Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Katha!

Katha!

gupt · 11 Mar 2007

vjkk vjkf i wanted people's views on katha, we are all missing this in our jeevan Katha = Father Keertan = Mother Satguru Jee Says The Following About Katha har a(n)mrith kathhaa saraesatt ootham gur bachanee sehajae chaakhee || Through the Guru's Teachings, they intuitively taste the sublime, exquisite and ambrosial sermon of the Lord. kathhaa sunath mal sagalee khovai || Hearing Your Sermon, all filth is removed. bhagathaa naam aadhhaar hai maerae govi(n)dhaa har kathhaa ma(n)gehi har cha(n)gee jeeo ||2|| His devotees have the Support of the Naam, O my Lord of the Universe; they beg for the sublime sermon of the Lord. ||2|| har kee kathhaa ridh maahi basaaee || Enshrine the Lord's Sermon within your heart, bhul chuk marf [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

singh5 · 11 Mar 2007

What is Katha? Is it a Gyani explaining a shabad? Which is the correct Katha? There is samparidaiyee style katha (done by Taksal, Nirmalas, etc) there is Missionary style Katha, and countless other styles. Which is the right one? "har amrit katha" in Gurbani refers to Gurbani itself. Katha of Vahiguru and Katha of Naam is nothing but Gurbani. Har kee katha is only Gurbani. Traditionally katha in Gurdwaras was about Sikh history like Katha of Suraj Parkash Granth or Panth Parkaash. To do katha of Gurbani is no easy thing. It requires someone with experience of that shabad and true spiritual understanding. Not just anyone can do it. For the most part as we see katha today, it is not productive.

Re: Katha!

Khalsaspirit · 18 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, We have to agree with SINGH5 on this topic. If you consider or adopted the Gurbani as your Parent then listen to it very carefully in this "Bachan" which we probably heard million times but never pay attention even for a single instance "SABH TE UTTAM HAR KI KATHA" Which clearly indicates to Gurbani not any man made kathas which we listen these days in Gurudwaras and Deras. Guru Mehar Karey Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Katha!

gupt · 18 Mar 2007

so wot about katha from people who have experienced the shabad and have a true understanding, like Sant Gurbachan Singh, Bhai Randheer Singh, Sant Isher Singh etc.. Wen Mahapursh like these do Katha of a Shabad wouldn't we getter a better understand of wot Satguru Jee is saying and which will lead us to read More Gurbanee & Jaap More Naam and improve our Jeevan as a whole

Re: Katha!

Khalistan_zindabaad · 18 Mar 2007

ALL i want to say is that, at the time of sant baba harnaam singh jee khalsa (rampur khera) when they used to hold abhiyaas camps. . . .Sant Kartaar singh jee & sant jarnail singh jee (later) used to do katha, bhai joginder singh jee talwara (akj) used to do kirtan, all the singhs from all jathas used to get together and listen to katha and kirtan, sooo whats the problem now?????????, the the older gurikhs didint see a problem with ''katha'' then why do we question it????

Re: Katha!

gupt · 19 Mar 2007

mabye because the youth don't understand gurbanee and gursikhi like myself

Re: Katha!

singh5 · 19 Mar 2007

I think that the main point is still not addressed. What qualifies someone to do katha? There really are no requirements. Any person can get on a stage now and start explaining a shabad. For sure someone with giaan and experience of shabad can say a lot of amazing and useful things but these people are rare. Katha of history is fine. It doesn't take anything but giaan to do that. But to do katha of a shabad requires some spiritual experience of it, which isn't as easy to come by. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written on this issue and says that katha of Vahiguru is Keertan. Katha is possible by spiritual Gursikhs but these people are not common.

Re: Katha!

Khalistan_zindabaad · 19 Mar 2007

however, there are still some gursikhs who can do katha, i can think of several that are still around, who are spiritual gursikhs. [gurbani]ijsih jgwie pIAwvY iehu rsu AkQ kQw iqin jwnI ]2]

Re: Katha!

gupt · 19 Mar 2007

so then y dont people listen to katha if it's from a person who's experienced the shabad nowdays??????

Re: Katha!

Khalsaspirit · 19 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Previous post's quote from keertan Sohila or Sohila sahib answered all. Who attained the "Russ" from Waheguru knows the katha. Now what is "Russ" look into yourself and find out if you or someone else reffering to attained this "Russ" by listening the man made katha. Any way a good topic opened by a Guru piyary. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

gupt · 19 Mar 2007

these are good comments, but i think some with some gyaan can answer this question, as it's a diffcult think to explain

Re: Katha!

peter pedro · 19 Mar 2007

i agree with what khalistan_zindabaad is saying. katha ie explaing of bani and history needs to be dun. ie gurmat veechar needs to be dun at Gurdware and other places. if katha was only Naam Abiaas, then this forum wud not exist, and those ppl who believe this wud not post of forums or even do veechar

Re: Katha!

singh5 · 19 Mar 2007

Katha of Akath Vahiguru is Gurbani. Gurbani ie. Guru Sahib is the only one who can do Katha of Vahiguru. To then further do Katha of this "akath katha" is only possible by a spiritual Gursikh who has experience of the shabad. It's not all that complicated.

Re: Katha!

Khalistan_zindabaad · 19 Mar 2007

ok, listen to this and tell me if you feel anything, http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/katha.php?q=f&f=%2FSant_Kartar_Singh_%28Bhindran_wale%29 http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/Sant_Kartar_Singh_(Bhindran_wale)/Sant.Kartar.Singh--Raj.Karega.Khalsa.mp3 http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/Sant_Jarnail_Singh_(Bhindran_wale)/Sant.Jarnail.Singh--Deh.Dhari.Gurudom.Da.Khandan.mp3 http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/Sant_Harnam_Singh_(Rampur_Khere_wale)/Sant.Baba.Harnam.Singh--Jivan.Katha.mp3 These are katha from puuran gursikhs,

Re: Katha!

Khalistan_zindabaad · 19 Mar 2007

and there are gursikhs who have experience this, if bhai fauja singh was to explain to us the meaning of a sabad would we listen to it???? obviously yes (well then thats katha).

Re: Katha!

gupt · 19 Mar 2007

yeah we wud listen so then thats man made like u said khalsasiprit

Re: Katha!

Khalsaspirit · 19 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, We think topic is going too personal and seems like some people has some intentions in their mind and Guru jane what they have. Some folks are blending some one's experience in "Har ki katha" and dragged the name of 20th century's one of the great Khalsa spirit Bhai Sahib Bhai Fauja Singh ji into this and we are not even close this spirit. I think this topic became more pavitter by remembring his name. And people without the bliss of "Russ" can not understand what the KATHA Guru ji is talking about because unfortunately under Guru the bhana they live by kun(ear) russ I/O Amrit Russ. They manipulate Gurbani to justify their thoughts even. They try to impose their thoughts without even paying attention to what Guru Sahib is saying in that Tuk or Pangti. We still stick to what Guru Sahib said in last shabad of Kirtan Sohila or Sohila Sahib. Which clearly indicate who attained Russ knows akath katha. and khima karna there were and are very few on this planet who attained that Russ. Other wise most of them who claim they are certified Gyani or Kathavachik do not even know what the Amrit Russ is. They are copying the patterns of Christian missionaries who has the mission to convert others. And with lame information they fool the sangat. Yeah discussing GurIthass, SikhIthass is necessary for a Gursikh but the Katha Guru Ji is talking about is not the GurIthass or SikhIthass. As some one’s writing are clearly influencing the five vikaars which can be seen clearly thru Zinadabad murdabad which is way out from Gursikhi, these words never seen in GurIthass or SikhIthass none of the Guru used it none of their khalsas like Bhai Mani Singh, Baba Banda Singh Bhadur, Baba Deep Singh ji, Akali baba Phoola Singh ji and of course Bhai Fauja Singh ji used these. And we have no idea what kind of katha people listen to which make them Zindabad or Murdabad or confuse them what to do instead khalsey used their bol baley and did Saheedi of their minds first with Akath Katha then physical. As Guru Sahib clearly indicates “jisay jagaiy piavay ayhu russ akath katha tin jani” So KhalsaSpirit's final words on this topic is start doing naam simran kamai and experience the bliss then see the difference as enjoyed by those in SikhIthas. This might take this or another life time(s). Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

Khalistan_zindabaad · 19 Mar 2007

Thank you, for your comments khalsa spirit, they are true. . . however certain gursikhs have experienced this amrit rass, therefore can do katha. e.g. http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/katha.php?q=f&f=%2FSant_Kartar_Singh_%28Bhindran_wale%29 http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/Sant_Kartar_Singh_(Bhindran_wale)/Sant.Kartar.Singh--Raj.Karega.Khalsa.mp3 http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/Sant_Jarnail_Singh_(Bhindran_wale)/Sant.Jarnail.Singh--Deh.Dhari.Gurudom.Da.Khandan.mp3 http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/Sant_Harnam_Singh_(Rampur_Khere_wale)/Sant.Baba.Harnam.Singh--Jivan.Katha.mp3 These are katha from puuran gursikhs,

Re: Katha!

Khalistan_zindabaad · 20 Mar 2007

[gurbani]pwrbRhmu hoAw shweI kQw kIrqnu suKdweI suix hir kQw auqwrI mYlu ] sB qy aUqm hir kI kQw ][/gurbani] Some interesting gurbani quotes [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

gupt · 20 Mar 2007

khalsa spirit thats i said at the start when the new question arose but u carried it on, people who have a high jeevan can explain the shabad because they have merged into the gur-shabad end of

Re: Katha!

jassmannn · 20 Mar 2007

This is a very interesting debate. I'm not a scholar or anything, but I think people are being driven too much by passion and mysticism, than logic and reason. Katha can be both talking about sikh history, or the translations of the bani. I think it is important to remember that the bani is there to be understood and like any other languages, or collection of languages, all you need to do it study and read them to understand what they mean. Ofcourse context and understanding will differentiaite, and this is where the simran comes into play, and only by truly meditating bani, is there any chance of an understanding which is above a superficial level. Sikhi and the gurdwara, as well as katha kirtan are all essential parts of the sikh religion. It is ofcourse important that we all read the bani, and the Guru Sahib Ji as often as possible. Then rather than conjecture on the rights and wrongs of a certain type of katha opposed to another or the person relaying their thoughts and translations can be avoided, as we can all try and have a relative understanding, which will only come from reading the bani. [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

Khalsaspirit · 20 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, I think some folks of first grade want to remain in first grade. They can not under stand the graduation or post graduation level knowledge. Again I mention that first grader do not know and would not know what the KATHA means because they are stuck with knowledge level of first grader. Gurbani quotes are used to twist, refers to other websites which are not giving the HAR KI KATHA either just man made KATHAVAN. If you really like these KATHAVAN you hesitate to listen to the SIKH MISSIONARY KATHAVACHIK, NIRMALAY SANT KATHAVACHIK, NIHUNG SINGH KATHAVACHIK, SGPC KATHAVAHIK, BHAI MANI SINGH TAKSAL KATHAVACHIKS, NANAKSAR KATHAVACHIKS and etc etc. They do the KATHA as per your definition and do much better than the website referred to. You hesitate because of your ego under influence of Vikaars as I mentioned earlier. You want to keep dragging the topic fine we will do it until admin close it. What as it very clear some folks want to keeps their antenna down. So giving them shabad explanation has no meaning because they already have their mind set with their pick n choose websites and stuck with ego. We can not do anything. One time I heard from the some one like the that they do not listen to Missionary KATHA because they are too scientific then we said what’s the problem Gurbani is way advance than science then they start bashing with other blames which keeps on going. So the point is some people like these has their own way of doing KATHAS so which one we say is true and which one is false. Another point lets ask all the so kathavachiks on this planet to do their style of KATHA of first five paurees of JAPJI SAHIB I CAN BET YOU Million KATHAVACHIKS WILL HAVE MILLION KATHAS. So which one to believe which one not. If you like (according to your level of knowledge) with one person's KATAHA. You will condemn others. This is what happening in this topic. IF we say sangat jio listen to KATHA BY SGPC and MISSIONARY KATHAVACHIK then you still be upset because you do not like as you stuck with you are stuck with ego. So first thing you should do is reviving your ego and also ask those websites too. Who on Sangat’s money keep spreading lame information and creating divisions by their man made KATHAVAN. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh <ADMIN Note: I think enough has been said. Topic closed unless someone comes up with something that adds significantly to the issue>

Re: Katha!

gupt · 20 Mar 2007

came across this article which will help Katha is the verbal explanation/discourse of Gurbani (the utterings of the Guru's) and our great history. Katha has been an integral part of Sikh practice since the revealed inception of Sikhism by Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee and great Sikhs of his era performed Katha and it was and is still through Katha that many people gain knowledge about Sikhism and become enlightened. Katha is both a spiritual and historical discourse, it endows the listener with spiritual and worldly knowledge, and helps Sikhs along the path of Sikhi. Sri Guru Amar Das Jee enlightens us about Gurbani Katha in the following manner, ਪਉੜੀ ॥ ਹਰਿ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਕਥਾ ਸਰੇਸਟ ਊਤਮ ਗੁਰ ਬਚਨੀ ਸਹਜੇ ਚਾਖੀ ॥ Through the Guru's Teachings, they intuitively taste the sublime, exquisite and ambrosial sermon of the Lord. (SGGS Ang 87) Gurbani Katha is also a form of Amrit, as the teachings verbally expressed in Katha make us reach this sublime stage of immortality. In the same manner that Naam/Gurbani is Amrit the discourse of this Naam/Gurbani is also Amrit as Sri Guru Amar Das Jee taches us in the above quotation. The filth of our bad actions is removed by listening and practising the teachings of Katha, as Sri Guru Arjan Dev Jee explains to us ਮਾਝ ਮਹਲਾ 5 ॥ ਕਥਾ ਸੁਣਤ ਮਲੁ ਸਗਲੀ ਖੋਵੈ ॥ Hearing Your Sermon, all filth is removed. (SGGS Ang 104) Katha is not just expressed on a stage in a Gurdwara, it can exist in conversation and discussion as well, so all the above quotations are relevant if we are promoting the idealogy of Gurbani when we are discussing things. This Katha is described as the most supreme discourse to enter, ਸਭ ਤੇ ਊਤਮ ਹਰਿ ਕੀ ਕਥਾ ॥ Highest of all is the Lord's Discourse. (SGGS Ang 265) Historical Katha This Katha has an equally important place in Sikhi, as it helps to preserve our heritage and reminds of our moral duties as Sikhs and to live up to the high standards set by our forefathers. The majority of this Katha is done by translating the Suraj Parkash Granth written by the Great Kavi Santokh Singh Jee. The Suraj Parkah is the most extensive history of the Sikhs that has been written but it was written approximately a 100 years after the ascendancy of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee to Sachkand. The majority of our history was written by non-Sikhs and even the history written by Sikhs has become distorted and we can only rely on those historical references which are backed by the ideology of Gurbani. Relevant stories are told that fall within the ideology of Gurbani and those which promote hypocrisy or non-Sikh practices are discarded. Historical Katha still holds great importance in what it teaches us, in terms of stories about the Gurus and Great Sikhs of the past. ਸਲੋਕ ਮਃ 3 ॥ ਬਾਬਾਣੀਆ ਕਹਾਣੀਆ ਪੁਤ ਸਪੁਤ ਕਰੇਨਿ ॥ Historical stories relating to our forefathers which are moralistic are narrated by Sikhs. (SGGS Ang 951) [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

singh5 · 20 Mar 2007

It's really sad that it seems there's no dialogue going on here. Gupt and "khalistan zindabad" keep posting the same tuks and same arguments without considering what has been said over and over again. Har kee Katha or Katha of Vahiguru is Gurbani. Same with "har amrit katha" or Amrit like description of Hari (Vahiguru) is only Gurbani. I'll be frank. I myself enjoy listening to the historical Kathas of people like Gyani Pinderpal Singh. I think Gyani Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwale also did great katha of Shabad. But most katha you hear from stages is just "kun-rass" it's intellectual stimulation and maybe even kun-russ with quotations from Persian and Hindi poets and Ghalib, etc. Do you really think Katha by Baba Maan Singh or other corrupt people is "amrit katha"? If you like Katha, great. Listen to it. It's better than watching TV for sure. But it is definitely not the "amrit katha" described by Guru Sahib. That is only Gurbani. You may be inspired by Katha but spiritual progress is only going to come from Gurbani and Kirtan.

Re: Katha!

jassmannn · 20 Mar 2007

Point well made gupt; I think that sums up the debate. There are soo many good speakers, who speak sense, and they don't have to be qualified, they just have to be good, honest people who have understood the bani and can relay that effectively. They don't have to belong to a group, or be well-known. Katha is an aid without which people will not understand the bani to fully appreciate its meaning, so everyone can one day be able to read and understand gurbani fluently.

Re: Katha!

Khalsaspirit · 20 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, As we all agree that Gurbani never contradict in its own bachans no matter came thru, Guru Shahib them self, Bhagats and Sikhs. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- [gurbani]mwJ mhlw 3 ] AMimRq nwmu mMin vswey ] haumY myrw sBu duKu gvwey ] AMimRq bwxI sdw slwhy AMimRiq AMimRqu pwvixAw ]1] hau vwrI jIau vwrI AMimRq bwxI mMin vswvixAw ] AMimRq bwxI mMin vswey AMimRqu nwmu iDAwvixAw ]1] rhwau ] AMimRqu bolY sdw muiK vYxI ] AMimRqu vyKY prKY sdw nYxI ] AMimRq kQw khY sdw idnu rwqI Avrw AwiK sunwvixAw ]2] AMimRq rMig rqw ilv lwey ] AMimRqu gur prswdI pwey ] AMimRqu rsnw bolY idnu rwqI min qin AMimRqu pIAwvixAw ]3] so ikCu krY ju iciq n hoeI ] iqs dw hukmu myit n skY koeI ] hukmy vrqY AMimRq bwxI hukmy AMimRqu pIAwvixAw ]4] Ajb kMm krqy hir kyry ] iehu mnu BUlw jWdw Pyry ] AMimRq bwxI isau icqu lwey AMimRq sbid vjwvixAw ]5] Koty Kry quDu Awip aupwey ] quDu Awpy prKy lok sbwey ] Kry priK KjwnY pwieih Koty Brim BulwvixAw ]6] ikau kir vyKw ikau swlwhI ] gur prswdI sbid slwhI ] qyry Bwxy ivic AMimRqu vsY qUM BwxY AMimRqu pIAwvixAw ]7] AMimRq sbdu AMimRq hir bwxI ] siqguir syivAY irdY smwxI ] nwnk AMimRq nwmu sdw suKdwqw pI AMimRqu sB BuK lih jwvixAw ]8]15]16] [/gurbani] ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Please read the whole shabad again and again and again just focus on shabad and while reading just a little pause on 6th pangti (Amrit Katha) also pause of shabad itself. Then previous quotes from Gurbani bacame very easy to understand. This is benti do not fool with khalsaspirit's wording because we are moorakhs. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Katha!

Admin · 20 Mar 2007

This topic is closed. Please don't post anything further. It will not be approved.