Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

converting away from Sikhi?

converting away from Sikhi?

Concerned Singh · 01 Apr 2003

I've been reading a lot about people converting away from Sikhi both in India and abroad. Apparently churches are springing up all over the Majha area with low castes becoming christians. I've read about hundreds of people in UK becoming muslims. One church website even has the testimonial of a former amritdhari in Southall. Why is this happening? If Sikhi is the greatest faith, why are we so small in numbers and losing even more people?

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

SarblohKaurKhalsa · 01 Apr 2003

WaheguruJeeKaKhalsa,WaheguruJeeKiFateh! Quality over quantity! Guru Sahib says again and again that only the fortune ones find this path. Bin bhaagaa (without good fortune), all the rest wander around lost. And you have to think that those people who convert away from Sikhi could never really have been great Sikhs to start with. How could they have been TRUE Sikhs if they lose faith in their Guru, turn their backs on their Guru and leave their Guru?? No true Sikh could ever even dream of doing that. Sikhi IS indeed the greatest faith, but only the fortunate ones will realize it. Most of these converts turn away from Sikhi for mayaa-related reasons. I have read about how Christian missionaries provide material wealth for converts in India, and incidentally, most of these converts come from deeply poverty-striken backgrounds. Coincidence? I think not. In my opinion, even a handful of Rehitvaan Gursikhs is better than a billion self-defined "Sikhs" because Guru Sahib only has pyaar for the Rehitvaan ones who follow Guru Sahib's hukams anyways -- "Rehit pyaari mujh ko, Sikh pyaaraa nae" WaheguruJeeKaKhalsa,WaheguruJeeKiFateh!

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

RoopKaur Khalsa · 02 Apr 2003

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh I totally agree with SarblohKaur bhainji. Only the people that have great kaamaayee can become total gursikhs, and it is one of the hardest paths tp walk on. If a person cannot stand upto the tests that guru ji places his sikhs in, than that means that that person does not deserve to be a gursikh. and its better that those people leave the panth rather than warp it and misrepresent it in the long run. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh ~RoopKaur Khalsa~

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

Kulbir Singh · 02 Apr 2003

I personally believe that we should be concerned about the missionary movements of the Christians in Amritsar Sahib. The Singh Sabha Lehar started as a result of 4 Sikh youths of that time announcing that they were going to adopt the Christian faith. We need to intensify parchaar in the villages of Punjab. Our youth needs guidance and this guidance can be provided by the Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh jee. What we Sikhs need to do is devise a plan to do parchaar in the villages of Punjab and in the cities of India, where the Sikh youth is fast losing it’s identity to the Bollywood stars. They are trying to be like the stars of Bollywood and cut their hair. Our Sikh bachiyaan (bhujangans, daughers) along with the bachiyaan of other faiths are trying to copy the Bollywood stars in everything they do. All this can be stopped if the Sikhs wake up and start doing parchaar. We should not wait for big organizations like SGPC to do parchaar. The singhs of Akhand Kirtani Jatha in India have this responsibility to do parchaar in the villages of Punjab. They should organize camps in the villages of Punjab and try to get Sikhi there. Recently I found out that my Mama jee’s son, who is about 18 years old, had cut his hair. I called him to find out why he had done so and he did not have any answer. He said “otraan hee” (just like that, for no reason). I told him tales of Guru Sahib and the Sahibzaade and he agreed to keep his hair back and wear turban. He also promised to do paath. The problem is that we are not doing any parchaar of paath in India. Why would someone want to keep kesh if one does not have pyaar with baani? The most important thing is to bring baani to the youth. Our youth needs to do paath and we need to teach them that. Unless our youth in India gets connected to Guru Sahib through baani, it is not possible for them to keep kesh. In cities out of Punjab, the situation is much better. The youth there keeps kesh but they too have this bad habit of wearing patkay. They have a one feet long beard but they still wear patkay. This should be stopped. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

observing · 03 Apr 2003

RAJ KAREGA KHALSAAA AQI REHAI NA KOHIIII "quality over quantity"???? IS THIS A PRETEXT ESCAPE OUT OF THE DAILY PROBLEMS THAT R BEING FACED??? INSTED OF TAKING INSPIRATION FROM PAST SIKHS SINGH SABHA AS BHAI KULBIR SINGH HAS STATD ...... WE LOOK FOR THE ROAD OUT COS WE JUST DONT HAVE THE TIME OR DONT WANT TO MAKE THE TIME FOR A UNITED EFFORT TO PRESERVE AND NURTURE THE PANTH FOR FUTURE TIMES...INSTED LETS JUST FOCUS ON OURSELVES.. YEH THAT MAKES SENSE AND PULL OUT A QOUTE FROM BANI TO JUSTIFY IT...THE PANTH IS BLEEDING AT ITS KNEES... ANOTHER 84 CUD COME ANYTIME WITH RSS IN CONTROL DONT WORRY ABOUT IT QUALITY OVER QUANTITY.. WEL GET 1 MILLION RSS HINDU FANATICS AND ARMY TO MASSACRE SIKHS AGAIN OH HANG ON THERES NOT ENUFF SIKHS AROUND TO DEFEND....SINGHO WAKE UP THIS ISNT THE PAST.. NOT ONLYHAVE NUMB ERS GONE DOWN,, PEOPLE DONT HAVE THE SAME SPIRIT.. OUR GURUS SET UP PLACES OF PREACHING WHATS THAT ABOUT THEN??? I UNDERSTAND THE ARGUMENT WE NEED QUALITY BUT Y NOT QUANTITY WITH IT?? HOW CAN U BENEFIT WITH BOTH??? CAN THE PANTH BE VICTORIOUS WITH BOTH OR ONE??? LETS ASK OURSELVES HOW PAKISTAN WAS CREATED?? THE VAST CHUNK OF PANJAB MAKES UP PAKISTAN..THE MAJORITY OF ITS CITIZENS VOTED FOR A PAKISTAN TO BE MADE.... WHAT CUD THE MINORITY OF SIKHS DO???NOTHING... ELECTIONS TOOK PLACE.... THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN WAS CREATED... INDIA WAS MADE.. THE MASSES VOTED FOR IT...SIKHS CANT GET NOWHERE DUE TO THEIR DWINDLING NUMBERS... IF WE WANNA MAKE A CHANGE DEMOCRATICALLY WE NEED NUMBERS TO INFLUENCE THE POLITICAL SPECTRUM. WHEN WE CAN DO THAT,, CHARDI KALA SIKHS WILL BE IN CHARGE OF THE AFFAIRS OF THE SIKH NATION, NO MORE RSS VEDANTIS SGPC BADALS... THE PANTH HAS BEEN GIVEN MIRI PIRI... TO GET TO THAT LEVEL U NEED NUMBERS... THEN WE CAN LOOK AFTER SIKHI AS WELL AS WORDLY AFFAIRS OF SIKHS... TODAY ANTI GURMAT ACTIVITIES TAKE PLACE... WE CAN SIT ON A FORUM,, WE CAN TAKE IT WITH THE JATHEDAR OF AKHAL TAKHAT, NO OUTCOME.... NO PANTHIC RESOLVES.. LEADERS?? PUPPETS OF RSS...THE INSTITUITON OF AKHAL TAKLHAT IS MEANT TO LOOK AFTER SIKH AFFAIRS...ITS NOT HAPPENING Y??? EXTERNAL CONTROL... HOW DO U RID EXTERNAL CONTROL??? HOW DID THESE PEOPLE GET IN CONTROL??? THROUGH SGPC MASS VOTES..... HOW CAN WE CHANGE THAT????PARCHAAAR, HELP PEOPLE GET INTO SIKHI, CREATE UNIFIED AIMS, BUILD NUMBERS, VOTE AGAINST THESE LEADERS WITH ENUFF VOTES TO GET OUR OWN PANTHIC LEADERS IN WHO CAN INFLUENCE DECISIONS ON BEHALF OF THE SIKH QUAM HENCE AKHAL TAKHAT ONCE AGAIN SERVED BY GURUS SIKHS AND NOT DUSHT.... ONLY THEN CAN WE PROGRESS.... U NEED NUMBERS.... RAJ KARGEA KHALSAA.... HOW DO EXPECT TO REACH THIS????VEEROH NOTHING COMES THROUGH SITTING DOWN, WE HAVE TO TAKE ACTIVE ROLES IN OUR PANTH QUAM, COMMUNITY... AND GEAR OUR COMMUNITY TOWARDS GURMAT JUST AS PAST GURSIKHS AS BHAI SAHIB RANDHIR AND BABA JARNAIL SINGH HAVE DONE...IF NOT FOR OURSELVES FOR THE FUTURE OF OUR GENERATIONS.. WHO WILL HOLD US RESPONSIBLE.... WHAT HAVE WE GIVEN THEM???

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

Mkhalsa · 03 Apr 2003

If you ask me this is a useless discussion. Don't get me wrong its not so good that sikhi is losing numbers. BUT this has been discussed and discussed on board after board, group after group for the past few years.. and the same things are said, the same arguments happen, etc, and nothing gets done, so what is the use talking about it again and again?

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

SarblohKaurKhalsa · 03 Apr 2003

WaheguruJeeKaKhalsa,WaheguruJeeKiFateh! Good points made by "observing" and Veer Kulbir Singh Jee. You are right, I was wrong :) WaheguruJeeKaKhalsa,WaheguruJeeKiFateh!

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

Singh · 03 Apr 2003

Kulbir Singh wrote: In cities out of Punjab, the situation is much better. The youth there keeps kesh but they too have this bad habit of wearing patkay. They have a one feet long beard but they still wear patkay. This should be stopped. I agree completely! Patka looks like a joke.. Even if its the very young kids taht do it, it can be tolerable, but the men, 18 - 30 all wear patkas everywhere! I personally think it looks ridiculous. It just looks funny. Dastaar is the best and also rehit, just wear it! =)

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

Mkhalsa · 03 Apr 2003

eheh patkas make these big strong hair men look like they are running around in spandex underwear.. like they are acting like little kids.. it just gives me that impression..

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

sikh · 06 Apr 2003

here is our chance to put the right people in power if we start on parchaar now we have 2004 till the new sgpc elections, with the sgpc split on diff agendas combined with a low turnout on polls, y cant sikhs gather up now and vote for the right leaders to work for the panth in the insitituitions? what can be done in strategies to make this happen? http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20030406/punjab1.htm#43 this is a chance that must not be missed, if it is we shud hang our heads in shame, considering the anti gurmat practices goin on such as inequality of women in seva, corruption etc...

Re: converting away from Sikhi?

Harbhajan Singh · 06 Apr 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh I’ve been thinking a long time about the conversions of Sikhs to other cultures. I would like to point out an observation about this topic. If a Sikh who has practised Sikhi all their life and then turns to another religion then its a sad loss. But if a person who is born out into a Sikh family but has never had true Sikhi exposed to them and then gets converted its a sadder loss. This is because they haven’t seen the beauty of the Sikh religion and Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee's message. Thousands of Sikh families are growing up like this. The parents have basically been converted to a western life(new religion). They don’t have the knowledge of their own religion let alone be able to teach their children. Western so-called Sikh families are trying to get on with life and succeed in this competitive world and see true Sikhi as a hindrance to that material success. I'm not saying that there is no Gursikh families out there. There is but it seems that there is a choke hold on the Sikh community by elder Sikhs who don't see this as a problem. Most Sikh institutions are run by the first/second generation Sikhs who don’t have the communication skills to be able to communicate with the younger generations and keep the Flame of Sikhi alive. I would implore to all young educated gursikhs to go on teaching courses and learn how to take workshops. The study that I’ve been recently been doing is that even other religions woke up to these problems and dealt with them a long time ago. In North America you have thousands of summer camps run by the big Jewish and Christian organisations. Lets applaud them as they are trying to keep their younger generation in their faith and when they grow older they will try to convert others. We need to follow their example and during the past decade the Sikhs have woken up and are holding camps and weekly workshops. Being a workshop leader/teacher im trying to prepare lessons on Converting of Sikhs and SikhiPride. SikhiPride lesson is complete however converting of Sikhs is a little more difficult as the lesson is based on no hatred towards other religions but the Reasons why conversion happens. Its more psychological than a bullet point lesson. I’ve got a huge amount of resources on the other main converting religions such as Christianity and Islam. I would like the sangats view on what they would want to know. This would enable me to make the workshops interesting and varied. Sangats help will be appreciated. Please reply with ideas and constructive thoughts. I will send these lessons to the Admins if they want them for their Parchar of Sikhi. Harbhajan Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa,Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh