ADHD
Ssingh · 24 Aug 2006
WJKK WJKF ADHD stands for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. Would anyone in the sangat happen to know how this is diagnosed or how a psychologist would try to diagnose ADHD in a teenager? WJKK WJKF
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Ssingh · 24 Aug 2006
WJKK WJKF ADHD stands for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. Would anyone in the sangat happen to know how this is diagnosed or how a psychologist would try to diagnose ADHD in a teenager? WJKK WJKFDalbir · 25 Aug 2006
Firstly, It must be said that the very existence of the disorder is contentious with some saying that it is not a real disorder. Recent research (not claiming to be an expert but I have just studied the subject), indicate that it is possibly the result of a dysfunctional reward system. This basically relates to the brain area known as the frontal lobe. This is an important area of the brain and is what makes us differ from primates. It mainly deals with inhibition and mental strategies, allowing planned out behaviour instead of instinctual responses. This dysfunction is thought to be behind the inappropriate and often impulsive behaviour exhibited by people who are thought to have the condition. Diagnosis in the west involves checking behaviour against set criteria in the DSM manual. This is a "bible" of mental health problems which explain the symptoms of each condition and (I think) now includes suggested therapies/interventions. 3 types of ADHD are recognised: DSM - 3 subtype classifications ADHD I – Inattentive Type (note:hard to identify) ADHD HI – Hyperactivity-Impulsive Type ADHD C – Combined Type Must be seen in at least 2 settings i.e. home and school, for at least six months by the age of 7. Can cause impaired social, academic and occupational functioning. Core features of disorder include: Inattention, Hyperactivity and impulsivity Secondary features include: Impaired motor coordination Poor academic and intelligent test performance, Executive dysfunction (difficulty with tasks requiring several cognitive processes necessary for goal directed behaviour). Adaptive functioning impaired. Social behaviour and relationships Sleep and accident risk Higher risk for accidents Assessment – Biopsychosocial disorder, assessment must be broad based. Interviews about child’s strengths, weaknesses, history, family stress and school. Info on any family dysfunction and peer relationships very useful. Specific info on parental interaction helps in both diagnosis and treatment planning. Direct observations of behaviour is also a very useful tool so child should also be interviewed if feasible, esp. with older youth. Teachers are also important source of information towards learning and academic problems as well as peer relationships. Controversially, (in my opinion), a very modern solution to the problem is through the use of a drug called Methylphenidate, which is very similar in effect and composition to Amphethamine (i.e. speed), and Cocaine. This is suggested to be used in conjunction with therapy and has be conclusively shown to reduce the negative social interactions and disruptive behaviour associated with the disorder. They are sometimes referred to as rapid shifts in attention. Methylphenidate basically works by regulating the dopamine release in the brain. Small doses of speed were the traditional medication before methylphenidate became popular. A number of causes have been suggested but the most recent feelings that it is the result of an interaction between genes and environment. Lack of omega oils in diet when developing or growing up is also highlighted. These nutrients are used extensively by the body in brain development especially in dopamine related systems.Ek_singh · 25 Aug 2006
Singh Jee, You may want to visit www.drweil.com and search on his site. He has very good articles on all kind of problems & disorders and they really help. Here are few useful articles for you. You can be member of his site and ask further help. http://www.drweil.com/u/QA/QA326602/ http://www.drweil.com/u/HC/HCA210/#2Ek_singh · 25 Aug 2006
You may also consider going to Ayurvedic Doctor and get their treatment. http://www.peacefullivinghhc.com/adhd.htmijs · 26 Aug 2006
well singh jeeeo i posted my experience some time back here ........and i too as ppl said and i realized ,have some kinda hyperactivity disorder.........well with gurujis grace its better slightlty coz its more of my mind taking over,with me.........so try to do paath so realized it wasnt too much of a disorder but ya some of it is quite similar well as far as the docs go.........no clue .........never had the guts to approach one...............by the way who is actually going through it............. do lemme know...........it can help me study myself betterHarjas Kaur · 26 Aug 2006
There is a theory that children of hunters had an active predatory ability to follow moving targets, like a tiger. As prey would move in and out of their field of vision, they would move in and out of interest with different targets, until one was near enough. They would then ultra focus for a short time to chase that one. But a predatory attention is one that is easily distracted by potential prey. These children conform poorly in schools designed by children of populations generally docile who sit still for long periods, like the feudal servants and farmers who sought protection from predation by submitting to powerful Lords. Both children can be equally intelligent. But they learn differently, and their needs are different. For example, you have to have a certain genetic constitution to sit mildly, receptively, learning for hours and even years at a time to achieve a college degree. Children of soldiers and hunters do poorly at this. What appeals to their innate nature is excitement, activity, and the ability to track prey. Instead of modeling learning situations to meet these varying needs among different racial populations, western countries generally label the children inferior in some way. Deficit implies deficient. In reality, it is the culture itself, and the man-made educational system which fails these children, dictates that their innate genetic differences are a disease, and treats them with social ostracism, patronization by psychological authorities, and prescribes psychostimulant drugs to damage their brains, to addict them to an artificial status quo. I know this, because I am a racial decendant of warrior tribes. It is the society which is sick, and not the children. However, the children become disturbed in such societies, because they cannot succeed in them. It is to me further proof that warrior societies like Sikhs should develop their own country, based on their own values, to protect and to promote their own best interests. This is necessary to avoid destroying yourselves trying vainly to conform to foreign cultural values and dominance. It is the death of warrior children to become docile and submissive and thereby easily brainwashed. ________________ Khalistan Zindabad! [quote]Damaged Hunters by Thom Hartmann Many thoughtful people on all sides of the ADD issue have asked me this question. One of the most articulate put it quite succinctly when he said that if he’d been alive 10,000 years ago he would have been doomed because “I’d forget to take my spear with me when we left for the hunt!” Others have taken pains to point out to me the necessity of organized cooperative action for most primitive hunting parties. The ideal of a hyperactive loner going through the woods looking for dinner doesn’t at all characterize how most anthropologists describe primitive (or today’s) hunter/gatherer methods. At first glance, it would appear that these considerations blow a hole in the hypothesis that modern people with ADD are carrying around a remnant of hunter/gatherer genetic material. It lends credibility to the notion that ADD is, in fact, a “disease” or at least “not normal,” and may not have ever been “normal” in human history. But that overlooks a critical issue: cultural context, the effect of what we learn to believe about ourselves as we’re growing up. Cultural anthropologists are quick to point out that it’s extremely difficult for any one culture to clearly view another. We instinctively assume when observing their behaviors that they’re motivated in the same ways we are, that they behave the way they do for the same reasons we would if we were in their situation, and that they share our assumptions about how the world works and humanity’s role in the world. This is a dangerous error, which even tripped up Margaret Mead when she was writing Coming of Age in Samoa. Since her well-intentioned but well-publicized error, few anthropologists would make this mistake. But it’s easy for somebody untrained in the field. The problem, essentially, is that most people, when thinking of “primitive times,” imagine themselves running around in the woods wearing animal skins and carrying a spear. In their mind’s eye, they transport a twentieth century person back into a fantasy past. But these “Connecticut Yankees in King Arthur’s Court” don’t represent what it was like to grow up in those times; they arrive in a different era complete with all our acculturation, carrying along all the damage done to them by our culture. They haul along the preparations we’ve received for a Farmers/Industrialists life, but utterly lacking preparation for a Hunters/Gatherers life. The fact of the matter is that people in hunter/gatherer tribes live very different lives than we do, and therefore grow up to be very different persons from us. ADDers are damaged by growing up in our society, but not in hunting cultures Cultural anthropologist Jay Fikes pointed this out to me when we first discussed the idea of hunters and farmers as an explanation for many modern psychological differences among people. His research showed that individuals living among the historically agricultural Native Americans, such as the Hopi and other Pueblo Indians, are relatively sedate and risk-averse. On the other hand, Fikes said, members of the hunting tribes such as the Navajo are “constantly scanning their environment and are more immediately sensitive to nuances. They’re also the ultimate risk takers. They and the Apaches were great raiders and warriors.” Navajo children grow up in a society of Navajo hunter and warrior adults (at least they did before we conquered them, destroyed their culture, shattered their religions, stole their land, and murdered most of their citizens). The Navajo raised their children as hunters and warriors. Until we arrived with horses and guns, they were extraordinarily successful, and had survived as an intact culture for thousands of years longer than we have. But we today are not a society of hunters, raiders, and warriors. We are farmers, office- and factory-workers. Therefore, we punish and discourage hunter and warrior behavior in our children and adults. When people grow up being punished for being the way they are, they become damaged. They think of themselves as misfits and incompetents. They lose their own personal power, become shaken and fearful, and develop a variety of compensating behaviors—many of which are less than useful. http://www.thomhartmann.com/damagedhunters.shtml[/quote] [img]http://www.geocities.com/TheTropics/8240/leeukie.jpg[/img] A lion was never intended by God to be a captive herd animal. [%sig%]Dalbir · 26 Aug 2006
Posted some info regarding ADHD which I learnt at university but the administrator hasn't posted it (well not yet anyway). I'm going to add some more, but if admin decide to post my earlier piece, forgive the repetition. I'm a bit concerned about administering drugs to young children. But Methylphenidate is the common medication giving to youngsters with ADHD. Therapy is also useful and the latest consensus is that medication should be used WITH therapy although medication alone is shown to have a positive effect. Although the existence of the disorder is disputed, its occurence is becoming more and more widely accepted, I guess in third world countries the problem is usually "solved" with "slipper treatment". Infact many children/youths with behavioural problems may have the condition which is basically thought to be down to a dysfunctional dopamine system in the brain. This makes sufferers impulsive and hyperactive often placing them in negative situations as they "thrill seek" or leave them with low self-esteem possibly due to poor interactions/communication skills with others. Assessment would be done via the DSM which is a manual describing or more accurately categorising various psychological issues. One problem with ADHD is that it is commonly thought to co-exist with other problems and this combination is often hard to accurately define. DSM gives the following advice to psychiatrists/psychologists for assessment. DSM - 3 subtype classifications ADHD I – Inattentive Type (hard to identify) ADHD HI – Hyperactivity-Impulsive Type ADHD C – Combined Type Must be seen in at least 2 settings i.e. home and school, for at least six months by the age of 7. Can cause impaired social, academic and occupational functioning. Core features of disorder include: Inattention, Hyperactivity and impulsivity Secondary features include: Impaired motor coordination Poor academic and intelligent test performance, Executive dysfunction (difficulty with tasks requiring several cognitive processes necessary for goal directed behaviour). Adaptive functioning impaired. Social behaviour and relationships Sleep and accident risk Higher risk for accidents Assessment – Biopsychosocial disorder, assessment must be broad based. Interviews about child’s strengths, weaknesses, history, family stress and school. Info on any family dysfunction and peer relationships very useful. Specific info on parental interaction helps in both diagnosis and treatment planning. Direct observations of behaviour is also a very useful tool so child should also be interviewed if feasible, esp. with older youth. Teachers are also important source of information towards learning and academic problems as well as peer relationships. A psychologist would make the assessment based on reports from schools, parents etc against such criteria. HOWEVER, in my opinion there a few things to be concerned about, firstly regarding the drug based medication, is it wise to give young children such substances? What are the long term effects? Secondly being "labelled" with the disorder itself can lead to children/youth feeling depressed, which can make things worse. There is a possibility that "problem behaviour" may be down to environmental factors more than a brain dysfunction, in the west, psychologist may not fully grasp issues such as poor communication between immigrant background youth and parent due to cultural gaps. This may be the root cause of such behaviour. Anyway here is some info from.... http://www.nida.nih.gov/Infofacts/Ritalin.html ...regarding the common medicine prescribed for the condition, called methylphenidate but sold as Ritalin: Hope it helps. -------------------------- Methylphenidate is a medication prescribed for individuals (usually children) who have attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), which consists of a persistent pattern of abnormally high levels of activity, impulsivity, and/or inattention that is more frequently displayed and more severe than is typically observed in individuals with comparable levels of development. The pattern of behavior usually arises between the ages of 3 and 5, and is diagnosed during the elementary school years due to the child’s excessive locomotor activity, poor attention, and/or impulsive behavior. Most symptoms improve during adolescence or adulthood, but the disorder can persist or present in adults. It has been estimated that 3–7 percent of school-age children have ADHD. Methylphenidate also is occasionally prescribed for treating narcolepsy. Health Effects Methylphenidate is a central nervous system (CNS) stimulant. It has effects similar to, but more potent than, caffeine and less potent than amphetamines. It has a notably calming and “focusing” effect on those with ADHD, particularly children. Recent research at Brookhaven National Laboratory may begin to explain how methylphenidate helps people with ADHD. The researchers used positron emission tomography (PET—a noninvasive brain scan) to confirm that administering normal therapeutic doses of methylphenidate to healthy, adult men increased their dopamine levels. The researchers speculate that methylphenidate amplifies the release of dopamine, a neurotransmitter, thereby improving attention and focus in individuals who have dopamine signals that are weak.1 Methylphenidate can be a valuable medicine, for adults as well as children with ADHD.2,3,4 Treatment of ADHD with stimulants such as Ritalin and psychotherapy help to improve the abnormal behaviors of ADHD, as well as the self-esteem, cognition, and social and family function of the patient.2 Research shows that individuals with ADHD do not become addicted to stimulant medications when taken in the form and dosage prescribed by doctors. In fact, it has been reported that stimulant therapy in childhood is associated with a reduction in the risk for subsequent drug and alcohol abuse disorders.5,6 Also, studies have found that individuals with ADHD who have been treated with stimulants such as methylphenidate are significantly less likely than those who do not receive treatment to abuse drugs and alcohol when they are older.7 (This is continued on the site)Dalbir · 27 Aug 2006
Harjas, I tried to make similar points to that in your post to an expert on ADHD in a (western) university but he seemed hell bent on promoting the drugging up of youth who behave in a non-conformist way. He also suggested that many substance abusers were ADHD sufferers who were "self medicating" It was strongly suggested that ADHD people were remnants of our evolutionary past. I think that they were trying to say that the rest of society had somehow made an evolutionary leap whilst those that supposedly had ADHD hadn't and were ill suited to modern life. I think a strong case may be made for this to be a western driven concept stemming from their strong need for conformist behaviour. This way they can pump spirited youth with mind numbing drugs and make them easily controllable. But to balance the picture off, some people may genuinely be suffering and benefit from medication/therapy. Being spirited and independent minded can quickly get one labelled as a trouble maker, coupled with being physically distinctive from the majority, this can be hard on anyone. I'm glad they didn't have these "solutions" when I was younger, I'd have been in big trouble myself! hee heeHarjas Kaur · 28 Aug 2006
Never trust experts. Trust Guruji and the natural balance of life. Our modern life is out of balance, thus natural living organisms, trees, fish, insects, birds, children are also reflecting this lack of balance. The answer is not more man-made arrogance. How idiotic to assert that ADHD is some remnant of primitive life when it is the best response of a hunter/warrior to a natural, healthy environment. As if to assert modern society has "evolved" somehow. [img]http://i.a.cnn.net/cnn/2005/TECH/science/04/08/earth.policy/story.vert.pollution.jpg[/img][img]http://www.bp.com/liveassets/bp_internet/bp_ultimate/STAGING/brand_assets/images/global_diesel_summary_less_pollution_180x144-.jpg[/img][img]http://www.crystalinks.com/pollution.jpg[/img] Evolution? Into what? [img]http://www.citepa.org/pollution/montagnes.jpg[/img] I prefer God-intended Primitive condition. Modern life itself is unhealthy for people. [%sig%]