Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is this acceptable

Is this acceptable

Robert Langdon · 30 Mar 2007

I was listenting to keertan the other day and whilst listening I started to wonder whether this was acceptable or not. Let me give you an example of what I mean... Whilst listen to the keertan the keertani sang this tukh: hou(n) kurbaanai jaao thinaa kai lain jo thaeraa naao then he sang 'Oh' lain jo thaeraa naao.... 'bhaee' lain jo thaeraa naao I was just wondering if this is acceptable to add extra words whilst singing gurbani. I understand that maybe the keertani is musth with gurbani russ, but whilst listening to the keertan when the keertani sang 'Oh' lain jo thaeraa naao.. the sangath aslo added on 'oh' aswell (maybe they dont know if that was part of the shabad) could a learned gursikh give advice if this is acceptable. (ps sorry if you think this is a petty post, but was just wondering) Bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: Is this acceptable

Balpreet Singh · 30 Mar 2007

Sometimes when a kirtani is singing something with force a bit of an "oh" happens inadvertently but certainly we shouldn't be adding any words to shabads. For example the shabad "Meri abai bintee sun leejai" has been turned into "Sun leejai maharaj meri abai bintee..." This sort of warping of the shabad seems wrong to me.

Re: Is this acceptable

confused · 31 Mar 2007

yaa gotta agree with Balpreet Singh

Re: Is this acceptable

Bachitar Singh · 31 Mar 2007

Thats a good question. What about when keertanis start doing waheguru in the middle of a shabad. Those specific wahegurus are not in the shabad. I have heard from a lot of senior singhs that Bhai Randhir Singh was against the singing of waheguru in the middle of a shabad. SDO is to blame for the famousing of it.

Re: Is this acceptable

harveen_singh_manchester · 01 Apr 2007

vjkkvjkf veerji do not blame one person for this its not good. who knows how much kamayee bhai sahib has had, so no blaming. and regarding the simran, well a senior singh i know very well who lives just 5 mins away from me who used to be there at bhai sahibs times, and he told me that this is not even true that bhai sahib was against simran in keertan, singhs did it in his presence who were very close to him. im nt sure if bhai sahib himself did simran in the middle of keertan, because when i asked the singh who lives near me he went gussa at me and i can understand why because he had a point, he asked if i consider bhai sahib as an authority? and i went quite.lol. anyways. the singh who lives near me told me a story, about him and a few other singhs getting together in amritsar 1 week after bhai randhir singh jis funeral and they did keertan one singh started the keertan with a shabad "bal bal gurdev jin naam drirhayeaa" which is a quite short shabad and he started simran and it went on and on for hours and no one realised the time he said 6-7 hrs passed then the simran stopped, and that singh was on of the keertanis at bhai sahibs times. but yeah, bhai sahib was against doing simran anywhere in the shabad, so you must know when to do it. once some singh was doing simran just anywhere he liked and bhai sahib just took the harmonium away from him. vjkkvjkf [%sig%]

Re: Is this acceptable

confused · 01 Apr 2007

actually i heard this originated from a raagi from Darbar Sahib

Re: Is this acceptable

CSJ · 03 Apr 2007

I heard this sdo guy is changing all the maryadas of Amrit so he is out of sikhi. Kamai means nothing if he start changing maryadas and put people on wrong way. [%sig%]

Re: Is this acceptable

Robert Langdon · 09 Apr 2007

So, if most people agree that one shouldnt add extra words to Baani, then can we say its wrong to start doing simran within the shabad?? Even though its not a word but a mahaan mantar, the gurmantar, but still are we not adding something extra? Dont get me wrong, Im just confused about this subject. I agree we shouldnt use Bhai Sahib as an authority, but Bhai Sahib was a uchi avaastha vaale gursikh, we can learn from him and many say bhai sahib never broke the shabad, Dr Surrinder Singh use to tell SDO not to start breaking the shabad. I knowa few elder gursikhs who still wont go against doing simran during keertan. But then at the same time we have many chardi kaala gursikhs who do simran in the shabad. Maybe if the keertani is must on the shabad and automatically starts doing simran then thats fair enough... Pata ni... what do the sangath think?? Bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]