Why am I Sikh?
Gurpreet Kaur · 22 May 2003
Please accept my Fateh..Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh..
I am writing this in the hope that someone from this forum will be able to guide me, or provide me with answers to put my mind at rest. Let me start from my present situation. I am a final year student at University, from a very orthodox Sikh family background, for which I am thankful as this environment has instilled in me a great love for our Guru's and Sikhism. However, recently, I have met a friend at University who is a great person, very intelligent, and also a practising Muslim. I have, from my limited understanding, gathered that the Guru's have taught us not to force religion or views upon anyone, and be tolerant towards all cultures and faiths.
My Muslim friend has recently questioned me about Sikhism, I regret to say I have not been able to answer his questions, this has deeply affected me in a way that I now feel perhaps my life has up till now been a way of 'going with the flow' without understanding what I am following. I would go as far as to say that my faith in religion is faltering. I am searching for someone, some guidance to perhaps, put my mind at rest. I believe, as most people do, that religion is of no use, until there is trust and faith. However, in the present time in which we are living, there is a danger of information overload, as in there are so many external influences, western, other religions, peer pressure etc, which make it necessary for every youth of today to be well grounded and clear about the faith which they are following. Otherwise, I think there is a danger of being led astray by people who are knowledgeable of their faith to the extent that its easy to falter, when you have no answer for what you are following.
This is exactly what has happened to me, or is happening right now, and perhaps to many other Sikh youngsters, for which we cannot blame them, as the leaders nowadays are too concerned about erecting wonderfully designed Gurudwaras, without concern for their Sikh children, their spiritual growth, as they are the ones who will have the responsibility of carrying out duties to actually keep these Gurudwaras going.
Coming back to the point, I will now explain what my Muslim friend has said to me. He said firstly, that Islam is the only true religion, and that God spoke through the Prophet Mohammad, and also revealed that he would be the final and last messenger of God, and no others would follow, and if people followed someone else after him, they would be considered 'infidels' and would face eternal hellfire after the 'last' day (Judgement Day). I said to him, that the present climate in India at the time of the birth of Guru Nanak Dev ji was of Islamic fundamentalists, who were forcing helpless people to convert, and Hindus were worshipping God through Idoltary, in which case Guru Nanak Dev Ji came into this world, to reinstate that there is one God and His worship should be carried out through meditation of His Name and selfless Seva.
At this point, my friend retorted that the Quran was the last book of God's words, and the Guru Granth Saheb was a composition of hymns written by not just the Gurus, but contributions were from Hindus and Sufi Saints. He also said, the Bible was changed by the infidels, and so God spoke to Mohammad to correct the Christians and Jews who were worshipping God in the wrong way, and if this was the case then Guru ji proclaimed a new faith, which is not valid as Mohammad was the last messenger. I asked him how he knew that Mohammad was the last Prophet, he said he knows because Mohammad was illiterate, a fact proven by literary sources, and the Quran was spoken through him in Arabic, so there was no way he could have tailored it according to his understanding. Also, he questioned whether Sikhism thought the Guru's were an incarnations of God, he said if not, then why do we bow to the Granth Saheb? To conclude, he was saying that the Prophet Mohammad spoke the words of God, in which God has clearly stated that Mohammad is the FINAL prophet, any after that are non-believers. In saying that, I must admit he agreed to the Sikhism's concept of One God and the Oneness of the Creator, however I am extremely confused as to whether Mohammad was right, if we say he was and so was Guru Nanak, it cannot be possible, because if God spoke through Mohammad also, then God was also saying that he is the final prophet, which contradicts Guru Ji completely.
I mentioned to him that the true muslims were not present at that time in India, and Guru ji had to come to save people from Islamic atrocities, however he said that was the misintepretations of people, that the Quran was not changed in any way, so the True religion was still present, and Guru Ji should have reinstated the Islamic beliefs, which do not teach torturing people or forced conversions, not concocted a new faith. In reply, I said the Christians were misled and God had to speak through Mohammad, he agreed, I said then were the 'people' not misled then also?, he said the 'Book (Bible)' was changed, and the Quran has never been changed, therefore God didnt have to speak through another Prophet. This doesnt seem to make sense, because I would say if people were being tortured and murdered in the name of religion, it doesnt matter if a holy book was changed, the atrocities should be enough for God to send us another Prophet. However, the fundamental question remains, which is the 'TRUE' religion, and the answer cannot be all of them, because all of them contradict each other, ie. if Islam is also right, then Sikhism has no validity, because Islam teaches Mohammad was the final messenger of God.
I am really concerned and in mental torment over this issue, I feel everything I ever believed in is crumbling away, is this a test of my faith? I have tried to ask many Sikh people, however, no one answers me, is this what our religion has become? This Muslim guy has all the answers about his faith, and I have none, whilst being brought up in a religious household, its very sad, because it means there must be many youngsters out there, being misled at this very moment, and we blame them, but there is no one out there to explain the fundamentals of our religion, so how are they to blame? I have seen so many websites preaching Islam, and when people are faltering in their faith who are Muslim, they have scholars that guide them, readily available, however, I think as Sikhs we need to work on this aspect, so that if someone like me is questioned about Sikhism, we have no doubts, and we can explain the reason why we are Sikhs.
Everything boils down to one question I guess, 'Why am I a Sikh'?
I hope someone can help me, or direct me to someone who can, I don't think I have ever felt so helpless and lonely in my life. Many apologies for anything I have said which may have upset someone.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh...
Gurpreet Kaur
Re: Why am I Sikh?
kulpreetsingh · 23 May 2003
Dearest Bhainjee Gurpreet Kaur Jee,
VAAHEGUROO JEE KAA KHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROO JEE KEE FATHEH !!!
( The pure and sovereign ones are the Wonderous Enlightener's own, and the Wonderous Enlightener shall Always be the master of Victory )
When you have discussions with your friends about their faiths bhainjee, you will begin to notice that many of them will try their very best to convert you into their fold. One the other hand, there is Sikhi, which encourages people to become Sikhs, but encourages Muslims to be good Muslims, Hindus to be good Hindus, Jews to be good Jews and so on and so forth. Typically, discussions such as these can end up in long drawn-out and sometimes even pointless arguments just to prove the superiority of one faith or another. The truth be told, some streams flow faster, some slower, some have more filth in them, some are cleaner. Do not be afraid to come to the realization that Sikhi does NOT say "all faiths are equal and lead to God at the same time."
If this was the case there would have been no need for Guru Nanak to set foot on this earth and enlighten the entire society. All those streams, bhainjee, are flowing towards the ocean. They have one commonality, you could call it the elemental base - the H2O (water) that is in all of them.
This water, bhainjee, of these streams, is called "eillaahee" "snaatan" "dharam" or "the God-sent, original and true religion." This true religion is the water in all those streams.
In some streams, this water has dried up. In some streams, it has become very toxic and polluted. In some streams, it has become blocked and therefore it takes a very long process to reach the ocean.
When you think about streams and rivers panjee, water flows and waves are created and there comes a point when you need to direct the water. So if this water is the true religion, otherwise known as the ultimate truth, otherwise known as LOVE, you need to direct it. You need to direct it so that it flows back into it's creator.
How do you direct it bhainjee? You direct it with the discipline and faith that a stream would need to travel straight into the ocean. This is called "dhunyaavee dharam" or "worldly religion."
These disciplines, this faith, these worldly tools used to help the stream travel without losing its path, and to travel the straightest and fastest path, these are what make the rules of worldly reilgions.
The best worldly tool to ride the waves, and continue on this straight path, is NAAM. The Name of God.
What is NAAM bhainjee? Naam is all that can't be explained by science - all that can't be explained by math - all that is beyond explanation. Naam is the essence, the sweet nectar, the balance, the support of the entire universe.
Bhainjee, the path of the Khalsa has the most water, of the purest form, and it goes down the straightest path at the fastest speed.
And on this path, the Khalsa path, NAAM is used 24 hours a day and 7 days a week.
Imagine, on this clean, wide, deep, vast, quickly-moving stream you have the safest, strongest, largest boat - called Naam.
Sikhi is the only faith that is so absorbed in this naam. And by being absorbed in this naam, the meditation on the essence of God, anybody can be liberated.
This is, in the best way I could tell you, the difference.
That is not to say that the "true religion" does not exist in the other streams. Of course if you have a stream there's water, right?
But you may ask the Saints. How so? Read Guru Granth Sahib and the saints will speak to you. The Sufis and Hindus and Muslims and Brahmins, the Jatts and Chamaars and Shoodhars, the Sodhis and Bedis, the worldly stereotypical definitions - they will all speak to you from their worldly stereotypes. They will all tell you which path is straight. They will guide you to which path is the best to travel.
"Khannio thikhee, vaalon nikkee,
ayth maarag jaanaa
Gurparsaadee jinee aap tajjiaa
har vaasnaa samaanee"
- Guru Amar Das Jee
Sharper than the edge of a sword, thinner than a strand of hair,
we must walk this path.
With the Enlightener's grace, whomever renounces their Self / Ego,
God's light will shine within them.
The saints say, the path that must be travelled is this one, where self/ego is renounced. When self / ego is renounced then what happens bhainjee?
"houmai maar eaek liv laagee a(n)thar naam vusaaeiaa ||"
- Guru Amar Das Jee
Conquering my ego, I am lovingly focused on the One Lord; the Naam has come to dwell within me.
So bhainjee, the saints destroy their ego. They travel this difficult path and they become imbued in the love for God. Then, finally the Naam comes to dwell within them. This is the path of the true religion, the path that on this world - on this earth - is walked by the Khalsa.
But where do you get this Naam from bhainjee?
Even if you have destroyed your ego - or you are almost there - how do you lovingly focus on God? Who teaches you this?
"gur miliai naam paaeeai chookai moh piaas ||"
- Guru Amar Das Jee
Meeting with the Guru, the Naam is obtained, and the thirst of emotional attachment departs.
So bhainjee, the way to travel on the stream to God is to walk this difficult path and destroy ones ego. Then by meeting with the Guru, and falling in love with God, the naam is obtained.
Who is our Guru ?
Our Guru, the enlightener, is our spiritual guide and our physical guide in this world. Our spiritual guide is the Guru Granth Sahib. Why do we bow to this Guru Granth Sahib?
vaahu vaahu baanee niru(n)kaar hai this jaevudd avur n koe ||
-Guru Amar Das Jee
Waaho! Waaho! is the Bani, the Word, of the Formless Lord. There is no other as great.
So your friend is right !! We consider our Guru the revealed light of God. This is why we bow before it. However, we do not consider physical flesh to be the light of God. The light of God is beyond flesh. This is why we do not have a human spiritual leader. We do not think that God can be born into a human body. If God could do that - where would everything else go, while God was in the human body? Clearly... God is everywhere. Therefore, only God's light can shine in human bodies. This is the same way you can stuff a few litres of water in a pot, but not an ocean.
So our Gurus were the light of God, and we belive Guru Granth Sahib to be the living light of God in this dark age. This is why we bow before it and treat it like the King of Kings or Queen of Queens.
We also believe that spiritual guidance is important as is physical, social and political guidance. For this we have a physical representation of the Guru. These are the Punj Pyare.
The Punj Pyare are five Khalsas, who are the saints that destroy their ego, and the soldiers who walk that narrow path, the warriors who discipline themselves, and the poets who sit in loving devotion of God. They went to the Guru, and they obtained the Name. They live the teachings of the Guru Granth Sahib. They are the representation of the water in that stream.
And, since you can only get this Naam - this boat, this ship - from the Guru, and the Punj Pyare are the embodiment of the Guru, you obtain the NAAM from them. They can teach you the method, they can teach you the mantr that will liberate your soul. All that is required is your complete and unwavering faith, and the surrendering of - nothing else - but your ego.
jinee eik man naam dhhiaaeiaa gurumuthee veechaar ||
Those who meditate single-mindedly on the Naam, and contemplate the Teachings of the Guru
thin kae mukh sudh oujulae thith suchai dhurubaar ||
-their faces are forever radiant in the Court of the True God.
oue a(n)mrith peevehi sudhaa sudhaa suchai naam piaar ||1||
They drink in the Ambrosial Nectar forever and ever, and they love the True Name. ||1||
- Guru Amar Das jee
Therefore, drinking the ambrosial nectar - the immortal essence - amrit, the Naam is obtained. The amrit is obtained from the Punj Pyare. The Punj Pyare are the physical embodiment of the Guru. The Guru's spiritual form is the Granth. Following the Guru's teachings, which are the very LIGHT OF GOD, the ego is renounced. When ego is renounced, loving devotion develops. When loving devotion develops, one becomes absorbed in the Naam. Naam is the boat that helps your soul merge into the supreme soul.
This is the beautiful story of this true religion.
It is revealed to those who committed great deeds and had the good fortune to learn these teachings. It is revealed to those upon whom God has grace. It may have been revealled to Mohammed, but what does his illiteracy prove?
Guru Nanak refused to learn any of the formal education from his teachers. Still, he knew everything, and wrote some of the most complex and inspiring poetry of human history.
Guru Har Krishan was challenged to prove that he was the Guru. So, with the touch of his cane, Guru Har Krishan had a mentally-retarded, deaf, mute person named "Chajjoo" recite, in native dialect - the sanskrit poetry of the Geetaa. The people around were amazed.
What does it prove if Mohammed was able to recite some words? Perhaps he was blessed with true guidance. However, the Qu'ran does not contain teachings which can be followed by the entire universe. The Qu'ran does not maintain equality within all of humanity. How can such a text, which does not teach the unity of humanity (including women), which does not preach God as the supreme soul, be the revealed text of God?
Once again, this is a stream - and it may have some water, but how fast is the stream? How deep? How pure is the water?
Some of the arguments that people make are completely false and are only made to make you believe their sides. Please, when you have a discussion with somebody, ask them to - in front of you - provide reliable sources, with real (not made up) interpretations of the writings. This way, they cannot tell you that in arabic "Gurpreet" means onion, etc.
In any case, with any situation bhainjee you will always need to keep in mind that the light of God shines within all - there is a small droplet of that true religion - that universal truth - the LOVE - that GOD - in everybody, and so we should not express or feel hatred towards anybody, even if they call you an infidel or suggest you are going to hell. Let them have their belief, but stand firm in yours.
My dear and beloved Gurpreet Kaur bhainjee, when you begin to read and read and read the writings from the realm of truth, which are in the Guru Granth Sahib, you will realize why they don't just call it "Enlightener of the Sikhs," but "Enlightener of the Universe."
____
Bhainjee,
in the future I humbly suggest that you limit your deep and philosophical discussions with your Muslim friends until you have tried your very best to research Gurbaanee. If he tries to argue with you, please do not engage in pointless arguments. They will only hurt your friendship and your own personal paths. Please tell your friend that you respect his opinion but disagree with it. Please tell him that you are a Sikh, and you will continue to learn on this beautiful path, and you encourage him to be a stronger and better Muslim. All of the shabads mentioned above are easy to find using www.sikhitothemax.com and www.srigranth.org.
Furthermore bhainjee, I would encourage you to never become disheartened or upset when somebody puts you in a corner in some argument. I know it can be confusing and frustrating, but always have undying faith. Your Guru, the Guru Granth Sahib, has the answers to all of your questions. It is the most vast, deep and profound literature of all human history. This is what the Khalsa must do - we must always remain in Chardee Kalaa. Chardee Kalaa is like the moon and the sun. The Sikh is the moon and the Sun is the Guroo. When the Sun shines, the Moon shines. When the Guru gives his grace, the Sikh becomes exhalted. The Moon always tries to reflect as much of the Sun's light as possible. The Sikh should always strive to become imbued in the Guru's love as much as possible.
Keep this relationship between you and your Guru, and you will always have undying faith and rising spirits - Chardee Kalaa.
Bhainjee, I have faith in you that you will easily drive over this tiny speed-bump and move forward on this beautiful path.
Please, if you ever have anymore questions always feel free to post. And even more importantly, in this HUGE post of mine - which I probably went off topic a lot - if I still of course did not answer any of your questions please please forgive me and remind me.
There are a lot of educated people who visit this forum and I'm sure the answers they provide you will be very enlightened and inspired. I wish you all the best panjee - keep your faith and your spirits high always.
VAAHEGUROO JEE KAA KHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROO JEE KEE FATHEH !!!
-daas
P.S. - On a side note Bhainjee, as per our Panthic Calendar, today is the Prakash Divas of Dhan Dhan Maharaj Sri Guru Amar Das Sahib jee, the Master of the 3rd Mansion of the House of Nanak. CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL SANGAT ON THE GURPURAB. Please pass this message to your friends and take this time to remember the teachings and the life-story of Guru Amar Das Jee.
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Khalsa Soulja · 23 May 2003
its all been answered on sikh-history.com forum. bhenji has posted her question on alot of forums.
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Kulbir Singh · 23 May 2003
>>>>>>>>>>>
This is exactly what has happened to me, or is happening right now, and perhaps to many other Sikh youngsters, for which we cannot blame them, as the leaders nowadays are too concerned about erecting wonderfully designed Gurudwaras, without concern for their Sikh children, their spiritual growth, as they are the ones who will have the responsibility of carrying out duties to actually keep these Gurudwaras going.
>>>>>>>>>
So true Bhain jeeo, You are absolutely right that we are errecting big buildings but are failing to errect great gursikhs. I wish the Gurdwaras did more parchaar than they are doing now. We need people with spiritual jeevan (life) to do parchaar. Our preachers and raagis do this work for money and as a way of earning their bread. It is okay if they earn their living off of parchaar but still the primary focus should not be earning a living but should be to do parchaar.
>>>>>>
Coming back to the point, I will now explain what my Muslim friend has said to me. He said firstly, that Islam is the only true religion, and that God spoke through the Prophet Mohammad, and also revealed that he would be the final and last messenger of God, and no others would follow, and if people followed someone else after him, they would be considered 'infidels' and would face eternal hellfire after the 'last' day (Judgement Day)
>>>>>>>
Bhain jeeo, this is where your faith will come in handy. There is no point in questioning this assertion of Muslims. If they believe that Mohammad Sahib was the last prophet, that is fine with us. If they believe that we all infidels will burn in hell, let them believe this way. What we need to do is place our faiths in Guru Nanak Sahib and believe what Gurbani says. Your Muslim friend is saying that Mohammad is the last and the true prophet. You can simply say in response to this that according to Gurbani, Guru Nanak is the avtaar of Kalyug and he alone holds the responsibility to take drowning creatures across this worldly ocean. Gurbani clearly mentions that Guru Nanak is the greatest of all:
SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN, KAL RAAKHI MERI||
What more proof do you need about the greatness of Guru Nanak? Is there anyone more truthful than Guru Arjun Dev jee? If not, then please bring faith on this pankiti and tell him that just as he is quoting from Quran, you are quoting from Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and as such believe that Gurbani is nothing but truth.
>>>>>
At this point, my friend retorted that the Quran was the last book of God's words, and the Guru Granth Saheb was a composition of hymns written by not just the Gurus, but contributions were from Hindus and Sufi Saints.
>>>>>>>>>
Now what to talk about this Muslim friend of yours, our own gursikhs are saying that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee contains baani of Hindu Saints and Sufis. This is a gross misconception in our panth that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee contains baani of Non-Sikhs. The reality is that all baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee belongs to either Guru Sahibaan or Bhagats/Sikhs of Guru Sahibaan. This is a long topic and we can discuss it in some other thread but it has been proven by many Sikh scholars like Giani Gurdit Singh jee, Bhai Nihaal Singh jee and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee that the baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee belongs to the bhagats of Guru Sahibaan. All bhagats like Kabir jee, Farid jee, Ravidas jee, and Namdev jee etc. were bhagats of Guru Nanak Dev jee. They did not exist prior to Guru Nanak as some historians say but were from the same period as Guru Nanak Dev jee and met Guru Nanak at Ayodhya, when Guru Nanak Dev jee also accepted Bhagat Ramanand jee as his disciple.
>>>>>>>>>
He also said, the Bible was changed by the infidels, and so God spoke to Mohammad to correct the Christians and Jews who were worshipping God in the wrong way, and if this was the case then Guru ji proclaimed a new faith, which is not valid as Mohammad was the last messenger. I asked him how he knew that Mohammad was the last Prophet, he said he knows because Mohammad was illiterate, a fact proven by literary sources, and the Quran was spoken through him in Arabic, so there was no way he could have tailored it according to his understanding.
>>>>>>>>>
I don’t think Mohammad Sahib was as illiterate as your Muslim friend is telling you. His first wife was a very rich woman and after marriage with her, he became involved in her business. He travelled far and wide in course of his business and trade. He proved to be a very successful businessman. An illiterate person would have never been able to do the kind of business dealings he did with the top business persons of that time. He was involved with the Jews and Christians in his travels to Egypt and other countries. To consider him an illiterate is an insult to his charismatic personality.
Not only was he a charismatic leader, but he was a very intelligent and wise person. This fact can be proven very easily after reading his life history. It is wrong to assume that since he was an illiterate, he could not have written Koran himself. Nevertheless, his illiteracy is not a proof of Koran’s authenticity as a word of God.
>>>>>>>>
Also, he questioned whether Sikhism thought the Guru's were an incarnations of God, he said if not, then why do we bow to the Granth Saheb?
<<<<<<<<<
First of all, it is a fact that Vaheguru himself formed his Guru-form to deliver people from the evil of this world. He formed a Guru-form of himself and this Guru-form (Gur-jyoti) is called Guru Nanak. Gurbani makes it very clear:
JYOT ROOP HAR AAP, GURU NANAK KAHAAIYO||
(That jyot-roop Vaheguru himself came to this world and called himself Guru Nanak)
This verse is from Bhattaan ke Saviyye. I personally believe that all gursikhs should have thorough understanding of Bhataan dee baani. Without this, it is impossible to understand the greatness of Guru Sahibaan.
Bhain jeeo, I suggest that you do more paath and do amrit vela. You said that you are a bit confused after hearing that Muslim guy’s views. Such confusions and weaknesses come only when we have not yet established a relationship with Vaheguru through paath and simran.
Sikhi is a beautiful way to Vaheguru and nothing else comes every remotely close to Sikhi. Where else would you find kirtan of baani? Where would you find sweet baani paath? Where would you find “Vaheguru gurmantr hai, japp haume khoyee”? Protection that “Gur kaa shabad” gives us cannot be found anywhere else.
Our Satguru is an alive vibrant force. Our Satgurus are always with us – GUR MERE SANG, SADA HAI NAALE||. Where would you find such sense of relief?
Another thing that I want to mention to you is that being a Sikh bibi, your closeness to a Muslim guy is not appropriate. Even if you are clean at heart at this time it is still inappropriate for a Sikh bibi to be friends (hanging out together at school or meeting up elsewhere etc) with guys and particularly a Muslim guy. It is not just matter of being clean at heart or fact but one must also be pure in appearance. In appearance it does not look good for a Sikh bibi to hang out with a guy at school or elsewhere. It is not old fashion but this is what Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee have written that such friendships are not appropriate.
I know that I may not have written a political correct statement but I can’t help writing this. Jo hoyegaa dekhiya jaavegaa. Guru Sahib daa aasra hai.
Koi bhul chukk dee maafi.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Why am I Sikh?
True Friend · 23 May 2003
Dear Bibi Gurpreet Kaur Ji
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai Kulpreet Singh has very beautifully portrayed the greatness of sikhi I hope this has gone someway in answering your questions.
I do not agree with the Admin view of not allowing post’s that are critical of Islam.
As long the posts are not offensive they should be posted on.
I am sure (as you your self have stated) that you are not alone in this predicament. Many of our Youth are probably in a very similar situation. The question probably is not that you are lost for answers( because you have given some very good answers in your discussion with your so called friend) , but that the questions are deliberetly designed to make you question your faith. Well let us consider this situation for a moment, why would your friend ( so called ) pose these questions to you when he knows that you could be deeply hurt. Surely a TRUE FRIEND would not even think about posing such questions that would cause deep hurt to a persons belief. The greatness of SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI is that it gives us TRUE guidance on every ASPECT OF LIFE. A great GOD devoted SAINT (Sufi Muslim) Baba FARID JI whose HYMNS are contained in SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI has said that if you desire to meet your beloved (GOD) THEN YOU SHOULD NOT BREAK ANYBODY’S HEART OR HURT THEIR FEELINGS. THE slok is as follows:-
jae tho pireeaa dhee sik hiaao n t(h)aahae kehee dhaa ||130||
If you desire your Beloved, then do not break anyone's heart. ||130||
(panna 1384)
These are words spoken by a Muslim (Sufi) saint who was enlightened by God.
It is also a historical fact that most saints were tortured to death by the so called True muslims. Empror Arungjev considered himself to be a true muslim because he practised all the rituals of Islam, but he lacked any compassion or love for humanity (two of the most important qualities on the path of realising GOD). That is why IN THE NAME OF ISLAM he ordered the martyrdom of SRI GURU TEGDHADUR JI andn Inhumanely tortured to death BHAI MATI DAAS, BHAI DYALA JI and BHAI SATTI DAAS JI. On top this he ordered the killing of millions of Hindues if they did not accept conversion to ISLAM. The Sikh History is full of suffering at the hands of fanatical muslims. But you will not find any example of a Sikh who accepted Islam even when faced with certain Death. The Chote Shaib jade ( the younger sons of our GREAT GURU SRI GURU GOBIND SINGH JI) at the ages of 6 & 8 chose death rather accept ISLAM.
Bibi ji please forgive me but your so called muslim friend does not even know the true meaning of friendship he seems me to be a fanatical Islamic missionary, whose only aim is create doubts in your mind about your faith before encouraging you to accept ISLAM. I say these words with great sadness that we live in a world where people like him have nothing better to do but to hurt other people’s feeling and cause offence to their faith. There are hundreds if not thousands of people like him who have been brain washed by fanatical Muslim preachers into converting Girls and Boys of other faiths into Islam. It is the same preachers who brain washed the terrorists of 9/11. They are promised handsome rewards for there effort in this world and the next.
Bibi ji SIKHI is great and wonderful because it instructs us to be HUMBLE, TRUTHFUL, HONEST, CARING, BRAVE AND HOLY.
A Sikh should never hurt anybody’s feelings
A Sikh should always strive to make friends with those that have Sikhi Qualties.
A Sikh should never go near a person who defames other faiths.
Bibi ji remember you may never win somebody in an argument on which religion is the greatest of all. But remember that ONLY the SIKH RELIGION has the ORIGINAL WORD OF GOD AS SPOKEN THROUGH GURU JI AND CONTAINED IN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. All other faiths books where written many years after the passing of the founder of that particular faith. This includes ISLAM and all other faiths. The SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI was compiled by GURU ARJAN DEV JI and GURU GOBIND SINGH JI.
Bibi ji my request to you is to totally break your friendship with this person and start taking time out to DO sangat of gursikhs, study GURBANI and SIKH HISTORY.
You will find all the answers you require.
Bibi ji please forgive me if I have hurt your feelings. May our Great Guru bless you with True Sikhi.
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh.
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Kulwant Singh · 24 May 2003
Khalsa Soulja, unlike other forums this forum does not indulge in Mohammed bashing. Hardly anyone from other forums (admin edit) answered her questions concerning Sikhism, all they did was just Mohammad bashing in a derogatory way. Kulbir Singh Jee, and Kulpreet Singh Jee, have given very great answers to Bhan-Jee Gurpreet Kaur, which you would not find in any other forum.
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Khalsa Soulja · 24 May 2003
im not questioning the quality of hte replies guys im jus sayin that bhenji has posted her message in LOADS of places.
yes there has been a little mohammed bashing but its not like muslims are innocent. for a fact they convert alot of sikh girls in uk (altho i dont care much since htey arent good sikhs to begin with) and theres alot of muslim sikh tension in areas.
im not stereotyping all muslims but the majority of muslims i know have tried to bring me to islam very subtley or obviously in one way or another
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Gurpreet Kaur · 24 May 2003
WJKK WJKF!
Dear Brothers,
In reply to Khalsa Soulja, this person has made extremely rude remarks about Guru Ji in other forums, my intention of asking this question was not to incite hatred towards other faiths, but I was genuinely appealing to my Sikh brothers and sisters, to perhaps guide me, because the Sangat, even a cyber Sangat is a integral part of our Sikhi.
All my brothers on this forum who have provided answers, I am very grateful to, and yes, I wanted an answer from a Sikh, thats all, not someone who looks for questions such as these as a chance to condemn other faiths, perhaps Khalsa Soulja jee is one of these people, I would urge him to try to respect everyone if he wants to be taken seriously, his remarks against Guru jee were extremely hurtful, and really, unecessary.
However Thankyou everyone, I am truly blessed to have great Sikh brothers out there that can help and guide me in my dilemma, lets try to support our Sikh sisters who are facing similar situations out there, instead of ignoring or condemning them.
Fateh!
Gurpreet Kaur
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Gurpreet Kaur · 25 May 2003
Fateh!
Dear All,
Im writing to apologise to Khalsa Soulja jee, I mistook him for another person, Mr Saqib Virk (he had a similar login name), who was slandering Guru Nanak Dev ji in another forum in response to my post, so many apologies bhaji.
Fateh!
Gurpreet
Ps. Many Thanks to all the Sikh brothers who helped me by answering my questions, I am very grateful, and especially to Bhaji Kulbeer Singh jee and Bhaji Kulpreet Singh jee, who have cleared all doubts I had, so I am indebted to them for their valuable insights :)
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Khalsa Soulja · 25 May 2003
bhenji....thnx.....hope the comments have been of help
if he made bad remarks towards guruji then do u expect for everyone to stay silent on islam? if he wishes to attack sikhis credibility why not attack islams credibility to prove iti s not the sole divine religion as he believes?Gurpreet Kaur wrote:
Re: Why am I Sikh?
Gurpreet Kaur · 25 May 2003
Fateh!
I wanted to convey my apologies to Khalsa Soulja Bhaji, I mistook him for a gentlemen who was being making very rude remarks about Guru Jee on another forum, as he had a similar login name, please accept my apologies Bhaji, I have written this in a previous post, I don't think it was put up.
Gurpreet
Fateh!