Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
Khalsa Raj of the 1800's
Khalsa Raj of the 1800's
Ssingh · 26 Aug 2006
WJKK WJKF
I am going to be writing an essay very soon... I have chosen to write about the rise of the Sikh empire. I am planning on having my research question be something along the lines of.. "was the thirst for a sikh empire based religous principles or was it just a thirst for power?" or something like that... i still have much research to do. but i was wondering if sangat could help me come up with a better research question to guide my research.. so that i don't go out researching in the wrong direction. In my essay i baiscally want to prove that the fight for the sikh empire was a fight led by religious principles. "Raj bina nehi dharm chalay hai"
Any help would be appreciated. Thank you in advance!
WJKK WJKF
Re: Khalsa Raj of the 1800's
Dalbir · 27 Aug 2006
In my essay i baiscally want to prove that the fight for the sikh empire was a fight led by religious principles. "Raj bina nehi dharm chalay hai"
-------------------------------------------------------
That will be hard to do seeing that the architect of the Sikh Kingdom itself (Maharaja Ranjit Singh) was majorly into nonSikh belief and action. Also how would you explain the misls fighting each other over land in this context?
In reality I think the truth is very much more complex than a monolithic group fighting with a single common cause or objective. Jagjit Singh, In his book suggests that the fighters closest to the time of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (point taken Mr. Admin) and Banda were religiously inspired but later when the Moghul and Afghan threat receded, religious motivation and unity broke down and was replaced by wealth and power concerns. That may explain why many sardars drunk, took drugs and had multiple wives and fought each other from the end of the 1700s onwards, as compared to those with Banda Bahadhur, who fought outnumbered until they were surrounded in a fort and starved till human skeletons and then voluntarily courted a public death in Delhi without complaint or any thought of converting to save themselves.
So I guess I'm trying to say that maybe Sikhs had different motivations during different periods in their history.
Re: Khalsa Raj of the 1800's
SomeSingh · 27 Aug 2006
which sikh empire? if it was raja ranjeet singh's, then def not religious. if it was the misl period sardars, then yes, you could make a case for that. if it was banda singh bahudur's, then yes def.
Re: Khalsa Raj of the 1800's
JSGyani · 31 Aug 2006
the first person to espouse..such a haleemee raaj is Bhagat ravidass ji in Gurbani when Bhagat ji mentions Begampura Shehar ko nau...
The "Question" of True Khlas raaj is..well fluid ...what do i mean..??
I mean TRUE KHALSAAAJ has got to be WITHIN EACH KHALSA....
Did GURU JI go about "enforcing"...i mean checking whether the Sikhs..say in Kila Anandpur Sahib...were doing their "nitnem"...wearing kacherras or carrying kirpans...i KNOW some such KHALSAS today will DO EXACTLY THAT if thye are running a KHALISTAN....type of Khalsa raaj !!
Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh a TRUE KHALSA ? If he wasnt...WERE ALL the REST of his subjects TRUE KHALSA ?? WHO is needed to be a TRUE KHALSA to make a Khalsa Raaj ?? Just for arguments sake IF Ranjit Singh was a "True Khalsa"...would his raaj be true Khalsa Raaj...? on HIS LIFE ALONE ?? was Afghanistan a true TALIBAN RAAJ ?? just because a few talibaans ruled it ?? or afghanustan can be atrue Talibnan Raaj even under the Infidel Americans IF each Afghani is a true Talibannee ??
In my opinion..to Akali Phoola Singh..his time was a true Khalsa Raaj...as he was TRUE KHALSA HIMSELF..even though his raja..ranjit singh drank and was a womaniser..to me in my HOME is true Khalsa raaj even though i live in a MUSLIM COUNTRY..
This si one major reason why the Kharkoo Lehr FAILED in Punjab...the kharkoos began to ENFORCE thier MORAL LAWS on all prematurely....giving the GOI a leverage into breaking them from the people...the talibans failed for teh same reason...
2. Read my Paper..from Crown to Crossroads...on the Misl Period..
[%sig%]
Re: Khalsa Raj of the 1800's
Dalbiri · 04 Sep 2006
There are things I still don't understand about the movement. Like killing Chamkila and his "girlfriend"
Even if he was singing dirty songs, I don't think there has been any precedent in Sikh history where killing such people was justified. I mean a beating would have done if they felt so strongly.
In all the Guru's time there were plenty of those bairagi types who walk around stark naked. Nobody killed any of them (to my knowledge) for being dirty.
Maharaja Ranjit himself was even more perverted than Chamkila, and although a few Singhs did try and assasinate him, most of us still admire his achievements.
I recall a point made to me about Pakistan. Jinnah, who basically procured the country was himself a pork eater and alcohol drinker. He still had enough love for his people to gain them the gift of self rule. Even the fanatical mullahs have to admit that.
In Canada I hear that certain "Amritdhari" organisations used 18 year olds to assasinate old Sikh buddhay, who opposed them politically. I'm a supporter of the idea of Khalistan myself but this sort of stuff just will not do. What kind of country would such people run. In the end the majority of Sikhs would reject it.
Even Sant Bhindranwalle, from what I have heard, brought people to the faith by parchaar and love and inclusion, not direct force.
Sorry for the digression.