

lakhvir singh · 16 Nov 2004

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh!! KhalsaJi, It's all very simple. Guru Nanak Dev Ji always preached to the Hindu to be a good Hindu and to a Muslim to be a good Muslim. Their beliefs are theirs to think about. We cannot argue for anyone. What we can discuss is Truth - which Baba Nanak preached. For a Sikh, Guru Granth Sahib Ji is our focus. Do not be distracted by anything else. Even Guru Gobind Singh Ji told his Sikhs not to speak against any religion, but to respect one and all. We will confuse ourselves by spending our spiritual energies on matters that the Gurus themselves did not indulge in. Our best is to encourage our Hindu, Muslim or Christian friends to be faithful to their respective religions, while we practice the same - work towards encouraging the self and our fellow Sikhs to continue refining their beings by following the tenets and beliefs of their own faith. Guru Nanak Dev Ji lived that philosophy all his life. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh!! L*

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Wahegur Ji Ki fateh. Tsk tsk veer P singh ji, now who is getting "angry". Where anger comes in any "repect" per se goes out the window. PLease PLEASE cool down ...give respect to whomsoever you choose...Joe Bob Ram krishan durga vishnu, indira, tom dick, harry, jesus. THEY are ALL RESPECTABLE people... at least to somebody and I have no problem with accepting that. Gussa mann na Handhayeh ji....Sheikh Farid....now that is one I can respect as He has written GURBANI.....yet many havent written gurbani or even a single line of anything but they are still respectable... so lets agree to disagree. Lets stop this debte right here before more anger creeps in. we are all learners with own attitudes and hangups.... BHUL CHUK MAAF JI. jarnail singh

Re: hindu gods

Rain drop · 16 Nov 2004

We believe in Hindu gods/devtas or believe not; that is separate discussion. Why Gurbani used their references is also a separate point. Are they fake or real, was the original post. As Arshi Ji say; for eight times, in Gurbani, Ram word is used for the character of Ramayana. Should that not be a point to prove, Ram exited. Even if he was an ordinary man; he existed or not, is the question? Kindly inform; do we find in Gurbani any where, that the hindu devtas actually existed not.

Re: hindu gods

Singh · 16 Nov 2004

The shabad on Bhatt Kal in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1390 is not even saying that Waheguru (God) came down as Ram Chander, Krishna etc. If you actually read the whole shabad you would see that its talking about Guru Ji and is concerned with the praise of Guru sahib.

Re: hindu gods

_____ · 16 Nov 2004

phaaji rain drop i copied and pasted this from the charan door thread. The verse below does state that they have happened, but the following verses also stress that we should only focus on Waheguru Ji il put the entire shabad up later, at the moment i am short on time. I am not sure whether bhai gurdas ji vara are mann as gurbani by all sikhs, but have myself been told that they are respected and venerated as being the chabbi of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 12 bishan leae avathaar dhas vair virodhh virodhh jodhh sa(n)ghaarae|| Visnu incarnated ten times and decimated his opposing warriors. mashh kashh vairaah roop nar si(n)gh hoe baavan ba(n)dhhaarae|| The incarnations in the forms of fish, tortoise, swine, man-lion, dwarf and Buddha etc. HAVE HAPPENED. parasaraam raam krishan ho kilak kala(n)kee ath aha(n)kaarae||

Re: hindu gods

dil · 16 Nov 2004

WGJKK,WGJKF; It is correct to say that at most places in gurbani worlds like murari, krishan,ram,shyam etc are used as synonym for god. But do not forget that these world are derived from the Hindu mythological. In fact these great personalities were sent by god to accomplish certain duties for man kind. Same way as we believe that God himself came to earth as Guru Nanak. These personalities were so great that hardly we can find difference between god and Hindu Avtaars, or Guru Nanak and other 9 gurus. with our small mind we are no one to degrade avtaars and gurus. We must respect all such great personalities and do simran of only one god who sent all of them to world. Even it will be a sin to do simran of guru Nanak dev ji or other nine gurus. There is a lot to write on this subject but on later date. WGJJK,WGJKF;

Re: hindu gods

_____ · 16 Nov 2004

This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 12 bishan leae avathaar dhas vair virodhh virodhh jodhh sa(n)ghaarae|| Visnu incarnated ten times and decimated his opposing warriors. mashh kashh vairaah roop nar si(n)gh hoe baavan ba(n)dhhaarae|| The incarnations in the forms of fish, tortoise, swine, man-lion, dwarf and Buddha etc. have happened. parasaraam raam krishan ho kilak kala(n)kee ath aha(n)kaarae|| Parsu Ram, Ram, Kisan and very much proud incarnation of Kalki have flourished. khathree maar eikeeh vaar raamaaein kar bhaarathh bhaarae|| Ram was hero of Ramayan, and kisan was all in the mahabharat. kaam krodhh n saadhhiou lobh moh aha(n)kaar n maarae|| But the lust and anger were not sublimited and greed, infatuation and ego were not eschewed. sathigur purakh n bhaettiaa saadhh sa(n)gath sehala(n)ghan saarae|| None remembered the true Guru (God) and nobody benefited himself in the holy congregation. houmai(n) a(n)dhar kaar vikaarae ||a|| All acted arrogantly being full of evil propensities.

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. Waheguru waheguru...we "read" and yet we dont "see". Guur Nanak Ji in Gurbani tells us: DONOT call them "blind" those who DONT have EYES ( because Waheguru didnt give them the organ of sight)..BUT CALL theose BLIND...the ones who HAVE EYES and yet REFUSE to SEE. What do I mean.???? The Shabad from Bhai gurdass Ji...Bishan leeae avtar given above has already appeared 2 times.... IF we all read the shabad carefull y we will see that Bahi ji si "mentioning" Vishnu, Parsram, krishn ramchander etc etc etc....BUT the MOST IMPORTANT sentence is:...BUT the LUST and ANGER...GREED...INFATUATION...EGO....remained as strong as BEFORE..AND NONE....REPEAT " NONE" REMEMBERED the TRUE GURU....AND "NOBODY" benefitted in the SADH SANGAT....AND " ALL " acted ARROGANTLY...BEING FULL of EVIL PROPENSITIES. Can anyone tell me the words "NONE", "ALL", "NOBODY" refers to whom?? WHO are the people in the LIST compiled by Bhai Gurdass Ji ?? "PROPHETS", "GODS", "KINGS", "DEVTAS" ???? WHO is in the LIST and which ONE in this LIST is NOT APPLICABLE to the Most Important sentence ?? Does any line specifically Say: Look here ...Ram chander... ( OR any of the names MENTIONED in the LIST in the Shabad)... was not LUSTY, GRREDY, EGOISTIC...not ARROGANT...Does Bhai gurdass Ji say Ram Chander ...etc...etc...etc.. ( any of them in the list)...BENEFITTED from SADH SANGAT...NO it DOEST SAY THIS ANYWHERE???? Everything is so crystal clear....and yet we continue to indulge in this "respect" respect respect scenario...actually none of thsi affects us at all as we are to BELIEVE in only GURU NANAK JYOT. Doesnt GURU GOBIND SINGH JI tell us in no uncertain terms: RAAM RAHIM Puran Koran ANEK kahehn...MATT ek NA MANIYON....Simrit SASTAR BED SABHEH bhuh bhed kahen hum EK nah JANIYOHN The CENTRAL WORD in Guru ji's slok above is "MATT" which is a STRONGEST WORD to SAY "NO"..like in Uthe MATT JAIYO....that is DONT GO there under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES... When GURU JI Himself is Saying in such a STRONG WORD as MATT MANIYON in RAAm RAHIm, Puran Kuran, Simrtee, SHASTAR, VEDAS etc etc...Why do we Find it SO DIFFICULT to let go of this "hindu/Muslim/anmatti baggage" DO we Find our GURUS Sahibaans so WANTING that they cannot FULFILL US...cannot SATISFY US enough that we have to go Maar our Face in other's KHURLEEAAN ?? This is the attitude why we have the MOST APOLOGISTS in our religion... IF a Muslim speaker comes on the air (TV radio) he will begin by saying: KORAN COMMANDS US..Prophet Mohhammed ORDERS US...become a MUSLIM and be SAVED...blah blah blah... Same for a Christian..etc. But when a SIKH speaker is given a "rare" chance to speak about sikhi for FIVE MINUTES....he will spend FOUR and a HALF minutes talking about " ALL religions lead to God, we all beleive in the SAME GOD, blah blah blah ..and when the signal is given to wind up and stop talking.... then in a low apologetic voice the speaker will mumble a few words about what GURU NANAK/GURU GOBIND SINGH/GURU GRANTH says....and it is time's UP... Good heavens JI IF All religions lead to GOD and is the SAME GOD..why did GURU NANAK come and why did the GURUS write GURBANI/Spread GURMATT over 250 YEARS ???..GURU NANAK spent years walking thousands of MILES...to MECCA that ISLAM is the SAME as GURMATT ?? Did GURU NANAK go to Hardwaar to tell the Hindus that the 33 Kror DEVTAS are the SAME as WAHEGURU ??... YES Gurbani does tell the Hindu to be a GOOD HINDU, same for the Muslim...BUT GURBANI doesnt say" A HINDU/MUSLIM/ is the SAME as a SIKH.....so you can CHOOSE to be what you want ?? IF this WAs so why did HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of SIKHS prefer the most horrible DEATHS rather than CONVERT to ISLAM ?? Doesnt Islam also mean WAHEGURU and same as Sikhi ?? DIDNT those SIKH MARTYRS "know" this ??? or didnt they know Waheguru was the SAME as the 33 kror devtas and so they could have SAVED their LIFE by just saying we are NOT SIKH but HINDUS. Seven Year old HARKIRAT SINGH who was arrested with baba banda Singh Bahadur Singh ji's forces, ....his mother had gone to Emperor Farkhsiyar and begged him to release her son who was still a child and told the emperor that eh was a HINDU and not a SIKH.... when this mother came to the place where the SINGHS were being Shaheed..and it was Harkirat's turn to get his head chopped off...the mother ran and gave the letter of AMNESTY she had got from the Emperor to the Mughal officer and he read it and said to harkirat ..YOU CAN GO HOME because you are NOT a SIKH. Harkirat saw "shahedee" slipping from his grasp...and he was so angry at his mother for this...He ran to the Jalaad and stood on his TOES to make up height and said: I am a SIKH, not a HINDU and this woman is NOT MY MOTHER. Please send me after the Shaheed Singhs...please hurry as my time is slipping by.... the Jalaad swung his sword and Harkirat was in the Shaheed Singh's company... a SEVEN YEAR OLD knows that Sikhi/Gurmatt is DIFFERENT from HINDU/gods/devtas/purans/veds/raam/krishan/ whatevcer....but we DONT...??? what a shame. KHALSA JI sorry for this long "TIRADE".... some of you may be annoyed ( some very seriously ANNOYED like P. Singh above)..BUT SIKHI/GURMATT is SIKHI and UNIQUE..VERY VERY INIQUE - in fact the ONLY One of its kIND in the world... And if we READ Bhai gurdassji, GURU GOBIND SINGH JI, GURBANI very carefully we will arrive at this CONCLUSION. There is NO ther conclusion....you can twist and turn to find such "other conclusions" but you are only kidding yourself. P. Singh Ji and others like minded singh jis,...read Bhai GURDASS JI above shabad and then decide if the persons mentioned are..ORDINARY men who get lusty, angry, greedy, kaami, krodhi, egotistical....or are they EXCEPTIONAL ones as you beleive. Please provide any GURBANI tuks that say these people mentioned by Bhai gurdass Ji are EXCEPTIONAL ones that deserve our utmost respect on par with our GURUS. THis may be true for a HINDU ( and I will DEFEND his RIGHT to that beleif with my life just as MY Beloved GURU TEG BAHADUR JI did)...BUT I will NOT beleive in them for any reason whatever..... NO APOLOGIES for the beleifs above. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 17 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh Ji, First of all I didn't read your long winded post, I just breifly skimmed through it. Anyways I did not put anyone on par with the Gurus, all I am saying Ram, Krishan are no ordinary Joes. It is views like this that are getting people on other forums annoyed enough to call this forum taliban.org, I don't agree with their assessment but you get the idea. Love and Light to all.

Re: hindu gods

D Singh · 17 Nov 2004

Gyani Ji is absolutely correct. It is easy for those who have not researched Gurbani thoroughly to read a few Shabads and get the wrong end of the stick. I'm not saying that is what people here are doing, but generally this does occur. I believe that: 1. Gurbani does not say whether Krishna etc existed, but does refer to people's belief in such charachters. 2. Even some Hindus say that Krishna never actually existed, he's only meant to be a mythological charchter etc, hence why squabbling over Ayodhia is meaningless. 3. Vishnu and various other multi-armed, multi-headed deities are most likely to be mythological charachters. When Guru Ji refers to them, He is refrring to the belief in such dieties that people have. Thsi is clear as any reference to such dieties in a Shabad always end with a higher lesson to take away. 4. To say that all paths lead to God is a complete misinterpretation of Gurbani. Gurbani very clearly states that without Satguru Ji, nobody has EVER reached God, nor can they. 5. Guru Sahib respected the right of others to follow whichever path they saw fit, but those unto whom Guru Sahib was merciful were fortunate enought o become Gursikhs and thereby reach God.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 17 Nov 2004

D Singh you are absolutely wrong in my opinion regarding the existence of Ram and Krishna. Of course they existed it is just that you are in denial since you don't want to deal with anything related to hinduness. I was like this too for many years. There is NOTHING in Gurbani that says anything about Krishna or Ram being mythological. Anyways believe what you want to believe.

Re: hindu gods

mANJIT KAUR · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. A very big Thank You to Veer D Singh Ji above for summarising it all so well...short and sweet. IF due to these Five points some would like to call this Forum Taliban.Org....that is their LOSS. So far as I have noticed from the posts, the vast majortiy of members here are genuine "SIKHS" that is genuinely want to LEARN, Never try to IMPOSE their views on others through the "Main Na Manoo tantrums"..oR simply because sant ji said so and so must be correct. I am a member of so many forums and so many mailing lists...I can vouch that this forum is the most liberal in accepting divergent views..BUT draws the line at GURU SAHIBAANS, GURBANI and GURMATT. Obviously we cannot and should not compromise on these three at any cost..IF we start to beleive ALL Paths lead to GOD and it is the SAME GOD...then we are on the wrong path. Gurmatt, Gurbani and Waheguru are NOT the GOD of the others...those Gods/gods are different. Just look at USA and IRAQ....BOTH say they Beleive in GOD and In GOD we TRUST... is it the SAME GOD for both sides ?? The Same GOD that sides BUSH and the one that BEHEADS INNOCENT HOSTAGES !!! IF the "GOD" of 2 Billion people is NOT the SAME....what about all the other paths that lead to "god" ? SO to all those who genuinely want to learn and benefit from Valuable input on Gurbani/Gurmatt....stay on this forum..those that want to beleive in EVERYONE else is the SAME..carry on...Taliban.Org or not such name calling never hurt anyone.( just to set the record straight the talibans destroyed the Buddhist monuments...what has anyone on this Forum ever destroyed to deserve such a name. All some veers and bhens have emphasised is MORE banis, more rehat, sarbloh/bibek etc which is MORE than the SRM..a bit more stricter perhaps but since when is being more dangerous..I always thought those who "slack" are the ones likely to drop out... Manit Kaur

Re: hindu gods

_____ · 18 Nov 2004

what i do understand is since the shabad was posted most points it stated were agreed upon but nobody seemed to mention the bit where bhai gurdas ji said "mashh kashh vairaah roop nar si(n)gh hoe baavan ba(n)dhhaarae|| The incarnations in the forms of fish, tortoise, swine, man-lion, dwarf and Buddha etc. have happened." thats all my point was, if bhai gurdas ji said that then they must have existed, or am i wrong here? Nobody is saying go worship them, gurbani only teaches worship of naam.

Re: hindu gods

Jasvir kaur Thind · 18 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Well said bhen ji manjit. WHY for heaven's sake should we be in "DENIAL" mode. The issue is simple and straightforward.... OUR ONE and ONLY GURU is GURBANI and the One and ONLY Path is GURMATT and One and ONLY NIshaana is WAHEGURU.. Raams and krishans are "dead ends"...splinter paths that began long ago and ended up not leading anywhere... "signposts" along the highway tell us they exist ( that is why gurbani "mentions" them ) BUT anyone with an iota of common sense will realise GURBANI is clearly telling us..THESE PATHS are Paggdandian and LEAD NO WHERE.... Raam Chander came along....and he began a "path"...but it leads to wilderness as HE Himslef failed to conquer His LUST/GREED/KRODH/LOBH/MOH/HANKAAR...only a TRULY BLIND PERSON will "follow" such a failed leader !! SAME story for Krishan/Vishnu/Brahma/ShivJi/Durga/whatever...NONE is TRUE LEADER that will lead you to WAHEGURU. Read Bhai Gurdass Ji's TESTIMONY that NONE of these Reached anywhere even "NEAR" WAHEGURU. WHY stop at these.... dont tell me you havent heard or read about Abraham/Moses/Elijjah/Zoroaster/buddha/Jesus/....a THOUSAND and ONE...others. They all existed and started PATHS..... IF I am in LONDON and I want to proceed to GLASGOW... I will take the One HIGHWAY that leads there....WHY would I bother about the Path or even "highway" from Delhi to Bombay ?? NO doubt this delhi-bombay highway EXISTS...and is MENTIONED in all geography books etc...BUT why Should I BOTHER is the 64 million dllar question....ESPECIALLY when the MAP BOOK specifically says: the Delhi-Bombay Highway DOESNT LEAD to GLASGOW. Thank You. jasvir _ Traveller on the SUPER HIGHWAY to WAHEGURU - GURMATT.

Re: hindu gods

inside out · 18 Nov 2004

I feel sick reading some posts..how can be so close-minded? Our path is of universal gurmat (the path of light)..embrace all around you, because EVERYTHING is a source of the divine.. To say that Ram/Krishna or even Buddha/Jesus are dead-end paths is very insulting, these are all gifts from your divine..Such behaviours will put insecurity in your 'path'..of course people relate this website to taliban..One thing I know for sure that this is NOT Sikhi..Denying the existance or even discounting these 'gems' will not make the light brighter, you NEED these *hindu* gods as you call it for your path.. ..Jai Shri Krishna..Jai Shri Krishna..Jai Jai Jai..

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 18 Nov 2004

inside out, I don't agree with your saying "you NEED these *hindu* gods as you call it for your path.." Sikhs only need Guru ji but you are right about the close mindedness in here and the intolerance for other people's viewpoints.

Re: hindu gods

very sure · 18 Nov 2004

i think one person with 3 different names using the same style of writing to convince others of his her point is responsible for this atmosphere via taking advantage of genuine queries raised by gursikhs. It seems that person is trying to build influence but if only that person was to see gursikhs arent easily fooled. we do not need self appointed interpreters we need only delve into Gurbani ourselves thats where all our answers lie. talk to gursikhs with rehet nam abhyas that u know, panj pyarey who are there for us.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 18 Nov 2004

very sure, I think you are directing your post at me since I don't see who you else it could be. Well first off ask the Admin if the IP addresses match, no need for your paranoia. I'm sorry that you feel your security blanket here on tapoban.org is threatened. I have no need to hide my identity, I post on SikhAwareness and SikhSangat as well.

Re: hindu gods

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 19 Nov 2004

in my experiences i have learned that all hindu gods and goddesses, avtars and sur, nar, mun, jan - all the greek gods and goddesses, all of the aboriginal and native spirits and souls, all of the wiccan fairies and ghosts all of them do in fact exist, but their powers are very limited compared to the power of a gursikh whereas those creatures have ridhia sidhia, humans have naam whereas those creatures top mission is to reach human life humans top mission is to reach the charan of guru jee all of these creatures are the dust under the feet of guru gobind singh jee guru gobind singh jee is the master of all these creatures, and they follow his order it says so in bhai nand lal jee's vaars.

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 19 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I second "very sure". ALL the "influence" we need is in ourselves..this is the 21st Century and none is easily "fooled"..although it is also a fact that a "fool" is born every minute. The STARS have their own LIGHT...the "MOONS" shine bright on "BORROWED" light...what we have to do is distinguish betweeen the two. Not every "MOON" is a STAR..although it may look brighter !! and there are many self appointed "moons"..but just be careful we dont blame the moons for our own failings...remember the Rishi who threw his wet towel at the "moon" for failing to Save His wife from Shivji.... Guru Gobind Singh Ji started the PANJ PIYARAE for this Very Reason - they are there for us to ask, consult, and fall back on in times of need. The Panj are always of "high moral character", have naam abhiyaas and most importantly when they are the PANJ - they are not merely humans they are GURU Roop. Dassan dass jarnail Singh

Re: hindu gods

Balpreet Singh · 19 Nov 2004

I believe that Hindu gods ie. devtas and devis do indeed exist. I don't think they are any further than Giaan Khand though. Raam and Krishna were probably very special people that came to this earth. But I don't think there has been any higher being than Satguru Nanak. The Devis and Devtas all thirst for the opportunity to receive naam from Satguru Nanak. The following story which was posted on this site quite some time ago clarifies this issue quite a bit (please do read it): _________________ A memorable story from the 1975 Dussehra Smaagam in Delhi, that came before the assembled sangat: A resident of Madras was a devotee of the Devi (Goddess). From his childhood according to his family traditions, he had always worshiped the Devi. The Devi became pleased at this loving devotion and worship and then gave him her Darshan (vision) not once but on many occasions. The devotee in his mind was very happy that his worship was successful and the Devi also provided him guidance in all his worldly works. She would stop him from doing any unsuccessful worldly business and guide him towards success. Quite a while passed in this state and the devotee asked the goddess to grant him liberation from the cycle of births and deaths. The Devi replied "This is not in my control." Hearing this, the devotee became disappointed. What did he know that "Deviaa(n) nahee jaanai marm. Sabh oopar alukh paarbrahm" (p. 894) The devotee then said to the Devi, "Where can I find liberation then?" The Devi replied, "When you transfer form this place to another, someone there will give you the lead in this regard. By listening to his instructions you will get what you want. You will also have to change your religion." After some time, the devotee was transferred to Vijiaavaadaa City and upon arriving there, he became eager to know who would lead him, as had been prophesied. One day, a very special Sikh (Heeraa/diamond) of Guru Dashmeesh Jee was doing nitnem. When the BaaNee entered the ears of this Madrasi brother, he felt as if a light current of electricity had passed through his body. He thought to himself, "This has never happened to me before? What has happened here? Is it possible that this Sardar is to be my leader?" He had this thought in his heart when he went to the Singh and asked "Forgive me, what are you reciting? This has given me a buzz through my entire body." The Singh then explained that he was reading the BaaNee of Guru Nanak Dev jee. The Madrasi brother told the Singh about his experience with the Devi and asked "Can you lead me to the path of liberation?" The Singh replied "You've come to the right place. Liberation (Muktee) can only come from Guru Nanak Saahib. For this, you will have to receive amrit with your wife and become a Singh. By the time the Amrit Sinchaar time comes, prepare yourself by learning Gurmukhee and reading BaaNee" This was all the Madrasi had been waiting for and he along with his wife began to learn Gurmukhi and in days began to do Nitnem. Such a colour coloured him that soon he brought home Sree Guru Granth Saahib. The divnely coloured couple even unfurled the Khalsa's Nishaan Saahib over their home and eagerly began to await Delhi's Dussehra Smaagam. By the time Dussehra Smaagam arrived the devotee's wife became a daily reciter of Sukhmani Saahib. Waiting, finally Dussehra arrived. The couple along with their two children arrived in Delhi. Doing Gur Gur, this couple was initiated and became the True Guru's naam abhyaasee Khalsas. Upon receiving the Gurmantar, the khanda of naam began to go by itself. Facing the Guru, he with his own eyes saw the Satguru and was fulfilled for life. "Bhoola Maarag so pvai jis dhur mastak laykhang. Tin janm svaariaa aapNaa jin gur akhee(n) daykhang." (p. 1099). After all this, the Singh had a thought in his mind, "What a broken and twisted method the Devi used to lead her devotee! Why didn't she just say 'you will get liberation from the door of Guru Nanak?" This actually is a very big revelation for us: Guru Nanak's name, or God's Naam, or GurbaaNee, or any words/Shabads uttered from the mouths of the Satgurus can only be uttered in Human life form, not after leaving the Human form. Forget meditating on Naam, gods and goddesses, devis and devtas, cannot even say the name of the Satgurus from their mouths. In such a helpless state, what liberation/muktee can they give to anyone? In his own words, Satguru Sachay Paatshaah who is the Master of Muktee in this era "Mukat Data Satgur joug maahi" asks the Devi: "Too(n) kaheeat hee aad bhavaanee. Mukat kee bareeaa kahaa(n) chhapaanee" (874) Then, we who are in the Human life form should consider ourselves very lucky that we have come to understand that liberation/muktee can only come form the door of Guru Nanak. There is no guarantee on life: "Hum aadmee haa(n) ik damee mouhlat mouhat na jaaNaa" (660) Then we should not delay at all. We should go for Amrit and become complete Singhs and then meditate endlessly on Naam, recite BaaNee and then we should achieve what we have taken human life for and return with a glowing face to the court of God. We should become free from births and deaths and "Tin janm svaariaa aapNaa jin gur akhee(n) daykhang" should be our spiritual state. Otherwise, let it not be that we regret that our short lives have come to an end and we have found ourselves in the situation "RaN vihaaNee pachhtaaNee ouTH chalee gaiee niraas" (134). NOTE: This Singh was a Telegu speaker and dedicated servant of the Goddess. He was peshed in the 1975 Dussehraa Smaagam and received amrit with his family. He was named Bhai Bhajan Singh and his wife was named Bibi Amar Kaur. When they received amrit, it was an amazing sight. On January 27, 1989, Bhai Bhajan Singh returned to the feet of the Guru. The blood-family of these Gursikhs have cut themselves off from them, knowing them to be Sikhs. The family lives in a rented home but they keep Satguru jee in their home with the utmost respect. The couple, alone, would do RaN Sabaaees. They would not drink so much as a sip of water from their relatives' or friends' homes. They were dealing with a situation where their entire worldly family was on one side and their faith on the other. And then fate struck. May Guru jee keep this family steadfast even after the deadly blow of the loss of the father. These poor people have no other support but the Guru and other Sikhs. There are four children. The elder son and daughter were in the 9th grade and the younger in the 5th when this happened. The mother feels sad sometimes, but the children say "Guru Granth Saahib jee is our Baba jee and Father: Mother, don't worry!" The family is receiving some pension from the Military and the AKJ also has begun to send some monthly assistance. Satguru jee himself is the sustainer of his children.

Re: hindu gods

very sure · 19 Nov 2004

p singh bhai sahib as a fellow sikh brother mark my words i never meant you. The person i meant know exactly who he she is, their wordings, use of grammer, and putting down others are very obvious under 3 different accounts.

Re: hindu gods

jss · 19 Nov 2004

P singh ji..i think you jumped the gun... i have been reading these posts...and it certanily isn't you who "very sure" could have been alluding to.... if i were to guess...it would be the giyani whose been trying to put you and everyone else who doesn't have the same tunnel vision as he does down...

Re: hindu gods

just thinking · 19 Nov 2004

I was just thinking does it really matter whether they existed or not? To me not really...

Re: hindu gods

O! · 19 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh Gyani, >>Guru Gobind Singh Ji started the PANJ PIYARAE for this Very Reason - they are there for us to ask, consult, and fall back on in times of need. The Panj are always of "high moral character", have naam abhiyaas and most importantly when they are the PANJ - they are not merely humans they are GURU Roop.>> Your points do not back up..you have failed to make a connection in your post..Guroo Maharaj did not 'start' the Panj Pyarey for 'this very reason'..Yes, they are here for us to ask, consult and fall back on in times of need. Yes, they are of high moral character, etc etc..but what relation does this have to do with Hindu Gods? No one is implying that you should 'fall back' on `Hindu Gods`, but to understand and appreciate the existence of all these different creations of Akal Purakh is key to the path of Gur-MAT! They are not an `influence` or a 'borrowed light' as you say..Just like reading a few sentences will not give you the full scope of a subject, understand the connections and depths..Gurmat is endless..

Re: hindu gods

Singh · 19 Nov 2004

I think the best stance is simple. These entities do/did exist. Or one may argue they were simply used in Gurbani because people of the time new of them. Eigther way, one thing is crystal clear no gods, Ram Chander, Krishna is to be worshiped, as Gurbani itself makes it clear that they are not on the level of Akal Purkh and are infact shown as entities pulled and attacked by emotions and death like everyone else. Hence they exist or existed but are still subject to death etc and are not worthy or worship. Just like a lion exists and has power it does not mean me worship it, as its also under the threat of death like all other creatures. People can respect whomever they want, but Gurbani does not show any special respect to these “hindu gods”, although they are mentioned as existing. Its as simple as that. I know Moses existed and respect some of his teachings, but just because he's mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji it does not mean Guru Ji is worshipping him in any way. I don't think anyone is ignorantly argueing that Guru Sahib reveals one higher being as prescribed in the mool mantra, jaap sahib and through out Guru Granth Sahib Ji and than contradicts this fundamental concept of Gurmat by worshipiing people and other creatures. I think the issue got confused half way through, perhaps "Singhnee" who started the thread should read more Gurbani for herself without relying on others to tell her what's what in Sikhi.

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 19 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The Panj Piyarae are more than just to Give us Khande Batte De Pahul and initiate us into Gursikhi/Gurmatt/Amrtidharees.... they are always there for consultation interms of doubts we may have, to hold our hand in case we falter along the path....etc etc. Their "role" doesnt end when we exit the Amrti sanchaar... I still take the opportunity whenever it is presented to ask Gurmukhs who have performed this sewa for gurmatt advice...more so the younger generation who just took Amrit should clear their doubts with such real experts rather than listen to half baked "experts". I was under the impression that "consipiracy theories" only existed on subjects like the death of Arafat, Assasination of JF Kennedy, assasination of Indira Gandhi , death of Shastri PM of India in Tashkent.... The veer named Singh has presented the closing argument. Please read his remarks carefully ( DONT accuse him of being me/she/shemale/female/rss/cia/fbi/whatever out to get you ( nameless jss etc). Existed/not existed/myth/fact.... doesnt matter as GURMATT is the ONLy thing that matters. GURBANI says that many hundreds of times. Note: I write on my own, under my registered address and for anyone to see...no aliases/hidden names/anonymous js or jss or jsss. This nonsense has been suggested before by these same people.Just give your arguments and let the readers decide. I DONT and Never have bothered about "people"....only IDEAS matter to me. I am also here to LEARN...but not to be brainwashed/browbeaten by ignorance...and I am not at all shy to admit that some posters who are obviously much younger than me have TAUGHT me some very valuable things..they have Guru Ji's Kirpa on them. I am here to STAY...no matter what conspiracy theories sprout up... Dassan dass jarnail Singh.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 19 Nov 2004

Thanks to very sure and jss, As long as there are seekers of truth there will be love and light. I was beginning to think that many posters here have the same "tunnel vision" and intolerance to anyone who does not share the same views, thanks for opening my eyes. The truth will set us all free!

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 19 Nov 2004

I hope it isn't against forum rules to post links to other message boards. I visit all the forums and am grateful for what I learned from other Sikhs on this forum and other forums in the last year and half. We were discussing Krishna on another forum, check it out: http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/community/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=7310&t=7310

Re: hindu gods

S.B.S · 20 Nov 2004

Naina Devi does SEWA in Harmandir Sahib EVERYDAY and make some point from there and then distribute among her followers!! Heard in a Katha by Giani Takhur Singh (Patiala, Student of D.D.T)

Re: hindu gods

ms · 20 Nov 2004

we are to believe that they did exist but that our waheguru who created and will destroy us also created and destroyed them

Re: hindu gods

ManjitKaur · 21 Nov 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Naina Devi as MAID in Harimandiir ?? has anyone seen a devi ?? Does Giani Thakur singh of Damdami taksaal actually SEEN a DEVI/DEVTA or is just a tall tale ?? Can anyone post a PHOTOGRAPH of this DEVI doing sewa ?? This tale is related in some Janam Sakhis...about the DEVI doing SEWA of JHARROO BARDAR in GURU Nanak's Darbar...the SAME DEVI that Bhai lehana Ji used to WORSHIP .... And anyone can tell me why ONLY in harimandir ?? Any other Gurdwara not the same ?? How do the HINDUS like it when we MAKE their DEVTAS/GODS do SWEEPER WORK in our GURDWARAS...Happy ?? I dont think so. Second question: What did the Fish/Tortoise/Crocodile Avtaars of VISHNU do ?? Did they TALK human language ?? Did they SAVE humans and give MUktee ?? Or what ? What was the purpose of ANIMAL AVTAARS.. to give muktee to ANIMALS ?? Please gvie any type of explanations ?? Seems to be copy of the CHINESE ANIMALS story of the New Year cycle of 12 animals etc etc...where each new year is dedicated too one animal. Flabbergasted Manjit kaur

Re: hindu gods

? · 21 Nov 2004

whos naina devi?

Re: hindu gods

JSS · 21 Nov 2004

I think giyani jee needs to relax.... I NEVER once accused anyone of being rss or any other stuff....There's no need to drag my name into this.... all i did was clarify Very Sure's post to P singh veerji... it looks like you're seeing things on the screen that just aren't there....i'd get that checked out if i were you... and for the matter...you are a smart guy...who has a lot of knowledge..BUT when people disagree with you...there's no need to put them down for it... i konw you say.."i don't care about people"....but guess what...God cares about people...he cares about how his children are treated....and if you can't treat god's children respectfully and with love...well then...i don't know what all that "gurmat" is gonna do for ya

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 21 Nov 2004

Kulbir Singh, would you like to add to this thread? All I was saying is do not belittle other religons and their messengers since everything has a part in this world drama but Gyani ji is too busy trying to prove that not only was Krishna nothing but an average joe but (in a more recent thread) he was also a Havaan full of lust.

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear JSS veer ji, sorry if i offended you in any way. I will take your advice about Gods children. I have dealt with many Thousands of Gods children by now...after a life time of teaching ( still do )...but guess what....some things can still be learnt...and thats why we are called sikhs...so OK your point taken. My words " I dont care about people" is meant to say that on Gods Path I dont care what people say to stop me...Nindo logo mujhko nindo...or "let people call me mad / whatever but i will continue His Bhagtee !! BUt in another way if a Gods child is hungry or wet..i WILL "CARE" by feeding him/ giving him dry clothes...IF a Gods child is seeking gurmatt... I will CARE by imparting what little i know of gurmatt...BUT if any "god''s child" says" Look at that mad gyani sweeping the langgar floor...I WILL NOT CARE one little bit.... P singh veer ji, I am NOT into belitteling other peoples religions/prophets/gods/devis. What is the use of that ?? I am not looking for a fight with anybody by calling his prophet bad/ whatever..why should I ?? hinduaan nu krishan ji mubarak... I "respect" a Hindus right but thats about it. BUT have you read the HINDU SCRIPTURES about Bhagawaan KRISHAN ?? have you seen the LEELAS of Krishan shown on DOORDARSHAN TV mahabharta SERIAL. I have seen many many serials shown on satellite TV that show all this LUST not only in Krishan but Raam Chander..as well. I ahve STOPPED my children from watching these serails from India as they are a bad influence on MORALS.... DO you know who makes these serails ?? HINDUS in HINDU RULED INDIA. What does that tell you ?? IS GURBANI TELLING A LIE ( aang 470) Am I misinterpreting this TUK that Krishan forcefully took advantage of a lady NOT his wife. ( shucks it is WRONG to take advantage of YOUR OWN WIFE also!!! as wives also have rights) Do you know where it is written that Krishan Ji had THOUSANDS of WIVES and THOUSANDS of children....its not a fairy tale book or fiction created by me....IT is in HINDU SCRIPTURES. RADHA was a MISTRESS and not a wife...yet she is the most famous..as in RADHA-KRISHAN !!! I am not into those who Bend over backwards to "connect" with Krishsn, raam Chander just to be prohindu.... Krishan ji has his place but not in my book. Sorry to offend you in this regard..but the TRUTH cannot be hidden. jarnail singh

Re: hindu gods

A Singh · 22 Nov 2004

OK let's take a step back here. The so called 'Hindu' gods can be viewed in many ways and to say that as Sikhs we do not need to "know" about them is a little misguided. We certainly do not worship them as we are firmly Nirankar-Pujaris (worshippers of Nirkankar-Akal-Purakh), however given the mention of these various gods in our scriptures and texts it is worth understanding their significance. Likewise, it is important for Sikhs to "understand" both the Semetic and Aryan traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam and Shivites, Vashvaites, Buddhists, Jains, Tantriks etc), for we are indeed the 'theesra mazrab Khalsa UPJEEO PARDHANA" -to be pardhan, i.e. leader, overseer etc, one must understand those upon whom they wish to lead. The attitude towards other faiths I see on this forum is at times no different from that of Nazi Dictators. This is one point. Now to actually consider the 'Hindu' gods, let's consider the following. There is a well known Punjabi saying that 'Sikha kol itihas, Hindu kol mithias' (i.e. Sikhs have history and Hindus have mythology). Let us understand the role of mythology in traditions across the world and what relevance they have for us as Sikhs. Most myths have their root in a single or mixed historical character, however the actual purport of a Myth is not its historical accuracy or reasoning but its emotional content. Many of the obsure visions created by myths are simply there to either make the reader think beyond what is being read or as part of the well known Guru-Chela relationship to ensure its maintanence (i.e. certain aspects of tradition and 'mat' cannot be simply written down, they need thorough investigation and analysis through a learned Ustad). If we view the Hindu Gods in historical light, we never understand their full meaning and just the same if we push them aside as mere fairy tales, this backdrop is ignored and missed. In most instances, these Gods, particularly when I've heard them explained in a Sikh context and in some cases studied their analysis under Tantrik texts are actually personifications given to certain states of Sargun Nirankar. As we are all familiar:- Brahma -Creative = Rajo Gun Vishnu -Preservation = Sato Gun Shiva -Destructive = Tamo Gun Now I'm certain we've all experienced these forces in our daily lives, sometimes in extremes -hence this is one way of understanding why they have been termed 'gods'. Gurbani clearly states that these are all part of the Sargun manifestion and maya, we are as gursikhs, to transcend all of the guns, including Satogun (i.e. go beyond what many Sikhs preach and stop at today -wearing white, vegetarian, pure, clean, honest etc), hence why these 'gods' are not to be worshipped. This is a basic outlook, which we can see increase in complexity as the number of demi-gods and goddeses increase. The compositions of Guru Gobind Singh, particularly Chandi-di-Var relate Chandi in a similar manner through symbolic analogies. To understand these works we need to understand what these 'gods' really are and not simply label them aside for bashing purposes -otherwise, we don't we all join the Kala Afghana crew.

Re: hindu gods

Singh · 22 Nov 2004

P Singh I checked out the thread where you are discussing Krishna. However for some reasion I cannot post, so here's my responce to the misguilded person who thinks Ram Chander is God; "* belief in dasam granth ji ( which states ramayan and mahabharat , in one part it even says ram was god.)" The above is completely incorrect. In-fact numerous shabads in Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Dasm Granth show Ram Chander to be a human being; as per the below. 1. Nanak Nirbhau Nirankaar..HOR KETEH RAAM RAVAAL...AAng 464 2.Pandeh tumra RAAM CHAND...so bhee avat dekhiya tha.. Ang 875 3.ROVEH RAAM nikala bhiyah..Ang 953 4. Man meh JHURREH RAAM CHAND... ang 1412 5. Raam JHURREH dil malveh.... aang 1412 6.Raam gayio raavan gaiyo jakohn bahu parwaar..aang 1428 The same applies to Krishna Ji. God himself is proscribed in the very first teachings of Guru Sahib as being beyound births & death, ie the Mool Mantra, Jaap Sahib etc. This is a basic concept of Sikhi. A few shabads may talk of God inside Ram Chander, just like Gods is inside me and you, and all creation. Guru Sahib even talks of God being inside water, the fish and even the net. Guru Ji even talks of God being inside the milkmaids as well as Krishna. In-fact God is inside and looks beautiful in all creation. This is where some people with little insight into Guru Granth Sahib mistakenly think Guru Sahib is saying Ram Chander was God, as per the above incorrect quote. Likewise Guru Sahib in few cases talks of Ram Chander etc from a story perspective in order to give a wider teaching or feeling. However people mis-read these and ignorantly think Guru Ji is contradicting his own basic Gurmat by worshipping others who are not beyond births and death and the description in the Mool Mantra and varies other parts. Ram Chand, Krishna etc were heroic people, and inside them was God just like in all creation, but according to Gurbani they could not have been God specially incarnated and taken birth on Earth. "I do not accept Ganesha as important. I do not meditate on Krishna, neither on Vishnu. I do not hear them and do not recognize them. My love is with the Lotus feet of God. He is my protector, the Supreme Lord. I am dust of his Lotus feet." Guru Gobind Singh Ji. "Even Krishna and Balbhadar meditated on the Lord, falling at the Guru's Feet." (Page 165)

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 22 Nov 2004

Singh, I do not know what your post has to do with me, I never said Ram or Krishna was God almighty. I did say they were no ordinary joes and you agree with me, so its all good. All our Gurus took birth to show us the way. They showed us the way is not to worship Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva, Krishna or Ram etc. They told us that there are millions of these beings or dieties, they are all part of creation, they are created and destroyed. They showed us the only way to merge with God is to worship the Divine Formless Infinite Creator. The only problem I have is the lack of tolerance here on this forum by some. If you were incarnated as a Jain, how much choice do you really have? Why put down other people? Its quite hurtful.

Re: hindu gods

P Singh · 22 Nov 2004

Singh, I will post your response to the misguilded person who thinks Ram Chander is God on that particular forum. thnaks for your posts, they make a whole lot of sense.

Re: hindu gods

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. dear P Singh Ji, I just cannot understand you. In GURBANI it is stated that BOTH USTATT (PRAISE) and NINDIYA are BAD and a GURMUKH shoudlnt do either. So we as gurmukhs neither "praise" nor "put down" other people's gods/devtas/devis.. to us OURS and to them THEIRS..MUBARAK. PERIOD. In Wadhans rag or Sorath ( off hand i forget wchich) Aangs around 600++ Guru Ji says clearly: DEVI and DEVas are NOT to be POOJAED..as that is like CHURNING WATER..a USELESS ACTION. CHURN the DAHIN or MILK of NAAM for the purpose of geting butter. That said i think we can let go off these hindu gods...enough has been said for now..dont you agree...LIFE is too short to waste on such frivilous things .. NAAM awaits... Lets churn MILK. Dass Jarnal singh.