Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Singh · 27 Oct 2006

Australia Muslim cleric suspended Australia's top Muslim cleric has been barred from preaching for up to three months, after comparing immodestly dressed women to "uncovered meat". Sheikh Taj el-Din al-Hilali's comments, suggesting that women who did not wear a headscarf attracted sexual assault, have caused a storm of protest. Sydney's mosque association said the suspension would give the cleric time to consider the impact of his words. But Australian Premier John Howard said the action was insufficient. Many people - including some Muslim leaders - have called for the cleric to be dismissed from office. Sheikh Hilali sparked more controversy on Friday when, asked by reporters if he would resign, he responded: "After we clean the world of the White House first." His comments, made outside his mosque in Sydney after Friday prayers, prompted a round of applause from supporters. Apology Sheikh Hilali's comments about women's dress were delivered in a sermon to some 500 worshippers in Sydney last month, during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan. SHEIKH TAJ EL-DIN AL-HILALI Born in Egypt Aged 64 Imam in Sydney Appointed mufti of Australia in 1989 Controversial mufti Australian press furious Edited transcript But it was not until they were published in The Australian newspaper on Thursday that a wave of anger was unleashed. "If you take out uncovered meat and place it outside... and the cats come and eat it... whose fault is it, the cats' or the uncovered meat?" Sheikh Hilali is quoted as asking during the sermon. The uncovered meat is the problem, he went on to say. "If she was in her room, in her home, in her hijab [headscarf], no problem would have occurred," he added. Sheikh Hilali has since apologised for his comments, which he said had been misinterpreted and taken out of context. "I unreservedly apologise to any woman who is offended by my comments. I had only intended to protect women's honour," he said in a statement published in The Australian. "Women in our Australian society have the freedom and the right to dress as they choose," he added. Muslim leaders decided to accept his apology and said that no action would be taken against the cleric. I think what he's done is so unacceptable PM John Howard Send us your views Mosque Association president Tom Zreika said the board was "basically satisfied with the notion that certain statements made by the mufti [were] misrepresented". "We felt the three months away would give him time to mull over what's been said," Mr Zreika told reporters. But many other Australians feel more action should be taken against Sheikh Hilali. "I believe that unless this matter is satisfactorily resolved by the Islamic community, there is a real worry that some lasting damage will be done," Prime Minister John Howard told Australian radio. "I think what he's done is so unacceptable and so out of line with not only mainstream Australian opinion but... mainstream Muslim opinion." "I know how strongly many Islamic community people felt about those comments yesterday, how damaging they saw them in terms of Australian-Islamic relations," added Federal Sex Discrimination Commissioner Pru Goward. "I think the pressure should not be taken off just because he has agreed to be silent for three months." Sheikh Hilali has courted controversy in the past, claiming in a 2004 sermon that the September 2001 attacks in the US had been "God's work against oppressors".

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

singh5 · 27 Oct 2006

What's wrong with the cleric's statement is that he seems to be blaming women for getting raped if they wear revealing clothing. Let me be clear, if a woman is wearing revealing clothing, she should not be surprised that she's getting unwanted attention and lustful looks from men. I think that may well have been the goal. At the same time however it think it's downright stupid to suggest dressing that way is an invitation to rape and we can question "whose fault is it, the cats' or the uncovered meat's?" This seems to suggest that we shouldn't blame the "cat" or the rapist, we should blame the woman? It would be foolish to agree with this. I do not favour women (or men for that matter) dressing immodestly. I think immodest dress does attempt to display the body like meat. But there is NEVER any justification for rape and the suggestion that the "cat" or rapist is not to be blamed is absolutely unacceptable. The message that women shouldn't wear revealing clothing and demean their bodies as show-piece slabs of meat is fine. The message that the "cat" or rapist is less to blame than the "meat" or woman is unacceptable.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 27 Oct 2006

It is not only immodestly dressed people who become victims of sexual assault. And an individuals dress sense, however immodest, is never and invitation to sexual assault. It may be ill advised and in some cases downright stupid to be dressed in certain ways in certain places, but nobody ever asks to undergo such a dehumanizing and heinous crime. People should stop and think before making blanket statements.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

PTE SINGH · 27 Oct 2006

offensive and disgusting remark for all the above reasons.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Man Singh · 27 Oct 2006

There is nothing wrong in his statement if you are living a society of thiefs and rapists. In such uncivilised societies laws are framed in such a way to justify the crimes of rapsists and looters like: 1. If you didn lock your house what's wrong if thief looted your house. 2. If you forgot your gun at home what's wrong if somebody killed you. 3. If you didin lock your car what's wrong if somebody stolen it. In such a society thiefs rapists and killers are protected and owners are blamed fro their negligence. As such theft, loot murder rape are not crimes and negligence is the biggest crime. Opposite to it in a civilised society, theft loot killing and rape are crimes. Though copmmon person should take best precaustions against them. The cleric has insulted the whole motherhood.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Harjas Kaur · 28 Oct 2006

"Opposite to it in a civilised society..." Ouch. I'm afraid America is not very civilized. We have among the highest murder rates in the world, and the majority of victims are women, wives and mothers. In fact, sexual assault here is also one of the greatest in the world. I always keep my kes covered, and dress modestly. I do believe that the way some women dress invites sexual assault. I think this cleric is right. Western societies are capitalistic. Capitalists know sex sells. So the industry sells images laden with sexual overtones and innuendoes. The top entertainers dress like prostitutes, and it affects the culture. Young girls want to dress and immitate them. So they do. [img]http://www.imaginarymaps.com/c-pics/jpeg/samples/britney%20spears%20(5).jpg[/img] You should listen to the song lyrics these scantilly clad young girls listen too and blar publically on their Ipods. (Rap song) Cant turn a ho into a housewife Hos dont act right Theres hos on a mission, an hoes on a crackpipe Hey ho how ya doin, where ya been? Prolly doin ho stuff cuz there you ho again Its a ho wide world, that we livin in feline, feminine, fantastical, women Not all, just some You ho who you are Theres hoes in tha room, theres hoes in tha car theres hoes on stage, theres hoes by tha bar hos by near, an hos by far Ho! (But can i getta ride?!) -by rapper Ludacris http://www.raplyricssearch.com/Songs/2788/ It is the culture itself which degrades women, and thus sets them up to be disrespected and mistreated. Dressing appropriately never hurt anybody. In fact, it shows respect for the God for oneself, and for men. [%sig%]

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Devil's Advocate · 28 Oct 2006

It's not so different from the view of some people that I read sometimes on this web site...

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Balpreet Singh · 28 Oct 2006

Devil's Advocate, would you care to elaborate on that or give an example?

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Devil's Advocate · 29 Oct 2006

I think Harjas Kaur did a good enough job of proving my point. How sad and pathetic that someone would blame the female/victim for getting raped. And in this case a female blaming females. Where is the empathy?? She is basically saying that a rapist does not have those tendencies or urges until he sees what a woman wears. I disagree. If the urge to rape is strong enough, an extra layer of clothing is not going to make a difference. I know of cases of Amritdharee Keskee wearing bibees who get raped (and they are fully covered). I disagree with this view because its blaming the victim, when you should blame the suspect. It puts the guilt on the victim. Its also like saying "If I don't talk with women or stay off chat programs, then I will have controlled my lust." Im sure I could data mine through all the posts on this web site and find enough posts to prove my point on this (but I don't want to waste my time because you have probably read these posts also). No, you won't control your lust if you avoid talking to women. You will just avoid it in the easiest way possible (rather than fighting it head on). This is a view i see a lot on this web site, and this is not real Sikhism. Sikhism is about actively working on bettering yourself. Not passively avoiding something to "better" yourself. Guru Jee tells us to fight our urges head on and control our mind. Not avoid anything bad Just because we avoid something, it doesn't mean that we have fixed the problem. It's like moving a pile of feces away from us and thinking that we don't have to deal with it because we moved it away. The feces is still there and eventually will start to smell really bad.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Balpreet Singh · 29 Oct 2006

I agree with you that a rapist doesn't need an excuse to rape. We shouldn't try to minimize the blame in any way. I don't agree with you take on avoiding problems though. I am a proponent of the belief that people should avoid closeness with the opposite gender. The way to control lust or any other vice is not through putting yourself in situations like that, but an internal battle with the help of naam/bani. I don't understand how someone who has a problem with kaam would be better off dealing MORE with the opposite gender than less. If you know putting yourself in a certain situation could lead to trouble you can't handle, you don't put yourself in that situation. Seems like common sense to me. So going to your example of the "feces" , you deal with it when you have the tools and knowledge. You don't go and start mucking around in it so that you end up soiling yourself.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

**** · 29 Oct 2006

sometimes we may argue with our mind and say to ourselves that if you don't talk to the opposite gender because you will let lust come to your mind then how are you going to concure this thought. By thinking in such a way one would only be causing more struggle to themselves and make following sikhi or hukam uneasy. When a sikhs mind is content then they don't bother themselves too much with these thoughts, they don't push themselves, rather use that time and effort to jaap more naam, with which ones mnd will be content. Then even if at some point you were to have an random conversation with the opposite gender then instead of feeling uncomfortable and hesitant one would very easily with a light mind be able to talk to the opposite gender as brother or sisters. I sometimes really feel the urge to talk to the opposite gender when i see that this person has alot of gian (knowledge) and actually tries to live its life in accordance to gurmat. For me the topic of having to talk to the opposite gender does not become an obstacle because what i see most is that this soul is connected to guruji therefore it makes it easy for me to talk to my brother or sister.

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Harjas Kaur · 29 Oct 2006

1. Amritdharee bibi's who get raped are victims of political oppression by a government intending to hurt and degrade Sikh militants. It is not even of the same caliber as rapes of opportunity. [quote]"I think Harjas Kaur did a good enough job of proving my point. How sad and pathetic that someone would blame the female/victim for getting raped. And in this case a female blaming females. Where is the empathy??"[/quote] 2. The issue is whether modesty or immodesty plays a part in inciting to rape, or providing justifications to a sick mind, or opportunities such as "parties" where males and females are present without supervision. This is relevant since a substantial number of rapes are "date rape" category and take place on University campuses. Provocative clothing, pornographic cultural images, songs, movies set up expectations which are interpreted by assailants as an invitation to rape. Do you think for a moment these images are innocent? Are these song lyrics or movies innocent? And when an innocent girl becomes a victim of an obscene and pornographic culture, the blame is not on her, but on her ignorance and on the commercial manipulations of a sex-crazed society. Doesn't anyone with sense teach this girl how to dress, behave and in whose presence she should be unattended? Because if you remove "rape" from the equation, what you have left is permissiveness and seductive clothing. If a married woman dressed like this and was flirtatious with other men, what effect would it have on the marriage? Without the victimization of rape, this same woman would be perceived as a target to be hit on by loose men. Is the clothing advertising something? Yes, and that is sexual availability and interest. If you want to bring an element of guilt or innocence into the equation, it is there, but will vary from person to person. Some college women want to find a promiscuous partner, and go to bars dressed obscenely to do this. This does not mean she is less a victim to be gang raped. And there are cases where this has happened. But there is something not innocent about the scenario. Same thing with date rape, where they engage in every behavior but intercourse, and then rape occurs because at that point, she said "no." It all boils down to this. People have no morality. And their lack of inhibitions create a society which victimizes us all...and that includes the young men. You can't prevent every bad thing that occurs, and some things happen because of karma. But, you can protect yourself from the evil intentions of others by being a moral and spiritual person far more than you can dressing as a prostitute. [quote]"I think Harjas Kaur did a good enough job of proving my point. How sad and pathetic that someone would blame the female/victim for getting raped. And in this case a female blaming females. Where is the empathy??" "She is basically saying that a rapist does not have those tendencies or urges until he sees what a woman wears. I disagree. If the urge to rape is strong enough, an extra layer of clothing is not going to make a difference."[/quote] Quote my own words to prove your point, don't tell people what you interpret I am "basically saying." Females have an obligation to protect their own honor. This is not achieved by wearing degrading fashions which parade the body in near nakedness to inflame the lusts of dangerous individuals. Suppose an innocent high school girl is walking home alone, wearing revealing clothes, common in her school... and nearby is a man who spends all his time on pornography, like so many serial rapists and killers admit. When he see's this particular girl. He is looking for 1. desirability 2. opportunity. Or have you not done research into rape studies that demonstrate rapists JUSTIFY TO THEMSELVES by the appearance of the potential victim, whether or not this will be thier target. [quote] "The movie was just like a big picture stand with words on it saying 'go out and do it, everybody's doin' it, even the movies.'" (Rapist interviewed by Beneke, 1982, p. 74.) Evidence has been cited showing that many males would like to rape a woman, but that an unknown percentage of these males have internal inhibitions against doing so.... Dehumanizing oppressed groups or enemy nations in times of war is an important mechanism for facilitating brutal behavior toward members of those groups. Ms. U, for example, testified that: "A society that sells books, movies, and video games like 'Custer's Last Stand' ['Custer's Revenge'] on its street corners, gives white men permission to do what they did to me. Like they [her rapists] said, I'm scum. It is a game to track me down, rape and torture me" (Russell, 1993a). However, the dehumanization of women that occurs in pornography is often not recognized because of its sexual guise and its pervasiveness. If males believe that women enjoy rape and find it sexually exciting, this belief is likely to undermine the inhibitions of some of those who would like to rape women. Sociologists Diana Scully and Martha Burt have reported that rapists are particularly apt to believe rape myths (Burt, 1980; Scully, 1985). Scully, for example, found that 65% of the rapists in her study believed that "women cause their own rape by the way they act and the clothes they wear"; and 69% agreed that "most men accused or rape are really innocent." However, as Scully points out, it is not possible to know if their beliefs preceded their behavior or constitute an attempt to rationalize it... Because the portrayal of rape is one of the favorite themes of pornography, a large and ever-changing supply of girls and women have to be found to provide it. Clearly, some women are voluntary participants in simulated acts of rape. But many of the rapes that are photographed are real (for examples, see Everywoman, 1988; Russell, 1993a). In summary: A significant amount of research supports my theory that pornography can, and does, cause rape. http://www.dianarussell.com/pornsrole4.html[/quote] [img]http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/j/msnbc/Sections/Newsweek/Components/Photos/060815_060821/060817_JBenetPageant_wide.hlarge.jpg[/img] 6 year old Beauty Queen Jon Bonnet Ramsey, rape and murder victim. Did her clothing attract the wrong kind of attention? Pedophiles all over the world have been lusting after her images. Something's definitely WRONG with that. [%sig%]

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Harjas Kaur · 29 Oct 2006

[quote]"Scully, for example, found that 65% of the rapists in her study believed that "women cause their own rape by the way they act and the clothes they wear"; and 69% agreed that "most men accused or rape are really innocent."[/quote] Really the issue isn't about how you or I or the young girls perceive their fashions, but how the rapist does. [%sig%]

Re: What's so wrong about this Cleric's statement?

Man Singh · 30 Oct 2006

Please see the third alternative i.e Sikhi From the quotes above, it sounds our minds are trapped in two alternatives only and we forgot our own way of life. American way of life is one pole and Islamic on the other. My point is focussed on Sikhi where womwn is allwed full freedom with decency. Harjas let's come out of our mouse trapp and think about our own culture and civilisational values. Issue here was very simple ie if Official veiw of Islam on women is so demeaning? In all religions of Indian rogin we considered man and women as `Soul' . Our ideal of womn is Mother. Opposite to it in Islam it has become sort of slave and in western world sort of co-wife. I am not saying theer are no bad guys aming Sikhs who mistreat their wives. But this mistreatng can never be the officially justified version in our system.