Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
PUNJABI RIVER WATERS NABBED
PUNJABI RIVER WATERS NABBED
og · 05 Jun 2004
SC orders Centre to construct SYL Canal
Gives govt 4 weeks to set up Central agency
Tells Punjab to pay cost of suit
S S Negi
Legal Correspondent
New Delhi, June 4
In a major boost to the Haryana Government, the Supreme Court today directed the Centre to construct the unfinished portion of controversial Sutlej Yamuna Link (SYL) Canal in the territory of Punjab to facilitate sharing of the Punjab rivers waters between the two states.
Allowing Haryana’s application for implementation of court’s January 15, 2002 order for construction of the SYL in the territory of Punjab, a Bench of Ms Justice Ruma Pala and Mr Justice P V Raddin in its judgement ordered the Union Government to appoint a Central Agency within four weeks for the execution of the work.
The court rejected Punjab’s counter-suit challenging the January 15, 2002, decree of the court by way of which the state was to construct the SYL by January 15, 2003. It also imposed a cost for filing the suit on Punjab, which was not specified in the order and had to be calculated by the Registry.
The court further directed the Union Government to appoint, within one month, a special committee of officials with representatives from both states, Punjab and Haryana, to supervise the construction work, which should be started as early as possible.
The Punjab Government was directed to hand over the land on which the unfinished canal was to be built, to the Central Agency within two weeks of its appointment.
Besides, the Punjab Government was ordered by the court to provide adequate security to the officials of the executing agency and the construction workers to be engaged by it.
The executing agency was directed to prepare a new map of the canal for the area where the job had to be completed on the basis of a fresh survey by keeping in mind that no damage was caused to the green belt falling in the way.
Punjab’s counsel Rupinder Singh Suri, after the pronouncement of the judgement, said that the order passed by the court has gone beyond the arguments forwarded by the parties as only the question of the maintainability of Haryana’s application was argued.
But the court did not agree with his contention and said the arguments had gone beyond this question.
Punjab, in its counter-suit, had stated that in the changed circumstances sharing of water with Haryana was not possible as the inflow in the rivers in the state had fallen from over 17 MAF to nearly 14 MAF during past two decades, while its water needs had increased with more areas coming under cultivation.
Though the court had not identified any agency to be handed over the construction work by the Centre, Haryana, in its application, had pleaded that the work be handed over to the Border Road Organisation.
Haryana, in its application, had said since Punjab had failed to implement the court’s January 15, 2002 order, the Union Government was bound to construct the canal as the Court had made it clear that if Punjab Government could not build the SYL, the Union Government would complete the project.
Punjab in its suit had also raised questions over the Rajiv-Longowal pact, which also included construction of SYL as a condition, saying that several other conditions in the 10-points agreement had not been implemented by the Centre in letter and spirit.
The Centre, in its affidavit, though had expressed its willingness to construct the canal and indicated that it had prepared a contingency plan for the job, but it had stated that without the cooperation of Punjab Government construction would not be possible.
http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20040605/main1.htm
Re: PUNJABI RIVER WATERS NABBED
? · 06 Jun 2004
two things came to my mind from the below articles.
1) sikh farmers from different states have been divided by politics. the gov is so desperate in destroying sikhs in every way it tries its best to do damage in every way possible. First we got split in caste, then groups rehets and now regions and inter states? how much more can we take? When sikhs are facing destruction on all sides they should congregate and collect up together like we did in the past how else do sikhs in india survive? Some people also claim the dsgpc softly approach to the two panthic gadhaars is related to caste politics against the akali dal. If this carries on we are sure to be finished, we need youth geared into religion and politics asap who work for the betterment of the panth united.
2) The second article estimates that 9 lakh hectares will go dry in punjab, did yoiu know the sau sakhis have detailed this land drieing, water shortage hundreds of years ago? why couldnt sikhsfacethe warning signs?why do we always need to let it slip so far where we loose out?
HARYANA SIKH FARMERS HAIL SUPREME COURT VERDICT ON SUTLEJ-YAMUNA LINK
http://www1.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/cms.dll/articleshow?msid=721507
SANGHOYA, Karnal: Majority of Sikh farmers in Haryana on Saturday welcomed the judgement of the Supreme Court giving directions to the Central Government to create machinery for speedy construction of SYL Canal in Punjab .
A resolution passed at a conference of Haryana State Kisan Khet Mazdoor Congress in Village Sanghoya not only expressed happiness over the Judgement but also congratulated Mrs. Sonia Gandhi for installing pro-farmer Government at the Centre.
The conference blamed former Punjab Chief Minister and SAD chief Parkash Singh Badal of creating impediments in speedy construction of SYL Canal in league with Late Devi Lal and now Haryana Chief Minister Om Parkash Chautala. Addressing the conference Tejinder Singh Mann - president of Khet Mazdoor Congress asked Chautala not to indulge into one up manship and instead use his relations with Parkash Singh Badal dissuading him from creating any ugly situation on the SYL issue.
The meeting noted that late Indira Gandhi had laid the foundation stone of SYL Canal in village Kapoori (Ambala District) when Bhajan Lal and Darbara Singh were Chief Ministers of Haryana and Punjab respectively. The Akalis had also agitated then at some distance away where Mrs Gandhi had laid the foundation stone. Police force was used to disperse the Akalis. Later, the Rajiv-Longowal accord was opposed both by Akalis and Devi Lal.
How come, that neither Devi Lal nor Chautala took any concrete steps for completion of remaining portion of SYL even though their friend Parkash Singh Badal remained in the saddle in Punjab . How come that Chautala is claiming credit for this conference questioned. The conference also urged the Haryana Sikhs to take their decision to safeguard their interest and not be led by emotional slogan mongering of SAD and its leader Parkash Singh Badal.
-------
CELEBRATIONS ON SYL VERDICT CONDEMNED
http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20040606/punjab1.htm#18
Chandigarh, June 5
Punjab Ministers Lal Singh, Partap Singh Bajwa, Gurchet Singh Bhullar, Santokh Singh and Sardool Singh, in a joint statement have condemned celebrations in Haryana on the SYL verdict, as reported in the Press today.
The Ministers have expressed their anguish and have stated that Haryana should not be looking for prosperity at the cost of the farming community of Punjab. “The state does not have surplus water and in case any attempt is made to divert Punjab water to the neighbouring states, nine lakh hectares of Punjab land will go dry,” the statement added.
the ministers said that the state government would explore all administrative, legal and political possibilities to ensure that no damage is done to the farmers of the state.