singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 28 Aug 2006
i just wanted to clarify that there is a difference between singhs and singhniaa. however much some of us may not want to admit this. singhs and singhnia were created differently and therefore have different roles to play on this earth. for a singhni to try and do everything a singh does or vice versa is silly. its going against nature.mostly singhs fought battles in wars in gurus times, this is not sexist this is the just the way it is. men are naturally in general stronger then women. the dumala was a war pag which is why singhs wore it, those few singhniaa who went to war would also wear a dumala. but to see singhniaa in massive dumala now a days is strange. as if they want to become singhs. bak in bhai sahib randhir singhs time it is clear to see all of the bibiaa wore keski and chunni with suit. now can this be called manmat?
i think we should clarify equality it doesnt mean tht singhs and singhniaa are exactly the same. which is why a singh can partake in panj pyare seva and a singhni cant. because the roop of a khalsa tht is to partake in this seva is to be a singh with no angs missing. a singh doesnt mean singh or singhni it means singh. if not why didnt guru gobind singh ji giv all sikh women the name singh as well as men the name singh.
now its all very well if ur a singhni and u beleive bana as rehit, gr8. but jus dont go trying to turn yourself into a singh. because there are 2 genders in sikhi. male and female.
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
Kulbir Singh · 28 Aug 2006
--------
the dumala was a war pag which is why singhs wore it, those few singhniaa who went to war would also wear a dumala. but to see singhniaa in massive dumala now a days is strange.
----------
Why is it strange to see singhniaan in dumaalay now a days? If Singhs who are not at war today can wear dumaalay, why can't bibiyaan wear them?
Fair enough, that Singhs and singhniaan belong to different genders but since they both get same amrit and are supposed to follow same rehit, they should also have the same rights. If a Bibi is following same rehit as Singh and if a Bibi got the same amrit, then who can deny them the same rights as Singhs?
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 28 Aug 2006
true,
im not denying tht they have same rights, a bibi has the right to fight in war, but this is not generallly her role. is wa imtrying to say. same with MASSIVE dumala
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
Kulbir Singh · 28 Aug 2006
-------
im not denying tht they have same rights, a bibi has the right to fight in war, but this is not generallly her role. is wa imtrying to say. same with MASSIVE dumala
-------
I don't understand why some people have allergy with bibiyan wearing dumaalay and why they want them to wear tiny one meter keskis covered with chunni. If gursikhs like yourself are going to oppose bibiyan wearing baana and dumaala, what hope can we have from ordinary people?
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2006
excellent, excellent
thank you for spending your time in trying to answer my queries in a constructive way.
"IF we go on thinking like this, then why not let bibiaa just wear the kirpaan when they are going to go out in battle, because in normal circumstances they do not need them."
now come on, thats just silly. kirpan is kakaar so we wear it whatever.
guru sahib gave us the kirpan for all times, you never know when you might need it.
i didnt say i had an allergy i just it is a war dastaar and gerenaly singhs went to war not singhniaa
great article, but tht tells us tht mata kartaar kaur wore dumala and chola once. the rest of the time she wore a suit, chuni and keski.
"BaNa is alike for both Singhs and Singhneeaa. On the head there should be the round Dumaalaa "
bhai sahib randhir singh didnt wear a dumala.
yes and like i said when going to wore singhniaa obviously wore shastrs, chola, dumala.
look, if you look in first post i didnt say bana was for males. and i think we also have to define bana, is bana just a chola? or can it be a korta? or a suit?
"Chola should be worn along with Kamar Kassa (belt around waist) and Kacherra (up to knees). In the olden days when the Khalsa was fighting many battles, Singhs and Singhneeaa had the exact same baNa. Even the Singhneeaa fought like the Singhs. (See "Ram Raj" book)."
kamar kassa- not many people wear tht nowadays, and no mention of hazoori and also again he says IN BATTLE.
this post is not saying. bibiaa please lob off your bana and dumala and wear a suit and a little keski. it is saying wear what you feel confortable in/wear what you think you should wear. but dont forget tht there are two genders and dont think. cos singh does/wears this i should too, because we are all equal.
the question is why did bibiaa in bhai sahibs time wear tiny keskis with chunis?
", including Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji, wore bana"
yeah again, whilst in battle and tht. and thts jus one example, what about the other hundreds of singhniaa?
bana is fine, dumala is fine. i guess i cant get out what im trying to say properly. i am not saying "bibiaa dont wear dumala and bana" its not as blatant as tht. im saying bibiaa recognise your role.
just like singhs uniform can be chola with no pyjama. this cannot be the uniform for a singhnee.
"As for the panj, it is true that there were no women that offered their heads when Guru Ji first asked for it. However, you did not offer it either, and neither did any of the males that are part of the Panj today. So technically they should not be allowed to be a part of the panj because they failed to give their heads back then. Why do the panj accept the heads of bibiaa today? It is because GUru ji himself accept the heads of his daughters, and once a person has sacrificed his or her head, and has become a Sikh, the roles they can play in the panth are not limited by their gender. How can you group a tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyaasi, jyot vigaasi bibi in the same category as a bujjer kurehitee by saying she cannot do seva in the panj?"
and here we go
unfortunately i didnt have a chance to issue my views in the lecture hall at khalsa camp so ill do it now.
ok, no women offered their heads therefore the roop of the panj was 5 singh. therefore a singh can be in the panj because he has the roop of a singh whereas a singhni doesnt. the panj accept heads of bibiaa because anyone take amrit, not anyone can be in the panj though. ie. angheen person, past bujjar kurehiti. just like i can say a tyaar bar tyaar, jyot vigaasi. naam abhyasi singh hu is ang heen cannot do seva in the panj. the roop of the panj has to be comlplete, has to be as it first was when guru gobind singh ji made the panj pyare.
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
Satnam Singh · 29 Aug 2006
As usual it's a sign borne out of fear of the female gender. As Bhai Balpreet Singh said in one of the Q & A sessions, the Only truth is Akaal Purakh. That is the ultimate truth. Other truths can change. Perhaps in this light we need to adopt the truth that all men and women are equal irrespective of anything including the biological make-up. Indeed the human body is but a mere tool to carry out the desire of our soul, our real timeless jot. Who knows in what past life what gender one was?
Are we ready to upgrade to a newer truth? A wise person fears not change as long as it harms nobody and is for the good of all. On the other hand we have those who deny the truth even when it stares boldly at them.
I stand by the Guru who declared equality for all bibiaa despite that instant when khalsa was created, for reasons known better to them. Who are we to judge why they never came forward?
Just suppose that a bibi did come forward, would Guruji have turned her down? Your answer will suggest which camp you side on.
satnam singh
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2006
no i am not saying they are incomplete
i am saying their form is different to the form of a singhs
therefore not suitable for panj pyare seva
jus like some 1 hu is ang heen has a form which is not suitable for panj pyare seva
there is a physical roop as well as a spirutal stage tht some1 hu is doing 5 pyare seva must adhere to. the orginal 5 were 5 singhs. this roop must be kept.
in bhai sahibs times- i use this phrase because bhai sahib followed tat gurmat therefore using his life and wat happened in his company is a good reference.
if a bibi came forward then the panj pyare would consist of 1 bibi and 4 singhs.
but tht didnt happen
so its 5 singhs
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
Gupt singhnee! · 30 Aug 2006
"the orginal 5 were 5 singhs. this roop must be kept."
True. the original roop must be kept.I think if panj singh is needed but there is shortage of a singh then all singhneea shud be tyaar bur tyaar 2 take on any sevaa but otherwise my view is that it should be 5 singhs because thats how it was in guru maharaj's time.:) Bul chuk maaf.
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
Prabhjoyt Singh · 30 Aug 2006
who said women cant be Granthis?
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 30 Aug 2006
doing granthi seva is very different to doing seva in the panj.
doing seva in the panj u must be a tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyasi, jyot vigaasi singh, no angs missing and healthy and tht. to do granthi seva u have to be amritdhari, or some ppl say u can do it as long as u have had ishnaan and are appropiatedly dressed
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
Hardeep Singh · 31 Aug 2006
Of course women can be in the punj pyare. Women can be tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyasi, jyot vigaasi singhnis, no angs missing and healthy and tht.
In a amrit sanchar the punj pyare are representing Guroo Gobind Singh jee and Guru Jee states it clearly that khalsa has no gender. Hence in an amrit sanchar the punj are transfering their spirtuality into the amrit.
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 31 Aug 2006
mr *
i did say singh if u didnt read properly and a singhni is not a singh
khalsa has no gender really, so why is there singh and kaur and not just singh for everyone
panj pyare had a roop in the begeinng
roop must be kept
roop was 5 SINGHS
its really not tht complicated
a singhni does not have the roop of a singh
the physical roop does matter.
if 5 singhnees were in the original panj then the panj pyare wud always hav to consist of 5 singhees.
but tht didnt happen
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 31 Aug 2006
how many times must i post the same thing.
a question wouldnt need to be asked about gender because only singhs can do seva anyway. and do they also ask if you have all of your limbs in tact by the way?
yes guru ji asked for 5 heads. 5 SINGHS came up. therefore thts the way it should stay. my ignorance? 5 singhs were orginally in the 5 pyare. this is the way it should be kept. this is the roop of the 5 pyare. its not sexist. its the just the way it is. all 10 gurus were male. is this sexist too?
5 singhs are required for panj pyare seva.
nd i dont really know what to say about the bibi nanaki story. its a bit stupid to try and compare the 2. any one can take amrit and be a sikh. but not anyone can be in the panj. can u not read. i have wrote tht at least once alredy.
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 01 Sep 2006
hissy fit?
what does tht mean?
wen im havin a fit ill let u know.
no it doesnt make sense. anyone can be a sikh, not anyone can be in the panj, even pro bibiaa in the panj will agree to that.
[%sig%]
Re: singhs and singhniaa
baba amarjeet singh · 01 Sep 2006
singhni ji
men and women being equal is a concept taken out of context. equal means not discriminating them becuase of gender. it doesnt mean tht they are the same and can do the same things and are made for the same things.
i am not saying singhniaa arent good enough or something to do panj pyare seva. im saying tht vahigurus hukam was for to 5 singhs to so panj pyare seva which was why 5 singhs were in the original 5. now neither me or you can argue with hukam.
tell us to do the same? hmmm
men and women are made for different things. ie. a man cant give birth
wether you like it or not. in general men are stronger then women. there is no point arguing about tht.
no, its not AGAINST nature for men to make roti. i make roti. i never said that. i said tht men and women do have certain roles. ie. its more of a mans role to fight on the battlefield, tht doesnt mean singhniaa never fuoght on the battlefield. i simply said tht there ARE 2 genders in sikhi. male and female. we shuldnt try and make them into one.
and lastly with "miss perfect" in ur addie, u dnt need to argue, u presumeably already know all.
and i am getting quite bored of writing the same thing. so unless someone has something new to say i suggest you at look at the responses from "reply" and "veechar" on this post
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=55557&t=54559#reply_55557
[%sig%]