Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

News · 18 Apr 2007

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20070418.BCPARADE18/TPStory/National India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade ROBERT MATAS VANCOUVER -- The government of India is launching a diplomatic protest over a parade in Surrey this month that included a float with alleged terrorist leader Talwinder Singh Parmar portrayed as a Sikh martyr. "We are very much concerned that this happened," Zile Singh, India's deputy consul-general, said yesterday in an interview. Diplomats from the High Commission Office in Ottawa intend to raise the matter with Canadian officials, he said. "This is not acceptable to us. We intend to convey that it is not acceptable, so the [Canadian] government understands," Mr. Singh said. "This should not happen again." The Sikh community in Greater Vancouver, which is splintered into factions, holds two competing parades to mark the Punjabi new year and the beginning of the harvest in Punjab. Gurdwara Sahib Dasmesh Darbar of Surrey held its annual Vaisakhi parade on April 7. The Vaisakhi Parade organized by Vancouver's Khalsa Diwan Society was held on Sunday. Print Edition - Section Front The parade in Surrey attracted thousands of people including prominent B.C. and federal politicians. News reports say the parade had a float that included Mr. Parmar among the portraits of Sikh martyrs and some organizers wore work jackets with the word "Khalistan," the name proposed for an independent state for the Sikhs carved out of India. Some children were wearing jackets with the logo of the International Sikh Youth Federation. Mr. Parmar, a militant Khalistani advocate, has been identified in a B.C. court case as the mastermind behind a mid-air bomb explosion aboard an Air-India flight in 1985, en route from Canada to London, England. Born in Punjab and later made a Canadian citizen, he was killed by police in India in 1992. There were 329 people killed in the Air-India bombing, which remains one of the deadliest terrorist attacks in aviation history. Mr. Singh said the portrayal of Mr. Parmar as a martyr was "very objectionable." Indian officials were also concerned that some people involved in the parade showed their support for groups considered terrorist organizations and banned in Canada, the International Sikh Youth Federation and Babbar Khalsa. The Indian consulate in Vancouver is aware of the views of those who attend the Surrey temple and does not associate with their events, Mr. Singh said. The diplomats however support events sponsored by the Vancouver temple. "We know the difference," he said, adding that he thought that Canadian politicians should also be aware of the differences. The politicians should know that the charitable status of the banned groups has been revoked and about the Khalistan issue, he also said. "All politicians must be aware of what is going on. They know about the Air-India disaster and what happened," Mr. Singh said. Liberal MP Ujjal Dosanjh, who was beaten up in the mid-1980s after speaking out against militant Sikh separatists, said he expected "a strong denunciation" from all politicians of any display that involves support for violence and hate." "I'm personally as a Canadian very, very saddened that this kind of display of violence is deemed to be acceptable in a parade that celebrates diversity," Mr. Dosanjh said. Mr. Dosanjh cautioned against jumping to any conclusions about the Surrey temple. Temple groups are fairly loose organizations and those who allowed the Parmar poster in the parade may not be representative of the temple. A person at the temple who did not give his name yesterday said an executive member would be available for a comment today.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Ibin Sikh · 18 Apr 2007

I think that the Indian consulate must be run by a bunch of morons. Who are they to object to what Canadian Sikhs can or cannot do at their parades? Sikhs have been carrying pictures of Singhs who have died since 1984. This isn’t the first time, but for some reason they are trying to make an issue out of it this year. These hypocrites have never arrested Sajjan Kumar or Jagdish Tytler for the Sikhs they killed on the streets of Delhi in 1984. Murderers like KP Gill are made coaches of the Indian hockey team instead of being charged for all the murders he committed against the Sikhs. Yet they are objecting to a 12” by 8” photo being hung on a float!

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Harjas Kaur · 20 Apr 2007

[quote]Mr. Parmar, a militant Khalistani advocate, has been identified in a B.C. court case as the mastermind behind a mid-air bomb explosion aboard an Air-India flight in 1985, en route from Canada to London, England. Born in Punjab and later made a Canadian citizen, he was killed by police in India in 1992. There were 329 people killed in the Air-India bombing, which remains one of the deadliest terrorist attacks in aviation history.[/quote] Talk about propaganda. AFTER 20 YEARS OF PREPARATION AT GOVERNMENT EXPENSE $130 MILLION, HYSTERICAL MEDIA COVERAGE, PUBLIC OUTCRY AGAINST "SIKH TERRORISTS" BLAMED FOR THE AIR INDIA BOMBING..... total and complete EXONERATION!!!!!!!!!! not even a weak case, or an unsubstantial case, but no case at all!!!!!!

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

jassmannn · 20 Apr 2007

Although I appreciate that many people have sacrificed their lives for the Sikh people and should be celebrated as such; the plane hijack was an outrage as far as I was concerned, and should never have happened. And also at Gurdwaras and parades. no images or banners should deflect from Guru Sahib, or Guru Ji's saroop, which has happened on soo many occasions. We all know why Vaisakhi is celebrated, if it is a cultural do, without Guru Sahib Jee present, then fine do as you please, but if it is a nagar Kirtan, I think it very inappropriate.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

confused · 20 Apr 2007

jassmannn....this is exactly what sikhi believes too its outrageous, but we also know that no true sikh would do such a thing and we don't believe that sikhs were involved i suggest you read this book...Soft Target: The real story behind the Air India disaster

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

confused · 20 Apr 2007

im pretty sure indian consulate got pictures of indra and rajiv gandhi why dont we go protest their supporting terrorists and mass-murderers

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Harjas Kaur · 21 Apr 2007

Jass ji, If the primary guys still living were declared not guilty after a huge trial where it was proved prosecuting police agencies had a great story to tell....but then admitted in court they had destroyed their own surveillance tapes...so now could be made to say whatever they wanted...when witness after witness failed basic credibilty test.... Why, after this has ALREADY BECOME ESTABLISHED FACT are they still publically blaming Shaheed Talwinder Singh Parmar, allegedly who gave the command to those exonerated as not guilty? If they are not guilty, how can he be who allegedly gave some nebulous (unprovable) command? He was shaheedi by Punjab police in 1992. It's real easy to target a dead man who can no longer defend himself from defamation. If you really study this case, 'confused' is right, the Indian government totally mislead and paid off the Canadian prosecutors. The Canadians won't do any kind of conscientious inquiry. They destroyed their taped conversations and blamed the Sikhs because Canada doesn't want to make an international scandal and alienate India. They went out of their way to protect someone, even to throwing kalank on their own faces. Who do you think that was? Here are facts you can look them up. Singh Bagri and Singh Malik were already under surveilance due to Indian government recommendation...but on this one day of the bombing...somehow these guys weren't under surveilance. It just defies the credible. And to this day there remains hysterical anti-Sikh sentiment because they made a fiction in the media. It was character assassination of the highest magnitude. I'm with 'confused,' we need to protest every image of every Gandhi for harming Sikh sentiments! Our shaheeds are holy to us. We honor them because they sacrificed so much for all of us. The Indian government agents did this bombing, and then identified themselves as Singhs so the target of blame was already clear. They just had a case where India arrested and quickly released a Nihang, who murdered and raped so many Sikhs while wearing Sikh bana as a pretended Khalistani while working undercover for police to kill support for the Kharkoos. I mean, what kind of sick government is Indian government? All they ever have to defend themselves with are lies within lies. [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

SilentElegance · 22 Apr 2007

Can someone remind this silly Indian murderous diplomat , this is Canada, NOT bharat mata, which they have offered half to Pakistan- I wonder if he has ever been offended by that given away by his bapoo gandhi, and chacha nehru ? I bet not! [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

sy · 22 Apr 2007

I heard these guys got used by the indian government, their use to be a good website up its down now www.airindiabombing.com and on the website it talks about how the indian government was able to use these guys for their terrorist activitys. How hard could of it bin for these guys to get used wasn't it malik who said he would kill 50 000 hindus. The guy was a terrorist in my eyes and no were in sikhi does it approve of killing inocent ppl or yelling that you will kill them.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 23 Apr 2007

I read one big article in this board how Hindus are trying to Hinduise Sikhism and pictured shown were some Hindus Deities portrayed along with Guru sahibs. I belived them. But now when I see some accused killers portrayed by Sikhs themselves along with Guru sahibs, does it means that these Sikhs are insulting great Gurus by portraying them with an alleged killer of 329 innocent people. I won'nt mind an accused killer of Gandhis put there, I won'nt mind an accused killer of , But accused killer of innocent people being glorified along with the greatest Humanist Guru sahibs is an insult to Sikhi itself and we should appreciate the efforts of Indian consulate by highlighting the issue. Such people have insulted even Gurus and their humanistice teachings. Yes It may be Canada and not Bharatmata, still nobody have rifght to equate Guru sahibs with accused mass murderers. BHul Chuk Maaf

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

not important · 23 Apr 2007

hahahahahaha man singh u gotta be kiding me "Such people have insulted even Gurus and their humanistic teachings." what bull man, the singhs did nothing against gurmat they upheld gurmat and i think that you are insulting the gurus by insulting such great shaheeds. "But now when I see some accused killers portrayed by Sikhs themselves along with Guru sahibs, does it means that these Sikhs are insulting great Gurus by portraying them with an alleged killer of 329 innocent people." of course not, he did not kill those 392 innocent people, as it was the indian government that blew up air india. innocent till proven guilty.. wjkk wjkf [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Khalsaspirit · 23 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, We would not be commenting on this topic as we have no information about that parade and reading above news did not give us exact picture either. But seems like this topic is turning towards left or right by calling Sikhs as mass murderers or etc. It is clear that they are 100% challenging the Canadian justice system which clearly showed the perfaction of their system to entire world in March 2005 by releasing those Sikhs who were blamed to be involved in such act which was imposed on Sikhs by GOI. And surly we believe in Canadian Justice System which is far fair than corrupt Indian Judiciary system. If some of the guys as above still have some trouble with those Sikhs then our advise to them is that, better to go see a psychiatric to be able to change your mentality about shaheed Singhs of SIKH NATION. At the same time misuse of pictures of Shaheed Singhs or any other related stuff should be strictly prohibited. Guru Mehar Karay. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

confused · 23 Apr 2007

my question is did you see them commit these acts...if you didnt just be quiet

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Harjas Kaur · 23 Apr 2007

I think it's obvious having read several news articles, that the Indian diplomat guy creating all this fuss and pressuring the Canadian politicians to take prejudicial action against the float were CAPITALIZING on the EMOTIONAL OUTRAGE which was media hype for so long concerning these men, but has DIED DOWN due to the ACQUITAL! Thus it remains obvious what handlers (corrupt Indian Government officials) have been manipulating the Canadian Press all along. Too bad for them their story of accusation, innuendo and direct blame didn't stand up in a court of law. THEY WERE FOUND NOT GUILTY DUE TO LACK OF EVIDENCE. IF THE BEST INVESTIGATORS IN CANADA COULD NOT PUT TOGETHER A CASE IN 20 YEARS... OTHER THAN DESTROYING THEIR OWN RECORDS AND RELYING ON DISCREDITED HEARSAY OF A FEW WITNESSES WITH PERSONAL GRUDGE AND NO PROOF... HOW DARE WE CONTINUE TO MALIGN EXONERATED SINGHS AND THE WHOLE SIKH NATION, AND THE KHALISTAN MOVEMENT. IN OVER 20 YEARS, NOT ONE PROTEST BY INDIAN OFFICIALS FOR CRIMES OF MASS GENOCIDE AND TORTURE, BUT ALL THIS OFFICIAL PROTEST OVER A SINGLE PICTURE OF AN ACCUSED MAN, WHO CAN NO LONGER DEFEND HIS REPUTATION, AND WHOSE ASSOCIATES WERE EXONERATED OF ALL CHARGES!!!!!!!!! I think the whole world can see who is setting up a hysterical case with no evidence, who has the most to gain from this propaganda, and who is the most reasonable suspicion of guilt in this bombing.... THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT ITSELF!!! [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 24 Apr 2007

Muslims also blame the same about 9/11. They also say that Americans and Jews themselves blasted their building and killed their own people only to find an excuse to malign image of muslims and to attack muslim countries. Ditto. exactly the same. One day Muslims may say Sikhs themslevs kileld their Gurus to malign Aurangjeb and Jehangir ther great muslim rulers. Will you belive them? Issue here is death of innocent people. Think for a moment if you youself were in flight, your children were in flight, your parents were blasted in flight. This is humanistic angle I simply wants to put forward. If people are angry with Indian government, they should go and kill and political leaders, army personnel and police oficers and jawans to show their enimosity. Nobody will call them terrorists. But when people kill innocent humans including women and children , it is wrong and altogather againt teachings of Gurus. Did Gurus ever attacked a colony of muslim civilisans to show their anger against Muslims or Hindus? No. never. they served humanity without any diference. They challenged tyrants like babur and Aurangjeb fearlessly, fought with their army and killed many demonic people. But did they ever attacked any civilians? So far spreadiung distrust is concerned, how sikhs will feel if they are told by muslims that you guys have fabricated history to spoil Muslims Image. A true Muslim can never kill any innocent person forget about your saintly Gurus. Let's think a little bit? Religions are founded on certain principles and all principles are resting on a big foundation known as Humanity. If we loose humanity, no matter what great principles we claim to be holding, religion has been killed.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

babbarsingh · 24 Apr 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I am one of the founders of Sikh Vision Foundation (the group who's float is being called into question) and its current President. We, as a group, have no regret with what we have stood for and nor should any other Sikh that views these great men with respect and admiration. First of all, there are never any pictures of Guru Sahibans on our float. There is no real artist rendering of our Guru's and even if their was, we have the Guru Granth Sahib to look towards instead. This float has always been called the Shaheed Singh Float. Four years ago we were asked to either remove all the pictures of these Shaheed Singh's or leave the Nagar Kirtan...we left the Nagar Kirtan. For 4 years we were not ALLOWED back in because we would not disrespect our beloved Shaheeds. This year, on an invitation from the Gurdwara Sahib, we once again entered the Nagar Kirtan with the same pictures that had gotten us banned in the first place. The government in control at any point in history will turn anyone rebelling against them into a terrorist. Future generations will change the course of a nation and those same individuals are viewed as Martyrs and the founders of a nation. Now I'll do my best to comment on the next issue. Ajaib Singh Bagri is an uncle of mine and I am extremely close to the family of Babbar Khalsa Founder Jathedar Talvinder Singh Babbar (Parmar). Jathedar Talvinder Singh was never found guilty in any court of law. He was acquited (as were Mr. Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri) of all wrong doing in this heinous crime. I am a supporter of a Sikh homeland and vehemently against violence of any sort against INNOCENT people, just as these men are. After 1984 I heard at least 100 people on various stages cry "blood for blood," definitely not the Sikh way to respond, but I am pretty sure that these people let their rage take control of them at this highly emotional time in our history. The principles that all Sikhs hold dear to them are pretty much to live and let live. How can that happen when a country denies its own citizens of basic rights to ensure that it does not succumb to the Brahminic propaganda that is slowly surrounding it? How can it be a crime in a democratic nation to show the picture of a Sikh Leader (Jathedar Talvinder Singh Babbar) that was tortured and killed in an Indian jail cell without ever being brought to trial? If he was in fact a wanted terrorist wanted on a murder charge, he was in their hands, why not put him on trial? The Punjab Police itself has admitted that he was in their custody, so when do we get those answers? When will his family learn the truth as to what happened to him and where his body ended up? The Air India bombing was a tragedy. Innocent people dying all over the world is a tragedy. But coming on this website and wrongfully accusing a man that was acquited of all wrong doing, a man that served his people and died for it, and above all a man that is no longer here to defend himself is also a small tragedy in my eyes. Most of our Singhs that fought in this era tried to make a difference in the lives of their people. What they had in their hearts only Waheguru will know. One final point. Such a ruckus was caused over the picture of a man who was never convicted of any wrong doing...yet we had the pictures of Shaheed Bhai Beant Singh, Shaheed Bhai Satwant Singh (they assassinated the Prime Minister of India) and the pictures of Shaheed Bhai Sukhdev Singh Sukha and Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Jinda (they assassinated the highest ranking General in the Indian Armed Forces), and that was not a problem???????????? Just makes me think if this is more of an issue for a few Canadian Journalists or the Indian Government.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

babbarsingh · 24 Apr 2007

Also, just a quick note...our float did not have the Guru Granth Sahib Ji on it, just a bunch of old bibian along for the ride!

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Khalsaspirit · 24 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Man Singh jio, This is our humble benti to you before you make any fuss about the shaheed Singhs mentioned in above News please think twice before you shoot out any hate activated wording against those Singhs who had given their lives for noble cause. If you think you are higher than Canadian Supreme Court please go see a psychiatric which is highly recommend for you at this moment. And for the Guru (if you believe in) sake DO NOT COMPARE SHAHEED SINGHS to the fanatic Islamic mass murderers of 9/11. Let us remind you again that , "IN THROUGH OUT HISTORY OF SIKHS, SHAHEED SINGH ALWAYS DIED FOR NOBLE CAUSE". And please do not try to fool with SIKH HISTORY. If you are a part of mass murderers then be a part of them and do not call yourself a Sikh or Singh and then we have nothing to do with you. A Sikh is never been a murderer in almost 550 years of Sikh history and will never be a part of it. Our wording is harsh Guru Mehar karay we will get over it. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 24 Apr 2007

Veer Babbarsingh Ji, thank you so much for coming on to this forum and clearing up all miscoceptions of the event. However, tihs message of yours should also be given to the media that are making such a huge issue of this. They (the media) are allowed to give their one sided story, yet no one has heard a response from any Panthic group, Gurdwara, comittee, Singhs etc. I do agree that displaying pictures of our beloved Shaheeds during a Nagar Kirtan is the least we can do to honour their sacrifice...but we need to take it one step further. We should also use this as an oppurtunity to educate both the Sikh and non Sikh masses about who these beloved Singhs and Singhnia were. Where did they come from, how did they live, why did they do what they did. Let's highlight the countless horrors that were commited against us by our so called own government, the so called largest democracy in the world. But like i said, since the issue happened in Surrey this year, I haven't heard any of our "leaders" come out with any serious statement. If all we show are pictures of Turbaned men with beards and AK 47s in their hands (as this is all that most typicsl North Americans see), of course there will be a lot of nervous citizens wondering what's going on in their back yards. However, if they see these pictures and are also educated as to why they look the way they do and why they carry weapons in there hands, then most reasonable, intelligent people will realize that these Singhs weren't/aren't terrorists. When this issue was in news, instead of remaining quiet (which looks a lot more suspicious) we could have used it as a perfect oppurtunity to go onto TV, radio, main stream news print to educate the general public. Just a quick example: It wasn't too long ago that Nelson Mandela and his party were considered terrorists by the United States government...And today nelson Mandela is celebrated as a true freedom fighter of this world. Let's not be discouraged, instead let's learn from our mistakes so we can continue to honour our Shaheeds.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

jassmannn · 25 Apr 2007

My issue with this whole subject as that the Shaheed Singhs have become the centre of reinvigoration for the born-again Sikhs rather than the history of the 10 gurus lives. On several occasions, I have met, who look like educated, well meaning Sikhs around the UK, who have full knowledge of what happened in 1984, who are enflamed and passionate about what happened then, but can't name the 10 gurus. First concentrate on the Sikh history the gurus left, and know what it is that you are fighting for, then try and fight any other issues you have. Otherwise it's the blind leading the blind.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Ibin Sikh · 25 Apr 2007

Man Singh, You mentioned that the Muslims also say the Americans were responsible for 9/11, and so do the SIkhs in case of India. But you need to realize one very important fact. Americans didn't have a track record of killing there own citizens in the last 20-30 years time. The Congress led Indian government has a very bloody track record. In the 70s when emergency was declared, they jailed tens of thousands of there own citizens who peacefully protested against emergency. I wont even mention operation blue star, but I will however mention the anti-Sikh riots in which thousands of innocent Sikhs from Delhi and other states outside Punjab were ruthlessly killed by the congress government, no one can deny that. So now, the question I pose to you is: If the Congress led government has no objection jailing tens of thousands of Indian citizens, and further killing in cold blood thousands of Sikhs (all Indian citizens) all across Indian during the Anti-Sikh riots, then what objection do you think they would have to killing a mere few hundred more in a airplane.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 25 Apr 2007

Babbar Singh jeo, your conslcuive sentence clarifies everything and asnweres the questions of all. " we had the pictures of Shaheed Bhai Beant Singh, Shaheed Bhai Satwant Singh (they assassinated the Prime Minister of India)" People appreciate the efforts of Sikhs eliminating tyrant Indira gandhi a lady of no religion but most approximately a Muslims and her name should be Indira Khan. " and the pictures of Shaheed Bhai Sukhdev Singh Sukha and Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Jinda (they assassinated the highest ranking General in the Indian Armed Forces), and that was not a problem????????????" No problem to people fighting with Army people or police or congress leaders. Problem simply occurs when innocent people travelling to homeland to see their loved ones are killed. I feel that's where fuss starts and that's why people react. Ibin Singh Jeo, "If the Congress led government has no objection jailing tens of thousands of Indian citizens, and further killing in cold blood thousands of Sikhs (all Indian citizens) all across Indian during the Anti-Sikh riots, then what objection do you think they would have to killing a mere few hundred more in a airplane." Clearly your statement means that Sikhs are as bad as congress if they do exactly the same what congress does? Again I am saying, killing of innocent people is wrong altogather no matter carried out by Muslims invaders since 713 AD, by British, by congress or by anybody else. Congress goondas committed crime against humnaity, why no sikh dared to kill sajjan Kumar or Jagdish Tytler or HKL Bhagat? A Hindu killed Gandhi fine. he was always for Muslims who killed 30 lac Hindus and Sikhs in 1947. Sikhs killed Indian Army chief, fine he was an associate of tyrrants. Sikhs kileld Indira Khan fine she was an tyrant. TAMIL Hindus killed Rajiv Gandhi fine, Rajiv desreved it as he made Indian army to kill their own tamil brothers and sisters. Hope some other natinalists will eliminate rest of gandhis the poison of India. Nobody bothers if some organisation is fighting for their freedom or dignity. Important Questions arise when innocent man women and children are killed. Look at kashmiri Muslims fighting for freedom. Who ruled kashmir for last 55 years? All Muslims. Why don'nt these muslim kashmiri freedom fighters kill these kashmiri leaders who associated with congress and enjoyed power. They kill helpless innocent Bihari, Hindus or sikhs and call this killing a freedome movement. Let's learn to differentiate between tyrants and innocent bread earners.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Khalsaspirit · 25 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Oh baba Man Singh jio. Again you are going off the topic. Quote "Congress goondas committed crime against humnaity, why no sikh dared to kill sajjan Kumar or Jagdish Tytler or HKL Bhagat?" Did you dare to do that? If not, better look your self in the mirror and then ask others. Quote "Nobody bothers if some organisation is fighting for their freedom or dignity. Important Questions arise when innocent man women and children are killed". No one said Sikhs killed any innocents only you are making fuss of it. From your wording seems like you were involved in that Air India act and because you have same last name which all Sikh men do, GOI is trying to confuse Canadian government that Sikhs did it. We think it is still a good time for you to commit your guilty for that act and why bothers others to blame for. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 26 Apr 2007

I was not even born at that time when AIR INDIA Bombing took place. Khalasasprit jio. Governments frame people. every leader worth of challenging nehru was slolwy eliminated from Indian political scene. Netaji Subhash was forcrd out of congress. Savarkar was implicated in killing of gandhi and put in Jail. Shyama Prasad Mukherji was found dead in kashmir Jail. Deen dayal Upadhyaya was found dead on a railway station. Madhav rao Scinidhia who tried to chalenge Sonia Gandhi was killed in a `plane accident' Rajesh Pilot was killed in truck car accident. Jitendra Prasad was found dead in myterious conditions. All these leaders have just one commonality: They tried to chalenge hegemony of Nehru and his decendents. You are right. I can be implicated for speaking the truth. It happens and may happen to anybody. But God is there to do justice. Decendents of so called Mughal Empires are selling red chilli around lal qila in delhi today. Imperialist Britain has reduced to a level of American Dog within last 50 years. God's action takes time and gives opportunity even to tyrants to mend their ways. Let's wait and watch.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Khalsaspirit · 26 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Baba [gurbani]mY nw mwnUM [/gurbani] Man Singh jio, kirpa karow bring a single evidence proving your thoughts about the original topic. Quote "Decendents of so called Mughal Empires are selling red chilli around lal qila in delhi today." What you expect with your wandering thoughts. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 27 Apr 2007

`evidence' are provided to ambigous things. Air exists in environment do not need any evidence even to blind. I have been in Delhi and Calcutta. Everybody can vist the place. If somebody writes a crap book and I quote from such book, you will belive it and I am saying that beased on personal witness visible to everybody, you are asking fro evidence. My village near Delhi was attacked by dacoits 6 times and till date no dacoit was ever punished due to lack of `Evidence' and `witness' ? Does it mean that my village was never attacked? There are certain things based on common sense. There are certain truths based on actual experimentation results anybody can do and no evidence or witeness are required fro that. `Religion' as a whole is based on personal experinece. None can produce any evidence that `God' exists. But truth is that God exists and many people have realised God and it is free to all to investigate. But is tere anybody who can produce `evidence' that `God' exists? The same way, please go to delhi, see Lal Qila and check the profession of decendents of Mughals. Recently a women of Mughal family was selling Tea in calcutta. I'll try to find news report if I get that news report from some where I'll post it here.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Khalsaspirit · 27 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Baba [gurbani]mY nw mwnUM[/gurbani] man Singh jio, Sorry that you trapped in your own web. Tell us if we can help you out. What kind of evidence you are providing here. Are you crazy? Please read our previous post very carefully what we asked. The problem with is that you are throwing any crap from top of your mind not even reading what we asked you. In very plain English we asked to provide a single evidence concerning to the topic. And instead of having any specifics about the topic you start selling the Chili powder, tea, air pollution of India etc and other crap. Baba jio are we not talking here about [gurbani] prcUn dI dukwn [/gurbani] or about Delhi or Calcutta or Madras of Paris or New York. We know you are frustrated now because of lack of specifics about the topic on which you started posting with bad intention anyway. Quote “There are certain things based on common sense. There are certain truths based on actual experimentation results anybody can do and no evidence or witeness are required fro that”. What common sense you talking about here, the one which you already lost going off the topic. Again do not try to sell here your chili powder or tea or milk or coffee because that is not the topic here. In a plain English the topic was about shaheed Singh's picture and Other prominent Singhs who contributed their lives or most part of their life to panth and GOI with help of people like you tried to called them terrorist and Canadian Supreme court denied that by ruling agianst the charges imposed on Sikhs, period. If you have any single piece of evidence which can reverse that decision bring it in. But in stead of understanding this plain English you are throwing the crap into the topic to make it cheap and waste topic. That’s why if the writers like you write a crap book no one believe it and read it. So please next time bring any thing relevant to topic before we further reward you with "Great Baba [gurbani]mY nw mwnUM[/gurbani]Man Singh ji Delhi or Calcutta wale". To bo honest with you, we not answering to hurt your feelings about Sikhi (if you believe in) but at the same time if you want to play blindly in hands of GOI we will definatly not let that happen here either. Also sorry to hear about incident at your village. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

SinghKaur · 27 Apr 2007

@ veer man singh Im new to this website, this is my first post but im sorry to say it is targeting ur ignorance. As so many brothers and sisters requested you any evidence regarding the topic i again humbly request you to bring any evidence that sikhs did it and killed innocent ppl. From the start of topic u r crying louder and louder "innocent ppl...innocent ppl".........we know they were innocent ppl.....but do u have any proof that sikhs did it......? Anybody can purchase tickets in the name of last name "SINGH A" or "Singh XYZ" and didnt even turned up to board the plane. Does it prove that a Singh purchased it ? Any Chandu or any Suchanand can purchase it and pretend to be a sikh and fill the luggage with anything. So pls just use some common sense and pray to waheguru that this black mark on a sikhs turban is washed away and we can atleast pay homage to all shaheeds. Waheguru bless u. [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 29 Apr 2007

Panthic Weekly has posted a response to the Canadian media this last issue. Its on [url]http://www.panthic.org[/url] [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 30 Apr 2007

My aplogy for any offence. I am not siding with GOI. I am siding with families of those who suffered. In my opinion those who were killed and suffered are the biggest loosers in the political fight of khalistanis and GOI. I seek justice for such suffering humanity and as a sikh ensuring justice for innocent people is the very purpose of sikhi. If sikhs dilute their purpose themselves for political gains, I feel sikhims has reduced to merely politics and humane angle is misisng altogather. I am sorry for any offence and apologise for if I have wrote something unreasonable in the eyes of my brotehrs and sisters.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Harjas Kaur · 30 Apr 2007

[quote]I am not siding with GOI. I am siding with families of those who suffered. In my opinion those who were killed and suffered are the biggest loosers in the political fight of khalistanis and GOI. I seek justice for such suffering humanity and as a sikh ensuring justice for innocent people is the very purpose of sikhi. If sikhs dilute their purpose themselves for political gains, I feel sikhims has reduced to merely politics and humane angle is misisng altogather.[/quote] You are completely unreasonable. Do you really delude yourself with this seeming nice talk about siding with the innocent while you do public nindya of innocent Singhs who were EXONERATED IN A FAIR COURT OF LAW? WHAT PROOF HAVE YOU THAT SIKHS DILUTE THEIR PURPOSE WHEN THIS CRIME HAS NEVER BEEN PROVED AGAINST THEM? Without standing up for political justice the Khalsa Panth is meaningless. That's why Guruji is the king of both Miri and Piri. Stop running the name of the Khalsa into the mud with your ridiculous ramblings. Show respect for Khalistani shaheeds who sacrificed EVERYTHING to protect the Khalsa Panth from political corruption and slavery to Indian government. Khalsa has never harmed the innocent, that's the propaganda of the actual perpetrators of this crime, who even after trial PROVED there was absolutely no evidence against the Singhs CONTINUE to spout blame and hysteria in the absence of any facts. Khalsa are defenders of the innocent, thats why Khalsa fight criminals like corrupt Indian government who murdered countless thousands of innocents in most disgusting ways. You aren't siding with anything but lies. [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Hardeep Singh · 01 May 2007

Have any gursikhs from Canada appeared on the news and challenged the media that the gursikhs were in the right. Also will they have the same float of shaheed singhs next year at the nagar keertan? [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Naam · 01 May 2007

This is very rich indeed. It was the Indian government itself that was responsible for the downing of that flight. The book Soft Target by Canadian journalists Zuhair Kashmeri of the Toronto Globe and Mail and Brian McAndrew of the Toronto Star exposed India’s responsibility for this bombing. In the book, Kashmeri and McAndrew quoted a Canadian Security Investigative Service (CSIS) investigator as saying, “If you really want to clear the incidents quickly, take vans down to the Indian High Commission and the consulates in Toronto and Vancouver, load up everybody and take them down for questioning. We know it and they know it that they are involved.” News wrote:

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Hardeep Singh · 01 May 2007

If gursikhs have proofthat it was the GOI, why don't they present this evidence to the courts? [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Naam · 03 May 2007

How did India get away with it? Part of the answer is that the keepers of our security, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) and its predecessor, the Security Service of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), were so preoccupied with the Soviet threat that nothing else seemed to matter. These agencies had neither the understanding of, nor the necessary multicultural manpower to deal with, any additional threats to Canadian security. To its credit, CSIS eventually woke up just before the tragic Air-India bombing that left 329 people, mostly Canadians, dead in June 1985. It chased the culprits right to the Indian embassy and consulates. But what it then faced was political interference. CSIS is not a police force. It cannot make arrests and it cannot lay criminal charges. Neither can it issue marching orders to diplomats it identifies as spies. It is bound by law to notify the police about criminal matters. When it comes to espionage, the Department of External Affairs must decide whether to remove the diplomats concerned. CSIS found External to be an obstacle in its pursuit of the Indian spy network. Officials in that department were not anxious to embarrass a country that was Canada's gateway to Third World trade. Few in CSIS were happy with what was happening in their' investigation of the Air-India bombing, as well as their investigation into foreign interference in the affairs of Canadian Sikhs. Pat Olson and Fred Gibson were two of several CSIS officials who complained about the investigation. They and others were incensed that the Indian connection was being buried for reasons of political and economic expediency. Similarly angry were some members of the Metro Toronto Police intelligence branch and the RCW. The book Soft Target is banned in India, for what reason?

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

panth ka daas · 05 May 2007

dear bros and sisters : WGKK WGKF. this is my first ever comment on any forum . Vir Man SINGH JI- i have read all the letters on this topic . i have failed to understand where it is leading to.!!!!!! it is a simple known fact that-- the person concerned in the topic and his associates were acuitted by the honourable court. and if their pictures are shown in the procession, where lies the problem? as to the blowing of the Air india boeing. it was the most heinous act and remains the most tragic event to have happened at the time & the scares of which will ever remain on the hearts of those who have lost their dear ones. the PANTH's heart goes out to them ( and always has). vir ji; i have read all u'r arguments too. but you heve never argued on the topic . but have allways talked on something that did not relate to the topic. except when you raise the "humanitarian" approach towards the bereaved of the tragedy. name one Sikh , who is happy at the killing of those innocents !!!! noone, least any sikh, can ever be happy while innnocent blood is being spilt anywhere in the world . so please do the kirpa of telling us if - the person ,Bhai parmar I mean was a terrorist (in the eyes of canadians and the Sikh) who had bombed the plane , . if not ( as is widely known now , cause all have been acuitted and not convicted in the case) , what is this hue & cry about ?. please enlighten me on that. panth ka daas

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

panth ka daas · 05 May 2007

where is the argument of Bhai man singh ji.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 10 May 2007

Bhai Panth ka daas, Two truths are know to every human being. 1. You were born 2. you will die Third truth in this word is realsied by those who reached Godhead. Rest of the information bank is simply a bunch of circumestancial beliefs established based on obseravtions of humans depending upon ones own perpective. Religious fanatics all over the world have three things in common: 1. They see conspiracy behind every even not favourable to them. 2. Miracle behind every favorable event 3. tendency to cover their misdeedsa dn inhuman acts with the name of God or by demonising the victims. Jehangir and Aurangjeb did the same and many people doing the same even today. If you are watching veide clips on canadian TV's related to documentary on Air India Bombing, it is very much visible that some among sikhs were openly thretening killing 50,000 Hindus. Secret files being opened in the new enquiry are clearly showing how parmar tested a bomb in vancouver island hills and police kept quite and some time later blast occured and innocent people lost lives. These circumestancial observations by a human mind. I am not saying I am absolutely true as absolute truth are only three I listed above in my life. Do you feel those who were weilding their swords and demanding blood of 50000 Hindus were `Sikhs' as per your definition of sikhi? I am surprised why a Sikh should penalise a Hindu for the crime of "super secular congress Goondas" loyal to none a but a lady of no religion? Is this justice as per sikh tradition that threten to kill 50000 innocents to revenge for crimes of congress goondas. Congress ruled Panjab afterwards purely on sikh votes as hindu usually vote for BJP in Punjab? If Hindus voting for congress become part of congress crime , then sikhs associated with congress are equally bad and present prime Minister. Muslims also voted enmass to congress party. Christians of India voted to congress all thorugh history. Therefore why these sikhs thretened to kill Hindus and not to kill fellow sikhs , Muslims, chrsitains etc for the same mistake of voting congress party? Only because Hindus are weak and never use bad words only due to their gratefulness for sacrifices of Sikhs to defend Dharma which Sikhs today claim that they sacrificed to defend `Hindus' as if they themselves were not under threat from Mulsims side by side with Hindus? Good and bad people are in every community. Every community have great people and criminals side by side. Criteria of greatness is service to humanity while criteria of criminlaity is torture to humanity. Whole Canadian media today is full of video tapes and intelligence reports how some among Sikhs were thretening to kill Hindus openly and one finr day that killeing occured. No court of law could punish Jehangir. No court of law could punish Aurangjeb Doest that mean they were innocent and never committed any crime against humanity? similar to court of laws mant times aqquit the people. Its not big news. But for common person like me, if a group of people threting to kill me for last some time and I was found killed one fine day. people will think that I have been killed by those who were thretening me. In reality I was under threat. Some people were thretening me. I was killed. I suffered and I expect those who threatened me should not be equated with great humanist Gurus in public pareds irrepective of if they really killed me or not? Recorded voices of parmar and otehrs are very much available in media and everybody is free to check if they irrationally thretened the whole Hindu community or not? Is this what great Gurus stood for? Did they ever called for blood of all Muslims? Did they ever called fro blood of even all Mughals to avenge crimes of fanatic Muslims against humanity? Just think Bhai ji. If there is thief in a community, should you call whole community as thiefs? If a Brahmin made the mistake, should we strat blaming whole Brahmins and steretype them as most of our preachers do nowadays? Are we ready to accept the same criteria for ourselves? Good people can be created by many methods. Khalasa of course fastest and purest but difficult to follow. Let's learn to respect of disrespect the people based on ther character and human values and not based on way of worship. My aplogy for any offence. I am neither expert nor journalist. I simply use my common sense while sharing my views.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

panth ka daas · 10 May 2007

you are right vir ji ! its is wrong to brand a whole community fortheacts of just 1 person. i am of the same views as u are. calling hindus as the culprits is certainly not right . i do not advocate that & never shall and nver did the Guru's teach us hatred. but just the fact that there is so much hue & cry about this matter , that irks me. i am against all generalisations. india has asked canada to let indian courts solve the case. it makes mockery of india itself. they have never been able to solve any case of the thousands of Sikh killed in the last 25 years, but want to solve the case of 325 people.not that their lives were less worthy. but just that the first case is regarding a majority of sikh & the second is that of a majority, other than sikh. the center has always been against & shall stay against the Sikh beliefs & faith.&there is no use talking of the puppet manmohan who now occupies the throne. bhul chuk maaf

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

SomeSingh · 10 May 2007

Man Singh, you claim that an entire group (Hindus) shouldn't be judged for the actions of one/some (Gandhi/Congress) - I fully agree - BUT why don't you practice what you preach? Don't judge all kharkoos by the actions of some.

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Man Singh · 11 May 2007

based on my experience , those who know a little bit `true' of history of India and Indian civilisation, they always salute Sikhs and Sikhi. But reality the history being taught for last 55 years in India is meant for glorification of gangas of mao, marx macauley and mohammed. centre has always been against very beliefs originated from soil fo India not only against Sikhs. Tradition of making mokery of sikhs through sardar ji jokes is too offensive and even sikhs like Khushwant Singh are in the front for the same. The names of all freedom fighters who were anyhow having faith in Indian ethos has been eliminated one by one. Contribution of Sikhsm arya samaaj and Hindu mahasabha has altogather been eliminated from public memory. Either assaissination or character assassination has been followed. Issue is how come they are so successful? Divide and rule. Sikhs are brainwqashed to consoider themseleves as minorities and are found most of the time stading against majority Hindus. In reality, its not `Hindus' who create trouble, it is secularists loyal to British throne even today who are real culprits. My feeling is that cunningly blame of all sins of secularists is pushed on the heads of `Hindus' or `brahmins'. We remain divided we are suffering. associates of foreign invaders are enjoyoing everything. I have travelled a lot in India and have seen `Hindus' who are little bit aware of true history of India simply have reverance for the Turban of Sikhs. Oposite to that secularists who always were loyal to British throne make a mokery of it. But blames are put on `hindus' and `brahmins' and we stand divided and being ruled by `secularist goondas'. Does anyone feels that Indira Gandhi, rajive gandhi or Rahul gandhi are Hindus? Definitely not?

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Harjas Kaur · 11 May 2007

At the time of Indira Gandhi's murder, it was shocking to people that police and cabinet ministers were leading riots. But the massive throngs of people were, by and large, Hindus, attacking Sikhs for perceived anti-Bharat sentiment. Bajrang Dal even today, as the youth wing of VHP threatens dire consequences to any minority who would divide Bharat, or secede from the union of territories of India. What you are so dishonest in your attempted portrayal of blame of Macauley (British historian), Marx (Communists), Mohammed (Muslims). It wasn't any of these groups raping, burning, torturing, looting, killing Sikhs.....and it wasn't only Congress either. You go on about threats after all these massacres, by Sikhs, to kill 50,000 Hindus in retaliation! Were 50,000 Hindus ever killed? No! But hundreds of thousands of Sikhs were raped, tortured, murdered in the country of India for decades after WITHOUT PROTEST OR APOLOGY! And not just by Congress, but by people with Hindutva sentiments intent on supressing Sikh sovereignty and division of India, as well as by fake Sikhs who were sell-outs for personal gain. You say there are taped conversations between Singhs about the bombing of Air India flight? Well, we heard all about it from Kim Bolan. But when it came to day in Court, the CSIS and Canadian Agencies committed the unprecedented...they claimed they erased the tapes. And they produced nothing to the Court in the way of actual evidence. All they had were testimony of discredited witnesses who the Canadian Judge himself said were NOT CREDIBLE. However much this offends your desire for reality, I'm afraid I must ask you to stop falsely accusing the Singhs who have already been EXONERATED IN A COURT OF LAW from the tabloid slander which was thrown against them WITHOUT EVIDENCE WHICH COULD STAND UP IN COURT! [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

SomeSingh · 12 May 2007

wow, Man Singh, you seem to know very little about the RSS. Look through the articles on sikhspectrum.com for more info on their organised pograms against muslims, and their propaganda and isolation techniques, their growing attacks against christians, their propaganda that Sikhi is a part of Hinduism which they do partly by distorting Gurbani and so on, and so on, and so on....

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

Khalsaspirit · 13 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, We think this guy should be rewareded for his the most ignorant posts ever on the entire forum. We requested this person not one time but many times that when you post some thing bring any fact relevent to topic but he never listened and keep shooting the crap from top of the head and see how he is traped. Any way he is eligible for following reward Great Baba[gurbani] mY nw mwnUM[/gurbani] Man Singh ji Delhi wale And sangat knows what to do with these posts once some one achieved that padvee. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

panth ka daas · 13 May 2007

since the case was dismissed in the court; india has been looking for an excuse to pounce on the sikh again. and that they wilfully found in the procession in canada. i never have understood the cheap pranks that the union govt. plays from time to time. this time they say that the picture disturbs them. but how can they sleep soundly when they have amongst their ranks mass killers. does that not irk them. the photo of a man who doesnot live anymore is the storm raiser, but those murderers with whom these politicians rub their shoulders every hour ,matters the least to them . they are hypocrites of the highest level

Re: India protests alleged terrorist portrayed as a martyr in Sikh parade

singh sahib · 14 May 2007

why would they care about one picture of a guy who did something against them, but they have no issue with the hundreds of others pics of people they themselves killed?