Guru Nanak Dev Ji May Have Been Visited Istanbul
CharhdiKalaa · 06 Nov 2006
New Research Have put light on new clues that might prove that Guru Nanak Dev Ji visited Intanbul.
[img]http://www.ajitjalandhar.com/20061105/mags/guru_nanak_dev_ji/nn7.jpg[/img]
[url=http://www.ajitjalandhar.com/20061105/]Click Here to Read Whole Story[/url]
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji May Have Been Visited Istanbul
Balpreet Singh · 06 Nov 2006
Although it's very possible Guru Nanak visited Turkey, we shouldn't jump to conclusions about this pillar. Just by the look of it, it doesn't look like it's 500 years old. It looks pretty modern.
I'm also curious why research would cost $50 000.
FAITH MATTERS
Guru Nanak's Turkish connect
Gur Kirpal Singh Ashk | TNN
Patiala: Did Guru Nanak Dev visit Istanbul in Turkey? Maybe yes, going by
what Sikh scholar Dr Davinder Singh Chahal, who is presently living in
Montreal (Canada), has to say.
Until now, there was a Sikh shrine in Baghdad to suggest that the Guru
visited as far as Iraq during the fourth udasi (missionary journey).
Dr Chahal had visited Istanbul in 1994 and saw a pillar 15 feet high and
6 feet wide in a park which had script in Arabic and Turkish language
containing reference of Guru Nanak in its first line. He could not figure it
out that time. This year when he visited Pakistan, he succeeded in decoding
the pillar script with the help of two Pakistani scholars Iqbal Kaisar and
Syad Afzal Hydar.
To do systematic research of the evidence, Dr Chahal is trying to get
help from the archaeology department of Turkey. He has established contact
with the Turkish ambassador in Canada for this project which would cost
around $ 50,000. Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC), on its
part, is ready to extend a helping hand for the project.
SGPC president Avtar Singh Makkar told TOI on Saturday they would soon
send a team of experts to Istanbul to collect the proof. If it is proved
that Guru Nanak had visited Turkey, then it would authenticate some
Janamsakhis which claimed that after Mecca, the Sikh guru visited Egypt and
then from Kahira, he went to Palestine, Syria and Turkey from where he
returned to Punjab via Baghdad, added Makkar.
He said SGPC would contact Turkey's ambassador in India with a request to
help in this regard.
Makkar said SGPC had also requested the British government to return
''kalgi'' of Guru Gobind Singh, chair of Maharaja Ranjit Singh, Kohi-Noor
and other items kept in British museum because these were part of Sikh
heritage.
Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji May Have Been Visited Istanbul
santbirsingh · 06 Nov 2006
Being from Montreal, I can tell you that Chahal, as a scholar, is a joke. The ideas this guy has make Ghagga look like an amazing scholar. One of his more disgraceful pieces of "research" is an article on Ik-Oan-kaar, or as he calls it, Omkar. You can read all about it on his website, http://www.iuscanada.com/journal/articles.html