BLIND FAITH AND Sikhi
Canadian Sikh · 27 Nov 2006
Is it wrong to question certain aspects of your religion, or does Sikhi beleive in having blind faith? Thank you for your views.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Canadian Sikh · 27 Nov 2006
Is it wrong to question certain aspects of your religion, or does Sikhi beleive in having blind faith? Thank you for your views.singh5 · 27 Nov 2006
Before entering Sikhi you are free to question everything and anything. Make sure you understand exactly what it is you are getting in to. Once you decide that Guru Nanak is the Satguru and you will follow him and then go form amrit/naam, you should accept every single word of Guru Nanak as the truth. There is no questioning it. Perhaps the interpretation can be discussed or reflected upon, but there should be total faith in everything. In my own capacity however I can say that there is NO contradiction or flaw in Sikhi. It is always an open challenge on my part to anyone to find even ONE.Devil's Advocate · 27 Nov 2006
I think it is good to question everything...that is the only way you get a better understanding of what it is you believe... Sikh means student....and it is the role of the student to ask questions and learn....Roopkaur · 27 Nov 2006
If you have given your head to Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, then how in the world can you question their teachings, because if you can, then your head is not completely given. WHen Sri Guru Angad Dev Ji was chosen to be the next Guru, it was because they had full faith in whatever Guru Sahib said, all others started questioning them. Even when the Panj Pyarey were selected for the first time, it was due to their full faith in Guru Sahib. THe ultimate giving of your head is when you have full faith in Guru Sahib, so that even when they say something that does not seem right or logical, such as when they told Bhai Lehna Ji to eat a dead carcass, or when Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked for five heads, we still have the same steadfast faith in them. One example of this is smoking tabacco. When Guru Sahib first said that his SIkhs cannot smoke it, it probably did not make sense, but now we are learning the extensive damage it does, not just to smokers, but to those who inhale second hand smoke as well. Some people now question the importance of keeping hair, but a day will come when this too will be proven to the rest of the world that it is best for humankind to keep their hair.jay · 27 Nov 2006
I think u can have blind faith, but person u r beleiving shouldn't be blind. I mean he should know all aspects of life and livingand even more, as our 11 Gurus.Canadian Sikh wrote: [%sig%]Seeker of the Truth · 28 Nov 2006
Hold on, so it is wrong to question Sikhi if you are a Sikh? If so, wow! I thought following religion like a sheep was against Guru Nanak Ji's teachings, no?guru_guru_jap · 29 Nov 2006
I dont think Roop Kaur meant that you cannot question about anything if you are a sikh. I also belive that if you consider Sri Guru Granth Sahib to be your true guru and have hundred percent faith in guru then you wont be questioning what guru says. for example, you cannot question the panj kakaars, our nitnem, gurbani etc. we can do veechaar and research to try to understand what they mean and how we can incorporate it into our life and practice what gurbani says. but you can't say 'oh i dont see the need to wear kirpan or do nitnem, it doesnt make sense to me so i'm not going to do it'. have faith, have respect and research, try to learn rather than question. And, if you still want to ask questions, read sri guru granth sahib and do veechar. all answers will come to you.niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot · 04 Dec 2006
One of my friend said this about faith : Faith is a state of openness or trust. To have faith is to trust yourself to the water. When you swim you don't grab hold of the water, because if you do you will sink and drown. Instead you relax, and float. And the attitude of faith is the very opposite of clinging to belief, of holding on. But I have some reservations on this topic , it is this topic exactly that makes sikhi unique .When people say they have faith ,and not belief , their basic premise is wrong : what they mean to say is I have faith (open belief) on something ( god, guru etc.) but dont know why . Hence their faith is actually a belief . And belief without knowledge in any case is "blind". ( but YES when we say Faith is a state of openness or trust. To have faith is to trust yourself to the water.When you swim you don't grab hold of the water----- it is moving towards the concept of "naam" but still not exactly naam) Guru sahib takes us out of this game of faith instead he has given us the cocept of gyan & bhao . man samjhaavan kaarnay kachhoo-ak parhee-ai gi-aan. ||5|| When we enter into the world of the guru the process is very simple :: 1) get the infinitesimally simple yet copletely omnipotent giyan from the guru , which leads to : 2) "bhaow" "naam" "prem" for the vaheguru in every thing and activity we do . Hence the english word faith is inadequate to quench the thirst of gurmukhs. Because faith is always blind but it is only through guru's gyian that the darkness is dispelled and the seed of "naam" is sown. bhul chuk maaf http://niyarakhalsa.blogspot.com/Tanu Kaur · 26 Dec 2006
The entirety of Asa Ki Var is an attack on blind rituals. Guru Nanak questioned everything, because he believed that a direct relationship with the Divine was the only way to get anywhere. Having complete faith in something is different than having blind faith in something. GurFatehonkar · 29 Dec 2006
The sikh religion has scientific base. those who want to go with sikh way must have good indepth knowledge of sikhi. [%sig%]