Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Need to understand what this is about

Need to understand what this is about

I am lost · 29 May 2004

I need to understand what this site is talking about, I am lost. Please explain to me. http://www.angelfire.com/folk/pothimala/ Did Guru ji wear a Topi?????

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Rashpal Singh · 29 May 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Ive just had a look at the site, and it is a blatant anti-gurmat site. These people are calling themselves Gurus! The Gur Gaddee was given to Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj. No other people. 'Keeta andhar Keet Kar, Dhosee dhos thare.'

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Singh · 29 May 2004

this site is obviously manmat... they seem to have there own guru... direct descendants of Guru Ram Das: 1. GURU RAM DAS SODHI- The Celebrated 4th Sikh Guru. Born-24-9-1534 Died -1-9-1581 2. GURU PRITHI CHAND-Elder Brother of Guru Arjan Dev ( 5th Sikh Guru) Born- 1509 Died-1606 3. GURU MEHR BAAN 4. GURU HARJI 5. GURU HARGOPAL 6. GURU GURDITTA 7. GURU JIWAN MAL – Born- 1694 Founder of Guru Har Sahai in 1745 A.D. 8. GURU HARSAHAI- Born-1725 Died-1750 9. GURU AJIT SINGH [Died 1813] 10. GURU HAMIR SINGH [Died 1834] 11. GURU GULAB SINGH [Died 1868] 12. GURU FATEH SINGH [Died 1879] 13. GURU BISHAN SINGH- [Born 1849] [Died 1910] 14. GURU JASWANT SINGH- [Born 1898] [Died 1971] 15. GURU ATAMJIT SINGH- [Born 1921] [Died 1979] 16. GURU HARESH SINGH- [Born 1946] [Abdicated 1995] 17. GURU YUVRAJ SINGH- [Born 1994] [Present Gaddi Nashin of Pothimala]

Re: Need to understand what this is about

er....... · 29 May 2004

from what i understand these people have there own gurus? and dont recognise any of the gurus after guru ram das ji? is the picture of the pothis of guru nanak dev ji true? come on kulbir singh ji et al.................. answer this pls

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Kulbir Singh · 31 May 2004

First of all, it is totally false that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee used to wear a seli-topi. Siri Guru jee used to wear a dastaar. There are some old but distorted texts that state that Siri Guru jee used to wear a topi. We should not believe such false statements. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written about this and has stated that it is blasphemous to even think that Siri Guru jee used to wear a topi. According to Bhai Sahib, there is an original picture of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee that was drawn by a Musavvar (painter) when Siri Guru jee went to Baghdad. Siri Guru jee is wearing a dastar in that picture and full-fledged beard. This picture is just beautiful and I have saw a copy of this picture many years ago. This picture is different from the one that Nanaksaris preach. As for this site, this site is run by Prithees, who have been excommunicated from Sikh Panth by Guru Sahib himself. Unless the followers of Prithi take amrit, we cannot associate with them. It is a shame that Khem Singh Bedi did rishta in this family. This proves that Khem Singh Bedi himself was a fake sant. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Need to understand what this is about

mmmmmmm · 31 May 2004

on the site there is a photo of devinder singh sodhi (he must have attended one of there functions) the ragi who has loads of tapes and cd's out we should also boycott buying or listening to his tapes

Re: Need to understand what this is about

clci · 01 Jun 2004

first were told that there are no pictures of the gurus then there is a picture of the gurus? which one is it to be?

Re: Need to understand what this is about

GuruSa Singh · 01 Jun 2004

It's strange how they started adopted attaching Singh to their names. Also their appearances changed from Sikh looking to the very strange Hindu look.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

SSBasra · 26 Dec 2004

According to Bhai Sahib, there is an original picture of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee that was drawn by a Musavvar (painter) when Siri Guru jee went to Baghdad. Siri Guru jee is wearing a dastar in that picture and full-fledged beard. This picture is just beautiful and I have saw a copy of this picture many years ago. Is this the picture you are talking about it is at www.basra.com just follows the sikhism link on the left hand side SSBasra

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Sahibzaadeyian dee prernaa · 26 Dec 2004

kkkkkkkk

Re: Need to understand what this is about

kaur · 27 Dec 2004

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh What the hell is Devinder Singh Sodhi doing in those photos? That is disgraceful, seeing as that group is excommunicated. Seeing as he is in UK over the first 2 weeks of January 2005, it would be good if somebody could ask these questions. I'll try my utmost if I get the opportunity. I think he's doing Keertan at Singh Sabha Southall for a few days. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Need to understand what this is about

kaur · 27 Dec 2004

look everyone we can believe what we want but all I know is that Nanaksar has a painting of Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji and Nanaksar is amazing as Baba Nand Singh Ji saw Guru Ji so that picture cannot be fals but the picture that Bhai Sahib Ji saw can still be true if you consider that of course Guru Ji will look different over the years but never can I believe that they wore anything other than a dastar and beard Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Believer · 27 Dec 2004

wjkk wjkf. i was told that Sri Guru Nanak Dev ji wore a topi when he went to mecca i think. Please dont be offended by reading the above... i was told Guru ji did so to go to mecca so that he would be allowed entry or something to that effect. I have only used the word "topi" because others have - it may have been a dastaar tied in a different style, i don't know. And rightly as pointed out already - there is no picture of Guru Ji - so why is this topic relevant?? im just sharing what i was told so please do not take offence. Veer kulbir Singh: you say that certain groups are excommunicated from the panth - exactly what does this mean?? surely we should be respectful to all as God is within all. are these groups not allowed to join sangat?? Please don't be offended - i am just sharing my thoughts. Bhul chuk di khima. wjkk wjkf.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

kaur · 27 Dec 2004

Fateh Jee The photo that SSBasra refers to, which can be seen at Basra.com is amazingly similar to the photo of Guru Nanak Dev Jee that was painted when Baba Nand Singh Jee had Parthakkh darshan. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Need to understand what this is about

khalistani · 27 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! a handwritten saroop of guru je by guru gobind singh je maharaj himself at sackh khand sri hazoor sahib, has the picture of guru nanak dev je and guru gobind singh je in it now, int hat picture, guru nanak dev je is in the famous one with bhai mardana je doing keertan with rabab on left, bhai balla je on left doing chaour sahib, and guru je in the middle with a red seli topi its pretty famous picture the saroop is at hazoor sahib beside the room with all of mata bhag kaurs weapons, and her gun, the one that looks like a cannon so be carefulw hen reffereing to purataan picturres but if guru je did wear one, its because they just laid the main principles of sikhs the foundation, the house still has to be built and finished by guru gobind singh je imagine if guru nanak dev je just came and started pure nihang bana, kirpan, khanda, everything right int he beginning first guru je laid the foundation then guru gobind singh je finished the house u cant just do it all at once u gotta take things slowly bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Need to understand what this is about

mr. singh · 28 Dec 2004

Khalistani, stop spreading misinformation all over the internet. Every little while, you mention some other saroop written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. GURU GOBIND SINGH JI DIDN'T WRITE ANY SAROOPS OF GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. This is a well established fact. Other singhs wrote the saroops, not Guru Sahib. Stop trying to confuse the sangat. Guru Nanak Dev Ji didn't wear a topi. Those are just paintings made according to the artists imagination. Paintings of the guru's made during the 1800's show them with large earings. Did our guru's wear earings? No. The artists simply draw the gurus according to the culture that they (the artists) are living in at that time.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

** · 28 Dec 2004

I like to point out that there is no difference between Guru Nanak And Guru Gobind Singh Jee. Guru Nanak is perfect and everything that they did was perfect.... Seli Topi was the maryada when gurgadhi was being passed up until 6th master which was performed by Baba Buddha Ji. This was changed to miri piri for Sahib Sri Guru Hargobind SIngh Ji.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

khalistani · 28 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! veer je mr singh je i went to hazoor sahib saw the saroop with my own eyes checked around with everyobdy is that guru jes saroop?? they said yes and it was goo look for uereself and wat u mean guuru je didnt write any saroops thas the biggest frekin lie i eve heard wat about guru je little saroop?? who wrote that wat about at barie sangat theres one there too go check ure facts ive seen these saroops by my own eyes there by guru je bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Need to understand what this is about

tankhyia · 28 Dec 2004

vaahe guru jee ka khalsa vaahe guru jee kee fateh prithi chand began his own guruship in the time of guru arjun himself, as did the sons of earlier gurus, and as would the sons of later gurus. dhir mal and ram rai are infamous examples, but prithi chand is particularly reviled in panthic history for his role in the shaheedi of guru arjun sahib and his attempts to assassinate the young baba hargobind (before he was made guru jee). bhai gurdas himself talks about prithi chand and calls him a mentally unstable character. the title of "mina" meaning a scoundrel or deviously dishonest person was given to this group by bhai gurdas and has stuck throughout sikh history. as with all fake daidharee "guru"-ships, such as the other sodhis (of dhir mal and the anandpur sahib sodhis (from suraj mal, son of guru hargobind sahib), the naklee-nirankarees, radhaswamis and namdharis, and all other fake baba groups, they tend to split up at a tremendous rate. it seems every time their "gaddi" is passed down, two new "gurus" are made. this is an obvious result of the fact that these people have not even one ounce of spiritual integrity and are obsessed only with maya and power. thus, the sodhis have split constantly throughout sikh history. guru gobind singh sahib jee when he created the khalsa in 1699 created a list of those people sikhs should not associate with, groups with whom sikhs should not carry out any personal, marriage or business relationships with, in any form. along with ram raiyai, dhir malia, the masands, the minas were a part of the list. thus, to not associate with this group is a hukam from guru gobind singh himself, and is a rule of the khalsa from its very INCEPTION. these sodhis have, however, over time split many many times, and thus, throughout sikh history some have folded back into the panth by denouncing their guruship and taking amrit. sometimes this was not genuine and was a result only of their desire for protection from mughals or afghanis, other times it was so that they could get close to the emerging politically and economically powerful sikh misls of the late 1700's. a group such as the one from the website above need desperately to back up their claims of being the "real" gurus of the sikhs. thus, they either make up absurd and ridiculous stories, such as the namdharis and nirankaris (who have no historical claims on guruship at all) or they create false "relics" in order to "prove" the guruship is theirs. thus, these "relics" are completely false and do not stand the test of scrutiny (which they would never allow anyways). guru nanak's pothi (the one mentioned in bhai gurdas's vaar) no longer exists. the pothis of the sodhis are fakes, blatant ones at that, with garbled and mixed up versions of japjee sahibs that look like nothing more than old and bad copies of bani. the idea that guru nanak, who bhai gurdas tells us lived simply his whole life, would wear jewels is absurd, and goes against all of panthic tradition and history. in addition, the topi idea is pretty damn stupid, and anyone who believes that guru nanak's rehit would be different from guru gobind singh's does not understand the true nature of the guru. the rehit of the khalsa existed from time immemorial, the khalsa has always existed, the guru only revealed it to the world. guru nanak is the embodiment of the khalsa, and the idea of guru nanak wearing a topi would be like guru jee not keeping keas, it is inconceivable, stupid and very disrespectful to even entertain such thoughts. it should be remembered that this lineage has been the cause of much hardship for the panth. prithi chand's evils are well known. his son and grandson wrote a lot of kachee bani in the name of guru nanak, and his son wrote a janam sakhi of guru nanak which is full of brahminvad and has led to much confusion and is the root of many of the fake sakhis of guru jee that are floating around out there, and which sikhs repeat not knowing their true nature. this group also did not allow guru tegh bahadur to enter darbar sahib (hence gurdwara thara sahib near akal takht where guru tegh bahadur did naam simran when he was not allowed into darbar sahib). this group also supported the mughals in hunting down sikhs in the post-guru gobind singh period and were responsible for the shaheedi of MANY sikhs in the dark days after baba banda singh bahadur's shaheedi. finally, from some old persian records i have read, it appears that guru gobind singh sent bhai mani singh and panj singhs at the head of a jatha to take back amritsar in 1700, and that jatha had a small battle with the sodhis from prithi chand's line. they killed many of them and took over amritsar for the guru. in response to "believer"'s post. guru nanak did not wear a topi to mecca, nor did ever wear one for that matter. bhai gurdas tells us in detail how guru nanak looked when he went to mecca, even telling us that guru nanak kept a pothi under his arm, but he did NOT state that he wore a topi. secondly. you state that guru jee pretended to be muslim to get into mecca. that’s a pretty absurd claim to make! the guru is afraid of the religious leaders of mecca?!?! he has to lie and cheat his way in?!?! guru nanak traveled FEARLESSLY around half the world! he faced down hindu, yogi and god knows what other religion’s leaders usually with no one but bhai mardana by his side. never forget that guru nanak sahib jee faced babur, the man who had just conquered all of afghanistan, central asia and INDIA after his HUGE victory which won his the throne of delhi, and he was not afraid to tell babur, to his FACE, that what he had done was immoral and wrong! and you think guru jee would be afraid of some mullahs in mecca! one of the main points of the mecca sakhis is that guru jee was so unafraid and so confident in the truth that he was not afraid to proclaim it from anywhere, even the HEART of another religion! he went to mecca dressed to purposefully stand out, so that people would notice him and come and ask him who and what he was! he wanted to start debate, begin vichaar and tell people the truth about vaaheguru. he didn’t go there as a tourist to take a look around write home about his exciting adventure! concerning his trip to arabia, bhai gurdas tells us that there were two who went. "ik baba akal roop, duja rababi mardana". one is the baba who is the form of the infinite itself and the other is the rababi mardana. how can the guru, who is the roop of vaaheguru! be afraid of anything, or need to hide at all?! about your other point concerning tankhaiyas. there are clear, and have always been, restrictions on who can enter sangat. those who believe in fake gurus, those who believe in caste and believe they are higher than others and do not sit in pangat and eat langar, women who wear veils into darbar, AND those who follow living gurus, all these groups have been barred from entering sangat by the gurus themselves. if one were to stop doing those things then of course, they may enter sangat and interact freely with gursikhs, otherwise, they can not. there are several historic accounts of guru amar das's darbar that describe these rules in context. as to what tankhayai means. it means someone who receives tankha, or a regular wage. there are two theories as to how this word came to be applied to those who are excommunicated from the panth. the first is the fact that sikh "bole" usually puts a positive or amusing spin on a negative thing, as we all well know (sava lakh for example). now, when someone has transgressed and is brought to account and admits their mistake, along with some sort of dharmic punishment (more path or seva, etc) a monetary punishment is also levied. this has become a joke in recent years (one prominent ragi who did kirtan in a mandir was given a 100 rupee punishment, 100 rupees for three ragis!!!). back in the 1700's and even later, when the khalsa was free and sovereign, the punishment was meant to act as a deterrent and a REAL punishment. taking money away HURTS and it makes people think twice about recommitting the offence, so the punishments were harsher, as they should be. the akal takht is after all, the legislative body of the khalsa as well its supreme court and military headquarters. another fake guru, a bedi, who supported the masands who killed all those sikhs at saka nankana sahib who later wished to join the panth was given a tankha of 30,000 rupees, and this was in the 1920's!! a tankha should be balanced to the relative economic welfare of the individual, and it should be a significant punishment. the panth has that power and should exercise it. thus, people who had to pay this punishment were said to be people who were getting their wage, or their tankha, thus putting a positive and funny spin on a fairly negative affair. the other idea of where the word tankha comes from is one that i tend to side with. when the khalsa was persecuted and under attack, especially in the days after baba banda singh bahadur's shaheed in 1719, in the days after bhai tara singh of vaan was shaheed (see the post by the admin of this site from a little while ago to read about bhai tara singh jee), sikhs were being hunted down like dogs. at this time, to work for the government meant you were automatically a SELL-OUT, someone who was anti-panthic, someone who was putting their own monetary situation above that of their guru and cared more about themselves than the panth. it meant you were part of a government, regardless of how low your position was, that was killing sikhs (sound familiar... hint, all those who worked for or still work for the indian government in some capacity). back in those days, most people did not have fixed wage. farmers made what money they could from their crops and livestock. artisans, merchants and traders made what they could from the buying and selling of goods. these people were all self employed. the only people who had set wages were those people who worked for the government and the army (a part of the government obviously). these people received tankha, and were thus tankhayas. they were assumed to be automatically against the panth and were considered patit. this can be seen in relation to shaheed bhai shubeg singh who worked for the mughals (was later shaheed for being a sikh along with his son bhai shabaz singh). when he went to the khalsa to offer them "navabi" (ultimately given to bhai kapur singh of course), he was made to do pesh, give "tankha" and take amrit for his mistakes. his mistake was not in his rehit as we would think of it, he did not consume drugs or alcohol, cut his hair or not do his nitnaim. instead, he worked for the government, and for the khalsa, that was just as bad as anything else, and he was not allowed to even TALK to the khalsa or come to akal takht sahib unless he retook amrit! this brings up another point, which i have been thinking about for quite a while now. one of the only things about the nihangs that they have kept decent, behind all the bhang, pheem and all the other nonsense they are stuck in, is the fact that nihangs don't work for any other government or army and consider themselves to be the independent khalsa. they don't pay for the train or buses because that would be legitimizing a foreign, non-panthic government, and they do not take oaths to anyone but the guru. i wonder, should not all of us do this? (lets not talk about the fat idiot santa and his disgusting sucking up to indira and congress). isn't it wrong to join any army or government, regardless of which country it is. if the guru is miri-piri dai malik, doesn’t that mean that we should be like the jehova's witnesses, and only recognized the sovereignty of the guru, and only recognize the guru as our political leader? it is hard to argue against the political intentions of the guru, what with the akal takht, the nishan sahib, our kirpans and so many other obvious signs of political independence that we STILL uphold today, even if we don’t always understand why. makes you wonder if we've forgotten a pretty important aspect of panthic tradition and rehit, one that the british would have been only too happy to try and get rid of (and which they could have with their buddies, the rajas of patiala and all those other useless "kings".). sorry for about all the mistakes with bani and historical information, which are many.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

. · 28 Dec 2004

Agreeing with Mr.Singh on the little Bharmgyani facts 'khalistani' holds, Pictures are too shown with deceptions of the Gurus with TilaKs.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Javir Kaur · 28 Dec 2004

WELL DONE MR SINGH JI. This spread of misinformation is really getting out of hand. These people write and say things as if " they were right there sitting on the lap of Guru ji when they saw him writing the Guru Granth Sroop"...!!! or IF they werent there in person...then SURE as XXXX their "Brahmgiani baba ji was THERE IN PERSON..and He said SO...and so it is UNWRITTEN LAW !!! what naievity. Build house slowly ?? What a load of crap...GURU JI as early as KINDERGARTEN AGE...TOLD OFF the PANDIT that He was NOT going to wear a JANEAU.... According to khalsitani's "slow theroy" Guru Ji would have said Never mind I will wear the janeau...you know IF I reject the janeau straight away...what will the Hindus think ?? So I better be Slow and WAIT until , GURU GOBIND SINGH Ji has finsihed building the House !!!...then I will throw away the janeayu and wear the KIRPAN GATRA !!! and no one will mind because the HOUSE is BUILT !!! Veers Ji, READ GURBANI carefully ALL the PANJ KAKAARS are mentioned IN GURBANI beginning with GURU NANAK JI....the BHAGATS aslo mention such PRINCIPLES of SIKHI...no body began building slowly and fast... the NEEHAAN of SIKHI were laid BY GURU NANAK...and no body builds a house without STRONG FOUNDATIONS. COMPLETE SIKHI/GURMATT BEGAN with GURU NANAK JI... Guur Gobind Singh ji completed the Task by making it all Official and closed the HUMAN MISSION and passed it BACK to Shabad Guru from which it BEGAN in the First place. GURU NANAK JI would NEVER wear a TOPI no matter what...( IF GURU JI can wear a topi then so can we ?? a Dear and loving father like Guru Ji will never do something and say something else. The PICTURES at hazoor sahib are totally MANMATT and one day when Proper GURMATT prevails there we will REMOVE them just as we removed them from AMRITSAR Harmandir sahib in the 1920s. Veer Khalistani dont get offended..this is my view and nothing personal agaisnt you...there are many things i agree with you. Jasvir kaur

Re: Need to understand what this is about

khalistani · 29 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! bhenji, y wud i get offended learning is a gud thing i myself was veery strongly against the idea that guru je cud ever wear a topi but then after i saw the saroop at hazoor, sahib,, which is by our 10th guuru, i cudnt denie it and tankhia veer je, or bhenji u say guru je went fearlessly true but they wernt gonna start a jang with the musalmans so they cud get in they had to make their point in a way people wud listen and they did that and bhenji thad house theroy is not a load of crap, not my idea btw, a very good singh used it in his katha and even u said u need a strong base thas wat guru nanak dev je they set the base we can say, y didnt guru je wear a kirpan?? then wat will u say guru j never did 5 banis and reheraas og my god and wat u gonna bout 6th, 7th, and 10 patshah having more than one wife u cant be guru je i think ive posted the sakhi here before bhai mardana walks over water, cause guru je told him to say vaheguru half way guru je says some next stuff guru je still walking bhai mardana trys to copy him he starts drowning so guru je tells him on the other side iits the job if a sikhs to listen to his guru not to try to be the guru we arnt gurus and once we get to sant leve, ull find out true for ureslef many sants in sikhis never even took amrit iin khandas sence like sant baba harnaam singh je, sant baba nand singh jes teacher at least i dunt thinkt hey took amrit maybe im wrong but many sants in sikhi, whos names have been mentioned in the sueleman tape, and countless sau sakhis like baba nand singh je didnt wear sri sahib allt he time so are they going to hell? NO WAY trust me bhenji, i used to be very against guru je wearing topi theory i posted ont his thread against it but after seeing that saroop, i cudnt say that anymore its proof right in front of my face that they did wear it bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Need to understand what this is about

SANT JI IS ALIVE · 29 Dec 2004

these ppl r worse den da nirankaris :(

Re: Need to understand what this is about

SANT JI IS ALIVE · 29 Dec 2004

veer ji or panji whu stated -->"Veer kulbir Singh: you say that certain groups are excommunicated from the panth - exactly what does this mean?? surely we should be respectful to all as God is within all. are these groups not allowed to join sangat??" Kulbir singh bhai sahib is write their r five groups of ppl which r not 2 b associated with and the rehat maryada states them very clearly 1)meenay 2)musandh 3)ramraiay 4)dhir maliay 5)gangu shahiya these ppl did varodhi of guru ji and ppl whu hav hatred can posses vaheguru in their hearts but r 2 blind to c dat. these five hiretic cults tried 2 screw up sikhi they changed bani stole money frum sangatand etc... 1)dhir mal started a new gur gadhi 2)ram rai changed bani frum "mitti muslmaan ki" to"mitti bhaiman ki" and guru sahib sed "jin bhaa adab na bani dhara|| janho so sikh nahin hamara|| and rejected his on kin ram rai and sed he was banned frum gur ki sangat there is much more but it is too much and u can find it alll on rehat maryada at www.damdamitaksalmehta.cjb.net or www.freewebs.com/damdamitaksalmehta

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Rupinder Singh · 04 Jan 2005

Dear Sadh Sangat Ji, I have asked Bhai Davinder Singh Ji Sodhi today ( 03/01/2005 ). About the photo in the mentioned site, and they explained to me that they went their because, they was not aware of links with the Pritithi Chand and It was a simple mistake done due to the lack of knowledge. Their was Parkash , Sangat and all the standard setup of Sikh Sangat, they only realised afterwards that it was Pritih Chand’s Cult and Then Bhai Sahib Davinder Singh Ji Sodhi applogiesed to Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, for the mistake which was genuinely made without any knowledge of this places alliance with Prithi Chand Group or Cult. They have asked me to put this message on the site to explain on their behalf so that everybody is clear that it was a simple mistake and they did not had any prior knowledge about the Prithi Chand element involvement with that site. Since then they have never been back to that place again. To be categorically clear Bhai Davinder Singh ji Sodhi only belive in Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and nobody else.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

.... · 04 Jan 2005

are you devinder singh sodhi online spokesman?

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Kulwinder Singh · 04 Jan 2005

No, I was asked by Bhai Sahib to write that reply. if you want to ask them something else then I can ask them on your behalf, they are in England for about next 10 days.

Re: Need to understand what this is about

.... · 04 Jan 2005

OK, this is excellent. Can you ask him where he learned keertan from, and how long did it take him to learn? Also I would like to know how (method) does he learn new shabads?

Re: Need to understand what this is about

Rupinder Singh · 05 Jan 2005

Dear Author Ji I asked your question to Bhai Davinder Singh Ji Sodhi and they was very happy to give reply your question Bhai Sahib told me that He learnt Kirtan from Nanak Sar in India, he said the study never complete , he is still learning, it is a ongoing process. His method of learning new shabads is so that he always tries to sing shabads of the same feelings and rhythm in a function so the rhythm and feelings synchronised. He do look into Rags but modify tunes to suit the need of all the sangat he does this because he like to involve sangat in the singing and doing kirtan with them rather then just listening. Many Thanks Rupinder Singh

Re: Need to understand what this is about

.... · 07 Jan 2005

Thank you for your response! Can you ask him when he will be coming the Canada, Vancouver area?

Re: Need to understand what this is about

lakhvir singh · 07 Jan 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. KhalsaJi, Our Guru is Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and our uniform is of the Khalsa. People will claim all sorts of things, which is nothing new even in this day and age. During the Gurus' times, these very people were against the Guru himself. There was only one Guru after the other, and the GurGaddi passed down through dedication to Truth. The Guru's 'bachan' was everything. GurSikhs respect, honour and follow the word of only Guru Granth Sahib Ji (which contains the writings of the actual Sikh Gurus). Arguments will never cease. Versions of everyone's stories will always find their reasons. But they can never be proved by pictures and claims. People argue about what Guru Nanak Dev Ji looked like, what he wore. But how many of those people follow his shabads? Why dwell on what the Guru looked like and what earthly things they left behind? The Gurus never told us to revere their belongings. All they instructed us was to follow the teachings of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Simple, plain Truth. Nothing else matters. We will waste our time arguing with people who contradict the teachings of Sikhi and of the Khalsa Panth. If one were to understand Guru Nanak, he/she would verily become Nanak. Nanak was a man who even his contemporaries failed to fathom. Even now, people want to claim his spiritual belonging. Where we falter is when we follow our own intellect. That is where we begin to lose our way, and of Guru Nanak. Guru Nanak's footsteps were followed by only nine succeeding Gurus and finally coming to rest in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Instructions of our Gurus are clear. Disassociate with those that challenged the hukam and word of the Guru. The masands misled and expolited the humble Sikhs of the Guru and they (the masands) ended up getting disowned by the Guru. The masands brought it upon themselves their own fate - they lost the Guru by their own deeds. Likewise, in today's age, if we do not live according to the teachings of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to begin with (if we all call ourselves Sikhs), then the Guru will disown us. One who does not believe in the teachings of Guru Granth Sahib Ji must accept the the fact that they claim that the Sikh Gurus did not write even a word of it. As Sikhs of the Guru, we walk a very fine line. We must stay on the path. Lend not an ear to the slanderer or misrepesentative of the Sikh Gurus. The various mushroooming deras, cults and babas can carry on for whatever they believe in. We must keep to our path. Only Akaal Purakh will judge whether what we followed was truthful or not. This is the dark age of Kalyug that has yet many more of its ugly heads to show. Only the Gurmukhs and the devotee of Truth will be delieved when Kalyug exhausts its scaling heights. The rest will be consumed by it. If we study Guru Granth Sahib Ji, we will find the Gurus speaking clearly about all these claimants - babas, self-declared holy men or men of word only, not of deed. Guru Nanak Dev Ji's entire works speak of the ways of the world - and separates truth from falsehood, ritual from true worship. The succeeding Gurus' writings and shabads also confirm Guru Nanak's word. Guru Granth Sahib Ji, thus, is our one and only proof that anything else contradictory to its teachings, is false. Let us not think about the cults that contradict the true Sikh path (of Guru Granth Sahib Ji - which is the one and only Guru of the Sikhs, no one else can claim to be so). We must be aware of what is around us, though. In our slightest slumber, these cults will sneak into our homes and steal off that which we do not guard. We must be ready to stand up against any force that challenges or insults our Gurus' way. Let others be what they want to be, but we must simply learn what we have been instructed to and in due time, we will also sit the test. Whether we fail it or pass it will depend on whether we stuck to the one thing that Guru Nanak Dev Ji and all the other nine Nanaks were dedicated to - the path of Truth. Guru Nanak was the seed and the Khalsa Panth was the fruit. Guru Nanak came to establish and Guru Guru Gobind Singh (as the tenth Nanak) sealed his mission which was completed in the form of the Khalsa. There is no other Nanak now, other than Guru Granth Sahib Ji because in Gurbani he does reside and rest. This is Nanak's shade of the tree of knowledge, under which, if we close our eyes and imagine, he sits in quiet meditation, singing the shabads of the praises of Akaal Purakh. All the other nine Gurus are absorbed in Nanak and Nanak himself absorbed in his Beloved. To understand Nanak is to become Nanak. Baba, O mere Nanaka, assi sab tere hi haan. Bhuleya nu rastay paavo, apni mat sannu vi baksho. Assi bhulanhaar haan, sannu apnay shabad naal jorhlah, Nanaka! Apnay Sikhan nu Gurbani naal jorhlah, nai tah assi ehe janam gavaa behtangey. Kar kirpa, sannu nimarta vich rakhna. Hum nahi changey, bura nahi koi. Sach teh chooth di pehchaan sirf tere shabda vich hi hai. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.