Keertan stage/floor?
@@@ · 17 Jun 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Should keertan be done on a stage or shoudl it be done on the floor? Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
@@@ · 17 Jun 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Should keertan be done on a stage or shoudl it be done on the floor? Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fatheJarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. This stage thingy seems to promote "STAGE"...that is to show the sangat which ragi is performing.... I think in olden days the ragis used to sit on the floor and this means many many can be in the Ragi jatha...instaed now a days only three and at the most six people cn sit on the stage. The Ragi jatha should sit on the floor... the ONLY PERSON sitting on HIS THRONE should be GURU JI......otherwise we have a "hierachy" of sorts.....1St GURU JI, 2nd Ragis.... 3rd Sangat....4th the handicapped/oldsters etc who sit on chairs stools OUTSIDE the Darbaar.... and this is no good. If I am not mistaken Bhai Randhir Singh Ji did his kirtan sitting on the floor. Dass Jarnail SinghSingh · 17 Jun 2004
Does it really matter?khalistani · 17 Jun 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! keertan shud be done at an elevated level whoever is doing keertan shud be higher than the person not doing keertan, reading bani, katha, watever gurmat activities it is involving bani Sant baba harnam singh je used to give his hajorria for the person reading bani to sit on vaheguru bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!S Singh · 17 Jun 2004
I don’t think one can equate a Chadhar to a stage. A Chadhar is not considered elevation from the sangat in terms of height, but it is a sign of respect. The stage on the other hand is a western influence into the Panth. Before the British came in we never had any stages in the Hazoori of Guru Granth Sahib jee. The stage being a British/western influence equates to how a British church has a stage for the priest while he reads out the sermon. Luckily we didn’t copy the way churches have chairs/benches in the main prayer hall. We should let go of non-sikh influences like having a stage and just use the traditional Chadhar.Mkhalsa · 17 Jun 2004
stages are wrong. look at darbar sahib, no stage! even if the rest of the patnh doesnt want to, jatha should follow this maryada. We are doing keertan for/to guru sahib. we are not doing keertan to show off to sangat or to others. When all of sangat can sit with keertani and participate, it is a great atmosphere.kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 Jun 2004
the other thing about the chadar is just that those people who are sitting close to the front have amrit keertan pothis and the chadar is there for extra security against dirt on the ground there are practical reasons for the chadar but definately stage is not a good thing i think this is not something to debate about stages are only for katha , and even then only for certain rare katha mostly keertan should be done in the sangat...... · 17 Jun 2004
but then the problem of non keski people sitting close to the kirtanees arises does it not?! · 17 Jun 2004
Stages are so barring. Only so many people can fit, excluding all the rest of the sangat. When keertan is done on the floor, then the whole sangat can be included rather than drawing boundaries between the keertanees and sangat and rather than making it look like a performance geared to please sangat rather than Guru Sahib. Sangatee keertan is much better anyways.Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 17 Jun 2004
Sangat is usually singing along with the keertan right? Then should they also not be on the stage. so then if everyone is singing along then everyone should be on the stage thus everyone ends up on the same level. Hmmmmm....so Khalistani jee it seems that there is no need for a stage. Respect for gurbani comes from listening to the keertan. We should avoid talking during keertan and try to keep kids under control. Guru maharaj has the gadi what other elevations are required. How can any person sit above the sangat?Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. >>>> but then the problem of non-keski people sitting close to the kirtanees arises ??>>>>>> What is this about non-keski people getting near the kirtanyees ? Are the kirtanyees "brahmins" who will get desecrated or bhitteh gayeh if a non-keski sits near them ?? This is the First time I am hearing such a thing ?? I thought in the Guru's Darbaar ALL are equal and can sit where they please - except that SEWA of GURU JI is excluded to non-amritdharees ( example Chaur Sewa, Deg Sewa, Ardass Sewa, Hukm sewa etc MUST only be done by Amritdharees.Dastardharees ) Dassan Dass Jarnail SinghMkhalsa · 18 Jun 2004
>>>Author: ...... Date: 06-17-04 16:52 but then the problem of non keski people sitting close to the kirtanees arises does it not?<<<< No. >>>except that SEWA of GURU JI is excluded to non-amritdharees ( example Chaur Sewa, Deg Sewa, Ardass Sewa, Hukm sewa etc MUST only be done by Amritdharees.Dastardharees )<<< Veer Jee, I humbly submit that keertan seva (ie leading sangat in keertan) is also reserved for amritdharis, as has been discussed on this forum many times.Singh · 18 Jun 2004
Mkhalsa...you say look at Darbar Sahib because it uses no stage... So if Darbar Sahib does not allow bibiaan to do seva...should we stop that as well?? There is stuff that happens today in Darbar Sahib that is anti-Sikhi. Another example, cleaning parikarma with milk.Hmm · 18 Jun 2004
I thought such people were called Patit? Patit are not allowed to do kirtan sewa?frustrated · 18 Jun 2004
I can understand if you don't want non-keski people to do keertan, that's the Jathhaa's choice and I respect that but you want to prevent them from getting laahaa too !??!?!?!bhagat · 18 Jun 2004
cleaning parkarma with milk is totally traditionJarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Yes I agree that KEERTAN/KATHA SEWA is also reserved ONLy for amritdharees ( at least outwardly dastaardharee/unshorn beard)....and patits cannot be doing such in the Guru's darbar. A GhonaMOna non sikh temporarily wearing a KESRI KESKI/PATKA just for kirtan katha looks even more odd especially when everyone can clearly see that he has freshly shaved his beard....this is BEADBEE of GURBANi and GURMATT. But anyone patit or not can SIT near the Raagis/Kathwachak/ as long as he/she is NOT participating in the Kirtan/katha actively and this I mean playing the tabla/second waja/chhamta/tallian etc. Personal experience has taught me that following this rule has brought many a patit to the GURU as he just cannot resist staying away from participating in the kirtan......if they had been "allowed" to participate as is..they would probably carry on being patitis.. Dass jarnail Singhns · 19 Jun 2004
I wonder what Guru Ji is thinking ?Dogma · 19 Jun 2004
please clarify who a patit is? Is this a just a MONA person, or can the definition be extended to those Singhs who have once taken amrit but have now cut their hair... Who is a patit? [%sig%]Mkhalsa · 19 Jun 2004
Dogma, you have it the other way around. A Patit is one who has committed a bujjar kurait being amritdhari, and this can be extended to monas.Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 19 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. A PATIT can only be an AMRITDHAREE who has committed a Bajjar KUREHIT and needs to be PESH to the Panj Piyaras for decision on readmission to the Panth. Since the Four Bajjar Kurehits consist of CUTTING HAIR KESH...a "mona" could be a patit. A MONA on the otherhand is just a MONA...If he has NEVER taken AMRIT and never been an Amritdharee. A patit is like an AWOL.....but if one has never joined the army then one CANNOT be AWOL. Dass Jarnail Singh.$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 20 Jun 2004
singh, why do u think that cleaning the parkarma with milk is wrong? milk is a 'puvitter' thing, its not dirty or anything. milk is more better than water when it comes to cleaning 'farsh'Mkhalsa · 20 Jun 2004
Milk is pavitar? do you know how much bacteria is in it? do you know that it is actually cow blood mixed with fats and excreted through their nipples. how is milk cleaner than soap and water? this is a brahministic beleif in my opinion.khalistani · 20 Jun 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! milk is crazy they clean nishan sahib using milk sometimes dhaei( yogurt) because like singh is the king said its better than water it has more bacteria that cleans better, something like that bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 21 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Milk is also a valuable food...Indians seem to be very into using FOOD to clean (MILK), BURN HAVAN (GHEE) and lots of other valuable foodstuffs go into the Havan Fires all over India. Again MILK is used to clean up the Ash at a Funeral..... the dead body/ashes is just that ASHES and ends up in the river....cant water be used ??? When everyone in India has been properly fed and taken care of they can burn all the extra food...but with more than HALF a BILLION PEOPLE eating one meal a day of just roti/daal etc it is a criminal thing to waste food like that. I am appalled at the number of children that dont get a spoon ful of MILK needed to survive???? BUT BALTIS of MILK are thrown on FUNERAL PYRES of Indians all over the World. Thats all. I have nothing against any maryada but then another question is that WHY isnt this Maryada of WASHING with MILK carried out at ALL GURDWARAS ??? after all every Gurdwara has the SAME GURU JI Parkash . Just questions.. Dass jarnail Singh