Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is bibek required?

Is bibek required?

Some girl · 09 May 2003

Hi! I'm not amritdhari yet, but I am planning to take amrit. I just had a question that some of you may be able to answer. If you take amrit is it neccessary to be bibek? I'm only 13 so I hope someone will PLEASE answer this question?

Re: Is bibek required?

Kulbir Singh · 09 May 2003

Please refer to the following url for more details on Bibek: http://www.tapoban.org/langar.htm As far as Bibek is concerned, it is absolutely a must. Without bibek, one can never realize Bhagtee. So says Baani: VEDEENAA KEE DOSTI, VEDEENEAA KAA KHAAN|| SIFTEE SAAR NA JANANEE, SADAA VASAI SHAITAAN|| (Ones who eat from non-devotees and ones who do friendships with non-devotees, can never realize the Sifat Salaah i.e. bhagtee and cannot get rid of evil from within). You are very young at this time. Consult your parents before taking such an important step in your life. The most ideal situation would be if your family is amritdhari. Then there should be no problem keeping bibek. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is bibek required?

Nirmaljot Singh · 10 May 2003

Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh! I think that you should definately be bibek. ***Edited by Admin***** Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Is bibek required?

mahakaal · 10 May 2003

mr kulbir singh... could u please not take gurbani completely out of context... u have only taken half of the first line... go to http://www.sikhitothemax.com/PageASP.asp?ShabadID=2956 for the full shabad. there u will find a completely different meaning when taken in context. a small benti to mr kulbir singh... could u please post the url of the shabad from perhaps the sikhitothemax website, or at least quote the author & page so that people can do their own research if they wish. thank u! :)

Re: Is bibek required?

Mkhalsa · 10 May 2003

mahakaal jee, many times sikhitothemax has many errors, which gursikhs are trying to fix. Also an english translation is not the end all and be all of gurbani. There are so many connotations, historical contexts, interpretations, etc etc that bani means so much more than what you will see in a simple translation. If you will notice, sttm also adds two seperate sentences together into one, which to you may look out of context, when it isnt. Please read the gurmukhi carefully.

Re: Is bibek required?

mahakaal · 11 May 2003

mkhalsa, i agree with u that there are problems with some of the english translations & that we should always aim to refer back to the gurmukhi itself for a better understanding. however, in the case above, looking at the gurmukhi, it suggests that it is the thieves & prostitutes (not 'Ones who eat from non-devotees and ones who do friendships with non-devotees' as mr kulbir singh states) who cannot realise sifat salaah. either posting the url of the shabad or quoting it in it's entirety would at least allow other people to look for themselves & make up their own minds.

Re: Is bibek required?

Sukhdev Singh · 12 May 2003

VahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh Sade Vade Veer Bhai Kulbir Singh probably could & might reply to mahakaal's statement, but I will try & help with what little knowledge I have as I am getting to feel a bit sorry for our veer as this site & it's questions are keeping him quite busy. However he is doing a maha seva of projecting true Gurmat. mahakaal states>> however, in the case above, looking at the gurmukhi, it suggests that it is the thieves & prostitutes (not 'Ones who eat from non-devotees and ones who do friendships with non-devotees' as mr kulbir singh states) who cannot realise sifat salaah. What Guru Nanak Dev Jee is referring to as Chor(thieves) can be found earlier, when Guru Jee states "Naven Chale Thirthi Maan Kote Than Chor" this is the Chor Guru Jee is refering to in Banee. Basically without going into great detail the real Chors in this world are the ones without Naam. Guru Jee states in Banee "BIN NAVE SABH CHOR" When Guru Nanak Dev Jee is referring to Rundeea this should be viewed in the context of Vaheguroo being our husband which becomes clear as you read on from that shabad. Bhula Chucka Dee Maaf Karnee. VahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh

Re: Is bibek required?

Kulbir Singh · 12 May 2003

>>>>>> either posting the url of the shabad or quoting it in it's entirety would at least allow other people to look for themselves & make up their own minds. >>>>>> Normally when I quote any Gurbani, it is not from a search engine. This is why I don't know the url for it. The shabad is from Soohi kee Vaar of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee >>>>>>>>> however, in the case above, looking at the gurmukhi, it suggests that it is the thieves & prostitutes (not 'Ones who eat from non-devotees and ones who do friendships with non-devotees' as mr kulbir singh states) who cannot realise sifat salaah. >>>>>>>> Please correct me if I understood wrong but I think you are saying that the word "Vedeen" in the quote of Gurbani I quoted means thieves of prostitutes. Let us now look at the whole shabad and then do vichaar on it: CHORAAN, JAARAAN, RANDEEYAAN, KUTANIYAAN, DIBAAN|| One who sits in the sangat (dibaan) of thieves, Kaami people (jaaraan), Randeeyaan (bad women) and Kutaniyaan (pimps). VEDEENAAN KEE DOSTI, VEDEENAA KAA KHAAN|| And (continued from above) one who does friendship with Vedeens (ones who is not a devotee of Guru Sahib) and ones who eat the food of Vedeens. Vedeen is a compound word made of two words i.e. Ve and Deen. Deen means Dharam and in here it means Gurmat Dharam as we don't recognize any other Dharam. Ve means without. The whole word means one who is without Gurmat Dharam i.e. without Gurmat Deen. This is how Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has explained about this Shabad in his great book - GURMAT BIBEK. SIFTEE SAAR NAA JANANEE, SADA VASAI SHAITAAN|| Such people (described in the two pankitis above) cannot realize the Sifat Salaah (praise of Vaheguru) and always have evil residing in them. GADHON CHANDAN KHAULIYE, BHEE SAAHOO SIYON PAAN People described in the three lines above are like donkeys and even if you bathe them with expensive paste of Chandan wood, they still like to get dirty in dirt (ash). NANAK KOORAI KATIYAIN, KOORA TANEEYE TAAN|| Guru Nanak Sahib says that ones who weave evil end up with evil. KOORA KAPAD KACHHEYAIN, KOORA PAINAN MAAN|| The clothes woven by evil thread, result in one wearing evil. This is on Ang 790 of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Veer jeeo, the 2nd and 3rd pankitis of this shabad have been interpreted by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and that is the translation I have followed. Hopefully this will clear up some things. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is bibek required?

r2d2 · 12 May 2003

Since the gurbani immediately before the thukh VEDEENAAN KEE DOSTI, VEDEENAA KAA KHAAN|| SIFTEE SAAR NAA JANANEE, SADA VASAI SHAITAAN|| mentions people such as prostitutes, theives, pimps, etc. Couldn't this mean that Guru Sahib is saying that those who eat out of these TYPES of peoples hands will not recieve Sifat Salaah? Also, couldn't an arguement be made that these two lines are being taken TOO literally? Couldn't the message be more directed towards the idea of keeping dirty sangat of evil people will never lead to Sifat Salaah? For example: the thukh "vedeenaan kee dosti..." is being taken LITERALLY here. However, if you decide to take THIS thukh to it's strictest literal meaning then you must also apply the same logic to the rest of the shabad. That means it is not "non-devotees" whom we must avoid, but prostitutes, theives, pimps...etc. How do you explain your change in interpretation from symbolic in one thukh to a completely literal interpretation in the thukh right after? Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Is bibek required?

Kulbir Singh · 12 May 2003

>>>>>> VEDEENAAN KEE DOSTI, VEDEENAA KAA KHAAN|| SIFTEE SAAR NAA JANANEE, SADA VASAI SHAITAAN|| mentions people such as prostitutes, theives, pimps, etc. Couldn't this mean that Guru Sahib is saying that those who eat out of these TYPES of peoples hands will not recieve Sifat Salaah? >>>>>>>> With our own matt we can derive as many meanings or interpretations as we want. Great mystic Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and great Sikh scholars like Professor Sahib Singh jee tell us that one pankiti of Gurbani can have only one meaning. The reason for that is that Gurbani has been written in a very special way. It has a great viyaakaran (grammar) that is very different from the worldly grammars. Normally it is not possible or is very hard to interpret more than two meanings. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has clearly interpreted this pankiti to mean that Vedeen means those people who have no deen i.e. are not part of the Gurmat Deen (Dharam). If someone here is more intelligent than Bhai Sahib or has more avastha (spiritual state) than Bhai Sahib, then it is a different case, otherwise, it is a good idea to agree to what our Bazurg (respectable) Gursikhs have written in their books. >>>>>>> CHORAAN, JAARAAN, RANDEEYAAN, KUTANIYAAN, DIBAAN|| VEDEENAAN KEE DOSTI, VEDEENAA KAA KHAAN|| SIFTEE SAAR NAA JANANEE, SADA VASAI SHAITAAN|| >>>>>>> Let me try one more time to explain these pankitis. Ones who do sangat of thieves, Kaami people, bad women, and pimps; and ones who do sangat of vedeens (ones who have no dharam i.e no Gurmat Dharam) and ones who eat of vedeens, can never realize the sifat salaah of Vaheguru and evil resides in them. In other words ones who do the following things cannot know sifat salaah and have evil residing in them: Chor - Sangat of Thieves (Bin Naavai sabh chor) Jaar - Sangat of Kaami people Randiyaan - Sangat of Women of bad character Kutiniyaan - Sangat of Pimps Vedeen - One who is without bhagti/Naam , non devotee - Sangat of Vedeen Vedeen kaa khaan - One who eats from Vedeens. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has interpreted this pankiti as this daas has tried to explain (based on his writings). It is up to you who you want to follow - Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib or your own intelligence or beliefs. If you are so stuck on this pankiti, here is another pankiti to support Bibek: SANTAN KAA DAANA ROOKHAN, SO SARB NIDHAAN|| GREH SAAKAT, CHHATEEH PARKAAR, SO BIKHOO SAMAAN|| Translation: The very simple food of Gursikhs is like amrit. 36 kinds of delicious food of saakats (non-devotees or ones who don't do bhagti) is like poison. Bibek is the fundamental of Sikhi. Without Bibek no one can proclaim the Nyaara pan (uniqueness) of Khalsa. Without Bibek Khalsa is doing "Bipran kee Reet". Ones who try to do bhagti without bibek, cannot reap full benefits. So says Gurmat. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is bibek required?

member · 13 May 2003

wjkkwjkf if i remeber correctly, I have a keertan track of bhai jeevan singh and he is doing the shabad VEDEENAA KEE DOSTI, VEDEENEAA KAA KHAAN|| SIFTEE SAAR NA JANANEE, SADAA VASAI SHAITAAN|| afterward he talks of who is a vaydeen and he says vaydeen is beh-amriteh i.e. those that dont take amrit ect... do not eat from/with them and dont make friendship with them... bhulla chuka di maaf -fateh

Re: Is bibek required?

r2d2 · 13 May 2003

Kulbir Singh, I wasn't "stuck" on any pankiti. The more I think about it the more I realize that I am somewhat bebeki myself. My whole family is amritdhari and I eat only from their hands. I guess I never realized it before. I still am somewhat uneasy about whether bibek is essential, but i know for a fact that it does feel 'wierd' when I eat food prepared by someone who is not amritdhari. Bhul Chuf Maaf

Re: Is bibek required?

Khalsa Soulja · 13 May 2003

im gonna take amrit in about 2 years......my mom aint amritdhari......does that mean im gonna have to make my own food all the time? im still struggling with spaghetti and cheesetoast lol!

Re: Is bibek required?

Singhnee · 13 May 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>im still struggling with spaghetti and cheesetoast lol!<<<<<<< You can buy the pasta machine and there is a book with it with many recipes. You can make same pasta with it as you buy from stores. (- : )

Re: Is bibek required?

Gurparsad · 13 May 2003

<<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>> Kulbir Singh Bani can have way more than one meaning, some pankties of bani can derive as many as 10 or more meanings. The more you read and read the deeper you get, and the more meanings you learn. Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji would derive 40 meanings sometimes and then apoligize to the sangat that he could not go further and derive more. Guru sahib left bani open to interperation by writing it in metahporical verses for reasons. if the case was as simple as posted above then bani would have rather been written in more textual format, rather it was written in poetic versses. Wjkk WJkf

Re: Is bibek required?

Kulbir Singh · 13 May 2003

Dear Gurparsad, >>>>> Kulbir Singh Bani can have way more than one meaning, some pankties of bani can derive as many as 10 or more meanings. >>>>> Please give us an example where you can have 10 meanings of a pankiti. If you are going to ignore the viyaakaran of gurbani and then do meanings, then what can we say. If you are denying that there is no such thing as "viyakaran" (grammar) of Gurbani, I can - by kirpa of Guru Sahib - prove to you that there is indeed grammar of Gurbani and that Gurbani is written in a very special way. In some cases where grammar does not pose a problem, it may be possible to interpret more than one meaning i.e. maybe two and this is why I wrote in my previous posting that it was impossible or “Very Hard” to interpret more than one meaning. But to do 10 meanings would be a stretch. I would like to see a pankiti to which you can have 10 meanings. Then we will discuss each meaning and see if that meaning is valid. >>>>>>>> Guru sahib left bani open to interperation by writing it in metahporical verses for reasons. if the case was as simple as posted above then bani would have rather been written in more textual format, rather it was written in poetic versses. >>>>> Now you are talking about the intention of Guru Sahib and explaining why he wrote baani in poetic form. I don’t think we can say for sure that he wrote baani in poetic form so that people could derive more than one meaning. The more valid explanation for poetic form seems to be that Guru Sahib wanted his gursikhs to do kirtan and if Gurbani was not in poetic form how would we do kirtan? Daas, Kulbir Singh