Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Women and Kirtan Seva

Sikh Women and Kirtan Seva

Gurpreet Kaur · 25 May 2003

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh! Dear Sadh Sangat jee, I am writing about the issue of women NOT allowed to do Keertan sewa in the Harminder Sahib. I fail to understand the issue here, and whether this should even be an issue? Equality of both genders in all respects is a integral part of Sikhi, this is what I have gathered. It's very confusing as to why Amritdhari Sikh sisters cannot do Keertan at Darbar Sahib. I don't wish to be insulting, but most Raagis nowadays seem to opt for this 'profession' for the sole reason of financial gain, or to go abroad, the quality of the Keertan is important and lacking, I think our Guru Jee's composed the Bani in Raags as a way of conveying their message in a way we can understand, and music is universal, you don't have to be an expert to enjoy it, however, as it is in Classical Raags, shouldn't the Raagis have some sort of training in this great art beforehand? I remember hearing keertan when I was 14 or so and thinking, where is the love and devotion?, there are many great Raagis, who adhere fully to our Keertan tradition, but I think maybe there should be more of them, as youngsters are losing interest because of the quality, in terms of music. Also, if Guru jee didn't intend this to be important, then why is the Bani composed in such beautiful Classical Raags? Guru Jee has blessed me with whatever little knowledge I have of Keertan, but I don't see why we can't also participate in the Keertan Sewa at Darbar Sahib. Bhul chuk dee khima! Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Ki fateh!

Re: Sikh Women and Kirtan Seva

Undergroundsikhi · 28 May 2003

Baba Nihal Singh, Horshipur lived up to his name 1980 With the protection of Baba Nihal Singh, Krishan Kaur Khalsa was the first woman to perform kirtan, in recent time, within the confines of Sri Harimandir Sahib. Vikram Singh Khalsa was performing kirtan on the Gurupurab for the birthday for Guru Ram Das Ji. This kirtan was for a Bhog on the roof of the Harimandir Sahib -- not in the main hall. When he finished, he motioned for Krishna Kaur Khalsa to play. As she began some SGPC sevadars moved to stop her but Baba Nihal Singh and some other Nihungs stood in their way and protected her right to perform kirtan within the confines of the Harimandir Sahib. Still no Sikh woman has performed kirtan in the main darbar. In 1979, Sikhs of American descent performed Kirtan in Darbar Sahib for the very first time while observing Guru Ram Das's Prakash Utsav. Sardar Vikram Singh Khalsa, Ajeet Singh Khalsa, and Guru Sangat Singh Khalsa performed kirtan in the main darbar. http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/history/his0826.htm 1984: Baba Nihal Singh was Right Hand Man of Sant Jarnail Singh, and had many gevious with the Indian Army's and Politians One Story i heard was that they; raided the camp and caught Baba Ji and his Singhs, and tied him upto a jeep and dragged him around the villages on a rope,tearing his skin apart and painstakenly broke his arms and legs. They tied his beard up with his "nala" from his kachera and beat him continuously. But baba ji , nver gave up.

Re: Sikh Women and Kirtan Seva

keeraa · 28 May 2003

This may lead the topic totally astray, but I feel that it's a pressing issue when thinking about women and keertan sevaa, and also in regards to the greater equality issue with which it gets linked. So, putting it out straight -- I think Guru Sahib's daughters SHOULD be allowed to do keertan and all other sevaa anywhere that Guru Sahib's sons can. HOWEVER I also feel that ALL the same rules should apply. No singh would be allowed to do keertan with his head covered by a chunni alone, so similarly, no kaur in a chunni should be permitted to do so either. I think we need to begin by enforcing the keski/dastaar rule upon bibiyaan before the issue of allowing them to do keertan etc can be opened up or else we're going to see some major dhills. I believe there was a Hukamnama issued in 1996 which simply stated something along the lines of "women must cover their heads with blue cloth before doing sevaa". This is so very inadequate. I feel that we need to set the rules and not back down from them, beginning with the keski issue. Until we do that, we'll have women demanding "equal rights" but who refuse to accept the equal rights given to them by Guru Sahib in the form of the Khalsa uniform. Until they're willing to ACCEPT the equality emblematized in the Khalsa uniform, the "equality" they fight for is all just a sham. So, to sum up, I say all the power to the bibiyaan fighting for "equality", but I also say MORE power to those who LIVE it. With Guru Sahib's kirpaa, some day we'll have a panth that really does practice equality and more singhnees who actually live up to the true benchmark of the Khalsa. With singhnees truly living up to that standard, how could anyone ever deny them any right?