Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

singhs and singhniaa

singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 28 Aug 2006

i just wanted to clarify that there is a difference between singhs and singhniaa. however much some of us may not want to admit this. singhs and singhnia were created differently and therefore have different roles to play on this earth. for a singhni to try and do everything a singh does or vice versa is silly. its going against nature.mostly singhs fought battles in wars in gurus times, this is not sexist this is the just the way it is. men are naturally in general stronger then women. the dumala was a war pag which is why singhs wore it, those few singhniaa who went to war would also wear a dumala. but to see singhniaa in massive dumala now a days is strange. as if they want to become singhs. bak in bhai sahib randhir singhs time it is clear to see all of the bibiaa wore keski and chunni with suit. now can this be called manmat? i think we should clarify equality it doesnt mean tht singhs and singhniaa are exactly the same. which is why a singh can partake in panj pyare seva and a singhni cant. because the roop of a khalsa tht is to partake in this seva is to be a singh with no angs missing. a singh doesnt mean singh or singhni it means singh. if not why didnt guru gobind singh ji giv all sikh women the name singh as well as men the name singh. now its all very well if ur a singhni and u beleive bana as rehit, gr8. but jus dont go trying to turn yourself into a singh. because there are 2 genders in sikhi. male and female. [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Kulbir Singh · 28 Aug 2006

-------- the dumala was a war pag which is why singhs wore it, those few singhniaa who went to war would also wear a dumala. but to see singhniaa in massive dumala now a days is strange. ---------- Why is it strange to see singhniaan in dumaalay now a days? If Singhs who are not at war today can wear dumaalay, why can't bibiyaan wear them? Fair enough, that Singhs and singhniaan belong to different genders but since they both get same amrit and are supposed to follow same rehit, they should also have the same rights. If a Bibi is following same rehit as Singh and if a Bibi got the same amrit, then who can deny them the same rights as Singhs? [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Roopkaur · 28 Aug 2006

I totally agree with you that SInghs and Singhneeaa both have different roles in life. However, the Sikh bana is in no way exclusively for males. IF we go on thinking like this, then why not let bibiaa just wear the kirpaan when they are going to go out in battle, because in normal circumstances they do not need them. By saying that the bana is just for males is extremely ignorant, Guru ji did not make two rehits for his children, why would he make two baney. THe salwaar kameez and the saree are from muslim and HIndu culures, why is it that Sikh women should stay stuck to the Muslim/Hindu culture, while their brothers and husbands adopt the Khalsa Bana. The bana is the uniform for the Khalsa, and both genders are open to join that army, Akaal Purkh Kee Fauj. In an army, even if you look at the worldy army, the uniform is the same for both men and women. By wearing the bana, I am not trying to emulate you, or the next Singh, it is my way of showing my commitment to the General of Generals, King of Kings, my Father, dhan dhan Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji. I am sorry you have a problem with this, please do not think it is an effort to become just like you. As for the panj, it is true that there were no women that offered their heads when Guru Ji first asked for it. However, you did not offer it either, and neither did any of the males that are part of the Panj today. So technically they should not be allowed to be a part of the panj because they failed to give their heads back then. Why do the panj accept the heads of bibiaa today? It is because GUru ji himself accept the heads of his daughters, and once a person has sacrificed his or her head, and has become a Sikh, the roles they can play in the panth are not limited by their gender. How can you group a tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyaasi, jyot vigaasi bibi in the same category as a bujjer kurehitee by saying she cannot do seva in the panj? As for bibiaa wearing bana during Bhai Sahib's time. There is an account of a British journalist that clearly describes Mata Kartar Kaur wearing AKali bana. And what to say of Bhai Sahib's time, going back to GUru Ji's time, bibiaa, including Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji, wore bana. Although biologically there are two genders in SIkhi, The religion itself does not have to do with our biology, but with our aatmaa, and our aatmaa has no gender, how can there be two sets of rules for the aatmaa, which is part of the chaauthaa pad gun, based on a person's biology, which is according to tre gun?

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 28 Aug 2006

true, im not denying tht they have same rights, a bibi has the right to fight in war, but this is not generallly her role. is wa imtrying to say. same with MASSIVE dumala [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Roopkaur · 28 Aug 2006

Author: Admin Date: 09-11-03 18:31 I was in the library today when I came across the following passage from an old newspaper. It describes the yearly gathering of the Central Sikh League in October 1920. I had always wondered whether Sikh women in the past had worn cholas, etc. My question was answered marvellously. Describing the event, the newspaper reads, "On one side of the hall, the daughters of Mata Sahib Kaur were appearing. At this, our royal meeting, the Singhnis present appeared to the Panth in the image of Mai Bhago. From amongst them, Bibi Kartar Kaur jee (wife of Bhai Randhir Singh ji) was in the uniform of an Akali of old. It was said that she was in truth the picture of a female Singh of ancient times" [Akali Newspaper, October 23, 1920, page 2] Mata jee was dressed like an Akali of Guru Sahib's time in a chola and dumalla and shastar. What an amazing sight it must have been! Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee's Singhnee, Mata Kartaar Kaur jee is a modern day role model for Sikh women. She had an extremely high spiritual state. When once Bhai Sahib was eating, he suddenly stopped and his mother asked from Mata Kartaar Kaur why this had happened, Mata jee replied that Bhai Sahib was feeding his Sarblohi fellow Gursikh Bhai Atma Singh who was at that time in Bhai Joginder Singh's house in Patiala. Bhai Atma Singh later came to Narangvaal and when he was asked about this, admitted that this indeed was what had happened. On another occasion, Bhai Sahib and other Singhs were doing keertan and were lost in divine colours and skipped dinner time. In Ranglay Sajjan in the story of Bhai Sarwan Singh, Bhai Sahib writes, "We were so lost in the Kirtan, that we passed into deep meditation. My wife, Kartar Kaur, visioned all this and came along late at night with our dinner. She shook us out of our stupor and had brought the steel utensils for serving food to the four persons. After getting our hands washed, the food was served. With half-closed eyes, drenched with Divine Love, while we were eating we watched this lady, a picture of true loving devotion. Bhai Sarwan Singh uttered a cry of pure love at her sight. In humility he had his head on her feet, saying “The holy sight of this Revered Mother has killed my hidden imperceptible ego. This ego had led me to believe, that I alone enjoyed the super-vision, extra-ordinary. I see visions in normal life and was feeling proud. This self-conceit has been destroyed today. I wonder how this Mother envisioned our presence here from a distance of one mile and known our exact number to bring food and utensils for four of us.” She partook of the food left by me. She always remained without food, till such time that I ate first. It was past mid-night." (translated by Bhai Jaspinder Singh jee) When Bhai Sahib was jailed, Mata jee endured days of extreme hardship and had all her property confiscated and could not even meet her beloved husband in jail. When Bhai Sahib returned, Mata Jee's joy could not be described. Bhai Sahib too had no less love for his wife. When Mata jee became very ill and it appeared she was close to passing, an ardaas was done at the Shimla Smaagam in 1951 during the amrit sinchaar for her health. As the Ran Sabaaee progressed that night, it was coming to a close at 5.30AM when a phone call arrived that Mata jee was absolutely fine and no one need worry. Bhai Sahib then took the vaja at 6AM and continued to do keertan for two and a half hours till 8.30 AM, even though the sangat had planned to leave by train at 6AM. The program finally ended at 10AM with an ardaas thanking Guru Sahib for curing Mata jee. It was at the 1952 Jalandhar Smaagam Ran Sabaaee on January 26-27 that Bhai Sahib was sitting in keertan and lost in divine colours when suddenly, Bhai Sahib opened his eyes at 2.30AM and looked towards Baoo Mul Singh jee and said "Look! Sree Kartaar Kaur jee has ascended!" and then again he was lost in keertan. At 4AM a Singh arrived from Ludhiana and the news spread in the rest of the Sangat that Mata jee had left this earth. Bhai Sahib and Mata jee's souls were so close, that he knew the moment she left this earth and didn't need anyone to tell him. Such is the closeness that is the ideal between a Sikh man and wife. Mata Kartaar Kaur is an example for all of us and an ideal Sikh Woman.

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Roopkaur · 28 Aug 2006

Author: Admin Date: 09-02-05 14:32 Part 2 of Khalsa Vidhaan Gurmat Lifestyle Translated from Khalsa Vidhaan by Bhai Kaur Singh ‘For a Sikh, only Kacherra and Dastaar are needed, it does not matter what else you wear. A Sikh women can choose to wear a Dastaar or not.’ Next we will say you can choose to wear a Kacherra or not – It is up to you. This is just an excuse to let go of other Rehats. Soon the committee will be saying Sikh women can take Amrit if they want to, but they don’t have to. When we have taken birth in the house of the Guru, our past life is gone. Before, the lifestyle the world had in accordance with the three virtues (Sato-Rajo-Tamo) is gone. Every bit has changed. Now we have to acknowledge and accept the traditions of Guru Sahibs house. Bhai Sahib Khan Singh Ji Nabha in his book ‘Mahan Kosh’ has told us who we should love and idolise, what to eat and drink, we start loving Gurus baNa. Our dress becomes like Singhs (all worldly fashions stop). Which BaNa is this? BaNa is alike for both Singhs and Singhneeaa. On the head there should be the round Dumaalaa (Not Nokhdhaar Pagh; I don’t know when this fashion started, originally the Pagh was round. See Bhai Khan Singhs ‘Mahan Kosh’ and the photo at the back of Ram Raj tract). Chola should be worn along with Kamar Kassa (belt around waist) and Kacherra (up to knees). In the olden days when the Khalsa was fighting many battles, Singhs and Singhneeaa had the exact same baNa. Even the Singhneeaa fought like the Singhs. (See "Ram Raj" book). Dumaalai with Chakars ( iron quoits) were worn to fend off blows from the Sword and kept the Dumaala strong and steady. They also work as Shastars (weapons). Until Raja Ranjit Singhs reign all women were donned in turbans – whose name, according to Rehatnamas was ‘Keski’ (5th Kakkar). Afterwards, we don’t know what happened, but weakness has crept into this Rehat also. The person who brought this weakness in the panth is Gianee Gurmukh Singh Musaafar. When he was Jathedar of Akaal Takhat, he stopped women from wearing Dastaar at the Takhat Sahib, before this it was seen mandatory for women to wear Dastaar. Amrit was not given without the Dastaar. Gurmukh Singh Musaafars wife did not wear Dastaar either. It would have been something else if he made her Tyaar-Bar-Tyaar and donned her with turban, instead he followed her and so much so, he decided to alter the Maryada at the Takhat Sahib. If a normal Sikh becomes weak then it affects him and his family, but if a leader becomes weak in Rehat then it affects the whole nation (panth).

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Roopkaur · 28 Aug 2006

Author: !! Date: 07-20-04 08:40 I thought this description was pretty amazing: ________ Adorning weapons, chakars [quoits] and knifes they wore many [in their dumallas – high conical turbans]. Forty kilos of weapons and armour they adorned. Dressed alike were young and old women. They were strong, powerful and of great charity. Some wore dress of women. Five dressed like men [i.e. in full warrior dress]. Getting Singh and Singhnias ready thus. Sending one Sirdar with them, the Singhnia set off towards the royal palace. The powerful Singhs stood outside. All the royal women came out to see them. They [Singhs] had great moustache and beards. Their eyes were full of rage and eyebrows greater. Wearing many weapons. Seeing their great form and beauty, they were as if incarnations of the warrior spirit. The Begams were astonished. Begams sent them [Singhs] gifts. Saluting the Singhs, they sent them away. Then they looked at the Singhnia. They took them into their palace. They [Singhnia] said, “Sat Siri Akal”. They replied “Salaam” and sat them down. Seeing their form and strong bodies. Dressed in armour and weapons. Listening to their conversation of plundering and war. And how to kill a hunt. And how to aim with bows and muskets. Hearing them, they were astonished. Under their ‘Salwars’ [trouser like garments], were ‘Kashehras’ [breeches]. Seeing their great clothes. Listening to their manly words. The Begams were astounded. The four Singhnia had a special female dress. They wore silver ornaments twenty pounds in weight. Seeing this they were awe struck. Their Salwars were twenty yard long. They wore heavy lower garments. Their top knots stood span and half high. Their Shmeezes were of special design. Their physiques were large and heavy. Seeing them the Begams were astounded because they stood unarmed and weak of body. Fearing the Singhnia they cowered to half their size. Then began discussion on religion. Singhnia dismissed all other religions. The traditions of Muslims [Turks] they called false. The way of Mohammed they said was full of faults. The Singhnia described all the atrocities of the Turks. Hearing them the Begams shuddered. Shocked they covered their mouths with their hands. Hearing of the chastity, sincerity and morals of the Singhs. The Begams spoke nodding their heads. “Singhnia you are of great fate. You move about with you husbands. We are pathetic and suffer greatly. Our life is like life imprisonment. One king has sixty wives. By marrying we are as if trapped in a trap”.’ (‘Naveen Panth Prakash’, Giani Gian Singh Nirmala, 1877, Bhasha Vibhag Publication, Pa.1151-1153)

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Kulbir Singh · 28 Aug 2006

------- im not denying tht they have same rights, a bibi has the right to fight in war, but this is not generallly her role. is wa imtrying to say. same with MASSIVE dumala ------- I don't understand why some people have allergy with bibiyan wearing dumaalay and why they want them to wear tiny one meter keskis covered with chunni. If gursikhs like yourself are going to oppose bibiyan wearing baana and dumaala, what hope can we have from ordinary people? [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2006

excellent, excellent thank you for spending your time in trying to answer my queries in a constructive way. "IF we go on thinking like this, then why not let bibiaa just wear the kirpaan when they are going to go out in battle, because in normal circumstances they do not need them." now come on, thats just silly. kirpan is kakaar so we wear it whatever. guru sahib gave us the kirpan for all times, you never know when you might need it. i didnt say i had an allergy i just it is a war dastaar and gerenaly singhs went to war not singhniaa great article, but tht tells us tht mata kartaar kaur wore dumala and chola once. the rest of the time she wore a suit, chuni and keski. "BaNa is alike for both Singhs and Singhneeaa. On the head there should be the round Dumaalaa " bhai sahib randhir singh didnt wear a dumala. yes and like i said when going to wore singhniaa obviously wore shastrs, chola, dumala. look, if you look in first post i didnt say bana was for males. and i think we also have to define bana, is bana just a chola? or can it be a korta? or a suit? "Chola should be worn along with Kamar Kassa (belt around waist) and Kacherra (up to knees). In the olden days when the Khalsa was fighting many battles, Singhs and Singhneeaa had the exact same baNa. Even the Singhneeaa fought like the Singhs. (See "Ram Raj" book)." kamar kassa- not many people wear tht nowadays, and no mention of hazoori and also again he says IN BATTLE. this post is not saying. bibiaa please lob off your bana and dumala and wear a suit and a little keski. it is saying wear what you feel confortable in/wear what you think you should wear. but dont forget tht there are two genders and dont think. cos singh does/wears this i should too, because we are all equal. the question is why did bibiaa in bhai sahibs time wear tiny keskis with chunis? ", including Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji, wore bana" yeah again, whilst in battle and tht. and thts jus one example, what about the other hundreds of singhniaa? bana is fine, dumala is fine. i guess i cant get out what im trying to say properly. i am not saying "bibiaa dont wear dumala and bana" its not as blatant as tht. im saying bibiaa recognise your role. just like singhs uniform can be chola with no pyjama. this cannot be the uniform for a singhnee. "As for the panj, it is true that there were no women that offered their heads when Guru Ji first asked for it. However, you did not offer it either, and neither did any of the males that are part of the Panj today. So technically they should not be allowed to be a part of the panj because they failed to give their heads back then. Why do the panj accept the heads of bibiaa today? It is because GUru ji himself accept the heads of his daughters, and once a person has sacrificed his or her head, and has become a Sikh, the roles they can play in the panth are not limited by their gender. How can you group a tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyaasi, jyot vigaasi bibi in the same category as a bujjer kurehitee by saying she cannot do seva in the panj?" and here we go unfortunately i didnt have a chance to issue my views in the lecture hall at khalsa camp so ill do it now. ok, no women offered their heads therefore the roop of the panj was 5 singh. therefore a singh can be in the panj because he has the roop of a singh whereas a singhni doesnt. the panj accept heads of bibiaa because anyone take amrit, not anyone can be in the panj though. ie. angheen person, past bujjar kurehiti. just like i can say a tyaar bar tyaar, jyot vigaasi. naam abhyasi singh hu is ang heen cannot do seva in the panj. the roop of the panj has to be comlplete, has to be as it first was when guru gobind singh ji made the panj pyare. [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

_lowest_ · 29 Aug 2006

waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh! _____________________________ a singh can partake in panj pyare seva and a singhni cant. because the roop of a khalsa tht is to partake in this seva is to be a singh with no angs missing. _____________________________ please forgive me if i misinterpret this bhaji, but it seems like you are trying to say bibiaN are incomplete? because they dont have the same form as males. if we cut our hands or feet off or something, then hunji we would have an ang missing. but waheguru made us as we are, so what im trying to say is bibia are complete people we are not lacking anything physically. sorry if this is the total opposite to what you were trying to say! bhul chuk maaf karo jee waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: singhs and singhniaa

WJKK WJKF! · 29 Aug 2006

"the question is why did bibiaa in bhai sahibs time wear tiny keskis with chunis?" <<<< why do we look towards bhai sahibs times for all the answers? yes bhai sahib je was amazing gursikh, but for rehit we should look towards maharaj's times first. we must use our knowledge of sikh ideology and beliefs and come up with logical answers. so what if most bibia wore only small keski n chunni in bhai sahibs time, who cares, times can change. if there is nothing wrong with bibia wearing dumala and chola, we should not say to them "oh in bhai sahibs times most bibia wore keski n chunni therefore we have to emulate those times therefore take that massive dumala off". das's personal view is that a dumala/chola dhari bibi looks amazing and very inspirational. das is not saying a bibi with small keski n chunni is not tyar bar tyar but we should not try to set rock solid bounderies between the two genders when it comes to these matters. we should not even look to bhai randhir singhs times all the time to see how things are done. sometimes we need to use our own logic about what is right n wrong aswel. it has been mentioned many times on this forum n even at khalsa camp that once in bhai sahibs times there was a bibi that done seva in punj. nw baba ji you will say "oh but that was only once, seems abit wierd that it only happened once". fair enough it wasnt very common, but it happened. further more jsut because this is what happened in bhai sahibs times doesnt mean fullstop thats the end of it, no discussion on the topic because bas this is what happened in "bhai shaibs times". comeon people maharaj has given you all a brain, maharaj has blessed alot of us (not das) with knowledge of gursikhi principles. das has no problem with bibi in punj unless maharaj himself tells me otherwise. das doesnt know who made up this ang heen rule, if maharaj made it then fair enough that is another debate, but where did this rehit originate? one thing das remembers is in bhai rama singh ji's autobiography, he writes that he had darshan of guru gobind singh at hemkunt sahib or a gurdwara on the way to hemkunt sahib. he says that he believes sri guru gobind singh ji gave him darshan in the physical roop of a bibi. if maharaj can do that then surely there is no question over bibia being in punj. again just because it wasnt a regular occurance in puratan times doesnt mean its not right. and like roop kaur has stated you cannot compare a tyarbar tyar jot vigaasi singhni to a bujjer kurehiti singh. duno about you baba ji but das knows who he would rather recieve amrit from, whether you think she is ang heen or not, fact is she is more suitable for the job of instilling naam within an abhlakee. maaf karna for any disrespect, das is only giving his personal view of it.

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Satnam Singh · 29 Aug 2006

As usual it's a sign borne out of fear of the female gender. As Bhai Balpreet Singh said in one of the Q & A sessions, the Only truth is Akaal Purakh. That is the ultimate truth. Other truths can change. Perhaps in this light we need to adopt the truth that all men and women are equal irrespective of anything including the biological make-up. Indeed the human body is but a mere tool to carry out the desire of our soul, our real timeless jot. Who knows in what past life what gender one was? Are we ready to upgrade to a newer truth? A wise person fears not change as long as it harms nobody and is for the good of all. On the other hand we have those who deny the truth even when it stares boldly at them. I stand by the Guru who declared equality for all bibiaa despite that instant when khalsa was created, for reasons known better to them. Who are we to judge why they never came forward? Just suppose that a bibi did come forward, would Guruji have turned her down? Your answer will suggest which camp you side on. satnam singh

Re: singhs and singhniaa

M B Singh · 29 Aug 2006

Bibian with Dumala or small Keski, let it be her choice. But small dastar bibian, should not be looked down upon. Dumala is a dress, not Kakkar.

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2006

no i am not saying they are incomplete i am saying their form is different to the form of a singhs therefore not suitable for panj pyare seva jus like some 1 hu is ang heen has a form which is not suitable for panj pyare seva there is a physical roop as well as a spirutal stage tht some1 hu is doing 5 pyare seva must adhere to. the orginal 5 were 5 singhs. this roop must be kept. in bhai sahibs times- i use this phrase because bhai sahib followed tat gurmat therefore using his life and wat happened in his company is a good reference. if a bibi came forward then the panj pyare would consist of 1 bibi and 4 singhs. but tht didnt happen so its 5 singhs [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Gupt singhnee! · 30 Aug 2006

"the orginal 5 were 5 singhs. this roop must be kept." True. the original roop must be kept.I think if panj singh is needed but there is shortage of a singh then all singhneea shud be tyaar bur tyaar 2 take on any sevaa but otherwise my view is that it should be 5 singhs because thats how it was in guru maharaj's time.:) Bul chuk maaf. [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

raj · 30 Aug 2006

just to add my view.... sorry for ive got my facts wrong or sound arrogant...but at gurujis time the 1st granthi was bhai buddha ji....so therefore does that mean now a days women cannot be granthi/ giani jsut becuz of the fact that the 1st giani was a male??

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Prabhjoyt Singh · 30 Aug 2006

who said women cant be Granthis? [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 30 Aug 2006

doing granthi seva is very different to doing seva in the panj. doing seva in the panj u must be a tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyasi, jyot vigaasi singh, no angs missing and healthy and tht. to do granthi seva u have to be amritdhari, or some ppl say u can do it as long as u have had ishnaan and are appropiatedly dressed [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

raj · 30 Aug 2006

no1 said women cant be granthis...but im using that as an example to the ppl say women cannot be 1 of the panj pyarey....so if women could be granthis then why not panj pyarey?....as in both times the 1 person to fulfill them duty were males? sorry they're just my views, could be wrong..not arguing whats right and wrong......as some ppl do believe its a personal chioce or opinion

Re: singhs and singhniaa

kaur 92 · 31 Aug 2006

i think what ''baba amarjeet singh'' is tryin to say is singhs n singhnia were made different for a purpose ,so why try to be like one another,now ''baba amarjeet singh'' i think u should try to be more understanding in the furture and not jump to conclusions.srry if i offended anyone,ecspecially baba amarjeet singh jee!bul chuk maaf

Re: singhs and singhniaa

* · 31 Aug 2006

Baba Amarjeet Singh Jee, you've stated that: "doing seva in the panj u must be a tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyasi, jyot vigaasi singh, no angs missing and healthy and tht". So in what way does a singhnee inherently disqualify when obviously she is capable of meeting the above stated criteria?

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Hardeep Singh · 31 Aug 2006

Of course women can be in the punj pyare. Women can be tyaar bar tyaar, naam abhyasi, jyot vigaasi singhnis, no angs missing and healthy and tht. In a amrit sanchar the punj pyare are representing Guroo Gobind Singh jee and Guru Jee states it clearly that khalsa has no gender. Hence in an amrit sanchar the punj are transfering their spirtuality into the amrit. [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 31 Aug 2006

mr * i did say singh if u didnt read properly and a singhni is not a singh khalsa has no gender really, so why is there singh and kaur and not just singh for everyone panj pyare had a roop in the begeinng roop must be kept roop was 5 SINGHS its really not tht complicated a singhni does not have the roop of a singh the physical roop does matter. if 5 singhnees were in the original panj then the panj pyare wud always hav to consist of 5 singhees. but tht didnt happen [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

* · 31 Aug 2006

In one of the many many past discussions on the issue of Singhnees in Punj Pyaarey, someone once posted the questions asked of possible candidates and the criteria upon which selection is based. Of those questions and the criteria, nothing would eliminate a Singhnee by virtue of gender. Unless you now add a new question whereby all candidates are asked to openly state their gender, how would you enforce it 100% in circumstances where a singh looked like a singhnee or vice versa? We all know that Guru Sahib never asked for MALES alone to step forward, so who are you to demand only males in Punj now? The original call went out for the entire sangat, males and females, and those who were worthy stepped forward. If you think their gender alone influenced whether they stepped up or not, you degrade the entire concept with your ignorance. If you're so inclined to make things as they originally were, then only women like Bibi Nananki Jee can be Sikhs to begin with, so saying only males can be in Punj is a far off concept. Since women HAVE already served in Punj Pyaaray, are the abhilaakhees who received amrit from them incomplete in some way? Are they missing the element that would have made them complete had the Punj been all male?

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 31 Aug 2006

how many times must i post the same thing. a question wouldnt need to be asked about gender because only singhs can do seva anyway. and do they also ask if you have all of your limbs in tact by the way? yes guru ji asked for 5 heads. 5 SINGHS came up. therefore thts the way it should stay. my ignorance? 5 singhs were orginally in the 5 pyare. this is the way it should be kept. this is the roop of the 5 pyare. its not sexist. its the just the way it is. all 10 gurus were male. is this sexist too? 5 singhs are required for panj pyare seva. nd i dont really know what to say about the bibi nanaki story. its a bit stupid to try and compare the 2. any one can take amrit and be a sikh. but not anyone can be in the panj. can u not read. i have wrote tht at least once alredy. [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Singh101 · 31 Aug 2006

Woah I don't agree with women in punj but the least you can do is argue your point properly instead of with a hissy fit singh. The bibi nanaki story makes sense because its comparible....first sikh and first punj....same sort of thing but i still dont know. anyway try arguing in good spirit....hissy fit only works wen u're 5.

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 01 Sep 2006

hissy fit? what does tht mean? wen im havin a fit ill let u know. no it doesnt make sense. anyone can be a sikh, not anyone can be in the panj, even pro bibiaa in the panj will agree to that. [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Singhni · 01 Sep 2006

Guru Fateh to all u singhs n singhnees out there Oki first of all I dun gree with wut u've written...If guru ji didnt want men n women to be equal then Y wud he give them the same respect n tell us o do the same?...... second The part about MEN being STRONGER then WOMEN!!..Wrong agn!...a women CAN do things a man can do...n women can b as strong and even stronger then men.... Third...I dunt find it against nature for a man to try n make roti, or do wut a women may do or for a women to try n do wut a man may do.....it depends on the person n how they may think....It isnt for ONE to decide whether a women can or cant do wut a man can do.....and if a women tries to do something a man does it doesnt just classify her as a man...It just means that she wants to do seva or w/e it is she has decided to do......and w/e a man/women decides to do we shud support her/him, Instead of telling her/him that she/he cant do it...b/c its against nature.....

Re: singhs and singhniaa

baba amarjeet singh · 01 Sep 2006

singhni ji men and women being equal is a concept taken out of context. equal means not discriminating them becuase of gender. it doesnt mean tht they are the same and can do the same things and are made for the same things. i am not saying singhniaa arent good enough or something to do panj pyare seva. im saying tht vahigurus hukam was for to 5 singhs to so panj pyare seva which was why 5 singhs were in the original 5. now neither me or you can argue with hukam. tell us to do the same? hmmm men and women are made for different things. ie. a man cant give birth wether you like it or not. in general men are stronger then women. there is no point arguing about tht. no, its not AGAINST nature for men to make roti. i make roti. i never said that. i said tht men and women do have certain roles. ie. its more of a mans role to fight on the battlefield, tht doesnt mean singhniaa never fuoght on the battlefield. i simply said tht there ARE 2 genders in sikhi. male and female. we shuldnt try and make them into one. and lastly with "miss perfect" in ur addie, u dnt need to argue, u presumeably already know all. and i am getting quite bored of writing the same thing. so unless someone has something new to say i suggest you at look at the responses from "reply" and "veechar" on this post http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=55557&t=54559#reply_55557 [%sig%]

Re: singhs and singhniaa

Khalsa · 03 Sep 2006

i aint read all of this 2 long bt sumtin about men r always stronger.. INCORRECT look at china from WWF.. look hw strong she was n then jus pop dwn 2 town.. and u will see sum skinny boy hus a weasle!!