Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

News · 02 Nov 2006

Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira Ex-US President Richard Nixon called Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi an "old witch", according to recently released documents from the 1970s. His national security adviser, Henry Kissinger, said "the Indians are bastards anyway" in the run-up to the India-Pakistan war of 1971. At the time, the US saw India as too close to the then Soviet Union. The US state department has declassified many documents this month on US foreign policy of the time. One key conversation transcript comes from the meeting between President Nixon and Mr Kissinger in the White House on 5 November 1971, shortly after a meeting with the visiting Indira Gandhi. MAY 26 1971 Kissinger: They are the most aggressive goddamn people around there Nixon: The Indians? Kissinger: Yeah Nixon: Sure "We really slobbered over the old witch," says President Nixon. "The Indians are bastards anyway," says Mr Kissinger. "They are starting a war there." He adds: "While she was a bitch, we got what we wanted too. She will not be able to go home and say that the United States didn't give her a warm reception and therefore in despair she's got to go to war." 'Special relationship' The Indo-Pakistan war took place between November and December 1971. The Pakistanis are straightforward and sometimes extremely stupid. The Indians are more devious, sometimes so smart that we fall for their line Richard Nixon It had its roots in demands in 1970 by East Pakistan, later Bangladesh, for independence. In March 1971, Pakistan's military acted to put down the secessionists there. Millions fled to India's West Bengal state. India supported an independent Bangladesh and ties with the US plummeted in August 1971 when Delhi signed a treaty with the Soviet Union that included mutual military assistance in case of war. President Nixon, on the other hand, had developed a "special relationship" with Pakistan's then military dictator, General Yahya Khan. In a White House conversation with Mr Kissinger on 4 June 1971, President Nixon berates his ambassador to India, Kenneth Keating, for wanting to, as Mr Kissinger puts it, "help India push the Pakistanis out". President Nixon says: "I don't want him to come in with that kind of jackass thing with me... Keating, like every ambassador who goes over there, goes over there and gets sucked in." Mr Kissinger then says: "Those sons-of-bitches, who never have lifted a finger for us, why should we get involved in the morass of East Pakistan? "If East Pakistan becomes independent, it is going to become a cesspool. It's going to be 100 million people, they have the lowest standard of living in Asia." President Nixon replies: "Yeah." Mr Kissinger: "They're going to become a ripe field for communist infiltration." President Nixon then openly courted China to try to turn the tide of the war Pakistan's way. With the Indian army and armed Bengali separatists winning, the US on 10 December 1971 urged Beijing to mobilise troops towards India, saying the US would back it if the Soviet Union became involved. China declined and on 16 December the war ended with the Indian army and Bengali separatists taking Dhaka. Exiled leaders had declared Bangladesh independent on 26 March 1971 and, in 1972, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman returned to become the country's first prime minister.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 07 Nov 2006

We know how good indira was when it comes to Human Rights long before Khalistanis came into being. Was it not the Sikhs against Indira when she declared emergency? There was no khalistan demand then? Was Rajiv correct in saying when a big tree falls earth is bound to shake? Was it non-hindus who killed the innocents on the streets of delhi? Hindus blow the trumpet of khalistani this khalistani that why did hindus not agree to have a muslim head of state of undivided india. Who was at the helm of affairs. WITCH's father.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Sitara · 08 Nov 2006

When he meant Indians he also meant "towel heads" like you not just towel wearing bahmans

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 09 Nov 2006

Sitara Ji where did the towel head come onto? Are you a fan of nehru topi?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 09 Nov 2006

"Hindus blow the trumpet of khalistani this khalistani that why did hindus not agree to have a muslim head of state of undivided india" Why Hindus should submit to the irrational demands of Muslims?. Muslims do not believe in co-existence with infidles as asked by their Allah in Quran. So Chadra Ji why do Hindus have problem when sikhs ask for a separate state?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Sitara · 09 Nov 2006

<> Not really, are you?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 09 Nov 2006

Singhjio, Please start looking at the truth. The people who muredered Sikhs after Indira's death were not inspired by Hinduism at all. They all were secular goondas loyal to a lady with no religion of if we go theoritically she was Indira Khan who mischiviously to befool the whole nation took name of Indira gandhi. I feel we singhs are trapped by propganda of Mao, Marx, macauley and Mohammed who blame Hindus for every eveil in India opposite to the truth that Hindus are percecuted lot in India having rights even lesser then Minorities. Poor Hindus do not have control even on their temples. I am not advocate of Hindus here but penalising the innocents for crimes of others is the biggest injustice. Lanlords appointed by foreign Muslim invaders establihsed untouchability in India and we blame Hinduism for that? The same landlords are put in backward casts today(jats yadavas Kurmis etc) and enjoying reservation in government jobs as they are part of secular gang. Let's not get moved by vicious propganda of secularists in India who cleverly blame Hindus for every eveil and get away with crimes perptrated by them. 1984 genocide was definitely carried out by secular goondas of congress loyal to secular congress and Hindus or Hinduism has nothing to do with it. I have met a number of practising Hindus including few RSS families and found nothing but reverence for Sikhs Sikhism and of course great Gurus. Therefore let's stop blaming Hindus for the crimes of `secular goondas' with Hindu names. In India communists also carry Hindu names, seculars also carry Hindu names and many christians also carry Hindu names. Let's not start doing `andher nagri chaupat raja, taka ser bhaji taka ser khaja' and hand anybody in whose nech the rope fitts in irrespective of who committed the crimes. Let's not penalise Hindus for crimes of secular congress goondas loyal to a lady of no religion in practical terms and Muslim lady in theoretical terms.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 10 Nov 2006

chandra Ji So you are saying that a non-sikh will define Sikhs and the needs of sikhs? Do we need Hindus defining the Sikh demands? Are you a Sikh so that you are able to tell the world what a Sikh needs? Are you telling me that when the Anandpur Sahib declaration was made there wasnt any sikh participating in that. ***** Sitara You may call indirectly call sikhs as towel heads as in your first post which you changed to turban wearing sikhs. But remeber it was the Sikhs who saved the bahu betian of loin cloth bhamans from the turks. Have some sharam.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Sitara · 10 Nov 2006

anjaan, You totally misinterpreted the intent of my post. I in no way intended to offend; and if I did, I sincerely apologise. The point I was trying to get across (rather badly) was that Nixon had a dislike for all Indians including Sikhs (who are referred to as towel heads by racist gorey). I simply used to term ‘towel head’ in order to get the point across more strongly. <> I also hope you remember the Hindus that gave safe passage and sanctuary to the Guru Sahibaan and their families.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 11 Nov 2006

Singh Ji, your article is definietely thought provocating and intellectual in nature. But how it is related to Indira Gandhi the lady of no religion and secular goondas of congress who killed 2000 Sikhs in 1984 and mischiviously gangs of Mao, Marx, macauley and Mohmmed blame it on poor Hindus who have nothing but revernce for Sikhs and Gurus. Some of our Sikh brethern also believe the lies of these gangs of Mao, marx, macauley and Mohammed which is very unfortunate. In spite of our differences, I still stand fro the same principle: Divided we fall and united we stand. Devided we fall and United we stand. Sat Sri Akal Ji.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 14 Nov 2006

Sitara Ji thanks for your post ******** <> I also hope you remember the Hindus that gave safe passage and sanctuary to the Guru Sahibaan and their families. ********** We also remeber the Hindoo Rajas who sided with muslamans againsts Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Chandra Ji ******** "So you are saying that a non-sikh will define Sikhs and the needs of sikhs?" I didn't get it. When did i do this? ********* You do it all the time. You are a Hindu arent you????? And I find it very funny how you alll the time on this message board try to paint Sikh identity, religion, needs in your own way. Will you accept a Musla telling you what hinduism is? "Do we need Hindus defining the Sikh demands? Are you a Sikh so that you are able to tell the world what a Sikh needs?" No, but if Sikhs start negating their Dharmic identity and start viewing themself in the image of Abrahmic cults they are no longer sikhs and they lose their right over Gurus and their teachings. Compared to these kind of sikhs i find a idol worshipping Hindu 100 times better as a sikh. ********* Typical RSS giberish. Who are your trying to fool? Idol worshiping Hinduu CANNOT be sikh till the time he gets away from PATHAR PUJA. *********** "Are you telling me that when the Anandpur Sahib declaration was made there wasnt any sikh participating in that." There is long distance between Aanandpur Sahib declaration and Bhindrawale declaring that Sikhi belongs to Abrahmic family of faiths, not Dharmic family of faiths. ******* Which declaration of Bhindrawale makes Sikhi as Abrahmic family of faith. From your posts it seems either you are scared or have a personal issue with Sikhs asserting their demand for Independance.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Sitara · 14 Nov 2006

<> You seem to remember them more than the countless Hindus that have helped you out...Always seems the case with Sikhs these days, always trying to remember how bad the Hindus were to the Sikhs and how good the Muslims were to you.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 14 Nov 2006

Sitara you may be right upto some extent but truth is that average Sikh knows that 99% of Sikhs are formed out of eldest male child being donated to Guru Govind Singh Ji Maharaj. If a Sikh is unaware if this tradition of `eldest brother going to Guru' then he/she is altogather ignorant to Sikhi. bad guys are verywhere in every country in every community. They exist even among Sikhs also. But Hindus and Sikhs are like nails and flash relationship which above blood relationship. Muslims of course smile when they see Hindus - Sikhs fighting among themselves. 1984 anti Sikhs riots are being publicised as Hindu - Sikh riots by gangs of Mao, marx, macauley and Mohammed though in truth this crime against humanity was perpetrated by secular goondas of congress loyal to alady of no religion. I know Hindus can'nt kill even animals forget about the killing the very people who sacrificed their lives(Sikhs) to pritect them from opression of Aurangjeb. Devided we fall. United we stand.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 15 Nov 2006

******* <> You seem to remember them more than the countless Hindus that have helped you out...Always seems the case with Sikhs these days, always trying to remember how bad the Hindus were to the Sikhs and how good the Muslims were to you. ****** Not these days but since the days when sahibzadey were done shaheed. Who was the traitor? Baman!!! At the same time we have our gurudwara buildings named after Dewan Todar Maal so dont try to say Sikhs of today. Who was responsible for the Anandpur Sahib Seige. Pahari Rajey Heard the Sakhi of Pancham Patshah? Chandra Ji ********* "Who are your trying to fool? Idol worshiping Hinduu CANNOT be sikh till the time he gets away from PATHAR PUJA." So Namdev was not a Sikh as well as Prahlaad. ********* Sikh Guru Sahib is Buut Shikan and Pathar puja has been debated earlier. Don you remeber Sikhs dont do Pathar Puja. ******** V.S. Naipaul, in his book, "India: A Million Mutinies Now", provides some intimate glimpses into the minds of some of the actors in the Punjab tragedy. An interview which he heard on the British Radio and which Bhindranwale had given from the premises of the Golden Temple undergoing fortification just before the Blue Star Operation: in this interview, Bhindranwale had said that Sikhism “was a revealed religion; and the Sikhs were people of the Book.” ******** You watch the world through tinted glasses (mind of VS Naipaul). Sant Ji would have said something in Punjabi, some one translated to a Gora in Indian English and the Gora Delivered it in British English. See the authenticity. Do you know when Guru Nanak Sahib gave his sikhs Japuji Sahib???? Then you will know if it was revealed or not? What does Dhur Ki Bani mean?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 15 Nov 2006

Man singh the Muslims in india were hindus at that time so there is common blood there aswell If some hindu was to start going mosque he is no longer a hindu. and a hindu who starts following sikhi is no longer a hindu. Simple as that. First try to find common blood with 22% of population then with the 2%

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 15 Nov 2006

[url]http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/6121084.stm[/url]

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Sitara · 15 Nov 2006

anjaan, You are still reinforcing my point i.e. just focusing on the bad parts only. We already know this. You haven't taken the arguement to the next level

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 15 Nov 2006

anjaan, difference betwen Muslims and Hindus is not merely what you said. it is not merely starting going to Mosque, it is whole whole lot of adopting Arab tribal way of life while Sikhs, jains, Budhists, Hindus etc all lead a way life originated from soil of India. Therefore difference is not merely switching over way of worship, it is switching over loyality from India centric to arab centric. So far as `patthar pooja' is concerned, I don'nt feel any religion on earth can manage without symbols. can you tolerate if Hindus also start calling us sikhi as `kagaj pooja' based on the the fact that Sri Guru Granth saheb Ji is wrottem on paper only? `Patthar Pooja' I feel means pooja without feelings and emotional touch. ie merely mechanical reciations like parrots merel;y by words. True worship is by mana, Vachan and karma. Using objects to explain any type of knowledge is the best way to teach people. Can you teach geometry without pictures or scinec without diagrams. rather we call such system teaching with objects as the best system in the world(Montessary system). I don'nt see anything wrong in `patthar pooja' if it is being done by man karam and vachan and helping people in initiating `pooran jyoti'. If a person merely pays obeinces to sri Guru GGranth sahib ji and just does mechanica Akhand Path without focus mind and emotions Bhagati, don'nt you feel he/she is merely doing `kagaj pooja' and that's what Guru nanak Devi Ji maharaaj opposed and called Patthar Pooja. problem with closeminded people is that they just go for literal meaning of the teachings of great people and follow words and not moral of the story. Let's focus on the moral of the whole story and not merely wordings. If you abuse others , yopu also will get abused this is univesal law. `Kagaj Pooja' and `Pathar Pooja' are not two different things. Basic meaning behind the oppostion of these is we should pray/do Path with mana Vachan and Karam to gain a `pooran jyoti'. If done without mana vachan and karam, neither paper not patthar will create `pooran jyoti' in you. If done with done with Mana vachan and karma even patthar will cause you the same. It is so scinentic and can be verified by anybody who have a soul. Therefore let's stop abusing each others. United we satnd and divided we fall. Remeber 1947, when emergency came Muslim being follower of foreign ideology considered all Indic religion followers and one and kicked them out. Let's learn lessons from History and see morals of the story and not words.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 16 Nov 2006

Sitara ji can you answer who was responsible for sending Guru Arjan Sahib to torture and who was willing to not let that happen?? Man Singh for clarification on calling Guru Granth Sahib equal to symbols please refer to the thread on pathar puja.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 16 Nov 2006

Chandra Ji i made no reference to angels and no gabriel Its you who compares sikhi to muslim, christanity whatever. Not me. ******* You can create your definition of revelation but as per the accepted definition of revelation by Judaism, Christianity and Islam ******** You define revelation based on those religions not me. **** This exactly is the need for revelation through an angel to a chosen man known as prophet ***** Is this the only route for revelation? You have not replied to my question "Do you know when Guru Nanak Sahib gave his sikhs Japuji Sahib???? Then you will know if it was revealed or not?" What does Dhur Ki Bani mean? Remember Khalsa is niara and different from hindu, muslim, isai and whatever. So DONOT equate monothesim of sikhism with that of islam or anything else. We have no devi devta in sikhism but hinduism believes in devi devta. We not scared of shani devta but hindu brothers do puja of shani. See the difference. (you may imply that having no devta we are trying to be muslim but that is your own imagination of a sick mind. **** ethics as an intellectual **** Do you believe that intellectuals are ethical? ******** You can create your definition of revelation but as per the accepted definition of revelation by Judaism, Christianity and Islam there is no evidence of revelation in Sikhi. Gabriel/Gibreel is missing in Sikhism ******* sikh guru sahiban rejected the 2 most common prevalent faiths of their times and here we have chandra singh making us accept the definitions as accepted by other faiths. you are mistaken my friend by trying to segragate sikhism from these faiths cos no one said that we have muchin common with them. its your internal fear of these faiths and that is the reason time and again YOU are the one bringing these into each and every post. guru sahib said ...buut puuj puuj hindu muai turk muae sir nai..... do you think neo-hindus are any better? did you change hindu religion than what was there 500 years ago? ****** His ultimate aim is to find admission ***** You think you are a know all? Hindu ana turku kana......we dont need admision anywhere alrite.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 16 Nov 2006

anjaan , I just tried to give a comparison. People engaged in criticising others should be ready to bear the criticism. I never said if `paththar pooja is good or not'. I simply said that if people call Hindus as Patthar poojaks, are we the follwers of books are ready to bear the tag of `paper worshippers' based on same logic? For a believer, book is not paper. It is Guru. but for a non beliver it is merely another bunch of paper. same way for a beliver the patthar is symbol of God. But for a non beliver is is simple a stone and it is stupid to worship it. Before abusing others let's put us in their shoes to judge if we are saying right or wrong. End of the story is `pooran jyoti'. If Anything is helping you in achieving the level of `pooran jyoti' then respect it otherwise not? I do not know how many of us have reached that stage of `pooran jyoti' but it is for sure that if somebody honestly follows Gurus instructions the person can reach that level. Thats why it is Panth. ie path to pooran jyoti. We are sure about it. But we can'nt say anything about other's path unless we verifie that path as well. Sri Ramkrishna paramhansa Guru of swami Vivekananda reached Pooran jyoti stage by Patthar pooja itslef so did Meera and Soordaas and Tulasi. Therefore let's focus on our spritual development based on path we are sure about. The other paths we do not not know and hence avoid criticism. I usually follow Gur Teg Bahadur and I nowhere found if the great Guru ever criticised patthar poojaks or any other form of worship. In Japji saheb Guru nanak dev Ji Maharaj clearly told that Bed, Puran etc all sing the praise of almighty God only.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 17 Nov 2006

Man Singh I agree with you. Now answer this question of mine in yes or no. i dont need a essay that guru nanak sahib was from hindu family and so and so. Do you think Sikhs are a part of Hinduism or are they a separate faith/religion?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 22 Nov 2006

Deep Ji, what you say is all correct and nobody can deny that. There are four ways to look at idolatory? 1. We start criticising it only because we are a defeated people by Muslims and christians and their preaachers bombarded us with criticism and we also started beliveing in their point and we oursleves strated criticising idolatory. Arya, samaj, Bahamo samaj and many others do it our of inferiority complex. 2. Second aspect is using VIVEK Budhi. Those who have done sadhna know the importance of ekagrata. This concentration from infinite objects to one object is achived bu focussing on Isht Devata or a Jyoti or point or on sound (jap naam) or on breathing etc. Then from one ultimately sadhak has to reach to Zero at mental platform to enetr into spritual domain. Therefore if some sadhakas used Idols of their isha Devata to get some help in their preliminary stages of meditation, what's wrong in it. Of course there may be better ways for the same as you rightly mentioned. 3. Third aspect is simple sceintific aspect. If we can understand mathematics better by using geormetrical figurs of matricies, then why not use these figurs. If we can learn theory behind scince experiment by using pictures and models then why not? same way if somebody used pictures in explaining sprituals truths then what's wrong in it? 4.Forth and the last is that if on oneside we say Akal is present in every object. Akal is present every where. Then we are confirming that Akal is present in idol also and a person worshipping Idol is worshiping akal only. Then where is the conflict? Rather our statement to break the idolas becomes conflicting when we cclaim that Akal is present everywhere? Did ever Guru Govind Singh Ji Maharaaj attacked any Hindus temple only to destroy the statues? I feel its just the matter of temperament. Ultimate goal is sadhana. Whatever tools can help us in that process, let's use them depending upon suitablility. If we take the the things with such rational and scientifc attitude, I am sure all conflicts will be eliminated and our path on Sprituality will be more clearere. If we can atain Bhrahmgyan without idoal, let's do it. If we can do the same with idols let's do it. If we can atain it be breathing or any other chantoing let's do it. Dogmatic things help in building an organisation but not in sprituality. becoming `ekakar with Akal Purakh' is the ultimate destination. If someone limit our efforts only to certain rituals and just do Idol worship, he'll reach nowhere. same truth is applicable to any spritual path including Sikhi. If we simple keep on doing `path' in a mechanical way, we'll reach nowhere. Combination of man Vachan and karam to any of the prescribed spritual paths will give beneifts. Gurmat if of course latest and fastest way to reach the destination and let every human understand.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

singh5 · 22 Nov 2006

there is no doubt that Gurbani calls worship of idols and rocks foolish and wrong. [gurbani] mÚ 1 ] ihMdU mUly BUly AKutI jWhI ] nwrid kihAw is pUj krWhI ] AMDy guMgy AMD AMDwru ] pwQru ly pUjih mugD gvwr ] Eih jw Awip fuby qum khw qrxhwru ]2] [/gurbani]

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 23 Nov 2006

Singh5 Jee what you say is very true for followers of Gurumat. problem is that our whole focus is only on `not worshipping idols' and that's it. Gurbani tells something beyong that as well. The method to lit the `pooran jyoti' and we never bother to progress on that path. same way Arya samajis spend 99% of their energy on condemning the `idol Worship' and merely 1% for their own teachings. Muslims do the same thing. 99% of their energy is wasted on criticisng `infidels' and `kafirs' and merely 1% for islam. Christians are no better. They remembr Devil more then God in their lectures and writings. My opinion is that we should reverse our attitude. let's spend 99% energy on practising Gurumat and try to recah `pooran jyoti' level in place of wasting our time on criticisng `idol worship' or `ido worshippers'.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 24 Nov 2006

Man Singh Ji when hindus say sikhs are part of hindus they should be willing to acccept the title of banaras ke thug (pujaris) and foolish idol worshipers. They accept that and I have no problem them calling sikhs as neo-hindus or part of hinduism

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 27 Nov 2006

aanjan maharaaj ji, I feel a person with exteremely narrow outlook can equate all Hindus with " title of banaras ke thug (pujaris)" and "foolish idol worshipers" Truly speaking Hindus are the real victims of these thugs. I understand among Hindus include everything idolism, non idolism, rituals , non rituals, karma kand, gyan kand and Bhagti. I myself have went through some of the Hindus scriptures as I learnt sanskrit during my school days back in UP state. I found in most of the Hindus Scriptures they : 1. Allow priest but not necessary 2. Allow idols but not necessary 3. Allo rituals but not necessary Therefore all Hindus are not Idolators(Arya samaj, Dev samaaj are examples). All Hindus are not ritualistic. All Hindus are not Priests. I understand that all the above are like models and cartoons for primary school kids to learn fast and just to make religion more intereseting. Real truth deep inside the scriptures is no way much different then Sri Guru Granth sahib as Sri guru Granth Saheb is the purest one. It is like Ph D theses in Sri Guru Granth saheb and kids stuff in Puranas. But if you go on the moral of the story , there is nothing much different.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Sitara · 28 Nov 2006

<> So if someone walks into a Gurudwara and rips up pages from SGGS will does that diminsh the greatness of GuruJi? Do you see the point I am trying to make?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Esher Singh · 29 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, First of all this thread was about Nixon's Dislike about Indians and Veer Chandra Singh moulded the thread into Hindus Vs Sikhs saying :- ........................................................... .......................................................... ....... Chandra Singh:- People like you probably needs to come out of their stupor due to Khalistani propaganda and need to know that for Nixon Indians included Sikhs as well. Also, He didn't hate Indira because there was something wrond with her. It was only because she refused take dictates from Nixon. .......................................................... ......................................................... .......... I ask Veer Chandra Singh where it was written in the post that Indians did'nt included Sikhs, does it mention.No it does not. That article was put there to discuss what the americans thought about indians (Sikhs included as well) and what is there perspective about Indians(Sikhs included as well) today. You have merely twisted the thread into Hindu/Sikh bashing thread. Veer Ji, I ask you a question, Why is it like that when a Sikh talks of separate identity of himself s/he is labelled as Khalistani propagandist? Shall i take it as growing signs of Hindu intolerance towards Sikhs? I ask you onething Jesus was born as Jew , so according to your theory all the christians are Jews? Am I correct here? Prophet Mohammed was not born as a muslim , he started Islam, so according to you all people who people who follow islam are not what they are?correct. We Sikhs do have seprate indentity of ourselves. naa ham hi(n)dhoo n musalamaan poojaa karo n nivaaj gujaaro eaek nira(n)kaar lae ridhai namasakaaro. Veer Chandra Singh ji , I have read many of your post on this forum and majority of them are about Abramic cult vs Indic Cults , this reflects nothing but Islamophobia(Afraid of Islam) and nothing else. We Sikh wants to live in India on equal basis, our forefathers a have served india with their blood and sweat and we also want (we are) to serve India with our blood and sweat , but not living as slaves or second rate citizens and also not like what the RSS/VHP guys say;- yeh to hamarey musalman hain, koi tashkent,samarkand,turkey ke nahin. yeh to hamarey musalman hain, jaisey hmara sirdard,hamari bimari, etc.. Right now it is muslims then it will be Sikhs, and you have started it by saying Sikhs are part of Hinduism [%sig%]

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 30 Nov 2006

Date: 11-28-06 07:05 <> So if someone walks into a Gurudwara and rips up pages from SGGS will does that diminsh the greatness of GuruJi? Do you see the point I am trying to make? Sitara Ji there is no analogy.......we pray FROM guru granth sahib and not TO Guru Granth Sahib. Hindus pray TO devi dont they....so the devi cannot save the hindus simple as that.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 30 Nov 2006

aanjan your posts are confusing me. As per my know;edge about Hindus they do not pray to statue of devi. Staue is simply a symbol made of stones similar to SGGS made of paper and ink. Hindus as I know pary : "ya devi sarva bhuteshu shakti rupena sansthita namastasyaye namastasyaye namastasyaye namo namah" "sarva swaroope sarveshe sarva shakti samavite, bhayebhyasatrahi no devi durge devi namostute" Of course they stand in front of a stature but pary that they salute the universal power of wahe guru that exist in each and every particle of the universe. Inttectual power(sarasawati), economic power (laxmi), Phyisical power (Shakti), devotional power (Bhakti) all are absolute. Only to explain to the people symbols are used. Exactly the way `dot' is used to explain the `point' in a geometry class though true definition of a point is an entity which do not have any dimesnion(no length no with no depth). But professor usese . symbol which is an approximate representation to explain to human minds what geormetry is. This is the only difference between formless God and God with form. This is well prooves fact today that story telling and usage of physical objects is the best way to teach around the globe. If our forefathers used these techniques 5000 years ago from now, we should be proud of it in place of being ashamed? Should we feel ashamed why a Professor used . to explain Point in geometry only because true definition of point of entity without length breath and depth? Let's be careful while downgrading others. Sometimes it prooves our own ignorance about other faiths. Muslims and christians are usually like that(Ignorant) and they see nothing beyong Idolatory, castism, untouchability and Sati whenever qustion of Hinduism or any Indian religion comes in to picture.

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Esher Singh · 30 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, ........................................................................................................................... Chandra Singh:- Because urge for this seperate identity is result psychology of imitation, born out of inferiority complex viz a viz monotheist cults. The fact is that it is not the old Sikhism of the Gurus but a new version of it which has been taking shape under the impact of very different ideological and political forces that is being pursued by Khalistanis. .......................................................................................................................... As i have stated earlier naa ham hi(n)dhoo n musalamaan poojaa karo n nivaaj gujaaro eaek nira(n)kaar lae ridhai namasakaaro Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Ang 1136 So seprate identity has been given to us by our Guru Sahiban's not by any Khalistani propogandist. There is no inferority complex among us but rather we are proud our history which full of valour,courage and its stand againest tyranny. Sikh fought againest tyranny and will continue to fight againest tyranny. Then it was Muslim rulers and now it is Hindu rulers. Fighting Muslim rulers was easier when compared to Hindu rulers , the reason for this is the Muslim rulers will openly state that SIKH is enemy of the state whereas Hindu rulers will never say it yet they undertake activities to undermine and destroy Sikhs and Sikhi. I ask you all who come to this forum few questions :- 1) Why Anand Marriage act 1905 was abolished? If the answer is for unity of the country then, why there is Hindu Marriage Act, Muslim marriage act , why don't we have Indian marriage act which will be common to all whether s/he is Hindu,Sikh,Muslim,Christian or somebody else? 2) Why Bhakhra Beas Mangement board (BBMB) , which manages the irrigation and electricity of Bhakhra-Nangal Dam is under central goverment instead of Punjab goverment? I do not find any other Dam , rights of water distribution under central goverment in any other state. Is it because Indian government does not trust SIKHS? Mind it ,BBMB was created way back in 1960's when there was no such thing as Khalistani thing. 3) Why Hindus residing in Punjab deaclared their mother tongue as Hindi in 1961 census whereas they still speak,write Punjabi? Right it is happening again but this time around it is Dalits from all over India who wants to state their mother tongue as "English" and the Indian state is denying this to them? I ask you why if something is againest Sikhs it good for the country but if the same thing happens againest Hindus it becomes Anti-national? [%sig%]

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

aanjan · 01 Dec 2006

man ji so you are saying that hindus of today are not hindus? my question is who are they who call on devima to protect them?

Re: Nixon's dislike of 'witch' Indira & Indians

Man Singh · 04 Dec 2006

aanjan maharaaj ji, the type of questions you are raising are those who never do sadhana. Those who ever tried to reach God and do little bit efforts and read scriptures will never ask such questions. Hindus scriptures describe God as `sat chit anand ghan' and entity beyong name and form. Ganesh Puran calls that entity as Ganesh with same qualities. Devi Puran calls the same entity as devi and Vishnu Puran calls the same entity as Vishnu. Shiva Puran calls it as shiva. The entity is the same. Steps to reach this entity is the same no matter which panth you follow.( I am not sure of abrahmic religions can be considered as path to God and can be called as panth). Khalsa panth is the purest panth to reach that entity. The Devi Hindis call for help is the same Power of God. Now what's name and form of that power is olely depents on the mental state of the caller. I don'nt see anything wrong in idol worshipping if an idol helps somebody to focus and meditate. Of course Khalasa do not recommend it. Many great saints and seers who saw God and described in words their forms whatever they saw . If an artist or sculptur makes a picture based on those words, it should be taken as a proof that God exists and can be seen as I can see you and you can see me. I wonder why should we join the band wagon of abrahmic religions in condemning or defending Idolatory. What's wrong in it if helps in somedoby'd sadhna? Who are we to Judge its utility. Let the person using this techniqi judge its unitility. So far Devi;s description is concerned : `sarva swaroope sarveshe sarva shakti samanvite' if a caller calls `budhi', `shakti', `laxmi' `saraswati' and any other form of shakti for help, what's wrong in it? me and you also use our shakti when in trouble. God and God's power these two things are same, are different at the same time. It depends of condition of our minds. Entity is the sa,e