Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
Student of Taksal · 24 Aug 2006
First of all, this isn't anything "newly invented". The source is Sant Kartar Singh ji who mentions this in the autobiography of Giani Gurbachan Singh ji Khalsa. The incident occurred in 1960 at Ludhiana when Gyani Gurbachan Singh ji and Bhai Randhir Singh met.
Giani ji explianed the spiritual arths of Raagmala to Bhai sahib, who then accepted that Raagmala is indeed Gurbani.
Btw....*(Gyani Takhur Singh ji and Sant Jarnail Singh ji were students of Sant Kartar Singh ji.)
Obviously AKJ doesn't believe in this, otherwise the last 46 years would be different. To each his own.
Before people divert this topic into whether Santji is shaheed... i will tell you no true taksali will ever counter the bachan of Baba Takhur Singh ji. Mahapursh said what they did for a reason. Many people float around rumours that Baba Takhur Singh said Santji would be back before he passed or before 2004....all just made up stuff. The only answer Baba ji ever gave was that keep shardha in Guru maharaj and time will reveal all.
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
Hardeep Singh · 24 Aug 2006
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh's stance on raagmala was strong.
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
Khalsaspirit · 25 Aug 2006
Guru piyare khalsa jio,
Waheguru ji ka khalsa,
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Topic brought by "confused" brother or sister need great attention. Topic is not light and need thorow study and individual Naam kamai to evaluate such kind of rumors spreaded in khalsa panth since day one.
Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji's admittance to some one just because of any scare does not make any sense at all. And the people or group or person who spread this rumor might have been done that so he assumed the same for the person in front of him.
Aside from Bhai Randhir Singh ji this is been proved number of times in panth in last more than 150 years since khalsa panth started to aware about its History and Gurbani that the aunthentication of Raagmala is not
proved that it is "Gurbani". and proved number of times in panth by
Sikh scholars, Historians and very other Highly spirtual Sikhs (Like Bhai Randhir Singh ji).
Since Bhai Veer Singh ji raised this point first in Chief Khalsa Divan's
Magazine "Khalsa Samachar" that Raggmala is not Gurbani but in his later life he backed down his decision and Chiek khalsa Divan Splitted over it.
As I mentioned earlier that since day one from the formation of khalsa there is always a parrallel force (With Gusikhi Bana or Without Gursikhi bana) who always try to degrade the Gurbani and Gurmat. During the period of physical presence of ten Gurus all anti elements were rejected
by education by Guru Sahib themself but since the Guru ship of Sri Guru Granth Sahib those elements raised again and only with tat-Gurmat they can be lowered.
Now about so called Taksalis who are spread this rumor are having questinable authentication about their Gurudom/deravad style puja rather than stepping towards Gurmat according to present Guru sri Guru Granth Sahib ji.
If anyone without have much knowlegde of Gurbani call clearly tell the difference between "Ik Oankaar to Nanak Naam Milay ta Jiva"
rather than "Ik Oankaar to Athaara Dus Bees".
Caution! Although Sahib sri Akaal Takhat Sahib's Hukam is to not open any dicussion in public on Raagmala until next decision. But still those so called
moderen taksalis do not dare to care about Sri Akal Takhat Sahib's Hukam and since 1986 or later they forcefully started to read this on Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib.
I have to use word " so called Taksali" beacuse they assumed themselves above the panth and even have no respect for their ancestor taksali Baba Jarnail Singh Ji khalsa who atleast consider panth above him for the same and strictly opposed his companions not to read this at Sri Akaal takhat Sahib during his stay in early eighties.
So in last but not least in the wake of this small evaluation the end result is crystal clear. And every one is requested to keep their Amrit vela and do swas-swas naam simran so that it will enlighten you path to Waheguru almighty.
and this is my humble request to you not to hear those rumors about the Gursikhs.
If this hurts anyones centiments forgive me for that but remember truth is
truth and it is bitter.
Seeking towards true khalsa and Khalsa raaj(not limited to certain terrion)
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
livingforwaheguru · 26 Aug 2006
Yeah confused and do yout think a lot of unity is gonna come out of your post. No offence but your post wreaks of conterversy... You want to ask taksalis about this question on a tapoban forum. Its hard for me to believe that you asked this question on this forum because u wanted answers from taksalis..I think u asked this question here because you wanted taksal to get ripped apart. Why else would ask such a question on a obviously anti rag maala site... I personally don't have enough knowledge to comment whetere its gurbani or not. I am concentrating on reading all of what my guru has to say. I think if one does enough bhagti and kamai he won't have to get into these silly arguments all knowledge of all the worlds willl come to him. If you really wanna know then i suggest you do some serious naam kamai and you will know. I'm neither taksali or akj..I have utmost respect for all the gurmukhs whether they were taksali or akj or nanaksar or raresahib or whatever. Jeevan speaks for itself. Stop trying to create contereversy..
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
baba amarjeet singh · 26 Aug 2006
in short.
no bhai sahib never said that raagmala was bani.
because in doing you so you are saying he lied to the sangat. bhai would never lie.
[%sig%]
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
livingforwaheguru · 27 Aug 2006
Hey confused.. It takes a big man to admit to his mistake.. But i believe you when you say you were not trying to start contervesy...And pls do not apologize to me. Guru ji knows i'm not worthy of anyones apologies.. I'm sorry if my msg came out harsh.
God bless you and may guru ji keep you in his sharan
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
baba amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2006
"Let us consider who we are discussing here. we are talking about a person who stayed hungry for 40 days so that he would not break his bibek. We are talking about a person who did not eat parshaada for several days because he did not get good quality hair oil and therefore could not comb his hair. We are talking about a person who spent 16 years in jail and kept all his rehit intact despite being tortured, beaten, and what not. We are talking about someone who believed in Sarbloh bibek as a hukam so strongly that he stopped doing seva in the panj when this hukam was stopped.
Now, how can someone in their right mind ever even think such rubbish without having the fear of doing ninda of such a Gursikh in their heart?"
bang on
[%sig%]
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
Khalsaspirit · 29 Aug 2006
Guru piyare khalsa jio,
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
"Let us consider who we are discussing here. we are talking about a person who stayed hungry for 40 days so that he would not break his bibek. We are talking about a person who did not eat parshaada for several days because he did not get good quality hair oil and therefore could not comb his hair. We are talking about a person who spent 16 years in jail and kept all his rehit intact despite being tortured, beaten, and what not. We are talking about someone who believed in Sarbloh bibek as a hukam so strongly that he stopped doing seva in the panj when this hukam was stopped.
Now, how can someone in their right mind ever even think such rubbish without having the fear of doing ninda of such a Gursikh in their heart?"
No doubt we have to agree with Roopkaur ji, but the thing to consider is who is doing the Ninda and Why?
The reason in todays date is as I mentioned in my earlier post that since day one from the formation(Sri Guru Nanak Dev ji) of Panth Khalsa
there is been a parrallel force (with Sikhi Bana and W/o Sikhi Bana) try to distort Sikhi and its followers.
So same is happenning in this case deravadees and Gurudom style's
fake Sant post holders (20th centuery invention to divert attention from Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji) are trying to distort Gurbani as well Jeevans of true Gursikhs but because of Akal purakh himself created this panth for the well being of all creations so these elements failed/fails/will fail against Gurmat.
Although they suceeded/can succeed for a short while but truth always won/win.
In last but not least keep Amritvela and swas swas simarn. If I hurt some one's centiments I beg for forgiveness and remember truth is truth and it is bitter.
Seeking for true khalsa and khalsa Raaj (Not limited to certain terrion)
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
Kulbir Singh · 30 Aug 2006
It’s totally absurd to think that Bhai Sahib admitted to Raagmala being baani in secret but did not admit it in front of Singhs out of the fear that they will lose faith in him.
It is further ludicrous to imagine that Bhai Sahib got impressed with the deep meanings of Raagmala that Sant Gurbachan Singh jee told Bhai Sahib. I have read these meanings and they absolutely make no sense and are totally meaningless. Bhai Sahib who was a master of Gurbani Viyakaran, could have not got impressed with these meanings since they are against Grammar and even simple human logic.
Bhai Sahib would have never felt ashamed if he had realised his mistake of not reading Raagmala all his life. Bhai Sahib was a man enough to admit his mistake. The fact of the matter is that such conversation never took place between Sant jee and Bhai Sahib. Sant jee and Bhai Sahib respected each other despite this minor difference.
During the times of Bhai Sahib, he was not the most prominent opponents of Raagmala. At that time Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha and Bhai Shamsher Singh Ashok were leading the movement against Raagmala. Who in Panth could have dared to talk in front of Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha? Ordinary so called gyanis used to tremble before him. Pandit jee was an ocean of knowledge and many scholars of that time had been his students at some point in life. If Sant Gurbachan Singh had to resolve to issue of Raagmala, he would have gone to convince Pandit jee and his group of scholars and not Bhai Sahib who was not leading the movement against Raagmala. Once Sant Amir Singh of Taksal tried but lost miserably to Pandit jee.
Rumours like this one are lurking within Taksal for long time. Another one of the rumour is that during his end days, Bhai Sahib was suffering a lot and requested Sant Gurbachan Singh to save him. Sant jee asked him to admit his mistake of Raagmala and only then he was released from the suffering. Such a bogus story this is. Total nonsense. Dr Tarlochan Singh was there during the last moments of Bhai Sahib and he has written how peaceful Bhai Sahib was. He was in total bliss and had no suffering.
Another absurd story about Bhai Sahib is that when Bhai Sahib tried to enter Sach Khand after passing away, doors were shut on him because he did not read Raagmala. These jokers who make up these stories don’t know that Bhai Sahib was a resident of Sach Khand right while living. Who could have denied him Sach Khand after leaving this body?
Don’t believe such stories. Bhai Sahib stayed in Chardi Kala till his last days on this planet and he never admitted Raagmala to be baani.
Kulbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: bhai sahib admitting to raagmala???
Jagjit Singh · 03 Sep 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I have never had any Gursikh from Taksal say this to my face. Possibly I am very wrong, but these controversies only seem to pop on the internet.
History is testimony to Bhai Sahib character being immaculate. In the khalsa Panth, we have been blessed with many great sikhs, and bhai sahib is one of them.
If this thing was said to me, it would make me think why such a thing is being said? I have spent many years in the sangat of AKJ, and if you mention Baba Jarnail Singh bindranwale, everyone would say, he was a chardi kala Gursikh. There is mutual satkar and respect for any Gursikh, especially those with kamai or seva for the Panth. Equally I have seen the same for Bhai Fauja Singh, by Gursikhs in Taksal. Most genuine Gursikhs are glad that such souls were in the Panth.
So if people are saying such things about a Gursikh like Bhai sahib, we have to wonder why? I assume there is a lack of insecurity there. People have set views on issues, and often drop names to back their views. When you drop a name such as Bhai Sahib, there is little room for argument. Anyone who has ever read any of Bhai Sahibs books soon realise he was on a different level.
In punjabi culture, and sometimes we often see this in Gurdwara disputes. When people cannot argue a issue on facts or points and are left wanting, they often make something up to discredit that person instead. It makes them feel good and massages their ego. They once again feel they and their view is superior. But these are meaningless, and ultimatley no truth can be hidden for long. It always shines out.
These things are done by insecure people. Anybody secure in their sikhi, jeevan, and rehit realise what a waste of time these "gallan" are. The raagmala dispute has been around for generations, and it will be for generations more. In that time, other Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib will pass through this earth. In centuries time, their names will be mentioned and name dropped.
As I said, I have never heard any Gursikh from Taksal say this to my face. If they ever do, then I am sure elders in the jatha can respond to them. But I think most people on the internet have realised that everything written on it should be taken with due dilligence. Often people say outrageous things to court controversy, thinking that no one will see what they are doing, but Guru ji sees all, and they are given due karams as a result.
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh