Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Santa Singh

Santa Singh

Kaal is eating me alive....... · 18 Jun 2004

Kulbir Singh, or MKhalsa, or anybody who knows.....Could you please educate me on Santa Singh Nihung / Nang (if that's the case) and his status within the panth right now? What type of person is he?

Re: Santa Singh

idunno · 19 Jun 2004

i don't know anything - all i've been told is he's technically the real jathedar of akal takhat, but he can't be because he is a thankhaeeaa and i don't know if he was forgiven

Re: Santa Singh

we · 19 Jun 2004

whats kaal? hatred?

Re: Santa Singh

haha · 19 Jun 2004

hes not the real jathedar of akal takht!! many nangs feel that since akali phoola singh jee was jathedar of akal takht all jathedars of buddha dal must be jathedars of akal takht. sarbat kahlsa didnt and would never choose santa singh as jathedar. the true jathedar chosen by sarbat khalsa is ranjeet singh.

Re: Santa Singh

? · 20 Jun 2004

i love akali phula singh to the max but he seems to be known as that and not " jathedar akali phula singh". is there factual evidence the word jathedar existed in that time? i always thought famous or old sikhs were only known as bhai and their meritocracy appointment in panthic affairs meant they were only sevedars. if im wrong plase correct me.

Re: Santa Singh

? · 20 Jun 2004

and when i say did the word jathedar exist in that time i dont mean for a chief figure of a band of fighters, i actually mean in the sense as it is used today as leader of panthic affairs. i dont see why anyone should have pope like status when it wasnt there in guru jis days. i dont see guru ji appointing anybody in his life as leader of miri piri affairs. banda singh bahadur was a fighter today we have a string of jathedars and committee leaders the system is not working. so what can?

Re: Santa Singh

khalistani · 20 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! santa singh is the current leader of buddha dal nihangs in 1984, he sided with india and built the new akal takht using indian gov. money then that akal takht was torn down, and under the leadership of baba thakur singhje the sarbat khalsa used its own money to make akal takht again santa singh has never apoligized till this day for using indias money, i think he hasnt, last i checked he hadnt bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Santa Singh

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 20 Jun 2004

wasnt he in charge of the rebuilding of harmandir saahib when the govt wanted to support the construction financially?

Re: Santa Singh

khalistani · 20 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! yes, he was in charge then sarbat khalsa tore that akal takht down, and under baba thakur singh jes leadership, a new akal takht was made by sarbat khalsa bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Santa Singh

asaaaa · 21 Jun 2004

akali nihang santa singh is jathedar of buddha dal. he is still one of akal takhats main figures for panthic decisions. no one here can bad mouth him. those of you called him and buddha dal "nang" should be ashamed. they do more good for the panth than all u internet addicts ever will. watch your mouths. no one likes anyone to diss on others whether it be taksal, akj, nihangs, sgpc, khalistani groups, etc... stop hating and promote unity.

Re: Santa Singh

to asaaaa · 21 Jun 2004

to asaaa in 1984, everyone was united, they fought and died united............. except Santa Singh and his buddha dal who choose to side with Indra Gandhi. History can never forget that, and that will always be his legacy, and the biggest black mark on nihangs...... When they were needed they turned their backs and joined hands with our murders. Speak to them about unity first....

Re: Santa Singh

Kaal is eating me alive....... · 21 Jun 2004

is he jathedar of one section of buddha dal or the entire buddha dal? Also, what is his current status within the panth? Last I had heard was that he went to the punj to get pesh and was reaccepted into the khalsa panth.

Re: Santa Singh

A Singh · 22 Jun 2004

Whatever one's views on Nihangs -that is a separate matter. Baba Santa Singh is the Jathedar of the Buddha Dal (who, in addition to the majority of Nihang Dals including those belonging to Baba Nihal Singh believe him to be the rightful Jathedar of the Akal Thakt -again, a separate matter, needless to say a contentious one in today's world). He spent 17 years in excommunication after the Akal Thakt under the command of the SGPC collectively acting as "Sarbat Khalsa" issued an edict against him following his move to rebuild the Akal Thakt using money provided by the Indian Government -this is the again a separate matter, but one which underlies the controversy surrounding him for many considered this to be an unwarranted act, given that the money had come from the same Government that issued orders to attack the Akal Thakt and the Harimandir Sahib. As a consequence of this, in 1987 the SGPC ordered the complete demolishing of the Akal Thakt, Santa Singh had sought to preserve insofar as possible the original components of Guru Hargobind Sahib's Akal Thakt, however the entire structure was under the 'Kar Seva' raised to the ground and rebuilt afresh. He has been subsequently re-admitted into the panth by the Akal Thakt, as stated after 17 years in excommunication, hence presently can no longer be termed a Tankhaiya, particularly if one accepts the original edict issued by the Akal Thakt to be "Sarbat Khalsa", one must therefore treat their subsequent actions as the will of the "Sarbat Khalsa". As one can expect there is some controversy also surrounding his "pesh" to the Akal Thakt and subsequent re-admission, depending on which side you wish to sit on, this and all of the above can be taken both positively and negatively insofar as Baba Santa Singh is concerned and also the SGPC and others during the 1980s who were involved with Sikh affairs and the Akal Thakt.

Re: Santa Singh

Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! Before slandering all Nihangs you should all realise that Nihangs such as from Harian Vela helped the Jujharu Singhs - so maybe everybody needs to do a bit more research of facts before bad mouthing ALL Nihangs. You wouldn't cuss down all AKJ's, or all Tapobaners so why why the double standard?

Re: Santa Singh

remember kaal.... · 22 Jun 2004

"As one can expect there is some controversy also surrounding his "pesh" to the Akal Thakt and subsequent re-admission, depending on which side you wish to sit on, this and all of the above can be taken both positively and negatively insofar as Baba Santa Singh is concerned and also the SGPC and others during the 1980s who were involved with Sikh affairs and the Akal Thakt." Could you please give me more details???? Harpartap Singh , I have utmost respect for Nihungs. I'm just trying to get more info on this person. So much controversy...I want to find the truth.

Re: Santa Singh

nihang or nang · 22 Jun 2004

i find it really funny how nihangs are getting so upset when some people call them nangs. If I remember it was them who started the phrase "nang" when they were making websites about Shaheed singhs. They called the Shaheeds of 1978 and 1984 till today as nangs. Before talking of hipocrisy, nihangs and Harpratap should clean up the nihang websites first..........

Re: Santa Singh

BirRaas Singh · 22 Jun 2004

jathedar akali nihang baba santa singh has been "readmitted" to the panth, so why is there even any discussion upon this? people can bad mouth him all they want for the kar seva that he did, but which was worse? using money from the govt to rebuild akaal takht or grounding the whole of akaal takht, losing EVERY SINGLE original aspect of it, all the frescos, all the foundations, all the art, all the interior architechture, all the craftsmonship, every single thing was lost, a legacy which was build by maharaj themselves, a place which was blessed with the dust of our gurus if anyone is the criminal its the SGPC who under the banner of "panthic kar seva" have lost our original akaal takht, no one can ever bring it back, it may look similar from outside, but it isnt the akaal takht that maharaj made for us ........ ....... :(

Re: Santa Singh

asaaaa · 22 Jun 2004

the websites ARE cleaned of calling shaheeds nangs. you spoke before checking. go.

Re: Santa Singh

Mkhalsa · 23 Jun 2004

>>>>the websites ARE cleaned of calling shaheeds nangs. you spoke before checking. go.<<< yeah, you know why? because they realized youth were dismissing them right off the bat and laughing their heads off at them and calling them nangs. they figured its better to brainwash gradually than come on too strong. it doesnt mean they have changed their views, in fact they are probably worse than ever. they should be shot on sight! hahahha

Re: Santa Singh

tarunjeet singh · 23 Jun 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Bir raas singh - what was even worse was the "Nihung" singhs didn't do anything about all the above mentioned things, SGPC has it's place in Sikhi but what place do the Nihangs hold?? If they are supposed to be the Khalsa Fauj then when the time came when our Holt Akahl takhat was being destryoed where were they??? Like you said our Gurus craftman ship, dust of there feet etc... Where were the so called Khalsa Fauj???? Firstly they don't do nothing to stop the Indian Govt attacking and dstrying Akhal takhat then they go and take money of them and help re-build it agian. Even if Buddah Dal doesn't want Khalistan or wasn't in favour of Jarnail Singh Bhindawala, they should have still fought for all the innocent peopel that died, all the women that got raped. GoIng on from that what about the November riots ??? Where were the "NIhang" singhs then????? SO YOU TELL ME WHO IS THE NANG - THE MAN YOU WAS TO CHICKEN TO DO ANYTHING WHEN HIS FAMILY IS BEING RAPED OR MURDERED OR THE SINGH WHO DIED TRYIGN TO SAVE THEM???? Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: Santa Singh

A Singh · 23 Jun 2004

We are going seriously off the topic now with the recent emotional comments from tarunjeet singh (these are subjects for another thread) and the hate message from mkhalsa (re: shoot them on sight). The question asked what who is Santa Singh and his position in the panth. This has been explained (i.e. Jathedar of the Budda Dal and the Nihangs and readmitted by the Akal Thakt after 17 years of excommunication following the political events of the 1980's). Further details on this front are widely availble on the net in numerous online news sites/archives, so please use those to look further into these two points -as I said before, depending on your personal bias, this information can be used to be pro-or-anti Baba Santa Singh. Finally, mkhalsa, please could you explain what benefit would be derived from "shooting them on sight" as you advocated in your thread. This action seems very politically motived in a facist tone (i.e. elimate forever those you oppose your thoughts and views, something common in history of facist secular and religious cults and organisations, too numerous to list here, but I'm sure everyone is familiar with some examples). You have previoulsy indicated that you approved of a website concerning the UK Nihangs where dolls and other immature means were used to ridicule them, once again totally missing the real issue (the points they raise and preach and the subsequent 'brainwashing' that you describe). All this in light of you having also stated that the issues they raise are easily destroyed and disproved, but no-one has bothered to do this as yet, seems very strange, for if it is simply that people don't care about them and their views, then why are seeing so many threads full of "nang-this and nang-that" and people going to the trouble creating immature websites about them and issuing hate-mail, threats and open indications to "shoot them on sight"? If we have all this time on our hands, why can't we be more constructive and actually look to disprove them properly with constructive argument and logic? Or are the present methods what you would describe as the "gurmat" method of play, seeing that you are a figure that many look up to and emulate (given the references to you on this and other sites)?

Re: Santa Singh

Harpartap Singh · 23 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! Is it any wonder that people do not listen to the views of people when they advocate the murder of fellow Sikhs? BEFORE slagging off all Nihangs why don't you find out the truth about those who gave Kurbania for our Qaum in 1984 and after - they came from Damdami Taksal, Nihang Singh dera's, no dera's, Dal Khalsa, etc etc. Shame on you all who malign Guru ji's shaheed Singhs memory... even though you know what the truth is

Re: Santa Singh

................. · 23 Jun 2004

Now the site takes the piss out of Baba Nihal Singh, these UK Nihangs are bad the. Keep away from them.

Re: Santa Singh

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 23 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Khalistanee veer Ji; You wrote: >>>>>> yes, he was in charge then sarbat khalsa tore that akal takht down, and under baba thakur singh jes leadership, a new akal takht was made by sarbat khalsa <<<<< See www.sikhiawareness.com and this Message Baord Thread DESTROYING SIKH HERITAGE. Santa Singh Nihung was guilty of taking GOI money to rebuild the Akal takhat.....BUT his re-built Akal Takhat RETAINED MOST of the previous artistry/meenakari etc...... the new one built with SIKH MONEY...RAZED EVERY STONE to the GROUND and built a BRAND NEW Akal takhat..... end of our HISTORY and HERITAGE..... the original akal takhat built by Guru Hargobind Ji is now underground !!! See the pictures posted at the Sikh Awareness site whereby sikhs are clambering all over the building breaking smashing it to pieces. I beleive the Kar sewa Babas and the likes are still carrying on OPS BLUESTAR PART TWO by destroying our HISTORICAL GURDWARAS BUNGAS, BHORAS, GURU Janam ASTHaans, etc and WIPING out our HISTORY for all time to come. The GOI "burnt" all our books, birs, historical manuscripts....the BABAS are demolishing all the BUILDINGS.....and building "robot" marble gurdwaras that look alike and have NO HISTORY. This is a BIPPAR CHANIKAYA SUPER PLAN to WIPE out SIKH HISTORY and SIKH MARKERS and mILESTONES from the face of this earth. GS Tohra who escaped Bluestar 1984 carried this out to the full extent. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Santa Singh

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2004

Santa Singh is the jathedar of Budda Dal. He was excommunicated from Panth for his mistake of siding with Indira's government and rebuilding Siri Akal Takhat against the wishes of Panth. After years of solitary living, he submitted before Siri Akal Takhat and was pardoned after tankhaah. Today he has been re-admitted to Panth and as such we should not have anything against him. If someone does not agree with the tankhat meted out to him, they can write to Siri Akal Takhat but now what has been done has been done and we should forget about it. One good thinkg about Santa Singh is his translation of Pracheen Panth Parkash. This translation is a just amazing. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Santa Singh

to harpratap and Uk nihangs · 23 Jun 2004

To Harpratap You mentioned "Shame on you all who malign Guru ji's shaheed Singhs memory... even though you know what the truth is" Is that why you cannot call Sant Jarnail Singh ji a shaheed??? It was Uk nihangs who maligned shaheed singhs, no-one else. Please stick to facts. To nihangs You mention that they have now cleaned up sites. Well that only took 2 years, after the damage was done. Are you also going to re-programme the youth who are filled up with lies against Shaheeds. As far as sites: They may have cleaned up about shaheeds, but what about the meat the narcotics, the "we are part of Hindu nation, not khalsa panth" the idol worship the Hindu Maat and on and on and on ................ Maybe in 10 years, it might be a decent website, after all the cleaning up.........

Re: Santa Singh

BirRaas Singh · 23 Jun 2004

tarunjeet singh, my point was not about "where were the nihangs", its about the actions of jathedar akali nihang baba santa singh, his actions were seen as wrong by the "panth" and suffered 17 yrs of excommunication and had his name slandered, even though he has been "readmitted" no one will give him the respect he deserves, that same stigma will still be attached to his name forget operation bluestar, the main point is what happened after 1984 the sgpc destroyed sikh history, lost every peice of akaal takht that there originally was, hundred of yrs of history lost, and baba santa singh accepted money on behalf of the govt, restored the akaal takht to its near original form, you weigh up which is worse, baba santa singh didnt deserve the punishment they got another good point to make is that the new akaal takht made under the supervision of SGPC is leaking, the roof is letting in water, and since the water has leaked through it ruined old saroops of sri guru granth sahib ji, but its ok, SGPC used the sangats money, SGPC is the panth, SGPC are supreme cos they hold the akaal takht dont let the "baba santa singh is a nang who sided with the govt" blind ur vision, we dont need enemies when our own leaders have no respect for our history, who needs the indian army to destroy akaal takht when we have the sgpc knocking it down themselves, who needs ppl like kala afghana putting doubts into the minds of sikhswhen we have leaders who cut and match gurbani as they please the only enemy of the sikhs is themselves and their paranioa

Re: Santa Singh

Mkhalsa · 23 Jun 2004

A Singh, >>>the recent emotional comments from tarunjeet singh <<< I thought he made some good points. where were this so called khalsa fauj when they were needed? to busy getting high? or too busy attacking their own brothers and sisters? >>>Finally, mkhalsa, please could you explain what benefit would be derived from "shooting them on sight" <<< Haha, not to sound uncaring, but Id probably have a good laugh! (joking) >>>This action seems very politically motived in a facist tone <<< so Im a facist for gurmat, sue me. >>>All this in light of you having also stated that the issues they raise are easily destroyed and disproved, but no-one has bothered to do this as yet, seems very strange, for if it is simply that people don't care about them and their views, then why are seeing so many threads full of "nang-this and nang-that" and people going to the trouble creating immature websites about them and issuing hate-mail, threats and open indications to "shoot them on sight"? If we have all this time on our hands, why can't we be more constructive and actually look to disprove them properly with constructive argument and logic? Or are the present methods what you would describe as the "gurmat" method of play, seeing that you are a figure that many look up to and emulate (given the references to you on this and other sites)?<<<< sachi? before you were on the net, or I even knew of you, I was on daily, hourly arguing with these nangs, disproving them point by point. I know a number of gurmukhs in the past who did this as well. But what happened? the nangs lied, cheated their ways out of it, deleted posts about it, cried that we were making things up (when everyone knows it was the other way around) and when worst comes to worst, they called us nindaks and post their typical gurbani lines showing how bad we are for attacking them. So finally after a month or two of this, I gave up and decided its easier to just call them nangs and laugh my head off everytime i hear anything about them: HAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Re: Santa Singh

Admin · 23 Jun 2004

We had to reject many posts with personal attacks on others. Please maintain the sanctity of the messageboard by not posting inappropriate messages. Admin.

Re: Santa Singh

Sunsingh · 23 Jun 2004

mkhalsa (or others), I'm interested in hearing your point-by-point refutation of snatan ideology. I know more than most about it, but still...I would like to hear a knowledgeable refutation of their points. I believe in the search for truth it's importent to examine all sides. If you're up to all that typing :)

Re: Santa Singh

? · 24 Jun 2004

why dont all of you people get a life........ baba santa singh has been readmitted by akal takhat and pardoned, thus we should now respect them, regardless of what ever happened in the past, lets remember that the same akal takhat that santa singh tried rebuilding with indian gov money is the same akal takhat which Guru Hargobind Sahib vested their power into! shall we also never forgive and respect all those people who our Gurus pardoned in their time on this world, think about it! until we dont learn to start following Guru Ji's hukam we are not going to get anywhere regardless of the fact that say the clergy who are in place at akal takhat may not be doing correct things we still must follow the hukams given! we all with our wise intellects keep going on, but lets remember this is all happening according to WaheGuru and Guru Ji's will, funny how we quote so often on other posts like death etc that we must obey WaheGurus will but on things such as this we forget the hukams...... Please sangat ji lets be more thoughtful and unite and love each other, and apologies for my opening remark and forgive me for anything wrong i said

Re: Santa Singh

A Singh · 24 Jun 2004

MKhalsa Bhaji, Thanks for getting back to me and for clarifying your position, for the benefit of the cyber sangat and those like me who did not have the good fortune to witness yourself and other "gursikh" Bhajis/Bhenjis in action, please could you post here the points which disprove the issues mentioned by the "UK Nihangs" -I'm certain the admin here will not remove them or allow for them to "lie their way of it" -the best thing would be if all the "Gurmukhs" who have the gyan to do this "point by point", please provide these point by point refutations here on Tapoban who all the sangat have it cleared for once and all. I believe there are a series of questions asked on the Sarabloh site, please could you provide the answers to these here, so others can benefit from the hours of daily effort you mentioned that you have put into this and have these addressed appropriately. As per my comments regarding Turunjeet Singh's comments, I never said that they were not worth discussing, I said they were emotional because we are discussing Santa Singh, to which Bhaji Kulbir Singh and myself have provided the answers to allow anyone wishing to look further the basic background by which to start -Turunjeet Singh's questions are better placed for another thread, as the topic is huge and by its very nature, emotional. Finally, I do not have any intention to "sue" you or anyone else, (looks like the California highlife is affecting you too much Bhaji with all these legal court cases surrounding you!), but I'm interested to understand your comment a little more, you claimed to be a "Facist for Gurmat", please expand, on the face of this, it seems no different to say Historically the likes of the Crusaders, who could be said to be 'facists' of the Church, the likes of Mir Mannu and others, who clearly were 'facists' in the name of Isalm and presently various MiddleEastern organisations, like Al Queda and Hamas, who are clearly 'facists' for Islamic causes. As things are rarely what they seem on 'face-value' I would rather you expand upon your comments so to avoid any misunderstandings. Thanks Bhaji. Gur FateH!

Re: Santa Singh

Mkhalsa · 24 Jun 2004

A Singh and Sun Singh, bhai sahib, I dont want to admit it, but I have given up. I have better things to do. I refuse to visit their websites or spend hours and hours typing this stuff becuase I have quite a few other sevas that I am committed too and just do not have the time or mental energy to do it again, arguing and arguing uselessly is a serious drain on ones bhagti. regretfully, i didnt save anything in any arguments against them, neither did others I know, very unfortunate.. if I get a chance, perhaps sometime in the future I can do it.

Re: Santa Singh

singh2 · 25 Jun 2004

MKhalsa "arguing and arguing uselessly is a serious drain on ones bhagti." and saying they should be shot on sight is seemingly OK, yeah right. BTW didn't you post a bunch of quotes about howsikhs must respect each other a few days ago, its always a good idea to really follow what you preach.

Re: Santa Singh

Mkhalsa · 25 Jun 2004

Those nindaks and begurs are not sikhs of guru sahib. They spend their time doing ninda of gursikhs, shaheeds, and guru sahib. They are not sikhs and deserve no respect from any self-respecting wannabe gursikh!

Re: Santa Singh

Admin · 25 Jun 2004

This thread is now closed. Admin