Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

$1NGH · 04 Jun 2004

I know this is a recent trend in the Sikh community, but I wanted to ask everyone who knows of such cases to remember a few things: 1.) Do not forget to support the wife/child. Do not think that you will get in trouble if you ignore the wife/child. If you are going to take a side, take the side of the abandoned wife/child. Do not continue a friendship with a deadbeat dad - he has committed the wrong/paap. Would you want to be friends with someone like that? 2.) Do not use the excuse that "we shouldnt judge people" or "we should use pyaar". You should judge people, and pyaar can only do so much to convince a boneheaded deadbeat what his priorities should be. If people werent judged, then injustices that had taken place in the past would never have been rectified. Where would Indira Gandhi be if she had not been judged? 3.) Do not be afraid to tell the deadbeat dad that he should support his child. As a sikh, it is your duty to stand up for people who have been treated poorly, no matter what the situation is. Guru Gobind Singh Jee demanded that all Sikhs stand up to support the ill-treated as best we can. What did the child ever do to the deadbeat to get treated this way? 4.) Do not think that the father is right (unless the wife has done something really blatant such as cheating). There is absolutely no reason in the world for a father to leave his wife and children. All arguments can be resolved. There is no reason for someone to walk out the door and never return. The child never treated the father poorly, so why does the "father" treat it so. 5.) Do not be fooled by outward appearances. A cholla, big dumalla, big kirpaans, kirtan, simran, ardaas, gatka mean nothing unless your actions and how you live your life support all of that. If it walks like a duck, then it is a duck. A person who abandons his wife/child is not a gurmukh. He has committed a huge sin. He has broken the promise he made when he did the 4 lavaan. Just because this person wore banaa at his wedding does not mean that he will be a great husband. 6.) Do not say that "you dont know the whole story" because even if the whole story is not known, what could justify someone leaving his wife/children? There is no justification for abandoning a wife/child. 7.) Do not gossip. Makes a bad situation worse. 8.) Guys, dont think that you can't talk to the wife just because a.) she is a woman b.) she is "married", or c.) you are friends with the deadbeat. Show her with a couple of kind words that you support her. Play with the children when you meet them. A few words can go a long way. Don't make the wife feel isolated. 9.) To the ladies, dont show support to the deadbeat (I know of cases where this has happened). How would you feel if one day your husband left you, and your "friends" went and gave him support. Remember, THE HOTTEST PLACES IN HELL ARE RESERVED FOR THOSE, WHO IN TIME OF MORAL CRISIS, MAINTAIN THEIR NEUTRALITY (Dante). THis was written by a Christian, but Im pretty certain that it applies to Sikhi as well. Also, think about it this way. Is the deadbeat really a father or a sperm donor?? A father takes care of his responsibilities, whereas a sperm donor just provides the ability to have a child and has no responsibility. I hope everyone thinks about this, and thinks about the consequences of their actions next time they are in this situation.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

... · 04 Jun 2004

I agree 100%

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh · 04 Jun 2004

I agree that if someone abandons their wife for no reason then it is of course completely wrong and deserves to be condemened. But, we must make sure that the husband has in fact really left the wife or has he been pushed away or the wife herself has left and won't come back.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

og · 04 Jun 2004

as per the topic of deadbeat fathers i agree totally people shud be judged accordingly and try to resolve matters and our sympathies shud be with mothers n kids. however we do not reserve the right to be sole judges in all matters we r not God. if we sat and judged everyone n sometimes we were wrong then what? n if we sat here judging then what happens to our own mind? but totally agree when someone committs excesses like ghandi we have a duty to fulfill but only when all means have failed when their is no other option left in such a case that was right.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 04 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I have a very personal stand in this issue. Such a deadbeat has abandoned his wife and child......and his so called "holy holy naam simran doing / SEVA / Waheguru Waheguru on their lips TOTAL HYPOCRITES " rich relatives are not only on the deadbeat's side but also egging him on by supporting his LEGAL initiatives to further abuse this poor woman. A totally GURSIKH Lawyer has come forward to stand shoulder to shoulder with her to help her.. ( BTW this so called "dad" is a just a sperm donor and "woman conquror" 'manhood demonstrator...no way a true dad or a true sikh. Jarnail Singh

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Amritpal Singh · 04 Jun 2004

Gurmat is equal in all ways, to both genders. Some of the above points should also apply to 'dead beat wives' as well. Why single out our Singhs and males, when there are cases of wives/moms who are neglecting there family duties and committments. I know alot of cases where the Singh is Chardi Kaala, and the wife is not, and the Singh is punished because of this. Also vice versa, the Singhni is Chardii kaala and the husband isnt and the wife suffers. My point is, please dont forget all the women out there who have given up on their family life for there own selfish needs and wants. Why just focus only on males. There is always two sides to each story, so to just make a baseless conclusion based on not knowing the entire facts is wrong in gurmat. When there is a problem with two gursikhs, both sides have to be listened too and the facts have to be discussed. After viewing both sides only THEN can you make a conclusion. Sometimes when both sides are known and all the facts presented, your opinion on a situation may change. We must remember that as Gursikhs, we cannot take everything we see at face value, things are not always what they seem.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh · 06 Jun 2004

Amritpal Singh... Im coming from a position where I know both sides of the story...the father is absolutely wrong here... i know of past cases, where i have heard both sides of the story, and everytime, the husband has been wrong...and being punjabis, we initially want to blame the wife...i agree with you on one point...in every situation there is blame on both sides... but there is absolutely no reason for a husband to walk out on his wife/children and never return! a marriage is based on compromise! when you are married, you will realize this. (im assuming you are not married yet) again, you are focussing on husband/wife...but what about the child? in most cases, the husband has abandoned the child...not just the wife...Do not make the mistake of forgetting about the child...in the end, the child suffers the most That is what a deadbeat dad is...someone who has abandoned his child i can guarantee 100% that you wont be able to think of a case where the wife leaves husband and child...i cant think of one in recent past. as far as the wife not going back...the husband can not give ultimatums...that is not called compromise...that is dictatorship...the last few cases that I know of, the husband has made ultimatums to the wife...that can never be acceptable...(men, learn to compromise...women, never accept ultimatums...vice versa applies) living with the husbands family is a punjabi thing...not a Sikhi thing...the wife is not required by gurbani to live with the husbands family...she is required by punjabi culture to live with husbands family...and we all know that there are things about punjabi culture that do not agree with gurbani... finally...how is a Singh chardi kallaa if he refuses to return to his wife...if he was so chardi kallaa...nothign would bring him down, including a non-Chardi Kalaa wife.... based on your tone, i think you are referring to friends of yours...maybe you want to go and sit with the wives of these friends and get the other side of the story before you call your friends Chardi Kalla Singhs"...

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

P Singh · 06 Jun 2004

If man and wife can't get along then that is fine but in noway does this mean that the man should stop being a part of his kid's life.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

... · 07 Jun 2004

Quick question to Abandoned Wife/Child...also to other Singhnees/children abandoned by husbands/fathers Can you highlight your experience...i.e. how do you feel people have treated you and your child compared to how they treated your husband? Who was treated better? Did he leave you for no reason (dont have to specify if he did)? Dont go into specifics if you dont want to...i just want to see if this thread proves what it set out to prove? (i.e. Singhs in these situations are treated better than Kaurs). I think the Sangat could really see how they treat these people, and what can be done to make their situation easier.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

chee chee · 07 Jun 2004

yes, i agree with amritjas singh, the deadbeat women should also be applied the rules above! especially if she runs off with a soola!

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

>><><< · 07 Jun 2004

chee chee and Amritpal jee. its fine to put women up to that standard as well...i agree that women should be treated exactly the same as men... but can you come up with any cases where the wife left the husband for no reason?? the majority of cases involve the husband leaving the wife...that is why the post refers to deadbeat dads...

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

... · 08 Jun 2004

I agree that men and women can both be at fault... I know of women who viciously beat up their husbands and husbands families (mother-in-laws), kidnap their kids, fake suicide to get husbands into jail, get husbands charged by police for no reason, cheat on their husbands, allow their family to steal from their husbands while their husband is at work...and at the same time they wear a dastaar (trust me I'm not making this up...there are some messed up people out there)...they go into gurdwara like they are great gursikhs the husbands of these women do not deserve this...neither do the children...and just as deadbeat dads shouldnt be allowed near their children...children shouldnt be allowed near such psycho parents either...

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

RK · 08 Jun 2004

I also agree with Amritpal Singh's post. Why should the husband always get the blame? Many times the wife is to be blamed as well. You cannot just blindy say, oh the husband is to blame because the child is with the wife. How would you know what the real situation is? You cannot just make rash judgements like that. To do so is narrow minded and against gurmat.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

... · 09 Jun 2004

husbands get majority of blame, because in most cases, husbands leave and do not come back....who abandons kids the most?? husbands wives do not leave husbands/kids as much as husbands do.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Kaur · 09 Jun 2004

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wives do not leave husbands/kids as much as husbands do. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> That doesn't mean that all husbands are "abandoners" at all. One needs to think and know why the husband "left" in the first place. One cannot just go ahead and say the husband is the evil doer in the relationship because usually it is the wife that probably drives the husband away. When conflicts arise, the wife doesn't let the husband anywhere near the child(ren) which becomes the wife's fault. Many think that the father has abandoned his child(ren) when it's really the wife who just won't let the father anywhere near their kids. So the wives that keep the child and father separated are to blame just as much as the "deadbeat" fathers.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

? · 09 Jun 2004

im not married yet and this kind of stuff scares me. i always thought two grown ups can talk about probs, so why does it get to a final stage where things cant be resolved?

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh · 09 Jun 2004

Several reasons... 1.) stubbornness on one side 2.) dont know how to communicate (most important) 3.) both sides are extremely different

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Moorakh · 10 Jun 2004

There's no need to be scared of this kind of stuff. Guru Ji has written our futures beforehand, so this kind of stuff is all in Guru Sahib's hands whether we like it or not. Kulbir Singh Veer Ji wrote something about one's wife/husband in a previous post (can't remember which one). Having a "good" or "bad" spouse relates to our own karma and whether one had a good or bad past with his/her spouse. A couple doesn't always have to "get to a final stage where things can't be resolved". I think it just depends on the 2 individuals in the relationship and whether they are both willing to act like civilized people when it comes to "bumps" on the road.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

... · 10 Jun 2004

Moorakh...so if a wife gets beat up by her husband...she should do nothing becuase it is in her Karma? I think a lot of abused/abandoned wives would disagree... Your view assumes that humans are nothign but puppets acting out a play and do not have any will...which (everyone with a mind will agree) is not really true.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Moorakh · 10 Jun 2004

Bhainji/VeerJi "...", for your information, WE ARE PUPPETS "acting out a play" and Guru Sahib IS THE PUPPETEER who controls and dictates what happens!!! "Kaat(h) Kee Putharee Kehaa Karai Bapuree Khilaavanehaaro Jaanai ||" What can the poor wooden puppet do? The Master Puppeteer knows everything. "Jaisaa Bhaekh Karaavai Baajeegar Ouhu Thaiso Hee Saaj Aanai ||3||" As the Puppeteer dresses the puppet, so is the role the puppet plays. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Gauree Ang 206 There are as well VARIOUS other shabads that tell us that we (mankind) are only the "PUPPETS" of Guru Ji and we ARE just "acting" out roles that the PUPPETEER (ie. GuruJi) has assigned us to play. So, if "everyone with a mind" disagrees with me, you ("...") are also saying that they disagree with gurbaNi which ("everyone with a mind") will surely disagree to. With this, I stand firmly with my above given views.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Kulbir Singh · 10 Jun 2004

----------- Kulbir Singh Veer Ji wrote something about one's wife/husband in a previous post (can't remember which one). Having a "good" or "bad" spouse relates to our own karma and whether one had a good or bad past with his/her spouse. ---------- Just want to clarify this. It is true that all our relationships in this janam are a result of our previous karma. The relationships like spouse, mother, father, brother, sister etc. are there because we owe Karmic debt to them. The karmic debt can be positive or negative. If our spouse and we share a positive karmic debt, then we would have a loving relationship i.e. we would give happiness to each other. On the other hand, if our spouse in this life is our enemy from previous life, then this spouse would give us hard time. Now the question is that if we are stuck with a relationship that is there to pay off negative karmic debt, what should we do? The answer is very simple and is written in Gurbani repeatedly. There are two ways to pay-off our karmic debts. The first way is to suffer the consequences of the karmic debt i.e. stay in an abusive relationship and pay off our karmic debt. When our karmic debt is over, either the relationship will become better or the relationship will break off. The other way and the better way of paying off the karmic debt is to clear off the karmic debt by doing simran, jap Naam and recite baani. Guru Sahib in his baanis writes: GUR KA SHABAD KAATAE KOT KARAM|| (The shabad of Guru, eliminates tens of millions of karma). When we let our concentration touch the sound of Naam and when we let our existing thoughts get replaced by the great thoughts of Guru i.e. Gurbani, our paaps or bad Karma start getting eliminated. The more paath we do, the better our relationship will get. We see the perfect example of Hira Harbachan Singh jee in Ranglay Sajjan written by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. This Singh was a pure atheist in his early age but after his parents and friends did numerous paaths and ardaas to change him, he all of sudden became a Brahmgiyani in a matter of couple of days. This example proves that anyone can be changed through Gurbani. The ones in bad relationships should seek protection and help of Gurbani and Naam. They should seek refuge in Guru Sahib and all their problems will vanish. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh · 10 Jun 2004

Veer Kulbir Singh... I am amazed at your answer. So basically, a woman being abused by her husband has 2 options: stay in the abusive relationship (becasue she deserves it) or do Naam Simran to wipe off your past sins. Going by your logic, the Shaheeds of '84 had 2 options: Sit down in the parikarma at Darbaar Sahib and do Naam Simran or do Nothing (because their past negative Karma dictated that they deserved it). Continuing with your logic, they were doomed by their Karma, so they could only do those things. And we all know that they fought back. Naam simran is important for your past karams...but I think it comes down to self-determination on how your future karams will be.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh too · 10 Jun 2004

I also don't agree with passively handling a bad or abusive relationship. EVerything may be determined by karma, but we've been also given the power of effort. We MUST make efforts to correct or situations and once we've made our efforts, then we can leave ourselves to Vahiguru and his will. But being passive and simply "taking it" is not a noble stand. It is a Hindu concept designed for lower castes and women. We are not powerless. We make our effort and then leave it to Vahiguru to let it bear fruit. And then we accept the consequences as his bhana. But passivity is NOT the way to go.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh three · 10 Jun 2004

Singh, what is amazing about Kulbir Singh's post. He wasn't referring to this specific event, but more to the general concept of karams. If someone is being abused by someone, the obvious thing would be to do something about it. But each situation is unique and it is not always easy for the abused to do something. In those cases, intervention would be needed. The attack in '84 wasn't about karam with the Singhs. It was an attack on a religion and the Singhs were fighting the oppression.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh · 11 Jun 2004

What is amazing the post is that it advises that humans should do nothing even if they are wronged. So what should someon do if their paratner cheats on them (a form of abuse)? Nothing?? The loyal mate suffers because of their past kamaee, but it doesnt mean that they should just sit back and do nothing? Because our lives are determined by our past, the Singhs/Singhnees past determined that they would be at Darbar Sahib. What they did in that situation was determined by them[\b]. God gave us a mind so that we could use it properly for good. Not to just sit back and do nothing when we are wronged. So anybody who has been wronged should be proactive. Do not internalize the situation and say that you can do nothing. Do something useful about it and try to fix your situation the best way possible. I can guarantee you that Kulbir Singhs way of thinking (that we should do nothing because our future is pre-ordained) is not the way things work in the real world! We are higher than other forms of lif because we have been given a mind and will, with which we can work to change and better our future. Our Karms determine what will happen to us. But we ourselves determine what we will do when things happen to us.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Kulbir Singh · 11 Jun 2004

“Singh”, I have been misunderstood here and perhaps my writing style has to do with creating this misunderstanding in you. I did not mean to say that we should not do anything about abusive relationships. I was only trying explain why some relationships are loving while others are hurtful. I think the misunderstanding occurred because of the following paragraph from my posting: “The first way is to suffer the consequences of the karmic debt i.e. stay in an abusive relationship and pay off our karmic debt. When our karmic debt is over, either the relationship will become better or the relationship will break off.” Say one has 100 units of negative debt and one does not do simran. In this case, unless one pays off these 100 units, the abusive relation will not end. One may try but it will not end. One will have to suffer the abusive relationship until the 100 units are exhausted. Of course, while going through this ordeal, one will try many things to save oneself but the bottom-line is that until and unless one exhausts these 100 units, one way or the other, this relationship will keep haunting. One may try going to the shelter house or move out of the relationship but other problems associated with this relationship like custody problems, poverty, court cases etc. will ensure that one suffers the full 100 units. I was just describing the reality of Karma. On the other hand if one does simran and paath and at the same time tries other ways to make the relationship work or do whatever to end the ordeal (according to Gurmat of course), then these 100 units of suffering would vanish at a much faster pace. I did not mean at all that we should not do anything in case of problems. A Sikh is a Karamyogi i.e. does the righteous act while living in the Bhae-Bhaavni (love and fear) of Vaheguru. Again, I repeat that I don’t advocate not doing anything in case of problems. I fully support doing whatever humanly possible and doing naam simran along with it. What I was previously trying to write was merely, how the Karmic debt works. Sorry if this caused any misunderstanding and thank you “Singh” for your sharp eye. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh three · 11 Jun 2004

What should be done if the partner cheats? What would be the gurmat solution to that situation? Saying We do as we are; we become as we do. Bhagavad Gita He who sees the inaction that is in action, and the action that is in inaction, is wise indeed. Richard E. Neustadt Drastic action may be costly, but it can be less expensive than continuing inaction.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Singh · 13 Jun 2004

Isn't it weird how husbands expect their wives to live "properly", but when it comes to their own sisters living "properly" they look the other way??

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Kaur · 13 Jun 2004

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>. What should be done if the partner cheats? What would be the gurmat solution to that situation? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I think the best solution for such a situation would be for the couple to get peshed before the Punj Pyare and ask them what to do. Only the Punj could really help out in such a situation and give the most gurmatly based solution.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Kaur · 14 Jun 2004

The issue I have with a couple sitting with the PANJ for marital problems is that 99.9% of the time the PANJ is all men...can this possibly be fair to the woman and her female /issues/perspective? The answer is NO. I know people with say "get a PANJ with women" but I know from personal experience that in practice this is not allowed. We requested female members to be in the panj and one of the main singhs said "no, if we allow women in this PANJ, then the story will out"... give me a break! This statements is not only degrading to woman but also to the whole idea of the PANJ. It is not fair for a couple to go to an all male PANJ…this needs to change… For example, a couple I know went to the PANJ and their peshi was turning bebek…her husband readily agreed although she was hesitant because she knew it would be a huge change in her daily life…and it was because SHE did all the cooking not him…so there was no impact on him…as he was just eating while she has to do all the preparation because everyone knows the wife has to cook (and this is all to true in the Sikh community)…see if there was a female in the PANJ…she may have understood this and put in place some guidelines that he had equally prepare…but that never happens in our “Punjabi-Sikh” families…

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

what?? · 14 Jun 2004

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The issue I have with a couple sitting with the PANJ for marital problems is that 99.9% of the time the PANJ is all men...can this possibly be fair to the woman and her female /issues/perspective? The answer is NO. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Why would the Punj be biased towards the couple?? Of all people, why would the Punj not treat the couple equally?? Of course the Punj would be fair to the woman and what she's going through! It would be ridiculous and totally against Gurmat if they didn't.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

RK · 14 Jun 2004

I do not think the gender of the panj really matters. What matters is that they should be chardi kalaa, rehit following individuals. If they are chardi kalaa, than they will listen with an open mind and consider both sides, no mattter what their gender is.

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Kaur · 14 Jun 2004

how can someone determine if the person is CHARDI KALA enough??? It is easy to say that gender does not matter, but realistically it does. "what??" you said "It would be ridiculous and totally against Gurmat if they didn't"...well my friend this is happening and yes I agree...it is totally against Gurmat.. Equal representation is required, especially if someone requests a female PANJ or at least a member of the PANJ to be female Chardi kala women exist and should be a part of the PANJ...its simple...if there is a female issue, then a female PUNJ will understand it better than a man... also some woman do not feel comfortable talking about certain issues to men...and why should they be forced to....the solution is to have co-ed PANJ... Can anyone give me a sikhi based arguement against a co-ed PANJ?

Re: Deadbeat dads in the Sikh Community

Admin · 14 Jun 2004

We have a feeling that this thread is becoming a bit too personal. No more posts under this thread will be entertained. If you have personal scores to settle, please do it at some other place. Our stand is that it is manmatt (against Sikhi) to have reservation seats for any gender. To say that one woman or two women must be present in Punj Pyaray is wrong. In the future some may argue that we should have one Chinese and one African in the Punj. Punj are chosen based on merit and seats for them cannot be reserved based on gender, caste or nationality. Whoever qualifies for Punj sewa should do sewa, whether it is a woman, a man, or any caste or nationality. Admin.