Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Singhnee & Patit having kids?

Singhnee & Patit having kids?

Singhnee456 · 17 Dec 2006

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh! Sangat Jee, I have a problem and would like some advice. My husband has left Sikhi, he is no longer a Singh. No longer see's Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee as his Guru. When we got married, he was a good Singh, but it seems he has had a change of heart. Guru Sahib Jee's hukam I guess. He has been talking about kids lately. But I don't think it is appropriate for a non-amritdhari/patit and a Singhnee to have any physical relations. We both know this. We both want kids (I don't want them now, but eventally) we just know we can't have them together. We could however adopt, but even then he's made it clear that he would teach them what his beliefs are, and that may confuse them when I'm trying to raise them as Sikhs. We are two people going in opposite directions, he is having a negative effect on my Sikhi, and that is the last thing I want. What's the best thing to do? I've been questioning whether it is even right for us to be married anymore, I don't believe a Singhnee and a patit should be married, I believe it is against Gurmat and is completely wrong. Please don't hesitate to reply, even if you have the littlest thing to say! [%sig%]

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

A Singh · 18 Dec 2006

Possibly you can give some time to your husband. There after if no improvement or change in thinking is witnessed possibly you can take a stand whether to continue with your marriage further or not. Forgive me for being a bit harsh in my expression, but in such situations we generally have to take a tough stand. May Waheguru guide you the right path.

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 18 Dec 2006

Can Sikhs divorce? I know one of the given parties is no longer considered a Gursikh, but does this anull a marriage that took place in Guru Jis hazoori? Can Sikhs Divorce for this or any other reason? if so please explain.

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

talikhaak · 18 Dec 2006

Yea, if you are an amritdhaari singhni then you shouldn't have physical relations with him, tell him that you both took an oath in front of Guru Sahib and as amritdhari gursikh couple you will spend the rest of your lives. The punj pyaare will tell you the same that, you can't have relations with him/her unless they seek forgiveness for their mistakes, etc. But like the person above said time is what maybe needed here. Time is the biggest healer and it changes things, so give it some time and see what happens, then make your decision based on that.

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

kulsingh5 · 18 Dec 2006

WJKK WJKF Dear Sister You have asked all the people of this forum to give you advice on a very complex subject. It looks to me that your husband has given up on his faith and has decided to move on; maybe you may have to take the same route and move on. Please forgive me sister if I sound harsh but you are so lucky you don't have any children, this would have been further problems for you both. As I am not an amrithdhari, I might not be able to advice you on what is the correct procedure for you to leave your husband, but you may have to talk to the elders in your family and ask them what action you should take. Yes time is the great healer but in this case you may have to wait months or even years. People in your husband’s case I have seen many, people take amrith and decide "this is not the way". Many of these people stick to their guns and do not change from their decision but in your case it may well be different, time may be your saver. I strongly recommend you speak to an elder form your family or his family and make a decision. May God help you in this time of need. Sathnam Sathnam Sathnam. WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

singh5 · 18 Dec 2006

I think the best thing to do is to get peshed at the next amrit sinchaar and ask the Punj Pyaaray what to do. You are right in thinking that a gursikh cannot have relations with a non-gursikh spouse. I think it would be a great thing if you could influence him to come back to Sikhi. But you married a Gursikh and if that person is no longer in Gursikhi the person you married has died. This is my understanding anyways. The punj pyaaray will have more wise advice but I feel that if after a prolonged attempt at helping him return to Sikhi there is no sign of change, that marriage is over as the person you married has finished.

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

Prabjyot Kaur · 18 Dec 2006

Waheguru ji Ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Bhanji, my heart goes out to you, it must have taken lot of courage to share your dilemma with the sangat. :hug: Since you asked first about having children...It is NEVER for the best benefit of the children whenever there is problems within marriage. Please don't bring any children (adopted or natural) in this marriage until both of you are on same path in body and soul. As far having marital relations, no one but Panj Piyare can only guide you on that. Physical relations create deep bond between man and wife; I don't see how can you stay married to someone who you do not respect or love enough to be in your life each and every moment? If he is okay with the current situation and is giving both of you time to sort out the situation, I would suggest that you also keep patience and do not take any decision in haste. In the meantime, take sharan of Guru Sahib, open your heart to Him, recite Sukhmani Sahib de paath as many as you can; do Ardaas for him. You might want to keep jal by your side while reciting Bani, use that amrit for fixing meals for both of you. You will be giving him the necessary medicine of faith, that he needs now. Be loving, compassionate, have faith in your love and Guru's blessings. HE is the vichola for your marriage; I am sure He woun't let you down. My advice is based on the miracles I have seen happening in similar situations. This is test of your love and faith. Guru Raakha! Prabhjot Kaur [%sig%]

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

Singhnee456 · 19 Dec 2006

Thanks everyone for your help. It's been two years since this has been happening, but we'll see what the future holds, gurprasad. [%sig%]

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

inlovewiththeguru · 20 Dec 2006

Excellent post by bhanji Prabyjot Kaur, Keep faith in waheguru, give him your heart, ask him to take over your marriage, ask him to make you the kind of wife he wants you to be, ask him to give you a new heart, new eyes so you can see your husband through waheguru's eyes. We are all children of waheguru, why should we forsaken our husbands becuase they are not who they where when we married them. Waheguru doesnt forsaken us, he is always there for us and we make such big mistakes. Speak to waheguru as you would speak to your best friend, tell him everything about your situation and what is in your heart and ask him to breath life into your marriage and into your partner. Give all of you to waheguru, and beautiful things will happen .... Only the guru can bring us true happiness. Note to Prabjyot Kaur ... your post was beautiful, i would like to talk to you about it .. perhaps an email address i can contact to you at ... Rab Rakha

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

Prabjyot Kaur · 21 Dec 2006

Virji, (inlovewiththeguru) & Singhnee456...you may write to me at [address removed] Guru Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

dust · 22 Jan 2007

If one person is bad, and is on the wrong path, it is not right to leave that person to their mess, it would be selfish to do that, espeically when you know that the true path is of guru ji, in this case is your husband on the wrong path, so it is your duty to do all you can to bring him back. Why dont we see God in all, all this is God's play, Singhnee ji, God is in your husband as well, do not think of leaving your husband for another. your situation is very delicate, and my prayer is for the betterment of you both. So many posts I see they are condemning the husband wife relations, and i feel sad for you both, because thats how society has moulded you according to their own opnions and dictates. God save you from such society and may you get the true wisdom within your heart.

Re: Singhnee & Patit having kids?

dust · 22 Jan 2007

If anyone got offended by my previous post, please forgive me, i bear hatred for none, I see all of you as my own.