Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Jagjit Singh · 19 Oct 2006
Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk
From Veil to Kirpan…..
Pyare jio, a couple of days ago Tony Blair made a very dramatic statement with regard to issue of muslim women wearing veils, in his monthly news conference. Due to large number of news stories on that day, many people may have missed this statement. He said it is “a mark of separation”. This is quite a dramatic use of words by a Labour leader, and gives complete backing to the path which has been set by the former Foreign Minister, Jack Straw. Tony Blair is a trained lawyer and has clear intention behind his use of words.
Many Sikhs are disregarding what is happening in UK, as just a “muslim problem”. The daily onslaught on news stories against muslims, is seen by some as something they have instigated themselves, or part of a larger West vs Islam confrontation. Many Sikhs who have grown up in UK, have had bad experiences with muslims, and do lack sympathy for their current situation. We tend to disassociate ourselves from them and are uncomfortable with the word “asian”.
The attacks of 9/11 changed the world. The attitudes in the West changed from being dominant with liberal attitudes, to one which dominated by conservative attitudes. Multiculturalism had flourished in UK, and many ethnic groups won rights which made them at ease with UK. In many areas, multi-culturalism has been celebrated to promote an area. The most prominent being the London bid for the Olympics, in which London was shown as the most diverse city, proud of its ethnic minorities.
However the subsequent attack of 7/7 and the general bad press of Islam have hardened attitudes against muslims. But its impact will be felt by other ethnic minorities, because UK has moved from a stance of “lets celebrate the distinctiveness of others” to one of “is their distinctiveness a threat to social integration?”
For either, Jack straw or Tony Blair to make such comments before would have been political suicide. But they are well aware that these comments are very populist. For example on Radio 5, a national radio station, Jack Straw received 95% support for his stance that muslim women should remove their veils in front of him.
Where does this leave Sikhs?
The day after Tony Blairs comment, the Independent newspaper had a special insert where it compared the muslim hijab or veil to that of the Christian cross, Jewish top cap and Sikh Turban. What we have to wake up to is that this debate is taking place in the arena of Islam vs West, but in fact it is eroding the core principles of multiculturalism. It is now common to hear political commentators stating the multiculturalism has failed in UK. Has it really? I sincerely hope not…
But it leaves the question…If a veil is a “mark of separation” and “makes people outside the community feel uncomfortable” as Tony Blair states, then does the Sikh Turban do the same?
This leads to more questions….Is religious expression a right? By wearing religious symbols are we less British? Do religious symbols pose a threat to social integration?
In the case of veils, Sikhism rejects the wearing of veils. Sahib Siri Guru Amar das ji specifically asked women from muslim backgrounds who attended his congregations to remove their veils, before entering the darbaar. Ideologically, I reject the veil as a means of suitable dress code for a male or female. However, I do feel sympathetic to any young woman who wishes to wear one, but is now seen as an instigator of social disharmony in UK by that choice. These young muslim women are not downtrodden as portrayed in the media. In fact, they are often highly intelligent and confident young women who just wish to physically display their pride in their faith. This is no different to young Sikh men who wear Dumallas (large turbans) and young sikh women who wears Keskis (turbans). My Dummalla (turban) and my beard are religious symbols that make me complete distinct within British society, and this something we are intentionally proud of wearing. I have never seen my dumalla as a threat to social integration, and in fact, I have never had any problems integrating into any part of society.
French Policy & UK Policy?
However what does ring alarm bells, is how easily people are taking the veils issue and comparing it with that of the Christian cross, Jewish cap and Sikh Turban. Many European countries are concerned with the population growth within Muslims, and see that as a threat to social harmony within their country. At times, they are targeting Islam directly, and others indirectly as a response. France has put in place policies which will make muslims a social under-class by denying them education if the refuse to remove the hijab. However they have clubbed Sikhs into this regardless of the contribution of Sikhs in WW1 & WW2. As a result Sikh children are not attending school if they refuse to remove turbans and patkas. This is purely a side effect of a policy against muslims.
In UK, Sikhs are far more secure. Although multiculturalism as a policy is under threat, its impact is probably irreversible. However we do need to look at where is Labour going with this issue of veils? Is there a distinct policy behind the comments of Jack Straw, or is this political pandering to populism rather than political ideals. If it is just populism, then that is far more dangerous than a clear government policy, because then path is out of control, with an un-known destination.
From Veil to Kirpan…
Many people in UK have become used to Sikh Turbans. We do not suffer from the same ignorance as those Sikhs who live in USA, where ever turban wearing person is seen as Bin laden.
However one does wonder if the Veil is so controversial, how long will it take for the media to pick up on the Kirpan? Now that it is open season on religious symbols, Sikhs in UK may well find themselves up against a populist stance by politicians against the Kirpan. Certainly we will find politicians and press far less sympathetic to the religious right to the Kirpan.
Maybe more Sikhs and sikh leaders need to be more vocal on this onslaught against multiculturalism, and see its impact as far bigger than mere Islamophobia.
Is there a Sikh Response?
I feel that Sikhs have always had a problem with coherent communication to the masses about Sikhism. When the “behzti affair” occurred, the Sikh voice was challenged and found lacking. Similar to muslims at the moment, where they have no coherent response to the daily onslaught. In fact, the militants within their ranks have more media coverage, which has just led to a siege mentality within their community.
Sikhs need to organise themselves, rather than wait for some incident to occur, and then wonder what shall we do? There are sections of the media, the usual suspects like the Daily Express and Daily Mail, who have made irresponsible coverage of Sikhs in the past. Even the Telegraph has attacked Sikhs directly.
Sikhs need to set up an organisation like SMART - Sikh Media Action Response Team. An organisation of educated and media savvy young Sikhs who can give a Gurmat Response to all issues facing Sikhs and non –sikh issues in a coherent manner. We can no longer rely on silence, or a Gurdwara Pardan to speak for Sikhs. The world is a different place and Sikhs need to ensure they have a coherent voice. This voice needs to start by assessing the current onslaught on multiculturalism and its lasting impact on Sikhs in UK.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Hardeep Singh · 19 Oct 2006
I think this will affect sikhs across the UK and I think it will come to a time where sikhs are going to have to fight for their rights. I knows its a horribe comment to make, but hard times will come!
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
fresno sikh · 19 Oct 2006
SSAKAL
To the singhs in Canada is it any better for sikhs in Canada long term. Should I make an effort to move there if all else fails? USA may follow them due to the growing hostilities between them and the miidle eastren world and since UK is their main sidekick.
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Jagjit Singh · 20 Oct 2006
- AN ARTICLE FROM ECONOMIST.COM -
THE UNCOMFORTABLE POLITICS OF IDENTITY
Oct 19th 2006
Multiculturalism may be dead, but it's not clear what will replace it
TONY BLAIR this week confirmed what has become ever more apparent in
the fortnight since Jack Straw lit the blue touch-paper with his
comments on the wearing of the veil by Muslim women. The government now
believes that Britain has struck the wrong balance between the
tolerance of cultural diversity and the need for minority communities
to integrate with wider society.
Asked at his monthly press conference whether he agreed with the
suspension of a Muslim woman assistant teacher in the Yorkshire town of
Dewsbury for refusing to remove her veil at school, Mr Blair said that
he "fully supported" it and that he believed the veil was a "mark of
separation". It was time, said Mr Blair, for these issues to be
properly debated.
Thanks to Mr Straw that is certainly happening. The former foreign
secretary and now leader of the House of Commons is the MP for
Blackburn, an old mill-town in the north-west with a large Muslim
population of mostly Pakistani origin. Earlier this year he treated his
friend and American opposite number, secretary of state Condoleezza
Rice, to a tour of the town. Ms Rice was reportedly astounded by the
lack of integration she found there.
As one of Britain's canniest political operators, Mr Straw knew he
would create a stir in revealing he had asked constituents wearing the
NIQAB to remove the veil from their faces when meeting him and that he
regarded it as a barrier to good community relations. But even he has
been surprised by the reaction.
For two weeks, the airwaves and the newspapers have been dominated by
what it is fashionable to call the politics of identity. There is still
no sign of the debate flagging. Indeed, the government seems to be
doing everything it can to keep it going. Last week Ruth Kelly, the
communities secretary, announced that the government was undertaking a
"fundamental rebalancing" of its relationships with Muslim
organisations and that funding would shift towards those which actively
tackled extremism and defended "our shared values".
Ms Kelly was reflecting growing government disillusionment with the
Muslim Council of Britain (MCB), an umbrella body that claims to speak
for Britain's 1.6m Muslims. Ms Kelly, a devout Catholic, took
particular exception to the MCB's refusal to join in the commemorations
of Holocaust Memorial Day. She also criticised both its insistence that
British foreign policy was anti-Muslim and its routine denigration of
police anti-terrorism operations.
Meanwhile, as minister after minister has weighed in on the subject of
veil-wearing, there has been wide coverage this week of government
plans to open up a quarter of the places in newly established "faith"
schools to non-adherents--a measure some see as aimed primarily at
Muslim schools that are now eligible for state funding. In another sign
of the times, an education department document, leaked to the GUARDIAN
newspaper, warned that universities had become fertile recruiting
grounds for extreme Islamic groups and proposed that academic staff
should keep a close eye on their Muslim students (see article[1]).
The trigger for much of this is not the London bombings carried out by
British-born Muslims on July 7th last year, shocking though they were,
but an allegedly much more extensive plot to blow up airliners flying
to America that was foiled in August. Since then, the security services
have reached alarming conclusions about the number of young British
Muslims who have been radicalised and their potential to become
terrorists. Increasingly, ministers believe that the willingness of
successive governments to tolerate and, in some ways, encourage the
separateness of Muslim communities in the name of multiculturalism has
been a colossal error.
The result is that the government has started to ask itself some
profound questions. How far is a liberal society obliged to go in
defending attitudes and behaviour that are hostile to it? Is it
reasonable to demand that members of all minority communities
integrate, at least to some degree, with the majority?
This has traditionally been difficult territory for many on the left.
Partly it is lingering colonial guilt, but mainly it is because the
left is uneasy with notions that appear to claim superiority for
majority cultural norms or which confuse the duties of citizenship with
loyalty to the symbols of nationalism. In the search for a fairer
society, the concept of national identity seemed either irrelevant or
unhelpful.
Those sentiments still exist within the Labour Party, but they are in
retreat. As John Denham, the Labour chairman of the home affairs select
committee, recently put it: "A society with a weak sense of any
cohesive identity will necessarily find it more difficult to organise
and sustain the collective responses that are needed not just to tackle
disadvantage, but the welfare state, crime and security issues that
dominate today's political agenda." Or, as the author Salman Rushdie
observed: "No society, no matter how tolerant, can expect to thrive if
its citizens don't prize what their citizenship means."
AN IDEA OF BRITAIN
Ms Kelly has made a stab at defining "non-negotiable" British
values--respect for the law, freedom of speech, equality of
opportunity, respect for others and responsibility towards others--that
every citizen must sign up to. Steps are also under way to introduce an
inclusive, narrative account of British history to be taught in schools
as part of compulsory citizenship classes.
Both are doubtless worthwhile. But it may be beyond the exhortations
of worried, well-meaning politicians to revive an idea of British
national citizenship that is relevant and powerful enough to do what is
needed. Unless Mr Blair's debate takes place where it matters most,
within the Muslim communities themselves, it is likely only to deepen
existing prejudices.
-----
[1] http://www.economist.com/displayStory.cfm?story_ID=8057937
See this article with graphics and related items at http://www.economist.com/world/britain/displaystory.cfm?story_id=8057611
Go to http://www.economist.com for more global news, views and analysis from the Economist Group.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 24 Oct 2006
"a national radio station, Jack Straw received 95% support for his stance that muslim women should remove their veils in front of him."
If I were a Muslim man, I would believe shooting Jack Straw for saying this would be preferable to the alternative. Especially after the degradation, torture and rape of Muslims in custody in Abu Gharib and Guantanamo, who can believe that western democracies have the best interests of the Middle East at heart.
I don't like what Jack Straw implies. I find it offensive and unnecessarily degrading for Muslim women to be told this publically by this racist idiot.
And there is most definitely a relationship between traditional Muslim veils and Turbans in the West. Both are perceived as foreign, feared, and discriminated against. Let France be an example of the growing intolerance of western countries which don't differentiate Islam from Sikhi. As the Middle East conflicts deteriorate, it will create a prejudicial backlash of hostility in western nations to anyone appearing remotely similar to stereotypes of "the enemy."
There is a difference between our Guruji who is the jyot of Waheguru requesting a Muslim woman to lift her veil in Gurudwara, and Jack Straw.
Is a beard also a mark of separation? What about salwar kameez? Where does the rationale end? When everyone is shaven and wearing western business suit, lightening his hair and skin to appear more euro? Converting to Christianity? A threat against one form of religious distinction is a threat against all. And it is an undeniably racist and intolerant "popular" opinion. I have "friendly" people telling me to take off my keski often. I see it as a wake up call. Things will only get worse. It's kali yug.
http://www.nationalreview.com/nr_comment/taheri200402031111.asp
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2006/10/22/MNGTILTRD51.DTL&type=politics
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 24 Oct 2006
Is this what things are coming to?
[quote]Islamic Leaders Label Woman's Death Hate Crime
KNTV-TV
6:09 p.m. PDT October 20, 2006
FREMONT, Calif. - Fremont police told NBC11 they are holding a man they're calling a "person of interest" in connection to the deadly shooting of a Fremont mother of six....The victim was identified as 38-year-old Alia Ansari.
Fremont police said Ansari, who was walking along a street with her 3-year-old daughter, was shot and killed Thursday afternoon. Ansari was walking to Glenmoor Elementary School to pick up two of her children....
Hamoyon Ansari told NBC11 News that he thinks his sister was the victim of a hate crime because she is Muslim and often wore traditional head wear. Ansari was born in Afghanistan.
Fremont police told NBC11 there is no evidence the woman was targeted because of her religion.
Islamic community leaders met with the Ansari family Friday and joined them in calling her death a hate crime.
"We don't have any other way of viewing this. It's as simple as that. She didn't have a purse, she had no money on her, and this is central Fremont, and how else do we interpret this?" said Hamza Yusuf of the Zaytuna Institute & Academy
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15353603/[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 26 Oct 2006
"Your point regarding the link between veils and turbans does not relate to the UK in any way shape or form."
I live in America, and I get discriminated against. if you think the average Christian westerner distinguishes between a radical Islamic and a Sikh, your kidding yourself.
"I find your reference to murder very disturbing and you should be more cautious about airing that kind of view."
Where the policemen do not obey the law, then there is no law. I find Straw's comments toward Muslim women to be disturbing. If politicians want to promote degrading sexual approaches to women, these attitudes should be tolerated, protected by law? What kind of laws are these which encroach upon and erode people's right to religion and promote prejudice, and invite exclusion, ostracism, violence toward minorities?
There is a lot going on here in the west which is offensive. The way we dress little girls, for example. And the music lyrics and television stereotypes which lead to so many of them being murdered. If a white man says he demands devout Muslim women to raise their veils in his presence, I find his attitude toward them to be a cause for violence because he is deliberately disrespecting them and their community. I am not the only one with this interpretation. It is explosive for Britain to take this approach politically.
History teaches us that words from political leaders can be murderous. To protect a community, sometimes it is necessary to silence offensive words. Right now you think this prejudice does not concern you. You couldn't be more wrong.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 26 Oct 2006
"But to make Britishers convince that we are opposite to evil so caleld Jehadis.There is need for Sikhs to get enlististed in Armed forces or police or Defeance of UK.This will make them a group like Jews in USA."
What if the war Britain and the USA are fighting against Jihadi's is immoral and is radicalizing them and creating a backlash of insurgency? Should Sikhs curry favor and make this bad name a part of ours?
What if the Israelis are creating conditions of prejudice which inflame the middle east? Do Sikhs also want this kind of reputation of injustice and brutality?
[quote]
Apart from showing the heinous damage wrought by the U.S. bombardment of Fallujah, and the carnage to Iraqi people, some of whom lay sleeping, the documentary also uses witness accounts from former U.S. soldiers, Fallujah residents, video footage and photographs, to support its claim that contrary to U.S. State Department denials, white phosphorous was used indiscriminately on the city, causing terrible injuries to Iraqi people, including women and children.
In the documentary a former U.S. soldier who fought at Fallujah comments, ‘I heard the order to pay attention because they were going to use white phosphorus on Fallujah. In military jargon it’s known as Whiskey Pete. Phosphorus burns bodies, in fact it melts the flesh all the way down to the bone … I saw the burned bodies of women and children.
http://last-straw.net/page/2/[/quote]
[img]http://last-straw.net/wp-content/uploads/white_phosphorusbone.jpg[/img]
[img]http://last-straw.net/wp-content/uploads/white_phosphorussleeping.jpg[/img]
[quote]ISRAEL ADMITS USING PHOSPHOROUS BOMBS DURING WAR IN LEBANON
Israel has acknowledged for the first time that it attacked Hezbollah targets during the second Lebanon war with phosphorus shells. White phosphorus causes very painful and often lethal chemical burns to those hit by it, and until recently Israel maintained that it only uses such bombs to mark targets or territory.
The announcement that the Israel Defense Forces had used phosphorus bombs in the war in Lebanon was made by Minister Jacob Edery, in charge of government-Knesset relations. He had been queried on the matter by MK Zahava Gal-On (Meretz-Yahad).
"The IDF holds phosphorus munitions in different forms," Edery said. "The IDF made use of phosphorous shells during the war against Hezbollah in attacks against military targets in open ground."
Edery also pointed out that international law does not forbid the use of phosphorus and that "the IDF used this type of munitions according to the rules of international law."
Edery did not specify where and against what types of targets phosphorus munitions were used. During the war several foreign media outlets reported that Lebanese civilians carried injuries characteristic of attacks with phosphorus, a substance that burns when it comes to contact with air. In one CNN report, a casualty with serious burns was seen lying in a South Lebanon hospital.
In another case, Dr. Hussein Hamud al-Shel, who works at Dar al-Amal hospital in Ba'albek, said that he had received three corpses "entirely shriveled with black-green skin," a phenomenon characteristic of phosphorus injuries.
Lebanon's President Emile Lahoud also claimed that the IDF made use of phosphorus munitions against civilians in Lebanon.
Phosphorus has been used by armies since World War I. During World War II and Vietnam the U.S. and British armies made extensive use of phosphorus. During recent decades the tendency has been to ban the use of phosphorus munitions against any target, civilian or military, because of the severity of the injuries that the substance causes.
Some experts believe that phosphorus munitions should be termed Chemical Weapons (CW) because of the way the weapons burn and attack the respiratory system. As a CW, phosphorus would become a clearly illegal weapon.
The International Red Cross is of the opinion that there should be a complete ban on phosphorus being used against human beings and the third protocol of the Geneva Convention on Conventional Weapons restricts the use of "incendiary weapons," with phosphorus considered to be one such weapon.
Israel and the United States are not signatories to the Third Protocol.
In November 2004 the U.S. Army used phosphorus munitions during an offensive in Faluja, Iraq. Burned bodies of civilians hit by the phosphorus munitions were shown by the press, and an international outcry against the practice followed.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/777549.html[/quote]
[IMG]http://www.rawa.org/child1.jpg[/IMG]
AFGHAN CHILDREN VICTIMS OF AMERICAN CLUSTER BOMBS
""SOME OF the most savage weapons of modern warfare." That’s how one BBC journalist described cluster bombs, the U.S. military’s latest weapon of choice in Afghanistan." http://www.rawa.org/cluster2.htm
[img]http://www.afterdowningstreet.org/sites/afterdowningstreet.org/files/images/Iraq-Today_0.jpg[/img]
Evil Jihadi's? Or corrupt western nations with no regard for human life who are creating civil war, oppression, and a Jihad?
Yes, by all means, to convince racist Britishers that Sikhs are not evil jihadi's, please join them in their wars to protect billion dollar interests against the desperation of impoverished nations.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 26 Oct 2006
[img]http://earthhopenetwork.net/iraq_protest_2-15-03_5.jpg[/img]
[img]http://users.mo-net.com/dreamweaver/war/deadiraqichildren4.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.empiriamagazin.com/Lapsszemle/iraqi-boy.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.ciai-s.net/Iraqi-prisoners.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.tutatuta.com/images/Iraq-baby-1.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20030517/wd4.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.themuslimwoman.org/images/iraqi_women_with_gun.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.tonypierce.com/images/afghanistan/kidgun.jpg[/img]
No one has ever gotten a blessing from giving a curse. What do you think the future will bring?
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 26 Oct 2006
Sikhs can do whatever they want. But there is karma involved in every choice. Both good, and bad. Until there is Khalistan, Sikh soldiers for hire will be just as unjust as the wars they choose. This isn't Khalsa Raj. And it could easily suck Sikh's into the quagmire of hatred and revenge felt now toward the west and Israel.
Soldiers do not pick and choose their battles? Yes, they do. That's why we are starting to see veterans in anti-war demonstrations and conscientious objectors refusing to ship out. Or are you implying some western gora have more morals than some people who claim to be Sikhs? Because if a certain Singh wants to join up, that's his business. but if "Sikhs" as a Panthic force support these conflicts and encourage Singhs to fight, they are giving the karma of opportunism, corruption and evildoing to those whose fight this doesn't belong to. The evil result that comes from all this will be ours to. You can't get away from karma by claiming you were only following orders, or that you didn't personally become enriched when you fought for international bankers and oil companies to profit. I think Singh's should keep their good name out of this. there is a reason the war is going badly and will continue to deteriorate.
A Sikh has an obligation to act according to conscience, to fight a just fight, a just war. Otherwise he just becomes an opportunist, tool, a lackey, another KPS Gil. And a soldier is liable in conscience for the evils he commits while following orders. Didn't the Nuremberg trials teach us this, when the arch nazi war criminals pleaded not guilty for following orders to commit crimes against humanity? Don't you think there is a reason the troops are starting to have mental health issues and breakdowns? It's because their doing something against the conscience.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 26 Oct 2006
"to fight and protect your nation especially one like the UK is an honour."
Thats the problem. This is an illegal war on trumped up, falsified claims. Fighting in Iraq does not protect anyone. In fact it creates a backlash of hatred more likely to cause us all harm. There is no honor in this war. None.
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 26 Oct 2006
"Harjas I beg to differ on source of hate in the minds of jehadis.
I is a big lie that Iraq or Afganistan war have prompted jehadis hatered against west."
There has been Islamic resentment toward the west ever since the creation of the state of Israel which displaced native Palestinians. Israeli human rights violations against Palestinians did little to change that view.
Afghanistan has animosity towards the US for manipulating Warlords in the fight against the Soviet Union precipitating devastation of the country and for CIA breaking promises with them. There is no Muslim animosity towards Sweden, for example.
Iran has animosity towards the United States for siding with the oppressive and corrupt regime of Shah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi for lucrative oil contracts, not to mention the sheer idiocy of the barbaric Arabian monarchy. All these regimes have fired a backlash of fundamentalist reform. Corruption of big business and arrogant western governments have literally shaped the jihad of the Islamic world.
There is plenty more on the table, and it's got nothing to do with Aurengezeb. If we side with injustice against anyone in the world...this same injustice will come to visit us. That is Divine law. At least let Sikhs stand for what is good and right in the world, and against evil by whoever commits it... and that includes our powerful patrons in the West. Otherwise we too are manipulated into being political tools used by wicked governments to do their dirty work, to promote and defend it.
[quote]A prominent national Islamic civil rights and advocacy group today called on the international community to intervene after at least 12 Lebanese civilians, including women and children, were killed in an Israeli attack on a convoy fleeing threats to destroy their village.
The fleeing civilians had reportedly sought protection from UN peacekeeping forces in the area, but had been turned away, according to American Muslims.
In a statement, the Washington-based Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) said:
"The international community must respond to this latest massacre of Lebanese men, women and children by taking concrete action to protect that nation's civilian population and infrastructure from attack.
"Israel has stated clearly, and demonstrated through violent actions, that it is attacking civilian targets in Lebanon in order to achieve a political goal. This is the very definition of state terrorism.
http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/viewArticle.asp?articleID=11667[/quote]
[quote](WASHINGTON, D.C., 7/10/06) - The American Muslim Taskforce on Civil Rights and Elections (AMT), a national coalition of 11 major American-Muslim organizations, today said Israel's continued targeting of the Palestinian civilian and infrastructure is a "war crime" that should be condemned by the Bush administration.
In its statement, the coalition said:
"The Israeli army has been waging a full-fledged war against the Palestinian population, killing scores of civilian men, women and children. These crimes followed an unprecedented act of kidnapping dozens of democratically-elected Palestinian officials and cabinet ministers, including the deputy prime minister. Such acts are nothing short of state-terror.
"The American Muslim Task Force calls on the Bush Administration to strongly condemn these war crimes and demand that Israel stop using American taxpayer-funded weapons to carry out attacks that will only serve to intensify the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the West Bank.
"Israeli aggression against a defenseless civilian population is also a violation of the US Arms Export Control Act, which mandates that American weapons can only be used for defensive purposes and not for violations of human rights.
http://www.icna.org/icna/press-releases/u.s.-muslim-coalition-condemns-israeli-actions-in-gaza.html[/quote]
[quote]"We stood by while this happened"
"Your book details the CIA's relationship with Afghanistan throughout the 1980s, when the United States was arming the mujahedin against the Soviets. Since Sept. 11, we've heard a lot about how our abandonment of Afghanistan led to the rise of the Taliban and the empowerment of Osama bin Laden...
So at the time Bill Clinton was elected president in 1992, Afghanistan was a mess.
It was a real crisis. The war was violent and seemingly intractable, the humanitarian situation was terrible, and efforts to intervene through diplomatic negotiations were languishing...
How distracted were we by the corporate oil opportunities there? There's a whole narrative thread about [the U.S.-based oil company] Unocal going through your book. It seems like a sizable part of the story."
http://dir.salon.com/story/books/int/2004/03/03/coll/index.html[/quote]
[quote]Former Senior CIA Officer: Oil and The Middle East: Why U.S. Foreign Policy Has To Change By Bill Christison
I started out by comparing the long-term effects of U.S. oil policies to a juggernaut. To show you why, I want to go back almost 60 years, to February 1945. In that month, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, while returning from the Yalta Conference, met with King Ibn Saud of Saudi Arabia on a U.S. warship in the middle of the Suez Canal. Two months later, Roosevelt was dead, but this meeting was probably one of his most important acts as a world leader The actual records of the conversations between these two men have never been released by either of their governments, but it is quite clear that an agreement was reached under which the United States guaranteed for the indefinite future the security and stability of the Saudi monarchy. In return, the Saudi King guaranteed U.S. access to, and joint development of, the massive Saudi oil reserves, also for the indefinite future. These mutual guarantees were later, implicitly at least, extended to apply to the other, and smaller, Gulf state monarchies, from the Arab Emirates to Bahrain and Kuwait. All of these guarantees were reinforced by the U.S. war against Iraq in 1990-1991, and these guarantees still today form the basis of U.S. oil policies in the Middle East.
So for close to 60 years now, the U.S. has continued to prop up and support these authoritarian governments. I'd like to give you an example of how this has worked in the case of Saudi Arabia. This is from an article that appeared in The Nation magazine last November, written by a British expert on world security affairs. Here are a few lines from this article. "To protect the Saudi regime against its external enemies, the United States has steadily expanded its military presence in the region. [T]o protect the royal family against its internal enemies, US personnel have become deeply involved in the regime's internal security apparatus. At the same time, the vast and highly conspicuous accumulation of wealth by the royal family has alienated it from the larger Saudi population and led to charges of systemic corruption. In response, the regime has outlawed all forms of political debate in the kingdom (there is no parliament, no free speech, no political party, no right of assembly) and used its US-trained security forces to quash overt expressions of dissent. All these effects have generated covert opposition to the regime and occasional acts of violence"
The United States pursued policies like these not only in Saudi Arabia and the smaller Gulf States, but elsewhere in the Middle East as well. When the U.S. overthrew Mossadegh in Iran in 1953, and reinstalled the Shah in power, Washington began carrying out precisely the same policies in Iran as it employed in Saudi Arabia. The Shah's secret police, known as SAVAK, and the Iranian military forces both grew markedly stronger. For 26 years the Shah's repressive regime succeeded in smothering internal dissent. In 1979, however, major internal dissent did erupt, supported by radical Islamic clerics who wanted all U.S. influence out of their land. The Shah was quickly overthrown. U.S. experiences in Iran since that date should have suggested to people in Washington that just perhaps the strong U.S. support for repressive regimes in the Middle East was not the ideal long-term policy for us to pursue...
Now, in the year 2002, this almost-60-year-old Middle East oil policy of the United States is showing signs of even more fraying at the edges. Beyond any question in my opinion, one of the root causes behind the terrorism of September 11 was this very U.S. policy of supporting for the past half-century and more these authoritarian and often corrupt Arab and Muslim governments. There exists a high degree of anger among many Muslims with their own governments, which have for so long been supported by the U.S.
Osama bin Laden is a good example of this particular root cause behind the September 11 terrorism. His wrath was directed as much against the Saudi government, for example, as it was against the United States...
The U.S. government, from September 11 right up to the present, has made it clearer than ever to the world at large that it will unilaterally decide what actions around the world constitute "terrorism," and what actions do not. Specifically, in the minds of Arabs and Muslims everywhere, the U.S. seems to have accepted all actions by Palestinians against Israelis, including acts against Israeli soldiers as well as those against innocent civilians, as being terrorism. At the same time, however, the U.S. appears to believe that no acts by Israelis against Palestinians constitute terrorism. Arabs see this as a double standard. When, also at the same time, Arabs see their own rulers expressing support for the "war on terrorism" as it is defined by the U.S., their antagonism toward their own rulers intensifies.
http://www.counterpunch.org/christison2.html[/quote]
[img]http://images.abovetopsecret.com/oil.gif[/img]
American Oil Barons bursting with greed
[img]http://www.pbs.org/wnet/wideangle/shows/iran/images/photo5.jpg[/img][img]http://www.wandea.org.pl/IMAGES/ir2.jpg[/img]
Shah of Iran, obscene wealth and brutality which led to religious revolution.
[img]http://www.npr.org/news/images/2005/aug/01/reuters/abdullahfahd_200.jpg[/img][img]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/graphics/campaigns/saudi/KingFaisalweb.jpg[/img]
Saudi Arabian King Abdullah shown next to late King Fahd and beside late King Faisel. Does the west support human rights violations and defend gross corruption for lucrative oil policies? And when rebellions begin, whose side do we support? Hint...it isn't the poor and powerless. But the poor and powerless are starting to overthrow these regimes.
[img]http://www.espionageinfo.com/images/eeis_02_img0571.jpg[/img]
Lieutenant Colonel Oliver North of the CIA Iran/Contra Scandal
[img]http://image7.bubbleshare.com/media/00/13/01/1e/3caaa20bf74653dc65c85e3a031f6fc5/580x435/02_580x435.jpg[/img][img]http://wanderingjew.typepad.com/photos/uncategorized/palestinian.jpeg[/img]
Disastrous Israeli-Palestinian relations oppression with American dollars, American bullets, American bombs, American planes create Anti-western Jihadists
Who wants Sikh sipahi's to become a part of this? These political wars are evil. And evil will come to the West because of them.
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 27 Oct 2006
[quote]He says clearly we should "get ourselves out sometime soon because our presence exacerbates the security problems. We are in a Muslim country and Muslims' views of foreigners in their country are quite clear. As a foreigner, you can be welcomed by being invited in a country, but we weren't invited certainly by those in Iraq at the time.
"The military campaign we fought in 2003 effectively kicked the door in. Whatever consent we may have had in the first place, may have turned to tolerance and has largely turned to intolerance. That is a fact. I don't say that the difficulties we are experiencing round the world are caused by our presence in Iraq but undoubtedly our presence in Iraq exacerbates them."
Dannatt also said the idea that Iraq would be turned into a pro-West liberal democracy and a model for the region was "naive..." -General Sir Richard Dannatt[/quote]
[quote]"the thread was about multiculturalism, veils and turbans in a UK context."[/quote]
The thread was about intolerance of Islamic headress and whether such intolerance could affect Sikhs as well. Since this intolerance is new, and stems largely from the current war in Iraq and radical Islamic backlash, what is impertinent about the issue?
[quote]"I my self did not agree with the war in Iraq on a strategic basis, yet I can find plenty of moral reasons for it. If looked at on a moral issue, as a Sikh, how is it wrong to engage the Taliban that has suppressed human and religious rights in Afghanistan for decades?"[/quote]
So it becomes a "moral" war because you disagree with Islamic government, Islamic history? We have a right to overthrow and force democracy? Christianity? To install puppet leaders? To manipulate regimes? To use terror weapons such as incendiary phosphorus and cluster bombs? How does this bring stability and justice to the region, or do we simply make it worse with pitiable justifications thinking "well they had an evil government and brutal history so they deserve our occupation and plunder of oil wealth. And we are honorable to engage in such self-deceptions" Where is the moral honesty?
The CIA had Saddam Hussein on it's payroll. It wasn't until his miscalculated invasion of Kuwait threatened the Saudi Royal interests that he collided with the American War machine. Further, the CIA destabilized Afghanistan years ago to manipulate a conflict against the Soviet Union during the height of the Cold War. The American military trained the Iranian Shah's terror forces which the Iranian people rebelled against and overthrew in an Islamic revolution. You'd have to be blind not to see the corrupt hand of the west involved in things the public is largely unaware. The UK cannot wash it's hands by collaborating with powerful American interests to involve itself in this conflict.
[quote]"Remember that under the Mughals..."[/quote]
These are not the same souls as the Mughals. And we are not the judge of their souls to condemn their lives today. And these are not even the same historical conflicts or issues. We are not discussing defects of Islamic law or even radicalism, but the fact that the richest militaries in the world are invading, occupying, oppressing and robbing countries they have no right to offend...unless you want sweeping justifications for Western Oil corporations.
Your prejudice is blinding you to accept and justify oppression of third world countries because they are Muslim. I do not see how fighting, shooting, bombing, oppressing Muslims in their own poor countries with the power and wealth of Western Armies will bring any blessing to Singhs. I do not see any honor or justification for it which is not contrived. Why don't you investigate what your own UK journalists are uncovering and exposing about this conflict, and reflect on the wrongness and prejudice it engenders against ALL religion, especially visible artifacts like hijab and turban.
[quote]Martin Bright, Antony Barnett and Gaby Hinsliff
Sunday February 29, 2004
The Observer
Britain's Army chiefs refused to go to war in Iraq amid fears over its legality just days before the British and American bombing campaign was launched, The Observer can today reveal.
The explosive new details about military doubts over the legality of the invasion are detailed in unpublished legal documents in the case of Katharine Gun, the intelligence officer dramatically freed last week after Lord Goldsmith, the Attorney-General, dropped charges against her of breaking the Official Secrets Act.
The disclosure came as it also emerged that Goldsmith was forced hastily to redraft his legal advice to Tony Blair to give an 'unequivocal' assurance to the armed forces that the conflict would not be illegal.
Refusing to commit troops already stationed in Kuwait, senior military leaders were adamant that war could not begin until they were satisfied that neither they nor their men could be tried. Some 10 days later, Britain and America began the campaign.
Goldsmith also wrote to Blair at the end of January voicing concerns that the war might be illegal without a second resolution from the United Nations. Opposition MPs seized on The Observer's revelations last night, accusing Goldsmith of caving in to political pressure from the Prime Minister to change his legal advice on the eve of war.
Senior Whitehall sources involved in putting together critical legal advice on the war told The Observer that Goldsmith was originally 'sitting on the fence' and that his initial advice was 'prevaricating'. This was 'tightened' up only days before the conflict began after concerns were raised by Sir Michael Boyce, the then Chief of Defence Staff, who told senior ministers of his worries. It is believed that Boyce demanded an unequivocal statement that the invasion of Iraq was lawful. It is understood that it was only after seeing Goldsmith's final legal advice, given days before the outbreak of war, that Boyce gave his approval.
Without this legal reassurace, military leaders and their troops could have laid themselves open to charges of war crimes. At the time, UK troops were already in Kuwait poised for an invasion.
Last week, Goldsmith controversially agreed to drop the Government's prosecution of the former GCHQ whistleblower Katharine Gun. Her defence had demanded documents relating to his legal advice, including communications with the Prime Minister.
Although Goldsmith denied his decision to drop the case was political, critics of the war believe the Government was desperate to prevent these details from being revealed in open court.
Menzies Campbell, Liberal Democrat Foreign Affairs spokesman, said: 'These allegations go to the very heart of the Government's case for war, and inevitably its credibility. I have no doubt whatever that if Parliament had been told these things, the Government would not have achieved its majority and been unable to go to war. Public opinion, already deeply divided, would have swung overwhelmingly against the Government.'
Opposition MPs have demanded a statement in the Commons from the Prime Minister and will redouble the pressure for an explanation. The revelations will also increase pressure for the Butler inquiry, set up by the Prime Minister into intelli gence in the run-up to the war, to study the Gun case and subsequent revelations. It will take evidence in private.
Last night former Cabinet Minister Clare Short told The Observer that she knew of military doubts over the legality the war: 'I was told at the highest level in the department that the military were saying they wouldn't go, whatever the PM said, with out the Attorney-General's advice. The question is: was the AG lent on?
'This was a very personal operation by Tony Blair. The Attorney-General is a friend of Tony's, put in the Lords by Tony and made Attorney-General by Tony.'
The Observer has also established that GCHQ, the Government's top-secret surveillance centre, has a specialist unit dedicated to spying on the UN. The revelation will strengthen claims that the bugging of Britain's diplomatic allies at the UN was routine and is likely to trigger a fresh international furore over the legality of Britain's spying operations abroad.
The former Chilean ambassador to the UN, Juan Gabriel Valdes, said last night: 'All I can say is what I said at the time when asked if I had information about spying on Chile and I said yes, it has been proved.
'It [eavesdropping] was one more element of tension during some very tense weeks. Nobody was very surprised. But it is one thing not to be surprised and another to do clearly illegal things.'
Gun leaked a top-secret email published in The Observer last March revealing a joint British-American operation to spy on the UN in the run-up to war. She claimed she acted to prevent the loss of human life in an illegal war.
http://observer.guardian.co.uk/iraq/story/0,12239,1158859,00.html[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 27 Oct 2006
[quote]Fake Iraq documents 'embarrassing' for U.S.
From David Ensor
CNN Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Intelligence documents that U.S. and British governments said were strong evidence that Iraq was developing nuclear weapons have been dismissed as forgeries by U.N. weapons inspectors.
The documents, given to International Atomic Energy Agency Director General Mohamed ElBaradei, indicated that Iraq might have tried to buy 500 tons of uranium from Niger, but the agency said they were "obvious" fakes.
U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell referred to the documents directly in his presentation to the U.N. Security Council outlining the Bush administration's case against Iraq.
"I'm sure the FBI and CIA must be mortified by this because it is extremely embarrassing to them," former CIA official Ray Close said.
Responding to questions about the documents from lawmakers, Powell said, "It was provided in good faith to the inspectors and our agency received it in good faith, not participating ... in any way in any falsification activities."
"It was the information that we had. We provided it. If that information is inaccurate, fine," Powell said on NBC's "Meet the Press" last Sunday.
"We don't believe that all the issues surrounding nuclear weapons have been resolved [in Iraq]," he said.
How were forgeries missed?
But the discovery raises questions such as why the apparent forgeries were given to inspectors and why U.S. and British intelligence agents did not recognize that they were not authentic.
Sources said that one of the documents was a letter discussing the uranium deal supposedly signed by Niger President Tandja Mamadou. The sources described the signature as "childlike" and said that it clearly was not Mamadou's.
Another, written on paper from a 1980s military government in Niger, bears the date of October 2000 and the signature of a man who by then had not been foreign minister of Niger in 14 years, sources said.
"The IAEA has concluded, with the concurrence of outside experts that these documents -- which formed the basis for the reports of recent uranium transactions between Iraq and Niger -- are not in fact authentic," ElBaradei said in his March 7 presentation to the U.N. Security Council.
Close said the CIA should have known better.
"They have tremendously sophisticated and experienced people in their technical services division, who wouldn't allow a forgery like this to get by," Close said. "I mean it's just mystifying to me. I can't understand it."
A U.S. intelligence official said that the documents were passed on to the International Atomic Energy Agency within days of being received with the comment, " 'We don't know the provenance of this information, but here it is.' "
If a mistake was made, a U.S. official suggested, it was more likely due to incompetence not malice.
"That's a convenient explanation, but it doesn't satisfy me," Close said. "Incompetence I have not seen in those agencies. I've seen plenty of malice, but I've never seen incompetence."
http://www.cnn.com/2003/US/03/14/sprj.irq.documents/index.html[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 27 Oct 2006
Any attempt to make the Iraq War into a moral conflict is an absurdity. Just look at the facts! And if you do not believe this degree of hatred and demonism won't spill over and hurt Sikhs and every decent person, you are blind.
[quote]THE GRAY ZONE
How a secret Pentagon program came to Abu Ghraib.
by SEYMOUR M. HERSH
The roots of the Abu Ghraib prison scandal lie not in the criminal inclinations of a few Army reservists but in a decision, approved last year by Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, to expand a highly secret operation, which had been focussed on the hunt for Al Qaeda, to the interrogation of prisoners in Iraq. Rumsfeld’s decision embittered the American intelligence community, damaged the effectiveness of élite combat units, and hurt America’s prospects in the war on terror.
According to interviews with several past and present American intelligence officials, the Pentagon’s operation, known inside the intelligence community by several code words, including Copper Green, encouraged physical coercion and sexual humiliation of Iraqi prisoners in an effort to generate more intelligence about the growing insurgency in Iraq. A senior C.I.A. official, in confirming the details of this account last week, said that the operation stemmed from Rumsfeld’s long-standing desire to wrest control of America’s clandestine and paramilitary operations from the C.I.A.
Rumsfeld, during appearances last week before Congress to testify about Abu Ghraib, was precluded by law from explicitly mentioning highly secret matters in an unclassified session. But he conveyed the message that he was telling the public all that he knew about the story. He said, “Any suggestion that there is not a full, deep awareness of what has happened, and the damage it has done, I think, would be a misunderstanding.” The senior C.I.A. official, asked about Rumsfeld’s testimony and that of Stephen Cambone, his Under-Secretary for Intelligence, said, “Some people think you can bullshit anyone...”
Rumsfeld reacted in his usual direct fashion: he authorized the establishment of a highly secret program that was given blanket advance approval to kill or capture and, if possible, interrogate “high value” targets in the Bush Administration’s war on terror. A special-access program, or sap—subject to the Defense Department’s most stringent level of security—was set up, with an office in a secure area of the Pentagon. The program would recruit operatives and acquire the necessary equipment, including aircraft, and would keep its activities under wraps...
“Rumsfeld’s goal was to get a capability in place to take on a high-value target—a standup group to hit quickly,” a former high-level intelligence official told me. “He got all the agencies together—the C.I.A. and the N.S.A.—to get pre-approval in place. Just say the code word and go.” The operation had across-the-board approval from Rumsfeld and from Condoleezza Rice, the national-security adviser. President Bush was informed of the existence of the program, the former intelligence official said...
Fewer than two hundred operatives and officials, including Rumsfeld and General Richard Myers, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, were “completely read into the program,” the former intelligence official said. The goal was to keep the operation protected. “We’re not going to read more people than necessary into our heart of darkness,” he said. “The rules are ‘Grab whom you must. Do what you want.’ ”
One Pentagon official who was deeply involved in the program was Stephen Cambone, who was named Under-Secretary of Defense for Intelligence in March, 2003. The office was new; it was created as part of Rumsfeld’s reorganization of the Pentagon...
Cambone was a strong advocate for war against Iraq. He shared Rumsfeld’s disdain for the analysis and assessments proffered by the C.I.A., viewing them as too cautious, and chafed, as did Rumsfeld, at the C.I.A.’s inability, before the Iraq war, to state conclusively that Saddam Hussein harbored weapons of mass destruction. Cambone’s military assistant, Army Lieutenant General William G. (Jerry) Boykin, was also controversial. Last fall, he generated unwanted headlines after it was reported that, in a speech at an Oregon church, he equated the Muslim world with Satan.
http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/040524fa_fact?040524fa_fact[/quote]
TORTURE BY AMERICAN GOVERNMENT AT ABU GHRAIB PRISON
[img]http://dahrjamailiraq.com/gallery/albums/abu_ghraib_torture_pictures_images_iraq_war/abu_ghraib_sbs08a.jpg[/img]
[quote]Violating Arab Honor: The Other Prisoners
May 25, 2004
By Bruce Kennedy,
Most of the coverage of abuse at Abu Ghraib has focused on male detainees. At JUS, we have been heading up an investigation into the abuse of female relatives of detainees at several prisons that are allegedly being raped by US soldiers and "contractors" as a means of "softening up" the captives. When photographs of some rape victims turned up on porn sites, we were accused of publishing "fake" shots! Amazing indeed is the naivety of some who think that porn publishers actually "stage" footage. In fact, they stage very little as they can purchase a glut of real rape footage on the black market much less expensively.
Our investigation is now focused on one horrific site. "Sex in war" a Norwegian porn site that appears to have no conscience in publishing pictures of our Muslim sisters as 'Iraqi bitches". We are currently underway filing official complaints with Norwegian police in an effort to force the disclosure of where these disturbing images were sourced from. We currently have allegations that points in the direction of US military and mercenaries based in Iraq.
woman in Abu GhraibYesterday the Guardian published a new report titled "The Other Prisoners" that alleges that woman detainees at the US controlled Abu Ghraib prison are being raped. Originally sparked by a letter smuggled out of the prison a year ago, the allegations were investigated as part of the report issued by US Major General Antonio Taguba in January that alleges images of a US military policeman "having sex" with an Iraqi woman.
Taguba discovered that guards have also videotaped and photographed naked female detainees. The Bush administration has refused to release other photographs of Iraqi women forced at gunpoint to bare their breasts and perform sexual acts.
In addition to our demands for a full investigation into the source of the Iraqi rape shots on "Sex in War", we now also call for the Pentagon to release the photographs of abuse against Iraqi woman at Abu Ghraib on the grounds that footage taken at the prison may have found its way to the Sex in War site.
Here is the Guardians report. Our investigation continues. If you have any information on the rape of female Iraqis, please contact [address removed].
The Other Prisoners
By Luke Harding
The Guardian
The scandal at Abu Ghraib prison was first exposed not by a digital photograph but by a letter. In December 2003, a woman prisoner inside the jail west of Baghdad managed to smuggle out a note. Its contents were so shocking that, at first, Amal Kadham Swadi and the other Iraqi women lawyers who had been trying to gain access to the US jail found them hard to believe.
The note claimed that US guards had been raping women detainees, who were, and are, in a small minority at Abu Ghraib. Several of the women were now pregnant, it added. The women had been forced to strip naked in front of men, it said. The note urged the Iraqi resistance to bomb the jail to spare the women further shame.
Late last year, Swadi, one of seven female lawyers now representing women detainees in Abu Ghraib, began to piece together a picture of systemic abuse and torture perpetrated by US guards against Iraqi women held in detention without charge. This was not only true of Abu Ghraib, she discovered, but was, as she put it, "happening all across Iraq".
a woman confined in Abu GhraibIn November last year, Swadi visited a woman detainee at a US military base at al-Kharkh, a former police compound in Baghdad. "She was the only woman who would talk about her case. She was crying. She told us she had been raped," Swadi says. "Several American soldiers had raped her. She had tried to fight them off and they had hurt her arm. She showed us the stitches. She told us, 'We have daughters and husbands. For God's sake don't tell anyone about this.'"
Astonishingly, the secret inquiry launched by the US military in January, headed by Major General Antonio Taguba, has confirmed that the letter smuggled out of Abu Ghraib by a woman known only as "Noor" was entirely and devastatingly accurate. While most of the focus since the scandal broke three weeks ago has been on the abuse of men, and on their sexual humilation in front of US women soldiers, there is now incontrovertible proof that women detainees - who form a small but unknown proportion of the 40,000 people in US custody since last year's invasion - have also been abused. Nobody appears to know how many. But among the 1,800 digital photographs taken by US guards inside Abu Ghraib there are, according to Taguba's report, images of a US military policeman "having sex" with an Iraqi woman.
Taguba discovered that guards have also videotaped and photographed naked female detainees. The Bush administration has refused to release other photographs of Iraqi women forced at gunpoint to bare their breasts (although it has shown them to Congress) - ostensibly to prevent attacks on US soldiers in Iraq, but in reality, one suspects, to prevent further domestic embarrassment.
Earlier this month it emerged that an Iraqi woman in her 70s had been harnessed and ridden like a donkey at Abu Ghraib and another coalition detention centre after being arrested last July. Labour MP Ann Clwyd, who investigated the case and found it to be true, said, "She was held for about six weeks without charge. During that time she was insulted and told she was a donkey."
In Iraq, the existence of photographs of women detainees being abused has provoked revulsion and outrage, but little surprise. Some of the women involved may since have disappeared, according to human rights activists. Professor Huda Shaker al-Nuaimi, a political scientist at Baghdad University who is researching the subject for Amnesty International, says she thinks "Noor" is now dead. "We believe she was raped and that she was pregnant by a US guard. After her release from Abu Ghraib, I went to her house. The neighbours said her family had moved away. I believe she has been killed."
Honour killings are not unusual in Islamic society, where rape is often equated with shame and where the stigma of being raped by an American soldier would, according to one Islamic cleric, be "unbearable". The prospects for rape victims in Iraq are grave; it is hardly surprising that no women have so far come forward to talk about their experiences in US-run jails where abuse was rife until early January...
A wooden interrogation shed is a short stroll away. As we arrived at the cellblock, the women shouted to us through the bars. An Iraqi journalist tried to talk to them; a female US soldier interrupted and pushed him away. The windows of the women's cells have been boarded up; birds nest in the outside drainpipe. Captain Dave Quantock, now in charge of prisoner detention at Abu Ghraib, confirmed that the women prisoners are in solitary confinement for 23 hours a day. They have no entertainment; they do have a Koran.
Since the scandal first emerged there is general agreement that conditions at Abu Ghraib have improved. A new, superior catering company now provides the inmates' food, and all the guards involved in the original allegations of abuse have left.
Nevertheless, there remain extremely troubling questions as to why these women came to be here. Like other Iraqi prisoners, all five are classified as "security detainees" - a term invented by the Bush administration to justify the indefinite detention of prisoners without charge or legal access, as part of the war on terror. US military officials will only say that they are suspected of "anti-coalition activities".
Two of the women are the wives of high-ranking and absconding Ba'ath party members; two are accused of financing the resistance; and one allegedly had a relationship with the former head of Iraq's secret police, the Mukhabarat. The women, in their 40s and 50s, come from Kirkuk and Baghdad; none has seen their families or children since their arrest earlier this year...
The women appear to have been arrested in violation of international law - not because of anything they have done, but merely because of who they are married to, and their potential intelligence value. US officials have previously acknowledged detaining Iraqi women in the hope of convincing male relatives to provide information; when US soldiers raid a house and fail to find a male suspect, they will frequently take away his wife or daughter instead.
http://www.duckdaotsu.org/the_other_prisoners.html[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 27 Oct 2006
[quote] Secret prison adds to divisions in Iraq
By Edward Wong and John F. Burns The New York Times
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2005
BAGHDAD As Iraqi investigators began sifting through a secret underground prison run by the Iraqi police in the heart of the capital, Sunni Arab leaders on Wednesday furiously denounced the Shiite-dominated government for supporting the torture of Sunni detainees there and called for an international investigation.
The discovery of the prison by the U.S. military has galvanized Sunni Arab anger and widened the country's sectarian divide just a month before elections for a full, four-year government.
The American general charged with securing Baghdad said Wednesday that Sunni leaders were supportive of the American raid on the prison, which began Sunday and ended Wednesday afternoon.
The commander, Major General William Webster of the Third Infantry Division, said his troops were prepared to investigate other credible complaints of torture by Iraqi security forces.
The American raid forced Ibrahim al-Jaafari, the Iraqi prime minister, to announce that the government would investigate instances of torture at the underground detention center, where many of 173 prisoners were found in weakened, malnourished states.
A former prisoner said in an interview Wednesday that he and other inmates, all Sunni Arabs, were regularly beaten and tortured, and he was left blindfolded for the entire duration of his stay, more than three months. The prison was in the basement of a major operations center for the Interior Ministry, in the center of Baghdad, and was reportedly staffed by policemen belonging to a powerful Iranian-trained Shiite militia.
For many Sunni Arabs, the uncovering of the prison and Jaafari's announcement confirmed widespread rumors that Shiite policemen and soldiers were abducting Sunni Arabs and torturing or killing them. The investigation comes at a politically sensitive time here. American officials have been urging the former ruling Sunni Arabs not to boycott the elections, as they did in a vote last January, and to take part in the formation of the new government.
The Iraqi Islamic Party, a prominent Sunni political group, issued a statement Wednesday calling for the United Nations and human rights organizations to "condemn the violations of human rights that the Iraqi government perpetrated, and demand an international investigation to punish all those who were involved in these crimes."
The deputy interior minister for intelligence, Hussein Kamal, said any instances of torture in the prison were not done according to policy. The ministry had begun its own investigation, he said, and the prisoners had been moved to another location for "humane care."
He added that the prisoners were accused of crimes such as terrorism and kidnapping, and that they were arrested with court warrants.
Kamal said he did not know whether the police in the center were tied to a Shiite militia.
For three days, American troops threw a security cordon around the center, a two-story building that was built as a bomb shelter during Saddam Hussein's time. Webster ordered the troops withdrawn Wednesday afternoon after the building had been closely searched and large amounts of documents taken away.
American officers said the documents would be studied by the Iraqi-led inquiry that Jaafari appointed Tuesday, with instructions that its conclusions be reported back to the government within two weeks.
One senior officer familiar with the events that led U.S. troops to the center Sunday evening said the decision to move on the center came after a flow of reports reaching the Americans, including one from a woman missing her 15-year-old son, described the center as "a notorious address" where people were being held for long periods and mistreated.
Most of these reports, the officer said, came from Sunnis.
The officer said the missing boy was not among the 173 detainees found at the center, and he depicted the conditions there in somewhat less lurid terms than those used by some Iraqi officials who gave initial accounts of the place Tuesday.
He said the detainees appeared to have been held in a series of separate rooms, but that the rooms did not appear to have built as a detention facility.
"There were not dungeon cells or those kind of things," he said. "I didn't see any torture chamber."
He said that all the detainees had undergone medical checks, and that while some were taken to hospitals, the reports he had received indicated that none of them were held overnight.
Sabrina Tavernise, Ali Adeeb and Khalid al-Ansary in Baghdad contributed reporting for this article.
U.S. defends munitions use
The Pentagon acknowledged on Wednesday using incendiary white-phosphorus munitions in a 2004 counterinsurgency offensive in the Iraqi city of Falluja, but defended their use as legal, Reuters reported from Washington.
Lieutenant Colonel Barry Venable of the U.S. Army, a Pentagon spokesman, said the U.S. military had not used the highly flammable weapons against civilians, contrary to an Italian state television report this month that said the weapons were used against men, women and children in Falluja who were burned to the bone.
"We categorically deny that claim," Venable said.
BAGHDAD As Iraqi investigators began sifting through a secret underground prison run by the Iraqi police in the heart of the capital, Sunni Arab leaders on Wednesday furiously denounced the Shiite-dominated government for supporting the torture of Sunni detainees there and called for an international investigation.
The discovery of the prison by the U.S. military has galvanized Sunni Arab anger and widened the country's sectarian divide just a month before elections for a full, four-year government.
The American general charged with securing Baghdad said Wednesday that Sunni leaders were supportive of the American raid on the prison, which began Sunday and ended Wednesday afternoon.
The commander, Major General William Webster of the Third Infantry Division, said his troops were prepared to investigate other credible complaints of torture by Iraqi security forces.
The American raid forced Ibrahim al-Jaafari, the Iraqi prime minister, to announce that the government would investigate instances of torture at the underground detention center, where many of 173 prisoners were found in weakened, malnourished states.
A former prisoner said in an interview Wednesday that he and other inmates, all Sunni Arabs, were regularly beaten and tortured, and he was left blindfolded for the entire duration of his stay, more than three months. The prison was in the basement of a major operations center for the Interior Ministry, in the center of Baghdad, and was reportedly staffed by policemen belonging to a powerful Iranian-trained Shiite militia.
For many Sunni Arabs, the uncovering of the prison and Jaafari's announcement confirmed widespread rumors that Shiite policemen and soldiers were abducting Sunni Arabs and torturing or killing them. The investigation comes at a politically sensitive time here. American officials have been urging the former ruling Sunni Arabs not to boycott the elections, as they did in a vote last January, and to take part in the formation of the new government.
The Iraqi Islamic Party, a prominent Sunni political group, issued a statement Wednesday calling for the United Nations and human rights organizations to "condemn the violations of human rights that the Iraqi government perpetrated, and demand an international investigation to punish all those who were involved in these crimes."
The deputy interior minister for intelligence, Hussein Kamal, said any instances of torture in the prison were not done according to policy. The ministry had begun its own investigation, he said, and the prisoners had been moved to another location for "humane care."
He added that the prisoners were accused of crimes such as terrorism and kidnapping, and that they were arrested with court warrants.
Kamal said he did not know whether the police in the center were tied to a Shiite militia.
For three days, American troops threw a security cordon around the center, a two-story building that was built as a bomb shelter during Saddam Hussein's time. Webster ordered the troops withdrawn Wednesday afternoon after the building had been closely searched and large amounts of documents taken away.
American officers said the documents would be studied by the Iraqi-led inquiry that Jaafari appointed Tuesday, with instructions that its conclusions be reported back to the government within two weeks.
One senior officer familiar with the events that led U.S. troops to the center Sunday evening said the decision to move on the center came after a flow of reports reaching the Americans, including one from a woman missing her 15-year-old son, described the center as "a notorious address" where people were being held for long periods and mistreated.
Most of these reports, the officer said, came from Sunnis.
http://www.iht.com/articles/2005/11/16/news/torture.php[/quote]
[quote]CIA Holds Terror Suspects in Secret Prisons
Debate Is Growing Within Agency About Legality and Morality of Overseas System Set Up After 9/11
By Dana Priest
Washington Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, November 2, 2005; A01
The CIA has been hiding and interrogating some of its most important al Qaeda captives at a Soviet-era compound in Eastern Europe, according to U.S. and foreign officials familiar with the arrangement.
The secret facility is part of a covert prison system set up by the CIA nearly four years ago that at various times has included sites in eight countries, including Thailand, Afghanistan and several democracies in Eastern Europe, as well as a small center at the Guantanamo Bay prison in Cuba, according to current and former intelligence officials and diplomats from three continents.
The hidden global internment network is a central element in the CIA's unconventional war on terrorism. It depends on the cooperation of foreign intelligence services, and on keeping even basic information about the system secret from the public, foreign officials and nearly all members of Congress charged with overseeing the CIA's covert actions.
The existence and locations of the facilities -- referred to as "black sites" in classified White House, CIA, Justice Department and congressional documents -- are known to only a handful of officials in the United States and, usually, only to the president and a few top intelligence officers in each host country.
The CIA and the White House, citing national security concerns and the value of the program, have dissuaded Congress from demanding that the agency answer questions in open testimony about the conditions under which captives are held. Virtually nothing is known about who is kept in the facilities, what interrogation methods are employed with them, or how decisions are made about whether they should be detained or for how long.
While the Defense Department has produced volumes of public reports and testimony about its detention practices and rules after the abuse scandals at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison and at Guantanamo Bay, the CIA has not even acknowledged the existence of its black sites. To do so, say officials familiar with the program, could open the U.S. government to legal challenges, particularly in foreign courts, and increase the risk of political condemnation at home and abroad.
But the revelations of widespread prisoner abuse in Afghanistan and Iraq by the U.S. military -- which operates under published rules and transparent oversight of Congress -- have increased concern among lawmakers, foreign governments and human rights groups about the opaque CIA system. Those concerns escalated last month, when Vice President Cheney and CIA Director Porter J. Goss asked Congress to exempt CIA employees from legislation already endorsed by 90 senators that would bar cruel and degrading treatment of any prisoner in U.S. custody.
Although the CIA will not acknowledge details of its system, intelligence officials defend the agency's approach, arguing that the successful defense of the country requires that the agency be empowered to hold and interrogate suspected terrorists for as long as necessary and without restrictions imposed by the U.S. legal system or even by the military tribunals established for prisoners held at Guantanamo Bay.
The Washington Post is not publishing the names of the Eastern European countries involved in the covert program, at the request of senior U.S. officials. They argued that the disclosure might disrupt counterterrorism efforts in those countries and elsewhere and could make them targets of possible terrorist retaliation.
The secret detention system was conceived in the chaotic and anxious first months after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, when the working assumption was that a second strike was imminent.
Since then, the arrangement has been increasingly debated within the CIA, where considerable concern lingers about the legality, morality and practicality of holding even unrepentant terrorists in such isolation and secrecy, perhaps for the duration of their lives. Mid-level and senior CIA officers began arguing two years ago that the system was unsustainable and diverted the agency from its unique espionage mission.
"We never sat down, as far as I know, and came up with a grand strategy," said one former senior intelligence officer who is familiar with the program but not the location of the prisons. "Everything was very reactive. That's how you get to a situation where you pick people up, send them into a netherworld and don't say, 'What are we going to do with them afterwards?' "
It is illegal for the government to hold prisoners in such isolation in secret prisons in the United States, which is why the CIA placed them overseas, according to several former and current intelligence officials and other U.S. government officials. Legal experts and intelligence officials said that the CIA's internment practices also would be considered illegal under the laws of several host countries, where detainees have rights to have a lawyer or to mount a defense against allegations of wrongdoing.
Host countries have signed the U.N. Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, as has the United States. Yet CIA interrogators in the overseas sites are permitted to use the CIA's approved "Enhanced Interrogation Techniques," some of which are prohibited by the U.N. convention and by U.S. military law. They include tactics such as "waterboarding," in which a prisoner is made to believe he or she is drowning.
Some detainees apprehended by the CIA and transferred to foreign intelligence agencies have alleged after their release that they were tortured, although it is unclear whether CIA personnel played a role in the alleged abuse. Given the secrecy surrounding CIA detentions, such accusations have heightened concerns among foreign governments and human rights groups about CIA detention and interrogation practices.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/11/01/AR2005110101644_pf.html[/quote]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 27 Oct 2006
[quote]Secret world of US jails
Jason Burke charts the worldwide hidden network of prisons where more than 3,000 al-Qaeda suspects have been held without trial - and many subjected to torture - since 9/11
Sunday June 13, 2004
The Observer
The United States government, in conjunction with key allies, is running an 'invisible' network of prisons and detention centres into which thousands of suspects have disappeared without trace since the 'war on terror' began.
In the past three years, thousands of alleged militants have been transferred around the world by American, Arab and Far Eastern security services, often in secret operations that by-pass extradition laws. The astonishing traffic has seen many, including British citizens, sent from the West to countries where they can be tortured to extract information. Anything learnt is passed on to the US and, in some cases, reaches British intelligence.
The disclosure of the shadowy system will increase pressure on the Bush administration over its 'cavalier' approach to human rights and will embarrass Tony Blair, a staunch ally of President George Bush.
The practice of 'renditions' - when suspects are handed directly into the custody of another state without due process - has sparked particular anger. At least 70 such transfers have occurred, according to CIA sources. Many involve men who have been freed by the courts and are thus legally innocent. Renditions are often used when American interrogators believe that harsh treatment - banned in their own country - would produce results.
The Observer has obtained details of two incidents in which men have been detained by the US despite being found innocent by courts in their own country. In one, a British businessman called Wahab al-Rami, an Iraqi living in the UK and a Palestinian seeking asylum were arrested by US and local officers in Gambia in November 2002 as they stepped off a flight from London.
Their seizure, which followed a tip-off from the UK security services - came just days after they had been arrested by British police on suspicion of terrorism and then freed by a British court.
Two were transported from Gambia to Guantanamo Bay - where they remain today - without any legal process. In the other incident, two Turks, a Saudi, a Kenyan and a Sudanese man were arrested in Malawi in June 2003 on suspicion of funding terrorist networks. Though freed by local courts, the men were handed over to the CIA and held for several months. Campaigners say these incidents are 'the tip of an iceberg'.
Few escape the ghost network of detention facilities, which range from massive prison camps such as that at Guantanamo Bay to naval vessels in the Indian Ocean, so accounts of life inside the new gulag are rare.
One of the most harrowing stories concerns a Syrian-born Canadian, Maher Arar, who was arrested by US authorities in late 2002 during a stopover in New York, on suspicion of terrorist activities.
After several days of questioning, the 34-year-old IT specialist was flown to Jordan, where the CIA passed him on to local security officials. He was repeatedly assaulted in Jordan before being driven to Syria, where he was kept in solitary confinement in a 6ft by 3ft cell for several months and repeatedly beaten with cables. All charges were dropped on his release. Arar said last week that he was 'trying to rebuild [his] life'. 'I never did anything to make me a suspect. I could not believe they would send me back to Syria, but they did,' he said. 'They sent me back to be tortured.'
The ghost prison network stretches around the globe. The biggest American-run facilities are at the Bagram airbase, north of Kabul in Afghanistan, Guantanamo Bay, where around 400 men are held, and in Iraq, where tens of thousands of detainees are held. Saddam Hussein and dozens of top Baath party officials are held in a prison at Baghdad airport.
However, Washington is relying heavily on allies. In Morocco, scores of detainees once held by the Americans are believed to be held at the al-Tamara interrogation centre sited in a forest five miles outside the capital, Rabat. Many of the detainees were originally captured by the Pakistani authorities, who passed them on to the Americans.
One is Abdallah Tabarak, a militant who is alleged to have been Osama bin Laden's bodyguard and was seized in late 2001 by the Pakistanis. Tabarak was handed over to US agents, sent to Bagram and then to Guantanamo, before being flown to Morocco. Last November, Amnesty International criticised the 'sharp rise' in torture during 2003 in Moroccan prisons.
In Syria, detainees sent by Washington are held at 'the Palestine wing' of the main intelligence headquarters and a series of jails in Damascus and other cities. Egypt has also received a steady flow of militants from American installations. Many other militants have been sent to Egypt by other countries through transfers assisted by the Americans, often using planes run by the CIA.
In Cairo, prisoners are kept in the interrogation centre in the general intelligence directorate in Lazoughli and in Mulhaq al-Mazra prison, according to Montasser al-Zayat, an Islamist lawyer in Cairo and former spokesman for outlawed militant groups.
Terrorists have also been sent to facilities in Baku, Azerbaijan, and to unidentified locations in Thailand. Scores more are thought to be at a US airbase in the Gulf state of Qatar, and a large number are believed to have been sent to Saudi Arabia, where CIA agents are allowed to sit in on some of the interrogations. Elsewhere, security officials merely provide the Americans with summaries.
The fate of high-value prisoners - such as those directly connected to the 11 September attacks or other al-Qaeda strikes, or senior aides of bin Laden - is unknown. Abu Zubaydah, the Palestinian-born al-Qaeda logistics expert, was arrested after a shoot-out in the Pakistani city of Faisalabad in March 2002 by a joint team of American and Pakistani special forces.
After a brief interrogation, Abu Zubayda was handed over to the Americans, who took him to Bagram and then, it is believed, flew him on to Jordan, where he has been held, along with several other high-value prisoners, in prisons in the capital, Amman, and in desert locations in the east of the country. Jordanian investigators are seen as 'professional' by Western intelligence services, although the nation has been repeatedly criticised for its human rights record.
Khaled Sheikh Mohammed and Ramzi bin al-Shibh, who both helped plan the 11 September attacks, were also transferred to American custody soon after their capture by Pakistani security forces in September 2002 and March 2003 respectively. They are believed to have been interrogated in Thailand.
The whereabouts of Riduan Isamuddin, the Indonesian activist dubbed 'the bin Laden of the Far East', who was passed to the Americans following arrest by Thai security forces in August last year, are unknown. Jabarah Mohamed Mansur, allegedly involved in an attempt to bomb the US and Israeli embassies in Singapore, is reported to have been interrogated in Oman.
What is clear is that the Americans are prepared to go to extraordinary lengths to capture suspects and to ensure that they are taken to an environment where information can be extracted as speedily as possible.
In March 2003, FBI agents kidnapped a Yemeni al-Qaeda suspect from a hospital in Mogadishu, where he was being treated for gunshot wounds. Two months earlier, a sophisticated operation involving a fake charity lured a 54-year-old Yemeni to Germany, where he was detained and later extradited to the US. To seize Mohammed Iqbal Madni, a suspected al-Qaeda operative, in Indonesia, US investigators worked three states' legal systems to provide an excuse to pick up the 24-year-old Pakistani. They then flew him to Cairo on a private US-run jet.
The exact number of prisoners held by the Americans or their allies is unknown, but US officials claim that more than 3,000 al-Qaeda militants have been arrested since 11 September. Only around 350 are held in Guantanamo Bay. Very few have been released.
The incarceration of prisoners captured by the Americans in jails in the Middle East has enraged militants. Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the Jordanian-born terrorist leader who is active in Iraq, said in April that prisons in his native land had become 'the Arab Guantanamo'.
'Whoever the Americans find hard to investigate in Pakistan and Afghanistan, they move to Jordan, where they are tortured in every way,' he said.
American officials are unrepentant. 'You have to break eggs to make omelettes,' said one last week. 'The world is a bad place.'
And Cofer Black, then head of the CIA counter-terrorist centre, said last year that 'there was a before 9/11 and an after 9/11. After 9/11, the gloves came off.'
But former intelligence officers criticised the new tactics last week. Milton Bearden, who ended a 30-year career with the CIA in 1994, said that coercion did not work.
'You just get all kinds of confessions that turn out to be completely untrue,' he said. 'And rendition to someone who will torture a suspect is as bad as doing it yourself.'
Wahab al-Rawi, whose brother is still being held in Guantanamo Bay, said that he was angry at both the British government and the US government.
'I just want to know how my own government can just give me up to the Americans. Who do these people answer to?
'I just ask God to punish them, because there is no power on earth that they seem to be afraid of.'
http://observer.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,6903,1237589,00.html[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 27 Oct 2006
1. " simply want to correct your sentence that `since jews were allowed to return their homeland, those who looted them and kicked out of their lands are feeling uncomfortable'.
It was the same as if some day in History Hindus/sikhs kicked out pakistan in 1947 are allowed to return to Pakistan and fanatics there start crying for their blood again. That's it. Jews are original owners..."
The Jews were forced out of Palestine over 2 thousand years ago by the Romans. Yes, it is their traditional homeland, but in no way are they the "owners" of it. It was a conglomeration of short-sighted politics which created animosity between Israelis and the Palestinians who had been living there for generations which has degenerated to a point where the UN is calling it war crimes.
2. "That was just a sheer mass of information, relating almost entirely to the U.S, cut and pasted with no effort to make any point what so ever."
These are published facts about the current war in Iraq which we all should reflect on, one half of the articles relate to britain. I'm not saying you should agree with me. I'm saying look at the facts which reputable news agencies are printing in both United States and Britain about corruption to manuver this conflict. Yes, it's a mass of information. It's always wise to be informed. There is strong reason to believe this war is illegal, this war has opened human rights loopholes to permit torture and rape of detainees, eroding ALL OUR RIGHTS, and the only people benefiting from this are multi-billion dollar corporations. If they are eroding rights of muslims, believe their will be a backlash to slap us all, including the growing homeless population of war veterans.
The purpose of placing this information is so Singhs can honestly see what is going on and make a decision for themselves if they want to volunteer armed service in this action. At least, you won't be misinformed about the conscientious issues.
3. "I am sure that infighting among Palestenians have killed more innocent women and children then Israeli forces.
Infighting among Pakistains and Afganistanis have killed more Muslims then outsideres. No of Muslims killed in Kashmir by Muslims is much more then killed by security forces.
I think this is not the right forum to propagate jehadi ideas."
How simple minded can you get. these are reputable news agencies and journalists exposing corruption of both British and American governments to manipulate all of us to support this war. It has nothing to do with the Jihadi position. As an American citizen, I oppose this war on moral grounds. not as a Muslim or a Jihadi. However, civil rights are being so undermined and violated perhaps in the near future I may be shipped off to a torture camp simply for being linked as a "jihadi" or something ludicrous.
You are wrong about the numbers killed by Palestinians versus Israeli Defense forces. You may examine Amnesty International website if you prefer. But consider the trillion dollar military wealth of israel in comparison with the rock-throwing and suicide bombing Palestinians. Consider the recent action in Lebanon where Israel acknowledged it used incendiary phosphorus against civilian targets in violation of the Geneva convention which it does not have to abide by, and then come and tell me about massacres by Palestinians.
"Quite ironically it was the supreme sacrifice of the Sikh soldier wearing his turban in two world wars for the British that has led to the rights us Sikhs enjoy here in the UK."
Not all wars are moral wars. Not all involvement will give Singhs a blessing. But go ahead and promote the value of this war if you must. It will only bring condemnation from Waheguru who is perfect justice. protecting your own rights while others lose theirs does not bless anyone. I do not say Islam is right or even good. I say that I have no right to support injustice against anyone, let alone call it an honor.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 28 Oct 2006
[quote]"It can be argued there is no such thing as a moral war, 99% of the wars that the Sikhs have ever been involved in were (by your definition or someone else’s) immoral."[/quote]
I think this again is an overly simplistic approach. First as a westerner, having lived among western ideology, our own west is publishing criticisms that the Iraqi invasion and occupation were an illegal action and manipulated by falsified documents and lying to the American and British public. hence my use of the term, "immoral."
Yes, killing is "immoral" but there are dharmic defenses. If someone attacks me personally, my family, my religion, my livelihood. Right now I see the Muslims as being prejudicially attacked and believe that karma will give them opportunities to strike back. The argument here is, will the propaganda machine supporting this war also threaten to erode Sikh rights? I say YES. It's obvious at least here in America.
Moreover, the issue was raised that Singhs should proudly support this war since Britain (at least) although they are partnered with the US, is in some moral right. And all Muslims are in some moral wrong, and therefore targets. But, this cannot be proven because the Iraqi's have never been in a position to invade us. 9/11 is the result of rogue (former) CIA operatives from Afghanistan coming home like forgotten chickens to roost. Again, karmic cause. The US completely destabilized the region and armed fanatics who became Taliban and Al Qaeda. The CIA even armed Saddam Hussein so he could cripple Iran. OMG, talk about manipulations heaped upon manipulations. We as American and British public are being horribly manipulated.
Instead of doing right by these countries, helping rebuild their infrastructure, providing food, education, medical care like we did with Japan and Germany after WWII, we just make economic sanctions hoping that starving the people will foment revolution against leaders undesirable to America. And then the people all hate us. We drop heavy bombs and send the radicals to torture camps. What do you think will result from this approach? friendship? Alliance? Or more terrorist retaliation?
Additionally, no one is analyzing how the Jihadists are becoming radicalized and more violent with each spreading act of war, massacre, injustice and insult. We have dozens of soldiers facing courts martial for massacre, murder, rape, and torture. In other words, if Britain's top General is publically saying that the Iraqi war is making the terrorist problem worse and eroding everyone's security, then I think it is a valid point. We have had at least 5 top American generals come out and say the same thing. It isn't only my opinion, nor is it some Jihadist position.
[quote]"Telling people to intergrate and represent their country because of my experience is a positive thing, You telling people not too because of yours is only negative."[/quote]
If Sikh's fully integrate, they will stop being Sikhs. Sikhs are marked for distinction by the articles of faith, and by kesh. A fully integrated Singh is clean-shaven, wearing business suit, and making nominal acquiescence to Christian majority beliefs and sensibilities. In America at least, wearing kes alone and they think you are Osama, a threatening figure, or member of a dangerous cult. From incidents which occur in Britain and Canada, there may be more acceptance, but I believe it is slight and tenuous. Sikh's are different, I don't care how many wars they fight in. But fighting in a war should not be undertaken lightly. Otherwise you're equating Singh's with soldiers for hire who will do anything for acceptance.
[quote]"Sometimes people forget or become ungratfull for all the great things we take for granted here, things that are worth fighting for."[/quote]
As having American Indian descent, and living in America, a land which brutally massacred and destroyed my ancestors and their culture, I don't jump on patriotic bandwagons very easily. This is not to say I am ungrateful for opportunities as an American. But you must also reflect that the American public is conditioned to being manipulated by wealthy, corporate interests. And already the newspapers are writing about homeless Iraqi and Afghanistan war veterans. The government uses them and then lets them rot without resources. So please, talk about ingratitude on part of veteran's affairs.
I do not believe you can stretch any argument that America or Britain are fighting to protect their way of life. What they are doing is endangering that way of life by provoking Islamic extremism by conducting an illegal action, which they pursued, not because of threat, but because of desire for controlling interest in the oil in the region. And these governments do not give a damn about Iraqi's, veterans, Sikhs, or you and me. Hence I do not delude myself with false loyalty.
[quote]"My belief in my nation is not so weak that it would be shaked by a handful of scum, if a handful of Singhs told you that you were not a Sikh would you judge the rest of us by them."[/quote]
What will shake great nations is not a handful of scum, but justice of karma. Great and powerful nations have been shaken in the past. they will be shaken in the future. All our actions matter to Waheguru. Karma is divine law.
[quote]"If thats the only reason that you have turned your back on your nation then you never had enough belief and love for your country in the first place."[/quote]
I love the country of my ancestors. It was not named America until the white people came. Further, I do not believe blind support of the George Bush administration has anything to do with loyalty to America. In fact, loyalty to America would say this war is bankrupting us, killing thousands of our young, destroying what is left of Iraq and Afghanistan, destabilizing relations with Iran and North korea, and we have more important things to do then pick sides in a brutal civil war which Iraq is now degenerating into.
[img]http://www.spacewar.com/images/bush-rice-bg.jpg[/img]
These people do not represent the interests of the American people. They represent the interests of CORPORATIONS. I do not believe Americans, British or Iraqis should be dying to manipulate the control of oil prices for the corporations who put presidents into power. This is not a war about protecting America or Britain. It was a war to destroy the Baathist (Sunni) regime for control of oil, and now we have given support to the Shia insurgency who will ally with Iran and blow us all to hell. Talk about stupid. Not only that but the Bush administration gave Israel the go-ahead to attack Lebanon to weaken Syria, and they used chemical warfare incendiary phosphorus against civilians and believe me, the entire Islamic world will be fighting a jihad against us now for a hundred years. And it was all about GREED. We are less secure now, and our grandchildren will be less secure. Not because of a handful of scum...but because of KARMA.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 28 Oct 2006
[quote]"if a handful of Singhs told you that you were not a Sikh would you judge the rest of us by them."[/quote]
If Singhs sang my praises to the skies...it would not make me who I am not. If Singhs crushed my reputation to the dirt...it would not take away from who I am. All these things will be sorted out justly when we die.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs & Multiculturalism in Uk - From veil to kirpan...
Harjas Kaur · 29 Oct 2006
[quote]"If you do ever come to England, please contact me and I will quite happily show you how Sikhs can be fully British and fully Sikh."[/quote]
If I come to England it will most likely be to attend a smagam and you can happily show me how well you sing kirtan of praise to Guruji.
[%sig%]