Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Keertan Important!

Keertan Important!

gupt · 20 May 2007

vjkk vjkf Found some interesting things about Keertan, please read the following, mainly the bit about breaking the shabad, and not finishing the Shabad & Simran Veer Surinder Singh jee was a Ranglay Sajjan of our Jatha, but he made sure that proper traditions were followed in keertan. In my presence hewould say to Bhai. Mohinder Singh SDO: "whatever shabad you start, finish it before you commence the next." Bhai Mohinder Singh had his own style of keertan, which was a "keertan-lecture". Sometimes he would even do a little viaakhyaa. His keertan was mostly to explain things to the people, in which he was able to showcase his knowledge. Veer Surinder Singh jee understood what Bhai. Mohinder Singh really wanted. He used to say "if you leave the shabad you are reciting half way and take the keertan somewhere else, those who’s consciousness is focussed on the shabad keep waiting and looking at your face. That person is waiting for the next pangtee. Then, your time is taken up by the disorganization you have caused and the time is over. No shabad was sung in totality so isn’t this disrespect of baaNee? You give ras to the listeners’ ears by playing good tunes (Mirzaa Saahibaa, etc) but you do not enjoy spiritual ras nor do you give it to the sangat." Every time, Bh. Mohinder Singh would lower his head and listen, but he never took the advice. Veer Surinder Singh used to say, "some keertanees have a fever to do keertan. They just sit at the vaja and don’t stop even when people are stopping them. Some, to make the keertan louder use "Vahiguru Vahiguru" dhunee as a style. Doing keertan of shabad is one thing and doing naam abhyaas in sangat is another. When doing abhyaas, do abhyaas. How did that Jatha, whose name is Akhand Keertanee Jatha, begin to break the keertan by doing abhyaas styles?" This custom did not exist in Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh jee’s time. Will the brothers and sisters in the AKJ take the lead from the keertan at Sree Harimandir Saahib? Here, in the non-stop keertan, you don’t here the "Vahiguru Vahiguru" dhunee. Is doing "Vahiguru Vahiguru" wrong? No. Blessed is the voice that says it. But keertan should be done while keeping the listener in mind. If some beloved of the Guru has his consciousness focused on the Shabad, he does not want to break away from the shabad even for an instant. Once I saw the suffering this break from shabad can cause in Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh jee. One Singh got up after doing keertan and another sat down and began to play the keys of vaja to get the tune. Bhai Saahib was sitting at the back and cried out "Start the Shabad, the khaal is drying up!" Those landowners who give water to their fields understand this saying perfectly. So, stopping the stream of keertan gives pain to the hearts of Veer Surinder Singh jee and Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee. Veer jee (Bhai Surinder Singh) used to say that too many keertanees do not do keertan with their minds at the Guru’s feet.

Re: Keertan Important!

talikhaak · 21 May 2007

Live and Let Live

Re: Keertan Important!

_lowest_ · 21 May 2007

waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh! ive never thought of it like that before, got a couple of questions... 1. is it acceptable to finish a shabad then do simran at the end? 2. what if the simran in the shabad is spontaneous? for example if the person just starts doing abhiyaas without planning it, should you stop yourself??? waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh!! [%sig%]

Re: Keertan Important!

jassmannn · 22 May 2007

I think people are getting to ritualistic about the way people do Kirtan. If you do kirtan for the sangat, then expect them to reward you, but if you do it for guru sahib, as it should be, then they will bless you. It is not disrespect if you don't finish a shabad and then start viakhiaya and the finish it later, and it's not wrong to use 2 lines of a shabad to explain a point that you are making in viakhiya which is relevant to your point. All the bani is a sarovar of Amrit, just because you drink some now and a little later, does not mean that your thirst will not be quenched! We all have different ways of doing Kirtan and different styles. As long as you read the bani correctly and you are respectful and have Guru Ji in mind, then all is well.

Re: Keertan Important!

Bazzer · 22 May 2007

I think each kirtani has his or her own style. The kirtan ebbs and flows like a river. Some do very simple kirtan - sthyi / antra / sthyi Some start a shabad and inbetween like to add viakhya while the saajs are still playing. Some statrt a shabad, will stop and do viakhya, may sing other shabads but will come back and complete the main shabad. Some, like to start a shabad and like to add tuks from other shabads that are related to the main shabad. Some like to start a shabad and add simran/jaap inbetween. Some like to do a proper Dundaut Bandhan / Alaap followed by shabad with akhaars and taans. Some like to sing a pangtee and get the sangat to repeat it. As a rule, once a shabd is started it should be completed. I have seen some kirtani, who running out of time will complete the shabad by just reciting the remaining lines, which is very comendable. To me this is the wonder of kirtan, each is amazing in its own right. None is right none is wrong. Some like one style others like different styles. At the end of the day each kirtani is trying to convey the shabad to the sangat. I think it would be a mistake if suddenly we had rules of do's and don'ts

Re: Keertan Important!

**** · 22 May 2007

If individuals feel the ras coming from the shabaad and then broken by dhunni, then that is quite understandable. This point applies to many. People will only understand this when they feel it themselves. Reading bani or doing simran can only be a good thing, but the above point i feel applies to those who only feel the constant ras coming from the flow of gurbani and broken if interupted.

Re: Keertan Important!

ns · 25 May 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Veer Gupt jeeo, no one doubt the avasthas Gursikhs of Ranglaay sajjan. Mohinder Singh SDO di ddo brilliant kirtan in my opinion and as I was only 15 at the time of listening to him, I still have recodrings and listen to them from time to time, there is something special from kirtan of those days.I agree with the criticism which is constructive from Surinder Singh Jeeo, maybe he was at a way too advanced level of kamai than people like Mohinder Singh Jee, every one is different, as per humkam " aaap aapani budh haai jeetee". We have kitan and naam dhuni presneted to us in both forms , and still we try and distinguish right and wrong. What about Baba Nidhaan Singh Jee of Hazoor Sahib , have you seen the karkaala he used when he was immersed in Gurbani and naam simran and maharaj gave darshan to him as we're all aware. It was prem and piar of shabad that will get you somewhere, and a doubt a certain technique will, whether it's naam simran or Gurbani kirtan the emphasis is to be imeersed in love for it. I'm not sure how the break up of kirtan came to abyaas stules in the jatha there is no one person you can blame for this. I personally think it'was out of pyaar for waheguru and I see nothing wrong with it and also respect and agree with what Surinder Singh mentions.

Re: Keertan Important!

Khalsaspirit · 25 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, This is nice to see that gupt jio finally like to hear some thing about keertan. Well the topic they brought up is between the high avashta Singh bhai sahib Surinder Singh ji and one time highly regarded keertani Singh bhai sahib Mohinder Singh ji. In our opinion very hard to judge the situation of keertani Singh but as bhai Surinder Singh ji mentioned is a very valid point also. On the other hand bhai Mohinder Singh ji also inspired many others for "kaljug mein keertan pardana" keertan sewa. Not to mention just recently one of our Singh's 3 years old toddler started to sing some of gurbani tuks by watching bhai sahib' 25 years old video. So, which means the way he did keeratn had effect but yeah not completing shabad needs attention for new keeratni Singhs. Again this topic is very high level topic we would say MA Phd level because of the Gursikhs involved. We would say gupt jio take the rass by singing as much as possible from Gurbani when it is sung. Good to see that you at least started to hear the keertan and gave importance to it. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]