Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

women in Panj Pyare

women in Panj Pyare

Bakhsheesh · 24 May 2003

One thing i want to know. White Sikhs let women be in Panj Pyare and most Punjabi Sikhs don't no matter what jathebandi. So is it okay. I mean can women be in panj pyare? are white Sikhs following the true path or punjabi sikhs?

Re: women in Panj Pyare

jagroop singh · 24 May 2003

Gurfateh i think that the teachings of our Guru fully support women if they wish to be part of the punj piyare. Gurfateh

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Singhnee · 24 May 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! In sikhi men and women are equal. All sikhs are khalsa of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee. If Guru Sahib jee didn't do any discrimination how can we do now? Both have to follow same rehit, get same naam, same kakaars, Amrit from same baata, same updesh, same kurehats, same baana and same hukams of Gurbani. Both chhuk Amrit to meet Waheguru then why women won't be allowed to do sewa as punj pyaaray or any other sewa which a sikh can do. There is only ONE MARAD and that is Akaal Purakh. All we are naars of Akaal purakh. Gurbani says: "ES JAG MEH EK PURAKH HAI AUR SAGLI NAAR SABAYEE" In same shabad: "PURKHAY SAVAI(N) SE PURAKH HOVAI(N)" (please correct any mistakes as I don't have these punkities in front of me at this moment) So, according to Gurbani we all are same in eyes of Waheguru. It is imperative that we don't ignore 50% of our population.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 24 May 2003

man and woman are the same, its horrible how women are discrimnated against like that. reminds me off how baba nihal singh ji khalsa, jathedar of a nihung dal, stood up for women rights in a kar seva in harminder sahib. maybe the new generation willc hange for the better and actually follow sikhi, and allow women to take equal share of seva.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

keeraa · 24 May 2003

Punj Pyaaray are selected based on merit (ie. how much rehit they keep, etc), not gender. There is nothing stopping a woman from being part of the Punj Pyaaray. This is one extremely uplifting point about Sikhi -- there is only one rehit, one amrit, one Khalsa, so in no way should women be looked down upon or excluded from any sevaa. Anything that is open for a singh to do, a singhnee can do as well.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Bakhsheesh · 24 May 2003

Singhnee Ji, Guru Ji used metaphor to teach us. If all are women then were Gurus women too? think about it. God made everyone equal but different and distinct. rehat is same and Amrit is same but Guru Ji asked for a head and no women stood up. Many famous Sikhs like Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji and even Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji were there but none stood up. I don't mean they were not brave enough but doesn't it show that Guru Ji wanted only Panj Pyare to come up in front because Guru Ji chose them for seva. Guru Ji does all good things by motivating you through mind. So I think these five were chosen for this special seva. Guru Ji could've chosen any woman but he didn't. No woman gave her head so why should women be in this seva? Five men stood up which was not a coincidence. Akaal Purakh had already planned everything and these five were chosen because it was in their karma. If Akaal Purakh wanted women to be in Panj Pyare, He/She would've chosen a woman too. If women be in Panj Pyare then it becomes Panj Pyareean. Taking one line from Gurbani and using it to prove your point is not a good thing. It all depends on which topic you are talking about. For example, Guru Ji called this world "Koor" and then called it "Sach" "Koor Raja Koor Parja Koor Sab Sansar" Then Guru Ji wrote on some other page "Eh Jag Sacche Ki Hai Kothree, Sache Ka Vich Vaas" So tell me why would Gurbani contradict itself. One way Guru Ji called this world bad and then second time Guru Ji called it beautiful. Why? See, it depends on the topic. Guru Ji called this world "Koor" but he did it to teach us. Guru Ji used many example of hindu gods in Gurbani but doesn't mean Guru Ji believed in them. If all are women in this world then why is this an issue? Women (men in this world) are already in Panj Pyare. So what is the problem? All are women and women are in panj pyare. So nothing should change. Right? Forgive me if I said anything wrong. If i did, please correct it so I could learn. thanks

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Bakhsheesh · 24 May 2003

Another thing I would like to point out. If one is chosen based on Rehat then disabled person should be chosen too because seva in Panj Pyare is not based on gender. If disabled people can't be in Panj Pyare then there has to be some physical requirement. if its all about Rehat then who cares about if a person is deaf or one eyed. Right? tell me if i am wrong.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

r2d2 · 24 May 2003

I heard that women can't be punj pyare based on their monthly cycle. Also I've heard the arguement that when Guru Gobind Singh Ji stood asking for one head he did not ask for a male head. I dunno...I personally haven't formed an opinion on the subject yet but that's the objections I've heard from people. Also, even though everyone claims that women can be punj pyare I have yet to see one. Maybe it's just more talk than action..

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Mkhalsa · 25 May 2003

>>>>>>>>>>>rehat is same and Amrit is same but Guru Ji asked for a head and no women stood up....Guru Ji could've chosen any woman but he didn't. No woman gave her head so why should women be in this seva? Five men stood up which was not a coincidence.<<<<<<<<< Bakhsheesh jeeo, Think about this... only 5 people from specific castes stood up as well.. does that mean panj pyare can only be khatri, jatt, water carrier, clothes washer, or barber? what about a chumar (shoe maker) or tarkhan? can they not be in the panj pyare then? your whole argument is illogical. What about gorae sikhs, some white person may have been there, and there definitely were those of muslim descent, can they not be panj pyare either? I keep hearing this argument again and again, but it makes no sense? >>>>>>>>If women be in Panj Pyare then it becomes Panj Pyareean. <<<<<<< is it not practice to call gursikhs in the "they" form. such as Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindra Valae, not Bhindra Vala.. same for singhnee not valee but valae... thus it would still be punj pyarae. >>>>>>So tell me why would Gurbani contradict itself. <<<<<<< Simple answer: It doesnt. >>>>>>Women (men in this world) are already in Panj Pyare. So what is the problem? All are women and women are in panj pyare. So nothing should change. Right?<<<<<<< Right nothing should change, women are already in panj pyare and have been for hundreds of years, and will continue to be, whether they are women in human form or not. What needs to change is peoples attitudes. --Daas Mkhalsa

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Bakhsheesh · 25 May 2003

It is not because of women's monthly cycle. Other religions like Islam consider women inferior and impure because of this but Guru Ji said it is part of woman's body which is created by God. We all come from women so that would make us impure too. I want to know the reasons that justify women being in Panj Pyare. That's all

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Amritpal Singh · 25 May 2003

I personally know of a women who has done Panj Sewa before. Women are allowed to do sewa as much as men are. If you find out otherwise I would suggest stay clear of that amrit sinchaar , as proper rehit is not being exercised.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Khalsa Soulja · 25 May 2003

the monthly cycle is a load of rubbish. guruji advisedAGAINST that prejudice. if women are spiritually advanced enough they should be in the panj. but take a trip to india and count on your hands how many proper keski wearing bibian you see- and i doubt youll count past your first hand. there are so few real singhnees left today it is no suprise none are getting in the panj. this is the fault of previous jathedars of akal takht for premoting bareheaded amrit and the fault of women for being sucked into hindoo/western culutre!

Re: women in Panj Pyare

UK Singh · 25 May 2003

Vaheguru jee ka khaalsa Vaheguru jee ki fateh This question has come up before, when i was getting in to sikhi, I heard Baba Jarnail singh's Speeches CD and Baba jee was speaking about this as even he had this question asked to him, and Baba Jarnail singh had said that when Guru jee asked for a head, no woman had stood up, so its no ones fault, so if it was five singhs and then it should be five singhs, but that doesnt mean sikhi is discriminating against women, its just the fact that five men had stood up, and we shoulnt change that now, women are still regarded just as the same as men in every other aspect. If I have said anything wrong pls forgive me Vaheguru jee ka khaalsa Vaheguru jee ki fateh

Re: women in Panj Pyare

UK Singh · 25 May 2003

Vaheguru jee ka khaalsa Vaheguru jee ki fateh This question has come up before, when i was getting in to sikhi, I heard Baba Jarnail singh's Speeches CD and Baba jee was speaking about this as even he had this question asked to him, and Baba Jarnail singh had said that when Guru jee asked for a head, no woman had stood up, so its no ones fault, so if it was five singhs and then it should be five singhs, but that doesnt mean sikhi is discriminating against women, its just the fact that five men had stood up, and we shoulnt change that now, women are still regarded just as the same as men in every other aspect. If I have said anything wrong pls forgive me Vaheguru jee ka khaalsa Vaheguru jee ki fateh

Re: women in Panj Pyare

argh · 26 May 2003

Bakhsheesh jeeo, you have made some rather absurd statements here, the most absurd being: "If women be in Panj Pyare then it becomes Panj Pyareean." How so?? When women join the Khalsa, do they become Khalsee instead of Khalsa? "I want to know the reasons that justify women being in Panj Pyare. That's all" Why not begin by justifying why only men should be Punj Pyaaray. Mkhalsa jee wrote: "Think about this... only 5 people from specific castes stood up as well.. does that mean panj pyare can only be khatri, jatt, water carrier, clothes washer, or barber?" That's a valid point. The physical/outer form of the original Punj Pyaaray shouldn't influence who can and cannot be Punj Pyaaray today. Unless we put restrictions on caste, height, weight, beard length, location, etc in order to maintain the same outer attributes of the original Punj Pyaaray, then there is no logical reasoning behind restricting this sevaa to only males based solely on the virtue of them being male. I think "Khalsa Soulja" jee has also raised a legitmate point. There seems to be more males dedicated to Sikhi than females, so it isn't such a surprise that we see so few singhnees worthy of fulfilling this sevaa. But their worth is not determined on a physical sphere; it is based on their inner spiritual qualities (rehit etc) which are the same for both genders. And finally, in regards to "UK Singh" jee's statement: "women are still regarded just as the same as men in every other aspect." How can you justify regarding women as "the same in every other aspect" when you have excluded them from participating in the very highest sevaa of all? Either you believe that women and men are equal or you don't. You either follow the teachings of Guru Sahib or you don't. You can't say "women and men are equal in every other aspect except this and this".

Re: women in Panj Pyare

unjaan · 26 May 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! This is so frustrating!!!!! Does no one see that there is no gender for the panj piaray?????? If you are going to be pointing fingers at the gender of the panj piaray doing seva and not their kamaiee..then why not look at who's beard is longer?? who is taller?? My point is..Gender is guru sahib's gift as is one's Height and finally as is the Length of one's Kes. Its much more difficult for us kaljugee jeev's to look past the gender of an individual and regard their kamaiee/jeevan as the determinant for doing this amazing seva. bhul chuk maaf, unjaan

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Bakhsheesh · 26 May 2003

<> The caste ends after you take Amrit. So there is no need for specific five castes. <> The one who is casteless can only be in Panj Pyare. If anyone considers himself as chumar or tarkhan then he can't be in this seva. it's that simple. <<>> I know that but did you understand the point i made. Using one line to fit your point is wrong. We need to look at the whole meaning of a Shabad. one line can't tell you everything. I gave you an example already. It depends on how Guru Ji is describing to us and how is He teaching to us. <> Yeah exactly my point. So leave it the way it has always been. Can you provide me with any proof that women did seva in Panj Pyare in 18th century, during the time of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, during SIngh Sabha movement or in 20th century and from Sooraj Parkash. It wasn't till white Sikhs came along and started doing this. A woman who says she must be in Panj Pyare is not qualified to be in that seva. one who openly says he/she is able to be in Panj Pyare and roop of Guru Gobind Singh Ji is definitely lying because Guru Ji said: "Kaho Kabeer Shoosha Ghatt Bolay, Bhareya Hoe So Kabhoon Na Dole". Real Sikhs think hundred times before they do this seva. <> Because it was men who stood up and gave their heads not women. We are not talking about caste here because caste ends when you take amrit. But your sex doesn't change. very stupid argument. i know <> Yes I do. <> This is not about equality. this is about qualification. Women failed in the test. none gave their head. <> then what about those who are disabled? they can be equal in spirituality but cannot be in panj pyare. why?? if women should be in panj pyare then disabled people too. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: women in Panj Pyare

unjaan · 27 May 2003

"Bakhsheesh", you said <> I dont see your argument, there is no logic in this statement..basically by stating this you've implied that women and disabled men/women alike are not accepted by Guru Sahib to do seva. ?? Bhajee/Bhainjee, please try to be less hot headed about this issue and think for a minute about what you have said..the only argument you have and are clinging onto with all your strength is that of 5 males went and offered their heads when Sahib Sri Guru Gobind singh jee asked for heads..Why dont you look at those piaray as khalsa and not males? <<>> Teek..no woman offered her head to Guru sahib at the time..we cant question why there were no women..that is all his hukam it was meant to happen that way... NOW, if a man gives his head to guru sahib..with complete humility he is given Amrit dee daat...similarly if a woman gives her head to guru sahib..with complete humility she is given Amrit dee daat.. According to your argument..a woman should not be given Amrit for she never stood up when the first 5 khalsa did, to offer their heads to guru sahib. ????????????????? There is definately something wrong with a bibi if she is saying allow me to do panj seva! it is up to sangat to decide who the panj should be before amrit sanchaar..and at that time, the persons mehnat, kamaiee, avasthaa, spirituality etc is looked at NOT THE BEARD OR LACK OF BEARD on their face!!! Khalsa jee!!! it is not their gender that is going to prepare the AMRIT!!!! it is their hands and their kamaiee!!!! guru sahib kirpaa karan...sanoo sariaahn noo gurmat bakhshan.. unjaan

Re: women in Panj Pyare

snegro · 27 May 2003

====>>> Bakhsheesh jeeo, Think about this... only 5 people from specific castes stood up as well.. does that mean panj pyare can only be khatri, jatt, water carrier, clothes washer, or barber? =======>> maybe but upon taking amrit one looses all caste status so it would be impossible to select such individuals hence your point is invalid and carries no wait.. when one takes amrit they do not drop or loose their gender...they do loose their caste.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Singhnee · 27 May 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Bakhsheesh jeeo I already answered all your questions but there was some problem with server and my post did not get through. <<<<>>>>>> Who told you dear Bakhsheesh jeeo that women failed in the test??? What about all singhnees then who gave Guru sahib jee their heads to take amrit??? Guru Gobind Singh jee ask for head in every Amrit Sinchaar which is according to gurmat and women are always their to offer their heads. Do you think Guru Sahib asked for head only once in 1699? Think twice before you jump to answer this question. From who we get amrit now a days? It is Guru Gobind Singh jee himself asking for our head and then give us amrit dee daat and naam dee daat at amrit sinchaar. Guru Gobind Singh jee apears in the punj piaaray in the presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Even a sikh child knows that. In your second post you also mentioned about women to called punj piaaryeean. You tell me if Guru sahib called women khalseean? Yes, men and women have different bodies we all know for what reason akaal purakh did that but in spirituality there is no difference in men or women. Spirituality starts from Amrit sinchaar and how there could be anything judged according to sex(men or women) Punj piaaray are choosen from khalsa sangat and only thing that counts is rehat and kamaayee of a tyaar bar tyaar khalsa nothing else. ` <<<<<<>>>>>>>> I can't axpect a sikh comparing women to disabled people. Bakhsheesh jee how your fingures typed this kind of manmat? I can't believe it. So you believe that women are disabled people. Please come out of Brahmanvaad and read Assa dee vaar. "SO KEO(N) MANDAA AAKHEEAI JET JAME(N) RAAJAAN" There is only one meaning of this punkiti and it's so easy to understand. Our Gurus spent so much of their time in educating people towards this kind of popular kureets in our society and today in 21st century there are still some people who are insulting women(khalsa) by comparing/calling them disabled people. Bakhsheesh jeeo you are here in human form through a woman otherwise there was no other way to come to this world. and you are calling women disabled people including your that great mother who brought you to this world. "BHANDO(N) HEE SABH OOPJEH(N) BHANDE BAJH NA KOE NANAK BHANDE BAAHRA EKO SACHA SOE" <<<<<<

Re: women in Panj Pyare

? · 27 May 2003

they should have some female panj pyare at some akj amrit sanchaars ive seen some AMAZING gurmukh bibian which seem like they are 100% completely attached to guru jee's charna, just like the singhs are, so why don't they get to do the seva? peopel should CHOOSE them and RECOMMEND them and make them do the seva to lead by example and show tru sikhi, tru equality

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Amritpal Singh · 27 May 2003

Vaaheguru jee ka khalsa vaaaheguru jee kee fateh! Could Admin please give us the Tapoban gurdwara stance on this females in panj issue that has come up. Are women allowed to do panj sewa at amrit sinchaars conducted at Tapoban Sahib?

Re: women in Panj Pyare

A Sikh · 28 May 2003

<> And the point I made was that If Khalsa is not gender but based on spirituality then everyone can be Khalsa and be in Panj Pyare. What I was trying to say is that if a Soorma Singh (blind man) takes amrit, he becomes khalsa but He is not allowed to be in Panj Pyare. At Akaal Takhat Sahib disabled Sikhs are prohibited from this seva. Women are not disabled nor they are inferior. I am not comparing women to disabled people. According to you Khalsa is not a gender but Naam Kamayee. If I assume this is true then all Sikhs should be chosen based on their Naam Kamayee. For example, if a Sikh is Pooran GurSIkh and Khalsa but he is one eyed, can he be in Panj Pyare? Can he do this seva? Again, don't say healthy women can be chosen because then you are going off teh topic and sticking to physical body. We are not talking about physical health. We are talking about Naam Kamayee. So if this one eyed SIkh is Khalsa and I mean Pooran Khalsa, can he be in this seva? According to Akaal Takhat Sahib and many other Jathebandis he cannot. What I am trying to get at is that being in Panj Pyare is not just based on Naam Kamayee but also physical appearance. This is why disabled people are not qualified for this seva even if they are spiritually very high. I hope you understand what i mean here. I am not saying women are disabled or disabled Sikhs are inferior but my point is something else counts besides, Naam Kamayee. I hope I made it clear enough. Please tell me if disabled Sikhs with high spirituality can be in this seva. If yes, then women can too because it is based on spirituality not physical appearance. If no, neither can women because something else counts besides naam kamayee. Try to understand my point here. again i wanna stress, i am not saying women are disabled. my whole point is against your argument of choosing Panj Pyare based on Naam Kamayee. If this is true then disabled Sikhs can also reach higher level of spirituality which enables them to be in Panj Pyare too. Right? <> Yes so why not go with the same hukam? no women in Panj Pyare. <> taking amrit de daat is different than giving amrit de daat. Being an Amrit Abhilakhi is different than being in Panj Pyare. Women can take Amrit but cannot give by being in Panj Pyare. <> Then why are disabled Sikhs prohibited from this seva. Their naam kamayee can be higher than others. if it's not based on gender and physical appearance then allow everyone including disabled Sikhs, Soorma Sikhs, one eyed Sikh because this seva is based on Naam Kamayee. <> But not to be in Panj Pyare to give Amrit. Their gave their heads to take Amrit. First five who gave their heads were chosen as Panj Pyare. When Guru Sahib Ji passed GuruShip to Guru Garnth Sahib Ji, again no woman was chosen in Panj Pyare. Only five men were chosen by Guru Ji. baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji and others were chosen but no woman. You can look into historical books. Most of the books provide the names of Panj Pyare but a woman's name is never given. << Do you think Guru Sahib asked for head only once in 1699?>> Yes but to be in Panj Pyare only not for any other reason. <> Panj Pyare who are always male. <> Waheguru. When did i write such a thing? I am not comparing. But tell me what's wrong with disabled people? are they inferior? if no, then how is it manmat? if yes, then how are they inferior? My point is if there is no difference in spirituality then disabled people (sikhs or khalsas) can also reach the same level of spirituality as other great Sikhs have and yet they are not allowed to be part of this seva. why? why did i compare women to disabled people? i didn't. you said it is not about health but spirituality and i said then lets everyone be in panj pyare including disabled people because again its about spirituality not physical appearance. <> I didn't, show me my exact words where i said women are disabled. and again, do u think disabled people are inferior? because you sound like women are better than disabled ppl? <> I agree. I did not call women disabled. I have clarified my point. <> Yes because it has always been men. Had women been in this seva, this issue wouldn't have been very controversial in Sikhi. You give me a name of woman who did seva in Panj Pyare during Singh Sabha movement or during Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's time? <> I personally don't. maybe you think disabled people are inferior to women but are you saying Sikhs in 18th century who were in Chardee Kala all the time were influenced by indian/hindu culture soon after Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave Guruship to Guru Granth Sahib Ji or Sikhs always followed "women inferior culture" even during the time of Guru Ji? if yes, then you mean Guru Ji could not get Sikhs out of an indian culture and get Sikhs to follow Gurbani. If no, then Sikhs never followed any indian culture in which women were regarded inferior. Sikhs were one with Gurbani and always followed their true rehat. this is why no such issue existed at that time. No raag Maala issues, keski/kes kakkar, panj pyare issues etc.. Women gave many sacrifices in 18th century and stayed in jungles with Singhs but never asked to be in Panj Pyare then why do you? <> Yes women have but not in Sikhi especially during 18th century. <> So women got more rights after Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji because She impressed Guru Ji so much or what? sounds like you are saying Sikhs refused to follow Guru Sahib and refused to consider women equal. After Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji's sacrifice Sikhs started regarding women equal. Are you implying this? because this doesn't make sense. Guru Amardas Ji gave women 22 manjis and women has always been regarded equal until 1849 and not a single woman was chosen to be in this seva an now suddenly you want this. why? women in 18th century accepted to be inferior or what? they sacrificed their own children. they were one with Sikhi. They knew everything. They didn't ask for this seva but you do. so either they were wrong or you are. you tell me who? <> You didn't understand my point. I know Gurbani does not contradict itself. Guru Ji was never confused. I did not criticize Gurbani. Show me where did i write it? actually you rewrote my point. <> exactly what i was trying to say. it all depends. <> yes and this was my point. <> Yes Guru Ji did. If sansar is not sacha then neither is God. God lives in it and that'd what makes it sacha. Guru Ji said "EH JAG SACHE KEE HAI KOTHREE". i think you know now. <> yeah, so why talk about this issues if women don't want it. this is very big seva. <> as same as woman that those who say they should be in this seva are not Khalsa. <> Showing hankaar is when one says he should be in Panj not if a man says men should be. this does not mean he is saying he should be. I say men should be in Panj but I don't mean i should be in this seva because i am a pappi banda. <> yes but being in Panj is not just based on spirituality because not all Sikhs are allowed in this seva. again, disabled people are prohibited not because of spirituality but because of physical appearance. I don't mean anything about women's physical appearance but you said it is based on spirituality but then why are disabled not allowed? <> I hope I can be Khalsa one day. Pray for me. <> but you don't see any. there must be a reason. right? I mean I seen AKJ bibian very Gurmukh and full of Naam Simran and yet they are not taken in Panj Pyare and I don't see them complaining. If I am wrong on this issue then pray to Guru Ji so that I can follow the true path and may He show me the truth. This issue has not been solved by whole Panth so what i am writing are ideas not beliefs. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Admin · 29 May 2003

>>>>> Could Admin please give us the Tapoban gurdwara stance on this females in panj issue that has come up. Are women allowed to do panj sewa at amrit sinchaars conducted at Tapoban Sahib? >>>>>> At amrit sinchaars held at Tapoban Sahib, women can do sewa in punj pyaare. At two occasions bibiyaan were selected to do sewa in punj. As per the situation at that time, they did pehredaar dee sewa. All the seven individuals (5 pyaare, granthi and pehredaar) who are selected at that time to do sewa have same qualifications. Anyone out of them can do any sewa in the amrit sinchaar. Many times the problem is that bibiyaan themselves, out of humility don't want to do sewa in punj. From Gurmat point of view, there is no prohibition for women to do sewa in punj. Being Gursikhs, how can we justify this discrimination?

Re: women in Panj Pyare

keeraa · 29 May 2003

Those bibiyaan posting in favour of women being allowed in Punj Pyaaray aren't doing so with self-interested intentions. That is to say, I don't think they are pro women-in-the-punj just so that they themselves can be given the chance to do this sevaa. The pro argument isn't quite so narrow. We should look at the bigger picture. When a singh commits a bujjar kurehit, to me, it seems that the ultimate punishment is that he loses the privilege of ever being in the Punj Pyaaray. If a bibi commits the same mistake, she wouldn't lose this honour (because, according to some views here, she should never HAVE this privilege to begin with!), so committing such a mistake seems worse for a male. This isn't right. A singh should aspire to be such a good singh that he can be considered for this sevaa. Similarly, a bibi should aspire to be such a good singhnee that she too can be considered for this sevaa...not out of ego or just for the sake of being able to say she has done this sevaa, but because we should ALL aspire to be tyaar-bar-tyaar and worthy of fulfilling any sevaa at any time.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Mkhalsa · 29 May 2003

A Sikh.. You have totally confused me.. are you on a fake name from being baksheesh? also, you have not clarified anything, either you are saying women are disabled or you are saying women cant have the same naam kamahee as men?? what?!?! whats wrong with a singh with one eye doing seva in punj if he is a gursikh? I am getting very confused here.. Also.. I commend tapoban sahib for being progressive, not only with this but also with rehat and many other great contributions to gursikhi.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

!! · 29 May 2003

Baksheesh, you mentioned that Akal Takht maryada says that disabled people can't be in panj. Well, that same maryada also says that women CAN serve in the panj. The whole thing of women not standing up and so women for the rest of time being disqualified is sort of like the original sin in christianity. Remember, most men didn't stand up either. Those that did, it reflected on them and they got kushee of guru saahib. They stood up for their guru as sikhs, not as representatives for all males for all of eternity. Nowhere in any rehitnamaa or gurbanee can we find a reference saying that women are inferior spiritually or incapable of doing any seva.

Re: women in Panj Pyare

MSingh ASr · 29 May 2003

Better, women are not selected for this seva, simply to prove so called "equality" It is kiddish to call it gender discrimination by sikh society. In 1699, no woman was inspired by GURU to present herself for this seva.This in no case, is a coincidence. What He wanted , He gave us. Why we want to confuse our past and future. This is enough to be satisfied and look into the CHOJes of CHOJI PRITAM. Let us be serious and silent enough to seek and read mystic meanings in GURU's every action. He called her PRINCESS, why she likes herself to be called LION. I do not know, what He meant. But He did meant, He did meant, in His every moment, on ths earth; new, wonderful, mystic; I think. WJKKWJKF

Re: women in Panj Pyare

Admin · 29 May 2003

Since no new argument is coming out of this debate and since this debate is not coming to a conclusion, we are going to close this thread now. No further postings to this thread will be approved.