Is falconry fine?
Atma Singh · 12 Jul 2007
VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Khalsa Jeeo, It seems to be an accepted fact amongst the Panth that Maharaaj Jee, at the very least in the form of Siree Guroo Hargobind Sahib Jee and Siree Guroo Gobind Singh Sahib Jee, kept birds of prey. Many people have said that this form of 'hunting' is fine because that prey taken by Maharaaj Jee's falcons/hawks/eagles was given Mukhtee from that incarnation. This to me is an obvious point… However, we know that to this present day, some 'Nihangs' still keep birds of prey. It seems that the Sikhs at the time must have also practised falconry. This is because at the very least they would have been charged with maintaining Maharaaj Jee’s birds which would have involved flying them and more importantly, feeding them meat and most likely taking them hunting themselves. This is because birds of prey need to be flown most days of the week during daylight hours to remain exercised and in good condition. It is also likely that this irked the Mughals. They would have probably, like many rulers at the time, outlawed falconry amongst the ‘lower classes’. In many societies, it was illegal to keep birds of prey without the consent of the rulers. So keeping these birds may have been an act of defiance on the part of Maharaaj Jee. I’m pondering all this because I have always been fascinated by birds of prey and am trying to work-out if it would be ethical if one day i took-up falconry. My current take on it all is that falconry seems to be a suitable pursuit for Sikhs. The bird is doing what it is naturally designed to do – kill prey and eat it. However, the falconer would have to collect these ‘kills’ and probably keep most of them in a small fridge and feed the bird at suitable times. This would therefore not involve killing but would probably involve butchering carcasses. When flying birds, the falconer would be handling pre-butchered pieces of meat in their hands, in order to train/control/reward the bird. This to me is an interesting topic because it would be nice to keep the tradition of falconry alive amongst Sikhs. Whether some of us accept it or not, it seems that the tradition of falconry has been linked with Sikhs for a long time. Many Gurdwara Sahibs have in the past organised falconry displays at Sikhee Camps in recognition of this history. In my mind, falconry is not the same form of hunting as is hunting with a gun – that is unnatural. It is not like killing foxes with dogs – the fox is viewed as a pest and it is doubtful that the kill is fed to a large pack of dogs who would be unable to satisfy their natural hunger for the meat. Eating meat is also not helpful to humans, spiritually-speaking and physically-speaking, humans can do without it just fine. Therefore, hunting for food is also not what falconry is about. Falconry is about a relationship between a magnificent animal and humans, where the animal does what it does naturally, while the human becomes an observer as this animal expresses its nature. To me it seems that falconry can be practised by non-squeamish (!) strict vegetarians like me. In terms of compassion, the falconer would never themselves directly kill an animal although they would be involved in butchering carcasses. They would not be doing this for enjoyment or profit; they would simply be assisting an animal which killed the prey itself to consume it. However, it is this part that I am uncertain about… Does Gurmat not teach that everyone involved in any part of the act must suffer as a result? Therefore, by handling meat, would the Sikh falconer be erring? With the above in mind, in terms of Bibek, who thinks that falconry is fine and who doesn’t? Should Sikhs not take part in falconry for other reasons – would that be wrong? If you are against falconry, how do you reconcile this with not only Maharaaj Jee but also Gursikhs taking part in it, historically-speaking? Can the Sangat please offer their opinions. [%sig%]