Guru Ji and Hindu gods
no one · 15 Jun 2004
Why is it that Guru Gobind Singh jee praised the Hindu gods so much, but Guru Nanak or the other Guru's didn't?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
no one · 15 Jun 2004
Why is it that Guru Gobind Singh jee praised the Hindu gods so much, but Guru Nanak or the other Guru's didn't?? · 15 Jun 2004
Paaein Gahai Jab Tai Tumrai Tab Teh Koaoo Aankh Tarai Nahee Aanaio Ram Raheem Puraan Kuraan Anaik Kahai Mut Aik Na Manaio Simrat Shaster Baid Sabai Boh Bhaid Kahai Hum Aik Na Jaanaio Siri Aspaan Kirpa Tumree Kar Mai Na Kahaio Sab Tohe Bakhaanio Siri Guru Gobind Singh JeeJinder. · 15 Jun 2004
Guru ji never believed in Hindu Gods per se, but if we look at his bani, he only has faith in Akal Purakh. Dhan Dasmesh Pita Ji. Greatest hero of all time.GSC · 16 Jun 2004
"Many may clam that Chandee Dee Vaar is a Hindu myth and to this statement I will say yes, it is based upon Hindu characters and Hindu mythology. However, Guru Gobind 4 Singh did not intend for this to be read as support of these Hindu myths. It was written to highlight acts of extreme daring and bravery on the battlefield and to show a battle between the forces of good and evil. Let us read this composition as a part of Sikh history and also remember it as an example of the great poetic prowess of Guru Gobind Singh." This is taken from http://www.lotusmedia.co.uk/sikhstudent/Documents/Gurbani/Chandi%20Di%20Var.pdf This site has the translations of chadi di var and has a brief analysisRashpal Singh · 16 Jun 2004
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Guru Gobind Singh Sahib used the names of Hindoo Avatars as metaphors for Vaheguru. He only believed in One Akaal, and as Jinder has stated, had complete and utter faith in only the one.Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004
WAHEGURU jI kA kHALSA WAHEGURU jI kI FATEH. We must also understand the different "historical aspect" of Guru nanak Sahib Jee and Guru gobind Singh Ji.....if both were to write and say and do the same exact thing than why have them both ??? That is why Waheguru sent us 10 Guru Jammeh.....each doing a different aspect of Waheguru's MISSION...BUT with ONE CENTRAL THEME - Absolute BELIEF only in WAHEGURU. Guru Nanak Sahib Jee DISCARDED the Hindu Janeau, Janam and other Sanskaars, AArtee, Castes, Teerath Yatras,Visited all the MAJOR Religious places to bring JAGARTA and Illuminate the TRUTH and DISPELL the DARKNESS of FALSEHOOD and RITUALS... Then the following GURUS ESTABLISHED SIKH Institutions to REPLACE the ones DISCARDED by GURU NANAK...Guur Ka Langgar to kill the false casteism, inequalities, and promote Brotherhood of Man....GURMUKHI to promote the common mans' language and discard the sanskrit monopoly of the Brahmin, Establish Sarovars and Harimandir, write the GURU GRANTH to replace the vedas and bhagwat gita, establish Miri and Piri, establish the Akal Takhat..... etc etc.. Each GURU JI added something to the Exuisite Mala begun by GURU NANAK.....and GUU GOBIND SINGH JI COMPLETED the Task by completing the PERFECT MAN - KHALSA SON OF GOD...for the PERFECT RELIGION - KHALSA religion of GOD...and placed the TAAJ of Waheguru on His Head ... Sabat Soorat Dastaar Sira... It is mischievious to suggest that GURU NANAK and GURU GOBIND SINGH JI are "different" in any way. There is absolutely NO DIFFERENCE in their GURMATT and TEACHINGS. No one can be a SIKH of GURU NANAK without being a SINGH of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI....and vice versa. Guru nanak Sahib Ji's GURBANI deals with His Time and Guru Gobind Singh Ji's GURBANI deals with His Time 250 Years LATER..but BOTH are parts of the SAME WHOLE and with the SAME MISSION ( not an iota of difference.) Dass Jarnail SinghSingh · 18 Jun 2004
Raam Raheem, Puraan Quraan Anaik Kehai, Mat Eik Na Manyo - Guru Gobind Singh Rough translation: Raam Raheem, Puraan Quraan I can mention many such people/scriptures, but I worhsip none of them.A Singh · 18 Jun 2004
Dear Cyber-Sangat, Why are we so afraid to admit that whilst we as Sikhs only worship and adhere to Nirankar Akal Purakh, the presence of devtas and devis in the Dasam Granth (and more that matter in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib -for a simple example re-read JapJi Sahib and also the Sodar) is not denying their existence. All Maharaj is saying is that these devtas and devis are also subject to Karma and Kaal (Death and time) and they too are created by Akal and worship Akal. "Taihee Durga Sajkay, Daita da naas karaya" "You (Akal Purakh) created Durga to destroy the Demons" (Chandi di Var). In fact Devi Devtas, whilst having numerous 'material' benefits as expounded by their related accounts, are also envious of the Human form, for it is only in the Human form that one may strive for Sach Khand. I hope this helps, the presence of Devi and Devtas is natural in the shabds in which they occur, for (a) pointing out as to where their status lies -i.e. servants of one Akal Purakh and (b) learning from their examples as Bhagats of Akal Purakh -this will explain their account in the Dasam Granth. Forgive any errors on my part, A Singh.Mkhalsa · 18 Jun 2004
Also, i think that guru gobind singh jee wrote about a lot of this stuff as a reference for us. Ie all the stories and tales written about in guru granth sahib jee need a context for us that dont know much about hindu mythology and instead of going to hindus for such things, we can learn from guru sahib waht he is talking about. I have heard this explanation from a number of people and it kind of makes sense.avidya · 18 Jun 2004
WaheGuruji Ka Khalsa WaheGuruji Ki Fateh Much of the above alas suggests that some people don't actually understand the word-for-word meaning of even Japuji Sahib, otherwise such statements would not arise; Guru Nanak Dev ji obviously descirbes Nirgun, Nirankar Akaal Purakh in mool mantar and then later relates; 'Gavhi Isar Brma Devi sohani sudaa svaarey Gavhi ind ind-aasan baithay devtiaa duri naalay' and 'Guru Isar Guru Gorakh Brma Guru Parvuti Maai' Yet Guru ji is not talking about nirgun svaroop akaal in these examples. He is describing the devtay. Rather than look to gurbani to support their opinion, I suggest people make their opinion soundly based on gurbani.anon · 18 Jun 2004
i agree with a singh, mkhalsa and avidya. the hindu gods do exist but they also worship akal purakh. and they are just as mentioned in SGGS as SDGS. i think people like to criticise guru gobind singhs bani particularly because there is more "controversy" around it. gurbani is gurbani.A Singh · 21 Jun 2004
Anon, Thanks for your comments. Mkhalsa Bhaji, I note your views, this was something I once shared when younger and it is something that many people argue for, personally I know no longer accept this as valid. The reason being, that what Guru Sahib has written in his accounts of the Avtars is markedly different from what is actually in the 'original' texts from which these are 'supposedly' translations. Just compare Chandi di Var with the Markande Puran, or Krishan Avtar with the Gita/Mahabharat and Ram Avtar with Ramayan and you can see this for yourself. Some may argue now that these are differences owing to Guru Sahib's translations, however I personally disagree for there are many instances where the material is absolutely new or at a tangent from the supposedly original -I consider to be 'revelations' from Guru Sahib about these matters and for me this makes the shabds more than simple translations or accounts, they are Bani from the Mukhvak of Guru Sahib with distinct teachings for his Sikhs. Also the argument that Guru Sahib wrote these as translations also appears to be far too rational an excuse to explain these banis, the stance of their appearence is given clear in the following Chaupai from the Rehras:- "Pritham daro Bhagvat ko dhyana, Bahor kaho kabata bid nana..." (First I recall to mind and meditate on the One (Akal) and then relay the accounts of the various Bhagats as best I can...) Gur Fateh.Mkhalsa · 21 Jun 2004
I agree with you.njsingh · 21 Jun 2004
guru alwayss praised these hindu gods and godesses to TELL A STORY. he praises those who have a story of war, worthy of teaching his khalsa. He remembers all of the reincarnations of vishnu and other devi devtas, to show why akaal purakh sent them down. Each of these gods of war fought corageously and these stories are to inspire bir ras into our khalsa. All of the reincarnations have martial heritage that was profound and unique. it is very very important that sikhs respect the history and stories nd myths of these devi devtaas that guru sahib has outlined. we are not to worship them, but instead worship the stories of war, and remember that even they were doing the work of a higher being -- akaal purakh.A Singh · 22 Jun 2004
nsingh bhaji, I agree with the general stream of your post, however when you state:- "we are not to worship them, but instead worship the stories of war, and remember that even they were doing the work of a higher being -- akaal purakh" I must disagree, we do NOT worship the "stories of war" as you state, but rather Akal only -certainly respect is shown to the Devi and Devtas in their various incarnations as bhagats of Akal, but even in Chandi di Var, focus must be retained on the first 2 pauris when we recall Bhagautee and the Gurus and Akal ("TAYHEE Durga saajke..."). Whilst the remainder of the Var continues with the Ustat of Chandi Mata, the point of it all is clearly stipulated in these first two pauris. I main point to the original post is what makes you think that these Devi and Devtas are "Hindu" when clearly Maharaj challenges that by indicating that they are from none other than Akal. It seems once again, at the mere hint towards our ancient and mythological heritage we become paranoid of RSS and other influences -for me the fact that these appear in our literature should be ample ammunition to use against the false-Hindutva campaigns of the RSS. Afterall, that's how they cause so many issues for us: Use GurBani and pictures/artifacts related to the Sikh Gurus, here we have the chance to counter this, but instead we have teams upon teams of supposed 'progressive' Sikhs who wish to disown this bani! "Ek Roop anek Darshan!"aaaaaaaa · 22 Jun 2004
"Frescos of Hindu gods, including Ram and Krishna, have disappeared during the ‘kar seva’ being carried out by Baba Jagtar Singh at the behest of the SGPC. The paintings of Sikh Gurus, Sikh warriors and religious leaders have been included during the ‘kar seva’ at Darbar Sahib at Tarn Taran. — Tribune photo Rajiv Sharma" (http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1562&highlight=whitewashed+tarn+taran) This is insanity. SGPC is removing the importance of snatan mythology from our culture. We are not to worship anything, but respect it. This is EVIDENCE that SGPC has commanded the artists to remove it all from the walls. (http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20030727/ind1.jpg) The more that our own gursikh sangat says to disown the snatanism from our culture, the more it will disappear. Soon it will be no longer in existance. Then Dasam Granth will look foreign to our next generation of Sikhs. SGPC is being very successful at removing its roots from sikhi even though bani refers to it alll the time.