Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

it is similar to a Sikh carrying a Kirpan

it is similar to a Sikh carrying a Kirpan

----^^^^---- · 29 Sep 2006

A terminally ill woman in the northern Indian state of Rajasthan has died after fasting for 14 days in keeping with a religious custom. Vimla Devi, from Jaipur, observed Santhara, a centuries-old Jain practice where one starves to spiritually prepare for death. Her fast led to a petition in the state's high court by critics who say the practice is similar to suicide. Vimla Devi was terminally ill and suffering from cancer. The petition is due to come up for hearing on 5 October. 'Not suicide' Her family says that her decision to observe Santhara was sanctioned by a Jain cleric and her family members. Jains say Santhara should not be equated to suicide "She had expressed her wish to adopt Santhara and give up her life and for 14 days she did not eat or drink," her husband, Sohan Lal Bhansali, said. Vimla Devi's family did not mourn or cry at her funeral. Instead a large number of people from the community took out a procession and chanted prayers along the way. Nikhil Soni, who filed the court petition, says he tried to break her fast and had even informed the local police asking them to take action. But police told him they were seeking legal opinion on the issue. It is an old tradition and has religious sanction, it is similar to a Sikh carrying a Kirpan [dagger] Rajiv Surana, lawyer from the Jain community Defending the custom, a female Jain priest, Sadhvi Shubhankar, said, Santhara is centuries-old and cannot be compared to suicide. "It is not an act of suicide, it is an act of rational thinking and courage." In the last few years there have been nearly a dozen cases of Santhara, including one some months ago when a Jain cleric starved to death in Sriganganagar. A Jain lawyer, Rajiv Surana says Santhara should not be perceived as a religious aberration like Sati. "It is an old tradition and has religious sanction, it is similar to a Sikh carrying a kirpan [dagger]."

Re: it is similar to a Sikh carrying a Kirpan

Harjas Kaur · 03 Oct 2006

I do not see any logical similarity to a Sikh wearing an article of faith. However, I do agree with the Jain community on this issue. This observance has a right legal protection. "It is not an act of suicide, it is an act of rational thinking and courage." Absolutely. I work as a nurse in hospital. I do not believe any state has the right to enforce prolonging the dying process in the name of medical prejudice. While witholding care, and nourishment from another can be perceived as negligence and homicide by a caregiver, the right to make religious peace with one's maker, and withdraw physically from this world in a fasting purification is far more sane than any desperate death in a hospital scenario. All they do in a hospital is try to cling to the body using surgeries, drugs, drips, forced feedings, antibiotics....long after the futility of cure is passed. This gives large profits to medical corporations, extended suffering and miserable deaths in what is usually a non-spiritual environment. Desperate staff try to cling to the desperate dying. When the Tibetan Buddhists came to America and saw the hospital system they said it was an insane way to treat the dying process...and it is. It is one thing to provide comfort, and another to mandate futile, desperate, hopeless, and painful treatments for a terminal disease process. I refused to let my own father die in a hospital. When he said he wanted to come home, we brought him home. he died peacefully from cancer in his sleep surrounded by loved ones. Imagine that. I haven't witnessed a peaceful death like that in 17 years of hospital nursing. If you are sick, go to a hospital. But if you are dying, what is the point? [%sig%]