Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

CharhdiKalaa · 15 May 2007

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh The ad which created wave of protests and clashes: [img]http://www.charhdikalaa.com/images/ad.jpg[/img] and other images [url]http://www.charhdikalaa.com/punjab.html[/img] fateh [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

i5abbi · 15 May 2007

http://www.ibnlive.com/videos/40627/violence-erupts-in-punjab-over-ad.html [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

kharkoo · 16 May 2007

whats written in hindi?

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 16 May 2007

Whats all the fuss about ? Since when did Guru Gobind Singh Ji wear pink clothes and make a pink "amrit" ? I have seen pictures of Ranjit S Dhadrian wearing similar clothes and gold kalgi on his dastaar. The whole thing is being blown out of proportion by the Akalis who were only too happy to go beg for votes from the same pakhandi during the recent Punjab elections, but when the pakhandi opted to back the congress the Akalis were looking for any opportunity to get one over on him.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

hps · 16 May 2007

There is nothing that one should get enraged at. One should have taken care of these things when things are quoted from 'SGGS ji'. He has been doing so for many year and we have been watching his recorded programs for quite sometime.He seems to be a very gentle and a simple person.Dera does not even asks for any thing like donation. Sikh leaders lack the courage on account of the vote polictics. Generally sikhs in other parts of the country ae not disturbed. He has listners in North india .He has some followers from the lower strata of hindus and ofcourse sikhs. This is nothing serious.Anyone can do this [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

psdullat · 16 May 2007

its not about color of dress or anything it s about acting in the manner Guru Gobind Singh ji used to be .. He has attacked the concept of writing Singh by asking aall to write INSAAN after their name

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

KhalsaKhardkoo · 17 May 2007

But did Sant Ranjit Singh have his followers attack Sikhs in the street, beating them up with lathis and hurling bricks at them? By the way the answer you're looking for is ...no. Have the followers of this dera attacked Sikhs, beat them up with lathis...you get where I'm going with this...And no this is not propoganda there are pictures on the net of it happening with news articles: http://epaper.hindustantimes.com/Web/Article/2007/05/15/012/15_05_2007_012_020.jpg So whether or not it started as an "...opportunity to get one over on him" or not, Sikh sentiments have been viciously hurt and Sikhs are being viciously attacked. Now is the time for a united front in condemnation of this dera and the actions of their chief and the actions of the followers. Watch news reports where even women of the dera are hurling bricks at Sikhs. "Since when did Guru Gobind Singh Ji wear pink clothes and make a pink "amrit" ?" And since when did Guru Gobind Singh Ji make 7 sitare? He didn't, but this is what Gurbachna said he would do to attempt to being himself on a parallel, it's the intention Bhai Sahib with how these people are acting. Pink, green, purple, whatever colour think of the underlying message he is conveying. You can argue that how would I know his underlying message, but in response you can say as the leader of an organisation with a member base of (supposedly) 30 million, you'd think he would have a bit of savvy, or at least his right hand men would be like errr what you doin? The whole act was a direct attempt to inflame and hurt Sikh sentiments, and unluckily for the chief he's succeeded. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

ijs · 17 May 2007

man that guy has cbi cases against his dera including the murder of a journalist who was gonna expose the dera...... and one very crucial point everybody seems to have forgotten about the amrit paan he was orgainzing.......... not that too with a kalgi and a gol turban when generally he wears a topi.........he too is a punjabi......... didnt he have any idea that wot he is gonna do, will resemble wot dasam pita did>?? sure he did and he too wanted to create a base........

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 17 May 2007

Khalsa Kardkoo Regarding your first point the dera followers reacted after misguided SGPC, Badal Akalis etc started condemning the behaviour of their pakhandi baba. Badal and co wheeled out rent a mob with dastaar on and you think they represent the Sikh quam ? Where was the reaction last year when these same people now being beaten up were knocking the dastaars off Akali Dal Amritsar members and doing beadbi of kesh ? They have never before attacked Sikhs, so why attack them now ? Simple answer it is all politics. It is well known that the Sacha Sauda lot told their followers to vote for the Congress in the recent Punjab elections, Badal and co also wanted the Sacha Sauda vote but were denied it. This resulted in the Congress party doing well in the malwa region. The advert gave Badal an excuse to get his party activists, rent a mob and the sant samaj wale to get involved. Where was the condemnation and demonstrations when Dhadrian wore similar clothes and fancy gold Khanda Kalgis ? Where was the condemnation when Dhadrian let Panj Piare (we all know how highly Panj Singh are revered in Sikhi, even Guru Gobind Singh Ji Mahraj did not disobey the hukum of Panj Singh) touch his feet. Was it not politically astute for people to take him to task over his behaviour ? This is a man who misuses the Sant prefix and happily fills his pockets abroad so he can spend all the money on his dera. Why is a dera needed on the Patiala Nabha road ? There are plenty of other Gurdwara in the area. What is the difference between the Sirsa guy and the Sant Samaj wale who all have their own dera and like to abuse the prefix Sant ? Who cares if he has 7 sitare or a 100 sitare. He has never been accepted in the Sikh fold and never will be. Let him make his 7 sitare, why are we bothered ? This over the top reaction is giving him the publicity he craves and Badal and co are also milking the whole event. There are hundreds of cults out there, each makes up their own beliefs if these people want to then so what ?

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

CharhdiKalaa · 17 May 2007

1 singh got shaheed in Sonam by firing from dera followers [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

ijs · 17 May 2007

1 SINGH SHAEED HO GAYA , one singh is killed at dera of sunam . he was from sangrur , puran gursikh , used to be in Panj Pyaras in Nagar kirtan NAGI we used to call him, left behind one female child of 3-4 months. Oh kal keh reha c ke MAR JAVANGE MAAR DYANGE EH JAAN GURU DE LEKHE LA DYANGE. he alone enterd the dera by climbing wall and shoot on chest by dera people Waheguru us nu aapne charnan vich jaga deve

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 17 May 2007

I have just heard that a singh has been shaheed. Check panthic.org for updates. I think they are keeping tabs on it.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

harveen_singh_manchester · 17 May 2007

i was watching alpha khabran before and they said about 20,000 sikhs have gt together and they want the government to do something about this, jathedar joginder singh vedanti and the other jathedars from the takhats gt together and they also want the poloce to do something. then they also showed the dera people talking abuot some crap like our guru never said anything wrong and the sikhs are not doing anything good and so on. and they also got a phone call by punjab police, who said that the deras(100 of them) have to be closed down and its better that you guys just get out quietly otherwise this is going t lead to a big massacre. it is mainly the jathedar of damdami taksal baba harman singh ji who stood with the singhs to fight.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

sloughsingh · 17 May 2007

Punjabis suck anyway...let them go to hell.......i have visited many times and they live in villages were bani is played at amritvela over speakers.....blissful....and yet they care not for sikhi....they smile and refer to my renewed found faith in sikhi as ......oh :) giani bhanigia.......what they want is gurus blessing of a US/UK/Canadian visa and not real peace of mind....and when guru sahib knows best for them i.e. they can chill in punjab than suffer abroad ,thus no forth coming visa....they go to these dera babi.....because guru sahib knows they don't need new top of the range jeeps etc. as it will bring them down in debts and new expenses.....they will learn the hard way.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Khalsaspirit · 17 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Not long time ago just about 2 months ago we predicted the Badal's patteren for Sikhi distortions and some disagred with us that time our question to them today do they still need any proof that Badal is a Sikh. Presenting those transcripts here and we again warn if the Sant cult is not controlled today you will face serious consequenecs in future which will be very difficult to resolve for future generations. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOPIC : Parkash Singh Badal Author: shere punjab Date: 03-26-07 21:46 Parkash Singh Badal what is everyonce opinion of the cheif minister of punjab and his ties to the bjp. Reply To This Message Re: Parkash Singh Badal Author: Khalsaspirit Date: 03-27-07 07:36 Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, THE BIG THUG imposed on innocents IN YOUR SAROOP by the centuries old thugs (baniyay). Now again watch the game and see further distortions for Sikhi. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Reply To This Message Re: Parkash Singh Badal Author: Dalbiri Date: 04-02-07 16:16 Whats happened. Has the Khalsa become so toothless that a twit like this can hijack the religion with the full knowledge of the vast majority of the panth? Reply To This Message Re: Parkash Singh Badal Author: Man Singh Date: 04-05-07 11:57 Everything other then vahegur is relative in this world. Emotional outbursts can not solve the probelms. To solve the probelms deep analysis , articulate planning, resource mobilisation and finest execution is required. Badal has replaced congress. The party that attacked akal takht, that butured 2000 sikhs in delhi and most cunningly put the blame on `Hindus' to hide the crimes of congress goondas. Badal is definitely lesser evil then congress. Of course there might be better options in future. But right now it is good news that congress the enemy no 1 of Sikhs has been kicked out. Voters and supporters of Badal and BJP are very much visible but I am surprised who are the forces that vote for congress and I do not see opposition to congress the real culprit of Sikhi. Is there any hidden agenda in criticising Badal and keepiong silence on crooked congress? Reply To This Message Re: Parkash Singh Badal Author: Khalsaspirit Date: 04-05-07 15:33 Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Bibi Harjas kaur carried the topic very well. Since the first khalsa came to this planet Jagat Guru Dhan Dhan Guru Nanak Dev ji Maharaj there are always hammering on khalsa tradition from both sides Front and Back door. Front door attacks were always handled very well in Sikh history since Baba Banda Singh Bhadur (Bhai Gurbaksh Singh ji). Recent examples of front door attackers are Nirankari Gurbachana, Lala Jagat Narayan, Indra Gandh, Beanta and etc. But khalsa panth till today failed to protect back door hammering/attacks which are difficult to judge by common a Sikh and most dangerous compare to front door, because at front door you and others can see who is doing what. Due to certain legitimate reasons we can not explain what back door entry means. All we can say is because majority of Sikhs give up the Guru sahib's Rehat which strictly start with Amritvela and they were/will fooled by these back door parties like this Nakli(fake) Akali Dal and Sant Corporation because they are in your saroop and because of lake of Gursikhi Kamai we let them play in our back yard and than they do but their mission is. And thats what happening in today’s Sikh world. Most of them except few they do not even know why they became a Sikh? In short at this moment the Deravaad is the cause. Our explanation is little bit tough to understand and if continue the topic will become so lengthy that will never end up. So we will pen off here. We highly recommend and request please carefully listens to Guru Granth Sahib Ji. They are giving you clear indications whatever the questions you have. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

SomeSingh · 17 May 2007

sikh groups gave the government 3 days to deal with the issue, otherwise they will take matters into their own hands. on punjabi news, a reporter from india said that sacha sauda has 30 000 followers in punjab. CRP (i've heard) has been called in. 2 of the deras of sacha sauda have been torched. there is a meeting at 7 PM at gurdwara Sukh Sagar in new westminister, BC of all sikh groups regarding this issue. As for the issue with Dhadrian, there actually was condemnation, and it was due to this condemnation that he publicly apologised and stopped doing these wrong things.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

harveen_singh_manchester · 18 May 2007

lol! giani bhangia... i heard that a lot of times.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

KhalsaKhardkoo · 18 May 2007

Insulting the Amrit-Sanchar Ceremony To inaugurate the ceremony, Ram Rahim first administered the drink to seven men and announced the forty-seven golden rules of the so-called Insa Panth which all members of the congregation must abide by. Later, Ram Rahim appeared in front of the seven men, whom he titled the 'Sat Sitare' (Seven Stars), satirizing the ‘Panj Pyare’ (beloved five) of the Sikhs and asked them to carry out a ceremony to initiate him in this newly formed religious order. At this ceremony, Ram Rahim was dressed in clothing much like the type adorned by Guru Gobind Singh Ji and mimicked historical accounts of Vasakhi 1699. Later after this event took place, tensions broke out in Bathinda in which Sikhs protested the acts of Ram Rahim's cult. Sacha Sauda followers also came out to oppose the protesting Sikhs and the scene became violent when at least twenty-five persons were badly injured. According to witnesses, Punjab Police officers just looked on as cultists beat the Sikh protestors with sticks and stones. Once the fight began to even out, the police finally decided to intervene and the tense situation was brought under control.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2007

The anger towards Sacha Sauda Dera is not purely because of the most recent action taken by Gurmit Ram Rahim the baba of this dera. The roots of this latest agitation by Sikhs lie in the years of provocations done by this dera. For years, Sikhs have been upset at their distortation of Gurbani and targeting gullible Sikhs and brainwashing them. Gurmit Ram Rahim mimicking Guru Sahib is just the last straw that broke the camel’s back. Before this, there have been many wrongdoings from their side. From what I have heard from Punjab, after losing up to 20 seats in the last elections because of Sacha Sauda effect, the Akalis decided to neutralize this cult and therefore the Dharam Parchar committee of SGPC started doing parchaar of Sikhi in full force in the strongholds of this dera i.e. Bathinda, Mansa and other parts of Malwa. Not taking this very well, the cult leaders did this latest provocation of mimicking Siri Guru Kalgidhar Patshah jee. It may be true that the Badal Akali Dal may be into it for political reasons but nevertheless, it is still good for the Panth because it has brought unity in Panth and it may force the Sikhs to look within and become better Sikhs. Here are some points that I would like to make with respect to this event: 1) This event has brought unity in Khalsa Panth. In the recent past, this kind of unity has rarely been displayed by Panth. May Guru Sahib do kirpa and Panth may always stay united. 2) I have never witnessed such good media coverage in India, for Sikhs. Almost always the media has been biased against Sikhs but in this case, they are positively covering the Sikh side of events and most of the media has condemned the Dera’s activities. 3) The statements of support from Hindus organizations like RSS, Bajrang Dal and others is a positive step. It does not matter whether they are doing this for some ulterior motive. The truth of the matter is that it is good to hear them praise Siri Guru Gobind Singh jeee and support Sikhs in this battle. By the same token, support from leftist parties and pro-communist parties is also a good thing. Even Congress MPs in the centre have expressed anguish at Dera’s activities. BJP MPs arguing in favour of Sikhs, in the parliament, was good. 4) I have not heard a single statement from Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann and it is pretty sad that at the time of such grave situation, he is fighting non-issues like installation of Beant Singh’s statue in Jalandhar. He has now ended up in jail and thus unable to be fighting for Sikhs. Involvement of Daljit Singh Bittu has been positive. 5) I have heard some shouting anti-Badal slogans and others shouting Khalistan slogans. I believe that this is not the right time and right place for such slogans. It will give the media and anti-Sikh politicians a chance to defame Sikhs. The police too will get an excuse to arrest and suppress this perfectly democratic and peaceful agitation against an anti-Sikh cult leader. 6) Dhadrian and all Sant-Mahatma along with leaders of all Sikh organizations were present at Damdama Sahib. I have heard that Mann Singh Pehowa said that whoever would cut off the head of the cult leader would receive one crore ruppees prize from him. 7) Comparing the Sikh sants with this dera leader is a very far fetched thing. Dhadrian has never mimicked Guru Sahib by making his own amrit or doing other such anti-Gurmat stuff. He did wear chamkeelay clothes but I don't think the idea was to imitate Guru Sahib and he has apologised for committing this mistake. Just my thoughts. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

CharhdiKalaa · 18 May 2007

1) This event has brought unity in Khalsa Panth. In the recent past, this kind of unity has rarely been displayed by Panth. May Guru Sahib do kirpa and Panth may always stay united. FULLY AGREE 2) I have never witnessed such good media coverage in India, for Sikhs. Almost always the media has been biased against Sikhs but in this case, they are positively covering the Sikh side of events and most of the media has condemned the Dera’s activities. PARTIALLY TRUE, MEDIA WAS UNBIASED UNTILL YESTERDAY NOON, AFTER THAT THEY TURNED AGAINST SIKHS AND HIGHLIGHTED THE MINOR VIOLENCE AS A BIG ISSUE AND TERMED DERA PPL AS PEACE LOVING. THERE ARE CONFIRMED NEWS THAT MEDIA HAS BEEN BRIBED BY DERA. SPECIALLY AJ TAK AND IBN. 3)I have heard that Mann Singh Pehowa said that whoever would cut off the head of the cult leader would receive one crore ruppees prize from him. THATS TRUE. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Man Singh · 18 May 2007

United we stand divided we fall. Good analysis bhai Kulbir Singh Ji.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

ns · 18 May 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Kulbir Jee mentions valid points but there is one thing I would like to add, Badal is in it for political gain without a doubt.Secondly pheowa mentioning to cut the guy's head off is just provocation , for the rape allegations outstanding against him , has he ever apologized?? 1 crorer ruppees oh sure thing maan singh has a few crorers under his belt.What a joke. I don't want to turn this into a bashing debate clearly in the Sikh Kaum there needs to be a number of representives who should control parhcharks and test them fully before they go and do parchar in any country.Soon as they step out of line they should be banned.Muslims are way ahead in this process and have it place, while the sikh kaum sleeps in this arena. It's clear that goverment is at work here as it was in the late 70's, trying to poke the needle to see how much reaction there is out there.Kaum hasn;t been one for a long long time, maybe this will bring it together.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

CSJ · 18 May 2007

Media is not taking sikhs side If you watch sahara samye. There are showing sikhs as violent people with wepons and those dhera people....... peace loving. They where asking reporters what kind wepon sikhs have. and showing one bus or tractor burning again and again. These ...... dhera people created same 1978 situation. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Niranjan Singh · 18 May 2007

Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, All the points you have presented are valid, except I would add that comparing Maan Pehowa with this dera leader is a NOT such a very far fetched thing. I don't want to digress from the main topic, but it is important to remind ourselves about the danger to the Panth from all such fake saadhs. First of all the Pehowa Saadh is a Bajjar Kurahitee, a rapist and molestor, he made the 'brave 1 crore' statement so he can try to rebuild his image in the Sikh community. He should not have been allowed to speak from a Panthic stage at all. The crore rupees he is offering belong to the Sangat and the poor farmers he has stolen land from. It is sad he was not thrown out of the Damdama Sahib meeting. The Singhs who protested against him have been in jail for several months, his chelas have attacked his rape victim's families just as the Sauda premees have attacked the the proptesting Sikh Sangat. The similarities do not stop here. Just like the Sirsa Sauda Baba, Maan Pehowa has actively : ** Imitated Guru Gobind Singh Ji, and told his followers he was His avtaar. (just like the sirsa baba) ** Raped minors girls in his dera ! (just like the sirsa baba) ** Has had people killed who started to expose him ! (just like the sirsa baba) ** Owns a massive dera with a massive following ! (just like the sirsa baba) ** Owns luxury cars, and many mansions ! (just like the sirsa baba) ** Has twisted the Sikh Amrit Sanchar Ceremony {bottled amrit, no 5 banees, sehajdharis as 5 piyaray, etc) (just like the sirsa baba) So if there is so much anger against the Sirsa baba, why does the Panth turn a blind eye to these thugs within our own camps ? They live and feed off of our Gurdwaras and facilities. Our goal should not be only to get rid of this Sirsa baba , but educate the Sikh Sangat so they can REJECT ALL pakhandi Babas who twist Gurmat and Sikhi. This includes the Pehowa monster. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 18 May 2007

This is all political and some of you guys have fallen for it. Where are the edicts from Vedanti and co against the Namdharis ? They continue to spout their farcical derogatory stories about Guru Gobind Singh Ji Mahraj yet they are courted by Badal and co.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 18 May 2007

I watched the story on NDTV news. They showed one of the pakhandis dera ransacked. It was great to see how respectful of Sikhi the demonstrators were, amongst the damaged items were gates etc with Ek Onkar written on them.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Khalsaspirit · 18 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh ns jio, Good thought. We would like to request Tapoban.org Singhs if possible to keep clear record of the claims made by all involved politicians, Sants and other so called panth leaders for this incident. They will be very usefull when you read them agian down the line even year later. Guru Mehar Karay, Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji kmi fateh [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

----^^^^---- · 19 May 2007

Hindu organisations say Dera head should apologise Saturday, 19 May , 2007, 15:17 Chandigarh: Various Hindu organisations, including VHP and Akhil Bhartiya Sant Samiti, on Saturday demanded that the head of Sirsa-based Dera Sacha Sauda apologise for having worn a dress similar to the one worn by 10th Sikh Guru Gobind Singh. Punjab on the boil In pics: Trouble in Punjab I didn’t imitate Guru: Dera chief Sacha Sauda rules out apology Full coverage: Punjab on the boil Samiti General Secretary Swami Hans Dass said at a press conference that various Hindu organisations had discussed the stand off between followers of the Dera and different Sikh organisations in Punjab at a meeting in Haridwar. These bodies felt that Dera Head Sant Gurmit Rahim Ram Singh had done wrong by wearing the dress and administering Amrit (nectar) to his followers hurting the sentiments of the Sikhs, he added. He should not only apologise for his actions, which had hurt the Sikhs and people of other communities, but also assure that he would not repeat such an act in future, Dass said. He said that the Hindu organisations would appeal to the people of various sides, including Sikhs, Hindus and Dera followers not to do any such thing, which can vitiate the peaceful atmosphere in Punjab, which had already gone through 15 years of turmoil in eighties.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

----^^^^---- · 19 May 2007

Bounty for Dera chief's head 19 May, 2007 l 0124 hrs ISTlNeel Kamal/TIMES NEWS NETWORK SANGRUR: Jo ohda sar kalm kar ke liaega ohnu sone, chandi nal tol diange (get Gurmeet Ram Raheem's head and you will be weighed in gold and silver equal): This was Takht Damdama Sahib jathedar Balwant Singh Nandgarh, one of the five Sikh head priests, calling for the head of Dera Sacha Sauda sect chief Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh on Friday. Announcing a bounty, just like the former UP minister Yaqoob Qureshi did for the head of the Danish cartoonist who had lampooned the Prophet, Balwant Singh said Sikhs couldn't tolerate the insult of their gurus and anyone equating themself with any guru was their enemy no. 1. Jathedar Nandgarh was in Sangrur for the cremation of Kamaljit Singh who was killed on Thursday night outside Sacha Sauda branch at Sunam. The man was attacked while returning from the Sikh congregation at Damdama Sahib. The jathedar repeated that Sikh organisations had given time to governments at the Centre and state until May 20 to arrest Ram Rahim Singh, failing which they would chart their own strategy to deal with him. He repeatedly called on the Sikh sangat to avenge the death of Kamaljit, saying he had sacrificed his life for the community. Damdami Taksal chief Harnam Singh Dhumma demanded the sealing of all Sacha Sauda Deras in Punjab. He demanded registration of a murder case against Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh in connection with the death of Kamaljit Singh. The funeral procession turned into a show of strength by the radical elements among the Sikh groups. While a total bandh was imposed in the town, young Sikhs, brandishing unsheathed swords, insisted on taking the body of Kamaljit Singh through the bazaars. After some negotiation, they relented and compromised on a shorter route.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

----^^^^---- · 19 May 2007

Dera chief should say sorry: Shahi Imam Express News Service New Delhi, May 19: Sant Gurmeet Ram Raheem Singh, the chief of Dera Sacha Sauda, Sirsa, should apologise from the Sikh community, said Shahi Imam Maulana Habib Ur Rehman Sani Ludhianvi while addressing a special Friday prayer at the historical Jama Masjid in Field Ganj. Habib ur Rehman said: “Keeping in view the sentiments of Sikh community, Baba Gurmeet Singh should apologise. This will help in maintaining the communal harmony in the country as well as in Punjab. Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh should order high-level enquiry into the whole episode so that the anti-social elements working behind it could be made public.” The Shahi Imam said that sentiments of all the communities have been hurt from this controversy and appealed to have patience. He said that last year, a Denmark-based newspaper hurt the sentiments of Muslims by publishing a cartoon of Prophet Muhammad. This led to protests by Muslims from all over the world, he said. Supporting the Sikhs in this incident, he said, “The whole Muslim community is with Sikh community like our ancestors Peer Buddhu Shah, Gani Khan and Nabi Khan who were with Guru Gobind Singh.” He appealed to Parkash Singh Badal Chief Minister of Punjab to take strict action against the anti-social elements and also urged the political parties to desist from drawing a political mileage out of the issue.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2007

It is good to see Muslims as well as Hindu organizations coming out against the evil action of the cult leader - Gurmit Ram Rahim. All religious minded people who love God should come against anti-social elements who are into provoking people for the own interests. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 20 May 2007

Bathinda - 19 May Damdami Taksal Chief & President of Sant Samaj - Sant Baba Harnam Singh Ji Khalsa has joined forces with Bhai Daljit Singh Ji Bittu, Sant Baba Baljit Singh Ji Khalsa Dadu Sahib Wale, Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Ji Dhadrian Wale, Sant Baba Daler Singh Ji Khalsa Kheri Wale and Nihang Dal bodies on a strong platform. On the other side dera sacha sauda have called for the arrest of Sant Baba Harnam Singh Khalsa, Sant Baba Baljit Singh Khalsa, Bhai Daljit Singh Bittu and Bhai Jasvir Singh a former Jathedar of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib as being hardliners and pressurising the Sikh clergy to take a stronger decision against the sacha sauda sect. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

gurmat · 21 May 2007

The latest news is that Panj Jathedar committee has ordered the state government and central governments that by 22 May Punjab will be shut and by 31st May all Deras relating to Sacha Sauda should be vacated and demolished to the grounds. .... I personally think that not just Dera Sacha Sauda but all other cults such as Nirankaris, Ashutosh, Darshan Dasi, Radhasoamis, etc should all be booted out of Punjab and never to return to the pure land of five rivers!... I think its time the whold Sikh Quam wakes up to this call and take this matter in our own hands and resolved in a peaceful way forward. Otherwise i'd definately vote to have young jujaroo sikhs separatist kharkhoo singhs to bring back those days where none of this ever occurred and we sikhs were in control. I've heard a lot of people saying today that those were the days when we are in control and it was literally Khalsa Raj.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 21 May 2007

Nirvair Singh Ji, >>Damdami Taksal Chief & President of Sant Samaj - Sant Baba Harnam Singh Ji Khalsa has joined forces with Bhai Daljit Singh Ji Bittu, Sant Baba Baljit Singh Ji Khalsa Dadu Sahib Wale, Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Ji Dhadrian Wale, Sant Baba Daler Singh Ji Khalsa Kheri Wale and Nihang Dal bodies on a strong platform. Shows the moral charachter of the Sant Samaj wale when they join forces with Bittu who invited policecat Sukhi to his wedding (even though he knew Sukhi had been shown as dead in a police encounter). Has Dhadrian really stopped wearing his flashy clothes ? If not then why are they not all ganging up on him ?

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

harveen_singh_manchester · 21 May 2007

yesterday jathedar joginder singh jee vedanti announced the decision taken by the singh sahiban. by 24th may 2007 all deras have to be emptied, otherwise god knows what will happen. on the other side one of the sacha sauda guys announced that there is no chance that we are getting out of the derey, unless the government takes a decision on this. gurmeet ram rahim also said there is no reason for me to apologize, i haven't done anything wrong.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 23 May 2007

Veer 'S-Singh' Jee, Dhaas does not really want to go off the topic, but just give you a quick response. Sant Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale did not EVER try to imitate or be equal to the Guroo Sahibaan. The "flashy/shiny" cloth Chola I believe was only ever worn once. The reason for that has also been discussed and settled a while back. The Kalgi issue was also discussed and settled a while back, that it was not a Kalgi but a Khanda (even Professor Darshan admitted his mistake in thinking it was a Kalgi). If, as some people are saying, Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee is "not a Sikh", then at least the thousands that take Amrit under their influence are. The Amrit the thousands per month take is not from him, but from the Panj Pyaare. If he is "Kacha" and he sings the so-called "Kachee" Bani, at least the Guroo they follow and bow down to in the end after they listen to the Diwaan and take Amrit (Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj) is "Pakka" and the Bani is "Pakkee". It is saddening to observe that when such a dark time is currently shadowing over Panjab, our so-called Sikhs are still worried about bringing down such Panthic individuals (not at all directing at my Veer S-Singh Jee above, but just generally), when the real cults, enemies and anti-Panthic forces are openly trying their best to degrade and humiliate Sikhi. We have fake Saadhs and Babe like “Raam Raheem” trying to imitate Than Guroo Gobind Singh Saahib Jee Maharaaj, Singh’s are becoming Shaheed, but our so-called Sikhs still have their internal agendas, even when the mainstream Panth is the closest to unity and Ekta since a long time. We cannot ever compare a Sant/Mahapurkh/Gurmukh/Gianee/Bhai...etc (or whatever one individual feels they should be called) to fake Saadh's/Guroo's such as Raam Raheem, Gurbachana, Ashutosh, Bhaniarawala...etc who claim to be living SathGuroo's and make their own places of worship and their own following by using the Sikh concepts for their own misuse. That is a completely different matter when someone is openly calling themselves SathGuroo, imitating Guroo Saahib by wearing similar clothes (as portrayed on photographs), really wearing a Kalgi, sitting in a royal Paalki, making their own "Bani" by using the same concepts from living SathGuroo of the Sikhs - Than Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj - then trying to mime the Amrit Ceremony as done by the tenth Guroo Saahib Jee, making their own version of the Panj Pyaare, their own “Amrit”...etc. Sant Mahapurkhs in Sikhism, in the past, present and future to come (not the fakes), such as Sant Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale on the other hand are the opposite of the above fakes, as they do not make their own following or call themselves SathGuroo. Their mission is simple, do Panthic Vichaar and Katha of Sikh Ithiaas, principles, and beliefs, to enlighten the Sangat of the importance of receiving Than Guroo Gobind Singh Saahib Jee’s Amrit and forming into the Khalsa Saint Soldiers and making Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj as their only solitary Guroo. In fact, the Samagams of Sant Ranjit Singh Jee are called and announced as “Guroo Manio Granth Chetna Samagam”. In the present state of affairs in Panjab, Sant Dhadrianwale are also in the forefront of the battle against the “Sacha Sauda” cult. Just yesterday during the ‘Bandh’ in Panjab, when the Singh’s in Ambala clashed with the Police during the peaceful protest, it was Singh’s of Sant Dhadrianwale’s Jatha, the Nirvair Khalsa Dal (Ambala) that have been injured, just like the first day of this battle against the fake Saadh in Bathinda. My apologies for going off the topic a little but I hope this has made the current situation a little clearer for “S-Singh” Veer Jee and others who may be reading. We have Panthic Sikhs here who mean good from the heart, but are side-tracked by false media propaganda. Dhaas hopes this will not change the direction of this topic, but end here (if anyone would like to discuss further, then please do email me). I think now at this time the Panth should set-aside its small internal differences, but create Ekta to battle against the evils surrounding it. Galthee Dhaas Dhee Maarf Karnee… Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 23 May 2007

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! The Antim Saskar of the first Shaheed of the anti-Sacha Sauda Dera Morcha, who was killed by the cult "premis" near the Suman Dera of the cult: [img]http://www.panthic.org/data/images/blog/ShaheedKanwaljiSingh_antimsaskar_0507.jpg[/img] Shaheed Bhai Kanwaljit Singh Jee A pooran Gursikh from Sangrur who was in the Panj Pyaare during Nagar Keertans. Before he became Shaheed he said "Maar Dhyaa(n)ge, Eh Jaan Guroo Dhe Lekhe Laa Dhyaa(n)ge". By himself he entered the Dera by climbing a wall and was shot dead by the cult. In the picture above from the funeral, many Sikh Jathebandhia, personalities and GurSikhs were present to pay their respects. Some of those that can be seen are Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa Dhadrianwale with Jatha, Jathedhaar Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee with members of Damdami Taksaal, Bhai Daljit Singh Bittu, and Jathedhaars of Thakhats…etc. [img]http://www.panthic.org/data/images/blog/ShaheedKanwaljiSingh_family_0507.jpg[/img] The family of Shaheed Bhai Kanwaljit Singh Jee can be seen in the photograph above. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 23 May 2007

Shaheed Bhai Kanwaljit Singh Jee [img]http://www.panthic.org/data/images/blog/Shaheed_KanwaljitSingh.jpg[/img] ਮਰਣੁ ਮੁਣਸਾ ਸੂਰਿਆ ਹਕੁ ਹੈ ਜੋ ਹੋਇ ਮਰਨਿ ਪਰਵਾਣੋ ॥ [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

onkar · 23 May 2007

Hey S singh Are you sikh or hybrid Stop asking bull **** try to focus on present issue khalistan Zindabad [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 26 May 2007

>>Hey S singh Are you sikh or hybrid Stop asking bull **** try to focus on present issue khalistan Zindabad onkar Why should I stop ? Why is it ok for Dhadrian to wear similar clothes and be accepted by Dhuma and co ? Why is Bittu part of this alliance after his links to police cat Sukhi are in the public domain ? A old misal family in Punjab have clothes of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Mahraj and they most certainly are not pink. If anything those who painted Mahraj Ji wearing pink clothes should be pulled up and account for turning our regal Guru Ji into a pop art figure in their poor paintings.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 26 May 2007

>>Hey S singh Are you sikh or hybrid Stop asking bull **** try to focus on present issue khalistan Zindabad onkar What is the present issue ? Some lowlife pakhandi issues an advert whilst dressed in pink and some of us put 2+2 together and get 12. The whole thing is political. The meeting that was held at Damdama Sahib was very interesting, a whole array of charachters were on display. Those accused of rape, sexual abuse and plundering money were VIPs at this meeting. Dhadrian who dressed in a similar style to this pakhandi even attended. Who was Dhadrian impersonating by wearing the shiny sitara clothes ? The so called Hukumnama issued by the Takht has already been shown as a complete joke and of political benefit to Badal. The likes of Makkar of SGPC and Sant Samaj wale have been holding meetings with the pakhandi dera so have already violated the Hukumnama. Will they be summoned to the Akal Takht for violation ? Where is the Hukumnama to shut down the Namdhari deras or the dera of Bheva and co who use Sikhi to enrich themselves and abuse women ?

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nagni Khalsa · 27 May 2007

VJKK VJKF Fateh to the fauj, Brothers and sisters one thing that has pleased me in this weeks events is that the panth has come together and put its differences aside. The problem is that our jathedhars are khusure and women who need to wear banga, Vedanti is sitting on the Akal Takht as the jathedar yet is a disgrace to the seat that has had soorma jathedar as Nihang Phoola Singh and Sant Bhindrawale to name a few. Those were the days when a hukamnama was submitted from the akal takht and the panth listened with respect, yet these so called jathedars have moh with the seat and the money and power which comes with that authority. I am a Nihang Singh who loves my maryada with all my life as that is what my soul craves for but in these last few weeks what i have realised is that these jathedars from the dals should hang there heads in shame as no one has spoken out to say we will do something about this in the way that is tradition for nihang singhs all it will take is one jathedar to stand up and be counted and people will follow, yet they are a disgarce to the neela bana and to the name NIHANG SINGH. As are other jathedars from other jathe bandi's. The one singh i have upmost respect for is Baba Harnam Singh Ji(Damdami Taksal) who has spoken out and showed that he has been born with some balls. One more thing all you khalse should understand is that this has all been prophicised by our gurus(Karni nama/Sau Sakhi) and that if you have had your blood boiled and bir ras running through your body then turn that into something positive by taking your nam,simran and seva to another level. The return of our father Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji fauja de malik is not far away wether you believe that or not the preparations in sach khand started a few years ago shaheedi fauja have already gathered at most the guru kars in india and will pargat hona when instructed to do so, the last quarter of jhooth is running so be ready and stead fast for that day as it is not too far away. My apologies if i have offended anyone with my comments. VJKK VJKF

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 27 May 2007

[quote]What is the present issue ? Some lowlife pakhandi issues an advert whilst dressed in pink and some of us put 2+2 together and get 12.[/quote] He's not just some low-life. He's quite respected as well as politically influential having some thousands of followers and a large votebank. And it's not about the pink dress. It's about the disrespectful way he altered amrit sanchaar, stirring with a serving spoon, creating sat sitare to mock the Panj Piare, calling himself "guruji." It's all a calculated ploy to erode Sikh traditions. When Gursikhs protested his disrespect of Gurmat, he ordered his followers to attack them, just like Gurbachana did in 1978 with Sant Nirankaris. As a result of the skirmish, 50-100 Gursikhs were wounded and one was shaheed. [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/2_Sirsa_gunda2.jpg[/IMG] The dera is financially rewarded because it's in GOI's best interests to weaken and divide Sikhs. Gursikh institutions don't get special funding. But every baba doing beadbi gets government sponsorship. That's the plan so Sikhs in Punjab will associate beadbi with political power, public respect and humanitarian projects like charities, hospitals, etc. When Sikhs pay homage to pakhandi babas as "guruji," and cut their hairs, and remove Singh from their surname and put Insaan instead, remove kakkars, and take amrit of Jam-e-Insaa, can't you see that the GOI uses these groups to eradicate Sikhism from Punjab? If Badal, and SAD, and Jathedar Vedanti and SGPC are corrupt its because that's part of the GOI assimilation plan. The protests show Khalsa Panth has had enough. The last thing Hindutva wants is Sikhs to stand united on anything, to assert their sovereignty in any way, or dare speak or think about closing deras and eliminating dera heads, which the corrupt government itself has planted, groomed and financially supported all over Punjab to create confusion, disloyalty, ignorance and divisions. And if you follow what Hindutva forces are doing at all, it is the Khalsa who are attacked time and again, as militants, agitators, ISI Karachi spies, etc. And these cults with their pro-Hindutva self-definition and eradication of Sikh identity, and utter defenselessness against beadbi is exactly what Hindutva wants to create out of Gursikhi....people who are identified with Hindus, Indian government, and who are so disoriented they attack and kill their own Sikhs! [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/ShaheedKanwaljiSingh_family_0507.jpg[/IMG] Shaheed Kanwaljit Singh Ji shot to death by Sacha (jhootha) Sauda premis. [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/Bathinda_gundas.jpg[/IMG][IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/Bathinda_loneSingh.jpg[/IMG] Dera Sacha Sauda beating a lone Singh. Notice, there are no kirpans waving, because no one is wearing kakkars. they are all waving lathis just like the RSS. [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/rss2.jpg[/IMG][IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/tribals-v-bangla.jpg[/IMG] RSS cadres. In 1978 the Punjab police were assisting the Sant Nirankaris in their assault on the Gursikh protesters. Just like with dera Sacha Sauda, Punjab Police DID NOTHING....until there were enough Sikh protesters to be a threat to dera premis. Dhadrianwale, Naamdharis, Radhasoamis, etc, are all a disease in Punjab. And the Panth has to be willing to shake the government to put a stop to it, or for certain, Sikhism will become a minority to all these sects within Punjab itself. But this is something Sant Ji warned about, even before the Golden Temple attack. So for these very critical reasons, the Panth needs to stay united and firmly support Gursikhi. Already Indian media is presenting this as a conflict between the dera and Khalistanis. Already the media is demonizing Sikhs saying they are on a rampage and not the dera premis. Already the media is blaming Babbar Khalsa and Pakistani ISI and not the idiotic provocations of the dera cult leader. Why? Because the government of India intends to crush ANY show of Sikh sovereignty with as much brutality as it did during gallughara. That's what this is about. It's not the pink dress. It's about Hindutva intolerance of Sikh religion, and escalating disrespect and aggressive manuvering to further erode Gursikhi in Punjab, and thus prevent Sikhs from having any political power. Sikhism is being oppressed in Punjab! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

SomeSingh · 27 May 2007

Harjas Kaur, most of what you're saying is right. There's a serious chance it could just increase more and more from this point on. But seriously, why is Baba Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale ji such a target for so many people when he wore no kalgi ever, and apologised publicly for his other mistakes???

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 27 May 2007

I agree with "SomeSingh" - Also, comparing a Sant Mahapurkh of the Sikh Panth such as Sant Dhadrianwale, who is in the forefront of this conflict and is openly criticising the fake baba "Gurmeet Ram Raheem" in diwaans, should not be compared to fake self-styled Guroo's such as the Naamdharis and Radhasoamis who call themself SathGuroo. Sant Dhadrianwale, as well as other Sant Mahapurkhs of the SIKH Panth and the fake self-styled "SathGuroo's" are blatently and completely two different matters altogether. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 28 May 2007

[quote]why is Baba Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale ji such a target for so many people when he wore no kalgi ever, and apologised publicly for his other mistakes???[/quote] [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/cell-phone-kalgi.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/kalgi-1.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/Mata-tek5.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/honor.jpg[/IMG] What kind of amritdharis are these? His parchaar needs to be investigated. Particularly his links to Arminder Singh and statements made about him that Indian government pays for buses to his diwans. Also what is this about him supposedly being the reincarnation of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale? Or at the center of some strange unity between RSS, sant samaj and Damdami Taksal? Because this boy may be extremely dangerous, and precisely because he appeals to Gursikh elements within the Panth. [quote]Has Damdami Taksal violated the Sikh "Maryada" by holding a yajna at its headquarters at Chowk Mehta in Amritsar district? The answer to the question seems to be in affirmative, if a video clip, photographs and allegations levelled by Shiromani Akali Dal (International) chief and former MP Atinder Pal Singh are to believed. Meanwhile, Atinder Pal Singh has urged Sikhs to boycott the "Virsa Sambhal Sammelan", to be organised by the Sant Samaj, the Damdami Taksal and some other organisations at Sirhind on February 26 as an " effort to divide Sikhs and to create a new sect of Sikhs". He has also urged the SGPC and the Jathedar of the Akal Takht to ban the sammelan. He has also asked leaders, which are participating in the coming sammelan to clarify whether they adhered to philosophy of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale or not. Atinder Pal Singh, who was accompanied by Gurmail Singh Dargapur, head of the religious wing of SAD (I), also gave a video presentation of a Yajna ceremony. According to Atinder Pal, the yajna was organised for 40 days from May 21, 2005. The yajna was conducted by the Taksal chief Baba Harnam Singh Dhuma to purify the its headquarters. Baba Dhuma also put "ahuti" in the yajna. By doing this, the taksal leaders have practically bowed down to Brahminical practices and shunned the basic principles of the Sikhism. How such people, who are not adhering to basic Sikh principles can lead Sikhs?" questioned Atinder Pal Singh and Gurmail Singh Dargapur. Baba Harnam Singh Dhuma is extending recognition to Baba Dhadrianwale, who has been projecting himself as an incarnation of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. Why Baba Dhuma is forced to do all this, which is not acceptable to the Sikhs. "We believe that the coming sammelan is nothing, but a deep conspiracy to create a separate sect from within the Sikhs and its objective seems to be to harm the Sikhs," said Atinder Pal Singh. http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2281/2006-02-26.html[/quote] The Truth Behind Dhadrianwala http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dwLohR2fMco ~Bhul chuk maaf karni Ji [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 28 May 2007

>>Harjas Kaur, most of what you're saying is right. There's a serious chance it could just increase more and more from this point on. But seriously, why is Baba Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale ji such a target for so many people when he wore no kalgi ever, and apologised publicly for his other mistakes??? Easy answer it was a kalgi, dastaar khanda do not have chain ropes to the sides. Secondly I suggest you attend some of his programs and see the pictures of him being sold of him. So why is it ok for him to make mistakes (yet he calls himself a Sikh Sant) and get away without anyone wanting to close down his dera ? The same dera where he had his now infamous birthday bash. Same for Bheva why no edict to shut down this mans dera or Vedanti and co requesting the state to investigate the allegations about him (Vedanti directly asked the state to speed up the investigation into this sirsa guy). Harjas Kaur, See your pictures and you can see dastaar wale standing around, so stop the usual RSS b/s. The dera issue was not as clear cut as you try to make it. If you bothered watching the news there were many keshdari wale at the sirsa dera.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

onkar · 28 May 2007

What is the present issue ? Some lowlife pakhandi issues an advert whilst dressed in pink and some of us put 2+2 together and get 12. The whole thing is political. The meeting that was held at Damdama Sahib was very interesting, a whole array of charachters were on display. Those accused of rape, sexual abuse and plundering money were VIPs at this meeting. Dhadrian who dressed in a similar style to this pakhandi even attended. Who was Dhadrian impersonating by wearing the shiny sitara clothes ? The so called Hukumnama issued by the Takht has already been shown as a complete joke and of political benefit to Badal. The likes of Makkar of SGPC and Sant Samaj wale have been holding meetings with the pakhandi dera so have already violated the Hukumnama. Will they be summoned to the Akal Takht for violation ? Where is the Hukumnama to shut down the Namdhari deras or the dera of Bheva and co who use Sikhi to enrich themselves and abuse women ? s singh that means you are try to justify the sin of that phandi baba which he committed by imitating Guru Gobind Singh sahib ji. We should take firm steps to punish this baba so in future, no body can even think of doing such things and this is the main issue. of course Badal and co should be punish Onkar Khalistan Zindabad [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 28 May 2007

You are returning back to a topic and discussion that has been discussed numerous times before. The fact if it was a 'Kalgi' or not has been confirmed. It was not a 'Kalgi', but two Khanda's, even Prof Darshan admitted this mistake he made on live Canadian radio. What "Indian Governmemt" links or with "Amrinder Singh"? - This is a new one, haven't heard this one before! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 28 May 2007

[quote]See your pictures and you can see dastaar wale standing around, so stop the usual RSS b/s. The dera issue was not as clear cut as you try to make it. If you bothered watching the news there were many keshdari wale at the sirsa dera.[/quote] [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/Bathinda_loneSingh.jpg[/IMG] RSS does promote a philosophy of assimilation saying all are Hindus, including Sikhs, and that some keep kesh and others don't. RSS is trying to make it's philosophy acceptable to mainstream Sikhs. but when analyzing RSS mischief (And if you don't see there is RSS mischief you are blind ~"so stop the usual RSS b/s.") one must analyze the diverse ways in which the organization makes inroads. Just because a segment of the Sirsa dera keeps kesh, what does this mean? Just because dastaarwale guys are running around with their shaved and trimmed beards doesn't mean they are all keshdari either. All it means is that the dera premis are deceiving Sikhs by retaining some semblance of Sikh appearance, and promoting decay of Sikh identity. It is obvious that many dera premis are not keshdari, and that the dera does not promote keeping kakkars. It is obvious that the dera is eroding the values and teachings of Sikh religious traditions, having undermined the amrit sanchaar ceremony with this Jam-e-Insaa thing. So what on earth is your point? Some wore dastaars? And? In the case of Gurmit Ram Rahim, it is likely the move against him was political because his influence extended to Congress Party and threatened BJP. As I have said before it appears the Sikhs are being manipulated by master politicians with multiple agendas. But the overwhelming agenda which unites both Congress Party and BJP-RSS against Sikhs, remains the ever-looming threat of Sikh unity and Sikh sovereignty. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 28 May 2007

Regarding the Sant Jarnail Singh Jee comment above by "Harjas Kaur" Penji: *NOTE* Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa Dhadrianwale (Gurdwara Parmeshar Dwar Saahib Patiala) of Sree Nirvair Khalsa Dal (Jatha Dhadrian) has never compared himself to Brehamgianee Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale (14th Jathedhaar Damdami Taksal) or claimed, as the Indian Media have propagated in newspapers such as the Tribune, "an incarnation of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale". This is all rumour. Sant Dhadrianwale openly does the Jeevan Vichaar of Sant Jarnail Singh Ji in India and abroad (as can be seen in the hundreds of live Diwaan recordings) and recognises Sant Jarnail Singh Jee as one of the greatest Sant Mahapurkhs to ever walk on this planet. Dhaas hopes this will clear any misunderstandings and rumour. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

SomeSingh · 28 May 2007

Like I've already said. He's already accepted responsibility and apologised. It's sad that while you guys do no prachaar of Sikhi you try to bring down a successful prachaarak for PAST mistakes which he HAS APOLOGISED FOR.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

S-Singh · 28 May 2007

>>>s singh >>that means you are try to justify the sin of that phandi baba which he committed by imitating Guru Gobind Singh sahib ji. We should take firm steps to punish this baba so in future, no body can even think of doing such things and this is the main issue. of course Badal and co should be punish Onkar Khalistan Zindabad onkar Exactly so lets shut down the dera of all the pakhandis. This will include bheva, dhadrian etc etc.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 29 May 2007

*SARSE WALA SAADH GURU GOBIND SINGH NAHI BAN SAKDA* Talwandi Slem (Nakoder Samagam - 19/05/2007) -SANT BABA RANJIT SINGH JEE KHALSA DHADRIANWALE- (Gurdwara Parmeshar Dwar Saahib Patiala) of Sree Nirvair Khalsa Dal (Jatha Dhadrian) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-461117233586573860&hl=en-GB[/url] (Part 1 of 4) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=377001457355595146&hl=en-GB[/url] (Part 2 of 4) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=108204532292416881&hl=en-GB[/url] ( Part 3 of 4) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-8388430727423590196&hl=en-GB[/url] (Part 4 of 4) ...A recent live diwaan recording regarding the current state of affairs in Panjab concerning Pakhand "Dera Sacha Sauda" and "Raam Raheem Baba"... Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 29 May 2007

This reminds me of fights between kids... "I said it was!" "No, I said it wasn't!" "It was!" "No it wasn't!" [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/kalgi-1.jpg[/IMG] Stop defending his kalgi! No other Singh anywhere sits on a high chair wearing some special chains and *cough* kalgi, under a special painting portraying a likeness of himself on the wall as if he was the Guru and letting people mata tekk to him and call him "Babaji." I don't care what someone said he made a mistake about seeing a kalgi...THERE IT IS IN PLAIN SIGHT! Stop asking people to swallow an elephant. Now I acknowledged that he apologized. I did not bring him up, but people in the Panth still have concerns and suspicions about him. his behavior was really bad. And no one has any video of his apology, so we have to take it for granted that while we have this explosive video, the guy admits to making a mistake. He should be extremely humble after a mistake like that. And while he may have apologized, people aren't likely to forget it, nor should they. Bad behavior like that is a WARNING! And people who have engaged in behavior like that in the past need to be watched closely...especially if they are doing public parchaar. Personally, Im not at all impressed with his "amritdharis," as they were all bowing to him as "Babaji." And that is my perogative. Simply to mention these obvious examples does not harm him. He did in fact make these mistakes. But if he's doing something good for Sikhi, good on him. He doesn't need blindly loyal defenders to justify his previous bad behavior to get people to accept him. I personally think we need to stop the entire baba thing. It leds to cultic corruptions. We need to close down ALL deras! And that is my opinion. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 29 May 2007

Okay. We are bad, and he is good. At least we're not in the video playing sant babaji this and that! [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/Mata-tek7.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/garland.jpg[/IMG] You say he never said he is the reincarnation of Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale? Time will show what the truth is. The fact remains Sant Samaj is swimming perilously close to the RSS. [quote]Baba Harnam Singh Dhuma is extending recognition to Baba Dhadrianwale, who has been projecting himself as an [u]incarnation[/u] of [u]Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale.[/u] Why Baba Dhuma is forced to do all this, which is not acceptable to the Sikhs. "We believe that the coming sammelan is nothing, but a deep conspiracy to create a separate sect from within the Sikhs and its objective seems to be to harm the Sikhs," said Atinder Pal Singh. He said the video CD of the yajna has been given to the Akal Takht Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti. "The Jathedar has assured us that he will look into the matter. But we urge him to issue a 'Hukumnama' to ban the sammelan," said he. [url]http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2281/2006-02-26.html[/url][/quote] [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Khalsaspirit · 29 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Let's see what somesingh ji has in his mind quote "It's sad that while you guys do no prachaar of Sikhi" 1. Could you elaborate more to whom you are tageting to? and keep in mind whatever you saying is off the topic anyway. quote"you try to bring down a successful prachaarak for PAST mistakes which he HAS APOLOGISED FOR" 2. Yes he is a successful prachaarak at the moment in your defination. Piyare jio about 10 years ago another Sadh Baba Mann Singh was also a suceessful prahaarak and his turn around was similar to this one. His chelas claimed he is a reincarnation of Guru Gobind Singh ji and at one time he gave amrit to 100,000 pranees in a day or few days. So what is your thought now about that great pracharak when Baba Dhadrianwale ji did not even existed in the picture. If your thought is different then why the stereo typing between two Sants? If your thought is still the same for both and you have equal status for both in your mind then Guru Sahib kirpa Karan Aap ji da bharam Banya rahaay. For these kind of parcharaks to whom many people like you gets attracted because of the quantity they are producing which is a just a few days fame nothing else. Yes they have good thing that they are going out to tell sangat at large that there are Guru Sahib known as Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, so that at some point ignored sangat will get attach to Guru Sahib. But at large the Dera Culture by Sant corporate world fits in follwoing Guru Sahib's Bachan. [gurbani]rotIAw kwrix pUrih qwl ][/gurbani] rotteeaa kaaran poorehi taal || They beat the drums for the sake of bread. A Gursikh (Real Sant) avoid above kind of parchar even the quantity is limited yet quality is maintianed because his/her attention is not Roti. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

SomeSingh · 30 May 2007

I'll believe this stuff about him projecting himself as the Guru or as an incarnation of Sant ji when I see it myself, or if it's reported in a reputable, nonbias news source. for the record, I am attracted to neither, nor am I a chela of either. Prachaar is of all different kinds, those who bring numbers into the panth provide a gateway, others who focus more on quality provide help from there on in. either way, whether you like this kind of prachaar or not, it still is prachaar of sikhi.

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Nirvair Khalsa · 30 May 2007

I agree with "SomeSingh" Veer Jee! [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 30 May 2007

Is it parchaar of Sikhi when his amritdhari chelas are all bowing down to him? Or is it parchaar of sant Dhadrianwale? If you visit his website...it is a cult of personality all glorifying him. Did he apologize for the painting of himself on the wall which people were lifting garlands up to as if he were in fact Babaji? [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Clash with Dera Followers - Exclusive

Harjas Kaur · 30 May 2007

The fly on his nose was funny. Why are they lifting their arms into the air? I've seen this in a lot of pictures. [url]http://parmeshardwar.com/genph/DSC06985.JPG[/url] [url]http://parmeshardwar.com/genph/DSC09788.JPG[/url] Why are these 2 guys behind him in this video clip keeping their eyes closed? It looks very unnatural and cultic. And the one in back with his eyes open is staring wide-eyed and unnaturally also. And why does sant have a little decorative baubble dangling from his khanda? [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fm9151lh2as[/url] Dhadrianwale.com what kind of Sikhi parchaar is this? Or is Sikhi about Dhadrianwale? [url]http://parmeshardwar.com/[/url] theres a whole page dedicated to his glamorous photos. It's titled "Baba ji's Photo's." I'm not impressed. A saint is supposed to have nirmata. Not pose about wearing pearl necklace. Or have entire website dedicated to himself and not to Guru. I don't even see intelligent katha anywhere on the website. Just ringtones... He does have a contact person listed. [url]http://parmeshardwar.com/cnirvair.asp[/url] [%sig%]