Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Dalbiri · 26 Sep 2006

I guess many of you would have ascertained my feelings towards this issue from previous postings. I feel the issue is important enough to warrant a separate thread. I want to know how you feel about the attempts by the British military to use Gurdwaras as recruitment centres for the army. Specifically from what I've seen in London, they target Jatt Gurdwaras in particular. I know Gurdwaras shouldn't be affiliated to any caste but for now the simple truth is that they are, so get over that one. So what are the sangats feelings regarding this issue? Often the Gurdwara committees seem more than happy to entertain such people. I think there is an old tactic of flattery used against jatts by the English where they are told they are a "brave" and "loyal" people at times of need, only to be treated like all other "pakis" when the need is gone. Is this beadbi? Should we allow our religious institutes to be used in this way? How does this fit in with the fact that Sikhs sacrificed more than anyone else to end British colonial rule. Please express yourselves, especially the bros from a jatt background. Personally I feel it is an issue that effects not only jatts, but sikhs in general. The actions of a few can influence wider perception of the community.

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

kharkoo · 27 Sep 2006

lol. Where's the nearest Jatt Sabha Prabhandak Committee then?

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Bazzer · 27 Sep 2006

I don't really see it as beadbi? How is beadbi taking place? The RAF came to one of our local Gurdwaras and they had a display of their stuff downstairs (darbar Sahib is upstairs) and the Gurdwara laid on a display of Sikh history for them. They gave a little talk, we gave them the usual Gatka display and there was a good humrous Q&A afterwards. If some of our sikhs can get opportunities in the forces and get good careers, and they are prepared to go to the front lines (although it was stressed that not all jobs take you to the front lines) then so be it. We allow politicians into the darbar Sahib, we have corrput committee members, at least the officers gave good respect to our traditions. [%sig%]

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Dalbiri · 28 Sep 2006

You can't see how being embroilled in another countries wars can be problematic. Especially if they are morally questionable, like invading a country on a false premise for its resources (i.e. oil). Isn't this very unSikh? Most people don't know but the British used Singhs to kill Chinese people during the Boxer rebellion because the Chinese were fighting for their sovereignity and to stop the British selling huge amount of opium (modern day heroin) to its people. Doing another races dirty work shouldn't be our style. How does it make sense that Sikhs complain about foreign interference in the Panjab if they help other foreigners interfere with other countries. As for showing respect for our traditions. What about motive and agenda, do you really think they are that bothered or interested in our traditions or more so in their own plans and objectives. Singhs shouldn't be so politically naieve.

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Seeker of the Truth · 28 Sep 2006

Let them fight for the British. Who are we to say they can't fight for the British? These people should know what they're getting into with they join the army. I personally wouldn't mind fighting for my country (Canada) if other peaceful methods have failed to protect my country.

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Bazzer · 29 Sep 2006

You think their agenda is to set up Sikh regiments and send then off to do their dirty work ? Hardly. There may be a trickle of Sikhs going into the forces, hardly enough to have a major impact on doing "their dirty work". Every one has a brain, nobody is forcing anybody to do anything, if a Sikh feels he can make a career in the forces, then I do not see anything wrong in that. If you feel that it is unSikh then don't join up ! We have to get out of this mentality that everyone is out to get us, be pragmatic, if it suits you, go for it.

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Dalbiri · 29 Sep 2006

Well , before Sikhs start colluding with Anglo-Saxons in their endeavours, maybe the British could do a bit more for Sikh causes. I notice how in the media here in general refer to 1984 incidents using the words "fundamentalist", "extreme" and so forth. Then they seem to be colluding with Hindu interests when it comes to the question of Khalistan, even when they should know that Sikhs did have their own Kingdom, sovereignity before they turned up and turned the Panjab into a bloodbathed border state. It is not about a mentality that everyone is out to get us but rather that we should stop and think before any of our people consider flying halfway around the globe to possibly kill other people who haven't done anything to us, or support other people that do. Where is the morality in that? Yes, pragmatism is not a bad thing but still. SOT, this isn't even about defending this country from attack, it is more about not supporting aggression by this country towards others, which they seem to have a long history of. Plus the way these people operate, once a few simple Singhs jump in, they use them in media campaigns all over the place to encourage other simpletons to join.

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Bazzer · 29 Sep 2006

I agree with you totally about this war that they are engaged in and the rights and wrongs of it, but you seem to regard any Sikh who joins up as a simpleton. This is rather naive, I do not think they are simple at all, I have met a few and they are well aware of events around them are use them to their advantage.

Re: Is this beadbi of a Gurdwara?

Dalbiri · 30 Sep 2006

There is a bigger point regarding good and evil and what we choose to do as Sikhs. Letting our Gurdwaras become involved in promting evil, defeats their purpose. I hope those Singhs know what they are doing. Plus I hope we don't get bad kamaai or karma as a quom from involving ourselves in these things.