Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Shere Panjab to reform?

Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 26 May 2007

http://www.sarabhapanjab.blogspot.com/ 24th May 2007 UK Panjabi-Sikh youth led a meeting in Smethwick on Sunday evening to address the problems facing UK Sikh youth. It was attended by prominent figures from the Panjabi-Sikh community including original Sher-e-Panjab hierarchy and Babbar Khalsa members. Calls were made to re-establish vigilante group Sher-e-Panjab, which was officially disbanded in 1997. Since 1997 the name Sher-e-Panjab (SP) has been hijacked by hooligans who have damaged the work previously undertaken by SP. This was one of the key factors that led to the recent Handsworth Vaiskahi Mela riot. An original SP Headhunter spoke to Sarabha Panjab “We started SP back in the 70’s to combat violence and intimidation facing the Panjabi-Sikh community. Many brave young men stood up to racist skinhead attacks and later on fanatic Muslims. We never bowed down to either one.” “Once SP gained the respect of the community and was feared by racists, we had everyone trying to jump on the bandwagon. Before we knew it, every tom, dick and harry claimed to be SP” “The aim was to protect our community but it became connected with hooliganism, crime and the drug scene!” “That’s when we officially disbanded SP, and I think because of that the Panjabi-Sikh community suffered. With a steady increase in racist attacks and abuse of Sikh girls, I have been requested many times by the youth to re-establish SP” “The violence and bloodshed at the recent Vaiksahi Mela demonstrated the lack of leadership and respect within the Panjabi-Sikh community. Inter-fighting is weakening our spirit, we need to unite.”

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Harjas Kaur · 27 May 2007

The Sikh community really needs this kind of support and leadership. Guruji bless and protect them! [%sig%]

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Seeker of the Truth · 27 May 2007

Cool. Here are some more quotes from that link: "History shows the Sikh Panjabi Nation has never bowed down to tyranny and injustice. The glorious past of Khalsa army under the command of Shah-e-Shenshah Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji demonstrated unity between all those who opposed injustice. Irrelevant if you are Mohna, Keshdari, Amritdar etc. Sikh youth must unite under the banner of the Nishaan Sahib. Soora so pahchaniye, je lade deen ke het, Purja-purja kat mare, kabhu na chhade khet. One who fights against the injustice and for the poor is the one who is brave, he may be cut into pieces but must not leave the field." Good stuff. I wonder how many sikhs are willing to stand up for their community.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 27 May 2007

SOT As always, it is the minority that DOES not the majority. The rest just live off the reputation. And people should realise that Guru Gobind Singh Ji never limited himself to strictly amritdharis in his dharam yudh. Even Sufis like Buddhan Shah were involved and make sacrifices. Remember Bhai Nand Lal Goya who wasn't amritdhari and was deeply devoted to Dasmesh pita as given in his surviving written Persian works. Simple historical facts.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

abc2 · 28 May 2007

SP (the original) really knew what they were doing and took care never to be marginalised or manipulated. They should be encouraged to take charge.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Seeker of the Truth · 28 May 2007

Dalbiri, We need a worldwide group of Sikhs willing to do that type of seva when needed. I feel like most of the youth today are lost and don't care about their community's problems at all. I don't think the older Sikhs and our so called Sikh leaders will have the guts to do such seva today especially here in the west. So it is pretty much up to us now. We are the future for our community. We got to make a statement and send a message to the world not to mess with apnay community.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

sy · 28 May 2007

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/05/01/nplot201.xml the story behind one of the accused terrorist doing a court marriage with a sikh girl is shocking and that they won't reveal her identity showing that she ran away from home to marry him. Thing is problems that lead to this are 1. parants don't teach kids about sikhism, i mean im learning on my own about sikhism my parants never took the time to teach me. 2. parants are extremely strickt i mean relax and trust your children especially your daughters if you educate them on morals and religion then they should turn out fine and let them make their own decisions you try controling their life they'll rebel 3. stop favouring boys i mean when a girl is born parants arn't that happy but a boy oh man party's for days. Boy gets keys to a life of paradise were parants make sacirfice after sacirfice which leads to the boy being spoiled needing mommy to take care of him, starts drinking hard gets into drugs fighting drops out of school i mean it goes on, while the girl is forced to do the house work so on and leads her to rebel. 4.stop ignoring the problems in the community help the girls who come from homes with domestic abuse and acholic fathers i mean how are these girls going to review their own community if the community turns a blind eye to this stuff. 5. don't judge or think your better then other sikhs, one thing that almost turned me away from searching was how some gursikhs would judge me for cutting my hair and drinking like their great but im a sell out, ive actually quit drinking now but not because of those gursikhs i think those kind of guys make problems worste they just pissed me off, im not saying all gursikhs are like this most are extremely great and don't judge at all but the once who do are just hypocrites since its against the teachings of the gurus to judge others.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 29 May 2007

"5. don't judge or think your better then other sikhs, one thing that almost turned me away from searching was how some gursikhs would judge me for cutting my hair and drinking like their great but im a sell out, ive actually quit drinking now but not because of those gursikhs i think those kind of guys make problems worste they just pissed me off, im not saying all gursikhs are like this most are extremely great and don't judge at all but the once who do are just hypocrites since its against the teachings of the gurus to judge others." You hit the nail on the head. This is THE thing that makes people run from Sikhs. What makes me laugh is the notion that the guys who do keep rehat are ANYTHING like the original Khalsas, who kicked ass all the way!! And not over petty minor nonsense but against governments and big armies. Liek the people who judge could ever compare to them. They haven't got anything near the heart or the brains.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 29 May 2007

Actually, Bhai Nand Lal ji was a Gursikh. There was more than one Singh with the same neame, hence the use of nicknames. Although, you are correct that Maharaj's fauj contained people from non-Amritdharee backgrounds. Many of them made huge contributions to the struggle.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 29 May 2007

SomeSingh I don't doubt Bhai Nand Lal was a Gursikh, just that wasn't an amritdhari for some reason.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Niranjan Singh · 30 May 2007

Bhai Nand Lal Ji was an Amritdharee Singh. His real name was Bhai Nand Singh, just as Bhai Ghanayia Ji's name was Bhai Ghanayia Singh, and Mata Gurjri Ji's name was Mata Gurjar Kaur Ji, and Mai Bhago was Bhag Kaur. How could Bhai Nand Lal Ji write RahitNamahas and the TankhahNamah and preach about the Khalsa but not take Amrit himself. By the way, the Amrit Sanchar initiation was started by Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji via Charn-Amrit, and every Sikh was obligated to take Charn-Amrit in order to become a Guru-wala. This continued until 1699 when Khanday-ki-Pahul was introduced, when all GurSikhs were re-initiated under the new maryada. Bhai Nand Lal Ji was no expection to this rule.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 30 May 2007

"How could Bhai Nand Lal Ji write RahitNamahas and the TankhahNamah" No scholar has ever formed the opinion that the rahit attributed to Bhai Nand Lal was written by the same person who wrote Zindgi Nama etc.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Harjas Kaur · 30 May 2007

this is nonsensical. Someone who cuts hair and drinks blaming Sikhs who keep rehit because they piss him off and are hypocritical to judge him. Well anyone looking at his mona face can tell what someone is, the face itself is telling on him. Lets be careful with the word judgment. To use your God-given discrimination not to associate with someone because of their bad behavior and wrong choices is called intelligence not hypocrisy. Nobody has to be kind and loving and accepting of wrong behavior. And to confront behavior as destructive and wrong which is destructive and wrong is appropriate. Just because it pisses someone off justifies badgering people from ever saying it's bad? Why do people who choose a bad lifestyle want everybody to embrace them with open arms? Guruji isn't going to. rihq bihq n kbhUM iqAwgY ] rehith behith n kabehoo(n) thiaagai || The Sikh never abandons the code of conduct. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh ----------------------------------- mIxw AOr msMdIAw monw kuVI jo mwr hoie isK vrqn krih AMq krygw KuAwr ]6] meenaa aar masa(n)dheeaa monaa kurree jo maar hoe sikh varathan karehi a(n)th karaegaa khuaar ||6|| Meenaas, Masandhs, those with haircuts and those who kill their daughters; If a Sikh associates with them, he will not be united with the Lord and will suffer at the time of death.. Thankhaanama Bhai Nand Laal Jee ------------------------------------------- rhq ibnw jg mo BrmweI ] rhq ibnw nr nrky jweI ]88] rehath binaa jag mo bharamaaee || rehath binaa nar narakae jaaee ||88|| Without discipline the whole world remains deluded. Without discipline they will go to hell. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Seeker of the Truth · 01 Jun 2007

LOL @ Rehatnama and Thankhaanama I take those sources with a grain of salt. No one should be judging someone else's action. Only god can judge me. "In the beginning, in the middle and in the end, God exists. Judgement is in His Hands alone." - Guru Granth Sahib, Page 1082

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Khatarnak Times · 01 Jun 2007

People can judge your actions. Infact that is what bibek budhi is about. It is being able to discriminate between right and wrong. Guru sahib continuously tells us to avoid bad sangat. This implies judgement on part of the Sikhs to differentiate between good and bad people. Infact without this ability to judge we wouldn't get very far in Sikhi.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

khalistani · 01 Jun 2007

harjas kaur judging others is wrong and hypocritical, how do you feel when a muslim or a christian judges you and thinks you follow a man made religion or a religion of the devil, and don't forget one of the greatest sikh leaders ever use to enjoy his alchole and was a womeniser his name was maraja ranjit singh. Yes its wrong to drink and cut hair in sikhi but to judge others for not following sikhi or not wanting to follow sikhi is hypocritical and honestly i think the person is stupid for doing so because the gursikhs who judge others are doing more damage then good to sikhi because its human nature for someone to get angry and fight back when someone is judging them or looking down on them, for the gursikhs who point out the benifits of not drinking and not cutting your hair those gursikhs are the once who contribute to sikhi and thats what needs to be done is explain the benifits not complain about the negatives.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 02 Jun 2007

No offense to anyone, i understand teh need to seek the truth about kes for onself, i also went through a long search for this truth. In Dasam Granth Sahb ji, the Guru writes that kes is a sign of his sikh.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 02 Jun 2007

What are Amritdharis to do then? Avoid all non amritdhari company/ Can you not see that there may be a lot of good people out there who aren't Amritdhari or even Sikh? Should we avoid them? Even Guru Gobind Singh Ji had non SIkh friends such as Buddhan Shah, why didn't he avoid them? What imp[ression would such a Gursikh leave on the world? That Sikhs are elitist, and discriminate and judge at any given chance? You talk about discriminating between good and bad like a hair cut could allow to make blanket decisions like that. How many outwardly Gursikh people do you meet that are corrupt..... If a Gursilh cannot look deeper and see if a person is good or bad on more than just external factors what powers of discrimination would he/she have?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Harjas Kaur · 03 Jun 2007

1. It is by actions that we have a window into someone's heart. It is only by actions we can see at all. If we willfully blind ourselves to the obvious, then naturally no one can say anything. But because we see, we are obligated to conform to the truth about it. If we do not discriminate by this definition, we will not be able to tell left from right, good from evil, truth from lies. We can ruin the souls of others not to point out wrongdoing. If we are silent, we cooperate in someone's downfall with a smile of blessing on our face. Never was it heard that someone went to Guru and said, "you change your rules and accept my sin or else you are a hypocrite!" Have fear of God! It isn't to the Panth you are addressing these concerns about Guru's teaching, but to Guru! 2. We are talking about Shere Punjab, which was disbanded because the gang and criminal elements became involved. We can and do discriminate what is best for ourselves, what movements we support, and what actions are detrimental to the spiritual jeevan of the community. This does not mean Sikhi is not 4 doors wide open. It does mean that we respect Gursikhi and do not support those elements which mock principles of Sikh religion. 3. If someone is LOL at rehitnamas and disregarding Gurmat, the intent is to create impression that you don't need amrit to be a Sikh, "amritdharis are hypocrites!" You don't need to keep kes to be a Sikh, "people who keep kes are hypocrites!" Just about everyone is a hypocrite except the one who drinks, smokes, cuts kes! Don't you dare judge and speak out against that! Yet they pick and choose principles of Sikh religion to suit themselves, and so distort Gurbani to others. We have an obligation to correct distortions of Sikh religion. Let's be clear about what the truth is. These are Guru's teachings, not my judgmentalism and hypocrisy. Any movement based on male pride, criminal gangsta behavior is doomed to failure. It has nothing to do with preserving the dignity of Sikh women, and everything to do with protecting the ego. A true movement must at least be spiritually guided. That doesn't mean everyone has to be perfectly spiritual, but at least should respect Gursikhi principles. If someone is a mona, and not amritdhari, they can still conform their life as much as possible to doing seva, and by this means come closer to Sikhi, door is open. There is a reason amritdharis are not to keep company with people who drink, smoke and cut kes...they exert a corrupting influence in which everybody will go down! 4. Gurbani says people get angry when confronted with the truth. Should we then start denying what the truth is? And that is the problem with Sikh girls who denounce Sikhi, rush off to marry Muslim boys, and wind up in Pakistan. There is a punishment involved for wrong behavior. I support Shere Punjab in it's intent to protect the Sikh community from evil people like Muslim missionaries. I don't care if they are amritdhari or not. I am not judging that. I am judging/interpreting what I perceive as disrespect of Sikh religion. I am analyzing corrupting influences which will eventually drag everybody down. I don't have to associate with, accept or promote that. I don't have to be bullied into a corner to be called hypocrite and judgmental for accepting Gurmat teaching. 5. If someone is mona, a drinker/smoker, but comes to Guru Sahib with hands folded, he is trying to be better, we should encourage him. But if he is disrespecting Gurmat to justify himself, he is anti-Sikh. Leave him. He will be a bad influence. If a criminal-gang-drug-alcohol-promiscuous group is planning to rescue someone, it begs the question, rescue from what? They also are making shameful misuse of Sikh girls. We should all judge ourselves because we all have panj dhoots. But the goal is to respect Guru's bani, and Gurmat teaching. The goal is to bow to Guru Sahib in an attitude seeking forgiveness. If you get pissed off at Guru's Sikhs because they are trying to follow Guru's rehit, you will never come in the door. Because you are disrespecting the door, which is Gurmat. [quote]pr Dn pr qn pr qI inMdw AKwiD Kwih hrkwieAw ] (402-15, Awsw, mÚ 5) par Dhan par tan par tee nindaa akhaaDh khaahi harkaa-i-aa. Others' wealth, others' wives and the slander of others - eating the uneatable, you have gone crazy. swc Drm isau ruic nhI AwvY siq sunq CohwieAw ]3] (402-15, Awsw, mÚ 5) saach Dharam si-o ruch nahee aavai sat sunat chhohaa-i-aa. ||3|| You have not enshrined love for the True Faith of Dharma; hearing the Truth, you are enraged. ||3|| [/quote] [quote]hir qyrI sB krih ausqiq ijin PwQy kwiFAw ] (90-3, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) har tayree sabh karahi ustat jin faathay kaadhi-aa. Lord, everyone sings Your Praises. You have freed us from bondage. hir quDno krih sB nmskwru ijin pwpY qy rwiKAw ] (90-3, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) har tuDhno karahi sabh namaskaar jin paapai tay raakhi-aa. Lord, everyone bows in reverence to You. You have saved us from our sinful ways. hir inmwixAw qUM mwxu hir fwFI hUM qUM fwiFAw ] (90-4, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) har nimaani-aa tooN maan har daadhee hooN tooN daadhi-aa. Lord, You are the Honor of the dishonored. Lord, You are the Strongest of the strong. hir AhMkwrIAw mwir invwey mnmuK mUV swiDAw ] (90-4, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) har ahaNkaaree-aa maar nivaa-ay manmukh moorh saaDhi-aa. The Lord beats down the egocentrics and corrects the foolish, self-willed manmukhs. hir Bgqw dyie vifAweI grIb AnwiQAw ]17] (90-5, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) har bhagtaa day-ay vadi-aa-ee gareeb anaathi-aa. ||17|| The Lord bestows glorious greatness on His devotees, the poor, and the lost souls. ||17||[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

sy · 04 Jun 2007

start summer camps for sikh youth, free camps and don't force parants to send their kids ask them would they like their children to attend, in these camps have them run from mourning to evening were they will learn sikh history, as well as respect for elders morals and get to play fun activity's like kabadi learn gatka and wresting and football and rugby. When sikhs are educated about who they are watch the amount of sikh girls running away with muslims disapear. Amount of drug addictions and alchole abuse and domestic violence start to disapear.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Seeker of the Truth · 05 Jun 2007

<<>> Huh? Those babas aren't even Sikh gurus. So why should I follow their teachings? I only follow Guru Granth Sahib. Guru Granth Sahib is my guru, not those rehitnamas.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 06 Jun 2007

Harjas - Don't go thinking being amritdhari makes you beyond the problems the rest of us mortals suffer from: OIf your not going to have compassion, understanding and love for ALL Sikhs after amrit then Sikhi will be done for. Here is some postings regarding the lastest piece of nonsense afflicting the community in the U.K. Note how it is a dastaar wearing girl who converted: http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=27745&hl=

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

not important · 06 Jun 2007

Guru Granth Sahib Is your Guru???!! Dont make me laugh..... in order for guru granth sabid to be your guru u have to accept his teachings. one of those teachings is that you cant be a hindu and a sikh.... STOP YOUR HYPOCRISY!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Seeker of the Truth · 06 Jun 2007

<<>> No, you need to stop making me laugh! Where did I say I want to be Hindu????? Last time I remember, guru granth sahib is the current guru for Sikhs. So I don't understand why you would make such comments.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Harjas Kaur · 06 Jun 2007

1. It is pure mischief when someone tries to limit Gurmat Gursikhi only to Shabadguru Ji and disrespect the entire framework of Guru's teachings. The foundation of Gurmat Gursikhi includes Shabadguru Ji Maharaaj, Dasam Granth, Vaaran of Bhai Gurdas Ji, Rehit Maryada, and Purataan rehitnamay. It also includes hukam of Akal Takht and instructions of Panj Piare and the entire Gurmatta and accepted knowledge of the Panth as an entity itself. 2. To tolerate disrespect of Gurmat Gursikhi is this the same thing as having compassion? People who pick and choose Gurmat teaching undermine the framework of Gursikhi like termites. If you listen to them long enough they will justify all kinds of things, eating meat, cutting hair, removing kakkars, no need to take amrit, no need to say your nitnam. Because they promote their own lifestyle as superior to Guru's teaching, people don't have to listen to that drivel. If someone sincerely wants to change their life and get close to Guru as they can, we should give them our support. Be as good as you can. At least people should be trying, should acknowledge the value of Gursikhi. But this other way, this rebellious attitudes and tearing down Gursikhi lifestyle in front of Sikhs...what are you trying to prove? 3. Your point about some amritdhari girl who converts to Islam? Are you tearing down the value of being amritdhari by using this example? Is this to illustrate something about the hypocrisy of amritdharis in general or some superiority of Muslim religion? This proves only how evil are influences like missionaries (even you can be a missionary if you preach contrary to Gursikhi and start tearing down the Panth.) All people ever do who want to do wrong things is justify them and preach against Gursikhi. As for the young Muslim convert, I feel sorry for her. A world of sorrow is coming her way. They are already using her as a propaganda piece to harm her parents, family, community. She has betrayed herself and doesn't even know it. Guruji is her only real and true friend. [u]Common themes[/u]: Amritdharis are self-righteous, judgemental, hypocritical, unloving, uncompassionate, think you're better than everybody else, Amritdharis are bad. All this other stuff is "human." anti-Sikh... because that's not what Guruji taught... (As if Guruji said it's perfectly okay to cut hairs, drink sharab, eat meat, smoke cigarettes, go dating, have girlfriends, be immoral, take drugs, go dancing, talk dirty and whatever else is the thing of the day.) And if you don't even have the common sense to say sorry to Guruji for doing wrong, but instead tell all the amritdharis they are wrong for not tolerating your craziness, not only have you no shame, but you are crazy. Everybody is human. Amritdharis are just people trying to do what Guruji wants. Everyone has their own karam and is at their own level. No one is perfect. There have been amritdharis who did worse sins than you, but the difference is they admit what is wrong, and they go for pesh, and they change themselves. But if you disregard Gurmat and try to tell yourself you belong to Guruji anyway, and don't need any obedience, you must think you are your own guru. If you say amritdharis are all the hypocrites...no one can even help you. Do your own thing. Don't say it's right. Don't say doing right is something wrong. [quote]"He who constitutes himself his own disciple is the disciple of a fool."[/quote] ~bhull chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 07 Jun 2007

for the person responding to my post, It's perfectly fine and good for amritdharees to hang out with non-amritdharees, so long as both are good sangat. I never said otherwise. please try to understand that most amritdharees do not look down on sehajdharees.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 07 Jun 2007

Harjas I'm just trying make a comment about unity in diversity. The fact on the ground is that many different people have a relationship to Sikhism be this through conversion, family history etc. etc. No one can deny that rehatdhari Sikhs are closest to the original conception of Sikhism but these other people have legitimate links to Sikhism itself. I'm not condoning any slackness but dealing with reality. In the final analysis the reason why Sikhs often leave to others is down to plain old feelings of being accepted and wanted. Warmth! We NEED this amongst ourselves. We do have problems with judgemental behaviour and it is not a good idea to simply ignore it. If taking amrit results in feelings of superiority over others then I can't see the spiritual dimension.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 08 Jun 2007

You're right Dalbiri, looking down on others shouldn't be done. but taking amrit, whether a person feels superior about it or not, is beneficial. A person can learn from anyone, just because they learn from someone doesn't mean that that person is their guru. Forgive me if I hurt you're feelings, but this is the truth. it's written in Gurbani in more than one place. I've read in Gurbani that a person does not have a Guru until they get Amrit. So only Amritdharees have a Guru. Sahajdharee (I was sahajdharee when I learned this), do not. once again, forgive me for hurt feelings, but I searched for 2 months through Gurbani and other writings to find this, and it is written explicitly in Gurbani.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Seeker of the Truth · 08 Jun 2007

SomeSingh, Can you please post quotes from gurbani to back up your statement?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 08 Jun 2007

Why change charnamrit to khande amrit?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 09 Jun 2007

I'll try to find it. I recommend you also search for yourself, both b/c it'll increase your own understanding, and b/c I'm not sure if I can find it. It was originally written in Bhai Gurdass dian Vaaran (may be elsewhere as well). Bhai Sahib was pooran Bhramgyani and the first sikh scholar. He lived during the time of the fifth Guru. The Fifth Guru wanted to include his writings in Adi Granth Sahib ji, but Bhai Sahib declined in humility, saying that his writing were not worthwhile. I believe it was a test of his nimarta, which he passed. Nevertheless, the Guru declared his writings as Gurbani and also declared them the 'keys to understanding the Guru's bani'. When I searched originally, I believe I was reading Prof. Jodh Singh's translation. The reason why I'm not sure I'll find it is b/c I'm not sure where I'll find a complete translation on the internet and I don't have access to Prof. Jodh Singh's written translation right now. Many people think that Amrit was introduced by the tenth Guru, but that's actually not true. The first Amrit Sanchar, along with rahit, was begun by the first Guru, Guru Nanak Dev ji. Similar to how we are to regard all the Gurus as one and the same b/c the same light exists in all of their different bodies, the final format of Amrit Sanchar was given by the Tenth Guru, but it is still the same Amrit as given by the first Guru with one difference that I know of. The difference is that Amrit used to inspire a too peaceful nature in the Sikhs. The Tenth Master wanted to inspire bir russ, and for this reason made the Amrit with a sword.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

sy · 09 Jun 2007

the best way to beat the islamic problem and conversions is to educate the girls in the sikh community, tell parants to stop focusing on working and making money and not spending time with their kids and teaching them their culture, the problem will be solved without a gang war when sikhs are educated on their culture religion history and are tought morals and are trusted.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 11 Jun 2007

I agree more with SY. Whatever the motives and well intentions of the SP, there violent and retributive approach is wrong and just promotes a tit for tat approach which never ends for years on end and creates a climate of hate. We are not living in the times of the gurus and the warfare has changed from battles and fighting with swords to politics and education. If we bring back a movement which is based on covert attempts to attach those who are savaging and attacking members of the community, we are and will be seen as no better than the perpetrators. We need to take a more tactile and bloodless approach. Whatever religion a person belongs to, we have learnt from our gurus that we will stand for what is right and using the right methods. When there is a time to life the sword, the that should be done, but that is not the case in this day and age as it was several hundreds of years ago. Bani is universal and immortal and has and will stand the test of time. We need to chance our attitudes to make sure we are safeguarding our guru's reputation and that of the sikh faith as protectors of the under priviledged and persecuted whereever they come from. The media can play a big part in this, but it is only through clever and useful methods that this can be achieved, and through education from top to bottom about Sikhi.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 12 Jun 2007

did these sher-e-punjab guys only attack perpetrators of crimes, or did they attack innocent muslims as well?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

SomeSingh · 12 Jun 2007

I believe the other reason for changing charnki amrit to Khande Batte da Amrit was that the tenth Guru was the last one in human form. So after the tenth Guru onwards the form of the guru is punj pyare and Guru Granth Sahbi ji.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

abc2 · 12 Jun 2007

Shouldn't we be asking: did the Pakistanis ever target any criminal Sikhs, or did they just go for any innocent victims they could overwhelm with superior numbers? Did the Pakistanis ever report any of the thugs in their community to the authorities, during their campaign of terror against the UK Punjabi community? The answer to both questions is 'no'. Remember al-Muhajiroun was only banned in 2006 (a long time after 9/11) and that was only at the request of the Russian government who discovered that members from this group (from the London School of Economics) were helping the Chechen militants. HuT (still active) and al-Muhajiroun worked and work on the Uni campuses which are their recruiting grounds. For a very long time in Britain, the authorities seemed unwilling to arrest these people, instead preferring the media to report on their outrageous antics (helping to contribe to the case for war overseas). These people support the creation of an Islamic state in Britain and over the whole world. They do not accept any non-Muslim authority. There are allegations that they have been used as 'useful idiots' in the big league political game. If you want to play politics you have to be useful, and as far as I'm concerned anyone who's calling for Sharia law or Islamic Caliphate in Britain should literally be squashed [u]even if the collateral cost is high[/u]. Nobody should be allowed to practise Islam in its Koranic, barbaric form (i.e. the Mahometan version). I for one am firmly in opposition to them.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 13 Jun 2007

Then why did the gurus have such relationships with muslims as Bhai Mardana, Mian Mir, Gani Khan and Nabi Khan? If they were not rejected by the Guru, than how can you make such a rash statement about them and be as stereotypical about them as they are of us. Tolerance my friend, tolerance, Find the people you have an issue with and the groups and deal with them using the appropriate means. Don't brandinsh whole communities of people, with a narrow minded approach. Don't forget that nearly a sixth of the world's population is muslim. They have a right to life and religious freedom, we as a minority have.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

abc2 · 13 Jun 2007

Jassmann there are many types of Muslims. One of them is the Mahometan kind, who believes that he must follow the way of Mahomet [u]as ordered on pain of everlasting torture in the Koran[/u]. The Koran has no respect for human rights, equality of women, right to life, respect for property, etc. It urges to wage war on unbelievers, in an utterly ruthless way, using rape and force and the threat of force mercilessly. Where is the 'tolerance' in that? Please let me know. Mahomet managed to convince a lot of people over the ages that the voices in his head came from a divine source, rather than an imaginary friend. He was a merciless psychopath and a very dangerous violent one. His followers attacked women and children in desert caravan, and massacred the Jewish people and forced them off their land. As a reward, he would give captured women to his followers, who would systematically rape them. [u]All of this set a precedent for the barbarism that Koranic Islam has brought to the world since Mahomet.[/u] As a responsible human being, I will resist to my last breath the type of Muslim who wants the Sharia law and who wants to wage war on the unbeliever. There is no way of living in peace with such people. Ultimately if the 'war on terror' cannot suppress the Muslim fundamentalism of Shia and Sunnis, then the responsibility to protect our right to remain 'unbelievers' will fall on our heads. Are we up to the challenge like our great ancestors were? As Sikhs, we are all Muslims of Peer Nanak Shah and not Muslims of Mahomet. Likewise, the likes of Bhai Mardana were also Muslims of Satguru Nanak and not of Mahomet, and definitely were not followers of the Koran. The Koran states: eat only Halal meat. Satguru Nanak Dev Ji specifically outlawed this 'Halal' for his followers without exception. Let's be clear, the Muslims who became Sikhs were not Mahometans and were not inclined to observe the Koran or any Hadith. In fact Mahometans are proportionally few in number, despite their disproportionately large barbaric influence in the Muslim world. Compare that to modern day, liberal secular England, where people are free to adopt or reject any faith, and to do what they want even if they are women. The type of scum who doesn't like this and wants to impose Sharia law even when they're in a country like UK, should be hanged. No way should there be an absolute religious freedom allowing people to practice the original, Koranic Islam. If you have sympathy with the contents of the Koran, go ahead and become a Muslim because you deserve it. But I believe this so-called 'religion' in its present form will be gone within 30 odd years from now. You can't impose Sharia law without temporal authority, or even beat your wife without the tacit complicity of your immediate neighbours, and those lands are feeling the pressure now (including from within). People have had enough.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 14 Jun 2007

Well I don't believe your translation of the Quaran, and regardless of what they say in their religion, it's not for us to judge. Like I said before, if you have an issue with certain factions of the Islamic community then take it up as you please and act appropriately, but I think you are very irresponsible, firstly because I am sure you have not read the Koran, and you have a very biased view. We are a tolerant religion, we must live in harmony with all, but stand up for the rights of the oppressed, not rant and rave against a whole religion or their leader, that is not what we have been taught by our gurus.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

abc2 · 14 Jun 2007

Jassmann you have made some erroneous assumptions and then drawing false conclusions from them. Firstly you said that I spoke out against 'Muslims', then you made the false assertion that Bhai Mardana and Mian Mir were Koranic Mahometans (people who believed in the instructions related in the Koran), and now you're saying that I haven't read the Koran. Actually I have Dawood's translation, and I found it through and through deplorably violent, bigoted and fascistic. It was a glimpse into a dark age I never believed could exist into the 21st century. Now, if you say this translation is no good (although your own provenance as a linguist would have to be weighed against that of the scholar Dawood) please recommend a 'nice' translation so that I can read a politically correct version. Actually I would be very pleased to find any politically correct translation of the Koran because this can be used to support Muslim moderates against Islamists. I have no issue with any faction of the Muslims community - only those Muslims who actually believe and want to practise Islam properly (as defined in the Koran). That's what I want to suppress and squash. If someone wants to pray at the mosque on Friday that's fine (as long as we have checked his imam is 'safe') but if that same person takes MAHOMET's perspective on scantily dressed women he sees in the street, or 'the house of war' and 'the house of Islam', or treating Muslims or 'people of one book' differently from Kufr, then he is the enemy of our civilisation. All those who defend Koranic Islam are defenders of the Taleban (who are credited with having implemented Sharia law of Sunni Islam strictly). Just like the Taleban didn't find it necessary to learn Pali before destroying the Buddha statues of Bamiyan, so those of us who are against the Islamists don't need to learn classical Arabic to know that we don't want [u]death by stoning[/u], the rule of God as defined by Mahomet through a stinking Islamic Caliph. And thanks, but whether some maniac writes it in classical Arabic or Greek or in modern English, it does NOT lend any credibility to the notion that there is an after-death [u]paradise of dark-eyed immortal virgins and 'pearly boys'[/u] for the sick followers of this perverted 'religion'. My views more or less tally with those of Ali Sina, so if you want to discuss these matters further please visit: http://www.faithfreedom.org and do it there. Thanks

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 14 Jun 2007

Well you make a very strong case, but to a socialist like me it just sounds very anti semitic and generalistic, when there are soo many translations of the Quaran, but you have chosen a specific text for your guidance, which is fair enough. So there will be sects that take the most extreme view in a translation as there are some in Sikhi. I will visit that site you have suggested and air my views there. I do agree there is some oppression in Islamic countries world-wide and if it a human rights abuse then we should step in. But we are all talk largely abd pick up the baton of injustice only when it afflicts our community. If we generalise to such an extent, some gullable people on this site may adopt that view and take it at word. I just think you should be careful before inciting such views, when Guru Ji preaches Equality and freedon of religious practice. And if there were attempts to force Sharia Law in this country, I shall be first on the picket line to defend the rights of the people against it.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 15 Jun 2007

Jassman, I get what your saying but there is another point where secularism also attempts to devalue and destabilise religions per se including Sikhism. What about that?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 15 Jun 2007

I don't feel destabilised. Do you?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 15 Jun 2007

No but I feel like there is some unnecessary jabbing going on by whitey...lol They need to do a lot more for us.....

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 18 Jun 2007

Dalbiri, We enjoy soo much in this country and we shouldn't get the beggar's bowl out everytime. If it's a right them we should demand it but not expect them to give us more than any other community settled here.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

abc2 · 20 Jun 2007

Hmmm... I now consider that I was wrong on this issue. Can't go around blaming all Muslims, or their religion, for the actions of a few. Sorry about that.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 20 Jun 2007

I'm talking about begging for anything like that. I'm just asking for a fair and balanced representation of Sikhs in the media. NOT mainly talk about gangs, forced marriages, violence or the usual crap about Sikh freedom fighters of the 80s being terrorists or extremists. Whatever negativity is being highlighted, balance it out with information showing how hardworking, decent etc. most Sikhs are. Plus the fact that so many Sikhs died for Britian should count for something...big And I do believe that in general the media seems to follow some discretely racist agenda where many others are subtly portrayed as trouble makers or backwards. Have you heard of the concept of "othering" This is a fundemental aspect of how Western society works by differentiating between "them" and "us" to give the population a vague sense of identity. Sikhs should be appreciated more.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 21 Jun 2007

Well, I still disagree. Somethign negative happening with anything is generally what makes the news. Any Sikhs hardly ever make it into the news anyway so why is there all this, oh they are picking on us mentality? I just don;t get it, and when we get somethign positive like the trafalgar square Vaisakhi Mela there is a furore about some other issue, like there was Bhangra, there was this and that. I have some to the conslusion that some people will just never be happy until we have the country worshipping us in the UK and the country has changed it's name to Khalistan. I'm just saying, guy, get over it, it's not that bad and it's not a conspiracy. When someone messes up, it's going to get reported, you just have to deal with it.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 21 Jun 2007

I hear you Jassman. I guess we all have to make efforts to make people understand and accept us fully here. BTW, I wasn't asking for Sikhs to be worshipped but rather a fuller appreciation of the SIkh contribution to the U.K. past and present. I mean those guys who volunteered for the world wars (as much as I don't agree with some of the colonial connotations), gave the ultimate (i.e. their lives) for this place. If we have red poppy day to commemorate veterans, they should make noise about the disproportionate sacrifices by Sikhs. In this day and age of mass propaganda and spin we need to make sure that some of it goes our way. You get me?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 21 Jun 2007

I do get it mate, I'm just of the opinion that we need to chill a little. It's not that bad. And also, there were other groups who fought in the War, they all want recognition as well and Sikhs have had exhibitions and events where these were remembered. I personally feel that I have it really good here and my rights are protected as with any other group. Now to what degree others have suffered abuses and the likes I don't know, but for me it's no better or worse than the experience of my cousins living in India. So what are we really asking for comparitively? Yes we do need media support and understanding, but there is no one unified body that speaks for the community and I don't know if that is a good thing or a bad thing.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 21 Jun 2007

Jasmann the fact on the ground is that the average Joe is heavily affected by what they see on TV, as stupid as this is. So it stands to reason that if we have mainly a negative portrayal (some but not all of which IS the fault of Sikhs), then we will be looked at with the usual hate and distrust. So I think we need to push, directly but more importantly indirectly for a apathetic portrayal. I saw that program on Channel 4 about the raj for example, that was blatantly biased. I complained to Ofsted and wrote back a month or so later saying..Thanks but we don't feel that it was biased blah blah....... But for Shilpa Shetty getting insulted their is a hue and cry! For a whole community to be maligned with rape and murder - nowt!

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 22 Jun 2007

So what you are basically insinuating is that Channel 4 on purpose tried to malign the community and there was no evidence that put that documentary together? Is that in essence your issue with that programme? I also watched it and I had no problems with it because there were culprits on all sides in Partition. So who shall I defend? Unless you have evidence to the contrary that no Sikh was invovled in ill treatment of other religions, I'm happy for them to put their documentary together based on what they found out. I work in the Media but I'm not here to propogate or manage a PR campaign for the Sikh community. We have had it a lot easier than the Muslims and some other groups of the years, so I think we are getting off lightly. If we as individuals do have problems with the portrayal, then put your own programmes forward and ideas as well as articles and the likes. That's one way to counter negative press.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 22 Jun 2007

"I also watched it and I had no problems with it because there were culprits on all sides in Partition. So who shall I defend?" Nope, Sikhs were sitting peacefully on their own land. They never had an idea of a religiously divided land before others started it. Hence the disproportionate sacrifice for freedom (you know the commonly cited figures). They were forced into a real crap situation where they were being driven off their lands. I don't agree with some of the actions of some people on the Sikh side (my great grand dad and his friend actually physically escorted a large Muslims group to camps (by marching them armed with kirpaans) threatening angry Sikh mobs. But still that programme made it look like Sikhs went on some mad rampage unprovoked! I'll quote a letter sent to me by Ofsted now: "The last days of the raj was introduced as an 'historical drama' - viewers would have not expected a detailed and historically accurate portrayal of events surrounding the partition of India." So its ok to create programs that are not true because of this. DESPITE the fact that we all know that large sections of the population will take the program to be true. Is that not plainly irresponsible? We all know the power of the media. Lets not pretend to be naive to the power of media. "The title's reference to "The Raj" suggests that the programme would concentrate from events from a British perspective..." Viewers..."could be expected to appreciate that what they were being presented with was not an indepth analysis of the conflicts that arose at the time but rather one particular aspect so that one major theme could be highlighted." So it was a load of old tosh with no attempt at subjectivity. In other words BIASED!!! Jassman, don't get me wrong, I appreciate the relative freedom we have here but don't be naive to the propaganda that gets played out in the media here.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Harjas Kaur · 24 Jun 2007

1. The purpose of media is to promote a governments objectives. Hence the media is supported by paid advertising. Advertisements notoriously sublimate content using sophisticated techniques and millions of dollars of testing... just so they can effectively manipulate the public on an unconscious or semi-conscious level. In other words...the media is brainwashing you! In fact, if you research it, the media was designed precisely for this purpose. 2. Usually advertisements attempt to induce the public to sell a product. A healthy economy is good for industry. But advertisements also sell a particular viewpoint. There is just no way Britain is going to put together a show on the Sikh Raj which isn't an apologetic for British history, British invasion, British imperialism, and British destruction of the Sikh Raj. Because such a show would be so contrary to British interests even today. Naturally there will be sophisticated and subtle bias to justify a need for invasion, or to blame irreconcilable Sikh militarism. The best you will get is some partial truth. When we see the Queen Mother restore the Kohinoor diamond to Panjab...that will be the day I believe in British honesty. [img]http://www.bendavidjewelers.com/gems/kohinoor.jpg[/img] Kohinoor Diamond set in the British Crown Jewels. [u]Psychological Warfare Against the Public[/u]: (sorry for the American slant. All major governments use these techniques.) Nazi-American Science [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_pAHABP2lA[/url] Political Programming [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjCvrR641lw[/url] How to Brainwash a Nation [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZ8ZvYNlxiM[/url] Programming the Nation [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udIhli5mo-Q[/url] Protect your minds Singhs. Media = Maya! Be careful what you let pass through the doors of your perception. Watch diligently what you put into your eyes and ears...it affects your mind. Most subliminal influences are intended to be seductive, influential, attack your own basic values, and promote an evil agenda. Don't be part of disloyalty to yourself, your Quam, your Guru. No, Sikhs are not perfect, but be loyal to yourselves and not to a conqueror's agenda promoting self-blame. Please be careful some may find these links offensive. I didn't post them to be offensive, but because these movies, songs, etc., are around us all the time as popular culture, we don't even recognize the hidden offensiveness that is subliminally there. I posted so the Singhs/Singhnis will be aware, alert, and protect their kids. [u]Music[/u]: Brittany Backwards [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf49IxrWUpk[/url] Queen backwards [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ca6k7i8p9Oo[/url] Charles Manson really did send followers out to murder people because he believed while under influence of psychedelic drugs that the rock band The Beatles were giving him hidden messages. And the rock band Led Zeppelin really did have an occult association with the teachings of Aleister Crowley. Sounds crazy I know...but all these wealthy and powerful bands really do have hidden, ugly and evil messages. It's just a crazy maya world. You want to be free of manipulation, fake lies and evil influences? Protect your minds, tie your jura, don't expose to blatant evil, and jap Naam! And Singhs, don't believe everything you hear. A lot of it is tailored to manipulate a certain response or a certain viewpoint. Maya always works against your freedom. Bibek is about using your discrimination not to be under the influence of anything evil, no matter how acceptable, common or harmless it pretends to be. Companies don't make mistakes with billion dollar advertising. And everything they do passes government censors and regulators. So what exactly is the government permitting? Beatles backwards: [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UVDlg4x468[/url] The Influence of the Beatles on Charles Manson [url]http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/manson/mansonbeatles.html[/url] Disney brainwashing the kids: [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNcZcEf20g8[/url] Good teenagers... [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCpKRQ3CAv8[/url] Nudity in children's films? [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kavyKWO8joQ[/url] Programming is real. [%sig%]

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

sy · 24 Jun 2007

i was wondering what can be done to stop muslim attacks on sikhs in england, i heard in my area last night that a young sikh about 17 was rushed by 7-8 muslims and beated pretty bad suffering a broken arm and hand.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 25 Jun 2007

Although I can appreciate some of the points that are being made above, they are all looking at the media as one single entity, which it's not. I agree there are programmes and advertisements which are not in the best of taste or appropriate, but some people are taking it to an extreme level. Guru Ji did not want us to live in a vacuum where we do not engage with the world. It is even more so today, as the internet is at our finger tips and we can access almost anything we want. Harjas Kaur said: "The purpose of media is to promote a governments objectives. Hence the media is supported by paid advertising." This is completely wrong. The media is out there to make money unless you are a PSB like the BBC. Media outlets will hamper to the advertiser and to the law so they don't get sued or shut down. The media is like any other business and they will put on what sells and does well and avoid what doesn't. They to have to make sure they are on the right side of the law, but not always pander to the Government, becuase it is the Government which put obstacles in the way, but it is the advertiser and the public that put food on the table. Also, there are many Sikh Radio station which play Kirtan and Path, and there are websites likes this forum for information, which are all part of the wider media. When we refer to media, can we either be specific about a medium or outlet, else you point becomes void as we are all currently conversing through the media.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 25 Jun 2007

Sometimes it just feels like certain elements of the media here in the UK seem to push a certain agenda which is bordering on xenophobic i.e. The Mail, The Sun and certain television programs that are shown such as the partition one. Take Richard Littlejohn (Littlebrain) for instance. I'm not saying all of media is on this agenda but those that are can be dangerous because the general public can be easily influenced by media (especially daily papers and television), rightly or wrongly. I'm just saying as Sikhs we should perhaps be careful to make sure we are not caught in the middle of this as recent events have caused a lurch to the right in the UK in my view. Let us just share views anyway. I do believe that Sikhs lack support and savvy when it comes to the media in general. We are way behind. Look at the type of movies created from Sikh backgrounds in the past (i.e. all those Panjabi films in the 80s), they seriously lack any sophistication whatsoever and just continue the old badla, anakkh, zameen thing. We do need to be represented in media more fully and this will only happen when we invest into this ourselves and through the new generation instead of always pushing them to be lawyers, doctors, accountants, engineers etc..

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 25 Jun 2007

The Thing with the Daily Mail is that it sells and he is popular because people out there have the same view as him. Some people in this country are racist but don't show it which is their opinion as far as I'm concerned and all we can do is be on our best bahaviour to make sure we show that we are the citizens our Gurus intended us to be. I think Xenophobic is a strong word, because even they join the bandwagon when it is seen as popular, as seen with Shilpa Shetty, (not sure if anybody bought The Sun the day after she won) but it was a whole thing about anti Racism. Basically they will write what sells and broadcast what works and that's because it is a business. We need to look within ourselves and not always blame others for our shortfalls as a community. If we want to do do something then we should have more people employed in the media, or we should be launching our own media etc.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 25 Jun 2007

"If we want to do do something then we should have more people employed in the media, or we should be launching our own media etc." Here here to that!!!! But also recognise that lumpen sections of popular media is pretty much against many things perceived as "foreign" and subtly (and not so subtly) do much mischief.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 26 Jun 2007

I don't think it is about mischief. If two Sikhs, for example, are invovled in a major incident, say a stabbing, then that will be reported. We can't say that is mischief. There are certain sections of the community, and I dare say the media, who are not pro foreigners etc, and that is their legitimate right. If someone says something against any section of the community say, white working class, muslim extremists, black people in London, there will always be many points that can be put forward to make the case the journalist is trying to make. They are not trying to be pro anything unless they are trying to prove a point with interviews and with evidence and even still there will always be two or more sides of opinion in any debate. So it is the journalist's editorial authority to decide what to and what not to include. Not ours to say, well I find that offensive so you shouldn't publish or broadcast it. Now, when the media doesn't give us what we want, that does not make their argument void, it is still an argument that they have put forward from their perspective and for that point it is legitamate, just as you feel any point that you might make is legitamate. I do know where there are wrong doings in the media, having worked in the industry myself. I do however, laugh at some of the accusations made against the media which would not feel out of place in an episode of spooks or 24. We need to stop being so sensitive, be more proactive in generating positive PR in the first place. If we have no media representative, then the only time the Sikhs are going to make it to the media is when there is a negative story, and that's just the way the cookie crumbles.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 26 Jun 2007

OK, so we agree that in general we get a disproportionate level of negative publicity as the result of the current media set up. I live in a very urban area of London. Violence is not unknown to take place here in our little town. Be it gang warfare, stabbings or violent muggings etc. It makes the local paper but only occasionally in the national ones. So why is it that over the years whenever similar violence takes place in say Southall, it is usually emblazoned in the national papers, typically including the the word "Sikh" in the headline, when it is generally the same type of stuff that happens around here? These things make you pause and think.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 27 Jun 2007

Personally, and I read several nationals everyday as part of my job, rarely see the word Sikh anywhere. In fact I can't specifically remember where we were last mentioned in any paper let alone a national. I don't think it is disproportionate when compared to the press black people get and then the muslims. We are relatively unknown in some parts of the country unlike muslims. I think there is a need for more positive PR, but you can never avoid negative coverage unless you have someone like Alistair Campbell working for you, and even then it is not guaranteed. Try and do good work and get some advice from a PR person on how to sell it into the media.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 28 Jun 2007

Jassmann I'm really surprised at your enduring pro-media stance. Do you work as one of those media watchers for organisations?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 29 Jun 2007

It's not pro or anti; it's the reality as I see it. People see the media as some alien entity or corporate conspiracy and don't see that actually iy's people running the media. People like you and me and others. Just because Rupert Murdoch owns the Sun, doesn't mean he sits there and read every article. He has a comment and an agenca, just as the Daily Mail has or even the BBC and there is no such thing as unbiased. I just think people need to wake up and smell the coffee. It's the real world, with people in it. Some people are not nice and some people are, we can't go around claiming all this conspiracy rubbsih when there is no evidence and we are too lazy to actually do anything but sit aorund on forums like we know it all. That's my issue. Most people who sit here with an issue about the media, have never had a job in the media, but apparently they have some insight that they can't prove but will go on about it to the point of accusing me of being part of some MI5 ploy which is trying to bring the Sikh religion down. To be honest, we are a small community, and don't really make the headlines at all unless there is some problem or a riot. And to be fare, I don't think any part of the Government really gives a damn considering the issues that they have to deal with. It's all high and might sitting at the side road making comments as people walk past, but what do these people reall know about how the Government is run, what their issues are and how a media agenda is set. We can all read books mate, but what about the reality. We harp on about the truth but how many of us are willing to look at the truth which is under our nose. Like a friend said to me, no Sikh Muslim, Christian or other person goes to their place of worship to be challenged, they all go there to here their beliefs reaffirmed. If you don't like what you here people start back biting, cussing or otherwise. Is that the kind of world you want to live in? People just believe what they want to, never challenge or question? That's a sure way to get to the truth isn't it??!!

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 29 Jun 2007

"Is that the kind of world you want to live in? People just believe what they want to, never challenge or question? That's a sure way to get to the truth isn't it??!!" You can say that about large sections of the media in the U.K. People like Richard Littlejohn just reinforce preconceived racist notions many in this country have. Same for the average Mail reader. So lots of people are at this "belief affirmation" thing! The problem lies with some of the beliefs/ideas being projected being directly or indirectly against us. You're probably right in that we can do little about it as power is kept away from people but to play down that it is commonplace seems wrong.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

abc2 · 29 Jun 2007

jassmann you stated: [quote] Most people who sit here with an issue about the media, have never had a job in the media, but apparently they have some insight that they can't prove but will go on about it to the point of accusing me of being part of some MI5 ploy which is trying to bring the Sikh religion down. [/quote] You and your pro-media sidekick 'kulsin' were the first to bring the Security Service (MI5) into the debate. Nobody has accused you directly of being an agent of MI5, but since you bring it up I agree it is a distinct possibility. Do you know how MI5 works? Their direct employees are not called 'agents' but 'operatives' or 'intelligence officers'. Part of their job is to run 'agents' who are in useful positions, such as the media. They use 'influence' (or whatever else is needed) on journalists and media people to get them to become 'MI5 agents' (not as in James Bond style spies or direct employees, but as useful idiots), to not only investigate people and circumstances but also to plant fake stories and fake grassroots (astroturfing). Astroturfing is when someone tries to create an impression of a grassroots movement, which is actually fake. They do this for political or financial advantage. Example: http://www.handsoff.org Read more about it here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astroturfing As a 'media professional', perhaps you can help us refine this definition of astroturfing. Please do tell us how the pros do it.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 02 Jul 2007

abc2 I don't deny the power of PR or astro-turfing, but I don't think the conspiracy goes as far as you like to believe. If a Government didn't use PR or spin, they wouldn't last a term in office. Every journo would be out for blood, and everytime a politician slipped up there would be calls for resignation, as we so often see. PR is a way of managing that crisis and winning support as every business, charity organisation does, not just the media. And I don't believe what you have said about MI5 - till it's proven, which it's not. We can all read books and decide that we agree or disagree with. I'm not even that pro-media to be honest, but I'm concerned by some of the radical 'out-there' theories brandished on this forum. People send me links which are nothing more than opinion pieces. So let's leave it at our own beliefs then, since none of us are likely to arrive at a consensus.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 02 Jul 2007

Jassman, If you are open minded then you mustn't discount possibilities. It isn't hard to imagine ye old Anglo-Saxons plotting away behind closed doors for all sorts of things. Plus their history shows they are especially prone and adept at this. You are right, some people might be too out there but to think that everything is as simple as it appears borders on the other extreme of plain naivety.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 04 Jul 2007

The thing is Dalbiri, I am rather liberal and open minded to what is possible; and I’ve definitely seen the darker side of human nature - on more than a few occasions. But I can’t just start considering the absurd, when there is no evidence, or reason for something to ‘allegedly’ be taking place. If you knew how easy it is to get a leak from a Government insider, then you would better understand why I have reservations about some of the theories people spread on these forums. I mean, don’t get me wrong, you are welcome to your views and opinions, and I know the Government does a lot of covering up, but you need to think realistically and with your feet firmly on the ground, on what actually is possible and has a reason, and what is total fantasy.

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 04 Jul 2007

What do you make of the fact that it now seems that the British intelligence was warned by the Yanks that a terrorist strike on a Scottish airport was imminent and failed to inform anyone?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

jassmannn · 05 Jul 2007

I would say they had limited intelligence and not enough info to arrest anyone, or know when and where. What has the Governement got to gain from a terrorist attack, and why would they not have done something if they had more information and knew where and when it was going to take place?

Re: Shere Panjab to reform?

Dalbiri · 05 Jul 2007

Don't discount the possibility that this "war on terror" has its benefits for our rulers in that they keep the proletariat subdued and geared up and looking outwards for bogeymen. A unifying force for the masses.