Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 13 Mar 2007
The documentary was nicely put together and showed that the documentary makers had put efforts to produce a representative account of the days leading to partition. However, the documentary did not do justice for the Sikhs. Below is a Complaint which I have sent to Channel 4 and Ofcom (the television regulators).
Benti to Sangat - please help to complain.
I sent this to Channel4.com, building upon what Dal Singh jee wrote in his complaint:
[quote]Subject: Racism & Ill-Feeling Against Sikhs in Documentary
On 12th March 2007 at 9pm, Channel 4 aired the programme "Partition". The programme was totally biased, misrepresentative of the Sikh perspective, which was very offensive, and many Sikhs feel invoked racism against Sikhs.
1. The Sikhs of Panjab were portrayed as communal troublemakers and shown as barbaric savages whereas the Muslims were simply defending themselves and the Hindus were peace-loving people caught up in the tension. This is firstly, totally false. Secondly, it invokes racial hatred against Sikhs as the other two communities (Hindus and Muslims) were portrayed as the victims.
2. The programme largely focused on Panjab, which historically has been the Sikh homeland and it is widely known the Sikh Kingdom which the last part of India to be annexed by the British was based in Panjab with it's capital Lahore and stretched from Kabul to Delhi. However, the programme only featured one Sikh speaker who was featured making comments "twice" only. Considering the history and politics, it was irresponsible of the documentary makers not including more Sikh speakers and the bias views shown incited hatred and ill feeling against Sikhs.
3. The documentary overlooked the disproportionate contribution and sacrifice of Sikhs for the independence movement as well as failing to explaining the position of Sikhs prior to the British invasion/annex of Panjab was mischievous to say the least. On the other hand it focused on the Muslim League and Congress Party contributions.
4. The documentary portrayed the British as a concerned innocent party throughout the programme, which was very patronizing, hypocritical and offensive. Prior to the British invasion of Panjab, the Sikhs had achieved communal harmony in the Panjab under Maharaja Ranjit Singh. However, 100 years of the British Raaj and the British policy of "Divide and Rule" led to communal in fighting as shown in the programme.
5. Master Tara Singh and Mr. Baldev Singh were only mentioned in minor detail. The documentary failed to even mention whom Baldev Singh was, his background and proposal. The proposal of a Sikh independent state was not mentioned and how the Congress made promises of the Sikhs of full autonomy and sovereignty in the independent India.
In conclusion the documentary makers did a praise-worthy job in compiling the programme together and efforts to make a balanced account of history, however the Sikh community are disappointed and hurt by the bias and misrepresentation shown in the programme, which undoubtedly invokes ill feeling and racial hatred against Sikhs in viewers who are unaware of the reality.
I would urge the documentary makers to make an apology to the Sikh Community for indirectly invoking racial hatred against Sikhs through the poor documentation of the programme, and in future documentary makers produce a more representative, unbiased and wholesome account of historical events.
I await a reply.
Kind regards[/quote]
Benti - The more people that complain to Ofcom and Channel 4, the more seriously television producers will take in account the Sikh Opinion. It may seem "minor" or "small issue" to some, however, if this goes unnoticed it allows more misrepresentation and more bias in the future. Best to nip the issue in the bud.
To make a complaint:
[url=http://help.channel4.com/SRVS/CGI-BIN/WEBCGI.EXE?New,Kb=C4_Author,Company={2EA1BB9C-510E-44A5-A481-01EB1DDA1669},T=CONTACT_VE,VARSET_TITLE=General]Channel4 Complaint Form[/url]
[url=http://www.ofcom.org.uk/complain/progs/specific/?itemid=286480]Complain to Ofcom[/url]
Details of the Programme:
Programme title: [i]PARTITION: The Last Days of the Raj
[/i]Date(s) & time(s) of broadcast: [i]12/03/07, 9pm to 10.30pm[/i]
Channel / station: [i]Channel 4[/i]
Bhul Chuk Maaf.
Manvir Singh
Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?
High Spirits · 14 Mar 2007
I used Manvir Singhs template because it was excellent and have also logged a complaint.
Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?
Satwinder Singh Khalsa · 14 Mar 2007
Please sangat jee, send them complaints as many as we can. I just send it. It is very important to raise this issue with people who made this documentary, so that in future they don't present such a biased and irresponsible account of Sikh history.
[%sig%]
Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?
sloughsingh · 18 Mar 2007
If the British picked their own four to represent the sikhs then how can any of you be so blind not to see that the british governments intention was to screw the sikhs.....you would have to be pretty ignorant.....they sure got revenge on us for causing them such problems but hey I love karmic law because they are reaping the rewards in plentiful supply of their creation of pakistan...ha ha ha
Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?
SilentElegance · 21 Apr 2007
There is a lot of confused debate here.
For whatever, the responses from the Sikhs and master tara Singh were a RESPONSES TO muslims attacks and killings for Sikhs.
It is unthinkble that a mere 2,000,000 Sikhs west of lahore were in any position to commit atrocities upon the 18,000,000 muslims.
The channel 4 programme was manipulated by a muslim flavour in its presentation , there is no doubt about that.
It spoke of Sikh militia launching attacks in the first instance...this is cannot be further from truth- as the Sikh militia reffered to -Akal sena came into force in response to muslim leaguers attacks.It was mainly to organise Sikh for self defense- not an offensive force.
The attacks and killings in muslim dominated areas like NWFP and Hazara began long before master tara Singh raised his sword.
Later atrocities were committed on both sides, but this does not abolish any responsibility of the initial perpetraters who started this.That is the point.
Sikh leadership was not poor, but not in any position to carry out actions or programmes or apply heavy pressure upon the brit adminsitration, as the Sikh numbers were in the minority.Simple.
The hindus and ,muslims had the numbers game on their side.The sikhs did not.sadly, we also did not have a sea coast line- which would have made a difference as in israel.
[%sig%]