Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 03 Jun 2007

The following line appears in SGGS. khu kbIr AKr duie BwiK ] (329-18, gauVI, Bgq kbIr jI) Says Kabeer, chant the two letters of the Lord's Name - Raa Maa. The English Translation appears to be slightly different than what appears on the face.Should one take the 'Naam' as 'Rama'.? To me the line , as tanslated, seems to be skewed.Is it a correct translation by some learned author and further is it ok. if one starts chanting 'Rama' instead of 'waheguru' in the light of the translation [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Harinder Singh · 04 Jun 2007

Dont trust these english translations. The two words are wahe and guru.ONly waheguru is true naam and rest all naams hold no power in this dark age of kaliyug. Whenever bani says "raam japp", the mamma of ram is mukta which means raam ie god ie allah NUU japp and DOES NOT mean raam japp. Whenever gurbani says, "raam naam japp" , the mamma of ram will be mukta again which means raam DE naam nu japp or raam DA naam japp and DOES NOT mean ram japp.

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jun 2007

By saying "Akhar duye" it does not mean japping Naam of two letters. In Siri Bavan Akhri Siri Guru jee says that we should only japp one akhar (Ek Akhar Har Man Basat, Nanak Hoth Nihaal||) . Does it then mean that Naam is to have one letter only? The words "duye" or "ek akhar" mean that one word Naam with few letters only is all we need to Japp to swim across this ocean of world. It does not mean that we should start looking for Naam that has two, one or three letters. The word that we get from Punj Pyaray is the word that Gurbani is talking about. Have no doubts over this. [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Another Dimension · 04 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh raamakalee mehalaa 5 ||(SGGS jeeo-885) Raamkalee, Fifth Mehla: koee bolai raam raam koee khudhaae || Some call Him, 'Raam, Raam', and some call Him, 'Khudaa-i'. koee saevai guseeaa koee alaahi ||1|| Some serve Him as 'Gusain', others as 'Allaah'. ||1|| kaaran karan kareem || He is the Cause of causes, the Generous Lord. kirapaa dhhaar reheem ||1|| rehaao || He showers His Grace and Mercy upon us. ||1||Pause|| koee naavai theerathh koee haj jaae || Some bathe at sacred shrines of pilgrimage, and some make the pilgrimage to Mecca.| koee karai poojaa koee sir nivaae ||2|| Some perform devotional worship services, and some bow their heads in prayer. ||2|| koee parrai baedh koee kathaeb || Some read the Vedas, and some the Koran. koee oudtai neel koee supaedh ||3|| Some wear blue robes, and some wear white. ||3|| koee kehai thurak koee kehai hi(n)dhoo || Some call themselves Muslim, and some call themselves Hindu. koee baashhai bhisath koee suragi(n)dhoo ||4|| Some yearn for paradise, and others long for heaven. ||4|| kahu naanak jin hukam pashhaathaa || Says Nanak, one who realizes the Hukam of God's Will, prabh saahib kaa thin bhaedh jaathaa ||5||9|| knows the secrets of his Lord and Master. ||5||9|| Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Balpreet Singh · 04 Jun 2007

Another Dimension, Could you please expand on the shabad above and how you believe it relates to this thread?

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

mpsingh · 04 Jun 2007

it is based on ur "faith" and beliefs which mantar u take. for sikhs it is waheguru or mool mantar and there are various other mantras but according to many saints. if the mantar is very smal(1-2 or 2-3 akhars) then it is very easy get siddhi(fast effect) over it. as a beginner u should start with a smalll mantar [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Khalsaspirit · 04 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ka fateh Khlasa jio and inparticular hps jio, The best answer can be given Panj Piyare only they will let you know what to chant and how to chant if you got qualified. No matter whoever answer you here its not gonna end here and you will be confused and your thread will also confuse other beginners too. If you already a amritdhari Singh and you are still in this doubt then pray to Guru Sahib to give answer thru Panj Piyare. As you already advised by some high avashta singhs here but still there are people out there who have no idea what Gurmanter is. And for gurmanter there is no choice to choose from. Again ask Guru Sahib for Gurmanter. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randeer Singh jee had the same question and only Guru Sahib answered it and if you believe Bhai Sahib may be lying then ask Guru Sahib directly they will definatly anwer you thru real Panj piyare if you intention is right. Our wording may sounds you harsh but it is reality. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 04 Jun 2007

I am thankful to all my friends for their response to my query. S.Mp singh ji, I have full regard for this forum. Kindly do not dilute by pasing remarks that are meaningless. In such acase it is beter to avoid posting unless you have etching at wrong place. DEar Friends I was listening to some saakhi where in it has been explained that in the entire Guri Granth sahib ji, there is no disclosurwe that 'waheguru' is the name and that this guru mantar is derived from the Vaaran. I am not sure of this. Secondly bij Mantar 'Ik Ongkaar' also is not clearly stated that it is 'Ik Ongkar' There is only a reference of Mool Mantra in SGGS ji. Fourthly , I am a person who do maintain kesh in 1984 riots and I never afterwards thought of Keeping thinking that HE never wanted it. It may be an escape rote for me .I do not know. In such a case Can I get Baptisation .I am 56 years old and live in India. I have strong faith in Sikhi and also do not want to die as it is. Is it Necessary to get the Naam from Panj Pyare or can I do with my 'waheguru' simran and Jap. Only serious persons may respond please. [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Khalsaspirit · 04 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh hps jio, See every one is ansh of param atama akal purakh. Which means we have the parmatama sitting within us some where which is actually our atma. Now the bridge between the atma and body is mind. And in kuljug on Guru Sahib are smarath to change and utilize the mind to see atma and meet akalpurkh. So definatly you need Guru Sahib's sharan to be on the spirtual path and one thing we can advise you is that the first step is to keep your kesh and do ardass with right intention. Guru sahib will do kirpa of his amrit di daat within this life cycle. [gurbani]crn srin gur eyk pYfw jwie cl siq gur koit pYfw Awgy hoie lyq hY ] eyk bwr siqgur mMqR ismrn mwqR ismrn qwih bwrMbwr gur hyq hY ] BwvnI Bgiq Bwie kaufI AgRBwig rwKY qwih gur srb inDwn dwn dyq hY ] siqgur dieAw iniD mihmw AgwiD boiD nmo nmo nmo nyq nyq nyq hY ][/gurbani] Guru mehar karay and also do ardass for we moorakhs Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Thanks, I am keeping hair

hps · 04 Jun 2007

Khalsaspirit jeo, No, Your wording is not at all hard. It is ,infact, illuminatiing. Thanks for all the inspiration that I derive from your posts. Yes, Dear I think that I should start keeping my hairs. I start from today and shall be informing about my progress thru. this post. Very many thanks for your nice advice. I do not require any answer from anyone.For me this thread is closed. Regards to all. [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

jassmannn · 05 Jun 2007

It does say in the Gurbani that 'Vaheguru guru mantar hai, japp home Koi' Vaheguru is the guru mantar but that does not mean that you can't japp raam, or even any other name. God has hundreds and millions of different names. Even if you do a lari of Japji Sahibs as Simran, or mool mantar. As 'another dimension' translated the shabad 'koi bole raam raam'. People have different names for God, so you can choose whichever as long as it is in praise of the lord. Raam and Allah both feature in the Guru Granth Sahib more than vahegur comes.

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Harjas Kaur · 05 Jun 2007

[quote]DEar Friends I was listening to some saakhi where in it has been explained that in the entire Guri Granth sahib ji, there is no disclosurwe that 'waheguru' is the name and that this guru mantar is derived from the Vaaran. I am not sure of this.[/quote] [quote]AkQ kQw kQI n jwie qIin lok rihAw smwie suqh isD rUpu DirE swhn kY swih jIau ] (1403-1, sveIey mhly cauQy ky, gXMd) akath kathaa kathee na jaa-ay teen lok rahi-aa samaa-ay sutah siDh roop Dhari-o saahan kai saahi jee-o. No one can speak Your Unspoken Speech. You are pervading the three worlds. You assume the form of spiritual perfection, O King of kings. siq swcu sRI invwsu Awid purKu sdw quhI vwihgurU vwihgurU vwihgurU vwih jIau ]3]8] (1403-2, sveIey mhly cauQy ky, gXMd) sat saach saree nivaas aad purakh sadaa tuhee vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahi jee-o. ||3||8|| You are forever True, the Home of Excellence, the Primal Supreme Being. Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Jee-o. ||3||8|| siqgurU siqgurU siqguru guibMd jIau ] (1403-3, sveIey mhly cauQy ky, gXMd) satguroo satguroo satgur gubind jee-o. The True Guru, the True Guru, the True Guru is the Lord of the Universe Himself. -SGGS Ji P. 1403 [quote] [quote]Vaars Bhai Gurdaas Ji gur isKhu gur isK hY pIr pIrhuM koeI] Sbd surq cylw gurU prmySr soeI] drSn idRSit iDAwn Dr guru mUriq hoeI] Sbd suriq kr kIrqn sqsMg ivloeI] vwihgurU gurU mMqR hY jp haumYN KoeI] Awp gvwey Awp hY gux guxI proeI ]ò] gur sikhahu gur sikh hai peer peerahu(n) koee|| shabadh surath chaelaa guroo paramaeshar soee|| dharashan dhrishatt dhhiaan dhhar gur moorath hoee|| shabadh surath kar keerathan sathasa(n)g viloee|| vaahiguroo guroo ma(n)thr hai jap houmai(n) khoee|| aap gavaaeae aap hai gun gunee paroee ||a|| By the teachings of the Guru many become disciples of the Guru, but some rare one becomes the Guru like that Guru. Only the practitioner of the word and consciousness can attain the status of Guru-God. Such a disciple concentrating on the philosophy of the Guru (and making it a part of daily conduct) himself becomes a likeness of Guru. Making his consciousness attentive to Word through recitation of Naam, he merges in the holy congregation. His Guru-manta is Vahiguru, whose recitation erases egotism. Losing egotism and merging into the qualities of the supreme Lord, he himself becomes full of qualities.[/quote] [quote]siqjug siqgur vwsdyv vwvw ivSnw nwm jpwvY] sathijug sathigur vaasadhaev vaavaa vishanaa naam japaavai|| In Satyug, Visnu in the form of Vasudev is said to have incarnated and ‘V’ Of Vahiguru reminds of Visnu. Line 1 duAwpr siqgur hrIikRSn hwhw hir hir nwm iDAwvY] dhuaapar sathigur hareekrishan haahaa har har naam dhhiaavai|| The true Guru of dvapar is said to be Harikrsna and ‘H’ of Vahiguru reminds of Hari. Line 2 qRyqy siqgur rwm jI rwrw rwm jpy suK pwvY] thraethae sathigur raam jee raaraa raam japae sukh paavai|| In the the treta was Ram and ‘R’ of Vahiguru tells that rembering Ram will produce joy and happiness. Line 3 kiljug nwnk gur goibMd ggw goivMd nwm jpwvY] kalijug naanak gur gobindh gagaa govindh naam japaavai|| In kalijug, Gobind is in the form of Nanak and ‘G’ of Vahiguru gets Govind recited. Line 4 cwry jwgy chu jugI pMcwiex ivc jwie smwvY] chaarae jaagae chahu jugee panchaaein vich jaae samaavai|| The recitations o f all the four ages subsume in Panchayan i.e. in the soul of the common man. Line 5 cwroN ACr iek kr vwihgurU jp mMqR jpwvY] chaaron ashhar eik kar vaahiguroo jap manthr japaavai|| When joining four letters Vahiguru is remembered, Line 6 jhW qy aupijAw iPr qhW smwvY ]ôù]ñ] jehaan thae oupajiaa fir thehaan samaavai ||aa||a|| The jiv merges again in its origin. Line 7 [/quote] [quote]vwihgurU swlwhxw gur Sbd Alwey ]ñó] vaahiguroo saalaahanaa gur shabadh alaaeae ||aa|| Vahiguru, God, is eulogised through recitation of the Word of the Guru, Gurbani. Line 6 Vaar 9 Pauri 13 inrMkwr Awkwr kr joiq srUp AnUp idKwieAw] nirankaar aakaar kar joth saroop anoop dhikhaaeiaa|| The formless Lord has been beholden in the form of the light (in Guru Nanak and other Gurus). Line 1 vyd kqyb Agocrw vwihgurU guru Sbd suxwXw] vaedh kathaeb agocharaa vaahiguroo gur shabadh sunaayaa|| The Gurus recited Word-Guru as Vahiguru who is beyond the Vedas and Katebas (the semtic scriptures). Line 2 Vaar 12 Pauri 17 [/quote] Bhul chuk maaf karni Ji [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Khatarnak Times · 05 Jun 2007

jasmann ji, Firstly, the pankti is from Bhai Gurdas jee's vaar and not from Gurbani. Secondly, we can't just jap any naam. If that was the case why did Guru Nanak come to the world because were jaaping those naam's before he came in physical form. Gurbani says, "kal taran guru nanak aya... ... sat naam parh mantar sunaiya" Meaning Guru Nanak dev ji came to the world to help people through kalyug by giving them the true name. The true name is not sat nam rather Sat nam is a description of the true name. The true name according to asa di var is "aapenay aap saajeo appenay racheo nao". The naam we jap is the one God created for himself, other naams such as raam, rahim, alllah ho are man made name's of God.

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Shaheed · 05 Jun 2007

Then how do we explain the story of bachitar natak where Guru sahib in his past life meditated on mahakal? unless you dont believe in that story. There is also another question that comes to mind. Which is that if any other mantar is insuffiecient then nobody could get mukhti until guru nanak dev ji came and enlightened us all. If naam is supreme and pravelent and timeless, how could there be only one jaap? [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Khatarnak Times · 05 Jun 2007

That's because Guru Nanak Dev ji only came in physical form during kalyug but before that he used to do direct (spiritual) kirpa on bhagats. i.e prahlad etc. There has only ever been one naam that God has created for himself. It says so in ASa di vaar.

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Harinder Singh · 05 Jun 2007

<> EKO NAAM HUKAM HAI. Hukam means Naam which means gurmantar ie. Waheguru. ONly people who are destined from dhurr are able to realize this. So jo changa lagda jappo, par waheguru ton binna gall nahin bann ni te jam dootan ne farr ke bohat kuttna hai.

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 05 Jun 2007

Dear friends, Some one has asked me if Sikhi is ot a 'branch out' of hinduism and the almighty should be 'Lord Krishna'. However as per sikh rehat nama sikhs are not to believe in Geeta and vedas /upnishdas. However, It was counter argued that Lord Krishna has already stated that He is omnipotent and all other 'omni'. How do we then reconcile that in Bani w are referring to some other god. It matters a little to me. An advice is required ,as usual'. Thanks [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

mpsingh · 06 Jun 2007

i am sorry if i am diverting from the topic. what about chandi di vaar? someone told me the whole vaar is of mantras which activates primal power within you. Bhul Chuk MaaF [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

jassmannn · 06 Jun 2007

Then why does Raam and Allah appear in Bani more than Vaheguru. The thing is mate, all can get to god, and as it says. Khatri, Brahmin, Soodh vesh, Updesh chou varna ko Sanjha' and 'Koi Bole Raam Raam, koi Khudai' Vaheguru is the gurmantar, but if I did simran of Mool Mantar, or Japji Sahib Lari, or Satnam, does that make it wrong. The whole bani is naam, why are we being so ritualistic and pedantic about it when the point is to sing God's praises?

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 06 Jun 2007

Jassman jeo, I am not orthodox nor am an theologist .It is question that was posed to me a couple of days back and I had no reply. I am satisfied with that I am . But we all learn new things and it is knowledge as to what people think about us. Mr. Khushwant singh ji has done a great damage to the sikhi and there is none to counter as his reach is far flung. I am just removing my doubt. For me Guru Sahibaan are my life and the same are my death. [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 06 Jun 2007

This thread for me is closed. [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

jassmannn · 07 Jun 2007

hps, Most of the time we need to think with a little logic and understanding of Bani. God is one, which means God is the same for all humans. The name is not important because God is God. Like a man: to someone he is a dad, to someone a brother, to another a friend and to another a husband. Same person just a different name. Sikhi is only a few hundred years old, and God existed before that. Guru Ji came down when the sins of the planet grew too much and people were not doing as they were meant to and were straying the path. Hindu theology and Krishna, Ram all took place which is why it is mentioned in Bani, but Guru Ji tells us that they are not the ones to be worshipped but even from there tales and stories there is something to be learnt.

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 07 Jun 2007

Yes, DEar jassmann jeo, But still I have a small doubt that I have to share. The entire SGGS is full the eulogoisation of name. And on Top of it it is stated in the Bani that Naam is gifted by Guru only. We are referring to thee three Mantras like bij, Gurmantar, Mool Mantra. Do you think that these should qualify for Naam. In my opinion the entire purpose of the induividual would be to establish communion with almighty and He shall bestow the gift of Naam irrespective of the fact whether Panj Peary has given some Naam. What do youthink sir. [%sig%]

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Harpartap Singh · 08 Jun 2007

rwmu jphu myrI sKI sKYnI ] Guru Nanak Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 416 Bhai Harinder Singh ji, Is the above pankti spelt correctly? I found it on Sikhi to the Max - here Raam is spelt with an aunkar and seems to be saying 'Jap Raam my female friends'

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

Harinder Singh · 09 Jun 2007

Veer, It seems to be a mistake as raam cant come with aunkarr. On ang 161, the rahao tuk has raam without aunkarr. '"raam japhu bhavjall utrahu paar" So its clear that there is a printing mistake in one of these tuks and the mistake is on ang 416 and this tuk on ang 161 is correct. Bhul Chukk maaf

Re: Should One Chant 'Rama' in stead of 'Waheguru'

hps · 09 Jun 2007

Rama and Krishna are generic names and there is no harm in chanting the name of God . If Guru Granth Sahib does not indicate the 'naam' then one can remember Him by any name. [%sig%]