Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Canadian Sikhs

Canadian Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 02 May 2007

How come you rarely hear anything bad happening to the Canadian Sikh community compare to the American Sikh and British Sikh community? Lately I have been talking to some American Sikhs & British Sikhs and seems like they deal with a lot of issues in their countries while Canadian Sikhs tend to have no problem living in Canada. So what is up with that? Is Canada a great place to live for Sikhs or is it that Sikhs in Canada are just doing a good job when comes to dealing with issues? I hope a fellow Canadian can answer my question.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 02 May 2007

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!! Seeker bhaji / bhainji I agree with your statement generally and I think that is because the Sikh community has been in Canada for more than 100 years, and they are pretty well recognized in most areas of the country. Other than the rural areas, and parts of Quebec, I think more than 50% of the people know that a man or woman with the 5 K's is a Sikh. In England / USA I think the crimes are not against Sikhs particularly, but more out of mistaken identity and racism. Some people think Sikhs are Muslims, or Taliban. There is more discrimination against South Asians because they are still an "unknown" compared to African Americans and European Americans. In Canada, all of the major media outlets are against Sikhs. There are huge propaganda campaigns taking place to vilify the Sikhs. However, on the political front, there is an amritdhari Sikh MP (Navdeep Singh Bains) and the Supreme Court gave Gurbaj Singh the right to wear his kirpan at school. Via Rail apologized to Balpreet Singh and refunded his tickets and changed their policies. Awareness on a professional front is higher, but on the media front there is a strong bias because there is a struggle between the people who currently hold power and the upcoming generation of Sikhs. The current powerful elite feel threatened so they support the media with people like Kim Bolan, Salim Jiwa, Terry Milewski, etc. to produce lies and propaganda about Sikhs. Furthermore, India (as a trading partner to Canada) puts a lot of pressure on Canada because they know that the largest population of Sikhs outside of Punjab is in Canada. Of course there are still individual hate crimes against Sikhs in Canada, but not nearly at the same level as USA or England. Here, the main issue is how the economic and political elite manipulate the media to cast a negative prejudice over all Sikhs. vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!!!!

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 03 May 2007

From my observations with a lot of Canadians, they have to deal with internal community issues. For example, in the US most non gursikhs respect gursikhs and basically everyone treats each other fairly well and respectfully. In canada you have this war of morality between moderates who couldnt care less for sikhi, but want to change it to suit them anyway and gursikhs. But most of the gursikhs in Canada I see are more passive, from an outsiders perspective, they dont say anything when things need to be said, perhaps because when people did make issues big (for example tables and chairs, it got way out of hand). An example of this passive nature is for example in the recent nagar keertan controversy. Why havent we heard anything back from the kids who were wearing the gatka dal sweatshirts that got relabelled by the media as ISYF?? I can tell you if that had happened in California, there would have been press conferences and press releases from 20 organizations, we would have sent letters and there would have been a general uproar about the media blatantly making things up. Or at least the people whos pictures were being exploited would speak up. But I dont see that there from the people who should be saying it. But they do have to deal with things more as a community, instead of single individuals being attacked, the whole community and Sikhi are attacked in the media by people like kim bolan.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 03 May 2007

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa, I agree what you said completely. Good post. Manjot Singh Khalsa, The moderate issue is a dead issue now. Also keep in mind that a lot of ethnic groups are being attacked by the Canadian media not just Sikhs alone. Yes, you are right about gursikhs in Canada being passive. But then again, every Sikh I met in USA is very passive as well. Your average American still doesn't know what a sikh is and some Americans think yoga is part of sikhi. [%sig%]

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Bachitar Singh · 06 May 2007

No offense other then canadians no one cares about or likes canadians. They are often made fun of. For example: The origin of the countries name. So when they were deciding the name for the country they decided to have a lottery system where they would pull letters. The first letter was a c. The guy who was pulling the letters said c aye. Then n aye and d aye and thus the word CANADA. [%sig%]

Re: Canadian Sikhs

confused · 07 May 2007

holy thats canada in a nutshell, amazing post manjot singh

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Dalbiri · 07 May 2007

All of the white Canadians I have met have been peaceful, mellow and majorly passive compared to the white working class English I have met, many of whom are not averse to violence. I think Canadian Sikhs have it easy compared to their US and UK equivalents. This I believe is behind the big differences between the communities. It may be wrong to put this down to older migration patterns in Canada as the English and Sikhs have had much longer contact than Canadians and Sikhs. My cousin recently spent 2 years in Canada (he grew up in London), and tells us that Canadians are infinitely much more polite than the people here. Here it would be inconceivable that people would stop and talk to you waiting at the bus stop whereas he said it was common when he was there. I think Canadian Sikhs are quite lucky to have such hospitable hosts although I know it wasn't like this in the past.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 08 May 2007

Dalbiri veerji / bhainji Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa Vaaheguroojeekeefatheh ! Almost all Sikh families in Canada have one or two generations born here. Some have three generations of Canadian-born Sikhs. I have a friend whose family has been in Canada for over 80 years. The Sikh community in total has been here for over 100 years. So we are now the hosts, not the guests. But of course in the spiritual sense we are all guests here in this world. Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa Vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !

Re: Canadian Sikhs

SilentElegance · 08 May 2007

Furthermore, India (as a trading partner to Canada) puts a lot of pressure on Canada because they know that the largest population of Sikhs outside of Punjab is in Canada. WRONG> The largest Sikh Population outside India is United Kingdom, Followed BY Canada. If the Sikhs in Afgahinstan did not have to leave, then Sikh population in Canada would have been 3rd largest. All we have heard of Sikhs in Canada is the Air India , and the Drug and gang killings - so please do not kid, about the passivity of Canadian Sikhs. No other Sikh community is riddled with such crime as seen in the Sikh gangs in BC. Sikhs in Malaysia have been there for 150 years and have one of the best living in the world for Sikh communities outside India.So is Thailand. [%sig%]

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 08 May 2007

Bachitar Singh, We are talking about Canadian Sikhs, not Canada in general. A lot of non-Canadian sikhs do care about issues that Canadian sikhs deal with. SilentElegance, I think there is more sikhs living in USA than Canada as well. But yes, you are very correct about Canadian sikhs not being soft. Dalbiri, People living in Toronto have a rep. in Canada of being very rude people. So don't be fooled, my friend.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Dsingh · 09 May 2007

When the nespapers make allegations about Sikhs in Canada does anybody reply to clear the Sikhs name? In the Uk the press complaints authority is alerted if there is a bias. Public applogies have been published in the past e.g the Daily Telegraph 'Madness under the turban article'. The lack of response in Canada gives a negative image of Sikhs in Canada and abroad .

Re: Canadian Sikhs

confused · 09 May 2007

SilentElegance...you are making many errors in your logical reasoning. You are drawing on your memory based on things that stand out. Rarely in the news you will ever hear about normal sikhs just living their lives, because it just doesn't sell. They will only print what will sell. Vancouver may be bad but at least there aren't stabbings at nagar keertans. Our Gurdwara committees may be bad but they don't openly support RSS. The larger population in a country only means there will be more crime but not a higher percentage. Put fact into your arguement its too dry, I could eat away at it all day. We may have more problems criminally, but UK has FAR too many problems with breaking Sikh Rehit Maryada. The way sikhs behave in punjab why should they behave appropriately anywhere else my friend. I don't what you people are talking about but I've lived in Toronto all my life and I've been all across Canada, as a Singh I've never been treated poorly, and in general torontonians are very polite. Punjabi people are very rude here but they are everywhere. Singhs here are sooo friendly. Everyone treats each other truly like they are brothers and sisters. Stop wishing you guys could live here and have what we have.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Roopkaur · 09 May 2007

Bachittar Singh, both as a Canadian, and as a student of history, I can assure you that your idea of the name Canada is grievously at error. The word originates from the Iroqouis word kanata, which means land or sttlement. I twas first used by Europeans, or more specifically, the French, to refer to New France, where Quebec now is. It was then used to refer to both the area of Quebec, which was lower Canada, and that of what is now Ontario, which was upper Canada. Later, when Quebec came under the British, the whole area was the province of Canada. In 1867, the provinces that chose to join became the dominion of Canada. As for the original question, it is not true that Canadian Sikhs are not in the news. Or that they are passive. You will have both passive and proactive people in all countries, it is not fair to generally label a whole group according to thier country. SAome examples of recent Sikh happenings are the case that Balpreet Singh bhaji won, and the case that Gurbaj Singh Multani won, which has insured that all Sikhs in Canada cannot be denied their education because of their faith. Another thing, shouldn't Sikh issues be seen as a panthic concern? So why are we now dividing these issues by countries, instead of dealing with them as a community?

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Bachitar Singh · 09 May 2007

Roop Kaur: It was supposed to be a joke. You know the ones where go ha ha ha. Or clever one chap.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

PTE SINGH · 27 May 2007

There seems to be some confusion, the UK has a larger and more established Sikh community. Sikhs in the UK have been extended rights and recognition above anything in the US and even Canada and political and economic links between the UK and India are considerably stronger, than those with Canada or the US. There are no "Sikh" problems in the UK, i am sure that racism generally is more of an issue here in the UK, however that is down to the History of the Nations and nothing to do with Religious recognition. You must remenber that Canada is a immigrant nation that has only really come togther with a history and identity over the last 100 years or so and immigrants that left their countries to make Canada there permanant home have been a large part of that. The UK has 1500 years of British identity and history and the Sikh immigrants that came here never even intended to stay.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 27 May 2007

<<>> Umm no. Sikhs in UK aren't above Canada. Sorry. How many Sikh politician are there in UK? Please elaborate your claims.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Bachitar Singh · 27 May 2007

To Seeker of The Truth: Whats your point? You started this thread for a reason. Instead of crying about it, go out and do something. [%sig%]

Re: Canadian Sikhs

PTE SINGH · 28 May 2007

Seeker of the truth, I don't know how to quantify "above". The Sikhs in Canada are certainly "above" the UK, in that Globally Canada is further north than the UK. Population wise offical UK gov figures put us at 336,000. The canadian population was 278,400 in 2001, maybe you guys have surpassed us since, however i don't understand the point or question you are asking?? Without being rude, Very little of what happens in Canada is of any real great world wide significance, that way we tend not to hear about the Sikh community out there. Except the small matter of an Air India plane, some nutter lad who took a hand gun into school for a "show and tell" demonstration, a marriage that ended in all sorts getting shot a few years back, and the riot that meant i had to ruin the crease in my trousers when i eat langer at my local gurdwara a few years ago. Other than that i'm sure you're all doing a splendid job. [%sig%]

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 28 May 2007

Bachitar Singh, Crying? I am NOT crying. Purpose of this thread is to find out what exactly are Sikhs in Canada are doing because it seems like they don't face any real threats from external forces (unlike the Sikh community in the USA & UK) so that we can use the same strategy that Sikhs in Canada are using and apply it to rest of the Sikh community in the world.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

SomeSingh · 29 May 2007

Singh, that guy who went into school with a gun wasn't a Sikh, he was nastik. He even wrote about how he hated all religion. Unfortunately, the Canadian media tends to paint east-indians as Sikhs, despite the fact that race and religion are two completely different things. I remember reading about a robbery in Ontario where media claimed the suspect was a Sikh, only to later find out that he's a Christian.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

Dalbiri · 29 May 2007

SomeSingh That guy who went bezerk with the gun DID come from a Sikh background. The fact that you are in denial of this says a lot. I remember that people (at the time) talked about the fact that he hated religion so much (i.e. his own) most probably because he met some ignorant narrow minded twats in our own community who threw him away instead of trying to be inclusive and open minded and incorporate him into a sense of community that is needed by all.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

jassmannn · 30 May 2007

Canada has not been problem free at all and neither has the UK. A lot of the racism problem in the UK comes from the issues related to the immigration policy and the numbers of people entering the country and the perceived problem that bring on stretching public services. The UK is a fantastic place to live, and generalising white working class people as all the same is not the case. I have have lived in both Birmingham and London and have found it a great place to live if you are willing to integrate, understand the culture and get on with the community. That doesn't mean giving uo your religion, it just means being nice and neighbourly. I've never had any major problems, and the Sikhs in the UK do have a lot of rights and protection.

Re: Canadian Sikhs

JASBIR66 · 06 Jun 2007

I agree with the last poster. Its strange that different countries have different viewpoints about one another. Of course it is difficult to hear anything negative about Canada in the UK, because the average Briton doesn't even know that Canada has any big or medium sized cities where there might or might not be sikhs living in. To the average European, Canada is one big ice zone with a lot of polar bears running about. But behind this indifference about the unimportance as a nation of Canada, there are some startling realities with regards to us sikhs. I've noticed some terrible problems regarding sikhs in Canada, and many non-sikhs I have met here in the UK do sometimes use these things to hit me with. Things such as 'marrying the own sisters' in gurdwaras (false marriages) to gain immigration. Punjabi christian churches (almost unheard of in the UK) The drugs. The gangs. The habit of sikhs giving themselves 'christian' names etc. The way I see it the grass is green neither on this side or that side. We all face a few problems and hurdles that need to be jumped if we want to get anywhere in this race.