Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Seeker of the Truth · 05 Jun 2007

Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EMxA3buFxtg Enjoy.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

onkar · 06 Jun 2007

true sikh can't leave the path of sikhism. This is a case of weak/ fake sikhs. we shld not be worry abt these people. Live long Khalistan [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Jagjit Singh · 06 Jun 2007

Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsaa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fatheh! Pyare jio, personally, I do think this is systematic of our own thinking. We think by teaching our kids keertan, that it will make them solid gursikhs. The reality is often that keertan is a fad for them, unless they progress into understanding of bani. Similarly, we think as long as they are wearing bana, they are good. Again this is also a fad. I believe that we need to engage youth in discussion to make them understand how Gurbani relates to their everyday life. Until they do not understand this, and cannot relate it to themselves, they are open to people from islam coming and doing the same with islam. For muslims, talking is their religion. They do not keertan, and abyass is only done by Sufis. Everyday they talk about islam, and overtime they become articulate in it, which is something that our kids are not. They know how to sow the seeds of doubt. This is why need to get out of the mentality that just because we see dumallas on our kids and they do keertan, that they will be fine and chardi kala. The reality is that they are good, but we still need to do Gurmat vechaar and allow them to relate Gurbani to their everyday life. During the 80s many amritdahri parents had similar misconceptions, but during the 90`s their kids fizzled away. This is because they had sikhi only in bana or peer groups. Only when sikhi is inside do people stay for life. This is why we need to engage our youth more with veechar in set ups like an academy at gurdwaras, or something.else. We should not just assume our kids are going to be fine by learning keertan, going to the odd rainsbhai/camp,etc. Ultimately sikhs do not talk enough about sikhism to them peers and kids. Only with regular discussion will our youth know how to respond articulately when others try and sow seeds of doubt in their minds. In relation to the bibi case. One thing I do not understand is how the parents are being kept from meeting their daughter? Plus is there any actual confirmation that she is amritdhari? Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsaa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fatheh [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Seeker of the Truth · 06 Jun 2007

onkar, you sound like you're in denial. Anyway, there are two solutions of solving this problem: 1) Educating Sikh youths and talking about this issue more openly to the public. 2) Sending a message to non-Sikhs that if they mess with the Sikh community, then they will pay the consequences either by word or by force.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

bebiha · 06 Jun 2007

what wrong with UK?...all the young bibian are goin into Islam...aren't there any awareness campaign to educate the youth on this Muslim tactics?....also educate them, on how to deal with the questions these muslims might throw at their sikhi!?.....something needs to be done..SERIOUSLY! [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 06 Jun 2007

Respectfully, I don't think this is a clear-cut case. Judging from the girl's age, I doubt she has given much time to researching the matter and investigate the Sikh and the Muslim religions. Therefore I think it's safe to assume that there's much more to the background of this apparent 'willing conversion' than has been brought to light i.e. the public domain. Which in turn gives rise to suspicion and doubt as to the motivation of the government propaganda agency the BBC, in reporting the 'approved for public consumption' elements of this 'complete' story which is obviously not complete.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sloughsingh · 06 Jun 2007

Wow...fantastic.....a BBC state government media report once again....British divide and rule at its best...1947 was another nice piece of work by lord Mountbatten but karma deals with these things as he was blown up by the IRA who's last london bomb was at the BBC itself, how uncanny and I think that says it all on my views of the BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/1201444.stm lets see were the reports are on 1984..... wake up sikhs get out of britian

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Man Singh · 06 Jun 2007

Such conversions are result of systematic brainwashing and has nothing to do with sprituality. In some cases even terror also used. Many such cases were reported in Egypt also where christain girls were syatematically chases harrassed and blackmialed to froce them to convert. It is not practical that every child become expert in Baani and sprituality. It takes time and in life sometime or the other a person decides to move on spritual path. But there are some vulture type of people engaged in trapping and converting especially girls. Such acts are like theft in our house. The only way to deal with thiefs and dacoits are : 1. Increase your strenth n security system 2. Expose the dacoits n their motives in society 3. Beat them back if society fail to pressures them to behave nicely. In the name of secularism and multiculturism, people have lost courage to call a dacoit as a dacoit. We are treating victim and culprit equally. Hope our secularists and multiculturist will enlighten how to deal with such vultures.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 07 Jun 2007

Agreed 100% with Sloughsingh on this one. This is exactly how divide-and-rule works. The British don't care for either Sikhs or the Muslims or anyone else. Understandably, they are only ever concerned with advancing their own cause. Punjab pre-annexation was played off using this technique, against the Afghans of NWFP. The British would step in and offer 'protection' to whichever side as in this case ('Soldier Sahibs' by Charles Allen is a must-read), after creating a problem that incited a reaction. I absolutely concur that it's time for us to leave Britain ASAP. As an individual I am making my preparations to emigrate and so should every person of intelligence who sees exactly how foreign and domestic policy and the BBC work hand in hand. Note Margaret Hodge MP's recent comments testing the waters for a racially segregated society. This conversion story is supposed to use us to help them exert pressure on the Muslim community, but I don't think it's had the reaction they expected. Soon we will be played off against the lower classes of white people too, much like in America post-abolition. It's all just a game to the British ruling classes. Beware. You CANNOT beat them at this political game, because they're always careful to make sure they are also the referee.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Dalbiri · 08 Jun 2007

Something funny is going on. Seems like some people in power want to stir things up. Maybe use Sikhs to deflect Muslim anger from themselves?

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 09 Jun 2007

Dear abc2 Ji you have said. “Which in turn gives rise to suspicion and doubt as to the motivation of the government propaganda agency the BBC,” Yob obviously has no idea about BBC. You seem to be full of poison for British Agency that just show your narrow mindedness. Any body who have different view then you seems to you have evil intentions. By the way I do not see any weight what so ever in your comments they are just full of poison and that is the reason I am writing these comments. sloughsingh Ji I suggest you should take your pills as without them you are behaving very mad ! Get help. Dear abc2 ji you also written, “it's time for us to leave Britain ASAP. As an individual I am making my preparations to emigrate “ Please do emigrate ASAP as this is the best you can do for Britain. You also write “ This conversion story is supposed to use us to help them exert pressure on the Muslim community, but I don't think it's had the reaction they expected. Soon we will be played off against the lower classes of white people too, much like in America post-abolition. It's all just a game to the British ruling classes. Beware. You CANNOT beat them at this political game, because they're always careful to make sure they are also the referee.“ You abc2 are really sad and have lot of time to imagine evil in everything and look for conspiracies every where. People you should disregard post from people like abc2 and sloughsikh. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Bhatra · 15 Jun 2007

these girls shouldnt even have to anser any question that muslims are asking them. if a muslim ask a girl a question about Sikhism tell the person to mind his own busness.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 16 Jun 2007

Kulsin you are out of order signing up here and then accusing members of being 'mad' etc. People here do naam simran so are unaffected by various forms of mass 'influence', and are politically minded and without slave mentality. They can make up their own minds without people like you telling them to 'disregard' so-and-so. I reiterate that 'Soldier Sahibs' by Charles Allen is a must-read (smoking gun evidence of how British operations work). Is the BBC a government propaganda agency? There's no doubt about that. Read these and comment: http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/003982.php http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?ItemID=7189 "A study of the four main British broadcasters - BBC, ITV, Channel 4 and Sky- carried out by the Cardiff School of Journalism found that the BBC followed a more pro-government line than its commercial rivals. It revealed that the BBC was twice as likely to use government sources as ITV and Channel 4, and that the BBC also used more military sources than the other channels. The BBC was less likely to use either official Iraqi sources or independent sources such as aid agencies that were often highly critical of the war. The BBC also appeared to significantly downplay Iraqi casualties: Only 22% of BBC stories concerning the Iraqi population were with regard to Iraqi casualties, compared with figures of 44% and 30% for Channel Four and Sky. The BBC was more likely to unquestioningly relay false stories such as the non-existent scud missiles supposedly fired into Kuwait in the early stages of the war as well as the mythical Basra "uprising". The study also made reference to the Prime Minister's claim that captured British soldiers had been executed by the Iraqi authorities, a claim Downing Street retracted the next day. The BBC relayed that claim but, unlike other broadcasters, not the retraction." http://www.camera.org/index.asp?x_context=3&x_outlet=12&x_article=1139 http://leninology.blogspot.com/2005/04/bbc-propaganda.html (govt line on banned weapons used at Falluja) http://www.williambowles.info/media/2005/bbc_iran.html (Targeting Iran) http://biased-bbc.blogspot.com/ http://ed.acrewoods.net/node/182 (Propaganda and the BBC) "The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in democratic society. Those who manipulate this unseen mechanism of society constitute an invisible government which is the true ruling power of our country...We are governed, our minds are molded, our tastes formed, our ideas suggested, largely by men we have never heard of. This is a logical result of the way in which our democratic society is organized. Vast numbers of human beings must cooperate in this manner if they are to live together as a smoothly functioning society...In almost every act of our daily lives, whether in the sphere of politics or business, in our social conduct or our ethical thinking, we are dominated by the relatively small number of persons...who understand the mental processes and social patterns of the masses. It is they who pull the wires which control the public mind." On a final note, we remember Jallianwala Bagh for the honour shown by the Sikh forces and the subsequent slaughter of unarmed civilians under British rule by General Dyer. And the modus operandi of the division of British India too. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sloughsingh · 16 Jun 2007

Dear Kulsin I am not full of poison but full of historical FACTS of what the agencys that make up the 'covert' british government have been up to in the past few centuries and anyone who gives a sh*t to what has happened to the sikhs in history should pay note to the involvement of the 'covert' british powers.......... the british military intelligence during the raj had collated information on sikhs and their mystical power of amrit from which they dervive their power and thus decided was a threat to their empire and must be 'destroyed' yes, 'destroyed'..........maybe this was just the past but seeing what britian has done to Iraq i.e. your average dumb british male just thinks they made a silly mistake and got stuck in a mess not of their making.....no they had been in iraq decades ago and created the country iraq and then after iraq war 1 instead of going on the ground they retreated then used years of sanctions that killed hundred and thousands of their children and crippled the country so when they went in for iraq war 2 it was much easy and boy oh boy is divide and rule rearing its ugly head over there........i judge people on their actions and if britians actions have been that of a right evil b*star* then i will say it...i don't fall for glossy images that countries project of themselves i look at their history.maybe our outbursts were harsh "it's time for us to leave Britain ASAP" but if you are not going to be able to be an amritdhari sikh with relative ease and safety then that is all that is important to an amritdhari sikh the rest of you are safe to stay without any alarm whats so ever i was talking too just amritdhari sikhs and the wearing of kirpan which i believe will be curtailed as much as possible on these shores.......or at least the public will look at you as if you are bin ladens right hand man or a sympatheiser and that is the power of the media that they control hearts and minds against the very site of a khalsa sikh............... every day the media is on the back of muslims which in turn effects me as a keshdhari sikh in the publics perception of me and thus treatment (thoughts/reactions) towards me ,if i cut my hair and go down the boozer like most sikhs in the UK then life can't be better than here in the UK...assimilation...but following sikh rehit is most definitly frowned upon........nothing has been mentioned about the sikh holocoust of 1984 on the bbc ,dear kulsin the bbc do ceebies for kids, they are not evil but a viechle that can be used and for example look into 9/11 and how actual lies can be reported like the passport of mohammad atta found intact and don't get questioned on the mainstream media...what is going on????i don't think you are at an intelligent level to understand that we do not live in a free world and it is a shame that the white population don't see that immigration has been used upon them as a divide and rule mechanism.......dear kulsin please tell me that u are not so niave to think that the media is not used as a tool by the powers at be...........also who created israel slap bang in the middle of all the arabs?.....was this the real final solution???????? look into 1947 and how a none practising 'sikh' was chosen by the british to decide on our behalf in london when they had the likes of Bhai Randhir Singh and hundreds like him locked up..........and yes you are right i do need to take some medicine soon because i am mad and god willing i will get better and stop posting this kind of 'nonsense'?????? and that medicine is AMRIT.then i will cease to care or even see these things popping at me from the newspapers and tv as it is hukam and all good.Waheguru...........

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sloughsingh · 16 Jun 2007

"On a final note, we remember Jallianwala Bagh for the honour shown by the Sikh forces and the subsequent slaughter of unarmed civilians under British rule by General Dyer. And the modus operandi of the division of British India too." Dear ABC2 on a final note please don't praise me or my comments on this forum anymore please,by adding your views and thus morphing my views with yours are not appreciated, because they were not unarmed, they were gurus sikhs and wore 'KIRPANS'............'HONOUR BEFORE DEATH'

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 16 Jun 2007

sloughsingh the phrase is 'death before dishonour' and most of those killed were trying to get away - many by jumping one on top of the other into a deep well. It is unlikely that every man woman and child present there was 'armed' as you put it with kirpans. Furthermore a mass of unorganised individuals doing a peaceful demonstration, some with kirpans against well-trained and disciplined riflemen is not strictly 'unarmed' I accept, but nevertheless a position where they could only find themselves victims of an extremely unfair SLAUGHTER. On a post-final note Sloughsingh, where I have morphed 'your' views with my own??? Rather, it seems that YOU are the one who has morphed YOUR views with mine. Next time ask me first, because to tell the truth I am a polite person and show all people 'respect and gratitude' even when I don't necessarily like them personally (yes this is praise but basically meaningless i.e. empty praise - just being nice), but I don't like people taking my thoughts from my head and passing them off as their own (some 'friendly' sarcasm there). Cheers

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 18 Jun 2007

Dear Abc2 ji, Ok First thing first, I am genuinely sorry for using the word like mad and so on….. I should not have done that but I did and I am sorry . I hope that should be enough to make us friend ( Every Gurusikh is my friend). We can have disagreement and discussion. Some time I loose cool some time you can loose cool but we are all , Sikh of Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. but the centre idea of my point is that every time somebody have difference of opinion with us , we think the worst in them. BBC is known for it’s truthfulness, you are saying they side with British Govt. as far as I remember, even in the years when Margret Thatcher was in office and Falkland war was going on, BBC was very honest about the facts and Margret Thatcher got very angry with them, The last biggest storm to hit BBC was when Blair Govt. accused them of sexing up the Iraq dossier. On many occasions BBC bring very uncomfortable truths about the British Govt. I have no Idea why would somebody think otherwise. You have written the reference of this book, I have spoken to people who openly admit, that they employed the Sikhs on difficult missions in two world wars, not because they wanted them to be dead quite the opposite of it because they knew that Sikhs will be able to achieve near impossible mission. Mr Churchill was a racist bigot but even he admitted that British owe a huge gratitude to Sikhs. That kind of comments from somebody like Churchill play an important note even today when it comes to give rights to Sikhs to carry Kirpan in Britain it is due to the sacrifices made by our Sikh forefathers. You mention Jallianwala Bagh it is the most Dark episode of British history in India. No British person think it was a good thing. What about the good British have done, securing the writings and relics of Sikhs, If it was up to the Sikhs you know would happen to them, Need less to say we have destroyed our valuable buildings not long ago in Takkhat Shri Hazoor Shaib. If you want to go on about the negative impact of British, I suggest you read the recent history and then compare the notes with the damage done then and now. Very ironically BBC have published news today that they need to be more fair in representing some other views rather then Just the Nice, Liberal view. It is not a criticism of being pro Government with hidden agenda it is recommendation to bring the other opinions in the country forward too. Dear Slough Singh Ji, I repeat as above I did with ABC2 Ok First thing first, I am genuinely sorry for using the word like mad and so on….. I should not have done that but I did and I am sorry . I hope that should be enough to make us friend ( Every Gurusikh is my friend). We can have disagreement and discussion. Some time I loose cool some time you can loose cool but we are all , Sikh of Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. You have mentioned Iraq ‘s past Yes, it is true that British created Iraq but you can not keep on going on about the past , British ruled large part of the earth, many countries suffered at the hands of that time of British. We don’t live in the past we live in present and work towards making better Future, Of course the history is a very good tutor, but let’s not twist the history. You have mentioned Why British did not involved Bhai Sahib Randir Singh Ji, My dear brother, Bhai sahib was not a political leader as far as I can tell he never stood as an election candidate, or a holder of an elected office. When British was leaving they were talking to people who was politically active and had mandate to backup, Akali party was electoral party that is the reason they were involved. IF you think Bhai Sahib was not involved is a some kind of conspiracy then British also had lot of Hindu right Winger in the Jails they even had some mandate but they were not the part of the process as you can not deal with the whole of India’s population to discuses the Independence, It had to be done with the leading parties which they did. So get your facts right don’t just make things up and make a case of some conspiracy. You said British wanted to destroyed the mystical power of Amrit, My friend nobody cause damage to us like Mugals did so far, they use to put prize on each of our head, which as far as I know have not happened since then. British gave Sikhs Jobs in Military gave permission to exercise their way 100%, due to that even today A Sikh regiments where ever they go they have a leader in the Troops and you know who is that leader … …. Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Yes that is fact these are things which British accommodated and they became part and parcel of our heritage, need less to say we played back British with our 100% commitment and blood. You have mentioned “nothing has been mentioned about the Sikh holocaust of 1984 on the bbc” Please have a look, http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/sikhism/history/operationbluestar.shtml http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/sikhism/history/history_2.shtml http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/3780105.stm http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/specials/171_afterbluestar/page2.shtml http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/3774035.stm Thing to remember is no BBC journalist was in Amritsar to witness the Operation Blue Star , so how can BBC say some thing like “holocaust” which we know happened but BBC only work on fact which are difficult to prove. You also saying “passport of mohammad atta found intact and don't get questioned on the mainstream media” I think you are listening to too many conspiracy theories which are just fabrication by those who do not want to say Muslims did it. Vir Ji I am sorry to cause hurt to you in my last post or this post my idea is not to cause hurt but bring some rationality when others get too emotional and get carried away. You have said “but following Sikh rehit is most definitely frowned upon.” I say this to you vir Ji, British are not very religious in terms of Eastern values, Yes British is the one who created “Life of Brain” it is fantastic movie but it shows you that British do not mind laughing at religion, but they are non discriminatory, They don’t think Bible is word of GOD so don’t expect something which they don’t do or see same as you. If they look at you with frowned then they also look at the look Vicar with same sentiments. On the another note I would say most of British people don’t understand the difference between Amridhari or No Amritdhar, Kahsadhar or Mona they will just say you are an Asian. So if you feel out of place then it may be little bit to do with you as well. You have said ”dear kulsin please tell me that u are not so niave to think that the media is not used as a tool by the powers at be”””” I am not niave on this issue, when people spend millions on PR it has it purpose and yes you can manipulate the media. But that to say that the press in UK is not independent would be Bazaar and serious mistake. Sikhs don’t have /use these skills, We are less organised, more divided and show no room for open discussions and we are quick to blame other instead of looking into our own problems and be mature about them to find practical solutions. I would like to Say Sorry to both of you again, It is an unconditional sorry and I had my madness the time I was writing, I need to take the Chill pill too. I hope you both forgive me, and take accept my apologies. I stopped writing on this forum while back as I do not want to cause hurt but expression of opinion does that some time, I should not use the offensive language, Which I did use and I am ashamed of it, Sorry. Brothers Bhul Cuck Maf. Sat Shri Akal. Shri Akal Shai !

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

jassmannn · 19 Jun 2007

Kulsin, You have made some very interesting points and I agree with you that people are actively looking for a conspiracy theory, and will look at every source which does not challenge their view. It's time to get real people and open your eyes. Sloughsingh spoke about a covert operation to collate information on the Sikhs because of their powers. Mate, there is just about 20 million Sikhs on the planet. The British were too preoccupied by the 600 - 700 million other people in Indian to be worried about such a small minority. People need to be more progessive and inclusive. If you have a problem with the BBC, why don't you join the corporation and actually see how they operate before reading some random book and staking a claim to the truth. Just for the record, the news for Channel 4, ITV and Channel 5 is all produced by ITN and it is the Sky and The BBC that are the other two main news providers. Please people, don't stake a claim to the facts or the truth, when you have nothing of the kind. Just ideas, some books which really do not constitute the truth.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Dalbiri · 19 Jun 2007

One thing I will agree with is that the Khalsa of today are totally out of their depth when it comes to modern media. They get tossed around as backward pindus in the current set up.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 19 Jun 2007

It's OK Kulsin I'm not angry. I think this topic of BBC propaganda must be a good thing, as it has at least inspired you to join the forum and share your rather strong views on BBC impartiality while seemingly the Khalistan and shaheedi issues are a bit tired now. Likewise, Mr Jassmann is an ex-journalist with some apparent loyalty to the BBC. Here's a quick question for you guys. Ever heard of the Services Sound and Vision Corporation (SSVC)? Kuslin I think there is absolutely [u]no basis in fact[/u] for your repeated claim that I paint people who disagree with me with the 'evil' brush. Not once have I ever done this, and I don't intend to start doing it now. Where have I said anyone is 'evil'? I would never call anyone that. I would use the words 'cunning' and 'treacherous' and 'Machiavellian', but since I do not subscribe to the Judeo-Christian hypocrisies I don't believe in 'good' and 'evil'. I don't think you do either. What was puzzling was this NewSpeak you came up with accusing me of being 'full of poison' or 'spreading hatred'. Why don't you accuse me of being a witch too? Apparently reasoning and evidence is not highly prized on this forum. Did either of you people actually bother to investigate the links I provided? Particularly the one mentioning an academic study of BBC as a propaganda agency? Go back, read and comment. The Director-General of the BBC is a political appointment. That does NOT mean he was appointed by the government of the day whether it be a Blair-led or Thatcher-led government. It DOES mean that he is a hand-picked 'safe pair of hands' selected by the ruling elite. He is appointed by the BBC Trust, a panel of individuals chosen by Royal Charter (a charter granted by the Sovereign on advice of the Privy Council). There is absolutely no question that reporters and workers in news offices lower down the food chain are in any way a part of a 'conspiracy' as you say. Rather, it seems that there is a clear Establishment agenda it has to follow, and the Director-General has to be mindful of that. Of course he can have his political opinions like anyone else, but his job is [u]loyal service to his 'panth'[/u] and everything else is secondary. On the subject of parliamentary democracy, and the roles played by Labour and the Tories in our 2-party political system, this is the meat and 2-veg of the way that the BBC works. First of all, this is just a pointless MOVIE being made and played for public consumption. The British public [u]loves theatre and drama[/u]. The BBC plies its trade as the 'impartial reporter' here in the public politics drama, IN FRONT OF the curtains. There is no difference at all between the Labour and the Conservative parties in this country. Both parties are a part of a pyramidical hierarchy of power. At the lower level, you have individuals such as myself, who are free to join a political party. Sometimes, we can even have jobs as party pamphlet distributors or tea- and coffee-servers in BBC newsrooms (like jassmann LOL), but we're not going to get the top jobs unless we've been vetted on our conditioning imparted by schooling and television. The sign-up-go-knocking-on-doors people are the people who are easiest to control but least useful because they are basically simpletons. Let's call these the 'Outer Party' members. There is a massive difference between the Outer and the Inner Party. The Inner Party can belong to any colour of political ribbon, because his strings are pulled directly by higher powers than the apparent UK executive (the Outer Party get its strings pulled by the Inner Party and not by any higher power). The BBC director-general is an Inner Party member, [u]as is Rupert Murdoch head of Sky[/u](who controls enough of the media to basically lead the public by the nose, so all political leaders need him), and as are MPs on the front bench in the Commons, called the 'executive'. However, the Inner Party itself is not the highest in the food chain. Top of the UK government is the institution of the Crown (basically representing the the noble bloodlines (highest CASTE), and which includes the PRIVY COUNCIL who select the BBC Trust). Above the UK government comes the EU, which constitutionally is placed higher than the sovereignty of member states. EU law has priority. EU policy is informed to the European Parliament and national heads of state by the Council of Europe (collection of foreign ministers). The foreign ministers and the PMs and Presidents of EU get their APPOINTMENTS and then their instructions behind closed doors from the Bilderberg Group. The movers and shakers such as So, when it comes to something that doesn't matter, such as being impartial in the face of the farce of 2-party politics, the BBC is careful to provide a lot of balanced reporting, as long as the INDIVIDUAL Inner Party member whether Blair or Thatcher or some other puppet loses face, but NEVER goes against the greater plan formed behind closed doors. ALL of the Iraq war reporting comes from Ministry of Defence. In some cases, they have created fake news stories and FAKE JOURNALISTS, who the BBC then willingly goes on to present as their journalist and their story, without disclosing the real source. Services Sound and Vision Corporation (SSVC) http://www.counterpunch.org/miller03142005.html http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/summary_0199-1180891_ITM (New Skies signs SSVC for distribution of The British Forces Broadcasting Service to remote bases.(Business)(Services Sound and Vision Corporation (SSVC)) - have to pay for this article) http://www.spinwatch.org/content/view/865/9/ ('BBC Say Fake Journalists Will Not Be Used Again') I also recommend Amandeep Singh Madra's book: Sicques Tigers and Thieves. Regarding what Sloughsingh has been saying, I can't comment. However, posts like this, mentioning that the BBC is nothing more than a propaganda tool, might very well get us locked up without trial, indefinitely, and forcibly medicated and humiliated in the near future. If Jassmann knows as much as he says, then the reason he's saying things which are in favour of the BBC is because he's scared. Look at this: http://economist.com/world/britain/displaystory.cfm?story_id=9262544 The reason injustices happen is because there are spineless people who not only fail to protest against abuses against human rights, but actually attack the KHALSAs who do.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 20 Jun 2007

Dear ABC2 ji, thanks for the reply, I am glad to hear that you are ok with me. You have written: “ Here's a quick question for you guys. Ever heard of the Services Sound and Vision Corporation (SSVC)? “ I am aware of different government channels which give the information out to give the Govt point of view on different matters. Nearly all the armed forces of all countries have their own media which release , news papers, periodicals, some TV documentaries and News for their audiences. So British are not unique in any way in this matte. So I am not sure what your question is trying to achieve? I said “Any body who have different view then you seems to you have evil intentions” and “imagine evil in everything and look for conspiracies every where.” When I said evil it is not some Super natural evil it is evil as social evil, some kind of negativeness. You have said “but since I do not subscribe to the Judeo-Christian hypocrisies I don't believe in 'good' and 'evil'. “ So for you Judeo – Christian have Hypocrisies is that a coming from a Sikh who’s Guru Say , “ We are not good and nobody is bad “ So you do not see anything They have done which have made this world better place ? You have said “What was puzzling was this NewSpeak you came up with accusing me of being 'full of poison' or 'spreading hatred'. “ I don’t think the above remarks are full of Love, do you ? I said “Any body who have different view then you seems to you have evil intentions” and “imagine evil in everything and look for conspiracies every where.” Dear Vir Ji you have written “ Did either of you people actually bother to investigate the links I provided? Particularly the one mentioning an academic study of BBC as a propaganda agency? Go back, read and comment.” I went to these sites and I can see they have produced some work suggesting your point of view, Can you tell me do you have any News Agency in the world which you think tell the truth ? Reply me this question and I will answer your request of comments in detail. Please do this . You have written “ The Director-General of the BBC is a political appointment. That does NOT mean he was appointed by the government of the day whether it be a Blair-led or Thatcher-led government. It DOES mean that he is a hand-picked 'safe pair of hands' selected by the ruling elite. He is appointed by the BBC Trust, a panel of individuals chosen by Royal Charter (a charter granted by the Sovereign on advice of the Privy Council). There is absolutely no question that reporters and workers in news offices lower down the food chain are in any way a part of a 'conspiracy' as you say. Rather, it seems that there is a clear Establishment agenda it has to follow, and the Director-General has to be mindful of that. Of course he can have his political opinions like anyone else, but his job is loyal service to his 'panth' and everything else is secondary.” I think the point you are making is based on your understanding that if a person is appointed by people who have close link with some power full people then the person will be baised. I think Vir ji humanity have shown in the history that people can and do behave honestly providing they are Honest, You can ask for a democratic elected leader of BBC by people and then that person can be Biased, and then you can have a appointed person who can be fair. In Britain we have house of Lord which Tony Blair has damaged quite badly, but the Lords were in the house from generation to generation, although hereditary system is difficult to defend, but these Lords were more independent then you can think, they defected many Govt, for Human right related issues in Britain. Now how can you explain that with your point of view that these kind people can not be independent and people always are biased. I think it is an Indian illness that they can not imagine to be Independent. Now listen to your self what you are saying “ …………………………………………….. “ but we're not going to get the top jobs unless we've been vetted on our conditioning imparted by schooling and television. The sign-up-go-knocking-on-doors people are the people who are easiest to control but least useful because they are basically simpletons. Let's call these the 'Outer Party' members. There is a massive difference between the Outer and the Inner Party. The Inner Party can belong to any colour of political ribbon, because his strings are pulled directly by higher powers than the apparent UK executive (the Outer Party get its strings pulled by the Inner Party and not by any higher power). The BBC director-general is an Inner Party member, as is Rupert Murdoch head of Sky(who controls enough of the media to basically lead the public by the nose, so all political leaders need him), and as are MPs on the front bench in the Commons, called the 'executive'. However, the Inner Party itself is not the highest in the food chain. Top of the UK government is the institution of the Crown (basically representing the noble bloodlines (highest CASTE), and which includes the PRIVY COUNCIL who select the BBC Trust). Above the UK government comes the EU, which constitutionally is placed higher than the sovereignty of member states. EU law has priority. EU policy is informed to the European Parliament and national heads of state by the Council of Europe (collection of foreign ministers). The foreign ministers and the PMs and Presidents of EU get their APPOINTMENTS and then their instructions behind closed doors from the Bilderberg Group. The movers and shakers such as So, when it comes to something that doesn't matter, such as being impartial in the face of the farce of 2-party politics, the BBC is careful to provide a lot of balanced reporting, as long as the INDIVIDUAL Inner Party member whether Blair or Thatcher or some other puppet loses face, but NEVER goes against the greater plan formed behind closed doors. ALL of the Iraq war reporting comes from Ministry of Defence. ……………………………………………………………………..’’’ Now if the above is not proving my point when I say “have lot of time to imagine evil in everything and look for conspiracies every where.” Then I don’t know what to say to you. You have mentioned FAKE JOURNALISTS, http://www.counterpunch.org/miller03142005.html Yeh who say that BBC can not make a mistake ? the point is not the BBC can not be wrong , it is the intention and some hidden agenda I object. Also BBC make mistakes very rarely . I have not read the book of “Amandeep Singh Madra's book: Sicques Tigers and Thieves.” And I can not promise to read this as there are many other things to do , and I am busy with at this stage. You have give the valid link as http://economist.com/world/britain/displaystory.cfm?story_id=9262544 But that is not proven yet at all to have caused the things you are mentioning, yes it seems it can be abused but we have to wait and see if this happen inform me if you come to any thing like that, I promise to do what ever I can to raise the people’s awareness about if the abuse of this power happen, But I seriously doubt it. You have written “The reason injustices happen is because there are spineless people who not only fail to protest against abuses against human rights, but actually attack the KHALSAs who do.” I would like to get clarification from you that the last comments are just general comments , you are not pointing at me that I have attacked the Khalsa ? I would like to say that reason Injustice happen is also because people don’t want to share the human values and join together to combat the Human Right abusers. It is much easier to demonise other, degrade other, think less of other and treat other as dumb wit , lower or consider your self above other then by default there is us and them then, their suffering is not our suffering so it is ok for them to get abused but not us. Now think about that my brother. Brothers Bhul Cuck Maf. Sat Shri Akal. Shri Akal Shai ! [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 20 Jun 2007

Also Abc2 ji, Why you picking on Jassmann, we should be glad that one of our brother have experience of working in world class media company, which may already do or will do good seva to the community. Congratulation Dear Jassmann ji, on achieving that experience. Sikho try to encourage each other to go into the Broadcasting and Journalism with world level companies and learn then educate other on how to use these medias to make Peace in the world by making Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji your guide. Thanks. Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

jassmannn · 21 Jun 2007

Thank you for your support Kulsin, it is very much appreciated. As for Abc. well what can you say, he is a have a go hero. He read a couple of books and a few websites and thinks he understands the BBC. They report against the Governement, literally everyday, but he doesn't see that. And if he had ever been sharp enough to get a job, other than tea or coffee maker in a media institution, then maybe he would be in a better position to comment. But he hasn't and he is welcome to his point of view, which neither acheives anything, nor proves anything. abc, the sites and the report you are reading can be translated and applied to many media institutions around the world. If you think the BBC is bad, mate you need to see ther other cowboys. They are one of the best in what they do and nitpicking such issues is fine, but they have given the Sikhs a lot of good coverage over the years through documenatries and programmes, but we are still a minority, which means we can't get 24 hour coverage, as much as you would love it. I just don't understand your mindset.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 21 Jun 2007

What more 'proof' did you want? I am the only one who has supplied ANY proof of any sort in this thread. Jassmann this is nothing personal but I find it surprising (or even doubtful) that the BBC chose to employ you, as you claim. This is something you have mentioned several times, and yet you seem to have a problem with your reading comprehension. You have stated that the BBC goes against 'the Government'. Go back and learn to read. Then read my previous post. I stated that the BBC will often criticise a politician or a political party, because 2-party politics is for simpletons, who enjoy drama and believe in Britishness, like the greater British public. One thing it will NEVER challenge or ask tough questions about is the Establishment. It will never challenge the institution of the monarchy, or the position of the House of Lords. Even the West Lothian question is dealt with with a delicate touch. As for 2-party politics, this is a joke and a farce. They are the same club wearing different coloured ribbons who take turns to be the 'face' of our government (this facade is for the greater public who believe in this display), and publish manifesto policies with little or no difference between them, the one that's coming up promising more pay less tax than the other. What will they NEVER mention eh Jassmann?? FOREIGN POLICY. Never in ANY manifesto of EITHER political party. This is because foreign policy is bigger than the drama-comedy of the 'party in power'. As for the BBC and foreign policy, it deals with this by taking its cue direct from the government. Do you think they let free independent and impartial news reporters and researchers roam around in Iraq and Afghanistan? These are war zones. War is an instrument of POLICY, nothing more. Hence, the BBC as the GOVERNMENT PROPAGANDA AGENCY participates knowingly in duping the public by publishing disinfo and outright lies. I.e. by knowingly representing government agents from SSVC as their OWN reporters, when they are not. They only admit it when they are caught out. Rather like you, I suspect. Of course, as usual you will have no evidence to support your claims about these matters despite my third detailed report here - only irrelevant personal comments about myself. It is possible to draw conclusions about your educational background from this. All you have come up with so far are vague assertions that you are or were a journalist. On another thread we had a similar conversation, where it seemed that you first claimed you were a journalistic student, then a journalist, then a retired journalist. As for who kulsin is, who knows who cares. He signed up to this forum [u]just to discredit any criticism of the BBC[/u]. That was his first post. Weird or what?? His changing tactics are fascinating. Like you he has still not addressed my comments about the SSVC, or the BBC Trust, or the links I provided proving that the BBC [u]is a government insider[/u] desperately needing to seem 'impartial' to give their SSVC propaganda some credibility in the eyes of the gullible. Address the issues not the individual is my advice. About your journalistic career: I'm sorry if I caused offense but judging from your use of grammar I honestly did not believe I was communicating with someone who held a position of responsibility or influence at the BBC. All it takes to be a journalist is some basic education and literacy BTW - I don't consider it a 'profession' like mine (which I'll keep to myself as a private individual). Most people can write in English. I am happy to continue this discussion for the benefit of people who might still be in 2 minds about the BBC and the long arms of Her Majesty's Government. However, this is a media-literate forum and very few people around here have any illusions about any British sense of 'fair play'. Rather, they want to use the same tactics to benefit themselves. 'Sikh' is learner.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

jassmannn · 22 Jun 2007

Well, abc, It is not your concern for whom I have worked and what positions I have held or not. Furthermore, I think you should read your own thread and see if it makes sense. The Royal family has no influence on policy so what difference would it make if the BBC challenged them. How on earth you have decided that they are ones that wield the cusp of power, the Lord only knows. The house of lords has been challenged and there are steps being taken to change the way it is being run from hereditry to partially elected. Which you would know if you watched the news. What do you want them to say about Foreign policy? When was the last time you watched the BBC news? Bias is a matter of opinion, and you seem hell bent on showing me these sites you have found. Mate I have been reading those kind of articles since the days I was a student, so I am fully aware of social theory and its application to the modern media. It's a two party political game because that is how politics in this country works and it seems to me no matter what I say you are convinced the BBC is biased so it is irrelavant what they broadcast or what they say. Please refer also to the ofcom rules of broadcast and the code of practice by which the BBC is regulated and audited. All available online or on request. As for evidence, all you need to do is switch on the TV and see what they are saying mate. Why don't you just do that, and then you can be in a position to talk about evidence. It doesn't get better than that.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 22 Jun 2007

Abc2 ji you have written “ask tough questions about is the Establishment ?” Give me an example of your tough question ? Just one example will do. You also write “ It will never challenge the institution of the monarchy, or the position of the House of Lords. “ Dear Vir Ji, BBC is a News, Media company not a school of thoughts which you think it should be ? it present history, News and entertainment and educate where ever it can but when was the last time you think BBC advocated, Democracy, Aristocracy, Monarchy or Savagery for any particular country ? You are saying “West Lothian question is dealt with a delicate touch” what do you expect BBC to do , Do a campaign for English Parliament ? full independent for Scotland ? You write further “ What will they NEVER mention eh Jassmann?? FOREIGN POLICY. Never in ANY manifesto of EITHER political party. This is because foreign policy is bigger than the drama-comedy of the 'party in power' “ Dear Abc2 ji Manifesto are written to win elections, When in history have you ever seen any political party fight election to say how they will deal with other countries ? your question is absurd, pointless and almost show your obsession and this fixation in your head about some hidden agenda of institution. +++++++ Below is special point 1 +++++++++++++++++++++ Never mind even that, just read the below link to see how labour party actually did make efforts to have ethical foreign policy. And did talked about the Foreign policy which you claim they never do. http://www.guardian.co.uk/indonesia/Story/0,2763,190889,00.html Read the below link to as you say they never deal with this issue: http://news.bbc.co.uk/vote2001/hi/english/main_issues/sections/facts/newsid_1156000/1156923.stm Above two links prove you wrong for sure. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ You have said “!Do you think they let free independent and impartial news reporters and researchers roam around in Iraq and Afghanistan?” Opps , I think they only send genetically modify reporters who match their DNA. ……… may be one of them is called Dr. Who…. You are saying “the BBC as the GOVERNMENT PROPAGANDA AGENCY participates knowingly in duping the public by publishing disinfo and outright lies. I.e. by knowingly representing government agents from SSVC as their OWN reporters, when they are not. They only admit it when they are caught out.” I seriously think you need to stop reading these strange conspiracy theories and take a break and start fresh, otherwise you are on the border line of paranoid about everything ( it is simple observation, I hope I am wrong and you are not paranoid but please give it some thought, just think you may be absolutely wrong, You have not given answer my question in the last post as do you think any news agency tell the truth or everybody just lie ) But it seem like you have set your mind on their got to be some thing more then what is out their philosophy, which only generate some fear, distrust and phobia about many things. I recommend you should change some people who you hang around, I think it is very easy for mind to get derailed like this and just because you don’t truest anybody you think every body else have some hidden agenda. People who have these kind of thinking normally don’t have many friend ( you may have some of your cult thinking friends but doubt any others) http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/3755686.stm You have written “As for who kulsin is, who knows who cares. He signed up to this forum just to discredit any criticism of the BBC. That was his first post. Weird or what??” Dear Abc2 ji , you are right on one thing who care who am I . and I congratulate you on this to get this right. You have said that I joined this forum to discredit any criticism of the BBC, now that is where you wrong, I been writing on and off on this forum form last about three year you can check for yourself by clicking on the link below. http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/search.php?f=1&search=Kulsin&globalsearch=0&match=1&date=0&fldsubject=1&fldbody=1 as you can see the first comment published by me are dated 25 Dec 2004. I don’t know if they are before you joined the forum or after that. But that is not important or relevant to this discussion. You have written: “His changing tactics are fascinating. Like you he has still not addressed my comments about the SSVC, or the BBC Trust, or the links I provided proving that the BBC is a government insider desperately needing to seem 'impartial' to give their SSVC propaganda some credibility in the eyes of the gullible. Address the issues not the individual is my advice. ” Dear Abc2 ji I have said in the last post “am aware of different government channels which give the information out to give the Govt point of view on different matters. Nearly all the armed forces of all countries have their own media which release , news papers, periodicals, some TV documentaries and News for their audiences. So British are not unique in any way in this matte. So I am not sure what your question is trying to achieve” I will sum up very briefly again, Every party involved in a conflict will provide their part of the story from their point of view so it is perfectly understandable that SSVC have their own agenda but when did BBC said that SSVC is a branch of BBC. Or they take their information as gospel ? SSVS’s mission statement is “To be the preferred provider of entertainment and information to Service personnel and their families worldwide.” BBC explain their mission as “The BBC exists to enrich people's lives with great programmes and services that inform, educate and entertain. Its vision is to be the most creative, trusted organisation in the world.” Now do you see the difference ? You have written “ “I am happy to continue this discussion for the benefit of people who might still be in 2 minds about the BBC and the long arms of Her Majesty's Government. “ Please see if this prove your wrong ? +++++++ Below is special point 2 +++++++++++++++++++++ Abc2 your fav links below as you write “BBC and the long arms of Her Majesty's” http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/3251589.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/4262963.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/4290976.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6276819.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/teachers/citizenship_11_14/subject_areas/government_central/newsid_2043000/2043050.stm +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Please continue the discussion : Two question you certainly need to answer 1. Do you think any news agency speak the truth ? 2. Would you change your stand if your point proven wrong ? And one request could you please comment on the Special point 1 and 2 as mentioned in the main text. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Just confession I am not good with spelling and my grammar is week too and some time I run the spell checker blindly and it make some terrible mistakes. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Brothers Bhul Cuck Maf. Sat Shri Akal. Shri Akal Shai [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sy · 25 Jun 2007

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgK7KwI7qPI a muslim responce.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sloughsingh · 25 Jun 2007

Dear Kulsin....your ignorance annoys me...so dear ABC2 lets get to work on this fool......watch the following link and then come back and try to tell me that i am paranoid and have no friends for i would like to see you look like the fool that you are by trying to talk yourself out of the information that i will present to you. Lets face it America's economic power is more mighty then its military...........so lets start there http://www.silverbearcafe.com/private/monopolymen.html

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Naam · 26 Jun 2007

http://www.sikhhelpline.com/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=39&Itemid=36 Statement By Girl's father: Bhai Amrik Singh 7 June 2007 Statement By Bhai Amrik Singh My family and I are devastated and grief stricken. Our eldest daughter (A Kaur, not her real name) has been snatched away from us and we have no means of contacting her. The Police have told us that she has converted to Islam and does not wish to meet us. They said she is under their protection. We wish to be satisfied of her welfare ourselves. Only parents know their child. We accept that in law she is an adult, but as an 18 year who lived with us all her life, we fear that in the present circumstances, she may not be able to make an independent decision for her own welfare. When I used to hear terrible stories about how young girls leave home for no apparent reason, I thought the parents had to share the blame. I am a loss as to why my 18 year old daughter left home without leaving a note. Today my daughter has not only been taken from me but from the entire Sikh community. We do not accept she has converted to Islam of her own free will, we do not believe she does not want to communicate with us - this is not characteristic of her. My daughter, was an A student in her GCSE and a devout Sikh who has been initiated into the Sikh faith. She performed Keertan (devotional singing) at the Sikh Gurdwara, the last time being 3 days before she suddenly left home. She has two younger sisters who share her conviction in the Sikh faith and were members of her Keertan Jatha (choir). It has come to our attention that my daughter met a Muslim convert at college 2 years ago, when my daughter was a minor. We want the police to investigate the possibility that she was actively targeted and "groomed" over a period of 2 yrs by this Muslim convert. At 16 years, my daughter was impressionable and could have been manipulated through the use of recognized psychologically techniques such as, 'brainwashing', 'mind control', 'undue influence', 'coercive persuasion', and 'thought reform'. I have grave concerns about the safety and psychological welfare of our daughter and that such grooming may have sinister undercurrents, both to create tensions between communities and more importantly, use this young impressionable girl for other activities. Police and Media I feel deeply let down by the local Police authorities who during the 2 weeks since she went missing, didn't communicate with me. Knowing where she was they could have helped me to meet my daughter and to help reassure us that she is well. It is not enough that the Police have asked her and she says she is well. An 18 year old, albeit an adult, under undue influence, needs her family, who know her best. The police are not the best to judge the situation. I want to know what the Police are going to do to help me bring my daughter back and investigate our fear that we are dealing with a forced conversion. The media report broadcasted yesterday by the BBC Midlands today on 5 June 2007 shows the gross insensitivity, cultural ignorance and downright irresponsibility in their reporting. My family had appealed to the BBC not to report on this incident as yet because police investigations were ongoing. We did not want any adverse publicity such that her return to her family becomes even more remote. By bringing this into the public domain, the BBC has created an unimaginable pressure on our daughter, potentially stigmatizing her within her own community and making it difficult for her to make any other decision. In addition, the report appeared to be sensationalizing and demonizing the Sikh community by associating an incident at the "caretakers" home with Sikhs, when there is no confirmation by the police of such an incident nor that any Sikhs were involved. We are the victims and the BBC reports have diverted the attention from our grief to the fears of the caretaker, whose antecedents we do not know. http://sikhhelpline.com/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=35&Itemid=36 Press Release: Sikh Awareness Society (SAS) 07 June 2007 Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Pyaare Sadh Sangat Ji & Media, Over the last two weeks, the SAS has been supporting the family and investigating the circumstances leading into the disappearance of A. Kaur (not real name), the daughter of Bhai Amrik Singh from West Midlands. There are growing concerns within the Sikh and wider(i) community that young impressionable youth are being radicalised and groomed(ii) by extremist Muslims at British colleges and universities. The investigation into the disappearance of A. Kaur has so far uncovered a network of participants, comprising of extremist preachers, recent converts, a protection racket and safe houses. Strong allegations suggested that a man with previous convictions of sex-offences was also involved in this network. There is evidence to suggest this network first targeted Miss A. Kaur two years ago when she was a minor, and we strongly believe that she was groomed during this period. Miss A. Kaur - Character Study Those close to A. Kaur know her as a homely, shy, religious girl. She had never lived away from home, nor was considered to be 'streetwise'. After observing a recent photo of her, we can confirm she does also appear considerably younger than her actual age. Our concerns are that this very impressionable, perhaps naïve girl was an easy target for extremist grooming. Miss A. Kaur had up until two weeks ago, regularly preformed Kirtan (religious hymns) at the Sikh Temple, as a fully practising Sikh. Her alleged conversion to Islam is so far based on rumours and hearsay. We do not know the exact procedure one must undertake to convert to Islam, but we can confirm she was a practising, Amritdhari (Baptised) Sikh up to her disappearance. She had never questioned her belief in Sikhism; in fact her favourite pastime was to participate in Gurmat (religious based) activities. Concerns of the Sikh Community It has to be emphasised that the main concern of the Sikh community is not about faith or religious persuasion. The very essence of Sikhism accepts all faiths and paths leading to God. Our concern is the Radicalisation and extremist grooming of youth and the 'racially-motivated sexual-exploitation(iii)' of young impressionable girls as identified by the DfES on 17 November 2006. To conclude, in light evidence collected and information available to us we firmly believe that there is an organised network of people involved in her disappearance. We are deeply concerned for her safety and her vulnerability to abuse in her new environment. Media Responsibility As a result of BBC's 'Midlands today' Television broadcast, this case received a lot of adverse publicity. We as the Sikh community feel completely let down. The BBC contacted the SAS prior to the News release. We had made it clear that at that point the circumstances leading to the disappearance of A. Kaur have not been established, and any news article will be completely based on rumours and allegations. Despite of this, the BBC broadcasted a sensationalised article based totally on gossip and hearsay. The BBC disregarded the sensitivity of the issue and the racial tensions it could provoke. The spokesman used by the BBC had no expertise on the issue regarding Miss A Kaur and commented on historical conflicts of Sikhs and Muslims - which could easily ignite and fuel racial tensions The BBC overlooked the real concerns of the Sikh community, which were for the safety of a run-away young girl and instead, created and incited a conflict of religions. By bringing a private matter into the public domain the BBC has stigmatised and effectively victimised the whole family. The news article was irresponsible; it disregarded the feelings of a heart-broken family and acted against racial and social cohesion. Sikh Awareness Society, [address removed] This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need Javascript enabled to view it Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh i) NEW GUIDANCE FOR HIGHER EDUCATION PROVIDERS TO HELP TACKLE VIOLENT EXTREMISM IN THE NAME OF ISLAM ON CAMPUSES: - "Up to 48 British universities have been infiltrated by fundamentalists and the threat posed by radical groups must be "urgently addressed", according to Prof Anthony Glees" Up to 48 British universities have been infiltrated by fundamentalists and the threat posed by radical groups must be "urgently addressed", according to Prof Anthony Glees - ii) Extremist Grooming - The gradual process of conversion to extremism: through the process of underming your current faith and character reform Undermining your faith: When the rituals, concepts and philosophy of your current faith are ridiculed, undermined, misinterpreted and misquoted with the aim that you abondon your faith and convert to extremism beliefs. Character reform: Where mind manipulation is used to convert an individual to extremism through recognized psychologically techniques such as 'mind control', 'undue influence', 'coercive persuasion', and 'thought reform'. iii) Racially motivated sexual exploitation: The sexual-abuse of young girls on the basis of their religion/beliefs race/ethnicity or colour motivated by extremist religious views and/or racism.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 26 Jun 2007

Dear sloughsingh I am sorry for my rather blunt language which some time show my past life of animal and I still have those animal instincts in me which is true I am not saying for just being humble , you are right I am fool, but I am trying hard to learn. I am sorry again to cause hurt. I watched this documentary with the link you have provided, Vir ji I have read and heard many stories related to this subject. I agree with you on this subject that other people have written about this too. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve_System show brilliant criticism about this too There are huge demonstrations related to WTO which have similar Free market Agenda. I think if you look at the G8, WTO, Word Bank they all openly admit that they have philosophy of Capitalism and they don’t really care too much about other things and they believe that the best way to do is Free Market. I don’t think the expansion of multinational should be uncontrolled. Even in the UK we have Competition Commission which don’t allow even companies to become very powerful where they don’t face meaningful competition. So I am not surprised by this, I do believe the World’s Big bank have very strange priorities, As the money lending is a dirty business up to certain point where it does the business without ethics. And people who do not disclose their business for scrutiny or are not accountable, bound to have some thing fishy to hide other wise why would you not want transparency in Governing of something that big. I have to say that Yes Banks do have agenda to make money, but just to blame the World war on Banks will be a serious shift of blame from Germany +’s Evil acts. I don’t believe that even you for 1 sec think that Banks made Hitler Kill the Jews, it was his decision to do that, Yes of course Banks and industrialist made fortune out of the Wars which always happen. Big wars happened before the Banking system was in place, Think of Roman Empire, Mugal Empire, Changae Khan ‘s Empire. These things was not funded by any Banks, so it is not always right to blame the Banks. British Need a lone after the second world war and they were made to beg from the US have look at the link http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/12/28/business/nazi.php Just a note, Same thing could easily be said about Medicine companies that they would like people to be sick so they can make money. Now think we can start this of everybody. But the case you have pin pointed it is absolutely have huge weight in it. But I stand by my comments regarding BBC, I have said BBC can make mistake and sometime they do make mistake, but to say there is hidden agenda and they have hand of the Government guiding them delivery of their service is absolutely wrong. My heart goes to the family who’s kid have gone which is the main topic of this particular talk, I only hope Guru Sahib give them strength to cope with very difficult time, and we as Sikhs do some internal investigation of our conduct and weakness and take guidance from Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji on how to be a light house for each other so not only our sister and brother see the Sikh way clearly but also we make call for others to join us in the BEST WAY OF LIFE – WHICH IS SIKHI WAY. I apologies to both of you again ABC2 and Sloghsingh for causing the hurt it was not intentional rather my animal mind which from time to time let me down. I seriously think , I rather be quite then upset my fellow Guru Sikhs. Sorry again. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sy · 26 Jun 2007

OK SO MUSLIMS TARGET SIKH GIRLS FOR CONVERSIONS. WHY DO THEY TARGET SIKH GIRLS AND WHAT ARE SOME SOLUTIONS TO STOP THIS FROM HAPPINING.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sloughsingh · 27 Jun 2007

There is a famous saying, be close to your friends but even closer to your enemies........as sikhs we do not consider others as enemies but if others see us as enemies or kafirs or dhimmies then we must educate ourselves first not just try to brainwash our kids about islam for we need to understand why they seem to be on a 24/7 jihad against the rest of the world but if in the past they have used the sword upon the sikhs and remember our ardas and look what they did....it seems now they are using the pen (mind control,propaganda) and the pen is mightier then the sword................just avoid bad sangat and the baddest of them all is those who undermine your heritage........talk to them about their great religion of peace and all that rape.....which i am sure there quran allows.....to hell with political correctness they can have their life and faith and practice in peace but if they want to destroy the way of life of others then let merry hell fall upon them and take the war on terror from afghanistan to pakistan!!!

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Man Singh · 27 Jun 2007

Such conversions are result of systematic brainwashing and has nothing to do with sprituality. In some cases even terror also used. Many such cases were reported in Egypt also where christain girls were systematically chases harrassed and blackmialed to froce them to convert. It is not practical that every child become expert in Baani and sprituality. It takes time and in life sometime or the other a person decides to move on spritual path. But there are some vulture type of people engaged in trapping and converting especially girls. Such acts are like theft in our house. The only way to deal with thiefs and dacoits are : 1. Increase your strenth n security system 2. Expose the dacoits n their motives in society 3. Beat them back if society fail to pressures them to behave nicely. In the name of secularism and multiculturism, people have lost courage to call a dacoit as a dacoit. We are treating victim and culprit equally. Hope our secularists and multiculturist will enlighten how to deal with such vultures in some better ways.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Dalbiri · 27 Jun 2007

We are doing something wrong because the girls are so easily converted.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sy · 27 Jun 2007

its not always conversions what happends is girl falls in love with guy, and guy can't marry a non muslim so he asks her to convert two things happen either the girl breaks up with him or she converts and marry's him depending on how much she loves him, their have bin cases were the sikh girl hasn't converted and they still married with the muslim man. MOST MUSLIMS THAT DATE SIKH GIRLS DON'T CARE ABOUT CONVERTING THEM, MOST MUSLIMS TARGET SIKH GIRLS BECAUSE MOST OF THE BECAUSE THEY ARE EASY AND MUSLIM GIRLS ARN'T, ALSO THEY TREAT MUSLIM GIRLS AS THEIR SISTERS AND SEE SIKH GIRLS AS ANYTHING GOES ALSO YOU DONT' SEE MUSLIM GIRLS THAT DRINK WEAR SKIRTS AND GO TO THE CLUBS WHILE SIKH FAMILY'S BELIEVE IN BEING WESTERNISED AND MOST SIKH GIRLS DRINK AND GO CLUBBING WEARING ALMOST NO CLOTHING. MOST SIKH GIRLS ARE JUST FOR BOOTY CALLS THEIR CONSIDERED BOOTY WHORES, I HAD A HINDU TELL ME THAT THE PROBLEMS ARE WITH GUJARATI AND PUNJABI GIRLS MAINLY BECAUSE IN PLACES LIKE ENGLAND AND AMERICA YOU DON'T SEE GIRLS FROM THE TAMIL COMMUNITY OR OTHER HINDU COMMUNITY LIKE THE BENGAL COMMUNITY DATING MUSLIMS AND HE CLAIMS IT HAS ALOT TO DO WITH THAT THESE PPL COME FROM HINDU NATIONALIST BACKGROUNDS.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Naam · 28 Jun 2007

Press Release 11 June 2007 Sikh Youth of Birmingham Following the march to Lloyd house on Saturday by some 200 Sikh youth expressing their concerns regarding the targeted grooming of young women by fundamentalists a meeting was held with the police and representatives of the Sikh youth today 11 June 2007 at Lloyd house. The agenda of this meeting was not about faith, but the implication of mainland British security and activities by fundamentalist within UK schools, colleges and universities. The issues raised and discussed were:- Explore opportunities for police and the Sikh youth to develop a constructive partnership of working together The "conversion" of a devout Sikh to change from one faith to another warrants further investigation as to the motives and tactics employed in this process. This is especially relevant when one considers that of the four 7/7 bombers and the shoe bomber, 2 were recent converts. And if someone can be groomed to change their faith, they can equally be groomed to carry out an act of violence. There are increasing number of such cases across communities where young people are being targeted at UK colleges and universities The psychological welfare of the girl that promoted this community reaction and further investigation of the individual who is associated with this girl and himself a recent convert from Christanity. Most importantly, It was also highlighted that should any act of atrocity be carried out as a result of these groomed conversions, then the Police have been alerted to activities in Midland based colleges and universities, as a result of this meeting by the Sikh youth. The meeting was constructive and taken seriously by the Police with positive steps towards developing a longer term working relationships. June 2007: Recent weeks have seen tempers flare in Birmingham with the news that a young Sikh girl was seduced into Islam. The 18-year old girl, who was a practising Sikh and did kirtan often, has not been home since and is said to be in hiding. The problem of aggressive conversions has been growing in recent years and this is giving rise to tensions between the communities. Community members have been actively involved in trying to resolve the matter. Discussions with the police have also been taking place on this pressing issue. Met. Chief Sir Ian Blair (left) has revealed that the police is targetting groups that force vulnerable teenage girls to convert to Islam. "The police has also acknowledged that radical groups have been active at university campuses. " (Daily News 13 June 2007)

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sloughsingh · 28 Jun 2007

Kulsin "But I stand by my comments regarding BBC, I have said BBC can make mistake and sometime they do make mistake, but to say there is hidden agenda and they have hand of the Government guiding them delivery of their service is absolutely wrong." Dear Kulsin there is a lot of history and evidence out there but hey here's something i found just reported today.......Kulsin are you on the other side???? or worse a paid agent.....for surely no one can be that ignorant of the truth http://infowars.net/articles/june2007/280607Film.htm

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Man Singh · 28 Jun 2007

But most of the cases are trappig n brainwashing and exploiting our tolerance. We are not doing anything wrong to girls dalbiri. Its simply a case of dacoits attacking villagers. Do you feel that villagers are doing something wrong to villagers and their associates? No. It is a big international racket funded by political and economic might of 66 Muslim country.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 29 Jun 2007

Dear Sloughsingh Ji, You have written, “kulsin are you on the other side???? “ Please specify which side you mean, from my point of view I am defiantly on the side of Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji. Then you say “or worse a paid agent.....” Well let me know who pay for my kind of behaviour It may interest me, If I get paid to be on the Side of Shir Guru Granth Sahib ji, I would most certainly take the offer. Then you say “for surely no one can be that ignorant of the truth” You are right I am not ignorant of the truth, but people who believe in this could be ? Have a look what this Mr Shayler is: http://www.five.org.uk/security/mi5org/shayler.htm above page show “ Differing reasons are put forward for why Shayler chose to go public with his claims. The Daily Mail itself said on August 28/1997 that he "resigned five months ago after being refused a promotion and took his story to a newspaper". But Shayler denies this. There is no dispute however that the newspaper paid Shayler at least £39,000 for his disclosures; he says this was to cover "living expenses" for his time in exile.” And don’t forget you can say USA Govt, Commission for 9/11 is lying but have a look when other countries ‘s courts ( not the Politian’s or police) have convicted people related to 9/11 , or you are saying these are “””” Conspiracies ””””” by the Spanish and German. Spanish courts are faulty too. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4281808.stm Germany court are faulty too. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6242867.stm Commission is wrong too http://www.9-11commission.gov/report/911Report_Exec.htm Bombing in 1997 is wrong too. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Trade_Center_bombing Who is right : A bunch of attention seeking individuals who have grivience against governments and different agencies. OK one govt, may be wrong, these people ignore the facts that Spanish and Germany courts have convicted people on the basis of evidence related to 9/11. Should we believe all the world is lying and just these idiots who just have love for conspiracy theories are some how more trustworthy then the rest of the world’s Justice system ? Think and think hard. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 29 Jun 2007

Out of the blue, 'kulsin' here brings up the topic of David Shayler, and says: [quote] Have a look what this Mr Shayler is: http://www.five.org.uk/security/mi5org/shayler.htm above page show “ Differing reasons are put forward for why Shayler chose to go public with his claims. The Daily Mail itself said on August 28/1997 that he "resigned five months ago after being refused a promotion and took his story to a newspaper". [/quote] Funnily enough I also resigned from a government post (nothing as glamorous as the secret service unfortunately) after being passed over for promotion (among many other reasons). What a 'coincidence' don't you think?

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 29 Jun 2007

Dear abc2 ji I have not said anything out of the blue, Sloughsingh gave the links http://infowars.net/articles/june2007/280607Film.htm And I looked at that and then gave the link regarding Mr Shayler as he is the presenter in the link provided by sloughsingh. You have also written “Funnily enough I also resigned from a government post (nothing as glamorous as the secret service unfortunately) after being passed over for promotion (among many other reasons). What a 'coincidence' don't you think? “ I seriously hope you have gained more valuable employment then before, I hope Guru Sahib’s Kirpa on you to get your carrier sorted. I am sorry to hear that you have to leave the Job, on the other hand some time change is good for the development, I seriously mean well for you. Our difference of opinions are one thing but We all should wish well for each other. Good luck my dear Gursikh Ji. If you would like to then you can comment on my previous post as you know why I posted the link. But don’t take it as a challenge of anything like that it is a free and good will talk. Thanks

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 30 Jun 2007

Kulsin have you heard this song (it's quite old): 'Most of them pretend to be your friend Just to put you in the lion's den.. I must beat them wicked men I must discipline them I don't like corruption' If you're dealing with corruption my friend you will be caught in the hell. This is a warning, that everything you do and think about is known to God. There is nothing outside his scope and the Khalsa belongs to God. Where you are and what you are doing, is a consequence of your own choice - the circumstances your will draws in to you. I left that job years ago out of choice and I don't hold the government or any of its departments responsible - only 2 very bad individuals who take cover behind their government jobs. Now, it is God's will that certain things were shown to me and I had to leave the job, because longevity is a hardship in the Continuous Hell (Nirvana Sutra, verse 19). But I will not allow the people around me or who I care about be continually duped by the various media, propaganda and false stories emanating from that building on the banks of the Thames: Vauxhall House, which supplies the majority of the 'news' content for national newspapers, repeaters (journalists) and the BBC.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 30 Jun 2007

One other thing kulsin: You say that David Shayler and others who do not accept the official version of events about 9/11 are: "A bunch of attention seeking individuals who have grivience against governments and different agencies. " Do you realise what a ridiculous argument that is? If they are motivated by 'grievance', then what are you, taking the opposite side motivated by? Obviously, 'favour'. According to your own logic. You walked right into it. The pattern in this thread is quite clear. You are fond of waffle and are either extremely offensive or odiously sycophantic. What you seem persistently incapable of, is addressing the evidence available. [u]Why don't you go ahead and explain why 9/11 could not have been a controlled demolition[/u], instead of attacking David Shayler, Richard Tomlinson, Michael Moore, etc. Maybe if you let us know who you are, we could attack your credibility too. But as they stand your arguments hold no water whatsoever, because the individuals concerned are not here to defend themselves and you are just revealing your rather unpleasant, slanderous character. The answer is simple: fudge. This is all you do. This is not my favourite food so stop spreading the fudge. Address the issues and the evidence. This here is a challenge.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

kulsin · 01 Jul 2007

Dear abc2 ji, I think I need to stop this debate now, you have said I am “either extremely offensive or odiously sycophantic” that is not how I want to present myself. To me you are a Gursikh and I don’t want to cause any type of hurt to my fellow human being never mind Gurusikh who I love more then anything else. I have said sorry before for causing hurt , I am sorry again. My intentions are not to upset you or anybody else, of course when we are having debates sometime it will cause hurt , but you seems to think It is intentional and I am a bad individual. Vir Ji I am a simple Gursikh of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I don’t think I want to be associated with the kind of aggravation I have obliviously caused you. Same as you I have read these stories and gone to read as much as I could one site may interest you is : http://www.debunking911.com/index.html. and I was just showing the opposite view to your view. I have no fun in causing hurt to you or anybody else. I genuinely believed that debating is a good thing. You know by default two opposite view will have to make attempt to prove their case, and I was just doing that. Other then that I am sorry for causing irritation or any such thing to you or your fellow thinkers and loved ones. I showed my point of view and vir ji you showed you point of view. I did use some blunt language and I did say sorry about that. Please treat those bad language remarks as taken back by me. So I don’t want any of you to have bad feelings. Bul Chuck Maf. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 01 Jul 2007

http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2006/12/357870.html [u]Con Coughlin, the Daily Telegraph & the ongoing business of conning the British[/u] [i]On the 13th November, the British Prime Minister made a series of remarks aimed at wooing Iran and Syria to help the Middle East Peace Process and solve the Iraqi crisis. The following day, in response, the right wing and conservative British newspaper, the Daily Telegraph, ran two different but related stories.[/i] On the 13th November, the British Prime Minister made a series of remarks aimed at wooing Iran and Syria to help the Middle East Peace Process and solve the Iraqi crisis. The following day, in response, the right wing and conservative British newspaper, the Daily Telegraph, ran two different but related stories. The main article written by Con Coughlin - the well-known and experienced British writer - was entitled, ‘Iran is training the next al-Qa'eda leaders'. The other was entitled, ‘Iran plotting to groom the Bin Laden’s successor’ which was written with George Jones.In these articles Coughlin claimed that Iran kept and trained Saif-al-Adel, a 46 year old former Egyptian army officer and the former security officer, in Tehran for the purpose of becoming the next al-Qa’eda leader. A careful study of those two astonishing articles indicates that the sources of the two stories, which are surrounded by bizarre allegations and grave accusations, are either ‘a senior Western intelligence official’ or ‘a senior Foreign Office official’. By glancing at the archives of the British papers in recent years, one can learn that in terms of the volume and the scale of image-tarnishing and negative writing against Iran, the 51-year-old Mr Coughlin, the former Managing Editor of Sunday Telegraph and the current Defence and Intelligence Editor of Daily Telegraph is far ahead of his other colleagues. Coughlin has been working for the Telegraph group – with some ups and downs and changes in position – since 1980. His father was also the legal affairs correspondent of the same paper. As well as relentless writing of articles in right wing British (the Telegraph Group and the Spectator) and American (New York Sun, Washington Times and National Review) publications, Coughlin has also authored a few books in the same manner as in his articles, most of which are about the life and era of the former Iraqi dictator, Saddam Hussein. ‘Saddam: The Secret Life’, ‘American Ally: Tony Blair and the War on Terror’, ‘Saddam: The King of Terror’, Saddam: His Rise and Fall’, ‘A Golden Basin Full of Scorpion: The Quest for Modern Jerusalem’ and ‘Hostage: Complete Story of the Lebanon Captives’ are the titles of the books authored by Con Coughlin. Although the ‘Sunday Telegraph’ and ‘Daily Telegraph’ are right wing papers and attached to conservative factions and allies in both the UK and the USA, none of the writers in these papers -or any other right wing papers - have been as steadfast as him in their opposition to Iran. A review of the works of this long-established British journalist shows that he has written over 150 short and lengthy articles, analyses and reports against Iran. This number of works is, of course, limited to the two papers where he is based; otherwise there are more works by him in other right wing publications such as the Spectator. A quick look at the contents and a general classification of Coughlin’s works during the recent years indicates that his writings have four specific particularities in terms of journalistic techniques and method of compilation. Firstly, writings with big and bizarre allegations combined with controversial and eye-catching titles against Iran and upon other Middle Eastern issues are identical to tabloids. Such writings are easily given extra attention and weight based on the position and executive rank of the writer within the Telegraph group. This is to the extent that sometimes such stories are printed as the first or second headline on the front page of these two papers. Secondly, news, analysis and reports are produced with suspicious, unknown and particularly untraceable sources, which are absolutely impossible to be tracked by readers and critics. These usual sources are unknown “senior Western intelligence officials” or “senior Foreign Office officials”. Thirdly, articles and reports of this nature are usually published at sensitive and delicate times where there has been a relatively positive shift in the international scope and within the media towards Iran. This is done in an effort to further add to the weight of the other pan of the scale that bears opposition to Iran. Finally, the pivotal argument and the gist of the story related to the controversial title of these articles do not usually exceed one line or at the most one paragraph. The rest of the analysis or report is focused on unworthy issues such as scattered and marginal background information that are irrelevant to the title, so that the article would be of an acceptable volume, in a presentable format and reader-friendly. For a more precise understanding of the particular method of report and analysis writing employed by this experienced British journalist, it would be worthwhile to review and mention some of the sources of Coughlin’s anti-Iranian articles published in the Daily Telegraph and Sunday Telegraph within the last one year, which makes this case more evident. 10/10/2006: “The West woke up too late to the nuclear threat of rogue states” Source: none. 04/08/2006: “Teheran fund pays war compensation to Hizbollah families” Source: “A senior security official”. 21/07/2006: “Meanwhile, Iran gets on with its bomb” Source: none. 14/07/2006: “Israeli crisis is a smoke screen for Iran's nuclear ambitions” Source: none. 13/07/2006: “Cat and mouse games on border that is 'our front line with Iran’” Source: An Israeli soldier. 12/06/2006: “Iran accused of hiding secret nuclear weapons site” Source: A senior western diplomat” 11/04/2006: “The West can't let Iran have the bomb” Source: “An official closely involved in the IAEA's negotiations with Iran” 07/04/2006: “Iran has missiles to carry nuclear warheads” Source: “A senior US official” 07/04/2006: “UN officials find evidence of secret uranium enrichment plant” Sources: “A diplomat closely involved in the IAEA's negotiations with Teheran” and “A senior diplomat attached to the IAEA headquarters in Vienna”. 04/04/2006: “Iran's spies watching us, says Israel” Sources: “A senior Israeli military commander” and “an officer with Israel's northern command”. 06/03/2006: “Teheran park 'cleansed' of traces from nuclear site” Source: “A senior western official” 11/02/2006: “Iran plant has restarted its nuclear bomb-making equipment” Source: “A senior Western intelligence official” 30/01/2006: “Iran sets up secret team to infiltrate UN nuclear watchdog, say officials” Source: “a senior western intelligence official” 16/01/2006: “Iran could go nuclear within three years” Sources: “A senior western intelligence officer” and “an intelligence official” 27/11/2005: “Teheran secretly trains Chechens to fight in Russia” Source: “a senior intelligence official” 29/10/2005: “Smuggling route [from Iran] opened to supply Iraqi insurgents” Source: “The National Council of Resistance of Iran” As it can be seen, the only traceable source of this British writer and journalist’s anti-Iranian writings within the last one year, is the so called ‘The National Council of Resistance of Iran’ (NCRI), the political branch of the group ‘Iran People’s Mojahedin Organisation’ (IPMO/MKO) which is in the banned terrorist lists both in the EU and the USA. Coughlin has a reputation in certain part of the British media for spreading lies in the name of unknown and untraceable intelligence officials. In 1995, when he was Sunday Telegraph’s senior correspondent, Coughlin published a report accusing the Libyan Colonel Qaddafi’s son of partnership in a massive operation involving counterfeit notes and money laundering in Europe based on information received by imaginary British intelligence and bank officials. There was a serious reaction to this report, followed by a British court case, which, eventually in 2002, turned out to be a great scandal for the Telegraph group. The British researcher, David Leigh, who was one of the senior editors of the Guardian at the time revealed in the second edition of the 11th year (2000) of the monthly ‘British Journalism Review’ (pages 21 to 26) that one or more officials from the British Intelligence Service (known as MI6) were providing Coughlin with their fabricated and unfounded stories for many years based on an engineered plan and in line with their psychological propaganda. Coughlin then converted them into first hand and breaking stories by publishing them in the Sunday and Daily Telegraph. However, Coughlin’s spread of lies was not limited to Iran and Libya. He is the same person who, in his report published on the 15 December 2003, claimed that there was a link between the Al-Qaeda member, Mohammed Ata, one of the September 11 collaborators and the Iraqi intelligence at the time of Saddam Hussein. In spite of the fact that this story was later on proved to be a lie and that American officials also reiterated that there was no such link, the story managed to produce a psychological and propagandistic justification for the military occupation of Iraq when it was published, less than 9 months after an attack on Iraq. Coughlin is the same journalist who provided the fabricated document at the beginning of the military attack against Iraq that that country’s army could access its weapons of mass destruction within 45 minutes. This was the same document that was used in the infamous Iraq Dossier produced by the British intelligence service. It was then referred to by Tony Blair and eventually led to the disgrace of the BBC correspondent, Andrew Gilligan, who had interviewed the British defence expert Dr David Kelly, who died shortly after that interview. Coughlin is also the person behind allegations in recent years that Iran is producing nerve gas and chemical weapons. Also in an article published on 27 June 2004 in Daily Telegraph, Coughlin claimed that the temporary closure of the newly built Imam Khomeini Airport in the suburbs of Tehran was the result of a nuclear incident. One should never ignore and neglect the fact that such stories can influence western public opinion and their respective governments and politicians. In the eyes of many Iranians and critics of journalism, Coughlin and those like him are merely instruments for promoting propagandistic policies and psychological operations of the western intelligence organisations. However, one cannot neglect the impact that such publications could have in shaping international public opinion. The same organisations and institutions that dub Coughlin and members of his club as an “important journalist”, “British intellectual” or the “prominent reporter”, swiftly promote and publicise his stories. His most recent story linking Iran and Al-Qaeda was reprinted in over thirty other newspapers around the world including in Canada, America and Australia, in just a few days. It would seem that a wise, appropriate and timely reaction in legal and media related terms to these silent and engineered media battles is the least that Iranian political and cultural officials and those with influence in the west can do against such actions.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Dalbiri · 01 Jul 2007

Man Singh, you said: "We are not doing anything wrong to girls dalbiri. Its simply a case of dacoits attacking villagers. Do you feel that villagers are doing something wrong to villagers and their associates? No." Firstly Sikh weren't supposed to be like innocent villagers. Secondly when the village has been pillaged repeatedly and the villagers fail to take appropritae security action - then yes - the villagers are to blame.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sy · 01 Jul 2007

has this topic gone off topic.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

abc2 · 01 Jul 2007

[u]The truth about journalists and MI5[/u] http://www.observer.co.uk/libertywatch/story/0,1373,758265,00.html By Martin Bright (The Observer, 21 July 2001) Until very recently the British intelligence services didn't officially talk to newspapers at all. Certain favoured journalists who had connections to people who worked in the services were passed information from time to time if it was thought useful to put it in the public domain. Sometimes the stories that resulted were true and sometimes not. In recent years, after intense pressure, MI5 and MI6 instituted a new system whereby each service has an unofficial press officer who talks to the media. Most organisations then designate a journalist who will deal with each service. They are then given a telephone number and the name of the individual intelligence officer. In the case of the Observer, I deal with MI5. Although some newspapers or individual journalists may hold 'special relationships' with individuals within the intelligence establishment, as far as I know, the same MI5 'press officer' deals with all my opposite numbers on other national newspapers for everyday briefings…. Most journalists feel that, on balance, it is better to report what the intelligence services are saying, but whenever the readers see the words 'Whitehall sources' they should have no illusions about where the information comes from. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Harjas Kaur · 01 Jul 2007

[quote]You say that David Shayler and others who do not accept the official version of events about 9/11 are:"A bunch of attention seeking individuals who have grievience against governments and different agencies. "[/quote] We're in deeper than you realize. Look at the accumulation of evidence veers/bhains. There is a coming military dictatorship in America. And guess what? They will persecute all of us. Please use discretion as these links describe sensitive subjects. But the issues are of such importance, the sangat, especially in US really needs to be aware. A Symphony of Lies [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7xyd_IRgGs[/url] Blaming Saddam Hussein for acts of Osama Bin Laden to justify Iraq War [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjCvrR641lw[/url] Retired Gen. Wes Clark, the Bush Administration planned to take out 7 countries in 5 years: Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Lybia, Somalia, Sudan, Iran. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXS3vW47mOE[/url] Zbigniew Brzezinski, former National Security Advisor to President Carter indirectly accuses Bush administration of preparing a provocation or even a false flag terrorist act in order to have a pretext to attack Iran. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QvAGAkseh1w[/url] [quote]“I encouraged the Chinese to support Pol Pot. I encouraged the Thai to help the Khmer Rouge. The question was how to help the Cambodian people. Pol Pot was an abomination. We could never support him. But China could.” ~ Zbigniew Brzezinski [/quote] Col. Gardiner, Without Congressional Approval, the Bush Administration is already conducting military operations in Iran. Phase Two of the Iraq war is invasion of Iran. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4nqrNbjfhw[/url] Ret. Gen. John Batiste begs Congress to protect the Nation from the Bush Administration. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMPIi03wSfY[/url] Ret. Gen. Paul Eaton: If Pres. Bush Won't Listen, Congress Must [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tw4jSZLkJqA[/url] Forced Resignation of Marine Major General Peter Pace because he did not support the invasion of Iran. [url]http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/iraq/article1434540.ece[/url] [quote]But General Peter Pace, chairman of the joint chiefs of staff, said recently there was “zero chance” of a war with Iran. He played down claims by US intelligence that the Iranian government was responsible for supplying insurgents in Iraq, forcing Bush on the defensive. Pace’s view was backed up by British intelligence officials who said the extent of the Iranian government’s involvement in activities inside Iraq by a small number of Revolutionary Guards was “far from clear”. Hillary Mann, the National Security Council’s main Iran expert until 2004, said Pace’s repudiation of the administration’s claims was a sign of grave discontent at the top. “He is a very serious and a very loyal soldier,” she said. “It is extraordinary for him to have made these comments publicly, and it suggests there are serious problems between the White House, the National Security Council and the Pentagon.” Mann fears the administration is seeking to provoke Iran into a reaction that could be used as an excuse for an attack. A British official said the US navy was well aware of the risks of confrontation and was being “seriously careful” in the Gulf. [/quote] Directive 51 & Homeland Security Directive 20 [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOIUYdO-0bY[/url] [url]http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2007/05/20070509-12.html[/url] President Bush signed Directive 51 into law. It grants Emergency Presidential Powers of a broad and sweeping scope never seen in American law. To protect the Constitutional government in a declared emergency, the Executive will usurp authority of Legislature and Judiciary, thus removing the checks and balances to Presidential Authority. Oddly enough, this legislation gives direct control of federal agencies to the Secretary of Homeland Security. In the event of a terrorist act on American soil, the President and the Department of Homeland Security will have control of the nation. this Directive was passed into law May 9, 2007. Nothing was said in the media. The public is largely unaware and apathetically unconcerned. The Coming American Police State [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jl1VIhdpl4c[/url] [quote]"With scarcely a mention in the mainstream media, President Bush has ordered up a plan for responding to a catastrophic attack. In a new National Security Presidential Directive, Bush lays out his plans for dealing with a “catastrophic emergency.” Under that plan, he entrusts himself with leading the entire federal government, not just the Executive Branch. And he gives himself the responsibility “for ensuring constitutional government.” He laid this all out in a document entitled "National Security Presidential Directive/NSPD 51" and "Homeland Security Presidential Directive/HSPD-20." The White House released it on May 9. [url]http://www.progressive.org/mag_wx051807[/url][/quote] Forced confessions of alleged Al Qaeda suspects arranged under torture with denial of access to attorneys, and charges which cannot be challenged in court due to being "classified." Rescinding the legal definition of Habeus Corpus and rewriting Article Three of the Geneva Convention to permit use of torture. Setting up Military tribunals empowered with the death penalty. Sounds like the Administration not only concocted 9/11 as a pretext for invasion plans, but it will set up the alleged criminals of the terrorist plot, and execute them before anyone can truthfully assess their guilt or innocence. President Bush bullying the media to justify torture and silence criticism. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irLosdf5Yp4[/url] [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viqZ1ouZaDU[/url] Bush removes the right of Habeus Corpus, thus regular American citizens can now be arrested and detained without charge, without access to attorneys, possibly moved to foreign countries to undergo torture to compel confessions based on the pretext people have somehow supported, associated with, given money to, known anyone involved in a declared "terrorist organization." This would include Babbar Khalsa International and International Sikh Youth Federation. A coming persecution is entirely possible. Sikhs need to wake up and be cautious. If this war begins to go very badly, minorities in America are famously used as scapegoats. Be aware of the public mood and the shift toward discrimination. The US, Britain and Canada may one day work together to persecute Sikhs with public approval. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqxmPjB0WSs[/url] Violating the Rule of International Law: [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KeBqnd78CUY[/url] Rep. Kucinich: "I have read the bill...are Members of Congress who challenge this Administration as to their taking us into illegal wars, is that somehow contrary to allegiance to the United States? [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxLjirbJjmQ[/url] Kangaroo Justice: The Military Commisions Act [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XmfG49aJRo[/url] Legalized tyranny [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uV90dYnIYqs[/url] Outlawed: Extraordinary Renditions -Torture & Disappearances [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHIKaDIBrCQ[/url] Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo Bay and the C.I.A. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wF3j4j8H1hk[/url] Former Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinsky, head of Abu Ghraib states the tortured detainees were innocent. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ip9Tv7E_yw0[/url] Retired Major General Antonio Taguba forced to resign because his investigation implicated Intelligence Agencies and the Bush Administration for orchestrating the torture in Abu Ghraib. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNxeynmRmnk[/url] Former guard at Abu Ghraib claims he helped torture and gang rape detainees. "Anyone with a fu---n rag on their head is fair game." [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3dvoBhevOQ[/url] The Department of Homeland Security and Fema are building internment camps for immigrants. Families and children are being detained in a prison like structure called the Don Hutto Residential Facility. UN delegates were refused access. One case of rape by guards has already been alleged there. It is in Taylor Texas. It is under the auspices of Homeland Security. It is owned by KBR a subsidiary of Halliburton. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HBCAgSCGM04[/url] [img]http://www.talkleft.com/border-fence.jpg[/img] T. Don Hutto Residential Facility Keep your eyes open to the American public and political mood. Right now there is huge discrimination, detainment, deportation and allegations of terrorist involvement against Muslims, Hispanics and anti-War protesters. We are starting to see dentention facilities like were previously used against Japanese Americans and Native Americans. Do not think Americans will accept the Sikhs. That's a false reassurance. I hate to say it, but you, we, are not the right skin color. And we are most certainly not an accepted religion. there is a deliberate blurring of the identities of Muslims and Sikhs in US, in Canada. I expect persecutions to start if they haven't already. Canadian 9 year old boy held in U.S. detention center [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bz3_VqU6OE8[/url] Iranian UCLA student tortured by campus police for failing to show student ID. He was protesting racial profiling claiming white students were not asked to show theirs. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5g7zlJx9u2E[/url] May 1, 2007 American Police paramilitary round-up and assault on Immigration Reform Rally. Journalists attacked and television cameras thrown to the ground. It's a chilling political warning of how the US is treating minorities. Remember the past. Don't be taken by surprise when it repeats itself. This country has a long history of racism, massacre and genocide. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ivn8PrZlAXo[/url] [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUCu85E_xoI[/url] Anti-War protests are being violently suppressed by militarized American Police around the country. These are not actions against criminals, but against American citizens Constitutional right to freedom of assembly and protest. San Francisco [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8NiCBfKkvSs[/url] At the United Nations in New York [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ool8-_I8hoY[/url] Miami [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cGeaGgk-m18[/url] Tacoma [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PzEjstUpxoQ[/url] Arrest of Ret. Colonel Ann Wright in Congress. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOeRk0gCIJA[/url] [quote]"This is a police state when the police are running Congress. This is just like what the hearing is all about, law enforcement, the FBI having unlimited powers to sneak and peek over us as citizens." -Col. Ann Wright[/quote] [img]http://blogs.southflorida.com/citylink_dansweeney/serve.jpg[/img] We really should all be alarmed by the direction this country is turning. Don't let it be too late before you take care to protect your family from an increasingly restrictive police presence and a government increasingly hostile to any criticism of its political policies, and toward immigrants and people in turbans. [quote]Gen. Tommy Franks says that if the United States is hit with a weapon of mass destruction that inflicts large casualties, the Constitution will likely be discarded in favor of a military form of government. [url]http://www.benfrank.net/nuke/ftaa112003/Police_Brutality_in_Miami.html[/url][/quote] [img]http://www.centennialofflight.gov/essay/Air_Power/Stealth/AP46G6.jpg[/img] America is a part of the Dark Forces. Just look at their demon planes. Don't ever be lulled into a false sense of security. We are living in the Kaliyug. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Man Singh · 02 Jul 2007

Yes Dalbiri, Villagers are to be blamed for their inactivity. But promary culprits are dacoits not villagers. let's recognise the culprits. let's evaluate their strenth. let's challenge them n beat them back. I have personal experience in challenging the dacoits and beating them back along with their local associates. Blaming villagers boosts confience of dacoits. therefore Real criminals are those who attack the villagers. how such criminals are to be dealt with need thinking planning n execution. First step is identifying the culprits.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

jassmannn · 03 Jul 2007

Abc2 and Harjas Kaur, You are welcome to your opinions, but what point are you trying to make? Once again, the articles in support of your point are opinion pieces, not fact. Look at what is happening all around the UK. Instead of clamping down on the real threat and doing what you can in support of your local communities and the Police, you are all obsessed with this idea that there is a cover up, the Governments in the world are all corrupt and everyone is out to get us; (that’s what is sounds like to me). Get with it people. Open your eyes.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Harjas Kaur · 04 Jul 2007

[quote]Once again, the articles in support of your point are opinion pieces, not fact.[/quote] I posted links of video in which the former commanding Generals of the Iraq War, the former National Security Council Advisor is alleging the Bush Administration is leading the country to ruin. Everything I have posted regarding the Bush Administration's rescinding of the right of Habeus Corpus, the Military Commisions Act, Directive 51, and rewriting the Geneva Convention to permit torture... In conjunction with the Department of Homeland Security being given contracts to build detention centers/prison camps for immigrants, the authority directly under the president and over Congress/Senate and Supreme Court in the event of a National Emergency, etc. All those things are facts. Not opinions. Draw your own conclusions. [%sig%]

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

jassmannn · 04 Jul 2007

Harjas Kaur, you can't say 'alleging' and then say it is fact. If someone is alleging something, then it is not a fact. They may be building detention centres, but they are for home-land security. The Americans may not want more people coming into the country, so they are looking after their interests. I thought that was obvious considering the terrorist threats they have had and the scale they were on. Guantanmo bay is now under review for closure, which W Bush has confirmed. Just think what you would do if you were in the same position as the American President and your people wanted reassurances that something was being done. No one denies Iraq was a mistake, but who is killing who out there. Whenever Saddam Hussein came out of power, this was inevitable considering the Sunni-Shia history of oppression, repression. When you are the leader of a country, you are meant to represent the people. They may be red necks, or they may be liberals, either way, W Bush know now that he is on his way out. Although I don't disagree that he has a lot to answer for and a lot is being covered up, but the stuff you are showing me proves nothing as fact and are, as I said, opinion pieces, even if they are experts. We all know W bush is a right old xxxxx but he is still the American leader.

LATEST: Girl Returns Home to Family

Akaal Sahai Singh · 08 Jul 2007

July 2007. We are pleased to announce that the girl at the center of the aggressive conversion uproar has voluntarily returned home to her parents. She had been under police protection at an undisclosed location since news of her disappearance broke out some weeks ago. The father of the girl would like to thank the sanggat at large as well as all Sikh organisations for their enormous assistance and support in their time of need. Please note that a thanksgiving programme has been set and all members of the sanggat are invited to attend: Programme: Sukhmani Sahib followed by kirtan Day / Date: Sunday, 8 Aug 07 Time: 3:00pm Venue: Guru Har Rai Gurdwara, High St, West Bromwich.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

sy · 08 Jul 2007

so any question as to why the girl ran off and converted, and if it was forced or not.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Naam · 10 Jul 2007

LATEST: Girl Returns Home to Family July 2007. We are pleased to announce that the girl at the center of the aggressive conversion uproar has voluntarily returned home to her parents. She had been under police protection at an undisclosed location since news of her disappearance broke out some weeks ago. The father of the girl would like to thank the sanggat at large as well as all Sikh organisations for their enormous assistance and support in their time of need. Please note that a thanksgiving programme has been set and all members of the sanggat are invited to attend: http://sikhhelpline.com/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=46&Itemid=1

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

khalistani · 12 Jul 2007

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYVNO_1hmrs dozens of these videos popping up on youtube saw them on another sikh website.

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Dalbiri · 12 Jul 2007

If a girl from an amritdhari background does this then everyone is sympathetic - if it is an average Sikh girl (you know what i mean) then everyone spits at her!

Re: Amritdhaari Girl Converts To Islam? (Video Link)

Harjas Kaur · 14 Jul 2007

[quote]If a girl from an amritdhari background does this then everyone is sympathetic - if it is an average Sikh girl (you know what i mean) then everyone spits at her![/quote] Not true. Naturally if her family and sangat are close to her they will tend to be more understanding of her situation. If someone never goes to Gurudwara, she won't even know anyone to have any support. Moreover, the circumstances of conversion all differ. Some never believed in Sikhi and are happy to be free from something they never respected in the first place. Some are naive and get seduced. Some are abused and forced to convert. People will respond differently to different scenarios. To those who had no respect for Sikhi and stand up on stage mocking the Guru, naturally everyone is annoyed with them. But if they are pressured, bullied, terrorized and kidnapped, naturally we will have a different response. In any case the conversion is a mistake. But some things will fail to have anyone's sympathy. One also has to wonder about your definition of the "average" Sikh girl, versus someone who was committed by amrit to Guruji. Why would someone with love and commitment to Guru change their mind? Those circumstances beg explanation. As opposed to some young girl who maybe goes out clubbing with Muslim guys in college and thus prone to their influence. In my opinion some people who call themselves Sikh are already lost to Sikhi, and conversion to something else is just an afterthought. ~Bhul chak maaf [%sig%]